C SUSIE HOPE R. TOMOL PREMEL JEAN B. FARILLON JEREMY C. LAMOSTE MURIEL M. JOVER ANALIE S. CORDERO Photo Courtesy: Google Images (https://www.amazon.in/understanding-Self-Seema-Sharma/dp) Module Outcomes At the end of the unit, the learners must have: 1. determined the different representations and conceptualizations of the self from various disciplinal perspectives; 2. compared and contrast how the self has been represented across different disciplines and perspectives; and 3. examined the different influences, factors and forces that shapes the self Rationale The perdurable question, "Who am I?" points to a deeply rooted need within the human species to understand the basis for the experience of unitary consciousness known as the Self. Today, the word "Self" has come to refer to a host of intersecting ideas, questions, concerns, and problems that are central to the human condition and predicament. At the same time, our fundamental experience of selfhood has inevitably led to the pursuit of the related but equally enigmatic question of "What is the Self?" Historically, concepts and theories of what constitutes the Self abound and at times have been so disparate that the term has assumed radically different meanings across disciplines. Lesson 1 PHILOSOPHICAL PERSPECTIVE Learning Outcomes: At the end of the lesson, the learners must have: 1. compared the role of philosophy in understanding the self; 2. distinguished the different concepts of the self from the philosophical perspective; and 3. created your own philosophy of the self. Introduction Before we even had to be in any formal institution of learning, among the many things that we were first taught as kids is to articulate and write our names. Growing up, we were told to refer back to this name when talking about ourselves. Our parents painstakingly thought about our names. Should we be named after a famous celebrity, a respected politician or historical personality, or even a saint? Were you named after one? Our names represent who we were. It has not been a custom to just randomly pick a combination of letters and number (or even punctuation marks) like zhjk756!! To denote our being. Human beings attach names that are meaningful to birthed progenies because names are supposed to designate us in the world. Thus, some people get baptized with names such as precious,” “beauty,” or “lonely.” Likewise, when our parents call our names, we were taught to respond to them because our names on our papers, projects, or any output for that matter. Our names signify us. Death cannot even stop this bond between the person and her name. Names are inscribed even into one’s gravestone. A name is not the person itself no matter how intimately bond it is with the bearer. It is only a signifier. A person who was named after a saint most probably will not become an actual saint. He may not even turn out to be saintly! The self is thought to be something else than the name. The self is something that a person perennially molds, shapes, and develops. The self is not a static thing that one is simply born with like a mole on one’s face or is just assigned by one’s parents just like a name. Everyone is talked to discover one’s self. Have you truly discovered yours? 2 Acquire PHILOSOPHY is called the mother of all disciplines because all fields of study began as philosophical discourses. Ancient philosophers attempted to explain natural and social phenomena, coming up to their own definitions of how the world works and what factors contribute to such phenomena. It was also inevitable to come up with various conceptions of what it means to be human, and the different definitions of the self. SELF is the condition of identity that makes one subject of experience distinct from all others. It is sometimes understood as the unified being essentially connected to consciousness, awareness and agency (rational choice). Empiricism vs. Rationalism Empiricists’ believes that there is no thing such as innate knowledge; instead knowledge is derived from EXPERIENCE- either perceived by the five senses or processed with the brain while the Rationalist movement believe that innate knowledge exist and it has different sources. It explains self from standpoint of what is “ideal” and “true” not felt by the senses or body. Conclusions are derived through logic and reasoning Who are you? To answer this question let us try to examine the following philosophers and their theories about the self or their basic tenets. 3 CLASSICAL ANTIQUITY 1. SOCRATES is known for the phrase “Know thy Self”. He uses the “Socratic Method” (the dialogue between the soul and it self) to know more about self. He also believes that Knowledge is inherent to man. https://freedomandcitizenship. columbia.edu/socrates Introspection is examining or observation of one’s own mental and emotional processes. 