LESSON 1 Theoretical Foundation of Nursing Introduction to Nursing Theories What is a theory? ● Is an organized system of accepted knowledge that is composed of concepts, propositions, definitions and assumptions intended to explain a set of fact, event or phenomena. ● “a creative and rigorous structuring of ideas that projects a tentative, purposeful and systemic view of phenomena” (Chinn and Kramer, 1991) Definition of Terms Concept – an idea formulated by the mind or experience perceived and observed. Proposition – explains the relationships of different concepts. (ex. Children do not want to stay in the hospital because of their fear of injections.) Definition – is composed of various descriptions which convey a general meaning and reduces the vagueness in understanding a set of concepts. Assumptions – is a statement that specifies the relationship or connection of factual concepts or phenomena. Phenomenon – Describes an idea or responses about an event, a situation, a process, a group of events or a group of situations. The following diagram explains the relationships of concepts, propositions, assumptions and definitions with theory and phenomena. How other Authors DEFINE THEORY: Parker (2001) Blackwell (2005) Delaune & Ladner (2006) Mosby (2006) Kozier (2008) “A theory, by traditional definition, is an organized, coherent set of concepts and their relationship to each other that offers descriptions, explanations and predictions about a phenomena.” “[It is] a reasoned proposed explanation of an occurrence, or of something that will occur or be produced, for which absolute proof is lacking “A theory is a set of concepts and propositions that provide an early way to view phenomena.” “[It is] an abstract statement formulated to predict, explain or describe the relationships among concepts, constructs or events. It is tested by observation and research using factual data.” “A theory is a supposition or system of ideas that is proposed to explain a given phenomenon.” Potter and Perry (2014) Smith and Parker (2015 “A theory helps explain an event by defining ideas or concepts, explaining relationships among the concepts and predicting outcomes.” “A theory is a notion or an idea that explains experiences, interprets observation, describes relationships and projects outcomes.” Characteristics of a THEORY ● Theories can correlate concepts in such a way to generate a different way of looking at a certain fact or phenomenon. ● Theories must be logical in nature. ● Theories should be simple but generally broad in nature. ● Theories can be the source of hypotheses that can be tested for it to be elaborated. ● Theories contribute in enriching the general body of knowledge through the studies implemented to validate them. ● Theories can be used by practitioners to direct and enhance their practice. ● Theories must be consistent with other validated theories, laws and principles but will leave an open unanswered issues that need to be tested. What is Nursing? American Nursing Association (ANA) Nursing is the “diagnosis and treatment of human responses to actual or potential health problem.” International Council of Nurses (ICN) Nursing encompasses “autonomous and collaborative care of individuals of all ages, families, groups and communities, sick or well and in all settings. Nursing includes the promotion of health, prevention of illness, and the care of ill, disabled and dying people. Advocacy, promotion of a safe environment, research, participation in shaping health policy and in patient and health systems management, and education are also key nursing roles. To assist clients in the performance of activities contributing to health, its recovery or peaceful death that clients would perform unaided, if they had the necessary will, strength or knowledge. Nursing is a “dynamic discipline. It is an art and a science of caring for individuals, families, groups and communities geared toward promotion and restoration of health, prevention of illness, alleviation of suffering and assisting clients to face death with dignity and peace. It is focused on assisting the client as he or she responds to health-illness situations, utilizing the nursing process and guided by ethico-legal moral principles. Virginia Henderson Association of Deans of Philippine Colleges of Nursing (ADPCN) *Focused in supporting communities, families and individuals in maintaining, restoring or achieving a state of optimum health and functioning. It is both a science and an art that is concerned with the quality of life as defined by the clients. What about a Nursing Theory? ● Nursing theory is a group of interrelated concepts that are developed from various studies of disciplines and related experiences. • An articulated and communicated conceptualization of invented or discovered reality (central phenomena and relationships) in or pertaining to nursing for the purpose of describing, explaining, predicting, or prescribing nursing care. (Meleis, 1991) *Another theorist, Barnum (1994), stated that a complete nursing theory is one that has context, content and process. Components of a Theory By Barnum (1994) Context Content Process Resembles environment to which nursing act takes place. Subject of the theory. Method by which nurse acts in using nursing theory. Nursing theories and models provide information about: 1. 2. 3. 