THE ARCHIVES OF THE MAHDIA Author(s): P. M. Holt Source: Sudan Notes and Records , JUNE 1955, Vol. 36, No. 1 (JUNE 1955), pp. 71-80 Published by: University of Khartoum Stable URL: https://www.jstor.org/stable/41716681 JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org. Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at https://about.jstor.org/terms is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Sudan Notes and Records This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms THE ARCHIVES OF THE MAHDIA by P. M. Holt Paper presented to the Philosophical Society at its meeting on 26 th October , 19 The archives of the Mahdia which are now in the possession of the M of the Interior form a collection of thousands of documents, written almost in Arabic, illustrating every aspect of the political and administrative histor Sudan between 1885 and 1898. In this talk I propose to show briefly ho collection was acquired, to describe the principal classes of documents w contains and to give an example of the way in which they may be used in or increase our knowledge of this critically important period of Sudanese history The year 1885 saw the failure of the British attempt to relieve Gordon in Kh and the withdrawal of Egyptian troops from Dongola. For the next eleve Wadi Haifa was the southernmost town on the Nile under Anglo-Egyptian con Throughout this period information about the Sudan was being assiduously co by the Intelligence Department of the Egyptián Army under the direction of W In 1889 the Mahdist army under 'Abd al-Rahman al-Nujumi made its il advance into Upper Egypt, to meet defeat in the battle of Tushka at which Alhimself was killed. Among the materials captured by the victors were some o official papers, including a letter-book of the correspondence received by him the Mahdi and the Khalifa 'Abdallahi. This was carefully examined by the Mil Intelligence Department and translations of some of the letters were given by in his book, Mahdiism and the Egyptian Sudan , published in 1891. The o letter-book as well as a number of separate letters from the Khalifa to Al-Nu are now in the Sudan Government archives. Shortly before Wingate's book was published, a much larger body of Mahdist documents fell into his hands. These were the official papers of the provincial administration of 'Uthman Diqnah in the Eastern Sudan, captured after the battle of Tokar in 1891. Wingate prepared a confidential report entitled Dervish Rule in the Eastern Sudany which is partly incorporated in his book, giving translations of some of these papers and summaries of others. Much of this material is now in the Sudan Government archives. Wingate's report does not indicate the extraordinarily large number of. documents pertaining to the provincial treasury of Tokar and its subordinate treasuries at Trinkitat and elsewhere which are included in this collection. They form the most complete body of Mahdist fiscal documents extant and a great deal of work remains to be done before they have been fully examined and catalogued. In 1896 the Egyptian Army under Kitchener's command undertook the reconquest of the province of Dongola. An action took place in June at Ferka in the north of the province. The Ansar under Hammudah Idris were defeated and their headquarters at Suwarda were captured. The advance continued and in September a second engagement took place at Hafir, north of the provincial capital. The military governor, Muhammad Bisharah, withdrew with his troops and by the end of the month Kitchener's forces had reoccupied the whole of the province. As a result of these two actions, a further considerable body of Mahdist papers came into the possession of the Military Intelligence Department. Since April, 1892, this organization had been issuing printed confidential reports, usually at monthly intervals. Translations This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 72 Sudan Notes and Records of specimens of the correspondence captured to Reports Nos. 48 and 49. A selection of le Bisharah was given in an appendix to Report The reoccupation of Dongola was followed i reconquest of the Sudan. The first of the two paign entailed took place by the river Atbara under Mahmud Ahmad, nephew of the Khalif Intelligence Department must have obtained m nothing is said of them in the Intelligence Re battle of Karari took place. Omdurman was oc and the records of the Khalifa's central admin Military Intelligence Department. What ha Syrian assistant, Naum Bey Shoucair, the hist words : - ť After the capture of Omdurman, the D.M.I, gave special attention to the collection of Khalifa's correspondence. The morning after the battle, he went round all the houses where the Dervish correspondence was stored. At first he went to the houses of the