Deer Park Public Library Project: Bid Date: Estimator: Architect: place BID #: 23-046 Roof, Ceiling, Lighitng HVAC Reconstruction Thursday, March 2, 2023 @ 11:00 am Rich DeLuca BBS Base Bid 1 - Roofing company bid amount % off of LOW bidder % TO of NEXT bidder 1 State Wide Roofing $ 314,069.00 0.00% 2 More Consulting $ 397,000.00 26.41% 26.41% 5.79% 3 LI Roofing $ 420,000.00 33.73% 12.38% 4 Barret Foofs $ 472,000.00 50.29% 19.49% 5 Stalco $ 564,000.00 79.58% 0.00% 6 Construction Consultants $ 564,000.00 79.58% 0.00% 7 Total $ 564,000.00 79.58% 0.00% 8 Alcon $ 564,000.00 79.58% 0.53% GTS $ 567,000.00 80.53% 5.82% 10 Ashlar $ 600,000.00 91.04% 5.00% 11 Preferred $ 630,000.00 100.59% 19.05% 12 Niko $ 750,000.00 138.80% -100.00% 9 place Base Bid 2 - Single Prime GC company bid amount Preferred $ 780,000.00 0.00% 1.91% Alt 1 95,000 Total w/Alts 1 875,000 3 2 KG $ 794,900.00 153.10% 2.78% 55,000 849,900 1 3 Alcon $ 817,000.00 160.13% 1.59% 56,000 873,000 2 4 Stalco $ 830,000.00 164.27% 0.36% 58,000 888,000 4 68,000 901,000 5 6 5 Total $ 833,000.00 % off of LOW bidder 165.23% % TO of NEXT bidder 2.16% 6 AFL $ 851,000.00 170.96% 2.35% 58,000 909,000 7 Patriot $ 871,000.00 177.33% 3.33% 56,000 927,000 7 8 Ashlar $ 900,000.00 186.56% 2.89% 45,000 945,000 8 9 Construction Consultants $ 926,000.00 194.84% 5.08% 53,000 979,000 9 10 Renu $ 973,000.00 209.80% 2.06% 57,000 1,030,000 11 11 GTS $ 993,000.00 216.17% 13.29% 33,000 1,026,000 10 12 Siba $ 1,125,000.00 258.20% -100.00% 100,000 1,225,000 12 place Base Bid 3 - Single Prime GC Combined company bid amount % off of LOW bidder % TO of NEXT bidder 1 Stalco $ 1,422,000.00 0.00% 0.07% 2 Total $ 1,423,000.00 0.07% 2.04% 3 Alcon $ 1,452,000.00 2.11% 0.21% 4 Preferred $ 1,455,000.00 2.32% 3.02% 5 Ashlar $ 1,499,000.00 5.41% 4.07% 6 GTS $ 1,560,000.00 9.70% 2.24% 7 Construction Consultants $ 1,595,000.00 12.17% 12.04% 8 Siba $ 1,787,000.00 25.67% 16.79% 9 More $ 2,087,000.00 46.77% -100.00%