4. Definitions of nursing and nursing practice. Principles that form the basis for practice. Goals and functions of nursing. Clarifies the scope of nursing practice. Nursing theories and models are derived from concepts 1. Concept is an idea of an object, property, or event. 2. Concepts are building blocks of theories. 3. In Nursing, concepts have been borrowed from other discipline (adaption, culture, homeostasis) as well as developed directly from nursing practice and research (maternal-infant boding, health-promoting behaviors). Types of concepts: 1. Empirical or concrete concepts: These are directly observable objects, events, or properties, which can be seen, felt or heard e.g. color of the skin, communication skill, presence of lesion, wound status etc., These are limited by time and space (it can be viewed/measured only specific period specific setting and variable). 2. Inferential concepts: These are indirectly observable concepts, e.g. pain, dyspnea and temperature. 3. Abstract Concepts: These concepts are not clearly observable directly or indirectly (known as “Non-observable concepts directly”) E.g. social support, Personal Role, Self-esteem etc. Types of Definition of Concepts CONCEPTUAL OPERATIONAL Comparable to definition from a literature such as a dictionary, encyclopedia, and journals. Specifies exactly how the concept will be determined and assess, it also identifies procedures and operations significant to determine concepts. Example 1: Hospital Stay The time during which a person is a The total of days as patient, beginning with registered patient in a certain hospital. admission day and finishing with discharge. Example 2: Ambulation To walk from one place to another or to move Taking 6 steps without assistance. about. Conceptual Models and Theoretical Models Theoretical models or frameworks are highly established set of concepts that are testable. Conceptual models or frameworks are representations of an idea or body of knowledge based on the own understanding or perception of a person or researcher on a certain topic, phenomena or theory. They can be represented thru a diagram or in narrative form which shows how concepts are interrelated. PERSON – PHYSICAL FITNESS & EXERCISE – LOWERED BLOOD PRESSURE CONCEPTUAL FRAMEWORK VS. THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK CONCEPTUAL It is a structure of concepts or theories which are pulled together as a map for the study THEORETICAL It is a structure of concepts which exist or tested in the literature, a ready-made map for the study. What are Nursing Paradigms? Nursing paradigms are patterns or models used to show a clear relationship among the existing theoretical works in nursing 1. Person 2. Environment 3. Health 4. Nursing 1. Person/Client - The recipient of nursing care. - It is important to know that a person is multidimensional, thus, care provided is individualized according to the needs of the patient. 2. Environment (or Situation) - Internal and external surroundings that affect the person. - Includes all possible conditions affecting the client and the setting in which health care needs occur. - There is continuous interaction between the client and the environment. 3. Health - Goal of Nursing care - The degree of wellness or well-being that the client experiences. - Dynamic and continuously changing. 4. Nursing - The interventions of the nurse rendering care in support of, or in cooperation with the client. - The diagnosis and treatment of human responses to actual or potential health problems (ANA, 1995). - The attributes, characteristic, and nature of the nurse providing care in conjunction with the client. PHILOSOPHY IN NURSING • • Specifies the definition of metaparadigm concepts in each of the conceptual models of Nursing. Sets forth the meaning of phenomena through analysis, reasoning, and logical argument. • Philosophies have contributed to the knowledge development in Nursing by forming a basis for subsequent developments especially in area of human science. SCIENCE Any systematic knowledge or practice in a discipline of study. In a more casual sense, science refers to a system of acquiring knowledge based on the scientific method. It is also the organized body of knowledge gained through research. The scientific method includes several steps: SCIENTIFIC METHOD Observation Gathering Information/Data Forming Hypothesis Experimental Investigation Conclusion or Theoretical Explanation Integration of knowledge and/or phenomenon by a rational/sentient being Recognition and collecting data for a particular scientific problem or inquiry. An attempt to explain or suggest a nature of a phenomenon. A set of examinations done to solve the particular query raised through the hypothesis process. A statement explaining a set of natural phenomena or a scientific query derived from Experimental Investigation. What is Knowledge? Knowledge can be defined as: • Information, skills and expertise acquired by a person through various life experiences, or through formal/informal learning such as formal education, self-study, vocational • The abstract or workable understanding of a subject or idea. • What is known in a particular field of discipline or study. • Facts and information or awareness or familiarity gained by experience of a fact or situation. Knowledge acquirement involves several cognitive processes. Types of Cognitive Process