E X A M P L E 13.1 A 7.2-m-long A-36 steel tube having the cross section shown in Fig. 13–9 is to be used as a pin-ended column. Determine the maximum allowable axial load the column can support so that it does not buckle. Pcr Solution Using Eq. 13–5 to obtain the critical load with Est 200 GPa, p2EI Pcr = L2 22 4 m/1000 p [200(10 kN/m2](– (75)44 - 14–1–4p12.752 (70)4)(1 mm)4 [29110362) kip>in ] A 14– p132 B in4 ———————————————————————— = 2 2 [24 ft12 in.>ft2] (7.2 m) Ans. 228.2 kN 70 mm 75 mm 7.2 m This force creates an average compressive stress in the column of scr = 64.5(1000 kip N/kN) Pcr 228.2 kN = ———–——————— = 14.3 ksi N/mm2 100 MPa 100.2 2 2 A (70)22]] mm [(75) -p12.752 [p132 in2 2 Since cr Y 250 MPa, application of Euler’s equation is appropriate. Pcr Fig. 13–9 E X A M P L E 13.2 The A-36 steel W200 46 member shown in Fig. 13–10 is to be used as a pin-connected column. Determine the largest axial load it can support before it either begins to buckle or the steel yields. Solution From the table in Appendix B, the column’s cross-sectional area and moments of inertia are A 5890 mm2, Ix 45.5 106 mm4, and Iy 15.3 106 mm4. By inspection, buckling will occur about the y–y axis. Why? Applying Eq. 13–5, we have 2 4 4 2 2 [291106)32kN/m kip>in ]137.14)in 2 )(1 m/1000 mm)4 ](15.3(10 mm p2EI p2[200(10 ——————————–———————————— = = 512 kip Pcr = 1887.6 kN L2 [12 ft12 in.>ft2] (4 2m)2 When fully loaded, the average compressive stress in the column is 512 kip kN (1000 N/kN) Pcr 1887.6 = ———–——————— = 56.1 ksi scr = 320.5 N/mm2 A 9.13 in2 5890mm2 Since this stress exceeds the yield stress (250 N/mm2), the load P is determined from simple compression: P P ; 36 ksi = 2 ———— 250 N/mm ; 2 9.13 in5890mm2 P 1472.5 kN Ans. In actual practice, a factor of safety would be placed on this loading. x y y 4m x Fig. 13–10 13.3 E X A M P L E P x y y x 4m A W150 24 steel column is 8 m long and is fixed at its ends as shown in Fig. 13–13a. Its load-carrying capacity is increased by bracing it about the y–y (weak) axis using struts that are assumed to be pin-connected to its midheight. Determine the load it can support so that the column does not buckle nor the material exceed the yield stress. Take Est 200 GPa and Y 410 MPa. Solution The buckling behavior of the column will be different about the x and y axes due to the bracing. The buckled shape for each of these cases is shown in Figs. 13–13b and 13–13c. From Fig. 13–13b, the effective length for buckling about the x–x axis is (KL)x 0.5(8 m) 4 m, and from Fig. 13–13c, for buckling about the y–y axis, (KL)y 0.7(8 m/2) 2.8 m. The moments of inertia for a W150 24 are determined from the table in Appendix B. We have Ix 13.4 106 mm4, Iy 1.83 106 mm4. Applying Eq. 13–11, we have 4m (a) Fig. 13–13a 4m 1Pcr2x = 6 in p 2[29110 [200(1026)ksi]29.1 kN/m2]13.4(10 ) m4 ———–——————————— = = 401.7 kip 1653.2 kN (1) 1KL22x 1144 in.2 (42 m)2 1Pcr2y = 6 p2[200(10 [29110326)ksi]9.32 in4 kN/m2]1.83(10 ) m4 ———–——————————— = = 262.5 kip 460.8 kN (2) (2.82 m)2 1KL22y 1100.8 in.2 p2EIx 2 3 4 p2EIy By comparison, buckling will occur about the y–y axis. The area of the cross section is 3060 mm2, so the average