Briefing Session for the 2022 HKDSE English Language October 2022 1 Rundown • Overview of the 2022 exam • Paper 1 • Paper 2 • Paper 3 • 2023 Assessment Framework 2 Attendance in 2022 Day school candidates: Whole group: 40,948 45,062 3 HKDSE English Language candidates 2012-2022 90000 80000 70000 60000 50000 Day School Whole Group 40000 30000 20000 10000 0 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 2022 4 General performance in 2020-2022 30 Percentage of Cands. 25 20 15 10 5 0 U 1 2 3 4 5 5* 5** 2020 7.2 12.5 25.3 25.4 19.4 6.2 3 1 2021 7.5 12.5 27.5 26.8 16.6 5.5 2.7 0.9 2022 7.8 13.1 25.9 25.8 16.9 6.3 3.1 1.1 2020 2021 2022 5 Paper 1 Reading 6 Contents • Statistical Information • General Comments and Recommendations 7 Number of Candidates Taking Optional Parts (2022) Part Number Sat Popularity (%) 1A 45 029 Compulsory 1B1 20 392 45.3 1B2 24 637 54.7 8 Paper 1: Reading Statistics (2022) Paper 1 1A 1B1 1B2 84 42 42 42 39.5 49.4 47.4 41.3 20.8 22.3 18.1 19.7 9 Paper 1 Statistics (Whole Group) 2022 Mean: 39.5% 10 Part 1A: Reading Passage Reading Passage Article about Hong Kong comic industry and its future prospects No. of items 42 11 Part 1A Statistics (2022) Full Mark Part A Candidates taking B1 Candidates taking B2 42 Mean Score (%) 49.4 S.D. (%) 33.5 16.5 62.6 17.3 22.3 12 Mark Distribution (1A-Whole Group) 2022 Mean: 49.4% 13 How B1 Candidates Performed in 1A (2022) Mean: 33.5% 14 How B2 Candidates Performed in 1A (2022) Mean: 62.6% 15 Part 1B1: Reading Passages Reading Passages Two texts with the theme of job seeking - A collection of four classified ads for job vacancies - Online article about the ‘slasher’ 42 16 Part 1B1 Statistics (2022) Full Mark Mean Score (%) S.D. (%) 42 47.4 18.1 17 Part 1B1 Score Distribution (2022) Mean: 47.4% 18 Part 1B2: Reading Passage Reading Passage Text evaluating the ethical concerns of adopting artificial intelligence (AI) in business operation 42 19 Part 1B2 Statistics (2022) Full Mark 42 Mean Score (%) 41.3 S.D. (%) 19.7 20 Part 1B2 Score Distribution (2022) Mean: 41.3% 21 General Performance Performed well in items • Finding meaning of simple vocabulary • True-False-Not Given • Multiple choice • Gap fill • Finding simple factual details about the text & its genre • Asking about the tone and intention of the writer • Matching 22 General Performance Items pose challenging to candidates • Items requiring inferencing • Gap-fill requiring holistic understanding of the message • Sentence completion questions • Items requiring candidates’ detailed understanding of the main arguments 23 General Observation • Some candidates did not follow instructions carefully • word limits not being followed (e.g. one word only) • how many times particular options can be used in an answer • more specific instructions. For example, in some items where candidates were asked to provide words found in the text 24 Recommendations to Candidates • Read instructions carefully • Avoid excess copying • Be aware of the grammatical cues provided in the questions 25 Paper 2 Writing 26 Summary Statistics Overall performance • • • The mean mark of the paper as a whole is 53.8%. The mean mark for 2022 is similar to that of 2021 and 2020. Number of candidates continues on a downward trend. Mean: 53.8% No. sat: 44,946 27 Paper 2 – Writing Summary statistics Part A Part B Mean mark 54.9% 52.2% Standard Deviation 18.9% 20.1% Due to the special arrangements in 2022, the weighting for Part A was increased to 11.2% and 16.8% for Part B. 28 Paper 2 – Writing Q1: Complete two sections of a visitor’s guide for Hong Kong Adventure Farm 29 Paper 2 – Writing Q1 About Hong Kong Adventure Farm (Write about 50 words.) Provide some general information about the farm e.g. basic facts – when it opened, location, how to get there background – history of the farm, mission overview/summary Top three things to see and do (Write about 150 words.) Recommend activities for first-time visitors e.g. describing attractions (more unique, more compelling) emotional responses discussing routes/itineraries practical advice 30 Paper 2 – Writing Q1 • Sub-question level word guide e.g. 50 words, 150 words • Candidates generally stayed within the word guide • It is important that candidates try and stay within the word guide / space or number of pages given so that there is some uniformity in terms of producing similar length of work which increases fairness when assessing performance in public exam 31 Paper 2 – Writing Part B 32 Paper 2 – Writing Part B