China Going Global Investment Index 2023 The Belt and Road Initiative’s second decade The world leader in global business intelligence EIU offers deep insight and analysis of the economic and political developments in the increasingly complex global environment; identifying opportunities, trends, and risks on a global and national scale. Formed in 1946, with more than 70 years of experience, it is ideally positioned to be a commentator, interpreter and forecaster on the phenomenon of globalisation as it gathers pace, enabling businesses, financial firms, educational institutions and governments to plan effectively for uncertain futures. Actionable insight to win in the world’s markets The world’s leading organisations rely on our subscription services for data, analysis and forecasts that keep them informed about emerging issues around the world. We specialise in: • Country analysis—access detailed country-specific economic and political forecasts, as well as assessments of the business environments in different markets with EIU Viewpoint. • Risk analysis—our risk services identify actual and potential threats around the world to help our clients understand the implications for their organisations. Available products: Financial Risk and Operational Risk. • Industry analysis—five-year forecasts, analysis of key themes and news analysis for six key industries in 60 major economies. These forecasts are based on the latest data and in-depth analysis of industry trends, available via EIU Viewpoint. • Speaker Bureau—book the experts behind the award-winning economic and political forecasts. Our team is available for presentations and panel moderation as well as boardroom briefings covering their specialisms. Explore Speaker Bureau for more speaker information. Contact us LONDON NEW YORK HONG KONG Economist Intelligence The Adelphi 1-11 John Adam Street, London, WC2N 6HT United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)20 7576 8000 e-mail: london@eiu.com Economist Intelligence 900 Third Avenue 16th Floor New York, NY 10022 United States Tel: + 1 212 541 0500 e-mail: americas@eiu.com Economist Intelligence 1301 Cityplaza Four 12 Taikoo Wan Road Taikoo Shing, Hong Kong Tel: + 852 2585 3888 e-mail: asia@eiu.com GURUGRAM Economist Intelligence TEG India Pvt Ltd Skootr Spaces, Unit No. 1, 12th Floor, Tower B, Building No. 9 DLF Cyber City, Phase – III Gurugram – 122002 Haryana, India Tel: +91 124 6409486 e-mail: asia@eiu.com DUBAI Economist Intelligence PO Box No - 450056, Office No - 1301A Aurora Tower Dubai Media City Dubai, United Arab Emirates Tel: +971 4 4463 147 e-mail: mea@eiu.com For more information on our solutions and how they can help your organisation, please visit www.eiu.com. CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Contents 1. Introducing the China Going Global Investment Index 3 2. 2023 main ranking and key findings 4 3. 2023 sub-rankings 7 Market expansion: the next billion consumers in Asia and Africa India: the market that keeps China at arm’s length 7 8 Supply-chain development: capturing friend-shoring and near-shoring trends 9 Which South-east Asian country is for you? Identifying the strengths and weaknesses of each 10 Natural resources: why Central Asia stands out, and why African countries 1 vary in their appeal 12 Technology and innovation: focusing on non-critical IP in the West 14 4. Balancing opportunities and risks 15 Appendix 1: methodology notes 17 Appendix 2: full ranking 19 Appendix 3: full list of indicators 21 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE • The China Going Global Investment Index demonstrates the quantifiable aspects of overseas investment strategy decisions and a systematic approach to identifying opportunities and risks, leveraging EIU’s economic forecasts and forward-looking risk-assessment metrics. Companies can, in turn, tailor the rankings to their particular investment objectives. • The 2023 edition of the Index ranks 80 investment destinations based on their appeal to Chinese investors. Many emerging markets have grown more attractive to such investors over the last decade, because of their natural resources, market size and/or pivotal role in the global supply chain. Outside Asia, we have identified several Latin American, Middle Eastern and African markets with strong potential. • The risk tolerance of Chinese investors has declined, and the rankings for countries like Iran, Myanmar and the Czech Republic are therefore low. Chinese investors can use the Index to help them avoid countries with high levels of operational, financial and sanctions risk, as well as those with cooling political relations with China. 2 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE 1. Introducing the China Going Global Investment Index The Chinese president, Xi Jinping, launched the Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) in 2013, and in the decade since, Chinese companies have become formidable global investors. The flow of overseas direct investment (ODI) is set to grow further in the coming decade, after enthusiasm waned briefly in recent years because of the Chinese government’s call for less speculative investment, souring relations with key destination markets and the impact of the coronavirus pandemic. In the current geopolitical context, overseas expansion has gained importance. It enables Chinese firms to navigate trade restrictions and to secure essential materials and technologies, and China to strengthen its relations with other countries (particularly those outside the West). We forecast that China will regain its position as the second-largest source of ODI by 2024. The increase in Chinese ODI will probably mirror the trajectory observed previously in more developed economies, as China’s income and technological capabilities advance and the domestic market matures. However, China’s ODI flows will remain small relative to its economic weight (and those of the US). EIU has long supported companies and investors aiming to