CAD. GOV & POLITICS
POL214 Y1Y Summer 2020
Professor David Pond - david.pond@utoronto.ca
Lecture 1 and 2 - May 4 & 6th
Textbook Chapter 1
Introduction
Liberal + Democracy
●
●
●
Small “l” liberal democracy -> refers to regime
Liberalism = colonial British export
Values of Liberalism
○ Trial by jury
○ Independent judiciary
○ Right of the accused to face their accusers in an open court
○ Free elections
○ Freedom of speech and of assembly
○ The rule of law
○ Legal equality
○ Popular sovereignty
○ Religious tolerance
National Di erences in Liberal Democracy
●
CAD = British-style parliamentary democracy
○
●
TEST QUESTION:
○
●
How democratic is Canada really?
Liberal democracies = representative democracies
○
●
Limited, indirect form of democracy
Other representative and indirect democracies -> eg. US republican system
Liberal Representative democracy -> Elect politicians who govern
○
Elect Members of Parliament (MPs) to the House -> vote on policies
■
Also has aspects of direct democracy at times (referendums), but
rare - 3 CAD Referendums:
1
●
●
1898 - on controlling liquor sales
●
1942: drafting soldiers to fight WW2
●
1992: to amend the constitutions
Can be contrasted with Direct or Plebiscitary Democracy
○
People directly make political decisions -> Referendum (yes/no question)
Features of Our System of Government
Legislative Branch
●
Domain of legislature - Where elected representatives debate and pass laws
○
Federally = Parliament of Canada
○
Provincially = provinces’ Legislature or Legislative Assembly
Executive Branch
●
Domain of the Executive - initially proposes decisions that legislature approves
○
Prime Minister and cabinet
○
Nonpartisan bureaucracy
■
●
Provincial level works the same way
Executives administer programs approved by legislature
○
The elected prime minister and cabinet direct the
■
Non elected and nonpartisan bureaucracy
Judicial Branch
●
Domain of the Independent Judiciary
○
Resolves disputes about the legality of government decisions
■
Whether they are following the law or violating citizens’ rights
Parliamentary regime at the federal level in Canada:
2
Winning Power - Majority and Minority
●
DEFINITIONS ON TEST
●
Parties win elections and form government by winning seats in the House of
Commons
○
Voters pick local Member of Parliament (MP) for their
riding/constituency
■
●
Constituency = seat, MPs hold seats in House of Commons
When a party wins 50% + 1 of the seats, they form a majority government
○
When one party does not win over 50% of seats, they form a minority
government
■
○
●
One party in power with less than majority
PM has more power in Majority
Coalition Governments
○
CAD elect few few (compared to NZ and Australia, for example)
■
Theoretically possible under parliamentary regime, but not so much
in practice
Parliamentary Government = Partisan
●
PM and ministers must be MPS
○
●
PM appoints cabinet ministers to run the government departments
○
●
3
PM = leader of party in power
Aka ministries
Elected government in Canada = partisan
○
Eg. Liberal PM selects cabinet ministers from other Liberal MPs elected to
House of Commons
●
Parliamentary democracy -> politics = competition between organized
parities
○
Government is run by part that wins most recent election
○
All losing parties = opposition to government
■
Sit opposite House of Commons to government party
●
○
MPs that lost election = opposition
All MPs in party that forms government who are not ministers =
“government backbenchers”
●
Parliamentary System has fused executive and legislative branches
○
Members of executive (PM and cabinet) sit in the elected legislature, the
House of Commons
○
●
PM and cabinet ministers must be MPs
Government Departments
○
Staffed by non-elected, non-partisan, career civil servants
■
○
Administer policies and programs chosen by cabinet
■
●
Aka public servants, bureaucrats
Debated and approved by parliament
Hallmark of Parliamentary system = Constitutional convention of ministerial
accountability
○
Ministers are accountable to parliament for all decisions made by the
executive, not the non-elected civil servants
Textbook Notes - Chapter 1
Political Regimes
●
4
Aristotle’s Six Regimes:
Who Rules
Common Good
Own Interest
One
Kingship
Tyranny
Few
Aristocracy
Oligarchy
Many
●
Democracy
Tyranny of the Majority
○
Majority mistreats minorities (hence Democracy in bad)
■
●
Polity
Polity does not exist in real life, just in theory
Canadian Regime
○
Based on equality and liberty = regime principles
Equality
●
Fundamental principle of democracy
○
Democracy grants political power to all citizens equally
○
No one has a special title to rule
○
Democratic principle of equality = political principle
■
●
●
NOT social or economic, only share political power
Direct Democracies vs Parliamentary Democracies
○
Directly involved in political process
○
Vs parliamentary = representative democracy with elected reps
United States’ Republical Regime
○
Full and final authority given to elected officials
○
Crown still has influence in parliamentary system
Liberty
●
Liberal democracy
○
●
Combines liberty and democracy
Liberty = private sphere should be free for all
○
Theory of liberalism = free as long as we don’t break the law
●
Contemporary liberal democracies -> 2 schools
●
Natural Rights
●
○
Innate rights of every human aka human rights
○
Inalienable even if not recognized
Utilitarianism
○
Importance of liberty derives from its usefulness of promoting human
happiness
■
Rights are created within each regime as a response to
circumstances
5
○
Harm principle - John Stuart Mill
■
○
Gov. cannot interfere if actions don’t harm others
2 Main Political Implications of the Harm Principle:
■
Onus of proof on government to show why law limits on individual
liberty is necessary
■
●
6
Law only valid if it is preventing harm of others
Three Essential Principles of Rights:
○
Protection of the private sphere
○
Respect for Minority Rights
○
The Rule of Law, no one is above the law