Uploaded by ccchanph

Summary Cohen and Caritthers

advertisement
COHEN
To find the impact of natural science to soc sci in the 17th century, the author focused on
the pre-Newtonian decades, taking into account the attempts to develop the science of
government and the state.
Thinkers that affected this movement:
● Galileo’s mathematico-phyiscal model was sought after by people who want to
incorporate math in social or political affairs. (he applied math to imagined systems,
which is a framework to be used by social scientists).
● Descartes attempted to incorporate mathematics to solve problems of Science and
Philosophy, that is to produce a geometric ethics.
● Harvey's comparison of the role of a king and the function of the heart is cast in
a traditional mode of thought, the ancient organismic analogy of the "body politic".
His analogies sanctioned exploration of political systems through physiology. Thus, he
recognised the relation of true science with the functioning of the state.
○ Harrington disagrees with Hobbes in the methodology of mathematics but instead
applies the Harveyan biology, and created a “political anatomy” that employs
empirical methods.
○ Harvey focuses less on the organismic concept of the body but rather the
dynamic function of each and the holistic view of the body. Harrington, being a
huge fan of Harvey, employed this idea in his political model and created a
metaphorical body with the focus on the mechanical system.
In the 17th century, there was an explicit goal to adopt mathematical frameworks and
duplicate the success of mathematical pioneers by producing a new science of the
state or of society in a mathematical mold.
The thinkers of 17th century mathematical social science did not only sought to emulate
the methods of mathematics but also to produce a numerical base for understanding
society and to propose quantitative analyses.
4 Forms of application of mathematics:
1. Produce works as clear and certain
2. Adopt the structural form of presentation: ordered sets of definitions->axioms and
postulates->proved theorems
3. Apply new mathematical techniques and methods
4. Use numerical social data
Thinkers who attempted to incorporate the framework of mathematics into social science:
● Benedict Spinoza wrote "Ethics” and used a geometrico-mathematical model. Set in a
strictly Euclidean framework, this treatise begins with a set of eight numbered
●
definitions and axioms, leading to numbered propositions and their proofs. He
doesn't use quantitative data, however used the same framework as mathematics (just
like the other thinkers mentioned below)
Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz who wrote "The Specimen" contains a suggestion of a
logical calculus of probabilities in a political context. He develops his subject in a
sequence of numbered propositions, interrupted here and there by the introduction
of a corollary or lemma. Thus the Specimen is of interest primarily as a
pioneering document in the mathematization of political science.
Social scientists such as Thomas Hobbes was able to adopt theories about the human body in
which he would later integrate it to philosophy. He coined the term “mechanical philosophy”
which is related to motion. Like Petty, Hobbes used the analogy of the human body in
presenting that the state can exhibit a continual motion — the movement of one state institution
can affect the other. Harrington delved more into the politics in which his constitutional model is
the basis of many constitutions.
CONTEMPORARY
POLITICAL SCIENCE
● The political culture of the Filipinos could be traced back to the years of colonization
especially the 300-year tyranny of the Spanish colonial government and the American
colony which will always be an important key in unlocking the history of politics in the
Philippines
● the political maturation and awakening of Filipinos gave rise to the Philippine revolution the beginning of their political literacy
● the Ilustrados greatly helped in the growth of the Filipinos’ nationalism through their
scholarly endeavors: “Propaganda Movement”
● 1946, Philippine president Manuel Roxas, signaled the opening of a whole new era.
● Political science as an academic discipline did not exist in the country before the
1900s
● It was under the American colony that the establishment of academic institutions led to
the emergence of social sciences as academic disciplines in the Philippines wherein the
Departments of Sociology, Economics and Political Science were established in 1915.
Main thinkers:
1. Dr. Maximo Kalaw- affirmed political science as the study of the state divided in 4
divisions: Descriptive Political Science, Historical Political Science, Theoretical Political
Science, and Political Law
○ four basic approaches to studying political science: juridical or legalistic,
historical, institutional, and philosophical
○ stressed the value of nationalism
2. Cesar Adib Majul- studies were focused on Filipino nationalism— the Philippine Reform
Movement, Philippine Revolution, and the socio-political thoughts of Jose Rizal and
Apolinario Mabini
○ nature and dynamics of Moro Society and political studies behind the Mindanao
conflict
3. Remigio E. Agpalo- one of the Filipino researchers who tried to localize Philippine
social sciences by analyzing Philippine society from the perspective of local culture
○ "pandanggo sa ilaw politics," as a reference to the folk dance, in explaining
political dynamism and the Pangulo regime that centered on the ideologies of the
country's heroes,
Malcolm's work, the Government of the Philippine Islands, as well as his joint work with the
Philippine Government of Kalaw, helped to develop legalistic and long-term governmental
strategies for the field of political science in the country.
ANTHROPOLOGY
● the emergence of Anthropology is motivated by the conqueror-conquered relationship in
which the native people of Africa, America, and Asia as objects of investigation and the
Western anthropologists as the investigating subjects
● Anthropology entered the Philippine scene in the 1900s to 1910 however it was not
appreciated until the formation of the Philippine Studies Program at the University of
Chicago after World War II
● anthropology was previously practiced during the 19th century through the use of
ethnography.
● Anthropology as an academic discipline was first introduced by Henry Otley Beyer, in
1917 at the University of the Philippines Diliman
● Anthropology in the Philippines began as early as the 19th century during the Spanish
colonization. However, it was “forged” during the entire colonization period since there
had been no proper distinction between the idea of the nation and ethnic others
● Rooted in the Western school of thought, particularly the ideas of Emil Durkheim, the
Father of Anthropology and Sociology
○ 7 years post-World War II in the year 1952, the two disciplines were separated
given that each of the disciplines have identified theiR own purposes
● Contemporary: “Post-Anthropology Age”.