expand beyond their home markets and go global. We developed the China Going Global Investment Index in 2013 to demonstrate to investors the quantifiable aspects of ODI strategy decisions and a systematic approach to identifying opportunities and risks. Leveraging our economic forecasts and forwardlooking risk-assessment metrics, the Index scores and ranks economies based on the opportunities they present to Chinese companies, and the potential risks tied to bilateral relations and the business environment. Companies can, in turn, tailor the ranking to their particular investment objectives using the same dataset. How EIU evaluates the appeal of different investment destinations to Chinese investors Market expansion (17%) Bilateral relations with China (17%) Supply-chain development (17%) Opportunity (67%) 2013 Natural resources (18%) Technology & innovation (15%) Risk (33%) EIU Operational Risk (16%) Market expansion (22%) Opportunity (50%) Supply-chain development (16%) Natural resources (7%) Technology & innovation (5%) Bilateral relations with China (30%) 2023 Risk (50%) EIU Operational Risk (12.5%) EIU Financial Risk (7.5%) Source: EIU. 3 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE The 2023 edition of the Index ranks 80 investment destinations based on their appeal to Chinese investors, using around 200 indicators. We have incorporated new markets that are gaining attention from Chinese investors, such as Bolivia and Uzbekistan. We have given a higher weighting to risks, particularly those associated with geopolitics, which reflects the increasingly riskaverse approach to investment decisions. The mix of indicators chosen has also evolved over the past decade. Methodology notes, a full ranking and a full list of indicators can be found in the appendices. 2. 2023 main ranking and key findings Investment destination 4 2023 Rank 2013 Rank 2013-23 Change Singapore 1 2 ▲ Indonesia 2 44 ▲ Malaysia 3 18 ▲ Hong Kong 4 3 ▼ Thailand 5 35 ▲ Vietnam 6 41 ▲ Switzerland 7 7 — UAE 8 11 ▲ Saudi Arabia 9 15 ▲ Chile 10 22 ▲ India 11 33 ▲ Bangladesh 12 52 ▲ South Africa 13 49 ▲ New Zealand 14 17 ▲ Russia 15 9 ▼ Qatar 16 24 ▲ Egypt 17 51 ▲ Colombia 18 50 ▲ Kazakhstan 19 38 ▲ South Korea 20 28 ▲ Singapore tops the ranking as the most attractive destination for Chinese investors. Its appeal lies in its status as an established global business hub, its cultural ties to China and its neutrality in the tensions between China and the West. All of these factors suggest lower operational risks for Chinese companies and investors, who often encounter restrictions in other countries. In addition, the affluent city state serves as a headquarters for Chinese firms looking to tap into the rapidly growing market of South-east Asia. Its acclaimed technological expertise also offers research-and-development opportunities. Altogether these factors render Hong Kong (ranked 4th)—a special administrative region of China and another business hub in Asia—less attractive in comparison. However, we highlight the emergence of policy uncertainties as Singapore places more emphasis on social inclusion, such as an increased focus on wealth taxation and wage increases for low-income workers, which could disproportionately affect certain industries. South-east and South Asia have climbed steadily in our ranking since 2013, reflecting the regions’ robust growth outlook, growing middle class, abundant strategic natural resources and relative openness towards Chinese investors. As export hubs, many countries maintain strong supplychain ties with upstream Chinese suppliers, while benefiting from reduced tariffs in key export markets downstream. The attractiveness of Indonesia (2nd) stems from its nickel reserves, abundant cheap labour and vast market size, while Malaysia (3rd) and Thailand (5th) are enticing because of their relatively established infrastructure and complementary supply chains. The appeal of India (11th), which theoretically offers significant opportunities, is hampered by strained bilateral relations. © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE 5 Investment destination 2023 Rank 2013 Rank 2013-23 Change Cambodia 21 N/A — Mexico 22 30 ▲ Israel 23 31 ▲ Ecuador 24 64 ▲ Peru 25 42 ▲ Germany 26 10 ▼ Brazil 27 26 ▼ US 28 1 ▼ Austria 29 25 ▼ France 30 20 ▼ Sweden 31 13 ▼ Australia 32 5 ▼ Morocco 33 60 ▲ Mongolia 34 N/A — Philippines 35 39 ▲ Japan 36 4 ▼ Ireland 37 N/A — Algeria 38 61 ▲ Denmark 39 14 ▼ Serbia 40 N/A — Pakistan 41 47 ▲ Tanzania 42 N/A — Iran 43 57 ▲ Azerbaijan 44 59 ▲ Norway 45 8 ▼ Papua New Guinea 46 N/A — Finland 47 16 ▼ Netherlands 48 21 ▼ Slovakia 49 N/A — Uzbekistan 50 N/A — The rising ranking of many emerging markets can be attributed to their strong ties with China, natural resources, market size and/or their pivotal role in the global supply chain. China’s import diversification strategy dictates that it will not rely on a single market for commodity supply, and a wide range of well-endowed countries are therefore present, from Latin American countries such as Chile (10th) to Middle Eastern markets such as Qatar (16th). Mexico (22nd) is notable for supply-chain opportunities tied to market access in North America. However, its geographical distance and less friendly bilateral relations, especially in comparison with Asian economies, have prevented a further rise in the ranking. Conversely, Turkey (72nd) has lost its allure for Chinese investors because of an unpredictable foreign and economic policy landscape. The ranking of many advanced markets, including the US (28th), Japan (36th), Canada (55th) and the UK (60th), has plunged. Their deteriorating relations with China and the subsequent screening of inbound investment present significant hurdles for Chinese investors. Investment from China in sensitive sectors such as advanced manufacturing and telecommunications now faces heightened scrutiny. Nonetheless, their unmatched market size, high income levels, stable operational environments and prowess in technology