Reasoning and Problem Solving Reasoning Inductive Reasoning – is the process of reaching a general conclusion by examining specific examples. A conclusion based on inductive reasoning is called a conjecture. A conjecture may or may not be correct. 3 PROBLEM SOLVING EXAMPLE 1: Use inductive reasoning to predict the next number in each of the following lists. a)3, 6, 9, 12, 15, ? b)1, 3, 6, 10, 15, ? PROBLEM SOLVING 4 Your Turn Use inductive reasoning to predict the next number in each of the following lists. a. 5, 10, 15, 20, 25, ? b. 2, 5, 10, 17, 26, ? 5 PROBLEM SOLVING EXAMPLE 2: Consider the following procedure: Pick a number. Multiply the number by 8, add 6 to the product, divide the sum by 2, and subtract 3. Complete the above procedure for several different numbers. Use inductive reasoning to make a conjecture about the relationship between the size of the resulting number and the size of the original number. 6 PROBLEM SOLVING Solution: Pick any number: a Multiply by 8: 8a Add 6 to the product: 8a+6 Divide the sum by 2: 8π+6 2 Subtract 3: 4a+3-3 = 4a = 8π 2 6 2 + = 4π + 3 • Therefore, the given procedure produces a number that is four times the original number. 7 Your Turn • Consider the following procedure: Pick a number. Multiply the number by 9, add 15 to the product, divide the sum by 3, and subtract 5. • Complete the above procedure for several different numbers. Use inductive reasoning to make a conjecture about the relationship between the size of the resulting number and the size of the original number. PROBLEM SOLVING 8 EXAMPLE 3: Length of pendulum, in units Period of pendulum, in heartbeats 1 1 4 2 9 3 16 4 25 5 36 6 The period of a pendulum Use the data in the table and inductive is the time it takes for the reasoning to answer each of the following pendulum to swing from left to right and back to its questions. original position. a) If a pendulum has a length of 49 units, what is its period? b) If the length of a pendulum is quadrupled, period? what happens to its 9 EXAMPLE 3: Length of pendulum, in units 1 4 9 16 25 36 Period of pendulum, in heartbeats 1 2 3 4 5 6 a) If a pendulum has a length of 49 units, what is its period? 10 EXAMPLE 3: Length of pendulum, in units 1 Period of pendulum, in heartbeats 4 2= 4 9 3= 9 16 4= 16 25 5= 25 1= 1 36 6= 36 a) If a pendulum has a length of 49 units, what is its period? Each pendulum has a period that is the square root of its length. Thus, the pendulum with a length of 49 units will have a period of 7 heartbeats. 11 EXAMPLE 3: Length of pendulum, in units 1 4 9 16 25 36 Period of pendulum, in heartbeats 1 2 3 4 5 6 a) If the length of a pendulum is quadrupled, what happens to its period? 12 EXAMPLE 3: Length Period Length Period Length Period 1 4 9 16 25 36 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 4 9 16 25 36 1 2 3 4 5 6 1 4 9 16 25 36 1 2 3 4 5 6 a) If the length of a pendulum is quadrupled, what happens to its period? Quadrupling the length of a pendulum doubles its period. 13 Your Turn Velocity of Height of Tsunami, Tsunami, ft/sec ft 6 4 9 9 12 16 15 25 18 36 21 49 24 64 • Use inductive reasoning to answer each of the following questions. • a. What happens to the height of a tsunami when its velocity is doubled? • b. What should be the height of a tsunami if its velocity is 30 14 feet per second? NOTE • Conclusions based on inductive reasoning may be incorrect. Example: Ms. Dela Cruz wears white on Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday. What color does she wear on Friday? PROBLEM SOLVING 15 Deductive Reasoning – is the process of reaching a conclusion by applying general assumptions, procedures, or principles. 16 PROBLEM SOLVING EXAMPLE 1: All birds can fly. Tweetie is a bird. Therefore, Tweetie can fly Every Filipino of age 18 and above can vote. Juan is a 24 year old Filipino man. Therefore, Juan can vote. 17 PROBLEM SOLVING EXAMPLE 2: Solve a Logic Puzzle Each of four neighbors, Sean, Maria, Sarah, and Brian, has a different occupation (editor, banker, chef, or dentist). From the following clues, determine the occupation of each neighbor. 1) Maria gets home from work after the banker but before the dentist. 2) Sarah, who is the last to get home from work, is not the editor. 