Khalifa's Katebs . . . where a large store of correspondence was discovered and put them (i.e. the letters) under guard. He then visited Yakub's house where also a guard was put over a large quantity of correspondence and other stores. Then the Beit El Amana was visited and a guard was put over the correspondence. The D.M.I, gave me orders (as I accompanied him to the above place) to look out for other correspondence in the town and put them all in one place. I visited Beit El Mai where a large store of Dervish official books and correspondence was found. I also visited over 100 private houses of noted Emirs wheçe I found a large quantity of important correspondence. I then collected all this correspondence . . . and put it in one room in a house of Yakub's. . . . Then I packed up this correspondence in parcels and brought it in a native gum-basket to Cairo.' The documents were roughly sorted through by the Military Intelligence Depart- ment to obtain information required by the new administration in the Sudan. Translations and transcriptions were made of a small portion of them. Shoucair used material derived from these archives in his Tarikh al- Sudan, where he quotes extensively from the documents which passed through his hands. Yet all the documents that have been printed, in whole or in part, in the original Arabic or in English translations, form only an insignificant proportion of the whole collection and virtually nothing has been published on the financial and economic aspects òf the period. After this examination at the end of the last century, the archives were again bundled up in brown paper parcels, about eighty in number. They remained in the War Office in Cairo until 1915, when they were brought to Khartoum. They remained undisturbed in the Secretariat, apart from a cursory examination of one or two parcels about twenty years ago, until I transferred them into boxes and started the long and still unfinished business of examining and cataloguing them in 1951. What proportion the collection made between 1889 and 1898 bears to the total mass of official documents produced by the Mahdist administration is .difficult to say. Naturally those dating from the time of the Mahdi himself are very much fewer than those dating from the reign of the Khalifa, since his period of rule was so brief. Moreover, the Mahdist government did not establish a permanent capital at Omdurman until a few weeks before the Mahdi's death and the elaboration of the organs of administration was a gradual process during the thirteen years of the Khalifa ' Abdallahi's reign. The documents which date from the Mahdi's time are chiefly copies This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms Archives of the Mahdia 73 of his letters and a few lithographed proclam give a detailed picture of the administration however, we have a number of letters from the Mahdist general-governor of Darfar, and Khalifa to him during the same period. Fr administrative functions of the Mahdi and the Khalifa. The documentation of the Khalifa's reign is very much richer, although there are some obvious gaps in the records that have been preserved. There are over twelve thousand letters which were exchanged between the Khalifa and his provincial governors and other chief officers. The largest group of these letters from a single individual emanates from Mahmud. Ahmad, first as governor of Kordofan and Darfiir and then as commander of the northern expeditionary force against Kitchener in 1897. Mahmud Ahmad was singularly lacking in initiative and bombarded both the Khalifa and Yacqub with correspondence on matters of every degree of importance. Since in the event he usually refused to follow the advice, often very sound, sent from Omdurman, an air of futility pervades these letters but historians may be grateful for the detailed picture which they present of provincial and military administration in the middle and later years of the reign. Other well-known governors who are well represented in this collection of letters are Hamdan Abu 'Anjah, 'Uthman Adam (Janu), Muhammad al-Zaki 'Uthman, Al-Zaki Tamal, 'Uthman Diqnah and Yunus al-Dikaim. With the exception of Muhammad al-Zaki 'Uthman, the governor of Berber, these were all governors of frontier provinces and were preoccupied with problems of defence. Light is thrown upon the administration of another type of province by the letters of Ahmad al-Sunni, who governed the Gezira and the eastern bank of the Blue Nile from Wad Medani and who had as his principal duty the provisioning of Omdurman. Of the Khalifa's letters to these officials, a much smaller number survives but the absence of the original documents is to a large extent compensated by the summaries of the letters which precede .the replies. There is also