Popularity of the questions Pie chart that shows the popularity of each question in percentages. Debating Popular Culture 19% 25% Short stories 4% Drama 2% Poem & Songs 1% Workplace Communication Social Issues 17% 13% 19% Sports Communication 33 Paper 2 – Writing Part B Mean percentages Mean percentages of each question, ordered by the highest mean percentage Elective Topic Mean (%) Debate (Q9) Social Issues (Q5) Work Comm (Q3) Pop Culture (Q2) Short stories (Q8) Sport Comm (Q4) Poem Songs (Q6) Drama (Q7) Letter to the School Management about four-day school week 57.9% Letter to the editor about the lack of interest in traditional art forms Letter of Advice about whether to quit one’s job and start a café 55.1% Article about hosting a YouTube channel for teens 52.6% Story about a hiker who gets caught in a storm 48.4% Speech about coming second in the championship finals 45.6% Bio about a musical group 45.3% Drama journal entry about a playing heroes and villains 37.4% 53.1% 34 Paper 2 – Writing Indicating choice of question Candidates should check that the question they attempted has been correctly indicated 35 Paper 2 – Writing Learning English through Popular Culture You are the host of ‘Teen Chat’, a YouTube channel that explores a wide range of topics from a teenage perspective. Write an article for Teen Magazine about why you started this channel and what you have learned in the process. Introduction • self intro, intro to situation Body • Explain why you started channel • Share/reflect on what you have learned Closing • Description of a situation/personal experience, e.g. relating back to Covid-19 • Reasons linked to starting YouTube Channel should be developed and not just listing a set of skills/lessons learned • Ideas organized in chronological, reverse-chronological order, comparecontrast, problem-solution, cause-effect • If too many details are included, e.g. detailed steps to perform a skill, may affect coherence 36 Paper 2 – Writing Introduction • Text could be written in first person / third person Body • Examples of success/failure pursuing dream, • pros/cons of either decision, • challenges of running a small business Closing • Wish reader luck/words of encouragement Learning English through Workplace Communication You write an advice column for Jobs Online magazine. A reader submitted the following question: My dream is to open a café with a few friends, but I’ve just been offered a promotion at my company. The pay is good, but I’m not that interested in the work. Should I leave now or wait a few years? — Kam Chai, 25 years old Write a reply to Kam Chai offering your advice. • Advice should address the dilemma and does not need to recommend one particular stance but provide some perspectives for the reader to consider • Too many possibilities and scenarios may complicate and confuse the situation and therefore candidates should make have in mind a clear progression and logical flow of ideas 37 Paper 2 – Writing Introduction • Greet audience, welcome to event Body • Description of the season/ commentary/analysis, reflecting on achievements • Word of thanks to coach, teammates, principal/Any lessons learned/gained; Closing • Looking forward to the next season Learning English through Sports Communication You are the captain of the school’s basketball team. Your team made it to the inter-school championship final but came second. Write a speech to be delivered to the team at the end-of-season dinner celebration. • Appropriate tone: celebratory and entertaining and not just a recap of what happened during the season 38 Paper 2 – Writing Introduction • Express stance Body • Changes in society/culture/trends and impact on young people • Reasons for the phenomenon Closing • Restate stance / hope for further action to be taken • • Learning English through Social Issues The following comment appeared in the editorial of Hong Kong Post: Young people today lack interest in traditional art forms such as lion dance, calligraphy or the art of tea drinking. You are the chairperson of your school’s Heritage Club. Express your views by writing a letter to the editor of Hong Kong Post. Candidates who were able to link specific attributes of traditional art forms and how they influence or do not influence the lifestyle of young people would be considered more relevant in terms of content and task fulfilment. E.g. Learning different types of tea and how to pour tea is more involved than drinking Bubble tea from a plastic container vs Students