compressive stress in the column will be x – x axis buckling scr = (b) 262.5 kip 3) N Pcr 460.8(10 ksi 150.6 N/mm2 = —————— = 59.3 A 3060 4.43 in2mm2 Since this stress is less than the yield stress, buckling will occur before the material yields. Thus, Fig. 13–13b Pcr 461 kN 2.8 m Ans. Note: From Eq. 13–11 it can be seen that buckling will always occur about the column axis having the largest slenderness ratio, since a large slenderness ratio will give a small critical load. Thus, using the data for the radius of gyration from the table in Appendix B, we have (c) 4 m(1000 mm/m) 144 in. KL b = ———–———— = 56.2 60.4 r x 2.56 in. 66.2 mm 2.8 m(1000 mm/m) KL 100.8 in. a b = ————–———— = 69.0 114.3 r y 1.46 in. 24.5 mm Fig. 13–13 Hence, y–y axis buckling will occur, which is the same conclusion reached by comparing Eqs. 1 and 2. a y – y axis buckling E X A M P L E 13.4 The aluminum column is fixed at its bottom and is braced at its top by cables so as to prevent movement at the top along the x axis, Fig. 13–14a. If it is assumed to be fixed at its base, determine the largest allowable load P that can be applied. Use a factor of safety for buckling of F.S. = 3.0. Take Eal = 70 GPa, sY = 215 MPa, A = 7.5110-32 m2, Ix = 61.3110-62 m4, Iy = 23.2110-62 m4. z P y y Solution Buckling about the x and y axes is shown in Fig. 13–14b and 13–14c, respectively. Using Fig. 13–12a, for x–x axis buckling, K = 2, so 1KL2x =215 m2 = 10 m. Also, for y–y axis buckling, K = 0.7, so 1KL2y =0.715 m2 = 3.5 m. Applying Eq. 13–11, the critical loads for each case are p2[7011092 N>m2]161.3110-62 m42 p2EIx 1Pcr2x = = 1KL22x 110 m22 = 424 kN p2EIy p2[7011092 N>m2]123.2110-62 m42 1Pcr2y = = 1KL22y 13.5 m22 = 1.31 MN x 5m (a) Fig. 13–14a By comparison, as P is increased the column will buckle about the x–x axis. The allowable load is therefore Pcr 424 kN Pallow = = = 141 kN Ans. F.S. 3.0 Since scr = Pcr 424 kN = = 56.5 MPa 6 215 MPa A 7.5110-32 m2 Euler’s equation can be applied. Le = 10 m Le = 3.5 m x—x axis buckling y –y axis buckling (c) Fig. 13–14c (b) Fig. 13–14 E X A M P L E 13.5 The steel column shown in Fig. 13–19 is assumed to be pin-connected at its top and base. Determine the allowable eccentric load P that can be applied. Also, what is the maximum deflection of the column due to this loading? Due to bracing, assume buckling does not occur about the y axis. Take Est 200(103) MPa, Y 250 MPa. z P 25 mm 50 mm 75 mm y 75 mm x 4.5 m Fig. 13–19 Solution Computing the necessary geometrical properties, we have Ix = 1 12 in.23 mm) = 363 in. (50in.216 mm)(150 414.06 106 mm4 12 A = 12 in.2 =mm) 12 in. (50in.216 mm)(150 27500 mm4 rx = 36 in.4 106 mm4 14.06 = 1.732 in. 43.30 mm ——–—–——–— 2 B D12 in.7500 mm2 mm e = 125in. KL = 1(4.5 1115 ft2112 in.