ETHICS (w/ citation) The term ethics is derived from the Greek word “ethos”, which means “way of living”. Ethics is a subfield of philosophy that deals with human conduct, particularly how people behave in social settings. In order to understand what is morally right or wrong, just or unjust, ethics explores the intellectual justifications for our moral judgment (Treasury Board – Canada, 2015). In addition, it also considers freedom, accountability, and justice, as well as how humans interact with both nature and other people. PHILOSOPHERS ON THEIR ETHICAL THEORIES TIME ETHICAL THEORY CONTROLLED IN PHILOSOPHERS ANCIENT MEDIEVAL What the world is? God Cosmo centric Theocentric MODERN Man; who am I? Anthropocentric CONTEMPORARY Existentialism Phenomenology Socrates, Plato, Aristotle St. Augustine, St. Thomas Aquinas Emmanuel Kant, D. Hume, Thomas Hobbes S. Kierkeegard, Karl Marx, Stuart Mill, Nietzsche, J. Rowls SOCRATES (469/470 – 399 BCE) Greek philosopher and considered the father of western philosophy. His father was the sculptor Sophronicus and the mid-wife Phaenarete. Studied music, gymnastics, and grammar in his youth and followed his father’s profession as a sculptor He served with distinction in the army and, at the Battle of Potidaea, saved the life of the General Alcibiades. ETHICAL THEORIES & APPLICATION Identifies knowledge with virtue Believes “the unexamined life is not worth living” Socratic paradox PLATO (428 – 348 BCE) Born in Athens, Greece towards the end of what is known as the Golden Age of Pericles Athens. Have come from the young Aristocles’ wrestling coach due to his broad shoulders; platon is the Greek word for “broad” Student and disciple of Socrates; Aristotle was his student Founded the Academy around 385 B.C. Father of western philosophy His well-known ideas include: The forms or platonic forms, concept of duality, beliefs on ethics, concept of the soul, and the allegory of the cave ETHICAL THEORIES Virtue Ethics “Human behavior flows from three main sources: Desire, Emotion, and Knowledge.” The reasoning of what is moral is decided by the person, instead of by rules or consequences; you decide what’s moral and right, not by what will happen. Plato believed that the human soul is divided into three parts: 1. Reason – thinking ability to judge 2. Spirit – emotional ability to feel empathy 3. Appetite – desires These three parts should be balanced to be able to make good decisions and choices. Plato devoted his whole life to one goal: helping people reach a state called Eudaimonia (fulfillment) EUDAIMONIA Condition of human flourishing or of living well Requires something extra/arete, or excellence and pure knowledge o Knowledge of all things is important, but knowledge of itself is more important o A person with arete/pure knowledge is someone who would attain Eudaimonia or fulfilling life APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES 1. Live honorably – the man who is conscious of no wrongdoing is filled with the comfort of old age. Happiness is deeply connected to ethics, hence, living virtuously is actually preventing you from achieving Eudaimonia. 2. Be in charge of your own happiness – the man who makes everything that leads to happiness depend upon himself and not upon other men, has adopted the very best plan for living happily. Happiness is a form of personal growth; we should not complain of unhappiness, waiting for other people to make us happy. 3. Care about the happiness of others – in caring for the happiness of others, we find our own. Plato linked happiness with being moral. Real happiness should include striving to contribute to the common good of society. ARISTOTLE The father of political science Ancient green philosopher and scientist; one of the greatest intellectual figures of Western history Even after the intellectual revolutions of the Renaissance, the Reformation, and the Enlightenment, Aristotelian concepts remained embedded in Western thinking Founder of formal logic, devising for it a finished system that for centuries was regarded as the sum of discipline. His writings in ethics and political theory as well as in metaphysics and the philosophy of science continues to be studied, and his work remains a powerful current in contemporary philosophical debate. ETHICAL THEORIES 1. Virtue Ethics – a philosophy developed by Aristotle and other ancient Greeks. The quest to understand and live a life of moral character. an ethical theory that emphasizes an individual’s character rather than following a set of rules. This character-based approach to morality assumes that we acquire virtue through practice. Why do we need to be virtuous? o Eudaimonia is a state or condition of “good spirit”, which means “happiness or welfare”. For him, it is the highest human good. What exactly does it mean to be virtuous? o Having virtue means doing the right thing, at the right time, in the right way, in the right amount, toward the right people. 