○ The problem with the history of Anthropology in the country is that it is innately
colonial
○ there had been only a brief period of interest in Philippine Anthropology by the
1900s and began to decrease by 1910
“Continuing Alongside The Katutubo-Current Challenges To Filipino
● Anthropology” Mangahas and Zayas (2018)
● anthropology in academia requires attention and assistance in its lack of resources to
further establish the discipline in a thriving condition.
● gap that is experienced by its practitioners when attempting to work with practitioners of
other disciplines.
● disagreements on what methodologies to utilize
● anthropologists are compelled to spend more time convincing others that the methods
they propose are as rigorous as the other disciplines
The 19th century Filipino thinkers such as Jose Rizal, Jose Burgos, Isabelo delos Reyes, T.H.
Padro de Tavera contributed to modern day anthropology with their ethnological writings.
first thinkers of anthropology in the Philippines started in the 20th century during the American
colonization with the likes of Alfred Kroeber, David P Barrows and the father of Philippine
Anthropology, Dr. Henry Otley Beyer.
In the contemporary time, Anthropology can be used as a way to give proper acknowledgment
to the indigenous people and their culture and put an end to the negative connotation of being
primitive and uncivilized that has been brought about by colonialism,
● more rigorous anthropological research on the multiculturalism of Filipino constituencies
in line with the contemporary process of nation-building and decolonization
SOCIOLOGY
Sociology as a discipline and a specialty was brought about by the increasing technological
advancements and the growth of industrialization in the west.
The rise of industrialization and capitalism brought major concerns to thinkers about how it
would change the course of European society
●
●
●
●
●
●
Sociology started during the 1890s. As historical records indicate, the Dominican
University of Santo.Tomas was the avenue for the introduction of Sociology in 1896
The colonial government of the United States established departments of Sociology
During the 20th century’s first quarter, Sociology departments concentrated on applying
sociological theories and concepts to improve their understanding of Philippine society
Its development began with its identification as a social philosophy, thereby concluding it
as a discipline of social science
○ Their main objective is to further understand how social institutions influence
social relationships that mold a better society
Halfway through the 20th century, scholars have witnessed that Sociology shifted
towards an approach that is more political and critical
○ thinkers approached it more as asocial science rather than as social philosophy
○
The scope of Sociology in general includes social change, social inequalities, social
order, social behavior, and more. One of its main objectives is to further help understand
society and how everything within it is interconnected. It helps illustrate the cause and
effect of certain events and circumstances within a particular society
● Ideology, one of the key concepts of Sociology, plays a role in shaping social
relationships and cultural values
○ In this case, sociologists studied how such cultural factors could influence the
voting attitudes of voters
● Gelia T. Castillo, a Filipino Rural Sociologist, stated that one of the most substantial
challenges faced by Philippine Sociology lies in the creative translation of practical
problems so that it can be analyzed and studied in research to elucidate solutions or
answers students studying the discipline often ask
● It has been established that Sociology did not flourish in the Philippines until the 20th
century. Conrado Benitez and Luis Rivera were Filipino professors who taught the
discipline in the vernacular
● The study of Sociology in the Philippines was further expanded by Serafin Macaraig
PSYCHOLOGY
1960s- turning point
● Psychology broke away from Philosophy
● start of the indigenization of the field itself: Main thinkers of Psychology began to
“critique and challenge academic colonialism
Colonial period: incrediblyWesternized; no concrete attempts were made to reject and correct it
in the 1960s
Virgilio Gaspar Enriquez- uses Filipino in teaching
● established the Philippine Psychology Research House (PPRH) which later became the
Philippine Psychology Research and Training House which became home to materials
on Sikolohiyang Pilipino with more than 10,000 references
● returned to the Philippines in the early 1970s to introduce the concept of Sikolohiyang
Pilipino (Filipino Psychology)
Him and Alfredo V Lagmay: historical and cultural roots of Philippine Psychology
psychological concepts, theories, and methodologies were to be based on local sources and
resources
Filipinization movements:
Virgilio Enriquez’s Sikolohiyang Pilipino (the 1960s), Prospero Covar’s Pilipinolohiya
(early-1970s), and Zeus Salazar’s Pantayong Pananaw (mid-1970s)
● some thinkers still argue that concepts introduced by Western thinkers still take part not
just in the psychology catered in the modern-day Philippines but also in other parts of
the world
ECONOMICS
1900s economics came to existence as academic disciplines with defined theoretical and
methodological frameworks.
social science practices were manifested and influenced by American frameworks
Philippine Economic Society (PES) was founded in 1962. This association was put in place
because the institution led by scholars pointed out anomalies and sudden need to address the
financial crisis
Gregorio Sancianco y Joson: first Filipino economist; El progreso de Filipinas or The progress of
the Philippines. To counter the tax evasion in the Philippines, Sanciano proposed a presumptive
tax that relies on the ability of an individual to pay regardless of race
American rule: Tools like mathematical models and empirical testing became the foundation for
today's economics
unlike other disciplines, it was not as significantly impacted by Marxism and postmodern
influences, has heavily utilized mathematical developments in their work (much more than other
disciplines),and did not intentionally set a goal of indigenizing the field unlike other disciplines
A department of critical economics was established in an effort to address issues in a “less
methodologically obsessed” manner
Download