Navigating the Future: The Impact of the Changing Role of Finance and Accounting on College Educators by Tom Hood, CPA/CITP, CGMA, EVP, Business Engagement & Growth, Association of International Certified Professional Accountants Disclaimer: The contents of this publication do not necessarily reflect the position or opinion of the American Institute of CPAs, its divisions and its committees. This publication is designed to provide accurate and authoritative information on the subject covered. It is distributed with the understanding that the authors are not engaged in rendering legal, accounting or other professional services. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. For more information about the procedure for requesting permission to make copies of any part of this work, please email copyright@aicpa.org with your request. Otherwise, requests should be written and mailed to the Permissions Department, AICPA, 220 Leigh Farm Road, Durham, NC 27707–8110. ii Navigating the Future Contents 2 Executive Summary Introduction 3 The Changing Landscape of Finance and Accounting Competition from other disciplines Changing role of accounting and finance professionals in business and public accounting 4 Poll Results and Brainstorm Analysis Ways to build students’ skills 6 Recommendations 7 Conclusion 7 AICPA & CIMA resources 1 Executive Summary The rapidly changing trends and evolving landscape of accounting and finance have significant implications for college educators. As the talent shortage in accounting and finance continues,¹ colleges and universities not only seek ways to increase their relevance and value, they also play a larger role in recruiting students to their accounting and finance programs. This white paper aims to provide the latest market insights into the changing roles and responsibilities of college educators. These insights are based on brainstorming sessions and the results of comprehensive polls conducted among educators, students, and industry experts during the 2023 AAA Management Accounting Section (MAS) Midyear Conference in Atlanta. The findings suggest a need for innovative approaches to teaching that emphasize technology and data analytics and underscore the importance of practical experience in the rapidly evolving world of accounting and finance. Introduction In recent years, the global field of accounting and finance has undergone substantial transformation, driven primarily by technological advancements, regulatory changes, and burgeoning efforts to report on environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors. In addition, declining college and university enrollments in accounting and finance — exacerbated by competition from other majors — have led to a severe talent shortage in the profession. According to the latest Robert Half Talent Solutions Report, of the 62% of accounting and finance managers who are actively hiring, nearly 9 of 10 face challenges finding skilled talent.² As a result, college educators need to adapt both their approach to teaching and their curricula to remain relevant and effective. 1 Tom Hood, “The case for accounting and finance as a high-demand occupation,” Linkedin, March 2, 2023. 2 “In-Demand Roles: Finance and Accounting Hiring Trends,” Robert Half Talent Solutions, accessed July 18, 2023. 2 Navigating the Future The Changing Landscape of Finance and Accounting The following list comprises “hard trends,” in other words, trends that are predictable, underway, and inevitable, whether we like it or not: • Demographics. Since 2010, college enrollment has declined 9.6%. The U.S. birth rate, moreover, has been falling for well over a decade, a trend that is expected to continue. These two facts mean that, in coming years, the United States will have fewer traditionally collegeaged adults (that is, those aged 18–24), fewer of whom might wish to enroll in institutions of higher learning. • Technological advances. The proliferation of technologies like artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning, and blockchain will continue to revolutionize accounting and finance, automating many tasks and changing the way professionals approach their work. These trends are developing at an exponential pace as processing speed, data storage, and bandwidth continue to grow. Futurist Daniel Burrus suggested that between 2021 and 2023 — a period that overlapped with the COVID-19 pandemic — technology accelerated by an average of five years. • Regulatory changes. Increased regulatory oversight and a focus on transparency and accountability have led to changes in financial reporting, auditing, and corporate governance practices. This oversight has expanded to include ESG requirements, previously outside the profession’s field of responsibility but now firmly within the profession’s goal to measure and facilitate corporate decision-making on nontangible value.³ • Globalization. Global integration and the increasing complexity of international financial markets have created new challenges and opportunities in accounting and finance. Competition from other disciplines In addition to the hard trends, shifts in the business environment (like a new bull market on Wall Street) and demand for data analytics and programming have led to the need for more finance, data analytics, and IT majors, all of which competes directly with traditional accounting jobs and careers. Changing role of accounting and finance professionals in business and public accounting The swift evolution of the accounting profession is concurrent with the acceleration of technology and with the hard trends referenced earlier. The terms value-added accounting and finance business partner capture the expanded role of accountants as basic transaction work of the past becomes automated. Gartner estimates that 55% of CFOs are aiming for an automated, touchless close by 2025.4 Our own research shows that the changing shape of finance and accounting arising from automation and outsourcing will require fewer entry-level accounting positions and a different mix of skill sets for those entry-level positions.5,6,7The good news? The need for educators is critical. 3 Accounting for the Sustainable Development Goals, AICPA & CIMA, November 2021 4 “Gartner Finance Survey Shows 55% of Functions Aiming for a Touchless Close by 2025,” Gartner, September 22, 2022. 5 “Changing Competencies and Mindsets,” AICPA & CIMA, June 4, 2018. 6 “The Changing Shape of the Finance Function,” AICPA & CIMA, June 2, 2018. 