and innovation have ensured that they remain attractive to investors in non-sensitive sectors. In this context, Switzerland (7th) and New Zealand (14th) distinguish themselves by remaining in the ranking’s top 20. © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Investment destination 2023 Rank 2013 Rank 2013-23 Change Turkmenistan 51 N/A — Spain 52 29 ▼ Angola 53 67 ▲ Dominican Republic 54 55 ▲ Canada 55 6 ▼ Nigeria 56 66 ▲ Portugal 57 40 ▼ Ethiopia 58 N/A — Hungary 59 N/A — UK 60 19 ▼ Poland 61 36 ▼ Sri Lanka 62 46 ▼ Zambia 63 N/A — Czech Republic 64 N/A — Italy 65 34 ▼ Bolivia 66 N/A — Congo (DR) 67 N/A — Kenya 68 65 ▼ Myanmar 69 N/A — Argentina 70 62 ▼ Belgium 71 23 ▼ Turkey 72 53 ▼ Bulgaria 73 N/A — Romania 74 N/A — Taiwan 75 12 ▼ Congo (Brazzaville) 76 N/A — Greece 77 56 ▼ Iraq 78 N/A — Venezuela 79 58 ▼ N/A — Ukraine 6 80 Risk considerations are very evident in the 2023 rankings. The rankings for Russia (15th) and Iran (43rd) have declined or stayed low as Chinese investors seek to avoid the potential for secondary sanctions. Despite this, Russia remains in the top 20 because of its resource endowment and market size, particularly with the withdrawal of Western companies leaving market gaps in sanctions-free sectors. Central and Eastern European countries like Poland (61st) have become less receptive to Chinese investment, especially after Russia’s invasion of Ukraine reignited concerns over European security. Many Central Asian countries rank lower than other emerging markets, given their less open markets and political volatility. Taiwan (75th) experienced the steepest drop in ranking, as crossStrait relations have deteriorated to one of their lowest points in recent decades. Controls on inbound Chinese investment have tightened considerably. Markets ranked at the bottom often face extreme challenges in their business environment, because of regional conflicts, local political upheaval and/or economic collapse. For instance, hydrocarbon and agricultural commodity investment opportunities in Ukraine (80th, bottom), Venezuela (79th), and Myanmar (69th) have been severely constrained by recent political and security crises. In the Democratic Republic of Congo (67th), the presidential election in 2023 serves as a flashpoint for instability. © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE 3. 2023 sub-rankings We also provide sub-index rankings tailored to specific investor interests. By fine-tuning indicator portfolios and adjusting their opportunity and risk weightings, we have identified the top 20 destinations for investors across various motivations. Methodology notes for these sub-rankings can be found in Appendix 1. Market expansion: the next billion consumers in Asia and Africa We anticipate strong momentum behind Most attractive destinations for market Chinese enterprises going global, with expansion investment expansion set to be particularly evident in Rank Destination consumer electronics, information technology 1 Indonesia services (eg data centres, e-commerce and 2 Bangladesh gaming), telecommunications, renewable 3 Vietnam energy and automotive products, where China 4 Malaysia has already been establishing its competitive 5 Pakistan edge. Seeking external markets has long been 6 Cambodia China’s ODI goal, but deteriorating relations with 7 Egypt conventional export markets and slow domestic 8 India 9 Tanzania growth have highlighted the urgency of finding 10 Colombia alternative markets. 11 Russia EIU nonetheless highlights risks 12 Ethiopia associated with market entry, ranging from 13 US local government policies towards imports 14 Angola and investment to public opinion on China 15 Philippines and Chinese products. Retail networks and 16 Nigeria infrastructure, taxation policies and the ease of 17 Israel profit repatriation are also prominent risks. 18 Brazil Market expansion opportunities are more 19 Congo (DR) prevalent in South-east and South Asia. We 20 Kenya forecast that Indonesia and Bangladesh will be among the top 20 global economies by 2040, based on market size, economic growth and the potential of the aforementioned sectors. Favourable industrial policies will also encourage firms to consider these markets as export bases. For example, though not listed in the top 20, Thailand’s combination of supply- and demand-side incentives for electric vehicles (EVs) is attracting Chinese automakers to position the country as their EV manufacturing hub in the Association of South-East Asian Nations (ASEAN). Africa’s market potential will be more pronounced in the late 2020s, with income and economic resilience continuing to improve and the African Continental Free-Trade Area (AfCFTA) 7 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE gradually taking shape. Transport and logistics services remain a key weakness in plans to develop better-connected regional markets, but—together with infrastructure development—they are sectors with high potential. Colombia stands out as one of the few Latin American countries in the top-ranked economies, as a result of the aggressive green transition policy promoted by the president, Gustavo Petro. However, Mr Petro’s weak position in the legislature points to the risk that none of his major reforms will be passed before his term ends in August 2026. Changes in government could result in policy discontinuity in the future. India: the market that keeps China at arm’s length India—the most populous country in the world and forecast by EIU to be one of the fastestgrowing economies in the 2020s—is the only single market that offers a potential scale comparable to that of China. Moreover, India relies on China for key inputs, including electronics and solar panel components, presenting a window of opportunity for Chinese investors. However, we expect India’s investment environment to become increasingly challenging for Chinese companies and investors. Corruption and bureaucratic hurdles, protectionist attitudes, challenges in land acquisition and other