Criteria
Excellent
4 pts
Good
3 pts
Presentation
Extremely enthusiastic,
motivating, obvious
interest in activity
presented, clear, audible
voice
Some enthusiasm,
and interest in
activity presented,
projected voice,
audible
Content
Firm grasp on knowledge
and understanding of the
topic being presented,
showed complete
knowledge, covered all
important facts
Basic knowledge
and understanding
of the topic being
presented
Organization
Instructed in easy-tofollow sequence,
organized, well planned
out
Proper equipment,
excellent location,
perfect lighting, clear
audio and visual, overall
excellent quality
Excellent sense of
design. Effective camera
techniques used for the
video and pictures.
Smooth transitions are
appropriate and aid in
delivery of the
presentation.
somewhat
organized, easy to
follow
Grammar, spelling,
punctuation,
capitalization are correct;
sources are documented
correctly and copyright
law has been followed.
Includes 2 – 3
grammatical errors,
misspellings,
punctuation errors;
sources are
documented and
correctly and
copyright law has
been followed.
Video Quality
Creativity &
Design
Conventions
Good location and
equipment, lighting
and visuals clear,
good audio
Good use of
graphics and/or
other design
elements. Some
transitions are
inappropriately
placed.
Fair
2 pts
Poor
1 pts
Showed little
enthusiasm, little
interest in
activities being
presented,
somewhat
audible
Some knowledge
and
understanding of
the topic
presented
missing a few
important facts
sometimes hard
to follow, not well
planned out
No enthusiasm, no
interest in activities
being presented,
barely audible
Acceptable
location and
equipment, audio
and visual
unclear at times
Minimal use of
design elements.
No transitions.
Includes 3 – 4
grammatical
errors,
misspellings,
punctuation
errors; some
sources are
documented but
not correctly.
Demonstrated little
knowledge or
understanding of
the topic being
presented.
unorganized,
confusing, hard to
follow, not planned
out
Poor location, poor
equipment, poor
lighting,
low visual and
audio quality
Use of elements
detracts from
video. Too many or
too gaudy
graphics;
transitions, too
many clips,
backgrounds
and/or sounds
detract from
content.
Includes five or
more grammatical
errors,
misspellings,
punctuation errors;
sources are not
documented.