7 “The Changing Role and Mandate of Finance,” AICPA & CIMA, June 3, 2018. 3 Poll Results and Brainstorm Analysis With this background and context, we polled accounting educators at the AAA-MAS Midyear Conference in Atlanta. The following key themes emerged: Embracing technology. College educators must stay abreast of the latest technologies and integrate them into their teaching methods to equip students with the skills future jobs will require. Expanding curricula. To reflect the evolving landscape, educators should expand curricula to include emerging topics like finance business partnering, data analytics, cybersecurity, and ESG factors. (Apart from ESG, these topics are incorporated into the CGMA Finance Leadership Program [FLP]; ESG will be covered in the next FLP iteration. The CGMA FLP supports academics with the latest technical and nontechnical content, allowing them to explore pedagogies and assessments for other skills identified herein.) Developing practical skills. Educators should place greater emphasis on real-world experience, internships, and case studies to help students develop practical skills and to better prepare them for their future careers. 4 Navigating the Future Responses to our survey of the educators at the conference were consistent with those of accounting and finance leaders in both public accounting and business and industry. Based on the survey results, accounting and finance students need the following skills for the future: 1. Communication and storytelling skills 2. Strategic and critical thinking skills 3. Technical accounting and finance skills (functional and domain expertise) 4. Facility with data and technology 5. Collaboration and integrated thinking skills 6. Agile mindset and work skills 7. Strong ethical foundation Ways to build students’ skills A brainstorming exercise asked conference participants to identify ways to build the skills students need to be successful accounting professionals in the 4th Industrial Revolution. Here are their responses ranked by number of votes: 1. Develop analytical skills: Corporate accounting and finance professionals need to be able to analyze and interpret financial data to make informed decisions. Students can develop these skills through coursework and through experiential learning opportunities such as internships and case studies. Students should also recognize the importance of nonfinancial data, be able to analyze it, and present it with the financials to give the whole story. The increasing importance of nonfinancial data to an organization’s overall performance is central to the role of the finance business partner. • Business games using past CGMA casestudy exam materials can be found here: Business games (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). 2. Emphasize the importance of soft skills: In addition to technical skills, it is important that accounting and finance professionals have strong communication, problem-solving, and collaboration skills. Professors can incorporate exercises and activities that help students develop these skills. • Classroom activities can be found here: Classroom activities (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). 8 3. Focus on ethics: Ethics are important in the accounting and finance profession, as financial decisions can have significant impacts on individuals, organizations, and society. • Classroom resources on ethics can be found here: Ethics (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). 4. Build applied technology skills: In addition to analytical skills, it is important for corporate finance professionals to have strong technical skills, such as proficiency in Excel, PowerBI, financial modeling, and data analysis. Students can build these skills through coursework and by seeking out opportunities to work on projects that require these skills. • Teaching tips and projects requiring technology skills can be found here: Technology resources (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). 5. Build adaptability and resilience skills: Finance and accounting professionals will work in a rapidly changing environment that will require awareness of the context they are operating in and the ability to adapt. 6. Develop strong communication skills: Corporate finance professionals often work with a variety of stakeholders, including investors, executives, and other finance professionals. To effectively present complex financial concepts and ideas — to succinctly convey the story that clients hire accounting and finance professionals to tell — students must combine what they learn from course materials with clear visualizations from data analytics. Frictionless Finance: Driving Data to Value, Deloitte, Workday, AICPA, 2022 5 • Business games can help students develop these skills as they work in teams to recommend solutions to business issues found in their assigned case studies. Business games using past CGMA case-study exam materials can be found here: Business games (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). • Data analytics games and classroom activities, including teaching tips, can be found here: Data analytics (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). 7. Encourage networking and professional development: Encouraging students to network with professionals in the industry and to engage in professional development opportunities, such as earning professional certifications, can help better prepare them for their careers. • The CGMA FLP offers academics in the Americas opportunities to incorporate FLP learning in their syllabi to undergraduate and graduate students. Contact Nora Luquer for more information. 8. Build collaborative relationships across the organization. • Teaching tips and collaborative activities can be found here: Collaboration (no-cost registration at thiswaytocpa.com required to access). 