Perception Association Learning Reasoning Communication Achieving understanding of sensory data. Combining two or more concepts/ideas to form a new concept, or for comparison. Acquiring experience, skills, information and values. Mental process of seeking conclusions through reason. Transferring data from sender to receiver using different mediums or tools of communication. What are the sources? ⮚Traditional Knowledge is a nursing practice which is passed down from generation to generation. When asked about the basis of the nursing practice the answer would be as simple as “It’s always been practiced this way.” ⮚Authoritative knowledge is an idea by a person of authority which is perceived as true because of his or her expertise. ⮚Scientific knowledge is a type of knowledge which came from a scientific method through research. These new ideas are tested and measured systematically using objective criteria. Types of Knowledge TRADITIONAL and AUTHORITATIVE Advantage • Disadvantage • • • Practical to implement Based on subjective data Limited use in a variety of practice setting In nursing practice, scientific knowledge through evidenced-based practice and research serves as the main focus. SCIENTIFIC • • • Systematic and accurate Theories it creates are les subjective than knowledg gained by other methods Requires time and effort produce credible results Phenomenon A phenomenon can be defined as sets of empirical data or experiences that can be physically observed or tangible. It is concerned with how an individual person reacts using the human senses concerning their surrounding and assessing the different behaviors and factors that affect such behaviors. In Nursing, phenomena can be: ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ Clinical or environmental setting of nursing Disease process Client’s behavior Interventions ✔ Practices that are utilized in nursing theories and metaparadigms (person, nursing, health and environment) PURPOSES OF NURSING THEORY Nursing Theory Development Education • Nursing theories were primarily used to develop and guide nursing education in universities and institutions. • They were once known to be more strongly established in the field of academics rather than in clinical practice. • In 1970s and 1980s, a number of nursing programs recognized the major concepts of some nursing models, structured these concepts into a conceptual framework, and build the complete curriculum around that framework (Kozier, 2018). ✔ ✔ ✔ ✔ ● ● Program objectives Course objectives Course description Clinical performance criteria Prepare students for practice as members of the professional community. To ensure adequate quality nursing delivery and to clarify and improve the status of the Nursing as a profession. Research ● ● To help us identify gaps in the way we approach specific fields of study such as symptom management, quality of life Different theoretical perspectives also help create new ideas, research questions and interpretations ● ● ● ● ● Grand theories "occasionally" direct nursing research. Based on Middle-range theories which focus on the discovery of concepts such as pain, self-esteem and learning. Theoretical concepts from social sciences served as one of the foundations in qualitative nursing research. Critical theory is used in the academe to describe theories that clarify how social structures influence a wide variety of human experiences from art to social practices. In nursing, critical theory research helps elaborate more on how structures such as race, gender, sexual orientation, and economic class affect experiences and health outcomes of the patients (Kozier, 2018). Clinical Practice Theories thoroughly guide critical thinking and decision-making in clinical nursing practice. ● Nurses will have a better understanding on the basis and nature of their work and be able to express it clearly in collaboration with other professionals. ● Nursing Theories strengthen professional independence by guiding the deepest and most important part of their practice. ● Nursing Theories are always critical in assisting nurses to facilitate questions, reflections, and critical thinking in every aspect of care. Example: The application of Leininger’s Transcultural Nursing Theory for developing culturally similar strategies that is useful to nurses working with suspected child maltreatment cases. ● Interdependence of Theory and Research ‣ The relationship between nursing theory and nursing research helps in building nursing knowledge! Nursing Knowledge-derived from basic and nursing sciences, experience, aesthetics, nurse’s attitudes, and standards of practice. (Potter and Perry, 2018) Composition of Nursing Knowledge ● ● Theoretical knowledge aims to stimulate thinking and broaden understanding of the science and practice of the Nursing discipline. Practical knowledge is referred to as the art of Nursing because it is gained through personal experience and learned during practice. Nursing Research 1. Theory-generating research is designed to discover and describe relationships and phenomena without imposing predetermined notions on the nature of the phenomena. 