2. PLATO believed that PLATO believed that the self is the soul and that man is a soul who uses a body. “TWO WORLD THEORY Ideal World (Intelligible world)-the true world of reality. Sensible World (World of Matter) - a world of becoming; it is a world of constant change. The nature of man lies in the dichotomy of body and soul. BODY is MATERIAL. The SOUL, on the other hand, can EXIST APART FROM THE BODY. It is immutable and indestructible. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ Plato 3 Parts of the Soul: APPETITIVE PART – part of the soul that drives man to experience thirst, hunger, and other physical wants. SPIRITUAL PART – part of the soul that makes man assert abomination and anger. It is the seat of EMOTIONS (i.e. anger, fear, hatred, jealousy). RATIONAL PART – it is the seat of REASONING. 4 3. ARISTOTLE stated that Man is a RATIONAL ANIMAL. Body and soul are in a STATE OF UNITY. Phenomena is matter and ideals are essence The BODY is MATTER to the soul and the SOUL is the FORM to the body. RATIONAL SOUL exists only in man. https://www.communicationth eory.org/aristotle MEDIEVAL AGES 4. AUGUSTINE OF HIPPO argued that man is a creation of God. Man is responsible for the existence of evil, not God, for God cannot will it because He is Absolute Goodness, says Augustine. It is therefore man’s nature, his freewill that makes man imperfect. Man is capable of reaching PERFECTION only if man keeps himself GOOD. https://www.britannica.com/bi ography/Saint-Augustine RENAISSANCE 5. RENE DESCARTES coined the phrase “Cogito ergo sum”- I think therefore I am SELF is a THINKING THING. Credited with being the “Father of Modern Philosophy.” The essential self—the self as thinking entity—is radically different than the self as physical body. https://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/Ren%C3%A9_Desc 6. JOHN LOCKE believed in “Tabula rasa”- man is born with a blank slate. Proponent of The Memory Theory of the Self. CONSCIOUSNESS is what defines one’s SELF Self is unified by consciousness Consciousness is unified by connections between mental states https://en.wikipedia.org/ wiki/John_Locke 5 7. DAVID HUME contended that the self is a bundle of perception. Hume argues that our concept of the self is a result of our natural habit of attributing unified existence to any collection of associated parts. SELF- is simply combination of all experiences with a particular person Believes that man can only know what comes from the senses and experiences. 8. IMMANUEL KANT stated that humans have inner and outer self METAPHYSICAL SELF explores the nature of being existence with no basis in reality. The INNER SELF includes rational reasoning and psychological state. The OUTER SELF includes the body and physical mind where representation occurs. SELF- seat of knowledge acquisitions for all human persons. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki /David_Hume https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/I mmanuel_Kant MODERN TIMES 9. GILBERT RYLE believed that the mind and the body are ordinarily harnessed together, but after the death of the body the mind may continue to exist and function. Ghost in the machine- in contrast of “Cartesian dualism.” Self is known through the actions revealed by MODES OF BEHAVIOR “I act therefore I am” 10. PATRICIA and PAUL CHURCHLAND said that the self is the BRAIN Neurophilosophy-Concerned with association of the brain and the mind. In order to understand the workings of the human mind, people must first understand the brain, its functions and wave activity. the physical brain and not imaginary brain that controls self https://www.philosophybasics .com/philosophers_ryle.html https://www.newyorker.com/ magazine/2007/02/12/twoheads 6 11. MERLEAU-PONTY posited that the self is EMBODIED SUBJECTIVITY and is based on experience PHYSICAL BODY is important in subjective being “SELF”- is a product of both idealist and realist standpoints. Mind and Body are so intertwined that they cannot be separated from one another. One’s body is his opening toward his existence to the world. The living body, his thoughts emotions and experiences are all ONE. https://psychology.wikia.org/w iki/Maurice_Merleau-Ponty 7 Activity I DO YOU TRULY KNOW YOURSELF? Answer the following questions about yourself as fully and precisely as you can. 1. How would you characterize yourself? 2. What makes you stand out from the rest? What makes yourself special? 3. How has yourself transformed itself? 