a large collection of letters to and from the Khalifa's brother, Yaťqub. Unfortunately these date almost entirely from the last two years of the reign, so that they will probably give only a limited amount of information about the development of Ya'qub's administrative functions. It has been said that Yaťqub was 'Abdallahi's wazir. This was true in effect although no such title was ever formally assumed by him in the way that 'Abdallahi deliberately assumed the style Khalifat al-Mahdi after the Mahdi's death. In the early letters Yaťqub is entitled £ Lieutenant of the Black Flag ' (Wakil al-Raiyah al-Zarqď ) but this phrase ceased to be used. His later correspondents styled him merely ' My Lord and Director ' ( Saiyidi wa-Murshidi), neither of which terms had any adminis- trative significance. Correspondence of the type I have described will, when it is thoroughly examined, throw an immense amount of light on the political history of the Khalifa's reign and on the course of events in the various provinces. There is enough material to employ a team of research students for many years to come. Probably no single document of revolutionary importance will be found but the cumulative effect of details acquired from these thousands of records will certainly change considerably the emphasis in any subsequent history of the Mahdia. My own work in a very small corner of the field - the correspondence between Mahmud Ahmad and the Khalifa in the months before the battle of the Atbara - has for example shown the inaccuracy of the account in The River War of the relations between the two and has indicated with the greatest clarity the conditions in the Mahdist army which contributed to its defeat. F This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 74 Sudan Notes and Records I turn now to the second great class of docu records. There are probably at least as many of of them are as interesting individually and they documents, such as orders upon the treasuries a earlier, there is a very rich collection of papers of Tokar and its associated sub-treasuries. An from the provincial treasury of Dongola. Ther at El Obeid, El Fasher, Berber and elsewhere. In earlier, the records of the General Treasury at is a mass of receipts, orders to the Commissione ments dating from the commissionership of Ib Khalifa's reign, and a certain amount of corres little of the Treasury accounts is extant. There monthly statements of revenue and expenditur of Ibrahim Ramadan in 1897, and a series of ret the storehouse of the General Treasury during learn much about the functions of the General we shall probably never be able to study in det carried out by Ibrahim Muhammad ť Adían missioner, Ahmad w. Sulaiman, in 1886. Other papers of a statistical nature are lists, c of troops, weapons and horses, inventories of th officials, lists of goods sent to the Treasury as Such documents are very numerous and mig information on the composition and equipment biographical material concerning the minor figu The Mahdist archives for the most part cons there are a few bourid manuscript volumes, reg Mahdi up th the year 1306/1888-9, and daftars uries. The Mahdist administration clearly re paper which had belonged to its Egyptian pr quality and so a large proportion of the docume They would however deteriorate rapidly with h hand for their microfilming and for the phot interest, such as the letter-books of the Mahdi of the documents is clear and legible. Some of emanating from the Khalifa's clerks, who were c istic of the official correspondence is its strict open with the formula, " In the Name of Go Praise be to%God, the Generous Guardian, an people blessings and peace*" There is a certain which follows, a characteristic letter from the follows : ' From the slave of his Lord, the Kha the Khalifa 'Abdallah! b. Muhammad, the K and his assistant, the agent of the Mahdia, t God guard him and watch over him.' Nearly all although Shoucair has noted a discrepancy of o in the Sudan and that in Egypt during the appeared but it was certainly before the death authenticated by the seal of the person by importance of the seal is shown by a letter fro This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms Archives of the Mahdia 75 thanking the Khalifa for a new seal and inf defaced. When a seal was lost, the letter was is an interesting contrast between the unform and the smooth, practised script of their cl during the lifetime of the Mahdi but they clerk, usually Ahmadi Mahmud or Al-Mudat some light on the question of the Khalifa's All this indicates the existence of a well-org and the provinces, with a definite tradition extent recruited from the clerks and acc administration in the Sudan. As far as the c be shown in detail by a staff-list compiled b immediately after the fall