POL101.9 Assignment: Bangladesh-China economic and strategic relations Submitted to: Dr. M Jashim Uddin (MJU) Full Time Faculty Associate Professor North South University Submitted by: Rafid Khandaker 2111686620 Date: 6.7.2022 Bangladesh-China economic and strategic relations Diplomatic relations between China and Bangladesh have been cordially maintained for decades, beginning from the late 70s under President Ziaur Rahman, and has continued under Khaleda Zia, Mohammad Ershad and currently Sheikh Hasina. Both countries have shown significant interest in further strengthening diplomatic and economic relations, and are already in the process of making that happen. However, certain questions, such as whether or not Bangladesh will fall into a Chinese debt trap, and how India will react to the alliance, must be answered. Bangladesh’s interests and benefits in Sino-Bangladeshi relations In order to answer these questions, we must first look at the interests of both nations that are driving their diplomatic and economic ventures. For Bangladesh, China is an invaluable ally in the face of Indian regional domination. India surrounds Bangladesh from 3 out of 4 sides, and is a behemoth compared to the tiny landmass of Bangladesh. This allows India to exercise significant influence and pressure on Bangladesh, as well as other small South Asian countries. That is where China comes in, swooping in to offer aid to these nations, positioning itself as a geopolitical rival to India. Hence, Bangladesh-China relations are inextricably tied with Indian influence in the region, and will have significant effects on Bangladesh-India relations as well. However, Bangladesh doesn’t just benefit from a Chinese alliance geopolitically, but also economically. China is Bangladesh’s largest trade partner, and Bangladesh is China’s 3rd largest trade partner. Trade between the two countries have soared to $14.7 billion by 2015, with imports from China increasing by 20% and exports to China increasing by 40% between 2010 and 2015 (M. Shahidul Islam, 2016). Still, there exists a trade gap between the two economies, with Bangladesh’s trade gap with China rising from $6.80 billion USD in 2013-14 to $7.43 billion USD in 2014-15. In order to combat this trade gap, production has started in Bangladesh by the labor-intensive Chinese sunset industries, especially in the garments and light-engineering industries. The goods that are produced are exported back to China, as well as other foreign nations, thus improving Bangladesh’s current account in the balance of payments. Furthermore, recently China has announced that 97% of exports from Dhaka will receive tariff exemption from 1 July, 2022, boosting the number of duty-free Bangladeshi exports to China from 3095 to 8256. During the COVID-19 pandemic, China has offered substantial aid to Bangladesh. Notably, over 3 million surgical and N-95 masks, over 110,000 sets of PPE and a large number of test kits, thermometers, ventilators, and sanitizers was given to Bangladesh by its Northern ally. Bangladesh has also sent aid to China in order to combat the coronavirus, giving medical accessories, including masks, gowns, caps and gloves. When it comes to the infrastructure in Bangladesh, China has made significant investments in it, by aiding Bangladesh in building ‘friendship bridges’. China is also involved in the building of other physical infrastructure such as ports, power plants, roads, etc. Bangladesh has also agreed to allow China to form economic and industrial zones in Dhaka and Chittagong, which will be exclusive to Chinese investors only. The Chinese government has selected the Chinese firm China Harbour Engineering Company Limited (CHEC) to be in charge of developing these economic zones. This initiative was taken first in 2014 by Sheikh Hasina when she went on a visit to China. The initiative, once completed, is expected to house upwards of 400 factories in the economic zones and only in three years is set to bring in over $2 billion USD Chinese investment to Bangladesh. Furthermore, during Xi Jinping’s Bangladesh visit in 2016, many trade agreements and memorandums of understanding were signed by the two countries, further bolstering their economic ties. China’s interests and benefits in Sino-Bangladeshi relations When it comes to China’s interests in Bangladesh, China has a lot to gain geopolitically and economically from the alliance as well. For starters, as discussed before, Bangladesh is a valuable ally for China in its tussle with India. China and Bangladesh are not that far away, and are only separated by a thin strip of