>ft2= 4500 180 in. mm)(1000) mm 180 in. KL 4500 mm 104 = ———–—= 104 rx 43.30 in. mm 1.732 Since the curves in Fig. 13–18b have been established for Est 200(103) MPa, and Y 250 MPa, we can use them to determine the value of P>A and thus avoid a trial-and-error solution of the secant formula. Here KL>rx = 104. Using the curve defined by the eccentricity ratio ec/r2 (25 mm)(75 mm)/(43.30 mm)2 1, we get P (MPa) — A 300 250 ec = 0.1 — r2 200 0.5 P 83 ksi MPa L 12 A 1.0 100 1.5 P (83 MPa)(7500 mm2) 622 500 N 622.5 kN Ans. KL — — 100 150 200 r A-36 structural steel Est = 200(103) MPa, σY = 250 MPa 0 50 We can check this value by showing that it satisfies the secant formula, Eq. 13–19: smax Fig. 13–18 P P ec L = c1 + 2 sec a bd A 2r A EA r 144 kip3) N 180 144622.5(10 kip 3) N 4500in.mm 622.5(10 250 36 ⱨ ——–——— c1 +1112(1) secsec a ——–—–— ———–————–——–—–— bd 2 2 3 2 211.732 in.2 A 3 2 2 12 in. 29110 2 ksi112 (2)43.3 mm D 200(10 ) N/mmin. 7500 mm 7500 mm2 [ ( 36 ⱨ 83[1 12[1 + sec(1.0586 sec 11.0570rad)] rad2] 250 250 36 ⱨ 83[1 1211 + sec60.65°] sec 60.56°2 252.3 250 36 L 36.4 The maximum deflection occurs at the column’s center, where max 250 MPa.Applying Eq. 13–16, we have vmax = ecsec a P L b - 1d A EI 2 [ ( ) ] 3 4500 mm ) Nin. 180 144 kip 622.5(10 mm sec ———–————–——–—–——–— b -6 1 d 4 ——–—— 1 = 25 1 in.csec a 3 24 3 2 2 10 mm A 29110 D 200(10 ) N/mm 2 ksi136 in 2 14.06 25 mm[see 1.0586 rad 1] 25 mm[see 60.65° 1] 26.0 mm Euler’s formula Eq. 13–6 ec = 0 — r2 Ans. )] 13.6 E X A M P L E The W200 59 A-36 steel column shown in Fig. 13–20a is fixed at its base and braced at the top so that it is fixed from displacement, yet free to rotate about the y–y axis. Also, it can sway to the side in the y–z plane. Determine the maximum eccentric load the column can support before it either begins to buckle or the steel yields. z x P 200 mm y y x 4m (a) Solution From the support conditions it is seen that about the y–y axis the column behaves as if it were pinned at its top and fixed at the bottom and subjected to an axial load P, Fig. 13–20b. About the x–x axis the column is free at the top and fixed at the bottom, and it is subjected to both an axial load P and moment M P(200 mm), Fig. 13–20c. y-y Axis Buckling. From Fig.13–12d the effective length factor is Ky = 0.7, so (KL)y 0.7(4 m) 2.8 m 2800 mm. Using the table in Appendix B to determine Iy for the W200 59 section and applying Eq. 13–11, we have Fig.P13–20a 1Pcr2y = 2.8 m 5136247 N 5136 kN 4m (b) y –y axis buckling x-x Axis Yielding. From Fig. 13–12b, Kx = 2, so (KL)x 2(4 m) 8 m 8000 mm. Again using the table in Appendix B to determine A 7580 mm2, c 210 mm/2 105 mm, and rx 89.9 mm, and applying the secant formula, we have Fig. 13–20b P sY = M= P(200 mm) or 4m 33 2 in42 p 2 )ksi] 149.1 22[29110 [200(10 N/mm ](20.4)(106) mm4) ———————————————— = = 1383 kip 1KL22y 1100.8(2800 in.22 mm)2 p2EIy [ Px 250 —–— 1 7580 1KL2x Px Px ec c1 + 2 sec a bd A 2rx A EA rx 200 105 8000 Px ———–— ——––——–— sec ——–— 89.92 2(89.9) D 200(103) · 7580 ( )] 421.2 [1 + sec(1.143 2.979 sec 10.0700 1.895 106 Px[1= Px2.598 103 2Px2] Solving for Px by trial and error, noting that the argument for sec is in radians, we get (c) x – x axis buckling Fig. 13–20 Px 419368 N 419.4 kN Ans. Since this value is less than (Pcr) 5136 kN, failure will occur about the x–x axis. Also, 419.4 103 N/7580 mm2 55.3 MPa Y 250 MPa. 13.7 E X A M P L E σ (MPa) A solid rod has a diameter of 30 mm and is 600 mm long. It is made of a material that can be modeled by the stress–strain diagram shown in Fig. 13–22. If it is used as a