Religious Symbols Lecture’s objective Introduction to symbols The significance of religious symbols Anthropological frameworks Is this a symbol? What is a symbol? Symbols are ALL around us Humans recognize qualities of material things around them They appropriate them, manipulate them, and give them meaning An apple: shape, smell, taste, and meaning (biblical) What is this symbol? Symbol: “a thing regarded by general What is a symbol? consent as naturally typifying or representing or recalling something by possession of analogous (The Oxford English Dictionary) Symbols can trigger social action and can give personal action form in the public arena. Example: A flag can represent nationalism What is religious symbol? Religious symbol: an iconic representation intended to represent a specific religion, or a specific concept within a given religion. “Religious symbols formulate a basic congruence between a particular style of life and a specific metaphysic, and in so doing sustain each with the borrowed authority of the other” (Geertz, 1973: p. 90). Geertz argued that symbols were part of a series of cultural patterns that provided both a ‘sense of direction’ and a ‘power of self control,’ (Geertz, 1973: p. 99). Symbols are open-ended and arbitrary Symbols in General Displacement- ability to use symbols to refer to things and activities that are remote from the user Openness – new meanings can be attached to new symbols Example: is a mask just a mask? Semiotics- the study of signs and symbols as elements of communicative behavior; the analysis of systems of communication, as language, gestures, or clothing. Ferdinand de Saussure (18571913) Types of Symbols Words, both written and spoken Elements of music and dance and of space and time Artistic expression (theatre, Wayang kulit) Artifacts (Totem poles in Pacific Northwest and Pacific Island cultures. Balinese Wayang Kuli A totem pole in Hawaii Religious symbols A symbol such as the swastika can stand for very complex ideas and can carry great emotional resonance. In 1919, the German Nazi Party adopted the swastika as its symbol (right turning) For Jewish population, this same sign represents genocide and trauma Hinduism, Buddhism- positive meaning such as prosperity and good luck (left-turning) Sanskrit su(“good”) and avasti (“to exist”) Figure 3.1 Navaho Blanket with Swastika. Early twentieth-century Navaho blanket woven of white, red, and dark brown wool, with swastika at each end.Whirling Log Any five-sided figure THE PENTAGRAM Most widely used religious symbols, both historically and cross-culturally. Early Christians used the symbol to represent the five wounds of Christ and the star that prophesied the birth of Jesus Witchcraze (14th-17th century) - “witch’s foot.” Satanists (20th C.E) adopted the pentagram as their symbol Man inscribed in a pentagram, from Heinrich Cornelius Agrippa's De occulta philosophia libri tres. The five signs at the pentagram's vertices are astrological. Figure 3.2 The Pentagram. (a) Pentagram, (b) Satanist inverted pentagram, (c) symbol of the Church of Satan. Even Christian symbols can be abirtrary CHRISTIAN SYMBOLS The cross did not gain general acceptance for many centuries Christians argued against the use of the cross as a symbol of Christianity (paganism or many gods) Roman Catholic (most identifiable) crosses are symbolic of crucifixion scenes The Protestant cross does not show the body of Christ Figure 3.3 Some Christian Symbols. (a) Roman Cross, (b) Greek Cross, (c) Cross of St. Andrew, (d) Tau Cross, (e) Coptic Cross, (f) Celtic Cross, (g) Cross of the Russian Orthodox Church, (h) Cross and Flame of the United Methodist Church (®The United Methodist Church), (i) Jerusalem Cross. Acrostic: a word that is derived from the first letter of a series of words. Icthus: a representation of a fish used in ancient times as a Symbolizing the belief pagan fertility talisman or amulet or as a Christian symbol for the Greek word ichthys interpreted as an acrostic in which the Greek letters are the initials of the words Iesous Christos Theou Uiou Soter meaning Jesus Christ Son of God Savior Icthus The British anthropologist Mary Douglas stresses the power of Mary Douglas (1921-2007) classification to order the world and make it conceptually manageable. She affirmed that all human beings have a profound need for a theory of a general order of existence, and religious symbols fulfill that need. In Purity and Danger