lOMoARcPSD|20899946
33 Lidasan v. Comelec - case digest
Juris Doctor (University of the Philippines System)
Studocu is not sponsored or endorsed by any college or university
Downloaded by Nathaniel Rene Palco (ngpalco@up.edu.ph)
lOMoARcPSD|20899946
KARLO’
SDI
GEST
Oc
t
obe
r25,1967
Li
da
s
a
nv
.COMELEC
Li
da
s
a
nv
.COMELEC
I
. Doc
t
r
i
ne/
La
w

§1,RA 4790–Bar
r
i
osTogai
g,Madal
um,Ba
yanga
,La
ngkong,
Sar
akan, Ka
t
bo, Di
gakapan, Ma
gabo, Tabangao, Ti
ongko,
Col
odan, Kabamaka
wan, Kapa
t
a
gan, Bongabong, Ai
pang,
Da
gowan,Baki
ki
s
,Bungabung,Los
ai
n,Ma
t
i
mosandMa
gol
a
t
ung,
i
nt
heMuni
c
i
pal
i
t
i
e
sofBut
i
gandBal
aba
gan,Pr
ovi
nc
eofLana
o
de
lSur
,ar
es
e
par
a
t
e
df
r
om s
ai
d muni
c
i
pal
i
t
i
e
sand c
ons
t
i
t
ut
e
d
i
nt
oadi
s
t
i
nc
tandi
nde
pe
nde
ntmuni
c
i
pal
i
t
yoft
hes
amepr
ovi
nc
e
t
obeknownast
heMuni
c
i
pal
i
t
yofDi
ana
t
on,Pr
ovi
nc
eofLanao
de
lSur
.Thes
e
a
tofgove
r
nme
ntoft
hemuni
c
i
pal
i
t
ys
hal
lbei
n
Togai
g.
Li
mi
t
a
t
i
onuponl
e
gi
s
l
a
t
i
vepowe
r
.
- Congr
e
s
si
st
or
e
f
r
ai
nf
r
om c
ongl
ome
r
a
t
i
on,unde
r one
s
t
a
t
ut
e
,ofhe
t
e
r
oge
nouss
ubj
e
c
t
s
.
- Thet
i
t
l
eoft
hebi
l
li
st
obec
ouc
he
di
nal
angua
ges
uffic
i
e
ntt
o
not
i
f
yt
hel
e
gi
s
l
a
t
or
sand t
hepubl
i
coft
hei
mpor
toft
he
s
ubj
e
c
toft
hebi
l
l
.



Asi
ts
t
ands
,t
we
l
vebar
r
i
osar
et
r
ans
f
e
r
r
e
df
r
om t
hepr
ovi
nc
e
ofCot
aba
t
ot
oLanaoDe
lSur
.Thi
sboughtaboutac
hangei
n
t
heboundar
i
e
soft
het
wopr
ovi
nc
e
s
.
The OP r
e
c
omme
nde
d t
o COMELEC t
os
us
pe
nd t
he
ope
r
a
t
i
on oft
hes
t
a
t
ut
eunt
i
l“
t
hes
i
t
ua
t
i
on i
sc
l
ar
i
fie
d by
c
or
r
e
c
t
i
ngl
e
gi
s
l
a
t
i
on.
”
Come
l
e
cde
c
l
ar
e
dt
ha
tt
hes
t
a
t
ut
e"
s
houl
dbei
mpl
e
me
nt
e
d
unl
e
s
sde
c
l
ar
e
d unc
ons
t
i
t
ut
i
onalby t
he Supr
e
me Cour
t
.
"
He
nc
e
,t
hi
sc
as
e
.
Pe
t
i
t
i
one
rLi
das
anr
e
l
i
e
supont
hec
ons
t
i
t
ut
i
onalr
e
qui
r
e
me
nt
t
ha
t“nobi
l
lwhi
c
hma
ybee
nac
t
e
di
nt
ol
a
ws
hal
le
mbr
ac
e
mor
et
hanones
ubj
e
c
twhi
c
hs
hal
lbee
xpr
e
s
s
e
di
nt
het
i
t
l
eof
t
hebi
l
l
.