pin-supported column, determine the critical load. 270 Solution The radius of gyration is σpl = 150 1p>421152 I = = 7.5 mm AA B p11522 4 r = and therefore the slenderness ratio is 0.001 11600 mm2 KL = 80 = r 7.5 mm Fig. 13–22 Applying Eq. 13–20 yields scr = p2Et 1KL>r22 = p2Et 18022 = 1.542110 - 32Et (1) First we will assume that the critical stress is elastic. From Fig. 13–22, E = 150 MPa = 150 GPa 0.001 Thus, Eq. 1 becomes scr = 1.542110 - 32[15011032] MPa = 231.3 MPa Since scr 7 spl = 150 MPa, inelastic buckling occurs. From the second line segment of the s - P diagram, Fig. 13–22, we have Et = 270 MPa - 150 MPa ¢s = = 120 GPa ¢P 0.002 - 0.001 Applying Eq. 1 yields scr = 1.542110 - 32[12011032] MPa = 185.1 MPa Since this value falls within the limits of 150 MPa and 270 MPa, it is indeed the critical stress. The critical load on the rod is therefore Pcr = scrA = 185.1 MPa[p10.015 m22] = 131 kN 0.002 Ans. ∋ E X A M P L E 13.8 P x y y An A-36 steel W250 149 member is used as a pin-supported column, Fig. 13–27. Using the AISC column design formulas, determine the largest load that it can safely support. Est 200(103) MPa, Y 250 MPa. x Solution The following data for a W250 149 is taken from the table in Appendix B. 5m A 19000 mm2 rx 117 mm ry 67.4 mm Since K = 1 for both x and y axis buckling, the slenderness ratio is largest if ry is used. Thus, 1116 ft2112 in.>ft2 1(5 m)(1000 mm/m) KL = ————————— = 72.45 74.18 r 12.65 (67.4in.2 mm) P Fig. 13–27 From Eq. 13–22, we have a 2p2E KL b = r c B sY = 3 3 2p 2 ksi] 222[29110 (200)(10 ) MPa ——–—–———–— 36 ksiMPa D 250 B = 126.1 125.66 Here 0 6 KL>r 6 1KL>r2c, so Eq. 13–23 applies. c1 sallow = 1KL>r22 21KL>r22c dsY 515>32 + [13>821KL>r2>1KL>r2c] - [1KL>r23>81KL>rc23]6 2 2 2>21126.12 ]36MPa ksi 172.452 [1 [1 (74.18) /2(125.66)2]250 = ———————————–—–——–———————— 3 3>81126.1233]6 515>32 [13>82172.45>126.12]-[(74.18) [172.452 /8(125.66) ]} {(5/3) + [(3/8)(74.18/125.66)] MPa = 110.85 16.17 ksi The allowable load P on the column is therefore sallow = P ; A PP 16.17 kip>in. 110.85 N/mm2 = ————— 2 2 19000 29.4 in.mm P 2106150 N 2106 kN Ans. 13.9 E X A M P L E The steel rod in Fig. 13–28 is to be used to support an axial load of 80 kN. If Est 210(103) MPa and Y 360 MPa, determine the smallest diameter of the rod as allowed by the AISC specification. The rod is fixed at both ends. d 80 kN 80 kN 5000 mm Fig. 13–28 Solution For a circular cross section the radius of gyration becomes r = I d 11>42p1d>224 = = 2 AA 4 B 11>42pd Applying Eq. 13–22, we have a 3 3) MPa] 222[29110 [210(10 KL 2p2E 2p 2 ksi] 107.3 ——–—–——–—– b = = = 107.0 D r c B sY 50 ksi 360 MPa B Since the rod’s radius of gyration is unknown, KL>r is unknown, and therefore a choice must be made as to whether Eq. 13–21 or Eq. 13–23 applies. We will consider Eq. 13–21. For a fixed-end column K = 0.5, so sallow = 12p2E 231KL>r22 2 2 3 3 2 2 [29110 2 kip>in 18 3kip 1212p [210(10 ) N/mm ] ] 80(10 )N ———–——————— ———–— = 2 2 2 2 11>42pd 23[0.5115 ft2112 in.