4. What will happen to yourself after you die? 5. What is your own philosophy of self? 8 Lesson 2 SOCIOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE Module 1: Lesson 2 Learning Outcomes: At the end of the lesson, the learners must have: 1. examined yourself against the different sociological views about self; 2. distinguished how the sociological perspective on the self are applied; and 3. demonstrated critical and reflective thinking in showing different aspects of the self. Introduction In this section, you will learn about how sociologists use paradigms to understand the social world. A paradigm is a broad viewpoint, perspective, or lens that permit social scientists to have a wide range of tools to describe society, and then to build hypotheses and theories. You can also consider paradigms to be guiding principles or belief systems. In the text, you’ll sometimes see the word paradigm used interchangeably with perspective, theory, or approach. 9 Acquire SELF is a relatively stable set of perceptions of who we are in relation to ourselves, others, and social systems. It is socially constructed in the sense that it is shaped through interaction with other people. SOCIALIZATION is a means by which human infants begin to acquire the skills necessary to perform as a functioning member of their society and is the most influential in learning process one can experience. LOOKING GLASS SELF by CHARLES COOLEY “I am not what I think I am and I am not what you think I am; I am what I think that you think I am.” https://www.pinterest.ph/pin/433 893745320806162/ The LOOKING-GLASS SELF is a social concept stating that a person’s self grows out of society’s INTERPERSONAL INTERACTIONS and the PERCEPTIONS OF OTHERS. The view of ourselves comes from the contemplation of personal qualities and impressions of how others perceive us. The term refers to people shaping their identity based on the perception of others, which leads the people to reinforce other people’s perspectives on themselves. People shape themselves based on what other people perceive and confirm other people’s opinion of themselves. Cooley adheres to the INTERACTIONIST PERSPECTIVE OF SOCIOLOGY which aims to understand the meanings attached to the certain situations and the behavior attach to it. He observed his own children to study human nature. 3 Processes involved in developing the Self-concept or self-image according to Cooley: We imagine what judgments people make of us based on our appearance. We imagine how the person feels about us, based on the judgments made of us. The result could lead us to change our behavior based on how we feel people perceive us. THE PRIMARY GROUP is the source of human nature and is characterized by close, intimate, face-to-face interaction whose primary function is socialization THE SECONDARY GROUP refers to the larger and more disparate ‘nucleated group whose members were rarely if ever all in direct contact. 10 THEORY OF SOCIAL SELF BY GEORGE HERBERT MEAD Mead's theory of the social self is based on the perspective that the self emerges from SOCIAL INTERACTIONS, such as observing and interacting with others, responding to others' opinions about oneself, and internalizing external opinions and internal feelings about oneself. According to Mead, the self is not there from birth, but it is developed over time from social experiences and activities. DEVELOPMENT OF SELF Preparatory Stage (imitation Stage) LANGUAGE develops self by allowing individuals to respond to each other through symbols, gestures, words, and sounds. PLAY develops self by allowing individuals to take on different roles, pretend, and express expectation of others. GAMES develop self by allowing individuals to understand and PARTS OF THE SELF “ME” part of the self is Objective element and active part of self. It is our Social Self and it is the organized set of attitudes of others which individuals assumes “I “part of the self is the part of you that’s existing out in the world, acting, being spontaneous, etc. It is the subject of action. It’s what you would commonly think of as yourself. It is in response to the ME self Social acts, through transactions between persons who are mutually oriented toward each other. 