2. Theory-testing research is utilized to determine how accurate a theory describes a phenomenon. *The end result of theory-generating and theory-testing research is to enhance nursing knowledge. Contributions of Nursing Theorists Theorist Practice Florence Nightingale (Environmental Theory) ⮚ Environmental Hildegard Peplau (Psychodynamic Nursing) Education Research ⮚ Development of excellent training system in St. Thomas Hospital and King’s College Hospital in London. ⮚ Scientific principles and practical experience in mastery of skills. ⮚ Invented the “polar ⮚ Provides clear design for the practice of psychiatric nursing ⮚ Emphasized the development of interpersonal relationship between the patient and the nurse. ⮚ Author of “Interpersonal Relations in Nursing” which aids nurses ⮚ Formulated effective psycho-therapeutic methods. ⮚ Formulated Virginia Henderson (14 components of Basic Nursing Care) ⮚ Nurses as direct ⮚ Nurse’s education demands universal understanding of diverse human being. ⮚ Designed three phases of curriculum development ⮚ Recommended library research. ⮚ Advocated research as a way to improve practice. Joyce Travelbee (Human to Human Relationship Model) ⮚ Hospice is one of her essential contributions ⮚ The focus of Nursing Education has shifted from a disease-oriented ⮚ Utilized by various aspects as integral part of nursing care: ✔ Good Ventilation ✔ Proper disposal control of noise ✔ Sanitation ✔ Water treatments caregiver help patients to become independent. diagrams” to analyze and gather data. concepts of anxiety as a means to constructively resolve angry feelings through experiential learning within the nurse-patient relationship. authors in their study of recently finding meaning in illness and suffering enables the patient not only to accept illness but it will also served as a self-actualizing experience. approach to holistic care approach. ⮚ Stated that nursing programs need to offer a much broader background in communication techniques, values clarifications, and care of the dying. Betty Neuman (Systems Model) ⮚ Goal-directed, integrated and holistic approach to client care ⮚ Formulated Neuman Nursing Process Format: ✔ Nursing Diagnosis ✔ Nursing Goals ✔ Nursing Outcomes ⮚ Holistic curriculum ⮚ Provides an effective framework in conceptual evolution among levels of education of nursing students from diploma to associate to baccalaureate programs. ⮚ Additional clarification and generation of testable nursing theories ⮚ Guide model to enhance the nursing care of clients with specific physiological stressors. Dorothy Johnson (Behavioral System Model) ⮚ Used assessment, disorders, treatment and evaluation instead of Nursing Process ⮚ “The behavioral system is said to determine and limit the interaction between the patient and his environment. ⮚ Focuses on the ⮚ Stated that nursing patient as a behavioral system and its dysfunction. research would: “Identify and explain the behavioral system disorders which arise in connection with illness, and develop the rationale for the means of management.” Imogene King (Goal Attainment Theory) ⮚ Utilized by ⮚ Nursing curriculum ⮚ Her work served as development and practice application in Ohio State and other universities. a theoretical basis for various studies. ⮚ Asserted that professionals in most specialty areas. ⮚ Developed the Goal Oriented Nursing Record (GONR) which is used to record goals and diagnosed cancer patients and their personal search for meaning. outcomes in patient settings. Dorothea Orem (Self Care Deficit Theory in Nursing) ⮚ Described nursing ⮚ Came up with the ⮚ Developed a management of Pertussis. ⮚ Teaching self-care to diabetic patients and End-Stage Renal Failure. ⮚ Pain assessment and control idea of a need for a nursing-specific knowledge structure. ⮚ Author of “Guides for Developing Curriculum for the Education of Practical Nurses” and “Foundations of Nursing and Its Practice”. number of instruments for research. ⮚ The 1st instrument developed named Exercise Self-Care Agency (ESCA) which is used to determine the capacity of patients to care for their selves. Faye Abdellah (Typology of 21 Nursing Problems) ⮚ Organized and ⮚ The typology ⮚ Believed that Sr. Callista Roy (Adaptation Model) ⮚ Manipulating the systematic basis of nursing practice. ⮚ Typology helps in efficient assessment, nursing diagnosis and planning interventions. ⮚ Uses scientific basis in problem-solving process. stimuli and not the patient. ⮚ Nurses enhance the interaction of person and their environment thus improving health. provided scientific body of knowledge and filled-in the gaps of weaknesses in nursing education. ⮚ Development of ⮚ ✔ ✔ ✔ ⮚ ✔ curriculum development in various institutions. Three vertical strands in the curriculum: The adapting person Health-Illness Nursing Management Two horizontal strands in the curriculum: Nursing Process evidenced-based practice on scientific data has a great impact in nursing research. ⮚ Development and testing of theories. ⮚ Practice-based research. ⮚ Development of programs of research. ⮚ Development of adaptation research instruments. ✔ Student Adaptation and Leadership Madeleine Leininger (Transcultural Nursing) ⮚ Prepares nurses to ⮚ Helps produce a ⮚ Focused on culture prevent culture shock and conflicts as they practice in different places with different cultures ⮚ Provides human care and health behaviors as background knowledge to understand nursing phenomena. well-qualified faculty prepared in Transcultural Nursing to teach and guide students. ⮚ Education in Transcultural Nursing leads to culturally competent nursing care. care. ⮚ With research method of (ethno-nursing) to examine theories. Jean Watson (Philosophy and Science of Caring) ⮚ Caring as an ⮚ Author of “Nursing: ⮚ Research must essential field in nursing. ⮚ Example in clinical setting (Intensive Care Units, Neonatal Intensive Care Units, Pediatric and Gerontological Units) Human Science and Human Care- a theory of “Nursing” ⮚ Described the Core of Nursing as aspects of the nurse-patient relationship resulting in a therapeutic result. focus on both subjective and objective patient outcomes in knowing that caring is important in nursing. Patricia Benner (From Novice to Expert: Excellence and Power in Clinical Nursing Practice) ⮚ Formulated the ⮚ Learning needs at an ⮚ Extended the study 1. 