1 Table of Contents 1 Brief Background about the business..................................................................................................... 3 2 Background about the topic .................................................................................................................... 4 3 Application of the topic in the chosen sector ......................................................................................... 6 4 Impact on various stakeholders .............................................................................................................. 9 5 Challenges that may be faced by the stakeholders.............................................................................. 10 7 Recommendations to different stakeholders ....................................................................................... 11 7 References ............................................................................................................................................... 12 2 ABSTRACT Around twenty years ago, Kuwait's food sector began to expand, and as the 20th century ended, the country's immigrant population proliferated. The nation's annual production increased by more than 570,000 metric tons, or 7.7 percent, on average from 2009 to 2014. Kuwait currently imports more than 96% of its food, despite having a high score on the global food security index. The underdeveloped agricultural industry in Kuwait is one of the critical causes of its reliance on imported food. The food industry is anticipated to create $925.80 million in sales in 2023 and expand at a rate of 12.00% per year (CAGR 2023–2027), with a market size of $1,457.00 million anticipated by that year. The use of blockchain technology to digitalize food systems gives a tremendous opportunity to improve efficiency, transparency, and traceability in Kuwait, which suffers from food insecurity. Blockchain technology generally refers to a state-of-the-art database system that permits open information sharing inside a business network. Businesses can utilize blockchain technology to build an unchangeable ledger for monitoring orders, accounts, payments, and other transactions because the data saved in blockchain databases are sequentially consistent, and the chain cannot be wiped or updated without the network's agreement. Blockchain combines three popular technologies to keep network transactions and records: cryptographic keys, a peerto-peer network with a shared ledger, and a computing method. Each transaction made by a business is recorded as a block of data, and these transactions show how mobile an asset is. The validity of each new block, and ultimately the blockchain as a whole, increases as transactions are tied together in an immutable chain. As a result, the blockchain gains its essential quality of robustness and becomes tamper-evident. Blockchain can be classified as public, private, consortium, or permissioned. Some of the components of blockchain include distributed ledger technology, smart contracts, and immutable data. The use of blockchain minimizes instances of deception and fraud. The use of blockchain technology could result in several data issues for the supplier and the food manufacturing organization, such as distributed denial-of-service attacks, double spending, geographical and legal issues, the risk associated with cryptographic assets, privacy and data protection, and more. I advise suppliers to utilize blockchain technology to reduce bureaucracy and increase supply chain transparency. Additionally, consumers—the most vulnerable stakeholders—must urge the adoption of blockchain technology to enhance food production and distribution traceability. 3 BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY AND ITS APPLICATION IN THE FOOD INDUSTRY 1 Brief Background about the business The food industry in Kuwait started to grow some twenty years ago, and as the 20th century ended, the country's immigrant population rapidly increased. From 2009 to 2014, the country's annual production averaged 7.7 percent, or more than 570,000 metric tons (Oxford Business Group, 2014). Kuwait ranked 27th out of 113 countries for food security in the 2019 Economist Global Food Security Index with a 74.8 out of 100. The United Arab Emirates (UAE) and Qatar (ranked 13), which are both ranked higher, are the only countries Kuwait trails (The Borgen Project, n.d.). Despite Kuwait's high ranking on the global food security index, it still imports more than 96% of its food. One of the main reasons Kuwait is dependent on imported food is the weak agricultural sector, which earlier yielded fruits and vegetables. Significant agricultural expansion is unlikely, given the 8.6% agricultural land and an annual average rainfall of about four inches. The food industry is expected to