Classical Studies Classical Mythology Intermediate 1 and 2 3818 August 1998 HIGHER STILL Classical Studies Classical Mythology Intermediate 1 and 2 Support Materials q CONTENTS Introduction In the beginning . . . The Underworld Quick reference list Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 1 Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 2 INTRODUCTION These support materials for Classical Studies were developed as part of the Higher Still Development Programme in response to needs identified at needs analysis meetings and national seminars. Advice on learning and teaching may be found in Achievement for All, (SOEID 1996) and in the Classical Studies Subject Guide. This support package provides student material to support the Intermediate 1 and 2 Classical Mythology unit. There are two main sections in the package, namely, In the Beginning and The Underworld. Between them these provide coverage of the myths detailed in the Arrangements document under Creation, The Afterlife and Visitors to Hades. Finally, there is a ‘Quick Reference List’ of the names included in the package. The material is designed so that students should be able to use it in a supported selfstudy mode, if required. In each section, there is a general introductory overview of the topic followed by a number of relevant sources which students are expected to study. Interspersed with the sources are questions and research assignments etc., targeted at Intermediate 1 or Intermediate 2 or all students as appropriate. Some questions are straightforward and can be answered from the text of the sources. Other questions demand more synthesis and evaluation; these questions contribute to the development by students of the core skill component, Critical Thinking. While students will tackle these questions individually for the most part, there may be opportunities for some collaborative working and staff will wish to discuss points raised with individuals, groups and the whole class. The exact way in which this material is used is, of course, at the discretion of the individual teacher or lecturer. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 3 Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 4 IN THE BEGINNING ... Remember that there is no ‘official’ version of Greek mythology. The Greeks and Romans had no sacred book of knowledge like the Bible or the Koran. You may find differences in the details of a myth, as told by different authors. As time passed, and people’s perceptions of the world changed, the way of telling the story changed. Compare, for instance, Hesiod’s description of the Creation with Ovid’s. Ovid lived perhaps 700 years after Hesiod. It is not surprising that his story sounds to us somehow more convincing than Hesiod’s. The following is a summary of Greek Creation Myth, gathered from different sources: Chaos was there first, a yawning gap, a nothingness out of which something, the Earth (in Greek ‘Gaia’ or ‘Ge’) emerged. Other beings formed from Chaos were Tartarus (the Darkness below the Earth), Erebus (Darkness), Nyx (Night) and Eros (the Creative Force). Gaia produced the Sky (‘Ouranos’ or ‘Uranus’) from herself, and then between them they produced the 12 Titans, three one-eyed Cyclopes and three Hundred-Handed Giants (the ‘Hecatoncheires’). Two of the Titans, Iapetus and Clymene, produced other Titans, namely Atlas, Prometheus and Epimetheus, all of whom were important later on in the story. There is also a hint in Greek mythology that Oceanos and Tethys, two of the 12 Titans, may have been the original creators. Cronus and Rhea Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 5 However, Ouranos did not like his children and refused to let them leave his mother’s body. This caused Gaia great pain and she persuaded Cronus, one of the Titans, to castrate his father. From the blood of the wounded Sky came giants, nymphs, the Furies and Aphrodite. Cronus released his brothers and sisters, although he soon imprisoned the Cyclopes and the Hecatoncheires once again. He produced six children with Rhea his sister. These children were the Olympian gods Zeus, Poseidon, Hades, Hera, Hestia and Demeter. Worried that he would be overthrown in turn, he swallowed his children, but Rhea saved Zeus and he was reared secretly in a cave on the island of Crete. Rhea substituted a stone for the baby and so tricked Cronus, who swallowed the stone. Zeus was fed by the sacred goat Amaltheia and the bees brought him wild honey. Friendly local gods, the Curetes, clashed their weapons to drown out young Zeus’ cries. Zeus forced Cronus to set free his brothers and sisters. Zeus then released the Cyclopes and Hecatoncheires. The Cyclopes gave Zeus his thunderbolt, Poseidon his trident and Hades his cap of invisibility. These helped the gods defeat the Titans in a great war. After the war some of the Titans were thrown down into Tartarus, while Atlas was condemned to hold the sky on his shoulders. Gaia then produced a terrible monster called Typhoeus, or Typhon, who was able to hamstring and imprison Zeus, but eventually Zeus was rescued and Typhon was imprisoned under the volcano, Mount Etna, on the island of Sicily. There were not yet any human beings. The Titan Prometheus, according to some writers, created them from clay. Zeus refused to allow them the use of fire, perhaps because Prometheus had cheated him by offering him the worst bits of a sacrifice. When Prometheus stole fire and returned it to men, Zeus punished Prometheus by chaining him and sending an eagle to chew his immortal liver. He also punished humans by sending to Epimetheus (Prometheus’ brother) the first woman, Pandora, who was to bring disaster to the world. Atlas and Prometheus Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 6 The human race came in for further trouble later, when Zeus decided to drown the whole lot in a flood. However, on Prometheus’ advice, Deucalion and Pyrrha survived by building a boat, and when the water went down again, repopulated the earth by throwing stones over their shoulders. Some writers talk of a series of Ages, named after metals, which traces the gradual downfall of human beings. They disagree on the number of these Ages: Hesiod counts five, while Ovid describes four. They all agree, however, that the Age they live in is the worst. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 7 Source 1 - The Creation Hesiod, Theogony, lines 116-141, 147-156 Indeed, the very first was yawning Chaos, and then broad-breasted Gaia (Earth), forever a secure seat for all the immortals who possess the peaks of snowy Olympus, and dark Tartarus in the recesses of the broad-pathed Earth, and Eros, Love, who is the most beautiful of all the immortal gods, bringing relaxation to the limbs, overcoming reason and wise decisions, in the hearts of all the gods and all mortals. And out of Chaos came Erebus (Darkness) and black Night, and from Night were born Aether (Bright Air) and Day, whom she bore, uniting in love with Erebus. And Gaia first bore starry Ouranos (Sky), equal to herself, to cover her completely, and to be a secure seat forever for the immortal gods. And she bore the long mountains, the lovely haunts of the graceful Nymphs, who live in the mountain glens. And she brought forth the everlasting Pontus (the Deep), with its furious waves, without the sweetness of love. And then bedding down with Ouranos, she brought forth deep-eddying Oceanos, and Coeus and Crius and Hyperion and Iapetus, and Theia and Rhea and Themis and Mnemosyne and golden-crowned Phoebe and lovely Tethys, and after them, last-born, was the wily Cronus, the most terrible of children. And he hated his fertile father. And then she bore the proud-hearted Cyclopes, Brontes and Steropes and strongspirited Arges, who gave Zeus thunder and crafted the lightning bolt. Another three children were born to Gaia and Ouranos, huge and mighty, unspeakable, Cottus and Briareus and Gyges, overbearing children. One hundred hands sprang from their shoulders, unimaginable, fifty heads grew on their shoulders, and their power and strength were boundless, as befitted their great form. These were . . . Source 2 - the Creation Ovid, Metamorphoses, Book 1, 5-9, 20-23, 32-37, 43-44, 69-83 Before the sea and the lands existed, and the sky which covers everything, the face of Nature lacked any definite feature throughout its entirety. People have called this ‘Chaos’, a raw and unorganised mass, nothing except unworked bulk, the conflicting seeds of the elements not properly joined, heaped together in the same place. A god, in other words, a better Nature, settled this dispute. He separated the lands from the sky, and the water from the land, and also parted the clear heavens from the thick lower atmosphere . . . Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 9 When the god - whichever one of them it was - had divided the mass in this way and organised into its separate parts, he firstly moulded the land into the shape of a huge ball, so as to be perfectly balanced. Then he ordered the seas to spread themselves out, and to swell up under the rushing winds, and to surround the shores of the encircled earth. He ordered the rolling countryside to stretch out, valleys to sink down, woods to be covered in foliage and the stony mountains to rise. He had hardly fenced off everything within strict limits when the stars, which had for long lain hidden under the mass, began to blaze out throughout the heavens. To prevent any region being deprived of its own lifeforms, the heavenly ground was occupied by stars and divine forms, the waters became home to shining fish, the earth held the wild beasts and the restless air received the birds. Up to this point there was still no nobler living thing, nothing capable of deep thought, which could rule over the rest. Then Man was born. Either that great Craftsman, the source of the improved universe, made him from divine seed, or the newly formed earth, recently separated from the heavenly aether, retained the seeds of its heavenly relation, and Prometheus mixed this with rainwater and moulded it into the likeness of the all-controlling gods. Source 3 - Typhoeus Hesiod, Theogony, lines 820-35, 847-60, 867-70 When Zeus drove the Titans from the sky, huge Earth gave birth to her last-born child, Typhoeus, from the lover of Tartarus, through golden Aphrodite. The powerful god’s hands were strong and well able to fulfil his tasks and his feet were untiring. From his shoulders grew one hundred snaky heads, those of a terrible serpent, with dusky, licking tongues. Fire flashed from the hooded eyes in these awesome heads. There were voices which issued from all those dreadful heads, which emitted all manner of sounds, quite undescribable. Sometimes they produced sounds which the gods could understand, but at other times the bellow of a bull, proud and untamed, or the roar of a lion, which has no pity in its heart. Or it would be the sound of a pack of dogs, or a hissing which echoed through the high mountains. (Zeus realised what was happening and thundered). The whole earth quivered, and the sea and sky too. Under the immortals’ attack, rolling waves seethed round and about the shorelines and there were tremours which could not be stopped. Hades, Lord of the Dead, below, trembled at the dreadful noise of the conflict, and so too did the Titans, Cronus and his fellows, who are underneath Tartarus. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 10 Zeus’ anger had now reached its peak. He seized his weapons, the thunder and lightning and the glowing thunderbolt. He leapt from Olympus and struck. He scorched all the unspeakable heads of the dread monster and when he had lashed him and defeated him with his blows, he flung him down wounded and the broad earth groaned. Flames from the thunder-blasted lord poured from the dark, rocky crevices of the mountain where he was hit … The earth melted and Zeus, with heartfelt anger, threw him into Tartarus. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 11 QUESTIONS Use Sources 1 and 3 (Hesiod) and 2 (Ovid) Intermediate 1 1. According to Hesiod, which two regions are said to be the home of the gods? 2. What name is usually given to the twelve children of Gaia and Ouranos? 3. What gift did the Cyclopes give to Zeus? 4. In what way does Hesiod suggest that Cottus and his brothers were monsters? 5. Which son of Ouranos was the most dangerous? 6. Who was Gaia’s last born son? 7. What did Zeus possess which helped him to defeat this monster? 8. How does Ovid explain the creation of the earth and the sky? 9. Ovid mentions two different ways in which humans may have been formed. What were these two ways? Intermediate 2 1. Is there any difference between Chaos, as described by Hesiod, and Chaos, as described by Ovid? 2. Do both writers believe that there was a divine plan working to create the world? 3. Why is Love such an important force in Hesiod’s account? 4. How are details in Hesiod’s description intended to portray the creature as a terrifying enemy for Zeus? 5. How does Ovid explain the appearance of the stars? 6. What are the main differences in Hesiod’s and Ovid’s account of the Creation? Research Try to find out: 1. what Cronus did to his father, and why. 2. whether Hesiod’s or Ovid’s account of the Creation is closer to the story in the Bible. 3. when and where Hesiod and Ovid lived. 4. which creatures appeared after Cronus attacked and mutilated his father. 5. how Greek artists usually portrayed Eros. 6. how some other cultures have explained the appearance of human beings on earth. 7. the latest scientific theories about the creation of the universe. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 12 Source 4 - Pandora Hesiod, Works and Days, lines 42-44, 47-68, 80-98 The gods kept hidden from mankind the means of making a living, or else you could do enough work in a single day to allow you a full year’s leisure . . . Zeus in his anger hid it, because crafty Prometheus tricked him, and for that reason he planned bitter sorrows for men. And he hid fire, but the good son of Iapetus stole it again for men from Zeus the Counsellor, in a hollow fennel stalk, deceiving Zeus the Thunderer. Greatly angered, Zeus the Cloud-Gatherer said to him: ‘Son of Iapetus, you know more tricks than anyone, and you are pleased that you have stolen fire and outsmarted me, but this will be disastrous for you personally, and for future generations of men. For, in return for stealing fire, I shall give them an evil thing, which they will enjoy to their hearts’ content while embracing their own destruction.’ So he spoke and the father of gods and men laughed. He ordered the famous Hephaestus to mix earth with water as quickly as possible, and to give it human strength and voice, creating the beautiful form of a maiden, as lovely as the immortal goddesses. He ordered Athene to teach her the skill of weaving, and golden Aphrodite to pour grace upon her head, and yearning which brings pain, and the cares which exhaust the limbs. He ordered Hermes to plant within her a doglike mind and a deceitful nature. He called this woman Pandora (All-Gift), because all those who dwell on Olympus gave her as a gift, a plague to men who eat bread. And when he had accomplished this irresistible trap, this act of sheer treachery, the Father sent Hermes, swift messenger of the gods, to Epimetheus, bringing her as a gift. Epimetheus took no thought that Prometheus had told him never to accept a gift from Olympian Zeus, but to send it back in case it was something evil for mortals. Instead he accepted it, and when he possessed the evil thing, he understood. Before this happened, the tribes of men lived on earth free from evil and hard work and harmful diseases … But the woman with her own hands drew aside the great lid of the jar and scattered them, bringing bitter sorrows to men. Only Hope remained there, in an unbreakable home, under the lip of the jar, and did not fly out the door. Source 5 - The Punishment of Prometheus Hesiod, Theogony, lines 507-534 Iapetus married a maiden daughter of Oceanos, the exquisite Clymene. She bore him a child, stout-hearted Atlas. She bore also the famous Menoitius, clever Prometheus with his nimble wits, and foolish Epimetheus, who was a disaster for mortal men, right from the start. For it was he who first accepted a woman, Zeus’ creation. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 13 Far-seeing Zeus struck down the arrogant Menoitius with his smoky thunderbolt, sending him down to Erebus because of his recklessness and overbearing pride. At the edge of the world, in front of the clear-voiced Hesperides, Atlas was forced to carry the broad sky on his shoulders, with hands which never tire. This is the fate which Zeus in his wisdom has allotted to him. As for Prometheus with his clever ideas, Zeus bound him with cruel chains, fetters impossible to break, and drove a pillar midway through his body. He set upon him a long-winged eagle. It devoured his immortal liver, and all that the bird had eaten during the day was replaced at night. The brave son of beautiful Alcimene, Heracles, killed it, rescuing the son of Iapetus from this cruel affliction, freeing him from his pains. He did this with full permission of Olympian Zeus who rules on high, so that on earth the glory of Heracles the Theban-born, might be even greater than before. Zeus did this out of respect for his famous son, and although he was angry, he suppressed the rage he had felt before, because Prometheus had matched his wits against the almighty son of Cronus. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 14 QUESTIONS Use Sources 4 and 5 (Hesiod) Intermediate 1 1. Explain why Epimetheus is described by Hesiod as ‘foolish’. 2. The three other sons of Iapetus and Clymene were punished by Zeus. Who were they and what happened to each of them? 3. Why did Zeus punish Prometheus? 4. Why was Heracles allowed to free Prometheus? 5. Explain what was inside Pandora’s jar. Intermediate 2 1. If Prometheus tricked Zeus, why did the god punish men instead of Prometheus? 2. Do you think Hesiod is being fair to Pandora in the way he tells his story? Explain your opinion. 3. Can you discover any similarities between the Greek story of Pandora and the story of Adam and Eve told in the Bible (Genesis, Chapters 2 and 3)? 4. What happens to Hope in Hesiod’s story? Would the story have had a better ending if Hope had managed to escape as well? Research Try to find out: 1. why Zeus took fire away from men in the first place. 2. how other mythologies explain the creation of man and woman. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 15 Source 6 - The Ages of the World People still often say that things were better in the past. This belief is sometimes found in mythology. The ancient Greeks and Romans looked back to the days when it was not necessary for people to work: in the Golden Age everything was beautiful. Ovid, Metamorphoses, Book 1, lines 89-102, 113-143, 143-150 First to be created was the Age of Gold, which kept good faith and did what was right of its own accord, without the need for law or compulsion. There was no fear of punishment, no threatening words fixed on bronze plaques and no cowering mass of people, terrified of the expression on the judge’s face. Everyone was safe without a judge. The pine tree had not yet made its way down from its home in the mountains to the ocean, so that it might visit foreign parts. People knew no shores other than their own. Deep ditches did not yet surround towns. There were no military horns or trumpets, no helmets or swords. Folk led an easy life, free from worry, without resort to warfare. The earth herself, unworked, untouched by the hoe, unwounded by the plough, gave everything of her own free will . . . Spring was eternal. After Saturn had been sent to gloomy Tartarus and the world was under the rule of Jupiter, the race of silver arrived, worse than gold, but worth more than gleaming bronze. Jupiter shortened the period of the old-time spring and reorganised the year into four seasons, by means of winters, summers, variable autumns and a short spring. Then for the first time people sheltered in houses; their homes were caves, dense woodland and branches tied together with bark. Then for the first time the seeds of Ceres were buried in long furrows and labouring oxen groaned under the yoke. A third race - of Bronze - succeeded that one, more savage by nature, and quicker to horrid warfare, but nevertheless not wicked. The last race is made of hard iron. At once every evil burst forth into this age of baser material. Shame and truth and good faith fled. In their place came treachery, deceit and lies, along with violence and a wicked love of gain. They spread their sails to the winds, which up till then the sailor knew very little about, and the ships’ hulls, which had previously stood in the high mountains, now danced over unknown waters. The surveyor now carefully marked out with a long boundary line the ground which had previously been common property, like the sunlight or the breezes. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 16 Not only was the rich soil invoiced for the crops and the nourishment it owed, but also journeys were made into the bowels of the earth, and the riches which she had carefully hidden away in the Stygian shadows were dug out - incentives to wickedness. Now harmful iron appeared, and gold, which is more harmful than iron. War, which fights using both, came along, shaking clattering weapons in a bloodstained hand … Decency lay overwhelmed and young Astraea, the Goddess of Justice, was the last of the heavenly ones to abandon the earth. Source 7 - After the Flood In Metamorphoses, Book 1, Ovid describes how mankind had grown so wicked that Jupiter decided to destroy all human life by flooding the earth. Two people only were allowed to survive, because they were righteous; the son of Prometheus, Deucalion, and the daughter of Epimetheus, Pyrrha. They rode out the storms in a boat, and when the waters subsided, they consulted the oracle at Delphi. Ovid, Metamorphoses, Book 1, lines 381-415 (abridged) The goddess replied ‘Go down from the temple, veil your heads and loosen your knotted garments. Throw the bones of your mother behind you.’ Then the son of Prometheus soothed Epimetheus’ daughter with gentle words ‘. . . our great parent is the Earth. I think that the stones in the body of the earth are being described as her bones. It is these we are ordered to throw behind our backs . . .’ They went down. They veiled their heads and loosened their tunics. As ordered, they threw the stones behind their own footprints. The rocks began to loosen their hardness and stiffness. (Who would believe it, if the story were not a time-honoured tradition?) After a while the stones became soft , and once softened, to take on … a sort of human shape, not distinct, but like marble statues in the first stage of carving which have not been properly rounded off. The crude part of them that was damp and moist and earthy was changed, to serve as flesh. What was solid and unbending was changed into bone. What had recently been a ‘vein’ in the rock remained under the same name. In a short space of time, by the power of the gods, the rocks launched by the man’s hands took on the appearance of men, and woman was made from those thrown by the woman. For that reason we are a hard race, familiar with hardship, and we give proof of our origin. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 17 QUESTIONS Use Sources 6 and 7 (Ovid, Metamorphoses, Book 1) Intermediate 1 1. Which god ruled the earth during the Age of Gold? Who replaced him? What are the Greek equivalent names of these two gods? 2. During which Age did the seasons appear? What was the situation before they arrived? 3. Why was there no need of agriculture during the Age of Gold? 4. After the Flood, why was Pyrrha upset at first by the Oracle’s words and needed to be soothed by Deucalion? Intermediate 2 1. Why were there no laws or judges in the Age of Gold? 2. Why does Ovid regard the arrival of sea-faring as an evil thing, suitable for the Age of Iron? 3. Explain why iron is ‘harmful’ and gold is ‘more harmful than iron’. 4. If Ovid does not believe that the human race was created from rocks, or expect the reader to believer it, why do you think he tells the story? 5. Suggest a suitable name for the Age we live in today. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 18 THE UNDERWORLD The mythological Underworld is a picturesque place, which poets often described in detail. It is a matter of doubt as to how many people actually believed in the existence of such a place. Hades’ kingdom (described as the ‘House of Hades’, or simply ‘Hades’) was thought to be under the earth, and access was gained through tunnels. One such entrance was at Taenarum, in the south Peloponnese, where a cave entrance can still be seen. The Romans pointed to Lake Avernus, beside the Bay of Naples. There were other entrances. The Underworld was circled by the River Styx (‘Hatred’), but there was a complicated system of additional rivers, which fed the Styx. These rivers had rather grim names: the Acheron, the Coctys (‘Weeping and Wailing’), the Lethe (‘Forgetfulness’) and the Pyriphlegethon (‘Burning Fire’). In the 5th century BC we first hear of Charon, the ferryman, and coins are found in some burials, apparently the fee for crossing the Styx. For Charon, see especially Sources 3 and 6b and 6c. The guardian dog, Cerberus, is well-known today, but in ancient mythology he appeared mainly in the story of Heracles’ last labour, when the hero was ordered to steal the dog from the Underworld. Cerberus is normally shown as three-headed today, but he often appeared with only two heads on Athenian vases, and Hesiod mentions fifty. Cerberus was often portrayed with manes of snakes sprouting from his necks, and a snaky tail. For Cerberus, see Source 6c. Cerberus Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 19 The geography of the Underworld is rather vague. We hear of the Islands of the Blessed, and Elysium, a pleasant suburb, where the sun shone and the climate was pleasant. In the ‘Odyssey’ (Book 4) the hero Menelaus is told that the gods will send him there because he is Zeus’ son-in-law, but in Book 11 we see his brother Agamemnon and other heroes in the normal Underworld. Virgil puts Roman heroes in Elysium. Normally, however, the Underworld is described as an unpleasant, mouldy place, where the feeble ghosts of the dead lead a shadowy existence, fluttering and squeaking like bats in a cave. Tartarus, on the other hand, the place for punishment, was far below the Underworld. Virgil imagines it as a fortress, protected by high walls and a moat of fire, guarded by the Furies and other monsters (see Source 6d). There are various names used for the Underworld: Erebus (‘Darkness’), Orcus and Dis appear, and ‘Pluto’ is used to mean the god Hades. Hades himself was an unattractive character, who hid away from the daylight. He once appeared on the surface, to steal the goddess Persephone, or Kore ( the ‘Maiden’), whom he wished to marry. This was said to have happened on the island of Sicily, at a place called Henna. Persephone’s mother, the goddess Demeter, was heartbroken, and wandered the earth in search of her daughter. The crops failed, and eventually Persephone was restored to her, but only for part of the year, because she had eaten pomegranate seeds in Hades’ house. At first there was little belief in punishment after death. The only ones to suffer in Hades were a small group of ‘super-villains’ who had offended the gods. The names often mentioned are Tantalus, Sisyphus, Ixion, Tityus and the daughters of Danaus. These characters suffered their own personal torments. The so-called ‘Judges of the Dead’ (Minos, Aeacus and Rhadamanthys) continued to settle disputes in Hades much as they had done in life. The ordinary dead wandered through the asphodel fields, suffering little more than boredom and a longing for the life they had lost. However, the idea of punishment for major crimes on earth gained ground (see Sources 2, 3 and 6d). Plato developed the idea of punishment, using the familiar images of the Underworld (see Source 5). Because the Underworld was an actual place, it was possible for the living to visit. Few people, however, succeeded, even in legend, and some of those found the way back even more difficult. Orpheus tried unsuccessfully to recover his dead wife, Eurydice (Source 7), and Theseus and his friend Peirithous were tricked by Hades. Helped by Theseus, Peirithous had attempted to steal Persephone, but Hades persuaded them to sit on special chairs, which trapped them. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 20 Heracles and Theseus Later, Heracles, on his mission to fetch Cerberus, freed Theseus, but Peirithous stayed in the Underworld. Heracles, then, was the only hero in Greek mythology to succeed in his visit to the Underworld. His capture of Cerberus may suggest a victory over death itself, and some legends describe his adoption by the gods on Mount Olympus. Another legend describes how he wrestled with Death in order to save his friend Admetus’ wife, Alcestis, who had recently died. In Roman literature, Virgil imitates Homer’s account of Odysseus’ visit to the Land of the Dead. The hero Aeneas visits the Underworld to seek advice from his dead father, Anchises (see Source 6). Odysseus in the Land of the Dead Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 21 However, some individuals clearly believed none of this. A Roman inscription on a tombstone states explicitly: ‘There is no ferry-boat in Hades, no ferryman Charon, no caretaker Aeacus, no dog Cerberus. We who are dead have become nothing more than bones and ashes.’ The poet Juvenal said that not even a child believed in the black frogs of the Stygian river, and thousands of souls crammed into a single boat. The philosopher poet Lucretius produced his own explanation of the sinners’ punishments in Hades (see Source 5). However, the powerful imagery of the traditional Underworld could still be used to great effect by a poet such as Virgil. Perhaps then, as now, many ordinary people approached death with the vague suspicion that some sort of journey to another place awaited them. Certainly many were initiated into the Mysteries of Eleusis in the hope of gaining a reward in the next world, and there was a widespread belief in the existence of ghosts. Elaborate funeral customs and regular Festivals of the Dead also point to a belief in some sort of afterlife. Only a small percentage of burials contain a coin for Charon. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 22 Source 1 - Circe’s instructions to Odysseus Homer’s epic poem, the Odyssey, which describes the adventures of Odysseus after Troy, may have been composed some time in the 7th century BC. It is therefore one of the earliest Greek poems we possess. In Book 11, Homer describes a journey to the Underworld. It is worthwhile reading the whole of Book 11: here is a translation of the instructions given to Odysseus by the witch Circe at the end of Book 10. Homer, Odyssey 10, lines 501-530. (Odysseus asked Circe) ‘Who will guide me on my way? Nobody has gone to Hades before in a black ship.’ So he spoke, and the goddess answered ‘Godlike son of Laertes, quick-witted Odysseus, don’t let the lack of a guide keep you from setting sail. Set up the mast and stretch out the white sails, then sit back. The breath of the North wind will carry the ship. Whenever you pass over the Ocean in your ship you will find there is a rugged coast and the groves of Persephone, with tall poplar trees, and willows which shed their fruit. Beach your ship beside the deep-swirling Ocean and make your way to the mouldy House of Hades.’ ‘There the Pyriphlegethon (Burning Fire) and Cocytus flow into the Acheron, which is an offshoot of the water of Styx. A rock marks the meeting of the two roaring rivers. Once you reach there, my hero, draw near, as I order you, and dig a pit a cubit long, this way and that, and around it pour an offering to all the dead. First, honey mixed with milk, then sweet wine, then thirdly water. Then scatter wine barley and pray to the empty shells of the dead, promising that, once you reach Ithaca, you will sacrifice a heifer that has not calved, the best you possess, and you will heap treasures upon the pyre. To Teiresias alone you will sacrifice a sheep, totally black, the most outstanding among your flocks. Once you have appeased the famed tribes of the dead by your prayers, then kill a ram and black ewe, turning them towards Erebus, while turning away yourself, as if longing for the waters of the river. Then the souls of the dead will come, and they will be many.’ A visit to the land of the dead Based on Homer, ‘Odyssey’, Book 11 Scene: A gloomy stretch of beach, under a dark, cloudy sky. Odysseus and his crew have just landed. They leave the ship and stand on the shore, looking around. Sailor I don’t like this place, Odysseus. Odysseus I don’t either, but I have my orders. I must visit the mouldy House of Hades and speak with the ghost of the prophet Teiresias. He will give me the advice I needed to get home again safely. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 23 Sailor This is a weird place: those strange trees and cliffs frighten me. Odysseus We are at the world’s end here. We have crossed the River of Ocean. But cheer up. It could be worse: some people have to live here all the time. Sailor You mean that this place is actually inhabited? Odysseus Yes. They are called the Cimmerians. They live wrapped in mist and fog, and they never see the sun. Sailor Poor folk. But tell me, Odysseus, how can you talk to the prophet Teiresias, if, as you say, he is dead and in the House of Hades? Odysseus I have my instructions. A rock marks the place where the Rivers of the Underworld meet, and there we shall sacrifice the sheep we have brought with us. The ghost of Teiresias will smell the blood. Sailor But, Odysseus … Odysseus What’s wrong? Sailor How can you be sure that the right ghost will appear? What if … something else comes? Odysseus That’s a risk we have to take. Come on, we’ve arrived at the right spot. Perimedes and Eurylochus, hold on to the victims, while I dig a trench in the earth. Odysseus dug a shallow trench, the length and breadth of a man’s forearm. Into the hole he poured offerings: milk and honey, sweet wine and, finally, water. Then he sprinkled white barley and said a prayer to the souls of the dead, promising further offerings on his return to Ithaca. Finally he killed the sheep, letting their blood soak into the earth. Sailor Look! Something is happening! Mist - or steam - rising from the ground. Odysseus The ghosts of the dead! Sailor There must be hundreds of them, Odysseus. And they are unhappy: they are crying. Odysseus They are hungry, my friend. Look, there are young girls, newly married, and boys who never reached manhood. There are old men who have suffered so much, and warriors, killed in battle, with their wounds gaping open and their armour blood-stained. They are empty and hollow, and so hungry. Skin the sheep and burn them quickly, men, and I shall frighten the ghosts off until Teiresias arrives. Sailor I recognise that ghost! Why, it’s Elpenor, my friend. But he’s not even buried yet. What’s he doing here? Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 24 Elpenor My lord Odysseus! Some unfriendly god, and the wine I drank, caused my death. I was sleeping on the roof of Circe’s palace, and when I awoke I forgot to use the ladder and came down the quick way! I broke my neck and my ghost came here, to Hades. Odysseus How can I help you, Elpenor? Elpenor When you return to Circe’s palace, please give me a proper funeral. Burn my body, together with the weapons I used to carry, and raise a mound for me on the beach. Mark the spot with the oar I used to pull when I was alive, and sitting on the rowing benches with my friends. Odysseus It shall be done, poor Elpenor. I shall not forget. Odysseus then spotted the ghost of Anticleia, his mother. She had still been alive when he had sailed to Troy, all those years before, and he was very upset when he saw her. However, he would not allow her to come near until he had spoken to Teiresias, who now came up to him, carrying a golden sceptre. Teiresias What has brought you to this terrible place, Odysseus? Step back and let me taste the blood. Then I may tell you about your future. Odysseus sheathed his sword and Teiresias drank the dark blood. Then he spoke. Teiresias Many troubles lie in front of you, my lord Odysseus. The gods will make your journey hard. Poseidon hates you, because you blinded his son. Odysseus Shall I get home safely? Teiresias Only if you control yourself and your men. One day you will reach the Island of the Sungod, where his cattle and fat sheep graze. If you do not touch them, you will all reach Ithaca safely - eventually. But if you hurt them, you will lose your ship and your crew. You will reach home late, in misery, on someone else’s ship. And you will find trouble in your house. Odysseus What sort of trouble? Teiresias Ruffians who want to marry your wife. They will be eating your food and drinking your wine. You will have to kill then, but it will not be easy. Odysseus Shall I find peace then? Teiresias Not even then. You will set out on your travels again. Your journey will last until you come to a land where the sea is totally unknown. The people there will not use salt to flavour their food. You will be carrying an oar, and when a traveller meets you who does not know what it is used for, then you will know that your journey is over. Sacrifice to Lord Poseidon and go home. You will die far from the sea, and your death will be peaceful. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 25 Odysseus Thank you, Teiresias. Now tell me this: I see the ghost of my dear mother over there, but she does not seem to recognise me. How can I persuade her to talk to me? Teiresias Let her taste the blood. Then she will talk. Teiresias’ ghost melted back into the shadows. Odysseus allowed his mother’s ghost to drink the blood. She recognised him immediately. Anticleia My dear son, how did you come to these parts? This is no place for a living man to visit. Have you come straight from Troy? Have you been to Ithaca? Odysseus Mother, I haven’t been home since we sacked the mighty city of Troy. I had to come here to consult the prophet Teiresias. Now, tell me what happened to you. How did you die? Was it a slow death, or quick and painless? What about my father and the son I left behind? And my wife, Penelope, is she well? Is she looking after my kingdom, or has she married again? Anticleia Penelope is still waiting patiently for you to return, although she is very upset and is constantly in tears. Your son is looking after your kingdom for you. However, your father has left the palace and lives in the country with the farm labourers. He goes around in rags and sleeps on the hard ground. He misses his son, Odysseus. That was my problem too, son. It was my heartache for you that brought my life to an end. Odysseus Mother, don’t go! Why can’t I hug you? You slip through my arms, like a shadow! Anticleia My dear son, what did you expect? When we die our physical bodies are burned away and the soul slips away like a dream. Farewell. After recognising and questioning the ghosts of many famous women, Odysseus came face to face with the soul of Agamemnon, the King of Mycenae, who had been murdered on his return home. Odysseus What has happened to you, my lord Agamemnon? Did Poseidon wreck your ship on the way home from Troy? Or were you killed on a raiding party? Agamemnon Oh, Odysseus, it was neither of these. I was murdered at dinner, like an ox in a stable, killed by my own wife, Clytemnestra, and her lover. You would have wept if you had seen us, lying there, beside the winebowl and the laden tables, while the floor swam with blood! Odysseus Poor man! Zeus has been cruel to your family. Look at the trouble your brother had with Helen. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 26 Agamemnon Yes, never trust a woman, Odysseus. Never tell your wife everything: always keep something back. Of course, I’m not suggesting that Penelope will murder you! She’s much too sensible for that. Now, can you tell me anything about my son, Orestes? He must still be alive, for his soul has not yet come here, to Hades. Odysseus I’m sorry, Agamemnon, I’ve no idea whether he is alive or dead. Then the ghost of Achilles appeared, with other Greek warriors who had died at Troy. Achilles What will you think of next, Odysseus? How did you dare to come here, where the dead exist without their wits, as ghosts? Odysseus I came to ask Teiresias about how I might reach Ithaca, my home. But how I envy you, Achilles! When you were alive we honoured you as if you were a god, and now you are dead, you are a prince here! Achilles Don’t praise death in front of me, Odysseus! I would rather be the poorest man alive, pushing a plough on someone else’s farm than be the king of all these dead men. But tell me about my son. Did he follow me to Troy? And what of my old father, is he still held in honour, or do people insult him, now that I am no longer there to protect him? Odysseus I have heard nothing about your father, but I can tell you about your dear son Neoptolemus. He followed in your footsteps, and came to Troy, where he fought well. He was in the Horse, when we tricked the Trojans. He could hardly contain himself, he was so keen to attack the Trojans. And after we attacked the city, he sailed home safe and sound, without a single word. Achilles Thank you, Odysseus. I am a little happier now. Odysseus Why does Ajax stand back? The other souls all want to ask me questions. Achilles He cannot forgive you for defeating him in the contest for my armour. Odysseus So not even death could make you forget your anger with me on account of that armour, Ajax! It was the gods’ fault, not mine. We all missed you, after you died. Talk to me, Ajax! Achilles It’s no good, Odysseus. He has turned away. Odysseus did not pursue him. Instead, he saw other souls: King Minos, still dispensing justice in Hades; Tityus, tortured by vultures; Tantalus, unable to reach the water and fruit he craved; and Sisyphus, pushing his rock. He talked to Heracles’ fierce ghost, who complained about the tasks he had been forced to perform on earth. Heracles remembered his success in capturing Cerberus, the Hound of Hell. Odysseus might have stayed longer, in the hope of seeing other heroes, but then it seemed that tens of thousands of ghosts were suddenly streaming up from the Halls of Hades. Odysseus was terrified that some monster might appear, and beat a hasty retreat back to his ship. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 27 QUESTIONS Use Source 1 (Homer) and EITHER Homer, ‘Odyssey’, Book 11 OR the play ‘A Visit to the Land of the Dead’. Intermediate 1 1. Where is the Land of the Dead situated? 2. Why does Odysseus want to talk to the ghost of Teiresias? 3. What attracts the ghosts away from their usual place of rest? 4. In what way is Elpenor’s ghost different from the others? 5. List the items of information given to Odysseus by Teiresias. 6. Why does Agamemnon feel bitter about women? 7. a) Why does Odysseus assume that Achilles, at least, will be happy in Hades? b) What is Achilles reaction to this assumption? 8. In what way does the behaviour of Ajax’ ghost differ from the others? Intermediate 2 1. Discuss the ways in which Homer’s description of the Land of the Dead differs from the more usual mythological descriptions. 2. Why does Homer include so many different ghosts in his story? 3. What impression of existence after death is given by this adventure? 4. What emotions do you think Odysseus would feel after his visit to the Land of the Dead? Research a) Read Source 2 (Pausanias). List the details in Polygnotus’ painting which agree with Homer’s description, and those which do not. b) Read the beginning of Homer, ‘Odyssey’, Book 24. Can you suggest why the description of the Suitors’ arrival in the Underworld has puzzled many critics? Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 28 Source 2 - Polygnotus’ painting of Odysseus’ descent into Hades Polygnotus was a famous Greek painter who lived in the 5th century BC. At Delphi he decorated the walls of a club-house, built by the people of Cnidus on the south west coast of Asia Minor (Turkey), with large wall paintings, one of which portrayed the Underworld. The painting is completely gone; there are no copies. However, Pausanias, a traveller in the 2nd century AD, saw it at Delphi and described it. The following are extracts from his description: Pausanias, Book 10, Chapters 28-31 (abridged) The water takes on the appearance of a river, clearly the Acheron, and there are reeds growing in it, and the forms of fish, but so faint that you would think they were shadows of fish rather than the real thing. There is a ship on the river and the ferryman at the oars. As for the ghosts carried on the boat, it is not clear who they are supposed to be. On the bank of the Acheron under Charon’s boat is a son who was unjust to his father being strangled by the father. Near this man is another man who stole holy things being punished. The woman who is punishing him is well versed in poisons and other things which damage people. Above those I have mentioned is Eurynomos. The priests at Delphi say that Eurynomos is one of the demons of Hades - and that he eats the flesh of corpses, leaving the bare bones. Neither the ‘Odyssey’ nor the ‘Minyas’ nor the ‘Returns’ knows of any demon called Eurynomos (and in all of these poems there is a description of Hades and the horrors there). I will describe him: his colour is between dark blue and black, like the blow-flies that settle on meat; he is showing his teeth, and he sits on the outspread skin of a vulture. Above the things I have described are Odysseus’ companions, Perimedes and Eurylochos, carrying sacrificial victims. These are black rams. Beside them sits a man and the inscription reveals that the man is Ocnos. He is shown plaiting a rope, and a female ass stands by him chewing away at the rope he has plaited. They say that Ocnos was a hard-working man, but he had a free-spending wife. Everything he saved by his hard work was soon spent by her. Tityos too is included in the painting, no longer being punished, but so worn out by his continuous punishment that he seems to be shadowy, and not even a complete ghost. . . . he has painted Elpenor and Odysseus, crouching down and holding his sword over the pit. The prophet Teiresias is approaching the pit. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 29 Odysseus’ mother, Anticleia, is standing on a rock beside Teiresias. Elpenor is wrapped in a garment of plaited reeds, the usual dress of sailors. Below Odysseus, siting on chairs, are Theseus and Peirithous. Theseus is holding Peirithous’ sword and his own in his hands, and Peirithous is looking at the swords. You might guess that he is annoyed with the swords, because they are useless for the daring deed he had in mind. Finally, Pausanias describes the figure from the Trojan War included in the picture: Agamemnon is next to Antilochos, supported by a sceptre under his left armpit and holding a staff in his hands. Protesilaos sits looking at Achilles. Patroclos is standing above Achilles. All are smooth faced, except Agamemnon. . . . Actaeon, the son of Aristaeos, is there, and his mother, holding a fawn in her hands and sitting on a deerskin. A hunting dog lies beside them, a reference to the way that Actaeon’s life changed at the end. If you lower your eyes to the lower section of the painting, you would see Orpheus sitting behind Patroclos on a sort of hill. He holds his lyre in his left hand, while with his right he touches the leaves of a willow tree. He is leaning against the tree. It seems to be the grove of Persephone where, according to Homer, black poplars and willows grow. . . . You would also see the famous Ajax, Palamedes and Thersites playing dice (Palamedes invented the game). The other Ajax looks on, his skin encrusted with seasalt, with the complexion of a shipwrecked sailor. Polygnotus seems to have taken pains to put all Odysseus’ enemies together. At the foot of the painting he has Hector, holding his left knee in both hands with a quite heartbroken appearance. Beside him is Memnon, sitting on a rock, and Sarpedon, covering his face with both hands. One of Memnon’s hands rests on Sarpedon’s shoulders … above them is Paris, still a beardless youth, clapping his hands like some country bumpkin. Penthesileia is giving Paris a disapproving stare . . . There is also a storage jar in the painting, and an old man, a boy and two women, one young, on a rock, and an old woman standing beside the old man. The others are carrying water, but you would guess that the old woman’s urn has broken. She is pouring what water there is left in the broken vessel back into the storage jar. It seems to me that these are those who have insulted the Mysteries of Eleusis. Below this pot is Tantalus, suffering all those things that Homer has attributed to him, but in addition the terror inspired by the overhanging rock. Source 3 - The god Dionysus visits the Underworld The plot of Aristophanes’ comedy ‘The Frogs’, produced in 405 BC, imagines the god Dionysus making a journey down to Hades to fetch back one of the famous dramatists Aeschylus and Euripides, so that he might give advice to the city of Athens, at the time doing very badly in a war with the Spartans. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 30 The following extract features Dionysus, who is accompanied by his slave, Xanthias, asking advice from Heracles, who, of course, has a lot of experience in this form of foreign travel. Aristophanes, The Frogs, lines 115-140, 143-150, 154-178 Heracles My dear fellow, don’t tell me you’ve got the urge to go down there too? Dionysus Don’t go on about it any more. Just give me some travel information: what route will take me to Hades quickest? And don’t give me one that’s too hot or too cold. Heracles Well now, what one should I mention to you first, I wonder? There’s the Rope and Bench methods - by hanging yourself! Dionysus Stop it. You’re making me all choked up! Heracles OK. There is a short cut you could take: it’s a well-trodden way, or rather, more ‘ground up’ in a mortar. Dionysus You mean a dose of hemlock? Heracles Exactly. Dionysus That would be a bitter pill to swallow! I’ve got cold feet already! Heracles Shall I tell you a way that’s quick and downhill? Dionysus Please do, for I’m not much of a hill-walker. Heracles Stroll on down to the Kerameikos. Dionysus Then what? Heracles Once you’ve climbed up the tall tower there … Dionysus What do I do then? Heracles Wait for the start of the torch race - you’ll get a good view from up there - and when the spectators say ‘Get on with it!’, then you … get on with it. Dionysus Where? Heracles Down. Dionysus But I’d lose what’s all neatly wrapped up inside my skull. I couldn’t go along that road. Heracles What then? Dionysus The one YOU used on your journey in the past. Heracles But that’s a long voyage. First you come to a large lake - bottomless of course … Dionysus Then how am I to get across? Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 31 Heracles In a little boat - only so big. An old sailorman will take you across, once he’s got his 2 obol fare … after that you’ll see snakes and thousands of wild beasts, really terrible! Dionysus Don’t keep trying to terrify me, for you won’t put me off. Heracles Then there’s masses of filthy mud and ever-flowing shit, and lying in it anyone who’s ever wronged a guest, or had a rent-boy and didn’t pay up afterwards, or gave his mother a thrashing, or punched his father on the jaw, or committed perjury … and then the sound of pipes will surround you, and you’ll see the most beautiful daylight, just like it is up here, and groves of myrtle, and happy bands of men and women and a lot of handclapping. Dionysus And who will these be? Heracles Those who have been initiated. Xanthias And I’m the mule at the Mysteries, by Zeus. But I’m not carrying these bags any longer. Dionysus Yes, and keep well yourself. Pick up the bedding again, you. Xanthias But I’ve hardly put it down. Dionysus And be quick about it. Xanthias Please, I’m begging you, hire one of these corpses being carried out for burial, if there is one suitably qualified. Dionysus What if I don’t find one? Xanthias Then I’ll do it. Dionysus Fair enough. Here’s one now. You there, yes, I mean you, the dead one. My man, are you willing to carry these little bits of luggage to Hades? Corpse How many pieces? Dionysus These. Corpse It will cost you two drachmas. Dionysus Good god, that’s too much! Corpse (To the bearers) Let’s be on our way. Dionysus Hold on, old fellow, can’t we haggle? Corpse If you don’t put down two drachmas, there’s no point wasting your breath. Dionysus Will you take nine obols? Corpse I’d rather be alive again! Xanthias What a stuck-up swine. I hope he comes to a bad end. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 32 Source 4 - The punishment of the wicked On his deathbed, Socrates explains to his friends about the nature of the Earth, Tartarus and the rivers of the Underworld (Phaedo 108e-13c). He then discusses the fate of the newly dead: Plato, Phaedo, 113d-114c When those who have died reach the place where their ‘guardian spirit’ leads them, they are first of all divided into those who have lived honourably and devoutly and those who have not. Those who are found to have lived neither one way nor the other set out for the Acheron, and, boarding the transport which is available for them, they arrive at the Acherusian Lake, and there they stay and are purified, atoning through punishment for their wrongdoings, and equally receiving honour for their good deeds, as appropriate. Those who are judged incurable, because of the scale of their misdeeds (for example, they happen to have committed many serious acts of sacrilege, or many unjust and unlawful murders), are hurled into Tartarus by their appropriate destiny, from where they never emerge. Those who are judged to have committed crimes which, although serious, are incurable (for example, an act of violence against a father or mother because of anger followed by remorse for the rest of their lives, or manslaughter under the same circumstances) must fall into Tartarus. However, after remaining there for a year, the flow of the waters throws them out again, the manslayers down the River Cocytus and the mother and father killers down the Pyriphlegethon. And, as they are carried along and pass the Acherusian Lake, they cry out and appeal to those they have killed or done wrong to, beseeching and begging them to allow them to be restored to the Lake, and accepted. If they convince them, they come out and there is an end to their suffering. If not, they are carried again into Tartarus and from there back to the rivers, and they do not stop suffering this until they persuade those they have wronged. For this is the justice their judges have assigned to them. But those who are judged to have led outstanding holy lives are separated and freed from these regions within the earth, as if from a prison, rising up to their pure abode, and dwelling on the True Earth. Those who have purified themselves sufficiently by philosophy live forever after without bodies and reach dwelling places more beautiful than these, which are not easy to describe, nor is there sufficient time now. True Earth: In our everyday world we are prevented from perceiving the beautiful reality of things. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 33 QUESTIONS Use Source 3 (Aristophanes) Intermediate 1 & 2 1. Why has Dionysus chosen to ask the hero Heracles for advice about the road to the Underworld? 2. What is the ‘large lake’ and who is the ‘old sailorman’ whom Heracles mentions? 3. Why are some of the ghosts happy, and dancing to the sound of the pipes? 4. Do you think two drachmas was a high charge for carrying the baggage? Give a reason for your answer. Intermediate 2 1. Why does Dionysus reject Heracles’ first suggestions? 2. Select two passages which show that Aristophanes’ picture of the Underworld is not meant to be taken seriously. Explain why you have chosen them. 3. Why does the mention of hemlock give Dionysus ‘cold feet’? 4. What sort of people are being punished in this picture of the Underworld? Use Source 4 (Plato) Intermediate 1 & 2 Complete the following table: CATEGORY OF SOUL PUNISHMENT Those who were neither particularly good or bad Those who committed a crime and were sorry afterwards Those who committed sacrilege (crimes against the gods) Philosophers Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 34 Source 5 - A rationalist’s account of the sinners in Hades Lucretius, De Rerum Natura, Book 3, lines 978-986, 992-1002 The truth is that all those things which are said to exist in the depths of Acheron are all here with us during our lifetime. There is no poor Tantalus, as legend has it, terrified of the great rock hanging over him in mid-air, frozen in needless terror; rather it is the pointless fear of the gods in this life which weighs down upon immortals, and each one fears the fall which chance might bring upon him. Birds of prey are not burrowing in to Tityos as he lies in Acheron: it is quite clear that they cannot find pickings in that huge chest cavity to last them for all eternity, but Tityos is here among us, the helpless lover, and the birds which tear him are the pangs of love; anguish and uncertainty gnaw at him, shredding him, and the same could be said of any great passion you might care to mention. Sisyphus is here too in our lives, right in front of our eyes; the man who is always thirsty in seeking out political power from the people, and always retires the sad loser. For the pursuit of power (which is meaningless and never granted), and to suffer the harsh toil involved, is the same as struggling to push the rock against the barrier of the mountain, a rock which in spite of everything rolls down again from the summit, and quickly seeks out the level ground of the plain . . . Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 35 QUESTIONS Use reference books and Source 5 (Lucretius) Intermediate 1 & 2 Complete the following table: SINNERS CRIMES PUNISHMENT Tantalus Sisyphus Ixion Tityus The Danaids Intermediate 2 1. Does Lucretius believe that the sinners in the Underworld exist? 2. Lucretius describes Tantalus as ‘terrified of the great rock’. What is the more familiar punishment he is said to have suffered? 3. Explain why Lucretius believes that, in real life, some people are suffering torments similar to Tantalus, Sisyphus and Tityus. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 36 Source 6a - The Entrance to Hades The Roman poet Virgil describes how Aeneas and the Sibyl, a prophetess, made their way into the Underworld. Virgil, Aeneid, Book 6, lines 268-294 Dimly they made their way through the lonely night, through the shadows, through the empty halls of Dis, a place without substance. Think of a pathway through woodland, when Jupiter has veiled the sky with cloud and dark night has leached the colour out of everything. Right at the very entrance, in what might be called the lobby of Hell, Grief and Haunting Worries have made their beds. Here dwell pale Diseases and glum Old Age, along with Fear, Hunger that drives men to evil, and ugly Need, forms terrible to look upon, and Death and Agony. Coma, close kingsman of Death, unsavoury Pleasures of the mind, and War the death-bearer are there on the threshold, and the iron bedchambers of the Furies, and crazy Discord, her snaky hair entwined with bloody ribbons. In the middle a huge, shady elm tree stretches the branches, full of years, which are its arms. The story goes that this is the lair of false Dreams, which cling under every leaf. Besides these are monsters in abundance, wild things of many kinds; at the doors are stabled the Centaurs, and Scyllas, with their double nature, and hundred-fold Briareus and the beast of Lerna (hissing horribly), and the Chimaera, armed with fire, Gorgons, Harpies and a shadowy form, triplebodied. At their approach, Aeneas presented his drawn sword, and he would have rushed against them and struck pointlessly at shadows, had not his wise companion assured him that they were thin souls, flitting without substance, creating a false impression of form. Source 6b - The Ferry across the River Styx The Roman poet Virgil describes what Aeneas and the Sibyl see when they arrive at the River Styx. Virgil, Aeneid, Book 6, lines 295-330 From here the road leads to the waters of Acheron, the river of Tartarus. This is a torrent, seething with mud, which boils up in a vast whirlpool, spewing out all its sand into Cocytus. A truly dreadful harbour official controls the waters of these streams: the terrifying and loathsome Charon. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 37 A thick, uncared-for greyness sprawls on his chin; his eyes stare, flaming; his filthy clothing hangs, knotted, from his shoulders. He propels the boat with a long pole, and attends to the sails, conveying the dead in his mouldering hull. The god may be old, but he is vigorous in his old age, and filled with raw energy. Thither came the whole crowd, fast and streaming, men and women alike, and even great-hearted heroes, their bodies now finished with life; boys too, and girls not old enough for marriage; young men, placed on the funeral pyre in front of their parents’ eyes, as many as the leaves which fall in the woods at the first cold snap of autumn, or as many as the birds which gather together on land, coming from the deep ocean waters, when the cold season forces them to fly across the sea, sending them to warmer lands. They stood begging to be the first to cross, and they stretched out their hands in their longing for the far shore. But the surly ferryman first picked out one group, and then another, while keeping others at a far remove from the sandy shore. Aeneas was profoundly impressed, and also moved by the confusion, and said: ‘Tell me, Sibyl, what this gathering by the river is all about. What do the souls seek? On what criterion do some of them forsake the bank, while others sweep the grey waters with the oars?’ The old prophetess answered him briefly as follows: ‘You are looking at the deep pools of Cocytus and the Stygian marsh, whose power the gods themselves fear, should they break an oath sworn in its name. All these helpless crowds which you see are the unburied ones: that is Charon, the harbour-master. These, whom the water bears, are the properly buried. None may be taken across the harsh-sounding stream, from one awful bank to the other, until his bones find a resting place. They wander for a hundred years, flitting and circling these shores. Only then are they admitted and visit once again the pools that they long for.’ Source 6c - the Sibyl cross the Styx When the ferryman caught site of them from the waters of the Styx making their way through the quiet woodland and turning their steps to the bank, he shouted aggressively at them, reproaching them before they could speak: ‘Whoever you are, approaching my waters with weapons, stop in your tracks right there. I’d very much like to know why you’ve come here. This is a place for ghosts, a place of sleep and drowsy night. It is absolutely forbidden to carry living bodies on the boat of the Styx. Hercules came down here, you know, and I can tell you I wasn’t pleased to take him out of the water, nor Theseus and Peirithous, although they were the children of the gods and there was no stopping them. Hercules with his bare hands forcibly chained the guardian of Tartarus and dragged him trembling from the throne of the King himself. The other of the two tried to kidnap the Mistress from the bedchamber of Dis. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 38 (The Sibyl reassures him that Aeneas poses no threat to either Cerberus or Proserpina (Persephone). What is more, he has the magical Golden Bough, which is the key to entering the Underworld.) Charon marvelled at the fateful branch, an awe-inspiring gift which he was seeing then after so long a period of time, and, turning his dark boat, approached the bank. Then he cleared away the ghosts who were sitting on the long benches and unshipped the gangplanks, allowing Aeneas’ large frame on board the vessel. The boat of stitched skins groaned under his weight, and let in much of the swampy waters through its seams. At long last he had conveyed both hero and prophetess across the river in safety and set them down on an unlovely mudflat, amid sedge grass. Huge Cerberus filled these parts with barking from his three throats, a monster lying in the cave opposite. Now seeing the necks were bristling with serpents, the priestess threw a titbit, a sedative made with honey and drugged corn. Ravenous with hunger, he opened his triple throats and seized the offering, then his huge body relaxed, he sprawled on the ground, his massive bulk stretching the whole length of the cave. With the guard neutralised, Aeneas gained access, quickly escaping from the bank of that one-way river. Source 6d - Tartarus Aeneas suddenly looked back, and saw, under a crag to the left, massive fortifications, surrounded by a triple wall, which in turn was circled by a river of fire, an allconsuming maelstrom, Phlegethon the Hell-River, a din of whirling boulders. Opposite, a huge gateway, its pillars of solid steel, so that no human force, and not even Heavenly Ones themselves, could breach it in war. A tower of iron looms high into the air, and Tisiphone, clad in a bloodstained robe, sits there unsleeping and keeps watch over the entrance night and day. From here can be heard groaning and the sound of harsh blows, the shriek of metal, as chains are dragged. Aeneas stopped in his tracks, drinking in the terrible noise in terror. ‘What sorts of crimes are to be found there? Tell me, priestess! With what punishments are they afflicted? What is the awful noise rising to the heavens?’ Then the prophetess began to speak as follows: ‘Famous leader of the Trojans, it is strictly forbidden for anyone who is pure in heart to set foot in that corrupt threshold. However, when Hecate put me in charge of the woods of Avernus, she herself taught me about the gods’ punishments, and gave me the full tour. Rhadamanthys of Cnossus rules this oppressive kingdom. He hears and punishes acts of treachery, forcing sinners to confess their crimes. When they were in the world above they were happy to put off making amends, the fools; now death has ensured it is too late. At once Tisiphone the Avenger, armed with a scourge, leaps upon them and lashes them, threatening them with the terrible snakes in her left hand, and calling upon the savage ranks of her sisters. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 39 ‘Then finally, their hinges screeching in a way that would make you shudder, the sacred gates open. Do you see what sort of guardian is sitting in the hall behind? What sort of shape is guarding the entrance? Within, a creature more savage has its lair, vast, with its fifty dark mouths open wide, the Hydra. After that there is Tartarus itself, a gaping abyss, plunging down into the shadows twice as far as our gaze skyward towards the heavenly Olympus. ‘Here the ancient offspring of Earth, the lusty Titans, writhe in the lower depths, cast down by a thunderbolt. And here I saw the vast twin bodies of Otus and Ephialtes, the sons of Aloeus, who attacked mighty heaven, attempting to tear down with their bear hands and dislodge Jupiter from his kingdom. ‘I saw Salmoneus paying a heavy price for mimicking the fire of Jupiter which crashes out from Olympus. This fellow drove in a four-horse chariot through the communities of Greece, through the heart of Elis, waving a torch in triumph, and demanded divine honours for himself, the fool, imitating the thunderstorms and the lightning bolt (which cannot be counterfeited) with the sound of bronze and the drumming of hornyhoofed horses. But the almighty Father flung his weapon from the thick clouds, hurling him headlong in an awful tornado. And he did not use a mere torch, a pine brand with its smoky light. ‘Tityos too, the offspring of the Earth who is the mother of all, could be seen, his body stretched out over nine whole areas, a huge vulture picking with hooked beak at the immortal liver and the entrails which provide a rich crop of punishment. It has made its home deep in his body, and forages for its fine food, no respite being given to the flesh which grows back again. ‘Need I speak of the Lapiths, Ixion and Peirithous . . . over whom the dark rock hangs, seeming about to fall at any moment, and actually gives the impression that it is already falling; the golden legs of lofty banqueting couches gleam, and a feast of royal extravagance is set out in full view, but the greatest of the Furies is lying nearby, and forbids all contact with the tables. She springs up, lifting her fire-brand, and yells in a voice of thunder. ‘Here are those who hated their brothers when they were alive, or struck a father, or cheated someone who depended on them; and those who found wealth, but gloated over it in solitude, and put none aside for their heirs (that is the biggest crowd!); those killed in adultery, those who followed the path of civil war and those who were not afraid to betray their masters. All of them are imprisoned and await their punishment. Do not seek to learn what punishment they will suffer, or what kind of fortune has submerged them. Some roll a large rock, or hang spread-eagled from the spokes of wheels. Unlucky Theseus sits and will sit forever, and Phlegyas, the most wretched of all, bears witness, warning all in a loud voice: ‘Be warned and learn justice. Do not scorn the gods.’ Here is a man who sold his country for gold, placing her under the power of a dictator; this one made laws and then made new laws - all for money; another entered a daughter’s bedroom and indulged in a forbidden liaison. All of them dared to do a horrible thing, and achieved their aim. Not even if I possessed a hundred tongues, a hundred mouths and a tongue of iron could I include every form of wickedness or list the names of all the punishments.’ Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 40 Source 7 - Orpheus and Eurydice Virgil, Georgics 4, lines 464-503 Sick with the pain of love, Orpheus tried to console himself with his hollow lyre, singing to himself on the deserted short. He sang of you as the day dawned, and he sang of you as the daylight faded. He even entered the jaws of Taenarum, the high gateway of Dis, and the grove which is murky with dark fear, and approached the ghosts of the dead, and the terrifying king, hearts that do not know how to be softened by human prayers. However, the thin shades were moved by his song, and, from their homes in the lowest depths of Erebus, they came, the ghosts of those cut off from the daylight, as many as the birds that hide among the leaves in their thousands, when evening or a wintry rainstorm drives them from the mountains; mothers with their husbands; and the bodies of great-hearted heroes, now lifeless; boys and unwed girls, and young men placed on the funeral pyre in front of their parents’ eyes. Around them is black slime and the ugly marsh-reeds of Cocytus. The unlovely swamp, and the Styx, its nine streams barring their way, imprisons them. Yet the very halls of Death, to the very depths of Tartarus, were stunned, and the Furies, their hair braided with steel-blue snakes. Cerberus held his three mouths hanging open, and the wheel of Ixion came to a standstill in the wind. And now, retracing his steps, he had escaped every pitfall, and Eurydice, restored to him, was approaching the breezes of the upper world, following behind (for Persephone had imposed this condition), when a sudden madness gripped the lover and he dropped his guard; forgivable, perhaps, if the Dead only knew how to forgive! He stopped, and, as his very own Eurydice was on the verge of daylight, forgetful, alas, and with his resolution broken, he looked back at her. With that, all his effort had been wasted, and the agreement with the heartless monarch was void. Three times a crash was heard over the pools of Avernus. ‘What great madness has ruined us both, Orpheus?’ she cried. ‘Look! Once again the cruel fates call me back and sleep closes my swimming eye. Now, farewell: surrounded by a vast blackness I am carried off, stretching out my nerveless hands, to you, yours, alas, no longer.’ With these words she suddenly was whisked out of sight, like smoke, dispersed into the breeze, and lost sight of him forever, as he grasped at shadows, wishing to say much more. The ferryman of Orcus would not allow him to cross the barrier of the swamp for a second time. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 41 QUESTIONS Use Sources 6 & 7 (Virgil) Source 6a Intermediate 1 1. What does Aeneas see at the entrance to the Underworld? 2. What are clinging under the leaves of the elm tree? 3. Why was Aeneas in no real danger from the monsters? Intermediate 2 1. What sort of atmosphere does Virgil evoke in this picture of the entrance to the Underworld? 2. Do the monsters listed by Virgil share any common factors? Source 6b Intermediate 1 & 2 1. To what does Virgil compare the souls on the riverbank? 2. Which souls does Charon refuse to take on board? Intermediate 2 1. Explain why the images used by Virgil to describe the souls are particularly effective. 2. What clues to Aeneas’ character are provided by his reactions to what he sees in Sources 6a and 6b? Source 6c Intermediate 1 & 2 1. Why does Charon become worried when he sees Aeneas approaching the River Styx? 2. What persuades Charon to let Aeneas and the Sibyl come on board? 3. How does Aeneas get past Cerberus? Intermediate 2 1. Compare the picture of Charon we are given here with the description of him in Source 6b. Is he as terrifying here as the previous description might have led us to believe? Give a reason for your answer. 2. Are there any light-hearted touches in Source 6b? Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 42 Source 6d Intermediate 1 & 2 1. What aspects of Tartarus make it a very grim place? 2. List the mythological figures mentioned here in Tartarus, and find out about any of them who are unfamiliar. Intermediate 2 1. Compare this picture of Tartarus with Aristophanes’ comic description (Source 3). Are there any similarities? 2. What makes Aristophanes’ description of the Underworld light-hearted and Virgil’s description solemn? Research Study the paintings of Hieronymous Bosch, or similar medieval images of Hell. Source 7 Intermediate 1 & 2 1. Why did Orpheus enter the Underworld? 2. What effect did Orpheus’ music have on the various inhabitants of the Underworld? 3. Why did Orpheus lose Eurydice for the second time? 4. According to Virgil, why did Orpheus look back? Intermediate 2 1. Do you think Virgil’s tone is sympathetic or critical towards Orpheus? Give a reason for your answer. 2. What details of the story has Virgil omitted? Do you think this improves or spoils the narrative? Give a reason for your answer. Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 43 Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 44 QUICK REFERENCE LIST OF NAMES INCLUDED IN THIS PACKAGE Note: Real people and places, except well-known countries are written in capital letters. Acheron one of the rivers of the Underworld Acherusian Lake another way of describing the River Acheron Actaeon a young hunter, turned into a stag by Artemis, when he saw her bathing. Torn to pieces by his own dogs ‘Aeneid’ a long poem written by the Roman poet Virgil AESCHYLUS a Greek writer of tragedies Aether the bright upper air Agamemnon a Greek king of Mycenae. Led the Greek Army to TROY Ajax (1) second best Greek fighter at TROY. Committed suicide Ajax (2) a Greek fighter at TROY. Drowned by Poseidon for blasphemy Anticleia Odysseus’ mother Antilochos a young Greek fighter killed at TROY Arges one of the three Cyclopes Aristaeos the father of Actaeon. A kindly god of shepherds but indirectly responsible for the death of Orpheus’ wife Eurydice ARISTOPHANES a Greek writer of comedies Asphodel a plant with white flowers, growing in the fields of the Underworld AVERNUS a lake in Italy thought to be the entrance to the Underworld Briareus one of the hundred-handed giants Brontes one of the three Cyclopes Centaur a monster, half man and half horse Cerberus the guard dog of Hades Chaos a yawning gap, or abyss, at the beginning of Creation Charon the ferry-man of the dead Chimaera a monster with lion’s body, goat’s head and snake’s tail Circe a witch in Homer’s ‘Odyssey’ who entertained Odysseus CNIDUS a city in South-West Asia Minor (now Turkey) CNOSSUS a city on the Island of Crete - home of the Minotaur Cocytus one of the rivers of the Underworld Coeus one of the Titans Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 45 Cottus one of the hundred-handed giants Crius one of the Titans Cronus one of the Titans, father of Zeus and other gods Cyclopes three one-eyed giants, sons of Gaia and Ouranos Danaids daughters of King Danaus, punished in the Underworld DELPHI sacred site in Greece, home of Apollo’s oracle Deucalion son of Prometheus, survivor of the Flood Dionysus the god of wine Dis the god Hades ELEUSIS a religious site near ATHENS, centre of the Mysteries ELIS a place in southern Greece, near OLYMPIA, home of the Olympic Games Ephialtes a giant who tried to scale MOUNT OLYMPUS. Also see Otus Epimetheus brother of Prometheus, husband of Pandora Erebus the Darkness under the Earth Eros in Creation myth, the Creative Force. Later imagined to be a winged boy, son of Aphrodite Erinyes see Furies Eumenides see Furies EURIPIDES a Greek writer of tragedies Eurydice the wife of Orpheus Eurylochos a member of Odysseus’ crew Eurynome a daughter of Oceanos, in one version of the Creation myth, the creator of the world Eurynomos a demon in the Underworld Furies grim goddesses of vengeance who live in Erebus or Tartarus. They punish those who break the laws of decency Gaia a Greek name for the Earth Ge a Greek name for the Earth Gorgons three monstrous sisters, of whom Medusa, beheaded by Perseus, is best-known Gyges one of the hundred-handed giants Hades the name of the god of the Underworld, or the Underworld itself Harpies monsters with birds’ bodies and women’s heads Hecate a goddess later associated with witchcraft Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 46 Hecatoncheires a Greek name for the hundred-handed giants (‘hecaton’ is the Greek word for a hundred) Heracles a famous Greek hero Hercules the Roman name for Heracles HESIOD a Greek poet who described the Creation and early history of the gods in his poems HOMER a Greek poet, credited with the ‘Iliad’ and the ‘Odyssey’ Hydra nine-headed watersnake, killed by Heracles Hyperion a Titan Iapetus a Titan, father of Atlas, Epimetheus and Prometheus Ixion a sinner in the Underworld, on a fiery wheel Jupiter King of the Olympian gods KERAMEIKOS the potters’ quarter in Ancient ATHENS Laertes father of Odysseus Lapiths a Greek tribe who fought the Centaurs LERNA home of the Hydra LUCRETIUS a Roman poet LYSIPPOS a Greek sculptor ‘Metamorphoses’ a long poem about Greek mythology by the Roman poet Ovid. ‘Metamorphoses’ means ‘Changes’ and the stories told in the poem often contain a change of appearance ‘Minyas’ a lost epic poem Mnemosyne a Titan, mother of the Muses Nymph a female spirit of nature Oceanos a Titan, identified with the waters around the earth Ocnus a man being punished in the Underworld, in a painting by POLYGNOTUS Odysseus a famous Greek hero who suffered many adventures on his way home from TROY ‘Odyssey’ a poem by HOMER which tells the story of Odysseus’ return to ITHACA after the Trojan War OLYMPUS a mountain in Northern Greece, home of the gods Orcus another name for the Underworld Orpheus a famous singer in Greek mythology Otus a giant. With Ephialtes he tried to climb MOUNT OLYMPUS and attack the gods Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 47 Ouranos the starry Sky of heavens OVID a Roman poet Paris prince of Troy, killed in the Trojan War Patroclus a Greek fighter, killed in the Trojan War at Troy PAUSANIAS a Greek traveller and writer, who described many places in Greece Peirithous king of the Lapiths, punished in the Underworld Perimedes one of Odysseus’ crew Penthesileia queen of the Amazons, killed in the Trojan War ‘Phaedo’ a dialogue by PLATO about the fate of the soul after death Phlegethon a river in the Underworld. See also Pyriphlegethon Phlegyas father of Ixion, punished in the Underworld for setting fire to Apollo’s temple Phoebe one of the Titans PLATO a Greek philosopher POLYGNOTUS a Greek painter Pontos the Greek name for the deep sea Prometheus a Titan who created man and was punished by Zeus Protosilaos the first Greek hero to die at TROY Pyriphlegethon one of the rivers of the Underworld Pyrrha wife of Deucalion, survivor of the Flood Rhadamanthys one of the judges in the Underworld Rhea one of the Titans, mother of Zeus and the other gods Salmoneus brother of Sisyphus, punished by Zeus for his pride Sarpedon an ally of the Trojans, killed in the Trojan War Scylla a monster encountered by Odysseus Sibyl a priestess who guided Aeneas through the Underworld SOCRATES a Greek philosopher, teacher of PLATO SPARTA important city in southern Greece, famous for its military way of life Steropes one of the Cyclopes Stygian Marsh another name for the Styx Styx the most famous of the rivers of the Underworld TAENARUM a place in Greece thought to be an entrance to the Underworld Tantalus one of those punished in the Underworld Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 48 Tartarus a place below Hades’ kingdom thought to be a kingdom or a place of punishment Teiresias a prophet Tethys one of the Titan, wife of Oceanos Theia one of the Titans, wife of Hyperion Themis daughter of Ouranos and Gaia, first wife of Zeus. Personifies law and order Thersites one of the Greeks at TROY, portrayed by HOMER as a troublemaker Theseus hero of Athens who had many adventures, the best known of which is the killing of the Minotaur. Punished in the Underworld VIRGIL a Roman poet who wrote the ‘Aeneid’ Xanthias the slave of the god Dionysus in Aristophanes’ play ‘The Frogs’ Zeus King of the Olympian gods, god of the sky Classical Studies Support Materials: Classical Mythology (Intermediate 1 & 2) 49