”
I
I
I
.I
s
s
ue
WON t
het
i
t
l
eofRA 4790vi
ol
a
t
e
st
hec
ons
t
i
t
ut
i
onalr
e
qui
r
e
me
nt
.
YES
I
V.Ra
t
i
o/
LegalBas
i
s
I
I
. Fac
t
soft
heCas
e



OnJ
une18,1966,t
hePr
e
s
i
de
nts
i
gne
di
nt
oRA 4790,whi
c
h
i
se
nt
i
t
l
e
d"
AnAc
tCr
e
a
t
i
ngt
heMuni
c
i
pal
i
t
yofDi
ana
t
on
i
nt
hePr
ovi
nc
eofLanaode
lSur
.
"
I
tc
amet
ol
i
ghtl
a
t
e
rt
ha
tt
we
l
vebar
r
i
osme
nt
i
one
di
nt
he
Ac
tar
ewi
t
hi
nt
hePr
ovi
nc
eofCot
aba
t
oandnotofLanaode
l
Sur
.
Pr
ompt
e
d by t
he c
omi
ng e
l
e
c
t
i
ons
,Come
l
e
c adopt
e
di
t
s
r
e
s
ol
ut
i
on ofAugus
t15,1967,whi
c
hr
e
s
ol
ve
dt
ha
tt
he
bar
r
i
os me
nt
i
one
d i
n RA 4790 wi
l
lc
ompr
i
s
e t
he
Muni
c
i
pal
i
t
yofDi
ana
t
onr
e
gar
dl
e
s
sofwhi
c
hpr
ovi
nc
et
he
bar
r
i
oi
ss
i
t
ua
t
e
d.
GRNO:L28089
PONENTE:S
ANCHEZ,J
.
,ENBANC
Thes
ubj
e
c
toft
hes
t
a
t
ut
emus
tbe"
e
xpr
e
s
s
e
di
nt
het
i
t
l
e"oft
hebi
l
l
.
Compl
i
anc
ei
si
mpe
r
a
t
i
ve
,gi
ve
nt
hef
ac
tt
ha
tt
heCons
t
i
t
ut
i
ondoe
s
note
xac
tofCongr
e
s
st
heobl
i
ga
t
i
ont
or
e
addur
i
ngi
t
sde
l
i
be
r
a
t
i
ons
t
hee
nt
i
r
et
e
xtoft
hebi
l
l
.
Thet
e
s
toft
hes
uffic
i
e
nc
yofat
i
t
l
ei
swhe
t
he
rornoti
ti
smi
s
l
e
adi
ng.
At
i
t
l
ewhi
c
hi
ss
ounc
e
r
t
ai
nt
ha
tt
hea
ve
r
a
gepe
r
s
onr
e
adi
ngi
twoul
d
notbei
nf
or
me
doft
hepur
pos
eoft
hee
na
c
t
me
ntorputoni
nqui
r
yas
t
oi
t
sc
ont
e
nt
s
,i
sbad.
I
t
ss
ubs
t
anc
er
a
t
he
rt
han i
t
sf
or
m s
houl
d bec
ons
i
de
r
e
d,and t
he
pur
pos
eoft
hec
ons
t
i
t
ut
i
onalr
e
qui
r
e
me
nt
,ofgi
vi
ng not
i
c
et
o al
l
pe
r
s
onsi
nt
e
r
e
s
t
e
d,s
houl
dbeke
pti
nmi
ndbyt
hec
our
t
.
TOPI
C:Par
t
sofaSt
a
t
ut
e
;Ti
t
l
e
SUBJ
ECT:SCON
Downloaded by Nathaniel Rene Palco (ngpalco@up.edu.ph)
lOMoARcPSD|20899946
KARLO’
SDI
GEST
Oc
t
obe
r25,1967
Li
da
s
a
nv
.COMELEC
Li
da
s
a
nv
.COMELEC
I
nt
hi
sc
as
e
,t
het
i
t
l
eofRA 4790pr
oj
e
c
t
st
hei
mpr
e
s
s
i
ont
ha
ts
ol
e
l
y
t
hepr
ovi
nc
eofLanaode
lSuri
saffe
c
t
e
dbyt
hec
r
e
a
t
i
onofDi
ana
t
on.