of Omdurman. A printed in Intelligence Report No. 60 and th archives. This shows, for example, that the 1898 had served over thirteen years before in the Sudan. The same was true of the two clerks in the Arsenal and the two in the Treasury of the War Department. Other departments had at least a nucleus of their clerical staff from the old régime - the First Cleçk of the Treasury of the Bodyguard, the Second Clerk of the Privy Treasury, two of Ya'qub's clerks, two of 'Uthman Shaikh al-Din's clerks and so forth. Some of these men had risen high in the service of the Khalifa. Yusuf Mikhayil, a Copt who had been a junior accountant at El Obeid when the Mahdia began, became one of the Khalifa's clerks and commanded the Coptic unit at Karari. Al-'Awad al-Mardi, head clerk of Taka Province under the Egyptians, was twice Commissioner of the General Treasury under the Khalifa. He had fallen from grace and was in prison when Kitchener entered Omdurman. One of his predecessors in the same profitable but dangerous post, Al-Nur Ibrahim al-Jiraifawi, had been a member of the local court of Khartoum in Egyptian times. He was appointed to the General Treasury after several years of service as com- missioner of the provincial treasury of Berber and, at the Reconquest, held the minor commissionership of the Treasury of the War Department. The importance of this clerical staff in the Khalifa's administration is shown by the careful instructions which he gave to clerks on. their appointment to provincial duties. Here is his commission to a certain Muhammad w. Hasan, who was sent as a confidential clerk to the governor of Berber, 'Uthman al-Ďikaim, in 1305/1887-8. ' We inform you that, because of Our good opinion of you, We have sent you to the Honourable 'Uthman al-Dikaim to undertake his service in the position of clerk, inasmuch as you have long remained here in that position in Our retinue and have understood its purpose. You must be of high zeal in the business to which you are deputed and execute it with sincerity, trustworthiness and integrity as is required, rejecting this world and not meddling in what does not concern you. Be to the Honourable 'Uthman al-Dikaim like the corpse between the hands of the washer. Be prompt to execute his commands. Personally read to him directly all correspondence from Us to Tiim. If he orders you to read anything to others of the Brethren, as the good of the Faith requires, then read it. If he orders you to conceal anything, then conceal it and disclose it to nobody. After you have submitted the letters to him and he has informed you of the replies which he wishes, answer them keeping to the orders given without any neglect. Do not inform anyone about them, even Wad Hamadnallah or Al-Nur Ibrahim (the provincial commissioner of the treasury), since it is not their concern, unless circumstances should necessitate their being in- This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 76 Sudan Notes and Records formed of some matter which may advantageou order of the Honourable 'Uthman they may be orders for 'Uthman, which are between you and in them between you. Except the aforesaid 'Uth anyone to meddle but are to be perpetually with office to which you are deputed as We instruct So far I have been dealing in general terms w clerical organization that produced them. I shou documents for more detailed description. The Mahdist administration that has hitherto receive system in the provinces. They are a number of l 1890 and 1892 by Sulaiman al-Hajjaz who as depu ( Wakil Mahkamat al- Islam) was the second h Sulaiman was sent with three colleagues on a Darfur, to report on and reorganize the admini Sudan which had suffered severely from dis Mahmud Ahmad, who had been appointed go 'Uthman Adam. Besides reporting on judicial a good deal of general information, both about described in the most flattering terms) and abou The party set out in November, 1890, and Sul sent from El Obeid where they arrived early in arrival the inhabitants were in a disturbed state because of the lack of law and order. Mahmud Ahmad adcjressed the people and read the Khalifa's proclamation against oppression and lawlessness. He then confirmed the local judges in office, putting them on oath to maintain justice. The itinerant judges then started to hear claims of oppression. These were very numerous and, since they seemed likely to provoke a disturbance, the judges decided to refer them to the Khalifa and suspend the hearing of them until his instructions arrived. Sulaiman reported that tranquillity had returned and prices had fallen. What further action followed, if any, does not appear. The governor and itinerant judges continued their journey and arrived at the beginning of January, 1891, at En Nahud. Here the business was largely