she wrote that it was almost inconceivable for a person in a traditional society to be without religion: “The person without religion would be the person content to do without explanations of certain kinds, or content to behave in society without a single unifying principle violating the social order” (1975, p. 76). "Purity and Danger" is an inquiry into different notions of dirt in different cultures What is sacred and profane? Pure or impure? Douglas studies the Jewish Kosher laws Douglas argued that Jewish Kosher laws were about symbolic boundary-maintenance (sacred/profane) Prohibited foods were those that did not seem to fall neatly into any category. For example, the place of pigs in the natural order was ambiguous because they shared the cloven hoof of the ungulates but did not chew cud. Interpretive anthropology: The study of cultural Interpretive anthropology and Clifford Geertz symbols and how those symbols can be used to gain a better understanding of a particular society. Culture is a unique system of symbols with multiple layers of meanings. People act out those meanings and communicate them. Example: Balinese cockfighting (rooster chickens). This practice represents the political and social organization of this society Anthropologists aim to “read” and interpret a culture’s (emic) “text”. Victor Turner and Symbolic Anthropology "Social drama“ Conducted research with the Ndembu of Rhodesia Interested in social order Social order depended on rituals and ceremonial performances Life crisis-rituals among the Ndembu include initiation ceremonies for boys and girls, and funeral rites. Symbolic anthropology is fascinated by the richness of culture What is the meaning of this elaborateness? "It is one thing to observe people performing the stylized gestures and singing the cryptic songs of ritual performances and quite another to reach an adequate understanding of what the movements and words mean to them" (1966) Forest of Symbols by Victor Turner (1970) Rite of passage: is a ritual that marks a change in a person's social or sexual status Example: circumcision, transition into adulthood Rites of passage: 3 stages 1st Stage • Separation: the ending of one social status. 3 Stages of Transition The individual may be physically and/or socially removed from their normal everyday life. 2nd Stage • Transition or Liminality: a stage between one status and another: where one is neither one thing nor another. (perhaps most important?) 3rd Stage • Re-incorporation: the person is reintroduced to society with a new social status. Regular rules of behavior are once again followed. Male transition into adulthood tend to be more ubiquitous in patriarchal societies Ndembu boys go through an initiates, daubed in white clay. In the liminal stage they are all nearly naked, and marked so as to be as nearly the same as the other initiands. The ritual is over, they will now return to the village. source: from Forest of Symbols by Victor Turner, from http://plato.acadiau.ca/courses/soci/chegwidden/rop/Ndembu/Ndemboys.html Artistic representations often illustrate and supplement religious texts Examples: religious paintings, architecture, monuments Sacred Art Small and grand in scale Eastern and western Polytheistic and monotheistic Architecture often incorporate cosmology Sistine Chapel Ceiling, Rome Angkor Wat, Cambodia King Pakal (603 CE - 683 CE) Ruled the Mayans Sarcophagus is buried under a temple The Sarcophagus of Lord Pakal Sarcophagus cover in the Temple of the Inscriptions, Palenque, Mexico. Pakal descending into the Underworld He will undergo a series of trials followed by his resurrection as a god The Maya ruins of Palenque sit in the mist-shrouded jungles of eastern Mexico. The Temple of the Inscriptions, shown here, is the site's most impressive structure. Deep within the temple is an ornate, vaulted chamber containing the crypt of the ruler Pacal. Sacred Time and Space Linear time (forward calendar) Solar / lunar time (cyclical seasons) Industrial (production) Hopi culture (time is chunks of memorable and important moments) Music (organized sound) is a key element in ritual The Symbolism of Music and Dance Music: expresses emotional states, produces altered states of consciousness, pleases supernatural powers, or makes contact with them Music is the facilitation of memorization Narratives and prayers are frequently chanted or sung (sound, rhythm, hymn) Gamelan, Indonesian Music and Dance