1.2.1 Consumer behaviour If a music store was to offer you the latest vinyl albums at £5 each how many would you buy? If the price rose to £15 per album would this change your behaviour? Why is that? AQA 1.2: I NDIVIDUAL E CONOMIC D ECISION M AKING 1.2.1 W HAT 1.1.1 – 1.1.5 were covered in Y1 YOU NEED TO KNOW Rational economic decision making and economic incentives Utility theory: total and marginal utility, and the hypothesis of diminishing marginal utility Utility maximisation The importance of the margin when making choices Students should appreciate that the hypothesis of diminishing marginal utility supports a downward sloping demand curve but they are not expected to understand the principle of equi-marginal utility or to use this principle to explain why there is likely to be an inverse relationship between price and quantity demanded R ATIONAL Rational choice theory. ECONOMIC DECISION MAKING Maximisation occurs when an economic agent tries to obtain the most that they can from the economic activity that they undertake This will differ dependent on the economic agent: Households or consumers wish to maximise their utility or personal satisfaction Firms wish to maximise their profits Government wish to maximise the welfare of the population B EHAVING Economic objectives are the use of resources in order to meet the goals of an economic agent over a period of time. RATIONALLY - ECONOMIC OBJECTIVES Economic agents have a variety of economic objectives They meet these objectives by making use of the factors of production available to them Land, Labour, Capital and Enterprise These factors of production are turned into products that will allow the economic agent to meet their targets Economic agents include: Households Firms Government What are the economic objectives of these American professionals? B EHAVING Private benefits are those benefits that accrue to an individual or firm through economic activity. - HOUSEHOLDS The economic objectives of households might include: The maximisation of private benefit from consumption Can there be hidden benefits of consumption? RATIONALLY Individuals will seek to attain the highest level of satisfaction available in their consumption of goods and services The maximisation of private benefit from working Individuals will seek to attain the highest benefit available in the supply of their labour This might include higher pay or better working conditions B EHAVING Do you maximise the time spent on your studies or are you satisfied with a certain level of work? RATIONALLY - FIRMS Profit maximisation Firms will seek to attain the highest level of profit available in their production of goods and services Profit satisficing A level of profit below profit maximisation that satisfies the needs of the owners or managers of an organisation e.g. working less hours to enjoy more leisure time or behaving ethically Sales maximisation Some firms will seek to maximise sales, possibly to gain market share Growth Some firms seek to maximise their growth potential e.g. through the takeover of other firms R ATIONAL 1 BEHAVIOUR 10 In pairs write on to sticky notes a range of decisions you make on a regular or semi regular basis e.g. buying shoes, choosing where to go at a weekend, buying lunch, buying sportswear etc. Place each sticky note on a spectrum as shown above. 1 is 100% irrational and 10 is 100% rational. What are the factors influencing whether your behaviour is rational? If you asked a friend to place the sticky notes on the spectrum on your behalf would they agree with your assessment of your own behaviour? U TILITY THEORY Does appearance affect satisfaction? Should this be reflected in price? Utility theory is concerned with the satisfaction that an individual derives from consuming a good or service The unit of measurement for utility is called utils Total utility is the aggregate amount of satisfaction an individual derives from consuming a good or service Marginal utility is the amount of satisfaction an individual derives from consuming one extra unit of a good or service TOTAL UTILITY How much satisfaction do you get from your first cup of tea or drink in the morning? Is this the same for your second? Total utility diminishes or decreases over time As individuals increase consumption of a good or service the amount of satisfaction, or utils, that they receive from this consumption will decline This occurs as an individual becomes more satiated, or satisfied, with the product TOTAL UTILITY Total utility can be illustrated in a table. Have you ever over indulged or consumed a product without really wanting it? A consumer gains 10 utils of satisfaction from consuming 1 chocolate bar The satisfaction, or utility, gained from the second chocolate bar is less than the first, but total utility increases to 18 At some point, e.g. the 4th bar, there is no additional satisfaction After this point utility starts to fall and there is dissatisfaction