>ft21d>42] 23[0.5(5000 mm)/(d/4)] (1/4) d 101.86 103 22.92 ———–—— = 1.152d 0.0108d2 2 mm d2 d2 mm d = 55.42 2.11 in. Use d 56 mm For this design, we must check the slenderness-ratio limits; i.e., 0.511521122 KL 0.5(5)(1000) 160 = ————–— = 179 r 12.25>42 (56/4) Since 107.3 179 200, use of Eq. 13–21 is appropriate. Ans. E X A M P L E 13.10 A bar having a length of 750 mm is used to support an axial compressive load of 60 kN, Fig. 13–29. It is pin supported at its ends and made from a 2014-T6 aluminum alloy. Determine the dimensions of its crosssectional area if its width is to be twice its thickness. 60 kN b 2b y x Solution 750 mm Since KL 750 mm is the same for both x–x and y–y axis buckling, the largest slenderness ratio is determined using the smallest radius of gyration, i.e., using Imin = Iy: 1(750) 11302 KL KL 103.9 2598.1 = = = ——— ry 3 bb 2Iy>A 211>1222b1b23>[2b1b2] (1/12)2b(b )/[2b(b)] (1) Here we must apply Eq. 13–24, 13–25, or 13–26. Since we do not as yet know the slenderness ratio, we will begin by using Eq. 13–24. P N/mm2 = 195 28 ksi A 60 kN 123kip 60(10 )N 22 ——––— = 195 N/mm 28 kip>in 2b1b2 2b(b) Fig. 13–29 b = 0.463 12.40 in. mm Checking the slenderness ratio, we have 2598.1 KL 103.9 = ———= 224.5 209.57 1212 r 0.463 12.40 Try Eq. 13–26, which is valid for KL>r Ú 55: 378125 MPa 54 000 ksi P = ———–—— A 1KL>r2 (KL/r)2 2 378125 60(10 123) 54 000 ——— = ————— 2b1b2 (2598.1/b)2 2 1103.9>b2 2b(b) b = 27.05 1.05 in. mm Ans. From Eq. 1, 2598.1 103.9 KL = ———= 99.3 96.07 5555 OK OK r 1.05 27.05 Note: It would be satisfactory to choose the cross section with dimensions 27 mm by 54 mm. E X A M P L E 13.11 A board having cross-sectional dimensions of 150 mm by 40 mm is used to support an axial load of 20 kN, Fig. 13–30. If the board is assumed to be pin supported at its top and bottom, determine its greatest allowable length L as specified by the NFPA. 20 kN 40 mm 150 mm y x L 20 kN Fig. 13–30 Solution By inspection, the board will buckle about the y axis. In the NFPA equations, d = 1.5 in. Assuming that Eq. 13–29 applies, we have 3718 MPa 540 ksi P = –———— A (KL/d)22 1KL>d2 3 5 kip 20(10 )N 3718 540N/mm ksi 2 ———–———–— = –————–— 15.5mm)(40 in.211.5mm) in.2 (150 11 L/40 L>1.5mm) in.222 (1 L = 1336 44.8 in. mm Here 1144.8 in.2 (1)1336 mm KL = –––——–—= 29.8 33.4 d 1.5 in. 40 mm Since 26 6 KL>d … 50, the solution is valid. Ans. E X A M P L E 13.12 The column in Fig. 13–32 is made of aluminum alloy 2014-T6 and is used to support an eccentric load P. Determine the magnitude of P that can be supported if the column is fixed at its base and free at its top. Use Eq. 13–30. P 40 mm 20 mm 40 mm 40 mm 1600 mm Fig. 13–32 Solution From Fig. 13–12b, K = 2. The largest slenderness ratio for the column is therefore 2(1600 2180 in.2mm) KL = = 277.1 277.1 3 3 r 2[11>12214 in.212 in.2 in.24 in.] mm] 1 [(1/12)(80 mm)(40 mm)]>[12 ]/[(40 mm)80 By inspection, Eq. 13–26 must be used 1277.1 7 552. Thus, 54 000 ksi ksi MPa 378125 MPa 54 000 378125 = —––——–— = 0.703 sallow = —––——–— ksi 4.92 MPa 22 2 1KL>r2 1277.12 (KL/r) (277.1)2 The actual maximum compressive stress in the column is determined from the combination of axial load and bending. We have 1Pe2c P + A I P11 in.212 in.2 PP P(20 mm)(40 mm) —––————–———— + = —––——–—— 3 40 mm(80 2 in.14 in.2 mm) (1/12)(40 mm)3 11>12212 in.214mm)(80 in.2 smax = 0.00078125 