generate $925.80 million in revenue in 2023 and grow at a rate of 12.00% per year (CAGR 2023–2027), with a predicted market size of $1,457.00 million by 2027 (Statista, 2022). The issues posed by food supply chains, though, are faced by the Kuwaiti food industry. As an illustration, during the Covid19 pandemic, disruptions brought on by various virus containment measures, such as the cessation of movements, greatly impacted the quality, safety, and freshness of food and resulted in shortages in the markets. This is because the effectiveness of logistics is crucial for the agricultural-food sector. Kuwait would profit from regional 4 transportation and logistics networks, which offer solutions like norms, directives, measurements, and techniques. The application of blockchain technology to digitalize food systems presents a significant opportunity to increase efficiency, transparency, and traceability (FAO, 2020). Data verification, which would be accomplished with the help of blockchain technology, serves as the foundation for the creation and quality of products. This will overcome the difficulty of trade efficiency, the need for tracking and openness for food safety, and funding. 2 Background about the topic Blockchain technology is described by Amazon (n.d.) as a cutting-edge database system that allows for open information sharing inside a commercial network. The data inside a block depends on the type of blockchain; for example, a Bitcoin Block contains information on the sender, receiver, and the number of bitcoins sent. Because the data is sequentially consistent and the chain cannot be erased or modified without the network's agreement, businesses can use blockchain technology to create an unalterable ledger for tracking orders, accounts, payments, and other transactions (Amazon, n.d.). Blockchain operates as follows, according to IBM (n.d.); as each transaction takes place, it is documented as a "block" of data; these transactions demonstrate the mobility of an asset, which can be intangible or tangible. A company's pick of info, including what, who, what, when and how much, and even the condition, can be recorded in the data block. Each block is linked to the ones preceding it and those after it, forming a chain of data as a set is moved from one location to another or a change of ownership. The blocks connect safely to prevent any blocks from being changed or being introduced inside two present blocks, and the blocks certify the precise timing 5 and order of transactions. To sum up, transactions are locked together in an unchangeable chain, with each new block strengthening the validity of the preceding one and, ultimately, the blockchain. This gives the blockchain its crucial feature of robustness and makes it tamper-evident. Gandhi (2021) claims that multiple kinds of blockchains exist, including private blockchain networks, which are unstructured peer-to-peer networks. A single organization, nevertheless, controls the network's governance, executing a consensual procedure and managing the copy of the ledger. Running a private blockchain behind a company's protected network and hosting it onsite are options. A public blockchain, like the one used by Bitcoin, allows anybody to register and interact. A consortium blockchain is a permissioned blockchain, meaning that many organizations can access and maintain records, making it more difficult for unlawful activities to occur. The final point regarding permissioned blockchain networks is that companies who create a private or public blockchain typically create a permissioned blockchain network. The requirement for an invitation or permission to join establishes limitations on who is permitted to engage in the network and what transactions. One of the main components of blockchain technology, according to IBM (n.d.), is unchangeable records, which prevent participants from altering or tampering with transactions once they have been added to the shared ledger. A new transaction must be entered to undo an erroneous record of transactions before both transactions are displayed. The second is distributed ledger technology, which gives all network users access to an unchangeable account of all entries in a distributed ledger. Transactions are only recorded once with this shared ledger, preventing the doubling of endeavors in conventional corporate networks. Thirdly, smart contracts, which are preconfigured and consist of guidelines that assist in expediting transactions, are kept on the 6 blockchain. A smart contract can specify parameters for corporate bond transfers, stipulate how much must be spent on travel insurance, and much more. For storing financial transactions, traditional database methods provide several difficulties. Take the sale of a property, for instance. The property belongs to the purchaser