3) The dentist and Sarah leave for work at the same time. 4) The banker lives next door to Brian. PROBLEM SOLVING 18 Editor Banker Chef Dentist Sean Maria Sarah Brian PROBLEM SOLVING 19 1) Maria gets home from work after the banker but before the dentist. Editor Banker Sean Maria Sarah Brian x Chef Dentist x 20 PROBLEM SOLVING 2.) Sarah, who is the last to get home from work, is not the editor. 3.) The dentist and Sarah leave for work at the same time. Editor Banker Sean Maria Sarah Brian x x Chef Dentist x x 21 PROBLEM SOLVING 4. The banker lives next door to Brian. Editor Banker Sean Maria Sarah Brian x x Chef Dentist x x x 22 PROBLEM SOLVING 1) Maria gets home from work after the banker but before the dentist. 2) Sarah, who is the last to get home from work, is not the editor. Editor Banker Sean Maria Sarah Brian x x x x Chef Dentist x x 23 PROBLEM SOLVING Therefore, Sarah is the Chef Editor Banker Sean Maria Sarah Brian x x x x Chef Dentist / x x 24 PROBLEM SOLVING Sean is the Banker Sean Maria Sarah Brian Editor Banker / x x x x Chef Dentist / x x 25 PROBLEM SOLVING Since there is only one chef, mark the other cell in CHEF COLUMN with x Sean Maria Sarah Brian Editor Banker / x x x x Chef x x / x Dentist x x 26 PROBLEM SOLVING Maria is the Editor Sean Maria Sarah Brian Editor Banker / / x x x x Chef x x / x Dentist x x 27 PROBLEM SOLVING Brian is the Dentist Sean Maria Sarah Brian Editor Banker x / / x x x x x Chef x x / x Dentist x x x / 28 PROBLEM SOLVING Your Turn Solve a Logic Puzzle Brianna, Ryan, Tyler, and Ashley were recently elected as the new class officers (president, vice president, secretary, treasurer) of the sophomore class at Summit College. From the following clues, determine which position each holds. 1. Ashley is younger than the president but older than the treasurer. 2. Brianna and the secretary are both the same age, and they are the youngest members of the group. 3. Tyler and the secretary are next-door neighbors. 29 PROBLEM SOLVING Exercise: INDUCTIVE OR DEDUCTIVE • 1. I heard lots of barking last night. The neighbor’s dog must’ve been pretty upset about something, since he rarely barks. • 2. All dogs bark. Fido is a dog, so he barks. • 3. No book in English begins numbering its pages on a left hand page. This is a book in english, therefore it will begin its numbering on a right hand page. • 4. Based on a survey of 3300 randomly selected registered voters, 56.2% indicate that they will vote for the incumbent officials in the upcoming election. Therefore, approximately 56% of the voles in the upcoming election will be for the incumbent. • 5. All mollusks are invertebrates. Snails are mollusks, so snails must be invertebrates. • 6. Jack is taller than jill. Jill is taller than Joey. Therefore, Jack is taller than Joey. • 7. Cats routinely kill birds and mice. There is a cat, so it almost assuredly kills birds and mice. • 8. No whales live in freshwater, and the lake is a fresh water, so there are no whales living there. • 9. In the sequence 3,6,9,12,15, the next term is going to be 18. ANSWERS • 1. I heard lots of barking last night. The neighbor’s dog must’ve been pretty upset about something, since he rarely barks. • Answer: Inductive • Reason: The speaker is relying on a collection of experiences to draw an inference. • 2. All dogs bark. Fido is a dog, so he barks. • Answer: Deductive. • Reason: The premises guarantee the conclusion • 3. No book in English begins numbering its pages on a left hand page. This is a book in english, therefore it will begin its numbering on a right hand page. • Answer: Deductive • Reason: The conclusion follows necessarily from the premises. • 4. Based on a survey of 3300 randomly selected registered voters, 56.2% indicate that they will vote for the incumbent officials in the upcoming election. Therefore, approximately 56% of the voles in the upcoming election will be for the incumbent. • Answer: Inductive • Reason: The conclusion does not follow necessarily follow from the premise. The conclusion follow with some probability… • 5. All mollusks are invertebrates. Snails are mollusks, so snails must be invertebrates. • Answer: Deductive • Reason: The premise guarantee the conclusion • 6. Jack is taller than jill. Jill is taller than Joey. Therefore, Jack is taller than Joey. • Answer: Deductive • Reason: The premise guarantee the conclusion. • 7. Cats routinely kill birds and mice. There is a