operational risks have long posed manufacturing supply chain, but the government’s incentives to promote manufacturing in India will be made available to Chinese players only on a very limited basis. Merely forming joint ventures ( JVs) with Indian companies will not ensure the circumvention of protectionist tendencies, and subsidies granted to Indian-Chinese JVs will be assessed on a case-by-case basis. Regulatory probes targeting Chinese companies (such as two consumer electronics brands, Xiaomi and Oppo) will continue intermittently, whether based on allegations of tax evasion, foreign-exchange violations or other legal issues. India's working-age population will grow significantly over this decade (change in working-age population between 2020 and 2030, m) difficulties for foreign companies, regardless of their origin. The strained relations between India and China, which we forecast will characterise bilateral Mainland China interaction for the rest of the decade, introduce -40.2 added geopolitical risks. India’s emphasis on self-reliance and its implicit competition with China point to a India Thailand (-3.3) 113.5 hostile environment for Chinese investment. Amid India’s continuing reliance on Chinese- Sri Lanka (0.2) manufactured goods and components, the country will aim to localise as much manufacturing activity as possible. The South Asian giant is well placed to benefit from geopolitical and economic Vietnam (2.8) 12.5 Philippines Malaysia (2.2) 18.2 Indonesia Source: EIU. trends that are driving the diversification of Asia’s 8 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Supply-chain development: capturing friend-shoring and near-shoring trends The sub-ranking for Supply-chain Most attractive destinations for Supplydevelopment assesses the competitiveness chain development investment of different investment destinations as key Rank Destination supply-chain nodes of Chinese manufacturers. 1 Singapore However, we suggest that investors consider 2 Malaysia the key operational risks associated with the 3 Thailand investment destination, such as labour market 4 Indonesia restrictions and disputes with major trading 5 Vietnam partners. Financial risks, such as exchange-rate 6 Mexico volatility and capital account convertibility, are 7 Egypt 8 Bangladesh also instrumental. 9 Morocco Beyond the natural “winners” of South-east 10 Cambodia and South Asia, several Latin American and 11 South Africa Eastern European countries stand out because 12 Chile of their integration with North American 13 Philippines and EU markets. Chinese manufacturers in 14 India Mexico enjoy tariff-free exports to the US via 15 Hungary the US-Mexico-Canada Agreement (USMCA). 16 Brazil Nonetheless, the long-term risk of the US 17 Poland restricting imports from Chinese firms operating 18 Bulgaria in Mexico could point to more opportunities in 19 Romania other Latin American countries, such as Chile, 20 Turkey which has strong resource endowment and a freetrade agreement with the US. North Africa and Turkey (alongside the Balkans, though not listed in the top 20) are up-andcoming regions that could fill some of the gaps in low-value manufacturing, along with supplychain activities such as warehousing and logistics. Egypt has a diverse industrial foundation and a focus on renewable energy which, combined with the strategic location of the Suez Canal, underscore its potential as a green hydrogen logistics hub. However, the government’s slow progress in rolling out hydrogen policies will lead to investment delays. The Balkans and Turkey, strategically situated between Europe and the Middle East, also maintain relatively low labour and regulatory burdens compared to the rest of Eastern Europe. However, Turkey’s economic outlook is hampered by soaring inflation, exchange-rate issues and potential capital controls. 9 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Manufacturers are moving to Mexico's border states, driving up real-estate demand (% of of industrial space absorption of 2021) Ciudad Juárez, Chihuahua 17% Tijuana, Baja California 8% Aguascalientes, Aguascalientes 2% 40-50% 30-40% 20-30% 10-20% 0-10% UNITED STATES Coahuila 20% Monterrey, Nuevo León 45% M EXICO Toluca, State of Mexico 2% Guadalajara, Jalisco 1% Guanajuato, Guanajuato 4% BELIZE GUATEMALA Sources: Grupo Bursátil Mexicano (GBM), using data from CBRE; EIU. Which South-east Asian country is for you? Identifying the strengths and weaknesses of each When comparing various investment destinations with similar rankings, a detailed breakdown of risks is necessary. For instance, for companies looking to establish manufacturing plants in South-east Asia, both Vietnam and the Philippines are appealing options because of their low labour costs. However, their risk profiles differ. Vietnam has significantly higher labour market risks compared to the Philippines, due to the former’s rising wages and lack of skilled labour. 10 Still, the Philippines’ restrictive labour regulations could result in increased labour costs and greater incentives for firms to remain informal. Conversely, security risk is relatively high in the Philippines, against the backdrop of significant drugs trade. Ties with China are likely to deteriorate, with the Philippines leaning closer to the US under the current president, Ferdinand “Bongbong” Marcos Jr. Continual monitoring of risks will be necessary for those who already have a significant presence in a given economy. In particular, risk scenario planning accelerates response at the business level when emergencies do occur. © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Comparing operational risk in Vietnam and the Philippines (EIU Operational Risk score, 100=high risk) Vietnam Philippines Financial 70 Tax policy Foreign trade & payments 60 50 40 30 20 10 Security Government effectiveness Political stability Infrastructure Macroeconomic Labour market Legal & regulatory Note. As at Q1 2023. Source: EIU Operational Risk. Top five risk