today have a lot of pressure from academic studies and no interest in traditional arts 39 Paper 2 – Writing Introduction • Wh-questions about the group Body • Background, style of music • Upcoming events Closing • For more information, click on this button Learning English through Poems and Songs The musical group Nine Dragons has asked you to help promote them by writing a bio for their website. The bio should include background information about the group, style of music and plans for the future. • Purpose is to promote the musical group and attract visitors to the website to learn more about group • Use of sub-headings to organize ideas would be appropriate for a website 40 Paper 2 – Writing Introduction • Context of the role/character Body • Discuss challenge or interesting moments of playing particular role and reasons for preference • May be a critical enquiry into one’s learning experience/self observation Closing Learning English through Drama As part of your drama class, you played the role of the hero and the villain in different plays. Write an entry in your drama journal. Reflect on which role you preferred playing and why. • Recounting personal experience/thoughts of playing either role or both roles • Reflections may reveal personal opinions/views/motivation behind performing (in general or playing a hero or villain) • Only describing a plot without reflecting on playing role of hero/villain would not fulfil requirements of the questions 41 Paper 2 – Writing Learning English through Short Stories Introduction • Main characters, setting Body • Description of the event/incident • Description of surroundings • Description of feelings/emotions/reactions Closing You entered the ‘Stories of Survival’ short story competition. The theme of this year’s competition is ‘Nature: friend or enemy?’ Write a story about a hiker who gets caught in a storm while hiking in the mountains. • Linking plot to the theme: e.g. convey nature as caring or something to be feared • Past tense: what happened • Present tense: dialogue • Future tense or conditionals: what the story meant to the writer or morals or meaning drawn 42 Paper 2 – Writing Introduction • Salutation/Greeting • Stance Body • Supporting arguments/counterargument Closing Learning English through Debating The School Management is considering a four-day school week. Students would only need to attend school four days a week instead of five, but the length of each day would be increased by one hour. You are a member of the Parent-Teacher Association (PTA). Write a letter to the President of the PTA stating your opinion either for or against a four-day school week. Give reasons to support your view. • Letter should provide clearly stated points that are relevant to the discussion of schools adopting four-day week instead of five • May present rebuttals to his/her argument and refute them (not necessary to do both) • Tone of a concerned parent or teacher would add more interest to the points given 43 Paper 2 – Writing Stronger performance • show some insight and/or personal reflection • express creativity • make arguments that are valid Fair Performance • • • answer the question but with more general comments informative but not always engaging have less variety (ideas, sentence structures, vocab) 44 Paper 2 – Writing • Plan and draft an outline before writing • Edit the work after writing • Help with producing a response that is more polished and concise • Ideas should be communicated effectively, clearly and appropriate to the genre • Longer responses will not necessarily score higher by virtue of length 45 Paper 2 - Writing Changes to the 2024 Assessment Framework • Due to optimisation of the curriculum and flexibility in teaching of the electives, the number of questions in Part B will be reduced from 8 to 4 Sample Paper • https://www.hkeaa.edu.hk/DocLibrary/HKDSE/Subject_Inform ation/eng_lang/ENG-SP-Paper2-2024.pdf • Past Papers are good resource for sample questions (Examiners’ comments on candidates’ performance and statistics) 46 Paper 3 Listening and Integrated Skills 47 Paper 3: No. Candidates Part B (%) 48 Paper 3: Mean Scores Part A Part B1 Part B2 Full Mark Mean Score (%) 52 46.9 53 39.1 53 43.4 SD (%) 26.7 25.1 18.8 49 Part 3A score distribution for all candidates 50 Part 3A score distribution for 3B1 candidates 51 Part 3A score distribution for 3B2 candidates 52 Paper 3A results per task Mean (%) Task 1 A conversation re: a tour of Henry’s Umbrella Store. 