Project Quality Management PMP Study Workbook Dan Ryan, MBA, PMP, PMI-ACP www.pmexamcoach.com TABLE OF CONTENTS Project Quality Management ................................................................................................ 1 Quality Overview ............................................................................................................................... 1 Quality Key Concepts ......................................................................................................................... 2 Quality Trends and Emerging Practices .............................................................................................. 3 Quality Tailoring Considerations ........................................................................................................ 3 Quality Considerations for Agile Environments ................................................................................. 4 Plan Quality Management.................................................................................................................. 4 Plan Quality Management: Inputs ......................................................................................................................... 5 Plan Quality Management: Tools & Techniques ................................................................................................. 6 Plan Quality Management: Outputs ..................................................................................................................... 8 Manage Quality.................................................................................................................................. 9 Manage Quality: Inputs........................................................................................................................................ 10 Manage Quality: Tools & Techniques ................................................................................................................ 11 Manage Quality: Outputs .................................................................................................................................... 14 Control Quality ................................................................................................................................. 15 Control Quality: Inputs .......................................................................................................................................... 16 Control Quality: Tools & Techniques .................................................................................................................. 17 Control Quality: Outputs ...................................................................................................................................... 20 Project Quality Management Project Quality Management P M P S T U DY W O R K B O O K PROJECT QUALITY MANAGEMENT Quality Overview According to the PMBOK® Guide, “Project Quality Management includes the processes for incorporating the organization's quality policies regarding planning, managing, and controlling project and product quality requirements in order to meet stakeholders’ objectives.” Project Quality Management also supports continuous process improvement activities as undertaken on behalf of the performing organization. The following processes are contained in the Project Quality Management Knowledge Area: Plan Quality Management Manage Quality Control Quality PMP Exam Study Tip Performing the processes in Quality Management result in two outputs that are used in other knowledge areas; verified deliverables and quality reports. Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 1 Project Quality Management Quality Key Concepts Project Quality Management concentrates on both the management of the overall project and the management of the project deliverables. Project Quality Management applies to all projects, regardless of the type of deliverables being produced. Quality techniques and measurements are specific to the type of deliverables being produced by the project. On any project, prevention (ensuring there are no errors in the deliverables before they are handed off to the customer) is always better than inspection (ensuring that there are no errors in the final deliverables after they are handed off to the customer). The cost of correcting product defects after delivery is usually considerably higher than the cost of preventing product defects before delivery. Cost of Quality (COQ) is an important concept in Project Quality Management and should be understood by all team members. Following are the major characteristics of COQ: ▪ COQ includes all costs over the life of the product. ▪ COQ can be minimized by evaluating the conformance to product requirements before the product is delivered to the customer. ▪ Product failure costs can be either internal (discovered by the project team), or external (discovered by the customer). Failure costs are also called the cost of poor quality. PMP Exam Study Tip Quality refers to the degree to which a set of inherent characteristics fulfill requirements. Grade refers to deliverables possessing the same functional use but different technical characteristics. Page 2 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management Quality Trends and Emerging Practices Following are some major trends and emerging practices to keep in mind for Project Quality Management: Customer Satisfaction – It needs to be ensured that you understand, evaluate, define, and manage requirements in order to meet customer expectations. Continual Improvement – The best way to improve quality on your projects is to understand and implement the plan-do-check-act (PDCA) cycle, which was created by Walter A. Shewhart and improved by G. Edwards Deming. Other quality improvement methods should also be employed to help improve both the quality of project management and the quality of the end deliverable. Commonly used quality improvement methods include Total Quality Management (TQM), Six Sigma, and Lean Six Sigma. Management Responsibility – Project success is dependent not only on the project team being constantly responsible for ensuring quality, but also on management being constantly responsible for providing the proper resources at the right time and in the right quantities. Mutually Beneficial Partnership with Suppliers – A mutually beneficial relationship helps to improve the ability to create value for both the project organization and the supplier organization. Quality Tailoring Considerations Each