In partnership with The Science The of Making of a Learning Modern Leader: Five ways to make your L&D strategy more successful Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? In partnership with Barbara Oakley Distinguished professor of engineering and influential researcher on the neuroscience of learning The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Table of contents The state of leadership today 3 Leading in a digital revolution Respondent profile 5 1. Leading the organization 10 The evolution of leadership over time Leading in uncertain times 12 6 The history of leadership 7 2. Leading teams 13 The anatomy of a modern leader 8 3. Leading transformation 16 4. Leading oneself 18 9 Drive impact with better leadership today 24 2 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? The state of leadership today 3 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? The pressure building over leadership skills development, coupled with the challenges in reporting soft skills impact and the difficulty of finding targeted and easy-to-execute leadership programs, means L&D leaders have to figure out how to scale leadership training quickly, at a reasonable cost. Indeed, the skills of modern leadership, such as strategic thinking, emotional intelligence, resilience, and Through our Making of a Modern Leader research involving a global survey of agility, have shifted significantly since the pandemic due to the changes brought about by remote work 1,000 people managers, with survey partner OnePoll, Coursera data from 100 and digital transformation, employee burnout, and economic uncertainty. million-plus learners, and insights from remote leadership champion GitLab, this report unpacks: This situation opens up several questions: What influence is leadership having on talent attraction and retention? How do we make sure our teams have what they need to survive in uncertain times? On top of this, 60% of executives believe we should be moving toward a fractionalized working approach where employees flow to tasks and projects based on their skills and interests rather than their traditional job roles.1 With this, leadership requirements will only become more of a prerequisite for everyone. 60% of executives believe we should be moving What leadership means today The four key areas of leadership to focus on in your organization The skills needed to connect, inspire, and thrive in these areas toward a fractionalized working approach 4 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Respondent profile A total of 1,000 managers employed in the United Kingdom, the United States, India, Australia, Mexico, France, Germany, and Saudi Arabia participated in the Making of a Modern Leader research. Nearly half of all respondents worked in either the financial services (12%), manufacturing and construction (12%), e-commerce (11%), or healthcare (10%) industries. Managers constituted the largest share of respondents, making up 54% of the pool, with a further 15% in the C-suite and 13% directors. More than half of all respondents worked in companies with up to 1,000 employees. Thirty-nine percent of the remaining respondents worked in companies of 1,000+ employees. Sector Seniority Financial Services 12% 12% 11% 10% Manufacturing and Construction E-commerce Healthcare Other GitLab’s Darren Murph also participated in the analysis portion of this research. Murph is a pioneer of and advocate for the title “head of remote.” He authored GitLab’s “Remote Playbook,” which codifies GitLab’s practices for working online. You can learn his takeaways on Coursera in his How to Manage a Remote Team course. Darren Murph 15% C-Suite 13% Directors 5% VPs Head of Remote, GitLab Other 5 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? The evolution of leadership over time 6 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? The history of leadership What does good leadership look like? It’s a challenge researchers have pondered for decades. Here are the various leadership models we’ve seen over time2: 1800s-1940s: Trait theory Leaders are born with innate traits, and leadership is not made or trained. 1940s-1950s: Behavioral theory Leaders are not born with particular characteristics but learn specific leadership-related behaviors. 1960s-1990s: Situational theories Leaders align their leadership styles for specific contexts given the impact of leader-follower dynamics. 1990s-2000s: Modern theories Leadership is the culmination of interactions between the leader, their followers, and the situational context. Coursera’s take today: Leadership in a hybrid world Leaders are agile employees of any age or seniority level who motivate and inspire themselves and others. They set clear goals and ensure accountability from anywhere in the world. Experts today recognize that the complexity of leadership requires studying multiple behavioral, situational, and cognitive dimensions. For this reason, this study takes a close look at the impact of technological innovation and other rapid socioeconomic changes on leadership. 