2. 3. 4. MARTHA ROGERS (Science of Unitary Human Being) Levels of Competency in Nursing Practice: Novice Advance Beginner Competent Proficient Expert ⮚ Nursing intervention is always focused on unitary human being and change the energy field early stage of clinical knowledge are different from those needed in later stage. ⮚ Seminars and trainings for nurses should focus more on teaching non-invasive interventions such as meditation, of formal models which direct care and substitute knowledge used in nursing practice. ⮚ The theory has been used by various researchers as it is applicable and found testable in different settings and studies. between human and environment. ⮚ Nursing interventions include all the noninvasive actions such as guided imagery, humor, therapeutic touch, music therapy, etc. which are used to increase the potential of human being ERNESTINE WIEDENBACH (Prescriptive Theory) IDA JEAN ORLANDO (Deliberative Nursing Process Theory) ⮚ Provides foundation for assessing or explaining client conditions. ⮚ Influenced many core concepts in nursing today, including nursing assessment, nursing process and nursing diagnosis such as self-care deficits. ⮚ The theory stresses the reciprocal relationship between the client and the nurse. ⮚ The dynamic concept of the nurse-client interaction is seen through collaboration therapeutic touch, and service education programs. ⮚ Wiedenbach proposed that nursing education serves the practice in the following ways: 1. Future practitioners of nursing 2. To gain experience in clinical areas of hospital 3. Its representatives may function in the clinical area and may work closely with the staff 4. Validation that need for help was met 5. Educational opportunities to the nurse ⮚ The theory is used in the academe by focusing on individual learning needs of the students and by addressing them together with student’s active participation. ⮚ In her model, the focus of nursing research is to be related to the client’s response to the health care experience. Her model promotes family relationships, control factors that disable conditions, and use healthcare practices, such as in the care of clients with cancer. ⮚ The theory provided a framework on how to produce improvement in the client’s behavior. Evidence of relieving the client’s distress shows positive changes in the client’s condition. ⮚ Serves as an evidence-based between the nurse and the client. practice in deciding and helping whether nursing action solve client’s problems. ROSEMARIE RIZZO PARSE (Theory of Human Becoming) ⮚ Provides an alternative nursing approach to solving client’s problem by focusing on how the client perceives them. ⮚ Provides nurses with emphasis that actions should focus on valuing the client’s experiences. understanding of the nursing education which focused on personal meaning and experiences of the clients rather than the traditional theoretical frameworks. LYDIA HALL (Care, Core, Cure Theory in Nursing) ⮚ Creation of the Loeb ⮚ Her theory supports Center for Nursing and Rehabilitation at Montefiore Medical Center. The center’s major orientation was rehabilitation and subsequent discharge to home or to a long-term care ⮚ The center’s guiding philosophy was Hall’s belief during the rehabilitation phase of an illness experience, professional nurses were the best prepared to foster the rehabilitation process, decrease complications and recurrences, and promote health and the model of primary care nursing and delineates definite ideas on professional nursing practice and education in terms of screening, monitoring and evaluating academe staff and mentors. It has contributions on the development on the concepts of care in the following areas: Critical care, Geriatrics, Dialysis, Perioperative ⮚ Creates a deeper ⮚ The theory is applied in crisis to change situations clients go through by conducting qualitative research. ⮚ Focuses on lived experiences of the client which are the foundation of phenomenological research. ⮚ In addition to case study research by nurses who worked at Loeb, an 18-month follow-up study of the outcomes of care was funded by the Department of Health, Education and Welfare. The purpose of the longitudinal study was to compare selected outcomes of two groups of patients exposed to different nursing environments (the Loeb program and a control group). Outcomes examined were cost of hospital stay, hospital readmissions, nursing home readmissions, mortality, and return to work and social activities. Overall findings suggested prevent new illnesses. that the Loeb group achieved better outcomes at less overall cost.