from consuming an extra unit Presumably the individual would not consume this final unit. However, there is evidence that this happens in the real world Chocolate bars Total Utility (Utils) 0 0 1 10 2 18 3 22 4 22 5 16 TOTAL UTILITY Total utility can be illustrated graphically As consumption increases, total utility rises at first and then starts to diminish Total utility No. of bars 25 20 15 Utils 10 5 0 0 1 2 3 4 5 M ARGINAL UTILITY Marginal utility is shown by the formula: Change in total utility Change in number of units consumed Marginal utility can be shown on a table Chocolate bars Total Utility (Utils) Marginal utility (Utils) 0 0 1 10 10 2 18 8 3 22 4 4 22 0 5 16 -6 D IMINISHING MARGINAL UTILITY Marginal utility can be illustrated graphically As consumption increases, marginal utility diminishes giving us diminishing marginal utility Total utility 12 No. 10 of 8 bars 6 4 2 Utils 0 -2 -4 -6 -8 0 1 2 3 4 5 D IMINISHING MARGINAL UTILITY AND THE DEMAND CURVE If increased consumption of a good or service provides fewer and fewer amounts of marginal utility, then at some point, consumers will only buy additional units if its price falls Therefore, we can equate diminishing marginal utility to the demand curve. As price falls, consumers gain greater satisfaction from demanding the good This means that as price falls, demand increases As price increases, demand falls Draw and label a demand curve to illustrate this slide. M ARGINAL UTILITY AND OPPORTUNITY COST Opportunity cost can be used to look at utility If an individual gains greater marginal utility from product A than product B this will be reflected in the opportunity cost and they will choose an extra unit of product A rather than product B This suggests that they prefer product A as the benefit foregone of the next best alternative i.e. product B is lesser U TILITY MAXIMISATION In the real world utility maximisation will involve the marginal utilities of all products, not just A and B. Utility maximisation occurs where the last £ a consumer spends on each product yields the same amount of marginal utility If the last unit bought of product A provides more marginal utility than product B than the consumer will continue to purchase more of product A until the last unit purchased has the same marginal utility as product B Given that individuals have budget constraints utility will be maximised where: 𝑀𝑈𝑥 𝑃𝑥 = 𝑀𝑈𝑦 𝑃𝑦 For example, for utility maximisation to occur for an individual, the MU of chocolate bars divided by the price of chocolate bars must equal the MU of soft drinks divided by the price of soft drinks U TILITY MAXIMISATION In the table, chocolate bars are £1 and soft drinks £2. The individual will look to maximise utility. This occurs where: 𝑀𝑈𝑥 𝑃𝑥 = 𝑀𝑈𝑦 𝑃𝑦 Here, marginal utility is equal for each product. Chocolate bars (£1) TU (Utils) Soft drinks (£2) TU (Utils) 0 0 0 0 1 7 7 7 1 2 13 6 6 3 18 5 4 22 5 20 MU (Utils) MU/P MU (Utils) MU/P 16 16 8 2 26 10 5 5 3 34 8 4 4 4 4 36 2 1 -2 -2 5 32 -4 -1 Utility is maximised when an individual spends all of their budget. If they didn’t, they can gain greater utility by spending more. We can see that the individual would buy 1 soft drink rather than 1 chocolate bar because 8 utils is greater than 7 utils (Under MU/P). They would then buy an extra 2 chocolate bars before they purchase any extra drinks. However, they get the same satisfaction from the 3rd chocolate bar as they do from the 2nd soft drink. U TILITY MAXIMISATION Given a budget of £10 what combination of chocolate bars and soft drinks would an individual purchase in order to maximise utility? This occurs where: 𝑀𝑈𝑥 𝑃𝑥 = 𝑀𝑈𝑦 𝑃𝑦 Chocolate bars (£1) TU (Utils) Soft drinks (£2) TU (Utils) 0 0 0 0 1 7 7 7 1 2 13 6 6 3 18 5 4 22 5 20 MU (Utils) MU/P MU (Utils) MU/P 16 16 8 2 26 10 5 5 3 34 8 4 4 4 4 36 2 1 -2 -2 5 32 -4 -2 We can work out individual combinations (consumption bundles) but the utility maximising combination occurs where £4 would have been spent on 4 chocolate bars and £6 spent on 3 soft drinks. At this point the total budget of £10 is spent and total utility is 56. To equalise the utility we can use the formula: 𝑀𝑈𝑥 𝑀𝑈𝑦 4 8 = or = 𝑃𝑥 𝑃𝑦 £1 £2 T HE IMPORTANCE OF THE MARGIN WHEN MAKING CHOICES The margin is fundamental when individuals make choices Individuals will only choose an option if the marginal benefit is greater than the marginal cost This will improve their total utility If the marginal cost is greater than the marginal benefit then total utility will actually fall In this instance the individual would experience dissatisfaction from consuming the extra unit The individual will consume up to the point where marginal benefit equals marginal cost 10 MINUTES TEST YOURSELF 1. What is meant by total utility? 2. What is meant by marginal utility? 3. What is the relationship between marginal utility and the demand curve? 4. Explain the importance of the margin when making decisions. End