scenarios for businesses operating in Vietnam Risk scenario Risk category Probability Impact Intensity The government drastically increases rules-of-origin enforcement actions Foreign trade & payments High High 16 Vietnam is hit by El Niño weather conditions Macroeconomic Very high Moderate 15 A major domestic bank fails, forcing the government to provide assistance Financial Moderate High 12 Plans to expand the capacity of ports and airports suffer multi-year delays Infrastructure High Moderate 12 Security Low Very high 10 Territorial disputes in the South China Sea lead to an outbreak of hostilities Intensity colour key: 1-4 5-8 9-12 13-16 17-25 Note. Intensity is a product of the probability and impact ratings, where “Very low” scores 1 and “Very high” scores 5. Source: EIU Operational Risk. 11 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Natural resources: why Central Asia stands out, and why African countries vary in their appeal China’s interest in natural resource Most attractive destinations for natural investments has evolved to become more resources investment systemic. The strategy to diversify imports has Rank Destination become increasingly evident, as has competition 1 Indonesia for mine exploitation and pricing rights. Priorities 2 Australia have shifted, with agricultural commodities and 3 Saudi Arabia strategic minerals like lithium, cobalt and nickel 4 UAE now taking precedence over coal. 5 Qatar For long-term mining projects, EIU 6 Brazil advises companies to monitor closely risks 7 Chile related to political instability, regulatory 8 Kazakhstan uncertainty, environmental protection 9 Vietnam policies, infrastructure deficiencies and 10 Iran foreign reserve coverage for capital 11 Russia 12 Canada goods imports. The emergence of resource 13 India nationalism can take various forms, including 14 Philippines escalated taxation, changing licensing and equity 15 Turkmenistan requirements and the imposition of export 16 US restrictions. Bilateral relations are increasingly 17 Argentina influential, with countries such as Canada limiting 18 Nigeria Chinese investments. High-profile projects are 19 Congo (DR) also vulnerable to the whims of the election 20 Iraq cycle, during which concerns about resource exploitation and “debt-trap” narratives might arise. Beyond the obvious choices of oil- and gas-rich Gulf countries, strong bilateral ties and geopolitical proximity have rendered Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan attractive to Chinese investors. Only a few African countries rank among the top 20 investment destinations, largely because of the aforementioned operational risks in many African countries. In addition, while China has expanded its reach across the continent’s mining sector, it still plays a minor role compared to regional giants and Western-aligned multinational mining companies, with incumbents likely to retain a dominant position. 12 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Monitoring the 2023-24 election cycle in Africa Tunisia Morocco Algeria Libya Egypt Cabo Verde Mauritania Mali Senegal Niger Sudan Eritrea The Gambia Chad Burkina Faso GuineaDjibouti Guinea Bissau Nigeria Sierra Leone Ethiopia Central South Liberia Somalia Cameroon African Sudan Côte d’Ivoire Republic Rwanda Uganda Ghana Kenya Togo Gabon Democratic Benin Republic Seychelles São Tomé & Príncipe of Congo Tanzania Equatorial Guinea Burundi Congo (Brazzaville) Comoros Malawi Angola Zambia Election for head of state and/or national legislature in ... 2023 Madagascar Zimbabwe Namibia Botswana Mozambique 2024 Eswatini South Africa Lesotho Mauritius Source: EIU. Mapping Chinese mineral investment in Africa (2021) Tunisia Morocco Algeria Cabo Verde Mauritania Mali Fe Niger Senegal Li Sudan Eritrea Cu Zn Au Ag The Gambia U Chad Au Guinea- Guinea Burkina Faso Au Nigeria Bissau Bx Fe Ethiopia Djibouti Sierra Leone Côte Li Central South Au Fe Fe Au Liberia d’Ivoire Cameroon African Sudan Fe Au Mn Somalia Benin Fe Au Ghana Democratic Kenya Bx Au Togo Gabon Uganda Au Mn Fe Au Republic Seychelles Fe Congo (Brazzaville) of Congo Cu Co Ct Au Tanzania Rwanda Major mineral locations Malawi Angola Zambia Bx Bauxite Li Lithium Comoros Dd Cu Co Cl Coal Mn Manganese Zimbabwe Madagascar Co Cobalt Ni Nickel Li Ni Dd Namibia Au Ct Coltan/TantalumPt Platinum Li U Botswana Mozambique Ag Silver Cu Copper C Ti Cl Dd Diamond Ti Titanium Mauritius South Au Gold U Uranium Dd Lesotho Africa C Graphite Zn Zinc Au Cu Bx Pt Fe Iron ore Source: EIU. 13 Countries in receipt of Chinese investment © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Technology and innovation: focusing on non-critical IP in the West Technology acquisition used to be a key reason for Chinese companies to go global, but it now constitutes a small share of ODI, as technological competition with the West intensifies. Although this sub-ranking is aimed at identifying markets with strong innovation capacity, acquisitions have become exceedingly challenging. We nonetheless retain the ranking to assist investors in non-sensitive industries in finding investment destinations. For example, Chinese game developers such as Tencent and Netease have maintained their investment activity in gaming studios in Europe, Japan and South Korea. For European countries, we advise investors to assess their investment risks based on the implementation of EU regulations on investment screening, and those on foreign subsidies in merger-and-acquisition deals. 