political, and granting of terms to those who wished to make their peace with the new governor. One again Mahmud Ahmad put the local judge on oath to maintain justice. In the last week of January the governor and his retinue reached El Fasher and ten days later Sulaiman al-Hajjaz wrote a long report to the Khalifa. He described the parades and interviews with army officers which Mahmud Ahmad held during his first four days at his provincial capital. The fifth day was a Friday and after the parade ùsually held on that day Mahmud met the judges of El Fasher, headed by a certain Muhammad al-Amin. They took the usual oath to maintain justice. On the following day Sulaiman received Mahmud's permission to sit as an assessor with the local judges, in accordance with the Khalifa's instructions. Meanwhile the district judges of Darfur were arriving in El Fasher and they too were invitedto sit as assessors. By this means their competence was tested and then, with the governor's concurrence, they were reappointed to their districts. Sulaiman informed the Khalifa that unsuitable judges would be replaced, appointments would be made to districts where judges were required and in due course a complete list of the judicial establishment of Darfur would be submitted to the Khalifa with a copy to the Mahkamat al-Islam in Omdurman. This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms Archives of the Mahdia 77 Sulaiman also reported on certain cases described in detail his procedure in one which in face of the lawlessness of the armed force the jihadiyah - the regular troops of slave or Sulaiman drew up an official statement of the Mahkamat al-Islam for the Khalifa's opinion, return of post. Clearly he felt that he had not a case in which the military were involved. I of the jihadiyah and instructed them to main to keep the law. What the Khalifa decided in subsequent correspondence but it is significa that Mahmud Ahmad put all the troops at oath, says Sulaiman, has been kept notably been a good example to the jihadiyah. Sulai write to congratulate the officers. Complaints from Kordofan continued t September, 1891, Sulaiman reported that he a few weeks later) had gone to El Obeid where th local judges. For several months longer Sul 1892, he wrote to inform the Khalifa of the Fasher to succeed Muhammad al-Amin. After consultation with Mahmud Ahmad he had appointed a judge from Bara. A statement in this letter confirms that district judges were appointed by order of the governor after a period of probation during which they acted as assessors with Sulaiman and that the new appointments were notified to the Khalifa and the Qadi al-Islam . Sulaiman reached the White Nile on his return journey in the middle of May, 1892, after a tour of nearly eighteen months. The contents of these archives will of course be of interest primarily to the Sudanese themselves and upon Sudanese students must fall the greatest share in exploring and utilizing the wealth of information that they contain. Yet it would be a great pity if the knowledge of these papers were restricted to those who live or work in the Sudan. They hold much of interest to historians and Orientalists abroad. In the past thefe has been perhaps a tendency to regard the Mahdia too narrowly, as an episode in Sudanese history unique in its nature, to be explained in summary terms of religious fanaticism or incipient nationalism. Such a view does credit neither to the complexity of the movement itself nor to the links which, as Dr. Shibeika has indicated, existed between the Sudanese Mahdia and other movements of revolt in Islam. The pattern of the Mahdia had medieval prototypes and bears a strong superficial resemblance to the early history of the Almohads in North-west Africa under the Mahdi Muhammad ibn Tumart. In its own day the Sudanese Mahdia was one form of the reaction against the decay of Islam which earlier in the 18th and 19th centuries had produced the Wahhabi and Sanusi movements. To set the Sudanese Mahdia against this background is of interest to historians of the Near East but it cannot effectively be done until they are able to see the Mahdia from within, to study in detail its ideology and to investigate the sources of its policy. In making this research possible, the archives in Khartoum can play a part of outstanding importance. Record of Discussion Dr. Shebeika opened the discussion by asking whether the conventional picture of the Khalifa had been much changed by the study of the archives. Mr. Holt, emphasizing that he had made but a partial study, said that the Khalifa This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 78 Sudan Notes and Records emerged as a man of remarkable, even outsta over the Sudan at a critical time, shortly after complex and efficient