7 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? The anatomy of a modern leader One goal of the research was to understand the evolution of leadership in the face of socioeconomic change and technological disruptions. To answer this question, we started off by asking middle managers to select the most sought-after characteristics of a leader before the pandemic versus today, as well as the characteristics they’d like future leaders to prioritize in the years ahead. Here are the results: Past: Current: Future: Organized and accountable Confident decision-maker Emotionally intelligent Persuasive Problem solver Agile and adaptable Strong business acumen Effective communicator Inspirational Critical thinker Strategic Trustworthy 8 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Leading in a digital revolution 9 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? The impact of the digital revolution 1. Leading the organization Hybrid, remote, and in-person challenges Given the speed at which companies introduce technological innovations, employees may get bogged down or even fall behind without proper leadership. To unlock your business’s competitive edge, A hybrid model is the most common setup for most organizations today. Having 50% office capacity empowering employees to leverage the right technology at the right at all times is what 41% of middle managers report in their organization. And more than a third of time and place is important. them believe leadership has changed for the worse with the transition (34%). The biggest resulting The result of this is a new set of expectations, demands, and skills in four key areas of leadership: leading an organization, leading teams, leading pitfalls, according to the research, are ignoring work-life boundaries (38%), neglecting team morale and company culture (37%), and communicating with credibility (30%). transformation, and leading oneself — which we’ll discuss in the following To address this, leaders must acknowledge and respond to a new suite of workplace expectations subsections. beyond the short-term response that emerged during the pandemic. 10 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Lead organizations with the right skills What has worsened in remote/hybrid leadership? culture across teams, and strategically plan for years into the future. With the added Ignoring work/ life boundaries 38% 37% Communication with credibility ensure the organization’s success going forward. 30% Prioritizing the wrong kind of things 29% Micromanagement 27% Failing to evaluate the performance 27% Little learning and growing 0% difficulties of remote work and digital transformation projects, the Leadership Academy from Coursera helps employees develop and grow these fast-evolving skill sets to Neglecting team morale and company culture N/A- nothing has worsened In today’s complex business environment, leaders need to grow the business, drive Leader spotlight: Tom is a middle manager at a global organization. He is looking to improve his strategic management skills. He could start with a short Clip on Coursera, like Leadership vs Management, then take the follow-up course, Stepping Up: Preparing Yourself for Leadership, followed by the handson Guided Project, Program Change Management in ClickUp, to identify and 26% classify the required components for change management. Going forward, he could take a Specialization like Foundations of Management to understand 8% how the concepts he learned link to real-world scenarios. 25% 50% 11 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Leading in uncertain times ʻʻ The challenges leaders face are exacerbated during uncertain times — like now, with a recession looming — as employees stress over their finances, worry about their job security, and question their purpose. Given these uncertainties, our research shows leaders who prioritize empathy, compassion, and patience (29%), are visible Leaders must step up to alleviate these concerns by offering assurances and flexibility. They must invest in new systems and ways of working which prioritize equitable access to information and enable more frictionless work. and open (26%), and are masters of change management (25%) are preferred. What should leaders master in challenging times? They practice empathy, compassion, and patience 29% They’re visible and hold an open dialogue 26% They’re masters of change management 25% They lead with kindness and respect 15% Darren Murph Head of Remote, GitLab They’re im6% perfectly human 0% 10% 20% 30% 12 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? 2. Leading teams The rise of the middle manager and individual contributor How can leaders best motivate teams? 