project is unique, which means that the project manager may need to tailor the way that Project Quality Management processes are applied. Following are key considerations that the project manager should keep in mind when applying the Project Quality Management processes: Policy Compliance & Auditing Standards & Regulatory Compliance Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Continuous Improvement Page 3 Project Quality Management Quality Considerations for Agile Environments Following are key considerations that the project team should keep in mind when working in an agile project environment: To handle changes in the project, agile methods include frequent quality and review steps. These are conducted throughout the project rather than only at the end of the project. Recurring retrospectives regularly check on the effectiveness of the quality processes. Agile methods focus on small chunks of work in order to ensure frequent, incremental delivery of project deliverables and their components. Plan Quality Management According to the PMBOK® Guide, “Plan Quality Management involves identifying project and deliverable standards and requirements, and documenting how the project will show compliance with these project and deliverable standards and requirements.” This process benefits the project by providing direction and guidance on how project quality will be managed and verified throughout the project. PMP Exam Study Tip It is important that quality management planning be performed in parallel with the other planning processes on a project. Page 4 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management Plan Quality Management: Inputs Project Management Plan Project Charter EEFs Project Documents OPAs Project Charter – Components for this process include product characteristics, measurable project objectives, and their related success criteria, all of which will have an impact on project quality management. Project Management Plan – Components for this process include the schedule the requirements measurement plan, the risk management plan, the stakeholder engagement plan, and the scope baseline. Project Documents: ▪ Assumption Log ▪ Requirements Documentation ▪ Requirements Traceability Matrix ▪ Stakeholder Register ▪ Risk Register Enterprise Environmental Factors (EEFs) – Examples include geographic distribution and cultural perceptions. Organizational Process Assets (OPAs) – Examples include the organization’s quality management system, and quality templates such as check sheets. Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 5 Project Quality Management Plan Quality Management: Tools & Techniques Expert Judgment Data Gathering Techniques Data Analysis Techniques Decision Making Techniques Data Representation Techniques Test and Inspection Planning Meetings Expert Judgment – Any individuals or groups within the organization possessing detailed knowledge and understanding of quality assurance, quality control, and quality systems should be consulted during the project whenever necessary Data Gathering Techniques – Following are some important data gathering techniques used in this process: ▪ Benchmarking – Comparing actual or planned project practices or quality standards to those of similar projects. The goal is to outline a performance measurement structure, to identify best practices, and to develop ideas for improvement. ▪ Brainstorming – Using creative ways of gathering data from a group of team members or subject matter experts to help in the development of the quality management plan. ▪ Interviews – Interviewing project participants, stakeholders, and quality subject matter experts. Data Analysis Techniques – There are two major data analysis techniques used in this process: ▪ Page 6 Cost-Benefit Analysis – A financial analysis tool used to estimate the strengths and Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management weaknesses of alternatives to help determine if the planned quality activities are cost effective, so that the alternative with the lowest cost and highest benefit will be selected. ▪ Cost of Quality (COQ) – The cost of quality associated with a project consists of one or more of the following costs: − Prevention Costs – Costs incurred as a result of preventing poor quality in the project deliverables. − Appraisal Costs – Costs incurred as a result of evaluating, measuring, auditing, and testing the project deliverables. − Failure costs – Costs related to nonconformance of the project deliverables. These can be internal or external (cost of defect repair). The most effective COQ includes a balance between the investment in the cost of prevention and appraisal, which will help avoid failure costs. Figure 6-1: Cost of Quality – Conformance vs. Non-Conformance Decision Making Techniques – The major one used in this process is multi-criteria decision analysis. Data Representation Techniques – Typical data representation techniques used in this Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 7 Project Quality Management process include: ▪ Flowcharts (Process Maps) – These show a flow of steps and the branching possibilities for a process, which eventually transforms one or more inputs into one or more outputs. A commonly used flowchart model to depict a value chain is the SIPOC Model (suppliers, inputs, process, outputs, and customers). ▪ Logical Data Model – This visually represents an organization's data, presented in plain business language that isn't dependent on any specific technology. ▪ Matrix Diagrams – These help in the identification of key quality metrics that will help ensure project success. ▪ Mind Mapping – This helps to visually organize information and enable the project team to rapidly gather project quality requirements. Test and Inspection Planning – During the planning phase, the project manager and the project team determine how to test or inspect the project deliverables to ensure they meet both stakeholder expectations and the project's performance and reliability goals. Meetings – These commonly include planning meetings with the goal of developing the quality management plan. Plan Quality Management: Outputs Quality Management Plan Quality Metrics Project Management Plan Updates Project Documents Updates Quality Management Plan – The quality management plan is a component of the project Page 8 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management management plan that describes how the project quality will be planned, structured and controlled. Quality Metrics – These are