Crankshaft and Its Maintenance K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) MA-8101 - EK Motor K Chatterjea Singapore Maritime Academy April 2023 Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 1 / 30 Aims & Learning Outcomes Aim: Understand the construction and maintenance of crankshafts. Learning Outcomes: At the end of this lesson the student should be able to: 1 Explain the material used for a crankshaft 2 Describe the construction of an one-piece-crankshaft 3 Explain the inspection procedure of a medium speed engine crankshaft 4 Explain the factors that cause overstressing of a crankshaft 5 Explain the possible causes of vibration on a crankshaft 6 Identify the factors that may cause misalignment of a crankshaft 7 Describe how crankshaft bearing clearances are checked 8 Sketch and describe the procedure for checking crankshaft alignment using deflection gauge between webs 9 Explain how to interpret the readings obtained from crankshaft deflection NOTE: All slides are based on [4] K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 2 / 30 Lesson Plan for the Module Figure: Lesson Plan for the Module K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 3 / 30 Functions of a Crankshaft in Diesel Engines A rotating shaft, called a crankshaft, transforms a piston’s reciprocating action into a rotational motion. Internal combustion engines employ these to carry out such actions. Connecting rods are joined to crankshafts through a series of cranks and crankpins. Figure: Diesel Engine Crankshaft [1] K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 4 / 30 Types of Crankshafts in Diesel Engines [2] The followings are the various types of crankshaft fitted to a diesel engine: 2-stroke large marine diesel engine fully built-up crankshaft semi-built-up crankshaft welded crankshaft 4-stroke engines have one piece crank shaft. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 5 / 30 Processes of Construction of One Piece Crankshaft 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Steel billet is heated and worked down under steam hammer or hydraulic forging End of billet is first worked to form an end coupling flange and journal Next section worked part forming two crank-webs and a pin form a block Third section worked on second journal It is followed by second block forged at correct angle to the first block Forging is continued until it is finished Journal and sides of webs adjacent to journal are finish-machined. Followed by machining of crankpin and inside of webs Holes and oil passages drilled, ground smooth to reduced stress-raisers including fillet radius at pin and journals Crankpins and journal hardened if thin shell bearing used Sets of hydraulic presses are then used to form the crankpin journal and webs. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 6 / 30 Processes of Construction of One Piece Crankshaft 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 Forging gives crankshaft continuous grain flow. Grain structure follows a path: parallel to and along the journal,bends round along the line of the web,round through the crankpin, and back down the second web, before turning again to follow the journal Continuous grain flow gives the crankshaft better fatigue resistance Forgings are machined, stress relieved. Radii at change of section is cold rolled. Crankshafts for surface hardened are made of a steel alloy known as nitralloy. (a steel containing 1.5%Cr, 1% Al and 0.2% Mo) Crankshaft is heated to 500C in ammonia gas Nitrogen dissociates from ammonia gas combines with chromium and aluminium to form hard nitrates at surface. Molybdenum refines the grain structure at the still tough core Heavy weights fitted to cranks in order to balance the reciprocating masses K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 7 / 30 Crankshaft Fillet Radius [3] A crankshaft frequently has a narrow fillet radius. Crankshaft fillet rolling is one of the often used engineering techniques to extend the fatigue life of the crankshaft. The fillet rolling process results in the induction of compressive residual stresses on and beneath the fillet radius surface. As a result, the crankshaft’s fatigue life is increased. Figure: Crankshaft Fillet Radius K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 8 / 30 Pro & Cons of One Piece Crankshaft ADVANTAGES: Continuous grain flow, webs is thinner Economy in weight, space and cost Smaller & lighter webs since no holes Thin crank arm, webs leads to longer journal bearing & lower specific bearing pressures Increase fatigue strength due to continuous grain flow. Approved by major classification societies Shaft lighter and thus more crank-throws in a single shaft No shrinkfit necessary thus no consequences of slip occurs DISADVANTAGES: More rigid and thus less tolerant to misalignment Difficulty in repairs ...if one section cannot be repairs by grinding or metal spraying, whole shaft to be renewed. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 9 / 30 Oil Holes in One Piece Crankshaft Oil holes are drilled in crankshaft for oil to travel from main bearing journal to crankpin and UP the connecting rod to lubricate piston pin/gudgeon pin and cool the piston. If the surface finish of oil holes is poor, then cracks can start from the flaws during operation At the exit points on crankpin, oil holes must not have sharp edges but to be smoothly radiused to reduce stress concentration at the edges. Oil hole drilled along the journal, webs crankpin in crankshaft must not compromise the strength of the crankshaft. The oil holes should be positioned horizontally when the crank is at TDC to avoid the loaded region. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 10 / 30 Oil Holes in One Piece Crankshaft - Figure Figure: Drilled Oil Hole in One Piece Crankshaft K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 11 / 30 Material for Crankshsft One Piece Crankshaft The materials for one piece crankshaft are steel. The compositions are generally 0.4carbon steel Fully built-up and semi-built-up crankshaft The materials for these types of crankshaft are generally unalloyed steel of low carbon steel or alloyed steel of low allloyed chrome and molybdenum steel. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 12 / 30 Forces on Crankshaft Diagram [5] Figure: Forces on A Crankshaft K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 13 / 30 Stresses on a Crankshaft Crankshaft experience the following stresses during dynamic loading: Bending of crankshaft contribute to compressive, tensile and shear stresses Twisting causes shear stresses Torsional stresses fluctuation when propeller comes out of water and plunges back into water. Sudden fluctuations of engine speed result in shock loading on crankpins. Misalignment and wear down of bearing K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 14 / 30 Stresses on a Crankshaft - Diagram Figure: Stresses on A Crankshaft K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 15 / 30 Likely Causes of Crankshaft Vibration Possible causes of crankshaft vibration Load due to unbalanced gears contribute to torsional vibration Load due to propeller thrust that could result in axial vibration. Operation of engine in the range of critical speed. Sudden shocks loads due to propeller racing in heavy weather Misalignment of crankshaft due to wear down of main bearing. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 16 / 30 Likely Causes of Crankshaft Misalignment Factors that may cause misalignment of crankshaft Main bearing supporting the crankshaft are damaged The lowest part of the engine structure as bedplate where crankshaft is resting is deformed / damaged Slack or broken tie bolts in some medium speed engine fitted with tie bolts Foundation bolts or holding down bolts securing the engine to the engine seating are loosen or fracture Chocks supporting the Engine to the engine seating are broken, cracked or fretted Propeller shaft bearing or stern tube bearing for the main engine are defective or wear down. The engine structure is weak due to corrosion and thus running components such as crankshaft will be affected Hull deformation especially due to grounding and fire that affect the engine seating condition and thus the crankshaft K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 17 / 30 Checking of Bearing Clearances Ensure risk assessment is completed in the entry into crankcase/confined space In the measurement of crankpin bearing clearance, use the Engine Instruction Manual as the guide. The use of a feeler gauge to insert between the crankpin and crankpin bearing are the commonly practiced. Measure thickness of crankpin and the inside diameter of the crankpin after it is tensioned to the correct torque. The difference between the inside diameter of the crankpin and the crankpin diameter gives the bearing clearance In the measurement of main bearing clearance, the use of ‘Kjaer ‘feeler gauge is used in certain engine (see Fig in the next slide) to measure the clearance between the journal and main bearing at the top. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 18 / 30 Taking Main Bearing Clearance with Telescopic Guage [6] Figure: Taking Bearing Clearance with Telescopic Gauge K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 19 / 30 Crankshaft Deflection - Introduction - I [7] Consider one section for better understanding i.e. two crank webs, a crank pin and two journals. If a straight length of shaft is supported at either end and is subjected to a central load. The effect in shaft is upper material in compression and the lower in tension. This effect is applicable to the section of crankshaft described above with the bearings supporting the assembly at the journals and the point loading being effect by the weight of the piston and conrod assembly (ignoring other loads found operational conditions such as combustion and centrifugal). K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 20 / 30 Crankshaft Deflection - Introduction - II It can be seen that the effect is to increase the distance between the webs at top dead centre (TDC) and reduce the distance at bottom dead centre (BDC). This deflection is normally found in all crankshafts although for smaller engines with very rigid cranks this may be very small. A set of measurements taken from an engine will reveal this deflection which should be constant through each crank/piston unit. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Figure: Crankshaft Deflection Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 21 / 30 Crankshaft Deflections - Points to Note After initial installation of the engine and alignment, a set of deflections are taken. These then form the datum line to which all other recordings are measured against. It should be noted that changes in circumstances will effect the deflections and are not indicative of faults. These include a) Ambient temperature b) Engine temperature c)Vessel hull loading (hogging, sagging etc.) d) Vessel afloat, dry docked ( again vessel hull loading can cause effects even in drydock due to movement of blocks, which tanks are full etc.) These effects are well known and an experienced engineer will take into account these factors when looking at a set of recordings. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 22 / 30 Crankshaft Deflections - Worn Out Bearing If a situation now occurs where a bearing becomes more worn than an adjacent one the effects will be shown as a change in the pattern of delections. When the cranks is turned from BDC to TDC the weight of the running gear causes the crank webs and crackpins to bend in such a manner that the distance between the webs decreases, and continues to decrease until the bearing is no longer in contact with the journal. The deflection when the crankshaft is approaching TDC will then go from its normal positive reading to zero and then to negative readings at which point the assembly is supporting the weight without the assistance from the lowered main bearing. Thus, any changes from natural deflections can be related to main bearing misalignement and is proportional to the differences in height of the bearings K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 23 / 30 Crankshaft Deflections - Worn Out Bearing Figure K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Figure: Worn Out Bearing Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 24 / 30 Crankshaft Deflections - Measurement Procedure These are generally taken using a spring loaded dial gauge as shown in the figure (next Slide). The crank webs are punch marked to ensure that the readings are taken in the same place each time. Five measuring points are taken - TDC, 90’ either side of TDC and 30’ either side of BDC. The latter two measurements are required as it is not possible to measure at BDC due to the Con rod. The measurements are always taken starting at the same starting point. In this case we will say Port side near BDC. The gauge is fitted and zeroed. Rotate the engine continuously and the readings read off during rotation. After the final reading the egine is rotated back to the start point. If the reading is not zero then it indicates that the gauge is moved and the readings are re-taken. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 25 / 30 Crankshaft Deflections - Measurement Procedure - Figure Figure: Crankshaft Deflection - Measurement K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 26 / 30 Location of Dial Gauge and Crankpin Position Figure: Crankshaft Deflection Positions K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 27 / 30 Values of Measurement as Positive , Negative and Zero Figure: Crankshaft Deflection - The Values K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 28 / 30 Sample of Crankshaft Deflection Form Figure: Crankshaft Deflection - Sample Forms K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 29 / 30 References [1] Iyas, M. D. ‘Crankshaft: Parts, Function, Types, Diagram & More [PDF]’. The Engineers Post, 27 May 2021. https://www.theengineerspost.com. [2] ‘Cast vs Forged Crankshaft’. Accessed 8 April 2023. https://www.dropforging.net/cast-vs-forged-crankshaft.html. [3] Ho, Simon, Yung-Li Lee, Hong-Tae Kang, and Cheng J. Wang. ‘Optimization of a Crankshaft Rolling Process for Durability’. International Journal of Fatigue 31, no. 5 (1 May 2009): 799–808. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ijfatigue.2008.11.011. [4] SMA Classnotes Accessed 7 April 2023. [5] ‘Marine Diesel Engines: Role and Purpose of the Crankshaft’, 25 December 2008. https://www.brighthubengineering.com/marine-engines-machinery/20969-components-ofmarine-diesel-engines-crankshaft/. [6] Anish. ‘Ways to Measure Main Bearing Clearance of Marine Engine’. Marine Insight, 2 March 2019. https://www.marineinsight.com/main-engine/4-ways-to-measure-main-bearingclearance-of-two-stroke-marine-engine/. [7]Moozhikkara, Vineeth. ‘Simple Explanation Of Crankshaft Deflections, Measurement Procedure, Readings,Curves’. MarineSite.Info (blog). Accessed 8 April 2023. https://www.marinesite.info/2013/10/simple-explanation-of-crankshaft.html. K Chatterjea (Singapore Maritime Academy) Crankshaft and Its Maintenance April 2023 30 / 30