57% Lead by example An underlying challenge of the remote and hybrid workplace is the intensity of leadership expected from less experienced employees, particularly middle managers. From motivating peers to maintaining company culture and driving business results, they’re on the frontline with their teams while also answering to senior leadership on business results. Middle managers in our research say that motivating teams and leading by example 54% Set clear goals 51% Encourage teamwork Empower team members 48% Give open and honest feedback to allow team members to grow 48% are their top leadership priorities (57%), followed closely by setting clear goals (54%), encouraging teamwork (51%), and empowering team members (48%). But because of the culmination of turbulent external factors and the pressures of leading without the requisite support or training, middle managers overseeing one to six people report feeling more stressed and less productive than senior executives managing 15-plus employees. They are 46% less satisfied with their jobs and struggle more than twice as much to maintain a sense of belonging3. Give praise and reward Be optimistic and positive Provide a vision and purpose 0% 45% 44% 43% 50% 100% 13 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Lead teams with the right training New managers are essential to organizations tasked with leading a team while continuing to bring in the revenue the business needs to sustain itself. Without proper training, rising middle managers may struggle in their new roles, burn out, or hurt their direct reports’ productivity and job satisfaction. Leader spotlight: Wendy was recently promoted to manager. She is now tasked to lead one other remote team member. To step up to the challenge, she is watching a course Clip on Coursera, Recruiting and Managing Your Team, while developing some team-based technology skills useful for team building and communication in a hybrid world through the Building a Team in Microsoft Teams hands-on Guided Project. Later, Wendy plans to take the Specialization Leadership Out of the Box to lead more effectively as she takes on more complex responsibilities. Remote work also brings high expectations on every employee in the business to perform as a strong team player, regardless of whether they have direct reports. Everyone must be responsible for clear communication, workload management, and structured decision-making. This is particularly challenging during a downturn, given that employees without direct reports ʻʻ Since we are remote, there is a high expectation to do your work without direct supervision. It means that every team member is responsible for communication, structuring decisions, and managing their workload individually. Darren Murph Head of Remote, GitLab typically have little to no say on strategy but are subject to the many pivots and re-shuffles an organization may go through as it tries to find its footing. 14 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? For this reason, employees at all levels urgently need leadership mentoring — 19% What should leaders do to inspire employee learning in the workplace? of managers say that leading by example and letting others see how you are learning new skills is the best way to inspire learning in the workplace. Modeling learning is more 19% Lead by example powerful than encouraging a more flexible workplace (16%), offering incentives and rewards (16%), and creating a diverse organization with a myriad of perspectives and experiences Encourage flexibility 16% Reward learning 16% for employees to learn from (15%). Mentoring is key to letting employees see their leadership potential and imbuing their confidence to make their best contribution. What’s interesting is that 70% of Fortune 500 companies offer mentoring programs open to all employees already, but there is little evidence of their effectiveness4. The cause? When mentoring is optional, those who require it the most are likely to decline it. Hire for diversity 15% Link learning to employee objectives 15% Allocate time to learn Foster curiosity 0% 10% 9% 25% 15 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? 3. Leading transformation The role of tech and data on leadership Connected with the new challenges of remote and hybrid work is the discrepancy between tech, What should effective leaders prioritize today to lead at their best? data, and leadership skills. With the increasing pace of digital transformation in the workplace, organizations rely more and more on tech and data subject matter experts to solve difficult 56% Motivating a team business problems. Encouraging employee development Here’s where it gets tricky: By promoting these technical leaders into managerial roles without proper leadership training, organizations hurt their business goals and team morale. Leadership, 39% Learning and growing once again, is a must-have for everyone in the business. 33% Setting priorities To lead at their best, more than half of managers say motivating a team (56%), encouraging 44% employee development (44%), and learning and growing (39%) must be prioritized. These are learned soft skills that new leaders with technical backgrounds may be unfamiliar with. 0% Handling conflict 31% Supporting individual employees 31% 25% 50% 75% 16 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Case study: Visible Alpha Lead transformation by merging technical and soft skills harmoniously Aware of the importance of helping technology experts build soft skills alongside technical ones to upgrade their team’s leadership abilities, the innovative financial market analysis software company, Visible Alpha, offers courses on Coursera in communication and team management to new hires, as well as to those looking to move into leadership roles. “We’ve found that Coursera is versatile enough to be useful for Many employees with the right technical skills to transform their business employees, managers, and executives. Our learners like that the lack the leadership skills to lead this transformation harmoniously content is from leading universities and institutions. Coursera’s rich throughout the organization. The Leadership Academy from Coursera helps employees ideate, experiment, and learn the key principles and practices necessary to inspire change in others and drive change in the organization. catalog means we can find leadership and communications courses relevant to our company’s specific needs.” -Alyssa Chen, HR Director at Visible Alpha. 