14 Most attractive destinations for technology and innovation investment Rank Destination 1 Singapore 2 South Korea 3 Switzerland 4 Germany 5 Israel 6 Japan 7 Austria 8 Sweden 9 France 10 Denmark 11 Netherlands 12 Finland 13 US 14 United Kingdom 15 Norway 16 Italy 17 Belgium 18 Australia 19 Spain 20 Canada © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE 4. Balancing opportunities and risks The mixed record of Chinese ODI over the last decade underscores the importance of anticipating the risks associated with entering a foreign country. The Chinese government has increasingly emphasised the “rationalisation” of overseas investment; the prioritisation of “small and beautiful” projects in the BRI is part of this drive. In our monitoring of Chinese ODI trends, we have recognised that risk tolerance has declined among many Chinese investors. Recognising different levels of risk tolerance and management capacity among investors, we have supplemented the ranking with an opportunity/risk matrix—a tool designed to categorise markets into various groups. The matrix does not aim to indoctrinate one set of investment guidelines, nor does it intend to provide sets of white or black lists. Instead, all shortlisted Destinations with few opportunities and high risk Destinations with more opportunities but high risk High risk Taiwan Ukraine Venezuela United States Greece BG TR Congo (DR) RO KE BE Canada Congo (Brazzaville) GB MM PL CZ HU IR IT ET NG Philippines Argentina BO ES UZ IE DO Brazil PT Russia Zambia TM PK JP FI Few AO South Korea AZ AU NL opportunities DZ SK NO Germany PG TZ Sri Lanka MA Mexico IL YG DK FR KH MN SE KZ EG Bangladesh CO AT QA Vietnam Ecuador PE Iraq New Zealand ZA UAE Saudi Arabia Switzerland Chile Thailand Destinations with less risk but few opportunities Hong Kong India More opportunities Indonesia Malaysia Singapore Destinations with more opportunities and less risk Low risk 15 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE economies are popular destinations for Chinese investment, and the matrix aims to indicate their relative opportunities and risks, as well as the possibility of leveraging EIU forecasts and ratings to evaluate market appeal quantitatively and to forecast the opportunities and risks that lie ahead. Destinations with more opportunities and less risk Destinations with less risk but few opportunities Destinations with more opportunities but high risk Destinations with few opportunities and high risk BD AT Austria DZ AO Chile Bangladesh KH Cambodia CL CO Colombia DK Denmark EG Egypt EC FR France HK Hong Kong Ecuador Algeria Angola AU Australia AR Argentina BR AZ Azerbaijan Brazil BG Bulgaria BE Belgium CA BO Bolivia Canada DE Germany MN Mongolia CD Congo (DR) CG Congo (Brazzaville) ID Indonesia NZ New Zealand ET CZ Czech Republic Ethiopia IL Israel PG Papua New Guinea HU Hungary DO Dominican Republic KZ Kazakhstan PE IN FI Finland Peru India MY Malaysia YG Serbia IR Iran GR Greece MX Mexico TZ IE Ireland IQ Iraq MA Morocco JP Japan IT Italy Tanzania QA Qatar NG Nigeria KE Kenya SA Saudi Arabia PK MM Myanmar Pakistan SG Singapore PH Philippines NL Netherlands ZA South Africa PL Poland NO Norway SE Sweden RU Russia PT Portugal CH Switzerland KR South Korea RO Romania Spain TH Thailand ES AE UAE TW Taiwan VN Vietnam 16 TR SK Slovakia LK Sri Lanka Turkey UA Ukraine TM Turkmenistan VE Venezuela GB UK ZM Zambia US US UZ Uzbekistan © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Appendix 1: methodology notes Main ranking The decision on what opportunities and risks to include under the two pillars of opportunity and risk is based on factors that Chinese firms and EIU identify as crucial in their decisionmaking process. We have pinpointed four motivations for which Chinese companies “go global”: market expansion, supply-chain development, natural resources and technology and innovation. The risk considerations include a country’s bilateral relations with China and the operational and financial risks to general foreign investors. The latter two are based respectively on our Operational Risk and Financial Risk ratings. Within these categories of opportunity and risk, we have selected a series of around 200 forward-looking quantitative indicators. The full list can be found in Appendix 3. All indicators are compiled into category scores and ranking. They are then aggregated to form scores for each of the two pillars (opportunity and risk). Finally, these pillar scores are combined to generate the overall China Going Global Investment Index score for each investment destination. The ranking is based on the scores, in descending order. When solely considering investment opportunities, the US, Indonesia and Russia are appealing to Chinese companies. Hong Kong, on the other hand, does not offer many opportunities. However, Hong Kong is less risky for Chinese investors. Indonesia presents moderate operational and financial risks, but its ties with China are solid. Russia is under Western sanctions, while the US has a fraught relationship with China. Indonesia ranks highly in our ranking because of its good balance of opportunities and risks. Risk considerations have made the US and Russia less attractive to Chinese companies and investors. Hong Kong ranks highly, largely because it is a low-risk market. Rank Destinations with most opportunities Rank Destinations that are least risky Rank A balanced approach 1 India 1 Singapore 1 Singapore 2 US 2 Hong Kong 2 Indonesia 3 Indonesia 3 Malaysia 3 Malaysia 4 Russia 4 Thailand 4 Hong Kong 5 Vietnam 5 Chile 5 Thailand 6 South Korea 6 Indonesia 6 Vietnam 7 Philippines 7 Switzerland 7 Switzerland 8 Bangladesh 8 New Zealand 8 UAE 9 Brazil 9 UAE 9 Saudi Arabia 10 Taiwan 10 South Africa 10 ˸ ˸ Chile ˸ 15 ˸ Russia ˸ 28 US ˸ 45 Russia ˸ 68 Hong Kong ˸ 77 US ˸ 17 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Sub-rankings We have singled out the top 20 investment destinations under each of the four motivations: market expansion, supply-chain extension, natural resources exploration and technology acquisition. We first selected winners that ranked the highest by opportunities, and then re-ranked the 20 economies, factoring in risk factors such as sanctions, conflicts and exchange-rate volatility. Using the natural resources ranking as an example, Russia and Australia offer the most natural resources investment opportunities for Chinese companies and investors, but their ranking drops after operational and bilateral relation risks are taken into consideration. 