following the exchange of money. The buyer and the seller can independently keep track of the financial transactions, but neither source can be relied upon. It is simple for the buyer to say that they have paid the money even though they have not, and the seller to claim they have not received the money even though they have. A responsible third party must monitor and verify transactions to prevent potential legal problems. The existence of this centralized authority not only makes the transaction more challenging but also establishes a weak spot. Both parties may be harmed if the central database is breached. By developing a decentralized, tamper-proof way to record transactions, blockchain reduces these problems (IBM, n.d.). 3 Application of the topic in the chosen sector Anwar (2020) claims that when blockchain technology began to take off, experts primarily believed it applied to the financial sector. The food business is one of the more open-minded applications of blockchain technology right now. It is important to note that, according to United Nations-Kuwait (2020), the adoption of blockchain technologies in the food industry would address several issues the Kuwaiti sector currently faces, including a lack of traceability in food processing and distribution, difficulties with inventory management caused by long food supply chains that affect the shelf life of high-value food products, an absence of accountability in labeling, and poor food safety caused by the long food supply chains. First, as was mentioned, Kuwait's food business needs to be more traceable in the delivery and processing of food (United Nations-Kuwait, 2020). Customers are left in the dark because they 7 have not learned how or how the food was produced. After all, tracking food goods is a significant problem, and most businesses seem reluctant in this scenario owing to the additional investments they will be forced to make. Therefore, the sector needs assistance now, which is made feasible by implementing blockchain technology. Notably, blockchain has all the necessary tools to manage food tracking from suppliers to the person who purchases it. Therefore, businesses can use this capability to improve their transparency on the assembly line and provide a higher standard of food to the market. By doing this, the Kuwait food industry will be able to comply with the GS1 requirements, which demand enabling transparency solutions to offer the best route to harmonization, safeguard business investments, and scale up (GS1 Kuwait, n.d.). Second, Kuwait's food industry must contend with subpar food safety, one of the most urgent problems in the global food market (United Nations-Kuwait, 2020). The necessity to guarantee an adequate supply of nutritious and safe foods is one of the primary difficulties facing the GCC countries, according to Al-Zenki & Al-Kandari (2010). Since these nations heavily rely on imported food due to the region's limited agricultural production and rapidly increasing food demand, widespread concerns about food safety and quality have been raised, particularly in the wake of a range of food risks in the outsourcing nations like avian influenza, BSE, and dioxin in poultry and meat. Thus, food safety is guaranteed through blockchain technology, and customers are at peace and able to purchase all of their items without worrying about the risks of contaminants or other issues. Through a networked blockchain system with the exporting companies, importing companies, and the government, it is easy to keep an eye on how they handle raw materials and completed goods. These requirements force domestic and foreign food businesses to treat their byproducts more cautiously to protect their goods' level and quality without any problems. 8 Thirdly, according to United Nations-Kuwait (2020), Kuwait faces a problem with food waste and suggests digitizing the food chain as a solution. Othman (2022) estimates that each year in Kuwait, one person wastes 95 kg of food. According to the food waste index report for 2021 released by UNEP and WRAP, Kuwaiti families waste 397,700 tons of food annually. According to the survey, households account for most of this waste, disposing of 11% of all the food accessible at the consuming stage of the food chain, compared to 5% and 2%, respectively, for food service facilities and retail outlets. Anwar (2020) claims that there are various reasons why food is wasted, ranging from poor inventory control to delayed product shipments. In each case, the industry is forced to deal with significant losses, which subsequently exerts additional pressure on it to produce more goods quickly to meet demand. Blockchain technology, on the other hand, enables businesses to begin tracking foodstuffs to uphold health codes, adhere to all regulations, and enhance their management