cat, so it almost assuredly kills birds and mice. • Answer: Inductive • Reason: Words such as “routinely” and “almost assuredly” indicate the inductive character of the argument. • 8. No whales live in freshwater, and the lake is a fresh water, so there are no whales living there. • Answer: Deductive • Reason: The premises guarantee the conclusion. • 9. In the sequence 3,6,9,12,15, the next term is going to be 18. • Answer: Inductive • Reason: The conclusion is based on pattern. Problem Solving 1. Problem Solving with Patterns Sequences A sequence is an ordered list of numbers. Each number in a sequence is called a term of the sequence. The ππ is used to designate the ππ‘β term of a sequence. A formula that can be used to generate all the terms of a sequence is called an ππ‘β − π‘πππ formula. PROBLEM SOLVING 42 EXAMPLE 1: Predict the Next Term Use a difference table to predict the next term in the following sequences. a. 5, 14, 27, 44, 65 b. 2, 7, 24, 59, 118, 207, … 43 PROBLEM SOLVING Solution: 5 d1 14 9 d2 27 13 4 44 17 4 65 21 4 44 PROBLEM SOLVING Solution: 5 d1 14 9 d2 27 13 4 44 17 4 65 21 4 90 25 4 Answer: The next term is 90. 45 PROBLEM SOLVING Solution: 2 d1 d2 7 5 24 17 12 d3 59 35 18 6 118 59 24 6 207 89 30 6 46 PROBLEM SOLVING Solution: 2 d1 d2 7 5 24 17 12 d3 59 35 18 6 118 59 24 6 207 332 89 30 6 125 36 6 ANSWER: The next term is 332. 47 PROBLEM SOLVING Your Turn: Use a difference table to predict the next term in the sequence. 1, 14, 51, 124, 245, 426 48 PROBLEM SOLVING 2. Problem-Solving Strategies One of the foremost recent mathematicians to make a study of problem solving was George Polya (1877-1985). He was born in Hungary and moved to the United States in 1940. the basic problem-solving strategy that Polya advocated consisted of the following four steps. 49 PROBLEM SOLVING Polya’s Four-Step Problem-Solving Strategy 1) Understand the problem. 2) Devise a plan. 3) Carry out the plan. 4) Review the solution. 50 PROBLEM SOLVING Polya’s four steps are deceptively simple. To become a good problem solver, it helps to examine each of these steps and determine what is involved. 51 PROBLEM SOLVING Once you have found a solution, check the solution. Ensure that the solution is consistent with the facts of the problem. • Work carefully. • Keep an accurate and neat record of all your attempts. • Realize that some of your initial plans will not work and modify your plan. PROBLEM SOLVING You must have a clear understanding of the problem. “Can you restate the problem in your own words?” Successful problem solvers use a variety of techniques when they attempt to solve a problem. 52 1) Understand the problem. You must have a clear understanding of the problem. Consider the following questions. • Can you restate the problem in your own words? • Can you determine what is known about these types of problems? • Is there missing information that, if known, would allow you to solve the problem? • Is there extraneous information that is not needed to solve the problem? • What is the goal? PROBLEM SOLVING 53 2. Devise a plan. • Successful problem solvers use a variety of techniques when they attempt to solve a problem. • β Make a list of the known information. • β Draw a diagram. • β Make an organized list that shows all the possibilities. • β Make a table or a chart. • β Work backwards. • β Look for a pattern. • β Write an equation. If necessary, define what each variable represents. PROBLEM SOLVING 54 3. Carry out the plan. Once you have devised a plan, you must carry it out. • Work carefully. • Keep an accurate and neat record of all your attempts. • Realize that some of your initial plans will not work and that you may have to devise another plan or modify your existing plan. 55 PROBLEM SOLVING 4. Review the solution. • Once you have found a solution, check the solution. Ensure that the solution is consistent with the facts of the problem. Interpret the solution in the context of the problem. Ask yourself whether there are generalizations of the solution that could apply to other problems. 56 PROBLEM SOLVING EXAMPLE 1: Apply Polya’s Strategy A baseball team won two out of their last four games. In how many different orders could they have two wins and two losses in four games? 