17 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? 4. Leading oneself The evolution of the competencies of a leader As leadership theories have evolved, so has the way of expressing the key competencies involved in leadership. Competencies like problem-solving, communication and conflict resolution have always been core leadership attributes, but how we express them is drastically changing. For example, while some leaders may seek to solve problems as quickly as possible for maximum financial results, others may view problem-solving through the lens of how their solution can create an impact beyond the bottom line. 18 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Four leadership styles and their leadership competencies manifested5 Focusing on tangible success, these leaders prioritize metrics related to financial results, such as costs and quality. Prioritizes efficient problem-solving, conflict resolution focused on financial return, and a competitive communication style. The Modern Missionary Driven by human values, these cause-guided leaders hope to build something meaningful that makes a difference rather than strive for more profits and growth. Focuses on meaningful problem-solving, conflict resolution aimed at making an impact, and inspirational communication. The Problem Solver These leaders are adept at confronting difficult challenges and identifying new opportunities. However, rather than relying on their team, they take charge and leverage their expertise. Prefers accurate, number-based problem-solving, conflict resolution that relies on core expertise, and top-down communication. The Solutions Finder Humble and self-effacing, these leaders believe in uncovering the talents of their colleagues and maximizing the collective genius of the organization. Focuses on joint problem-solving, open communication, and collaborative conflict resolution. The Classic Entrepreneur Our research shows that while respondents have experienced a fairly even split of leadership styles throughout their careers, the leadership style they find most appropriate for leading today is the Solutions Finder leadership style (31%). This leadership style fits the skills-first (versus role-based) business mentality. Workers flow to tasks and projects based on their skills and interests rather than their traditional job roles, uncovering the organization’s collective genius. 31% of respondents find the Solutions Finder leadership style most appropriate for leading today 19 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? It also sits well with the current employee demand for more autonomy. Recent research by Deloitte shows that half of the employees surveyed were more likely to join and remain at organizations that Reflecting on oneself matters in leadership offer them agency and choice in how they apply their skills to work6. It’s possible that the misalignment in leadership style needs (by business goals) and business wants (by employee preferences) caused higher-than-normal attrition rates in recent years, as evidenced by the Great Resignation. For leaders to better define problems, determine long- and short-term solutions, and solve inventively, they need a foundational understanding of how they operate as individuals and where they need to adapt to give the best of themselves to others. Indeed only 26% of employees surveyed by Deloitte in recent research strongly agree that their employers treat them as whole individuals who offer diverse contributions based on their unique portfolio of skills, yet this is what half of the employees prefer. Leader spotlight: Rob recently joined the business. He is going through a tough period outside of work, impacting his mood and people management skills. To navigate this challenge, Rob started taking the following courses to reflect on himself and lead better: 26% of employees believe employers are using their talent to their fullest first, the course Clip on Coursera, Why Emotions Matter: Physical and Mental Health; then, a hands-on Guided Project, Assimilating into your New Job, to create a 30-60-90 plan that set him up for success in his new role; and, finally, The Science of Well-Being course to build more productive habits to be happy. 