systems. It is simple to increase productivity and minimize food waste because they can keep track of everything online, even in real time. Last but not least, fake food products provide a problem for Kuwait's food business. The Ministry of Commerce and Industry, according to Times Kuwait (2020), was able to prevent the counterfeiting of 52,000 cooking cans imitating a worldwide brand. They were seized when the products were sold to food outlets without invoices. Blockchain technology makes it simple to cut down on or completely eradicate the rising quantity of fake goods in Kuwait's food industry. Improved food traceability throughout processing and delivery makes this possible. Because a blockchain can follow every product from the factory to the customer, it can verify whether the product is genuine. Locating the issue's root cause might also lessen the likelihood that counterfeit goods will enter the market. 9 4 Impact on various stakeholders Stakeholders might be impacted by the use of blockchain technology in Kuwait's food industry in various ways. First of all, Question Pro (n.d.) believes that adopting blockchain technology in the food business will allow customers to monitor, manage, transmit, and submit contends for their warranties. In other words, customers can independently check a product's complete life cycle, and businesses cannot influence it. Second, a manufacturing company can monitor raw materials from their inception in a supply chain until the finished product is distributed to the final consumer. Blockchain technology enables traceability by giving a snapshot of the supply chain network at a glance. A food manufacturing company would also have a competitive edge with the deployment of blockchain technology because current consumers often rely their faith in a company on its environmental and social responsibility. Thirdly, according to Technology Innovation Management Review (2021), numerous food controversies in the past few years have eroded consumer confidence in the global food industry. For example, in 2013, several European meat exporters substituted horsemeat for lamb and beef, affecting 1,000 tons of food. Similarly, Astill et al. (2019) estimate that locally caused foodborne diseases caused by contaminated food impact 4 million Canadians annually. Customers and food manufacturing companies will benefit from fast turnaround timeframes to recent incidents of food scandals and foodborne outbreaks due to the adoption of blockchain technology. This is based on the idea that food accidents are difficult to track down in the supply chain because of a lack of transparency and ineffective batch sorting. Lastly, suppliers will profit from using this technology in Kuwait's food business because both sides can track blockchain payments. As a result, suppliers who wait for processing are at a disadvantage during the purchasing process (Ashcroft, 2022). Blockchain expedites the procedure, 10 increases party control, and strengthens the supply chain. Similar to this, the zoned architecture of blockchain enables suppliers to quickly respond to and abide by Kuwait's food restrictions and trace materials along the food supply chain until they reach the manufacturing food company, promoting security by nullifying identity theft. 5 Challenges that the stakeholders may face Although blockchain technology has many advantages, some obstacles prevent its widespread use. First off, according to Shirley (n.d.), using blockchain technology could lead to various data issues for both the supplier and the food manufacturing organization. These difficulties include distributed denial-of-service attacks, double expenditure, geographical-legal issues, the risk associated with cryptographic assets, and privacy and data protection. Notably, no one entity is in charge of the accessibility or security of a ledger in a permissionless public blockchain system. This increases the chance of deception, deceit, and mistakes spreading through the distributed ledger. Second, special tax issues related to blockchain and cryptocurrency rules may result in higher costs. Additionally, because these restrictions are constantly changing, producing ROI early on is always more complicated. This primarily affects suppliers and enterprises that manufacture food (Shirley, n.d.). The existence of several standards and regulations for product safety, as well as the need to balance innovative products with regulatory compliance, would present additional difficulties for suppliers in the Kuwaiti food industry. This calls for efficient corporate management to maintain technological alignment with those changes. The implementation of blockchain technology is also expensive, so producers and suppliers of food will incur higher costs. 