P = 0.3125P Assuming that this stress is uniform over the cross section, instead of just at the outer boundary, we require sallow = smax; 4.92 0.00078125P P 6297.6 N 6.30 kN Ans. E X A M P L E 13.13 The A-36 steel W150 30 column in Fig. 13–33 is pin connected at its ends and is subjected to the eccentric load P. Determine the maximum allowable value of P using the interaction method if the allowable bending stress is (b)allow 160 MPa. E 200 GPa, Y 250 MPa. Solution P 750 mm y x Here K = 1. The necessary geometric properties for the W150 30 are taken from the table in Appendix B. A 3790 mm2 Ix 17.1 106 mm4 ry 38.2 mm d 157 mm We will consider ry because this will lead to the largest value of the slenderness ratio. Also, Ix is needed since bending occurs about the x axis (c 157 mm/2 78.5 mm). To determine the allowable compressive stress, we have 4m 1(4 m)(1000 mm/m) 1115 ft112 in.>ft2 KL 104.71 = 120 = —––—————–— 38.2in.mm r 1.50 Since a M = P(750 mm) P 2p 2 ksi] 2 [29110 (200)(10 ) MPa 2p E KL ——–—–——–—— 125.66 = = 126.1 b = r c B sY 250ksiMPa D C 36 2 22 3 3 Fig. 13–33 then KL>r 6 1KL>r2c and so Eq. 13–23 must be used. sallow = [1 - 1KL>r22>21KL>r2c2]sY [15>32 + [13>821KL>r2>1KL>r2c] - [1KL>r23>81KL>r2c3]] 2 2 2 >21126.12 ]36 2ksi [1 [1 11202 (104.71) /2(125.66) ] ⴢ 250 MPa = —––————––—–——————————––––————–—– 3 3 3 3 {(5/3)+ [13>8211202>1126.12] [(3/8)(104.71)/(125.66)] [(104.71) /8(125.66) ]} [15>32 - [11202 >81126.12 ]] = 85.59 10.28 ksi MPa Applying the interaction Eq. 13–31 yields sb sa + … 1 1sa2allow 1sb2allow P130 in.213.10 in42 6) mm4 P>5.87 in.22 P/3790 mm P(750 mm)(157in.2>141.4 mm/2)/17.1(10 —––——–—2 + —––——–———————————— = 1 1 10.28 ksi 22160 ksi N/mm2 85.59 N/mm P = 8.43 40.65kip kN Ans. Checking the application of the interaction method for the steel section, we require 3 8.43 kip>15.87 in.2 mm2) sa 40.65(10 ) N/(3790 = ——–—–——–——–—— = 0.14060.125 0.15 0.15 OK OK 2 2 1sa2allow 10.28 kip>in 85.59 N/mm E X A M P L E 13.14 The timber column in Fig. 13–34 is made from two boards nailed together so that the cross section has the dimensions shown. If the column is fixed at its base and free at its top, use Eq. 13–30 to determine the eccentric load P that can be supported. P 60 mm 60 mm 20 mm 60 mm x y 1200 mm Fig. 13–34 Solution From Fig. 13–12b, K = 2. Here we must calculate KL>d to determine which equation from Eqs. 13–27 through 13–29 should be used. Since sallow is determined using the largest slenderness ratio, we choose d 60 mm. This is done to make this ratio as large as possible, and thereby yields the lowest possible allowable axial stress. This is done even though bending due to P is about the x axis. We have 2160 in.2 2(1200 mm) KL = —––——–— = 40 40 d 360in.mm The allowable axial stress is determined using Eq. 13–29 since 26 6 KL>d 6 50. Thus, 540 ksi ksiMPa 3718 MPa 540 3718 sallow = —––——– = —––—–— = 0.3375 ksi MPa 2.324 2 2 1KL>d2 1402 (KL/d)22 (40) Applying Eq. 13–30 with sallow = smax, we have P Mc sallow = + A I P14 in.213 P(80in.2 mm)(60 mm) P P —––——–——————— 2.324 N/mm + 0.3375 ksi2 = —–——–——— 3 3 in.16 in.2 mm) (1/12)(600 mm)(120 mm)3 60 mm(120 11>12213 in.216 in.2 P 3.35 kN Ans.