When Brains Dream
"When Brains Dream: Exploring the Science and Mystery of Sleep" is a book by neuroscientist Antonio Zadra
and sleep researcher Robert Stickgold. The book delves into the fascinating and sometimes enigmatic realm of
dreams, offering insights into why we dream, what dreams might mean, and how they relate to our waking
lives.
Stages of Sleep and Dreaming
●
●
●
Hypnagogia (N1): This is the initial stage of sleep as you're just beginning to fall asleep. The question
posed for this stage is "What ongoing concerns was I just thinking about?" This suggests that the
transition from wakefulness to sleep may involve a continuation of thoughts from our waking concerns.
The hypnagogic stage is often accompanied by vivid sensory phenomena and may include insights or
fragments of thoughts related to problems or events that were on your mind before you fell asleep.
N2 Dreams: This is a deeper stage of sleep, but not as deep as REM sleep. It's characterized by the
presence of sleep spindles and K-complexes in the brain's electrical activity. The question for this stage
is "What associated recent memories can I find?" This implies that during N2 sleep, the brain may
process and integrate recent memories, possibly making connections between recent experiences and
established knowledge.
REM Dreams: REM sleep is the stage of sleep most commonly associated with vivid dreaming. The
question for REM dreams is "What remote, weak associations can I find?" This implies that during REM
sleep, the brain's dreaming process involves making connections between distant or unrelated
concepts, ideas, or memories, which could be the source of the bizarre and highly imaginative nature of
many dreams experienced during this stage.
NEXTUP Model of Dreaming
The "NEXTUP" model is an innovative framework for understanding why we dream, introduced by Antonio
Zadra and Robert Stickgold in their book "When Brains Dream." NEXTUP stands for "Network Exploration to
Understand Possibilities," and it represents a new way of thinking about the function of dreaming within the
context of sleep and cognition.
Here's a breakdown of the model:
●
●
Network Exploration: This refers to the brain's ability to explore its vast network of stored information
during dreams. According to Zadra and Stickgold, during sleep, especially during the REM (Rapid Eye
Movement) stage, the brain isn't constrained by the same logical and linear boundaries it adheres to
during wakefulness. Instead, it's able to make broader and more unusual connections between
disparate concepts, memories, and emotions.
To Understand Possibilities: The authors suggest that this exploration allows the brain to simulate
and examine various scenarios and possibilities. This process can lead to problem-solving and creative
thinking. The brain assesses and integrates new experiences from the waking hours with past
memories and knowledge, potentially leading to insights or the consolidation of new learning.
The NEXTUP model implies that dreams are a form of consciousness that occurs when the brain is in a state
of heightened internal focus, allowing for the recombination of cognitive elements in novel ways. It's a process
through which the brain sifts through and evaluates recent experiences and unresolved issues, simulating
different perspectives and scenarios as a way of preparing the dreamer to better face future challenges.
This model is a departure from some traditional views on dreams, such as the psychoanalytic interpretation
that dreams disguise unconscious desires. Instead, the NEXTUP model posits a more direct cognitive function
for dreaming, emphasizing its role in memory consolidation, emotional regulation, and creativity.
NEXTUP and Creativity
Here is a simplified explanation of how the NEXTUP process can be associated with creativity:
1. Networking: Dreams are thought to create complex associations between different memories and
ideas, networking them in new ways. This networking process can lead to the combination of previously
unrelated concepts, a cornerstone of creative thinking.
2. EXploration: During dreams, the mind explores various scenarios and emotional landscapes, often
without the constraints of reality. This exploration within a dream can break free from conventional
thinking patterns, allowing the dreamer to stumble upon creative solutions or ideas.
3. Transformation: Ideas and memories in dreams can be transformed into new configurations. This
transformation process, which can be bizarre and surreal during dreams, can encourage lateral thinking
and the generation of novel ideas when the dreamer is awake.
4. Understanding: The often-problem-solving nature of dreams, where scenarios are played out and
sometimes resolved, can lead to a deeper understanding of issues or problems. This could, in turn,
inspire creative insights relevant to waking life challenges.
5. Prediction: Dreams sometimes involve the brain attempting to predict future events based on past
experiences. This prediction process can simulate various outcomes, some of which may be creative
forecasts of future scenarios.