57 PROBLEM SOLVING PROF. ANNABELLE Q. SOLLANO Solution Understand the problem: A baseball team won two out of their last four games. In how many different orders could they have two wins and two losses in four games? • There are many different orders. The team may have won two straight games and lost the last two (WWLL). Or maybe they lost the first two games and won the last two (LLWW). Of course there are other possibilities, such as WLWL. 58 PROBLEM SOLVING PROF. ANNABELLE Q. SOLLANO Solution Device a plan A baseball team won two out of their last four games. In how many different orders could they have two wins and two losses in four games? • Since it is about “order”, we will make an organized list of all the possible orders. Each entry in our list must contain two W’s and two L’s. PROBLEM SOLVING PROF. ANNABELLE Q. SOLLANO 59 Solution Carry Out the Plan A baseball team won two out of their last four games. In how many different orders could they have two wins and two losses in four games? • 1. WWLL • 2. WLWL • 3. WLLW • 4. LWWL • 5. LWLW • 6. LLWW PROBLEM SOLVING PROF. ANNABELLE Q. SOLLANO 60 Solution Review A baseball team won two out of their last four games. In how many different orders could they have two wins and two losses in four games? • The list has no duplicates and the list considers all possibilities, so we are confident that there are six different orders in which a baseball team can win exactly two out of four games. 61 PROBLEM SOLVING PROF. ANNABELLE Q. SOLLANO Solution Answer: Therefore, there are 6 different orders in which a baseball team can win exactly two out of four games. 62 PROBLEM SOLVING PROF. ANNABELLE Q. SOLLANO EXAMPLE 2: Apply Polya’s Strategy In consecutive turns of a Monopoly game, Stacy first paid $800 for a hotel. She then lost half her money when she landed on Boardwalk. Next, she collected $200 for passing GO. She then lost half her remaining money when she landed on Illionois Avenue. Stacy now has $2,500. How much did she have just before she purchased the hotel? 63 PROBLEM SOLVING Understand the Problem In consecutive turns of a Monopoly game, Stacy first paid $800 for a hotel. She then lost half her money when she landed on Boardwalk. Next, she collected $200 for passing GO. She then lost half her remaining money when she landed on Illionois Avenue. Stacy now has $2,500. How much did she have just before she purchased the hotel? We need to determine the number of dollars that Stacy had just prior to her $800 hotel purchase. PROBLEM SOLVING 64 Device a plan In consecutive turns of a Monopoly game, Stacy first paid $800 for a hotel. She then lost half her money when she landed on Boardwalk. Next, she collected $200 for passing GO. She then lost half her remaining money when she landed on Illionois Avenue. Stacy now has $2,500. How much did she have just before she purchased the hotel? Since we know the end result, let’s try the method of working backwards. PROBLEM SOLVING 65 Carry out the plan In consecutive turns of a Monopoly game, Stacy first paid $800 for a hotel. She then lost half her money when she landed on Boardwalk. Next, she collected $200 for passing GO. She then lost half her remaining money when she landed on Illionois Avenue. Stacy now has $2,500. How much did she have just before she purchased the hotel? • Stacy must have had $2500x 2 = $5000 just before she landed on Illinois Avenue; • $5000-$200= $4800 just before she passed GO; • $4800x2= $9600 prior to landing on Boardwalk. • This means she had $9600+800= $10,400 just before she purchased the hotel. 66 PROBLEM SOLVING Review In consecutive turns of a Monopoly game, Stacy first paid $800 for a hotel. She then lost half her money when she landed on Boardwalk. Next, she collected $200 for passing GO. She then lost half her remaining money when she landed on Illionois Avenue. Stacy now has $2,500. How much did she have just before she purchased the hotel? • To check our solution we start with $10,400 and proceed through each of the transactions. $10,400 - $800 = $9600. Half of $9600 = $4800. collected $200 (4800+200= $5000). Half of $5000 = $2500. 67 PROBLEM SOLVING Answer: She have $10, 400 just before she paid for a hotel. 68 PROBLEM SOLVING God blessο 69 PROBLEM SOLVING Reference: Aufmann, R. N., Lockwood, J. S., Nation, R. D. & Clegg, D. K. (2013). Mathematical Excursions, Third Edition. CA: Brooks/Cole, Cengage Learning. 70 PROBLEM SOLVING