20 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? ʻʻ With socioeconomic uncertainties on the horizon, leaders cannot afford to undermine credibility and jeopardize their reputation by compensating with overconfidence. Instead, they need to find a way to reassure their teams and approach the future with confidence using empathy and strong storytelling, relying on concrete information and particularly on strong data and strategies. Darren Murph Head of Remote, GitLab 21 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Leadership Academy Leadership Academy “An important part of leadership development is the realization that there are “An important part of leadership development is the realization that there are component skills that can be learned and mastered.” component skills that can be learned and mastered.” Leadership Academy Develop employees to lead without limits DevelopDevelop employees to lead without limits employees to lead without limits Lead Yourself Lead Yourself Lead Teams Lead Teams Matt Dearmon, Director of Leadership Matt Dearmon, Director&ofProf. Leadership Development & Prof. Development Lead Organizations Lead Organizations Core human skills for productive Develop teams at all levels that Empower your workforce with Core human skills for productive Develop teams at all levels that Empower your workforce with interactions and impact collaborate and thrive management and org. dev skills interactions and impact collaborate and thrive management and org. dev skills Sample SkillSets: Sample SkillSets: Sample SkillSets: Sample SkillSets: Sample SkillSets: Sample SkillSets: Emotional Emotional Intelligence Intelligence NewNew Managers Managers Managing Managing Managers Managers Diversity Diversity andand Inclusion Inclusion People People Development Development Organizational Organizational Development Development Interpersonal Interpersonal Skills Skills Team Team Management Management Strategic Strategic Management Management Lead Transformation Lead Transformation Digital Digital Transformation Transformation Design Design Thinking Thinking AgileAgile Aware Aware World-class World-class content & expert content & expert instruction instruction Hands-on Hands-on learning learning Pictured: Sample Guided Projects. Pictured: Sample Guided Projects. Over 2,000 Guided Projects available Over 2,000 Guided Projects available on Coursera. 100 added monthly. on Coursera. 100 added monthly. PlacePlace your your screenshot screenshot here here Track, measure, Track, measure, and benchmark and benchmark entry-level entry-level skillsskills *Pictured a subset of SkillSets the SkillSets available inLeadership the Leadership Academy *Pictured herehere is a is subset of the available in the Academy Coursera Coursera Proprietary & Confidential Proprietary & Confidential 11 11 22 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Useful courses to develop a Solutions Finder leadership style Lead Yourself Lead Teams Simulation Skills: This is Your Brain on the Future (Institute of the Future) How to Manage a Remote Team (GitLab) Storytelling and influencing: Communicate with impact (Macquarie University) Building High-Performing Teams (University of Pennsylvania) The Growth Mindset (University of California, Davis) Leadership focused on Human Flourishing (Tecnológico de Monterrey) Lead Organizations Lead Transformation Inclusive Leadership: The Power of Workplace Diversity (University of Colorado) Agile Leadership: Introduction to Change (University of Colorado) Six Sigma and the Organization (University System of Georgia) Superbosses: Managing Talent & Leadership (Dartmouth College) Organisational design: Know your organisation (Macquarie University) Collaborate on Files in Slack: Local & Google Drive Integrations (Coursera Project Network) 23 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Drive impact with better leadership today 24 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? In the face of global socioeconomic uncertainty, technological disruptions, and a hybrid workplace, effective leadership is more important and complex than ever. Our research shows a discrepancy between the types of leaders employees need and those currently heading our teams and organizations — especially as hybrid work requires more roles to step up to the plate. Learning leaders should prioritize upskilling their workforce in leadership competencies that empower technical experts to lead transformation, provide the business with a competitive edge and reduce talent attrition. Deploying ongoing, easy-to-access, soft skills training for all through affordable and scalable leadership programs, such as Leadership Academy from Coursera, could be the solution. Ready to power your organization with the next generation of leaders and create high-performance teams? Request a consultation today. Above all, these programs should be flexible, cater to existing foundational knowledge, offer a mix of learning formats, from short clips to full courses and specializations, and provide in-course assessments and hands-on learning to help employees retain knowledge. 25 The Making of a Modern Leader: Do your employees have the skills to lead through change? Endnotes 1 The skills-based organization: A new operating model for work and the workforce. Deloitte. September 2022. 2 Leadership Theories and Styles. WGU. April 2020. 3 It’s Time to Free the Middle Manager. Harvard Business Review. May 2021. 4 Why Your Mentoring Program Should Be Mandatory. Harvard Business Review. October 2022. 5 The 4 Leadership Styles, and How to Identify Yours. Harvard Business Review. August 2016. 6 The skills-based organization: A new operating model for work and the workforce. Deloitte. September 2022. 26