18 Rank Top 20 destinations with the most natural resources opportunities Rank Re-ranked after factoring in their risk ranking 1 Russia 1 Indonesia 2 Australia 2 Australia 3 Brazil 3 Saudi Arabia 4 Iran 4 UAE 5 Indonesia 5 Qatar 6 Canada 6 Brazil 7 Qatar 7 Chile 8 Saudi Arabia 8 Kazakhstan 9 Congo (DR) 9 Vietnam 10 US 10 Iran 11 India 11 Russia 12 Vietnam 12 Canada 13 Turkmenistan 13 India 14 Iraq 14 Philippines 15 UAE 15 Turkmenistan 16 Argentina 16 US 17 Kazakhstan 17 Argentina 18 Philippines 18 Nigeria 19 Nigeria 19 Congo (DR) 20 Chile 20 Iraq © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Appendix 2: full ranking Investment destination 19 2023 Rank 2013 Rank 2023 Opportunity Rank 2023 Risk Rank* Singapore 1 2 19 1 Indonesia 2 44 3 6 Malaysia 3 18 11 3 Hong Kong 4 3 68 2 Thailand 5 35 17 4 Vietnam 6 41 5 14 Switzerland 7 7 25 7 UAE 8 11 28 9 Saudi Arabia 9 15 27 11 Chile 10 22 65 5 India 11 33 1 63 Bangladesh 12 52 8 18 South Africa 13 49 46 10 New Zealand 14 17 63 8 Russia 15 9 4 45 Qatar 16 24 33 15 Egypt 17 51 24 19 Colombia 18 50 35 17 Kazakhstan 19 38 29 20 South Korea 20 28 6 42 Cambodia 21 N/A 21 22 Mexico 22 30 22 24 Israel 23 31 20 25 Ecuador 24 64 73 12 Peru 25 42 48 13 Germany 26 10 14 32 Brazil 27 26 9 43 US 28 1 2 77 Austria 29 25 62 16 France 30 20 34 29 Sweden 31 13 43 23 Australia 32 5 18 36 Morocco 33 60 38 26 Mongolia 34 N/A 56 21 Philippines 35 39 7 57 Japan 36 4 12 50 Ireland 37 N/A 15 48 Algeria 38 61 26 39 Denmark 39 14 59 27 Serbia 40 N/A 60 28 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Investment destination 2023 Rank 2013 Rank 2023 Opportunity Rank 2023 Risk Rank* Pakistan 41 47 23 47 Tanzania 42 N/A 64 30 Iran 43 57 13 60 Azerbaijan 44 59 50 38 Norway 45 8 57 35 Papua New Guinea 46 N/A 74 31 Finland 47 16 52 40 Netherlands 48 21 61 37 Slovakia 49 N/A 72 34 Uzbekistan 50 N/A 36 52 Turkmenistan 51 N/A 42 51 Spain 52 29 41 53 Angola 53 67 71 41 Dominican Republic 54 55 54 46 Canada 55 6 16 70 Nigeria 56 66 40 56 Portugal 57 40 69 49 Ethiopia 58 N/A 45 59 Hungary 59 N/A 44 62 UK 60 19 30 66 Poland 61 36 39 64 Sri Lanka 62 46 80 33 Zambia 63 N/A 76 44 Czech Republic 64 N/A 58 61 Italy 65 34 67 58 Bolivia 66 N/A 70 55 Congo (DR) 67 N/A 31 71 Kenya 68 65 47 67 Myanmar 69 N/A 55 65 Argentina 70 62 78 54 Belgium 71 23 49 68 Turkey 72 53 32 74 Bulgaria 73 N/A 37 75 Romania 74 N/A 51 72 Taiwan 75 12 10 80 Congo (Brazzaville) 76 N/A 79 69 Greece 77 56 53 76 Iraq 78 N/A 75 73 Venezuela 79 58 66 78 Ukraine 80 N/A 77 79 * The higher the risk ranking, the lower the risk. 20 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Appendix 3: full list of indicators Opportunity Category Sub-category Market expansion Market size & growth Targeted industry Natural resources Food & grains Fossil fuel Industrial metals 21 Indicators Primary source Reference period Real GDP (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Private consumption (% real change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Gross fixed investment (% real change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Nominal GDP EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Total population EIU forecast or estimates 2023 Population (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Personal disposable income (per head) EIU forecast or estimates 2023 Personal disposable income (% real change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Mobile broadband subscriptions (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* IT services spending (US$; % change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* Healthcare expenditure (US$; % change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* Solar/wind/other alternative energy consumption (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* Gross electricity consumption (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* New passenger car registration (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* New commerical vehicle registration (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2019-25* New electric vehicle registration (% change, year on year) EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Arable land (per head) FAO 2020 Net food exports FAO 2021 Proven coal reserves EIA 2021 Proven natural gas reserves EIA 2021 Proven oil reserves EIA 2021 Copper (reserves) USGS 2022 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Opportunity Category Technology & innovation Sub-category Innovation input Innovation output Supply-chain development Industrial readiness Input cost Labour environment Infrastructure 22 Indicators Primary source Reference period Iron ore (reserves) USGS 2022 Lthium (identified resources) USGS 2022 Cobalt (reserves) USGS 2022 Nickel (reserves) USGS 2022 Rare-earth (reserves) USGS 2022 R&D researchers (full-time equivalent; per million) UNESCO Latest available Gross domestic expenditure on R&D (% of GDP) UNESCO Latest available School life expectancy (primary to tertiary education) World Bank 2021 Relative knowledge intensity of the economy OEC 2021 Patent applications (domestic and abroad) WIPO 2019-21 H-index SCImago 2022 Number of brands in top 500 Brand Finance 2023 Manufacturing as % of GDP World Bank Latest available FDI inflows as % of GDP EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 FDI inflows total EIU forecast or estimates 2023-27 Labour cost EIU forecast or estimates 2023 Business electricity prices Global petrol prices September 2022 Linear regression between overall unit labour EIU forecast or cost growth and nominal GDP growth estimates 2023-27 Working age population EIU estimates 2021 Working age population (% of total) EIU estimates 2021 Infrastructure risk score (including power, port and logistics, road, air and rail transport, EIU Operational telecoms and IT, cybersecurity and weather Risk resilience) March 2023 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Opportunity Category Sub-category Indicators Primary source Reference period Export opportunity Applied