CHAPTER 6 COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT PROCESS A community development assessment should be done before a community develops a strategic plan, before it develops action steps to address community problems. A good assessment forms the foundation for a successful community and economic development effort. Without a good assessment, communities are usually “driving blind” The assessment will identify the strengths on which planned development can be built and identify the weaknesses that need to be eliminated or mitigated as much as possible to give the community the best probabilities for success. ANALYSIS OF THE EXISTING SITUATION SWOT ANALYSIS An analysis tool with a square segmented into 4 quadrants containing the following: (S) strengths, (W) weaknesses, (O) opportunities, (T) Threats analysis assesses internal and external factors, as well as current and future potential. Focuses on real-life contexts. It can help the community to analyze and devise a successful strategy for the future. It can also uncover areas that are holding the community back. Internal Factors Strengths o excels at o What do you do well? o What unique resources can you draw on? o What do others see as your strengths? Samples: o Existing local skills o Abundant resources o Infrastructure o Tried and proven practices Weakness o performs poorly at, lacking o What could you improve? o Where do you have fewer resources than others? o What are others likely to see as weaknesses? Samples: Prevalent poverty Lacking skills Poor infrastructure Poor Hygiene External Factors Opportunities o Are favorable external factors that could give the community a competitive advantage. o What opportunities are open to you? o What trends could you take advantage of? o How can you turn your strengths into opportunities? Samples: Growing regional economy Growing tourist arrivals Little competition in a certain trade or product. More land to develop into housing units. Threats o Factors that have the potential to harm the community. o What threats could harm you? o What threats do your weaknesses expose to you? Samples: Exposure to hazards Increasing competition Increasing prices of land Higher opportunities in other areas ACTION PLANNING An action plan is a description of the activities needed to be done to move the community toward its vision. It can help the community turn their visions into reality, and increase efficiency and accountability within an organization. It describes the way your organization will meet its objectives through detailed action steps that describe how and when these steps will be taken. For each project that is identified, there should be detailed plan of what needs to be done, who can do it, when it will be done, what information is needed, and what resources are necessary to implement the strategy. Action plans should be prepared based on agreed on strategies and goals. Each action step or change to be sought should include the following information: What actions or changes will occur Who will carry out these changes By when they will take place, and for how long What resources (i.e., money, staff) are needed to carry out these changes Communication (who should know what?) The action should meet several criteria. Is the action plan: Complete? Does it list all the action steps or changes to be sought in all relevant parts of the community (e.g., schools, business, government, faith community)? Clear? Is it apparent who will do what by when? Current? Does the action plan reflect the current work? Does it anticipate newly emerging opportunities and barriers? Reasons for Developing an Action Plan To lend credibility to your organization. To be sure you don't overlook any of the details To understand what is and isn't possible for your organization to do For efficiency: to save time, energy, and resources in the long run For accountability: To increase the chances that people will do what needs to be done ACTION PLANNING WORKSHOP an eight stage process that uses the Focused Conversation Method and the Consensus Workshop Method. Develops a concrete plan with clear forms of accountability. Steps: 1. Context – orientation, goals & objectives 2. Current reality – baseline, issues & concerns 3. Victory- success indicators 4. Key actions – Interventions 5. Assignments- persons responsible 6. Commitment – Time & Resources 7. Calendar- Time Frame, Targets 8. Resolve- Confirmation Context (Goals and Objectives) the background to what is at hand and the outlining of the process that is to be followed. Goals A goal is an idea of the future or desired result that a person or a group of people envision, plan and commit to achieve (Locke, 1990). Objectives It is something toward which an effort is directed. SMART goals are: Specific: Well defined, clear, and unambiguous Measurable: With specific criteria that measure your progress toward the accomplishment of the goal Achievable: Attainable and not impossible to achieve Realistic: Within reach, realistic, and relevant to your life purpose Timely: With a clearly defined timeline, including a starting date and a target date. The purpose is to create urgency. Examples: Create new job opportunities to decrease unemployment and poverty levels within the community. Design a community that have inclusive amenities which encourages social interaction to cultivate a sociable and participative citizenry. Current reality what is the current situation, including what resources are available. Existing/lacking Resources Geographic limitations and hazards Social Infrastructure Socio-economic conditions Heath & Hygiene Income of Families Community Finances Jobs Safety & Security Education Etc. Examples: 20% Unemployment 60% living below the poverty threshold The area located in the North-east accounting for 30% of the community’s area is considered a landslide hazard. Lacking community & recreational facilities such as a community hall & basketball court. Victory (Success Indicators) identifying what success will look like. Success Indicators the successful extent of the interventions made as an answer to the issues and concerns. Examples: Unemployment reduced to 5% Families living below the poverty threshold reduced to 15% The area located in the North-east is preserved as an open space with 100% of affected families relocated to safe locations. 