Indian land, the Siliguri corridor, which also connects Northeast India with mainland India. Now, in the case of a full-on war breaking out between the two behemoths if it were to happen, China would most likely have its eyes set on Northeast India, and would attempt to station troops at the Siliguri corridor in order to cut off Northeast India from the rest of the country. In this scenario, Bangladesh will have a vital role to play, as it would be India’s best option to send troops and supplies over to the Northeast and retain control over it. But if China is able to get Bangladesh on its side, Northeast India will essentially be cut off from the mainland, effectively giving China dominion over it. (Mohsin 1992: 67-68) Bangladesh is also a vital strategic ally for China in its maritime endeavors. The Chinese follow the Mahanian theory, named after the great American naval strategist Alfred Mahan (Holmes & Yoshihara 2007). This theory emphasizes the importance of naval affairs in a country’s economic and commercial prowess, and therefore a strong navy and naval bases in foreign waters are a necessity. For China, the application of this theory means domination of the Indian Ocean, and Bangladesh provides a great avenue for them to achieve that, mainly through the Bay of Bengal. This issue is especially important for China as it is becoming more and more dependent on maritime international trade, especially for energy. Energy supply is at the heart of China’s economic growth – and this is of utmost importance to China’s ambitions of bolstering its national power. (Len 2015: 7). This crucial energy supply is, to a great extent, dependent on the Indian Ocean and its Sea Lines of Communication (SLOC) (Holmes & Yoshihara 2008: 368-73; Paul 2010). Most of China’s imported energy, about 80%, come from West Asia and Africa, and is transported through the Indian Ocean and then pass through the Strait of Malacca (Len 2015: 4; Albert 2016). Because this need for energy is not likely to subside, China’s reliance on the Indian Ocean will not either. Therefore, the importance of Bangladesh in China’s economic and strategic calculations will also continue to rise. China’s economic and geopolitical interests in Bangladesh and the Indian Ocean come at an intersection when we take into account the interests of its rivals in the region, India and the US. India has similar goals with the Indian Ocean as China, but holds more control over it, which China would undoubtedly like to see change. China is also unhappy with the US’s “pivot to Asia” policy (Santis 2012; Silove 2016), which it deems to be an effort to contain China’s power and influence in the region, and is supported by India (Burgess 2015). All these issues make it so that China’s efforts of gaining maritime might in the Indian Ocean are ever more important. To this end, it is speculated that China deems Bangladesh as very attractive, and this is in line with China’s interest in establishing a deep-sea port in Sonadia Island off Cox’s Bazar, Bangladesh. Another dimension of Bangladesh-China relations is China’s ‘Security through Development’ philosophy. China has learned a lesson from the downfall of the Soviet Union that military might alone cannot ensure national strength and endurance, and economic prosperity and power are just as important. To this end, China is on a mission to strengthen economic ties with countries in Asia and Africa. China’s economic rise will help to ensure that it holds its rightful place as a leader in today’s multipolar world, something which has long been the ambition of the Chinese. China also emphasizes its commitment to respect countries’ sovereignty and security, that is to say it has a policy of non-interference in the internal affairs of other nations. Chinese officials, such as Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi and President Xi Jinping have stated that they do not seek to lead the world or be a hegemonic or expansionary force, but instead wish to work with other nations as cooperative partners. This is heartening to countries allied with China such as Bangladesh, as it reassures that their internal matters will not be meddled with by a stronger, outside force. Concerns and roadblocks for the alliance Now that the ins and outs of Bangladesh-China relations have been more or less discussed, the challenges and obstacles that stand in their way must also be addressed. Firstly, we must go back in history to the time of the liberation of Bangladesh from Pakistan. China, then, was very much opposed to the liberation movement, and supported a united Pakistan. This