specific descriptions of a project attribute or product attribute and how the Control Quality process will verify that the project and the product are within compliance. Project Management Plan Updates – Any recommended change to the project management plan must have a change request submitted. Although many different project management plan components may require change requests, following are the most common ones for this process: ▪ Risk Management Plan ▪ Scope Baseline Project Documents Updates – Although many different project documents are updated as a result of performing this process, following are the most common ones: ▪ Lessons Learned Register ▪ Requirements Traceability Matrix ▪ Risk Register ▪ Stakeholder Register Manage Quality According to the PMBOK® Guide, “Manage Quality is the process of identifying project and deliverable standards and requirements, and documenting how the project will prove compliance with these project and deliverable standards and requirements.” This process benefits the project by increasing the probability of meeting the quality objectives, identifying ineffective project processes, and identifying causes of poor quality. Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 9 Project Quality Management The data and results from the Control Quality process is analyzed in order to present the quality status of the project to the stakeholders. Quite often on projects, depending on the organizational structure, the organization may have a separate Quality Assurance Department that performs some of the activities in Manage Quality. PMP Exam Study Tip The focus of Quality Assurance is on the processes used in the project. Manage Quality includes all the Quality Assurance activities, but also includes the product design activities and process improvement activities. Manage Quality: Inputs Project Management Plan Project Documents OPAs Project Management Plan – Components for this process include the quality management plan. Project Documents: ▪ Lesson Learned Register ▪ Quality Control Measurements ▪ Quality Metrics ▪ Risk Report Organizational Process Assets (OPAs) – Examples include the organizational quality management system and results from prior audits. Page 10 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management Manage Quality: Tools & Techniques Data Gathering Techniques Data Analysis Techniques Decision Making Techniques Data Representation Techniques Audits Design for X (DfX) Problem Solving Quality Improvement Methods Data Gathering Techniques – Examples include checklists. Data Analysis Techniques: ▪ Alternatives Analysis – Used to evaluate quality options that have been identified with the goal of selecting the options that will benefit the project the most. ▪ Process Analysis – Used to identify process improvement opportunities. ▪ Document Analysis – Analyzing the documents produced by the Project Control Processes (e.g., quality reports and test reports) can identify out of control processes that may affect project execution. ▪ Root cause analysis (RCA) – Used to determine the “actual cause”, or “root” cause of a variance, defect, or risk. Decision Making Techniques – The major one used in this process is multi-criteria decision analysis. Data Representation Techniques – Typical data representation techniques already discussed include affinity diagrams, flowcharts and matrix diagrams. Other techniques used include: Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 11 Project Quality Management ▪ Cause and Effect Diagrams – These are also referred to as why-why diagrams, fishbone diagrams, or Ishikawa diagrams. They are used to get to the root cause of a problem so that effective solutions can be developed to solve the problem. Figure 6-2: Ishikawa Diagram ▪ Histograms – These are in the form of a bar chart and display a graphical representation of numerical data. Figure 6-3: Histogram Page 12 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management ▪ Scatter Diagrams – These present a graphical depiction of the relationship between two variables. Figure 6-4 Scatter Diagram Audits – These are a structured and independent set of steps that are followed to determine whether the project's activities comply with the organization's and project's policies, processes, and procedures. Design for X (DfX) – A set of technical guidelines followed during product design for the optimization of a specific aspect of the design (X). Problem Solving – This technique involves searching for solutions to challenges and issues that you may encounter on your project. The ability to master this technique is critical to effective project quality assurance and project quality improvement. Quality Improvement Methods – These are tools used to analyze and evaluate possible opportunities for improvement on your project. Important methods include Plan-Do-Check-Act (PDCA) and Six Sigma. Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 13 Project Quality Management Manage Quality: Outputs Quality Reports Test and Evaluation Documents Project Management Plan Updates Change Requests Project Documents Updates Quality Reports – The lessons learned register is created as an output of this process early in the project. After that it is used as an input and updated as an output in many processes throughout the project. At the end of a project or phase, the information is transferred to an organizational process asset called a lessons learned repository. Test and Evaluation Documents – These are used to determine if the quality objectives have been achieved, and are inputs to the Control Quality process. Change Requests – If project management plan components, project documents, project management processes or product management processes are impacted by this process, a change request should be submitted by the project manager. Project Management Plan Updates – Any recommended change to the project management plan must have a change request submitted. Although many different project management plan components may require change requests, following are the most common ones for this process: ▪ Quality Management Plan ▪ Scope Baseline ▪ Schedule Baseline ▪ Cost Baseline Page 14 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management Project Documents Updates – Although many different project documents are updated as a result of performing this process, following are the most common ones: ▪ Issue Log ▪ Lessons Learned Register ▪ Risk Register Control Quality According to the PMBOK® Guide, “Control Quality process involves monitoring and recording the results of the quality management activities in order to assess performance and ensure the project outputs are complete, correct, and meet customer expectations.” This process benefits the project by verifying that the project work and project deliverables meet the quality requirements of the project stakeholders, which is critical in gaining final acceptance of the project deliverables. PMP Exam Study Tip Performing quality control on your projects is an iterative process that ends with a demonstration that the deliverables match the customer’s acceptance criteria. Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 15 Project Quality Management Control Quality: Inputs Project Management Plan Project Documents Approved Change Requests Deliverables Work Performance Data EEFs OPAs Project Management Plan – The major component of the project management plan that is used as an input to this process is the quality management plan. Project Documents: ▪ Lesson Learned Register ▪ Quality Metrics ▪ Test and Evaluation Documents Approved Change Requests – During Perform Integrated Change Control, the change log is updated to reflect any approved changes that need to be implemented. Examples include the repair of defects, improved work method processes, and schedule updates. Deliverables – The deliverables that are outputs of Direct and Manage Project Work are inspected to ensure that the meet the acceptance criteria included in the project scope statement. Work Performance Data – This can include information on project status such as observations, technical performance measurements, and quality information about schedule performance. Page 16 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management Enterprise Environmental Factors (EEFs) – Examples include the PMIS and governmental agency regulations. Organizational Process Assets (OPAs) – Examples include quality standards and policies, and reporting procedures for issues and defects. Control Quality: Tools & Techniques Data Gathering Techniques Data Analysis Techniques Inspection Testing/Product Evaluations Data Representation Techniques Meetings Data Gathering Techniques – Following are some important data gathering techniques used in this process: ▪ Checklists – These can be used to employ a structured method of managing the control quality activities. ▪ Check Sheets – Also referred to as tally sheets, they are used to organize facts and data relating to potential quality problems on the project. Figure 6-5: Check Sheets Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 17 Project Quality Management ▪ Statistical Sampling – This is used to select a small sample of the project deliverables for inspection to measure controls, and to verify the quality of the deliverables. ▪ Questionnaires and Surveys – These are used to collect data concerning customer satisfaction once a deliverable has been deployed by the customer. Data Analysis Techniques – There are two major data analysis techniques used in this process: ▪ Performance Reviews – Performed to measure, compare and analyze the quality metrics outlined in the Quality Management Plan to ensure that the actual results match them. ▪ Root Cause Analysis – Performed to determine the source of defects so that they can be repaired. Inspection – This involves evaluating whether a work product conforms to the documented standards issued for the work product. Testing/Product Evaluations – Finding errors and defects and other nonconformance problems is the main goal of testing. It compares the quality of deliverables to the guidelines outlined in the Quality Management Plan to ensure they match the documented requirements. PMP Exam Study Tip It is critical to perform early testing on your project so that you can identify any nonconformance problems. This will help reduce the costs by fixing those components that don’t conform before they are delivered to the customer. Data Representation Techniques – Typical data representation techniques already discussed include cause and affect diagrams, histograms and scatter diagrams. Other techniques used in this process include control charts. Following are some characteristics of control charts: ▪ They are used in the determination of whether or not a process is stable or is displaying Page 18 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Project Quality Management predictable performance. ▪ They contain upper and lower specification limits to determine if the results are within the acceptable range outlined in the Quality Management Plan. These are usually dictated by the customer. ▪ They contain upper and lower control limits to determine if the results are within the acceptable range outlined in the Quality Management Plan. Control limits are usually dictated by the organization performing the work and use statistical calculations to establish the rules for determining when a process is stable. Figure 6-6: Control Chart Meetings – Project teams may attend different meetings as part of the Control Quality process. The two major types of meetings that are used in this process are approved change request review meetings and retrospectives/lessons learned meetings. Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources Page 19 Project Quality Management Control Quality: Outputs Quality Control Measurements Verified Deliverables Change Requests Work Performance Information Project Documents Updates Quality Control Measurements – These are the documented results of activities performed in the Quality Control process and are captured in the format outlined in the quality management plan. Verified Deliverables – These are the deliverables that have been verified for correctness that result from performing the Control Quality process and that serve as an input to the Validate Scope process. Work Performance Information – This includes information that is a result of performing the Control Quality process. Examples include fulfillment of project requirements and recommendations for corrective action. Change Requests – If changes surface while performing activities in the Control Quality process that may impact the project management plan or project documents, a change request should be submitted by the project manager. Project Documents Updates – Although many different project documents are updated as a result of performing this process, following are the most common ones: ▪ Issue Log ▪ Lessons Learned Register ▪ Test and Evaluation Documents Page 20 Visit www.pmexamcoach.com for exam resources