6. Psychological Insight: By representing and working through emotional or psychological issues,
dreams can provide personal insights. These insights can be creatively incorporated into one’s work or
can spur a process of self-discovery that fuels creativity.
The creativity fostered by the dreaming process as explained by NEXTUP is not direct; instead, it provides a
fertile ground for the subconscious mind to experiment with ideas and emotions in a way that is unrestricted by
the limitations of the conscious, waking mind. When these ideas are recalled upon waking, they can be refined
and directed in creative pursuits.
Hill Cognitive-Experiential Model of Dreaming
The Hill Cognitive-Experiential Model of dream interpretation was developed by Clara Hill and her colleagues
in the 1990s. This model integrates aspects of cognitive theory with experiential therapy and proposes a
structured method for interpreting dreams to better understand the self and resolve personal problems. The
model suggests that dreams can provide insight into a person's feelings, thoughts, and behaviors by exploring
the symbolic and emotional content of dreams.
1. Preparation
Before attempting to analyze a dream, it's important to establish a safe, comfortable environment and build
rapport if working with a therapist. The individual should be ready to explore the dream without judgment and
with an open mind.
2. Exploration
In this phase, the person recalls the dream in as much detail as possible. They describe the dream without
attempting to interpret it, capturing the events, characters, settings, and emotions involved.
3. Insight
Following the exploration, the person (or the therapist, if in a clinical setting) encourages a deeper
understanding of the dream by asking questions like:
●
●
●
What are the main metaphors in the dream?
How do these relate to the dreamer's waking life?
What are the connections between the dream emotions and the dreamer's current emotional state?
During this phase, elements of the dream are connected to the dreamer's waking life, aiming to reveal the
underlying thoughts, conflicts, or desires that may be influencing their behaviors or feelings.
4. Action
Here, the dreamer considers what can be learned from the dream and how it can be applied to their life. They
identify potential actions or changes they can make in response to the insights gained from the interpretation of
the dream.
5. Consolidation
In the final phase, the dreamer or the therapist consolidates the experience and any insights or actions that
have arisen from the process. This helps to reinforce the understanding and the practical steps the dreamer
can take moving forward.
The Hill Cognitive-Experiential Model is particularly notable for its structured, phased approach, which guides
the individual from recollection to insight, and then to practical applications. This makes it a useful tool not only
for self-exploration but also within psychotherapeutic settings, where dreams can be used as a gateway to
deeper psychological understanding.
Default Mode Network
The Default Mode Network (DMN) is a large-scale brain network primarily active when a person is not focused
on the outside world and the brain is at wakeful rest, such as during daydreaming, but also during tasks such
as reflecting on oneself, thinking about others, remembering the past, and planning for the future. Here are
some key aspects of the Default Mode Network:
1. Active During Rest: The DMN is most active when we are not engaged in focused activities and the
mind is allowed to wander or daydream. This is somewhat counterintuitive because it implies that our
brains are active in a structured way even when we're not consciously directing our attention to tasks.
2. Self-Referential Processing: The DMN is thought to be involved in self-referential thoughts and
processes, such as introspection and self-reflection, thinking about one's own emotions, moral
reasoning, and considering one's personality traits.
3. Thinking About Others: The network is also involved when we think about others' perspectives and
feelings, suggesting its role in social cognition processes like empathy and theory of mind (the ability to
attribute mental states to oneself and to others).
4. Remembering the Past and Imagining the Future: The DMN is engaged when people reminisce
about past experiences, imagine future scenarios, or engage in goal-directed thought.
5. Mind Wandering: It's also active during periods of mind-wandering, which can involve recalling
memories, envisioning future events, or generating spontaneous thoughts.
6. Connectivity and Mental Health: Alterations in the functionality of the DMN have been associated with
several mental health conditions, such as depression, anxiety, and schizophrenia. Excessive rumination
and negative thought patterns can be linked to increased activity in the DMN.
7. Task-Negative Network: The DMN is often described as a "task-negative" network because its activity
typically decreases when a person engages in specific goal-directed tasks that require attention to the
external environment, which activates the "task-positive" networks.
Understanding the Default Mode Network has important implications for understanding mental health
disorders, the effects of meditation and mindfulness practices (which can reduce DMN activity), and even the
mechanisms behind consciousness and self-awareness.