100% implementation of the community hall & basketball court. Key actions (Interventions) what are the key tasks and implementation steps that need to be completed. It can be in the following form: Strategies - A method or plan chosen to bring about a desired future, such as achievement of a goal or solution to a problem. Examples: Tap the existing sustainable loca bamboo resources and create a local bamboo industry with the collaboration of local businesses and the Bamboo Technology Resource Center –MSU-IIT. Policies - a deliberate system of principles to guide decisions and achieve rational outcomes or a statement of intent, and is implemented as a procedure or protocol. Examples: All community facilities and amenities shall be inclusive and accessible. Building materials for the construction of relocation houses shall be sustainably sourced to minimize the environmental impact of the project. The Urban design of the neighborhood shall adapt the principles of walkability, connectivity and self-sufficiency. Programs - a set of related measures or activities with a particular long-term aim. Examples: Feeding program Provide proper nutrition to malnourished children to improve their heath and well-being. Activities: Determine beneficiaries, distribute food supplements, provide breakfast & lunch meals, monitoring Skills Development program Provide training to unemployed community members to gain new skills and address the lack of workforce within the local industry Activities: Coordination with local industries, Provide skills training/ on the job training Projects - An undertaking that can be carried out individually or collaboratively which may require careful planning to achieve a particular aim. Examples: Relocation housing project Community hall and basketball court project Seawall project Farm to Market road project Assignments (Persons Responsible) allocating roles to group members. Including who will lead and where does accountability and responsibility for each key task or implementation step lie. Examples: Feeding program Cooking for meals: Community members cooks with daily salaries. Heath Monitoring: Barangay heath clinic Commitment (Time & Resources allocated) identifying and stating what each group member or stakeholder will contribute and deliver. Examples: Feeding program Cooking for meals: World food program (WFP) will allocate 500 thousand pesos for the salaries of cooks and ingredients per month. Heath Monitoring: Barangay heath workers monitor the children’s weight every week for 3-months. Calendar (Targets) the placing of key tasks or implementation steps on an action timeline. Examples: Feeding program Cooking for meals: World food program (WFP) will allocate 500 thousand pesos for the salaries of cooks and ingredients per month. Heath Monitoring: Barangay heath workers monitor the children’s weight every week for 3-months. Resolve confirming the group’s plan and their level of commitment and motivation to implementing it. CHAPTER 7 COMMUNITY PLANNING DEVELOPMENT MONITORING & EVALUATION It is a group of activities and indicators to measure a project’s ongoing success in relation to clearly defined outputs. It allows you to assess progress and achievements in line with your objectives. M&E offers a tangible way to ensure that your project is accountable, transparent, minimizes collateral damage and actively identifies wasteful processes and poor performance. Why is Monitoring & Evaluation important? Communities are seldom interested in monitoring and are primarily concerned with getting things done. However there are multiple reasons why it is useful to measure its progress and evaluate its efforts: To keep people involved and informed about the progress To better manage policies, programs and projects To measure the performance of an Organization or an intervention To determine if the program is a success or a failure To learn and document the experience To determine the failures and correct it To establish Accountability and Transparency to supporters and funders To gain more support for future endeavors MONITORING It occurs throughout the project to ensure you are meeting your objectives. It provides direct insight into the activity’s impacts. Tracks movement of indicators towards the achievement of specific, predetermined targets. Clarifies program objectives Links activities and their resources to objectives Translates objectives into performance indicators and sets targets and baselines Routinely collects data on these indicators, compares actual results withtargets Reports progress to managers and alerts them to problems if the deadlines are met if the resources allocated are appropriate if the amount of work is manageable if the group is working effectively & efficiently Traditional monitoring focuses on implementation monitoring Involves tracking inputs (money, resources, strategies) Activities (what actually took place) Outputs ( products & services Produced) More on monitoring how well a project, program or policy is being implemented Often used to assess compliance with work plans & budget. Results-based monitoring Involves the regular collection of information on how effectively the is performing. Important to determine whether a project, program, or policy Performance Indicators A variable that tracks the changes in the development intervention or shows results relative to what was planned. The cumulative evidence of a cluster of indicators is use to see if an initiative is making progress. Normally accompanied by a measurable target - often a percentage - to help quantify success. There are different types of indicators you can use: Objectively Verifiable Indicators Indirect Indicators Qualitative Indicators Objectively Verifiable Indicators Show the important characteristics of the objectives and the performance standard expected to be reached in terms of quantity, quality, time frame and location. Example: Target: Increased access to healthy community facilities & amenities Indicators: # of households that can access a community park within a 400 meter walking distance. Indirect Indicators assess the achievement of a target in an indirect way These are indicators you can use if the outcome cannot be measured directly Happiness of the Workforce: Tracking the number of sick days or work leaves taken by staff. There is a 80% drop of staff taking sick leaves after 7 hours work time was implemented 4 months ago Qualitative Indicators an important indicator when seeking to understand how the ‘process’ of your project is being received by the community. Give insight into how satisfied beneficiaries are with your project, whether the project has led to sustainable behavioral changes Can be hard to analyse → you can still use Objectively Verifiable Indicators (usually a percentage) even if your indicators are qualitative. Example: # of families perception about their financial status 50% of families reported less stressed about their finances. EVALUATION Takes a broader view, considering progress toward stated goals, the logic of the initiatives, and its consequences. Done by month, quarter or annually. Important to conduct after a project is completed. Allows the organization to reflect upon and analyze the collected data from the monitoring activities Analyzes why intended results were or were not achieved Assesses specific casual contributions of activities to results Examines implementation process Explores unintended results Provides lessons, highlights significant accomplishment or program potential, and offers recommendations for improvement Evaluation Addresses: WHY - on what causes the changes we are monitoring HOW - what was the sequence or processes that led to successful outcomes Compliance/ Accountability - Did the promised activities actually take place and as they are planned Process/ Implementation - Was the implementation process followed as anticipated, and with what consequences.