6 Navigating the Future Recommendations Partnerships between academic institutions, industry stakeholders, and AICPA & CIMA should be encouraged to facilitate knowledge exchange, improve curricula, and provide students with access to internships and job opportunities. • Invest in educator training programs to ensure academics are equipped with the skills and knowledge needed to teach emerging technologies and topics. • Develop training programs to ensure academics have the skills and knowledge needed to teach nontangible value articulated through ESG. • Regularly review and update curricula to ensure they remain relevant and reflect the latest industry developments. The CGMA FLP is a great resource for the latest global developments in accounting and finance. • Encourage internships, industry collaborations, and hands-on projects to help students develop practical skills and gain valuable work experience. • Foster a culture of continuous learning among educators and students to promote the development of future-proof skills and lifelong learning. Conclusion Although it is undergoing a period of rapid transformation, the future of the profession is bright. The skills and knowledge accounting and finance professionals have always possessed remain essential. As college and university educators, you play a critical role in inspiring the next generation of accounting and finance professionals. By embracing technology, expanding curricula, developing practical skills, and fostering industry collaboration, you can ensure your students carry into the future the skills they will need to succeed and thrive. AICPA & CIMA resources Video interviews Follow me here on Linkedin to access semimonthly video interviews (click on “Follow” or “Connect with me”). Stay connected to our work by following #FutureofFinance. • The library of past episodes (blionline.org/linkedin-live), where you can find, among other videos, the following: An update on What’s the Future of Finance: Highlights from AICPA & CIMA Future of Finance Summit from December 2022 Claire Bramley, ACMA, CGMA, CFO of the U.S. software company Teradata, on the Changing Role of Finance Today 8 Shifra Kolsky, CPA, controller at U.S. financial services company Discover Financial Services, on Making the Shift to Value Partner Graham Collins, FCMA, CGMA, VP of investor relations at British multinational BP, on What is the Future of Finance? • For future episodes, follow #FutureReadyLive on Linkedin. Podcasts “Future of Finance takeaways: Talent, transformation, trust,” Journal of Accountancy, December 14, 2022. “CPA leader takeaways: Listening, self-awareness, flipping the pyramid,” Journal of Accountancy, December 14, 2021. Articles “AICPA & US DOL announce registered apprenticeship for finance & accounting,” Linkedin, November 16, 2022. “The impact of ChatGPT and Gen AI on the Future of Finance,” Linkedin, April 18, 2023. Find the latest research and whitepapers at Management Accounting & Finance resources and articles at Journal of Accountancy – Management Accounting Contact us: Tom.Hood@aicpa-cima.com Ash.Noah@aicpa-cima.com Joanne.Fiore@aicpa-cima.com Nora.Luquer@aicpa-cima.com Ken.Witt@aicpa-cima.com Jan.Taylor@aicpa-cima.com Deloitte, Workday, AICPA & CIMA, Frictionless finance: Driving data to value, 2022. 7 “Management accounting certainly needs to evolve from a core focus on costs, largely based on manufacturing models. The future (and the now!) demands management accounting professionals and systems that partner with organization leaders to define, measure, and manage value creation based on the organization’s specific strategy and environment needs. This is an exciting time to be part of the management accounting evolution.” Monte Swain Deloitte & Touche Professor of Accountancy Marriott School of Business Brigham Young University “We can’t fight technology. Instead, it is important to help our students embrace technology and use technology to support them in their work, especially in relation to analyzing, interpreting, and communicating data, and using data to problem-solve.” Khim Kelly KPMG Professor of Accounting Kenneth G. Dixon School of Accounting University of Central Florida. 8 Navigating the Future “I think [management accountants] were once number crunchers, but I’ve observed a shift to how management accountants now play a much more strategic role in supporting business functions across the organization. I think this has created a demand for management accountants to have a broader skillset, especially in their ability to interpret and share insights from the numbers. I also hear from students working in controller office positions that they are now being asked to do things like quantify a firm’s sustainability performance, which introduces new and exciting challenges for management accounting.” Shane DiKolli Bank of America Associate Professor of Business Administration Darden School of Business University of Virginia Founded by AICPA and CIMA, the Association of International Certified Professional Accountants powers leaders in accounting and finance around the globe. aicpa-cima.com © 2023 Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. All rights reserved. AICPA and CIMA are trademarks of the American Institute of CPAs and The Chartered Institute of Management Accountants, respectively, and are registered in the US, the EU, the UK and other countries. The Globe Design is a trademark of the Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. For information about obtaining permission to use this material other than for personal use, please email copyright@aicpa-cima.com. All other rights are hereby expressly reserved. The information provided in this publication is general and may not apply in a specific situation. Legal advice should always be sought before taking any legal action based on the information provided. Although the information provided is believed to be correct as of the publication date, be advised that this is a developing area. The Association, AICPA, and CIMA cannot accept responsibility for the consequences of its use for other purposes or other contexts. The information and any opinions expressed in this material do not represent official pronouncements of or on behalf of the AICPA, CIMA, or the Association of International Certified Professional Accountants. This material is offered with the understanding that it does not constitute legal, accounting, or other professional services or advice. If legal advice or other expert assistance is required, the services of a competent professional should be sought. The information contained herein is provided to assist the reader in developing a general understanding of the topics discussed but no attempt has been made to cover the subjects or issues exhaustively. While every attempt to verify the timeliness and accuracy of the information herein as of the date of issuance has been made, no guarantee is or can be given regarding the applicability of the information found within to any given set of facts and circumstances. 2306-367370 9