DreamEdge Ideation Framework
Preparation Phase:
1. Define the Problem: Clearly articulate the problem you are trying to solve.
2. Gather Materials: Prepare what you will need to capture ideas as soon as you wake up (e.g., a
notebook, voice recorder).
Induction Phase:
1. Relaxation: Find a comfortable and quiet space where you can relax without falling into a deep sleep.
2. Focus on the Problem: Think about the problem you want to solve as you begin to drift into a light
sleep.
Hypnagogic Phase:
1. Physical Trigger: Hold an object that will create a noise when dropped (like a spoon over a plate) to
wake you as you enter the first stage of sleep.
2. Immediate Response: As soon as you wake up from the sound, immediately record any ideas or
images that come to mind.
Interpretation Phase:
1. Review the Content: Look at the ideas you've recorded. They may be abstract or symbolic and could
require some interpretation.
2. Make Connections: Try to connect these new ideas to the problem at hand, looking for novel insights
or solutions.
Application Phase:
1. Develop Solutions: Use the insights to formulate possible solutions to the problem.
2. Experiment and Refine: Test these solutions in a waking state, refine them, and apply what works to
your problem.
Reflection Phase:
1. Assess the Outcome: Reflect on the effectiveness of the ideas generated and the process itself.
2. Iterate as Needed: Repeat the process if necessary, potentially with variations in focus or technique.
This creative troubleshooting framework leverages the hypnagogic state's potential for spontaneous and
non-linear connections, similar to those in dreams, to tackle problems with fresh perspectives.
Sleep-Dependent Memory Evolution
The concept of sleep-dependent memory evolution refers to the theory that memories not only consolidate
during sleep but also undergo qualitative changes. This idea posits that during sleep, especially in the rapid
eye movement (REM) phase and slow-wave sleep (SWS), our brain actively processes and transforms newly
acquired information from the day, influencing how memories are organized and interpreted. Here’s an
overview of this process:
Transformation and Integration
1. Synaptic Changes: Initial memory traces are formed and stored in a relatively raw and unprocessed
form during wakefulness. Sleep promotes synaptic changes that can lead to a more efficient
organization of these memories.
2. Emotional Processing: Emotional aspects of memories, often processed during REM sleep, can
undergo changes that affect the salience and subjective feeling of the memory, sometimes leading to a
reduction in emotional intensity (known as emotional regulation).
3. Memory Integration: Memories are not stored in isolation; they're integrated into a pre-existing
cognitive schema. Sleep helps in linking new information with existing knowledge, which can lead to a
more nuanced understanding and generalization of information.
4. Creative Insights: There is evidence that during sleep, particularly REM sleep, the brain makes novel
connections between disparate pieces of information, which can lead to creative problem-solving and
insight.
Memory Evolution Over Successive Nights
1. Reiteration of Cycles: The process of memory evolution isn't limited to a single night's sleep.
Successive nights can lead to further refinement and evolution of the memory trace.
2. Abstracting and Generalizing: As memory evolves over successive sleep periods, there is a trend
towards the abstraction of underlying patterns and principles rather than retaining specific detail. This is
important for learning concepts and general rules.
3. Adaptive Forgetting: Part of evolving memories is deciding what to forget. Sleep appears to be
involved in selectively pruning certain synaptic connections, which is crucial for cognitive flexibility and
preventing information overload.
Memory Replay
1. Hippocampal Replay: During SWS, the hippocampus is thought to replay the day's experiences. This
"replay" can lead to a strengthening of specific memory pathways.
2. Neocortical Involvement: Over time, with repeated replays, the reliance on the hippocampus for
certain memories decreases as they become more firmly embedded in the neocortex.
Influences on Sleep-Dependent Memory Evolution
1. Phases of Sleep: Different types of memories are affected by different sleep stages. For example,
declarative memories benefit from SWS, while procedural and emotional memories benefit from REM
sleep.
2. Sleep Quality: The architecture of sleep (e.g., timing, duration, and quality of different sleep stages)
influences how effectively memories evolve.
3. Timing: The timing of sleep in relation to learning is critical. Memories are most plastic and susceptible
to evolution in the early stages after acquisition.
The idea of sleep-dependent memory evolution extends beyond the mere stabilization of memory traces to
encompass a dynamic process of cognitive development. It suggests that our brains actively refine and
enhance memories during sleep, contributing to learning, emotional health, and problem-solving abilities.