administration. His we stances of the time and especially his fear of his attempt to control personally all sides of t initiative among his subordinates. There wa Mahmud Ahmad before the Battle of Atbara, well as major issues. The Khalifa had a flair f threat of Muhammad Khalid's advance on Om by astute Machiavellian counter-plotting - bu consistently sacrificed long-term policy to sho the Ta'aishah from the west to gain immediat the riverain tribes. Asked what light the financial papers threw on the Mahdist economy, the speaker stressed that, while trivial individually, the total effect of the papers was great. The urgent need was for microfilming so that the data could be studied as a whole. Mr. Krotki wondered whether original manuscript reports might not have greater accuracy than more comprehensive modern reports. Mr. Holt was not sure of the integrity of those who compiled the Mahdist statements : indeed a monthly balance sheet which he had brought along showed an obvious fraud, and the sad history of the Commissioners for the Treasury, for whom disgrace and execution was the all too common fate, reflected as much upon their honesty as upon the political conditions of the time. However, the general picture of the economy was true. Replying to Mr. Jolliffe , Mr. Holt said that it was not certain that we had documents which were taken to Cairo from Omdurman in 1898. As to a filing during the Mahdia, letters from individual governors were apparently kept t and there was a system of copying letters which stopped in A.H. 1306 (1889) af great famine which seriously weakened the Mahdist àdministration. Dr. Adawi asked how far the Mahdist rising went beyond a local movemen was linked to the Islamic movements elsewhere in the Middle East. Mr. Holt replied that he did not know : if such links were to be formed they would be traced in the letters of the Mahdi. The best evidence was in the Arabic life of Shaikh Muhammad 'Abduh. Dr. Adawi asked how far the early rise of the Mahdi followed that of other prophets. Mr. Holt said that there was an attempt to reproduce the conditions of early Islam, as in the appointment of Khalifas. Both the Mahdi, in letters to the Hejaz and Morocco, and the Khalifa, by writing to various sovereigns, had tried to establish contacts abroad but these were different matters to natural links with similar move- ments. Replying to Yousif Eff. F adi Hassan , Mr. Holt said we had few pre- 1885 letter from the Mahdi. They had been highly prized by the recipients and were carr about until they perished. However, copies existed in the letter-books of vari officials. These surviving letters were mostly exhortations on religious affa invitations to join the Mahdist movement, or warnings to opponents or waverers. ★ * * This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms Archives of the Mahdia 79 Jjtfj ÃilJlj i-j l^ir i-jNl <jübj cuUMjJl êjljj (J ^ M^A- MAo <^-¿k übj~i! ^-L Jl^jÜlJ _^J¿* JT I <„JLJvv2AÍI J APj^il ¿ÜJ L^îd ^ L5J jlj J i* Ul Sjöül oJU ¿P íiyJkl Jj jJ U'c*l-I ioLS" ¿P Vii* ijaju f J?L .jbjJI • J^!/4 <-5 (J*" ^ ^ t M t ÄSyc« Jäj JL>-I aIJLV) 0) JLäj J¿J £ ÜO 4 fll?*Al 5;^Lí (T) SJlil ¿íl^l ja ¿Op I ^JP ip^il OAA O AM ) .iiJl^ll ; ÃJU1 . ÃJLSJj» Ï;^/j ^Jp O^IPI -UP OA>-I JîL - fe • fc .C*¿£ i>jl^} iL*» ' ^ ^>- o ^ .'yyjJjJ UjLl>-l wLxj Jliil l jl if Lôjwai CJIT a5'^ ô/i jN L-J iLU -1$p CJLo ^]l 0*>L-l ^11 cJLJ ^ij . ôj ji¿u i>^)wLi4 cJlS^ - A^» ^ V - ajLÜ-I . j£' l^li ç'£o- ¿jvj O^L-^il <u^l>-^ *uJJ~l J-^p ( c i^iva^i Ic^4 ^ ãí^^4 jr s^ip ja jir Ãi«i5^ ^ y 0^)1^1 ^P ^ . Oj ^.jÜkl «-LJLWVJ 4**jí> ^ ô^w*x*wxl A^i>til <U ir (^JJl ^ l>" JíL-JI ci^" ^-UP ^ ^>-1 . jUjJ^I ¿jíj£ jl ^4 iJUl^ ioUa^-NI üJIj <yty' ¿f iS íSLaj This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms 80 Sudan Notes and Records ípyjU à&yté- iolsÄ^Nl {¿ J^- J . J J^fr ~<Àf V.^"1 Obl-Ui^ll ( . Aj -l^il JjJb CJir J3l ÂJLÏJJI o'cJl*^ cOUJjdl^ ÃjLx!I jlj . JLiLlllj (J 4*P jA (^y*p' ^P ÃX li ¿LutaS" ^J^~3 #L)Ij^JIí ÃJ ¿j* jt-A 0te^ ^ A^JCLûj A1>-^] (. <*- ^ll^Ä^l ji? ^ jjb^J ôLi^S" U- 4jiy jA*J (Jlp L»w2X4 (^Ij . J¿L>- jjijbj j'i^ J Ã*U!I Jl¿>^l <Jp Jj ioL¿¿i i^-Üi < ^ ^>-Nl ÃJ olS^-jj ÃJl^JI 4j wi^il ¿^J AJLlII L)I |¿| i>t^>c-s¿2.!l ÃíjUll ¿^j í C-l^l w'i - iijiwb»- ^1 CJlS" tl^Lw- j^L^4 ¿p ^:j ; Jr^^. ' J>-^ ¿r4 iu$U Cojj 1 ¿ L^ 1$ ^ j^- L> I l) 1 «-^ ^ ^ L!^4 .¿*Jl ¿uJ 4j jl^l ¿ÜL¿S^ «JL-Jl <uiA-l O} I ^J^-äj c- J AÍP j^XS^AJI CJ^-^ U¿)l ¿)l5j ,L-^ap ^ ^>- <lJ>j (J aJLÍí oXãaa ôjb} 1¿jI ¿} Sjjlj 2¡¡>j> tl« 4j1 A*3 {£ J ^ ^- ' APjI^4 Jp 0^w'¿ 1^ A^aI^ Í^LJIj aJ là ¿LrfLwJI (j Ul (¡ aJjU^ wUp ^1 Jj^I S^ï C-J^í ^äj ; <daLJI ^ j jj JjjJ Í^jUISI c-J->- aJI Jl^ AU-IP J ÃLjklI . 4j ^Jl JjLŽJI (j^ ¿^P JiS^ 4jji This content downloaded from 203.189.244.98 on Mon, 03 Jul 2023 12:36:28 +00:00 All use subject to https://about.jstor.org/terms