11 Activity 2 My Self through the Years Paste a picture of you when you were in elementary, in high school, and now that you are in college. Below the picture, list down your salient characteristics that you remember. My Elementary Self My Elementary Self My Elementary Self After having examined your “self” in its different stages, answer the following: 1. Similarities in all stages of my “self” 2. Differences in my “self” across the three stages of my life 3. Possible reasons for the differences in me. 12 Lesson 3 ANTHROPOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE Learning Outcomes: At the end of the lesson, the learners must have: 1. increased awareness of the various dimensions of anthropology and its influence on self-concept; 2. appreciated how each culture develops a unique cultural lens; and 3. reflected on your own identity how culture influences our beliefs and behavior. Introduction Anthropology is the study of human differences, cultural and biological, in the context of human nature. Anthropologists identify and compare behaviour of a particular group against the full range of human behaviour. Such comparison should uncover principles that apply to all human communities. Third World Focus was the distinguishing characteristics of this discipline. Until after the Second World-War, anthropology focused almost exclusively on non-western or 'tribal people'. For a long time, anthropologists assumed that non-European cultures were different enough to justify a different social science discipline to study them. This assumption seems less persuasive today. 13 Acquire Study of Humanity and How I feel About Life https://www.scribd.com/presentation/416152668/Anthropology-as-a-Perspective-in-Understanding-the-self The study of human societies and cultures and their development Culture is the set of unwritten norms of conduct that guide the behavior of a group Culture is the acquired pair of glasses through which we see life https://www.scribd.com/presentation/416152668/Anthropology-as-a-Perspective-in-Understanding-the-self Archaeology Examines the remains of ancient and historical human populations to promote an understanding of how humans adapted to their environment and developed. 14 Linguistic Anthropology Examines the language of a group of people and its relation to their culture. Cultural Anthropology Promote to study of a society’s culture through their belief systems, practices, and possessions. Physical Anthropology Looks into the Biological Development of Humans and their contemporary variation. Culture Filters “On Automatic” We see and interpret behavior through our own cultural filter (cultural programming) Parents, friends, and relatives were simply passing on the message Forming stereotypes about people who were different from us (politician, Igorot, homeless) Dilemmas of a Society Hierarchy vs. Equality Individualism vs. Collectivism Performance vs. Caring Uncertainty vs. Let it be Flexibility vs. Discipline Three Ways we can Relate to Culture CONFRONT -you believe that your behaviors are the right behavior CONFORM- when you adapt your way to behave, when you conform to the whole society COMPLAIN- what happens is that you will isolate yourself into social bubbles of foreigners living in segregation with the society The challenge of becoming culturally competent Diversity is an inside job. Diversity goes beyond race and gender No one is the target of blame for current to past inequities. Human beings are ethnocentric The human species resists changes, continuing to seek homeostasis. Human beings find comfort and trust in likeness It is difficult for people to share power 15 Activity III Name: Date: Program, Year and Section: Score: Direction: Write an essay about what it means to be Filipino. 16 References Csordas T. (1999) Self and Person. In bode (ed). Psychological Anthropology. Praeger. 331- 350 David, Randolph.2002. Nation, Self, and citizenship: An Invitation to Philippine Sociology. Department of Sociology, College of Social Sciences and Philosophy, University of the Philippines Geertz, C. (1973). The Impact of the Concept of Culture and the Concept of Man. 33-54 and Person, Time and Conduct in Bali.360-441. In The Interpretation of the Culture. Basic Books Hume, David, and Eric Steinberg. 1992. An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding; [with] A Letter from a Gentleman to his Friend in Edinburgh; [and] An Abstract of a Treatise of Human Nature. Indianapolis: Hackett Publishing Ingram, P.D. (2001). An Overview of Diversity Awareness. Penn State College of Agricultural Services, Pennsylvania Plato. 2017. The Republic. Germany: BookRix Zagorca, G. (2010). An Anthropological Conceptualization of Identity. Synthesis Philosophical 25-43 Internet Sources Whittaker, G. (2016). What is Social Psychology? Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=k99ZWnQ-o4U What is Anthropology? http://www.americananthro.org/AdvanceYourCareer/Content.aspx?I temNumber=2150 https://courses.lumenlearning.com/wmopenintrotosociology/chapter/sociological-perspectives/ lumenlearning.com/sociology/chapter/theories-of-self-development/ https://www.slideshare.net/NaraMier/module-3-anthropology-and-thestudy-of-culture 17