Sleep-Dependent Memory Consolidation
The concept you're referring to is based on research suggesting that learning new information shortly before
sleeping can significantly enhance memory consolidation. The principle behind this idea is rooted in how sleep
stages contribute to the processing of recently acquired information. Here's why learning before bed can be
beneficial:
1. Reduced Interference: When you learn new material right before bed, there's less opportunity for
subsequent experiences to interfere with the memory consolidation process. This phenomenon is
known as "retroactive interference," where newer information can disrupt the memory of the older
information.
2. Sleep Stages and Memory Types: Different types of memory are believed to be consolidated during
different sleep stages. Slow-wave sleep (SWS), which is more prevalent in the earlier part of the night,
is particularly important for consolidating declarative memories (facts and information). Meanwhile,
REM sleep, which dominates later sleep cycles, is more involved with consolidating procedural
memories (skills and tasks).
3. Memory Replay: During sleep, and particularly during SWS, the hippocampus is thought to replay
memories from the day. If you've just been studying, these will be the freshest memories, and thus
more likely to be replayed and consolidated.
4. Synaptic Consolidation: Sleep facilitates synaptic consolidation—the process by which the neural
connections that represent new memories are strengthened. Learning right before sleep can prioritize
the day's new information for this process.
5. Hormonal and Neurotransmitter Support: Sleep triggers the release of growth hormone and other
substances that aid in repairing and building brain cells, facilitating the physical process of memory
consolidation.
6. Emotional Processing: If the learned material has an emotional component, REM sleep can help
regulate the emotional response and embed the learning more deeply into memory.
7. Creative Insights: Learning before bed can lead to integration of new information with existing
knowledge, which can foster creative insights upon waking.
It’s important to note that this doesn’t necessarily mean one should cram all studying into the moments before
sleep. Quality and duration of sleep are essential, as is distributed practice (spreading out learning over time),
for optimal memory consolidation. However, reviewing the most important or challenging material right before
bed can be an effective strategy to make the most of sleep's natural role in memory consolidation.
Sleep-Dependent Memory Consolidation Framework
1. Preparation Phase
●
●
Content Selection: Choose the material you want to learn or review. Prioritize difficult or complex
topics that require deeper processing.
Mindset Conditioning: Create a relaxed and focused mindset to avoid anxiety and promote better
encoding of information.
2. Learning Phase
●
●
Timed Study Sessions: Engage in study sessions, ideally not exceeding 45-60 minutes to maintain
attention and avoid cognitive overload.
Active Engagement: Use active learning techniques such as self-testing, summarization, and teaching
back the material to improve encoding.
3. Pre-Sleep Phase
●
●
Review Before Bed: Spend 15-30 minutes reviewing the most important or challenging parts of the
material just before going to sleep.
Relaxation Techniques: Incorporate relaxation techniques such as meditation, deep breathing, or
reading (non-study material) to transition smoothly into sleep.
4. Sleep Phase
●
●
Sleep Hygiene: Ensure good sleep hygiene by maintaining a cool, dark, and quiet sleeping
environment and sticking to a regular sleep schedule.
Sleep Duration: Aim for a full night’s sleep (7-9 hours for adults) to allow for adequate cycles of REM
and NREM stages.
5. Post-Sleep Phase
●
●
Morning Review: Briefly review the learned material after waking up to reinforce memory traces.
Note Variances: Record any dreams or thoughts upon waking that may relate to the material as they
might represent integrative or creative thinking.
6. Follow-Up Phase
●
●
Spaced Repetition: Utilize spaced repetition in the days following to further solidify the memories.
Application of Knowledge: Apply the learned concepts in practical scenarios or discussions to
enhance understanding and retention.
7. Evaluation Phase
●
Self-Assessment: Regularly assess retention and understanding of the material.
●
Sleep Quality Monitoring: Keep a sleep diary or use a sleep tracker to monitor the quality of sleep and
its relationship with learning effectiveness.
8. Iteration and Adjustment
●
●
Adaptation: Adjust the framework based on what is most effective for your individual learning and
sleep patterns.
Consistency: Maintain consistent application of the framework for ongoing learning challenges.
The SDMC Framework can be personalized based on individual schedules, learning styles, and sleep patterns.
Consistent application, along with personal adaptation, can help to optimize the benefits of sleep on memory
consolidation.