11 7 Recommendations to different stakeholders First, I advise suppliers to adopt blockchain technology in order to cut down on paperwork and improve supply chain transparency. This advice is supported by the fact that a blockchain supply chain enables parties to record information such as price, date, location, quality, certification, and other pertinent details to manage the supply chain more efficiently. Additionally, according to Deloitte (n.d.), the presence of this info within the blockchain can enhance transparency and adherence over external foodstuff contract manufacturing. Besides, it reduces losses fueled mainly by product counterfeiting, boosts monitoring of the material supply chain, and strengthens a company's position as a pioneer in ethical production. Because consumers are more environmentally sensitive and health-conscious and only buy items they can fully understand the origin of, food manufacturing enterprises should be at the forefront of integrating blockchain technology. Sales volume will rise thanks to blockchain, which will also help the business's reputation and brand recognition. Thirdly, in order to improve food production and distribution traceability, consumers—the most vulnerable stakeholders—must demand the adoption of blockchain technology. Additionally, Kuwait's government must be tenacious and implement strict measures to control items from local and foreign food manufacturers that are counterfeit in order to support customers' demands for safe and healthy food products. 12 7 References Amazon. (n.d.). What is blockchain technology? https://aws.amazon.com/what-is/blockchain/ Astill, J., Dara, R. A., Campbell, M., Farber, J. M., Fraser, E. D., Sharif, S., & Yada, R. Y. (2019). Transparency in food supply chains: A review of enabling technology solutions. Trends in Food Science & Technology, pp. 91, 240–247. Deloitte. (n.d.). Using blockchain to drive supply chain transparency. https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/pages/operations/articles/blockchain-supply-chaininnovation.html Evan Shirley. (n.d.). Blockchain challenges in the food and beverage industry. Clarkston Consulting. https://clarkstonconsulting.com/insights/blockchain-challenges/ FAO. (2020). From impact to transformation – improving the food supply chains in Kuwait in the context of COVID-19 pandemic – Kuwait policy note. https://www.fao.org/3/cb2553en/cb2553en.pdf GS1 Kuwait. (n.d.). Traceability. https://www.gs1kuwait.org/traceability Hasib Anwar. (2020). Blockchain in Food Industry: Food Traceability And Safety. 101 Blockchains. https://101blockchains.com/blockchain-in-food/ IBM. (n.d.). What is blockchain technology? https://www.ibm.com/topics/what-is-blockchain IvyPanda. (2020). Kuwaiti Food Industry and Its Development Report. https://ivypanda.com/essays/kuwaiti-food-industry-and-its-development/ Kuwait Times. (2022). Food waste increased significantly in Kuwait in recent years: Food Bank. https://www.kuwaittimes.com/food-waste-increased-significantly-in-kuwait-in-recentyears-food-bank/ 13 Oxford Business Group. (n.d.). Kuwait: Appetite for growth in food and beverage sector. https://oxfordbusinessgroup.com/articles-interviews/kuwait-appetite-for-growth-in-foodand-beverage-sector Question Pro. (n.d.). Blockchain: 4 Ways it Benefits Consumers. https://www.questionpro.com/blog/blockchain-4-ways-benefits-consumers/ Sameer Al-Zenki & Dina Al-Kandari. (2010). Assessment of the food control system in the State of Kuwait. https://www.academia.edu/28180794/Assessment_of_the_food_control_system_in_the_S tate_of_Kuwait Sean Ashcroft. (2022). Ten benefits blockchain brings to supply chains. Supply Chain. https://supplychaindigital.com/digital-supply-chain/ten-benefits-blockchain-brings-tosupply-chains Statista. (2022). Food – Kuwait. https://www.statista.com/outlook/dmo/ecommerce/food/kuwait Technology Innovation Management Review. (2021). An Exploration of Blockchain-based Traceability in Food Supply Chains: On the Benefits of Distributed Digital Records from Farm to Fork. https://timreview.ca/article/1446 The Borgen Project. (n.d.). 5 F A C T S A B O U T F O O D S E C U R I T Y I N K U W A I T . HTTPS://BORGENPROJEC T.ORG/FOOD -SECURITY-IN -KUWAIT/ Times Kuwait. (2020). Ministry thwarts largest commercial fraud on counterfeit food products in Kuwait. https://timeskuwait.com/news/ministry-thwarts-largest-commercial-fraudon-counterfeit-food-products-in-kuwait/ United Nations-Kuwait. (2020). Supply chain during Covid19 crisis in Kuwait webinar series #3: Controlled environment agriculture, food cold chain logistics and digital technologies. 14 https://kuwait.un.org/en/126663-supply-chain-during-covid-19-crisis-kuwait-webinarseries-3-controlled-environment Yashoda Gandhi. (2021). What is a Blockchain and How does it work? Analytics Steps. https://www.analyticssteps.com/blogs/what-blockchain-and-how-does-it-work