weighted tariff faced in major markets WTO 2022 Distance from the closest of China's largest export markets (EU, US and Japan) CEPII N/A China's largest export markets (EU, US and Japan), or trade agreement with them US, EU and Japan March 2023 Number of anti-dumping and anti-subsidy cases brought by large markets per US$ m of imports WTO and IMF 2013-22 Number of regional trade agreements notified to the WTO and in force WTO March 2023 Risk Category Sub-category Indicators Primary source Reference period Bilateral relations with China Distance & cultural relations Distance from China EIU scoring; CEPII N/A Traveller volume EIU scoring; OAG; FlightsFrom.com July 2023 Public perception of China EIU scoring; Pew Latest available Ethnic Chinese population EIU scoring; national sources Latest available Chinese language use EIU scoring; national sources N/A Belt and Road Initiative membership NDRC March 2023 Membership of selected regional and multilateral institutions EIU scoring March 2023 Alignment on international affairs at UN General Assembly EIU scoring; Erik Voeten Latest available Historical militarised disputes EIU scoring; Correlates of War Since 1949 Militarised disputes EIU scoring; Correlates of War March 2023 Political & geopolitical relations Trade relations 23 Membership of selected security institutions EIU scoring June 2023 Bilateral trade with China (% of the country's EIU scoring; GAC* total trade) 2013-22 Bilateral tade agreement in force and/or RCEP membership EIU scoring; MofCOM March 2023 Anti-dumping and anti-subsidy cases against China per US$ m of imports from China EIU scoring; WTO 2012-22 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 CHINA GOING GLOBAL INVESTMENT INDEX 2023 THE BELT AND ROAD INITIATIVE’S SECOND DECADE Risk Category Sub-category Investment relations Indicators Primary source Reference period WTO dispute settlement cases against China EIU scoring; WTO March 2023 Troubled investments EIU scoring; AEI 2005-22 and The Heritage Foundation EIU scoring; World March 2023 Bank Bilateral investment treaty in force Contracted project value EIU scoring; 2013-19 MofCOM EIU Operational & Financial Risks† EIU Operational Risk EIU Financial Risk Political stability risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Security risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Government effectiveness risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Legal & regulatory risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Macroeconomic risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Foreign trade & payments risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Financial risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Tax policy risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Labour market risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Infrastructure risk score EIU Operational Risk March 2023 Soverign risk score EIU Financial Risk April 2023 Currency risk score EIU Financial Risk April 2023 Banking sector risk score EIU Financial Risk April 2023 Political risk score EIU Financial Risk April 2023 Economic structure risk score EIU Financial Risk April 2023 * Historical data compiled based on data from national sources and international organisations. † The scores under EIU Operational Risk and Financial Risk are a simplified representation of 129 indicators. 24 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 EIU Viewpoint: Country Analysis Preparing you for what’s ahead Understand a country’s political, policy and economic outlook with our award-winning forecasts, analysis and data. Our experts assess the global dynamics that impact organisations, so you can plan and operate effectively. What’s included? • Global and regional outlook spanning politics, economics and market-moving topics • Daily insights on the developments that impact the future outlook • Executive summaries of country forecasts over the medium-term outlook • Medium-term country forecasts on ~200 countries’ political and economic landscape • Long-term country forecasts on the structural trends shaping ~80 major economies • Industry analysis on the outlook for 26 sectors in ~70 markets • Commodity forecasts on supply, demand and prices of 25 critical goods • Macroeconomic data on forecasts, as well as historic trends • Industry data on demand and supply of key goods, now and in the future • Proprietary ratings on the business environment • Thematic analysis of the cross-cutting issues that our experts expect to shape the global outlook How Country Analysis helps you to stay ahead Expansive coverage - global, regional and country-level analysis for nearly 200 markets, delivered by our analysts. Every month, 20,000 data series are updated, enabling you to adapt and plan ahead. Challenging consensus - stay ahead of your competitors. For more than 70 years our forecasting teams have made bold calls, accurately. A nuanced approach - intuitively designed to address politics, policy and the economy, our methodology includes detailed insights in addition to data. Robust, accurate information - apply insights with confidence. Our forecasts and analysis are nonbiased and rigorously researched. To arrange a demonstration of EIU’s Country Analysis service or to discuss the content and features included, please visit eiu.com/n/solutions/viewpoint/country-analysis/ 25 © The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited 2023 Copyright © 2023 The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited. All rights reserved. Neither this publication nor any part of it may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise, without the prior permission of The Economist Intelligence Unit Limited. While every effort has been taken to verify the accuracy of this information, The Economist Intelligence Unit Ltd. cannot accept any responsibility or liability for reliance by any person on this report or any of the information, opinions or conclusions set out in this report.