61.7 Task 2 An interview re: the history of a porcelain factory and the reasons for its decline. 48.3 Task 3 A conversation between two members of Hidden Hong Kong Tours at Bolin Medicine’s factory. 44.3 Task 4 A conversation between two members of Hidden Hong Kong Tours about an interview with a retired toy factory worker in Hong Kong. 33.7 53 Paper 3A: Recommendations • Candidates should spend the preparation time familiarising themselves with the tasks. With the help of the information given, they may be able to predict the likely development of a text. •Candidates may predict the vocabulary they will hear in the recording and make guesses about possible answers. •Candidates should read the prompts and stems carefully to predict the required form of the answer, i.e. whether it should be a single noun, noun phrase, clause or sentence. •For some tasks, it is important to gain an understanding of the whole section of conversation: candidates may consider jotting down notes first before coming back to complete their answers during the tidy-up time. •Candidates should be prepared to compose answers in their own words: certain items may require them to infer the answers though not explicitly stated in the text. •Before moving on to Part B, candidates should take the time to check whether their answers make sense and are clear. 54 Paper 3B: Integrated Skills • Situation In both Parts B1 and B2, candidates took the role of Nico Lin, who works at Shiny Diamond Lighting Limited, a company that designs, makes and sells neon lighting products and services. In both parts, Nico is assigned to write texts for company use. 55 Paper 3: Mean Scores Part A Part B1 Part B2 Full Mark Mean Score (%) 52 46.9 53 39.1 53 43.4 SD (%) 26.7 25.1 18.8 56 Paper 3B1: Integrated Skills Three tasks: • Task 5: write an email to the students at the Hong Kong Design School to encourage them to apply to join Shiny Diamond Lighting Limited as trainees • Task 6: draft a leaflet on how neon signs are made for customers who visit the neon light factory • Task 7: complete a webpage detailing the company’s products 57 Paper 3B1: Task Mean Scores Task 5 6 7 Part B1 (easy section) Full Mark Mean (%) S.D. (%) 18 18 17 35.6 36.0 46.2 26.5 27.2 28.1 58 Part 3B1 score distribution 59 Paper 3: Mean Scores Part A Part B1 Part B2 Full Mark Mean Score (%) 52 46.9 53 39.1 53 43.4 SD (%) 26.7 25.1 18.8 60 Paper 3B2: Integrated Skills Three Tasks: • Task 8: a short history of the company for its website • Task 9: an email reply to Wan Yuen Estate Residents’ Association • Task 10: a short speech for the opening of an exhibition 61 Paper 3B2: Integrated Skills Task 8 9 10 Part B2 (difficult section) Full Mark Mean (%) S.D. (%) 18 17 18 47.2 46.9 36.2 20.8 22.6 21.2 62 Part 3B2 score distribution 63 Paper 3B: Recommendations •Weaker candidates tended not to understand the entirety of what was required in each task: candidates should take time to read all the instructions given in the Data File. •Candidates should pay particular attention to what is required in each task and only then locate the relevant information by reading the Data File texts carefully. •Whenever necessary, candidates should adapt the language of the Data File to suit the purpose of the task they are working on and be wary of copying large amounts of text indiscriminately. •Candidates should first read the given headings on the note-taking sheet and anticipate what kinds of information will be presented in the recording. •After listening to the recording, candidates should spend some time tidying up their notes, so that they can familiarise themselves with the information that will be useful for the tasks they will attempt. 64 Paper 3B: Reminder from the Assessment Guidelines Any / all of the following may vary from year to year: • • • • • • • The nature of the listening task The number of tasks The length of the tasks The points allocation per task The total points allocation for Part B The aspects of performance tested Etc. 65 2023 Assessment Framework Component Public Examination Paper 1 Reading Weighting 20% Duration 1½ hours Paper 2 Writing 25% 2 hours Paper 3 Listening & Integrated Skills 30% About 2 hours Paper 4 Speaking 10% About 20 minutes School-based Assessment (for school candidates only) 15% 66 Publications • 2022 DSE English Language Question Papers • 2022 DSE English Language Samples of Candidates’ Performance for all papers and all levels on HKEAA website http://www.hkeaa.edu.hk/en/ • To be published in November 2022 67