Nott
hes
l
i
ght
e
s
ti
nt
i
ma
t
i
oni
st
he
r
et
ha
tc
ommuni
t
i
e
si
nt
hea
dj
ac
e
nt
pr
ovi
nc
eofCot
aba
t
o ar
ei
nc
or
por
a
t
e
di
nt
hi
sne
w Lanao de
lSur
t
own.
Fort
her
e
as
onsgi
ve
n,wevot
et
ode
c
l
ar
eRe
publ
i
cAc
t4790nul
land
voi
d,and t
opr
ohi
bi
tr
e
s
ponde
ntCommi
s
s
i
on f
r
om i
mpl
e
me
nt
i
ng
t
hes
amef
ore
l
e
c
t
or
alpur
pos
e
s
.
Thebane
f
ule
ffe
c
toft
hede
f
e
c
t
i
vet
i
t
l
ehe
r
epr
e
s
e
nt
e
di
snots
o
di
ffic
ul
tt
o pe
r
c
e
i
ve
.Suc
ht
i
t
l
e di
d noti
nf
or
m t
he me
mbe
r
sof
Congr
e
s
sast
ot
hef
ul
li
mpa
c
toft
hel
a
w andi
tke
ptt
hepubl
i
ci
nt
he
dar
kast
owha
tt
ownsandpr
ovi
nc
e
swe
r
ea
c
t
ual
l
yaffe
c
t
e
dbyt
he
bi
l
l
.
Wer
ul
et
ha
tRe
publ
i
cAc
t4790i
snul
landvoi
d.
________________________________
Sugge
s
t
i
onwasmadet
ha
tRe
publ
i
cAc
t4790ma
ys
t
i
l
lbes
al
va
ge
d
wi
t
hr
e
f
e
r
e
nc
et
ot
heni
nebar
r
i
osi
nt
hemuni
c
i
pal
i
t
i
e
si
nLana
ode
l
Sur
.Howe
ve
r
,t
hi
si
si
mpr
ope
r
.
Ther
ul
es
t
a
t
e
st
ha
tf
orwhe
r
eapor
t
i
on ofas
t
a
t
ut
ei
sr
e
nde
r
e
d
unc
ons
t
i
t
ut
i
onalandt
her
e
mai
nde
rval
i
d,t
hepar
t
swi
l
lbes
e
par
a
t
e
d
andt
hec
ons
t
i
t
ut
i
onalpor
t
i
onuphe
l
d.Thi
sr
e
mai
nst
obet
r
uei
nt
hi
s
c
as
e
.
Thef
a
c
tt
ha
tonl
y9pr
ovi
nc
e
soutoft
heor
i
gi
nal21woul
dr
e
nde
rt
he
s
t
a
t
ut
eout
s
i
deoft
her
e
al
m ofwha
tCongr
e
s
ss
oughti
tt
obe
.I
not
he
r
wor
ds
,t
her
e
mai
ni
ngval
i
dpor
t
i
onst
he
r
e
ofc
annotbes
ai
dt
obet
he
r
e
s
ul
tofCongr
e
s
s
’t
r
uei
nt
e
nt
i
oni
ne
nac
t
i
ngRA4
790.
Addi
t
i
onal
l
y
,i
fuphe
l
d,t
hene
w muni
c
i
pal
i
t
yofDi
a
t
anonwoul
dnot
s
uffic
i
e
nt
l
yc
ompl
ywi
t
ht
her
e
qui
r
e
me
nt
soft
e
r
r
i
t
or
y
,i
nc
ome
,and
popul
a
t
i
on.
Re
publ
i
cAc
t4790i
st
husi
ndi
vi
s
i
bl
e
,andi
ti
sac
c
or
di
ngl
ynul
land
voi
di
ni
t
st
ot
al
i
t
y
.
V. Di
s
pos
i
t
i
on
GRNO:L28089
PONENTE:S
ANCHEZ,J
.
,ENBANC
TOPI
C:Par
t
sofaSt
a
t
ut
e
;Ti
t
l
e
SUBJ
ECT:SCON
Downloaded by Nathaniel Rene Palco (ngpalco@up.edu.ph)