might cause strains in the relations between the two nations, especially among the more passionate Bengalis who remember the days of the liberation war and are not willing to forgive. On the other hand, India played a major role in aiding Bangladesh emerge victorious in the war and liberate itself from Pakistan, and the friendly ties between the two nations that resulted from this can still be felt today in Bangladeshi civil and political society. Due to this and several other factors such as its geographical advantages, India holds significant influence in the Bangladeshi market, and this is a big threat for China, and can undermine Bangladesh-China relations. Therefore, Bangladesh must be careful when treading diplomatic ground with its neighbors, so as to not offend one too much in an effort to please the other, as well not to hurt domestic sentiments of those who view India in a positive manner due to the historical and cultural ties. When we move into the modern day, one of the most glaring issues with the Bangladesh-China relations is the immense trade gap between the two nations. China exports to Bangladesh way more than it imports from it, and this gap has widened ever so steadily between 2000-2013, going from $697.27 million USD to $5865.88 million USD. However, Bangladesh can still has the opportunity better capitalize on trade with China. According to research done by Dr. Ma Razzaque, head of Research and Policy Integration for Development (RAPID), just capturing 1% of the share of China’s imports will make way for Bangladesh to earn about $25 billion. Some have also brought up concerns about Bangladesh falling into a ‘debt-trap’ by becoming too reliant on Chinese loans. Examples of countries falling into such debt-traps are Pakistan and Sri Lanka, who are suffering now because of their excessive dependence on said Chinese loans. However, the numbers show a more promising picture for Bangladesh when compared to its South Asian counterparts. For instance, the debt ratio to nominal GDP for Sri Lanka and Pakistan are 104% and 41%, but for Bangladesh it is only about 22%. Bangladesh avoids overreliance on China due to its strong ties with India and Japan, and by rejecting projects it deems economically unsustainable. Conclusion Therefore, even though there are several obstacles facing Bangladesh and China in their bid to fortifying their alliance, they are nothing impossible to overcome. All these obstacles must be addressed diplomatically in order to usher in an era of prosperous Sino-Bangladeshi relations, an era that will benefit both nations to a great extent. Research and evidence has shown that the relationship between the countries is already bearing fruit, and is set to be even more fruitful in the future. But only time will tell if the fruit will be sweet of taste or tinged with sourness, and if China will keep its promise being anti-hegemonic or go down the far-tootravelled path of expansionism. References: Quiyum, D., & Jahirul, M. (2021). Bangladesh-China Economic Relations, 1975-2000: An Overview. South Asian Studies, 2(35). Mannan, M. A. (2019). Bangladesh-China relations: Mapping geopolitical and security interests. Bangladesh-East Asia relations: Changing scenarios and evolving linkages, 81-118. Ranjan, A. (2019). The Making of Bangladesh-China Relations. Jindal School of International Affairs, 2(1), 32-44. Sarker, N. M. (2014). Bangladesh-China relationship at the dawn of the twenty-first century. Peace and Security Review, 6(11), 72-96. Islam, M. S. (2012). China-Bangladesh relations: contemporary convergence. Daily Star, 25. https://www.thedailystar.net/news-detail-219707 Rahman, S. A. (2021). The BRI in Bangladesh: ‘Win-Win’ or a ‘Debt Trap?’. The Diplomat. https://thediplomat.com/2021/11/the-bri-in-bangladesh-win-win-or-a-debt-trap/ In aggressive bid to woo Bangladesh, China announces tariff exemption for 97% of exports from Dhaka from 1 July-World News. (2020, June 22). Firstpost. https://www.firstpost.com/world/inaggressive-bid-to-woo-bangladesh-china-announces-tariff-exemption-for-97-of-exports-fromdhaka-from-1-july-8509761.html Sakhawat, N. (2020). China-Bangladesh relations stronger than ever before. Daily Star. https://www.thedailystar.net/opinion/news/china-bangladesh-relations-stronger-ever-1972993 Bhuiyan, P. S. (2021). China and Bangladesh: Brotherly relations through trade and commerce. China Daily. https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202112/06/WS61ad74bea310cdd39bc79900.html Gottlieb, C. J. P. (2018). The China-Bangladesh Relation And Its Implications For U.S. Foreign Policy. (p. 158)