2. The Four Cardinal Values a. Prudence – judge well about what the right action is b. Justice – disposes one to do what is right and to want to do what is right c. Temperance – seeking legitimate pleasures at the right time and in the right way d. Courage – strikes the mean with regard to feelings of fear and confidence APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES 1. Virtue Ethics o Practicing being honest, brave, just, generous, and so on. A person develops an honorable and moral character. o Treating our character as a lifelong project, one that has capacity to truly change who we are. 2. Prudence o Aristotle refers to the practical wisdom that a person should develop as a part of his personality. According to him, prudence is a prerequisite to demonstrate the virtue of courage. The latter requires practical judgments before a person acts. 3. Justice o Aristotle refers to actions that are lawful and fair. Fairness involves the demonstration of equity and redressal of inequity in day-to-day life. Justice is to give your enemy what is due to them in the proper ways. 4. Temperance o Aristotle means self-control, and moderation demonstrated both in war and peace, on a collective and individual level, is a virtue. 5. Courage o The demonstration of moderation with respect to foolhardiness and overconfidence. To put it in simple words, it is an observance of mean with reference to feelings of fear and confidence in daily life. ST. THOMAS AQUINAS ST. AUGUSTINE Aurelius Augustinus, also called Saint Augustine of Hippo or St. Augustine, was born in 354 at Tagaste, Algeria, in North Africa. He was the bishop of Hippo from 396 to 430 and one of the Latin Fathers of the Church. In Roman Catholicism, he is formally recognized as a doctor of the church. Baptized at the age of 33 by Bishop Ambrose of Milan Augustine’s decision to embrace the Catholic faith was at the same time a commitment to spend the reminder of his life as a “servant of God”, that is, even though he had been living for years with a woman who he deeply loved, and with whom he had fathered a son, to whom he gave the name Adeodatus. ETHICAL THEORY According to the book of “The Cambridge Companion to Augustine,” Augustine regards ethics as an enquiry into the “Summum Bonum: the supreme good”. It says that it provides the happiness that all human beings seek. He also developed the platonic idea of the rational soul into a Christian view in which humans are essentially souls, using their bodies as a means to achieve their spiritual end. It was also through him that Christianity received the platonic theme for the relative inferiority of bodily pleasures. APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORY 1. Man must seek to grow in virtue 2. Man must seek to grow in knowledge 3. Man must seek to grow in love Happiness is the bottom line of St. Augustine’s theory, man’s pursuit of happiness through participation in God. Also called the angelic doctor; greatest Scholastic philosophers Produced a comprehensive synthesis of Christian theology and Aristotelian philosophy that influenced Roman Catholic doctrine for centuries and was adopted as the official philosophy of the church in 1917. ETHICAL THEORY “Good should be done or pursued, and evil (or badness) avoided.” APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORY For an action to be moral, the kind it belongs to must not be bad, the circumstances must be appropriate, and the intention must be virtuous. He believed that all actions are directed towards ends and that happiness is the final end. Happiness is not equated with pleasure, material possessions, honor, or any sensual good, but consists in activities in accordance with virtue. EMMANUEL KANT Highly influenced German philosopher Born into an artisan family of modest means Kant’s famous work, the critique of pure reason, published in 1781, when he was 57 years old. He published rather prolifically and his work gained attraction across Europe. He wrote other two critiques: the critique of practical reason and the critique of the power of judgment. ETHICAL THEORY Deontology o An ethical approach centered on rules and professional duties o Derives from the Greek word deont, which refers to that which is binding Kant’s deontological philosophy stemmed from his belief that humans possess the ability to reason and understand universal moral laws that they can apply in all situations. o He divided his deontological beliefs between hypothetical and categorical imperatives. Hypothetical Imperatives – actions we ought to take, but only if we have a goal; depends on some condition; it should only be obeyed if you wish to achieve some specific goal. Categorical Imperatives – actions we ought to take regardless of whether doing so would enable us to get anything we want; it should always be obeyed, regardless of your goals. APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORY 1. Reason is the slave of passion 2. The delicacy of taste and passion 3. The is/ought problem THOMAS HOBES 1. The will 2. The categorical imperative 3. Kingdom of ends DAVID HUME Scottish enlightenment philosopher who is best known today for his highly influential system of philosophical empiricism, skepticism, and naturalism Argued the existence of innate ideas Argued that inductive reasoning and belief in causality cannot be justified rationally. Influenced utilitarianism, logical positivism, the philosophy of science, early analytic philosophy, cognitive science, theology, and many other fields of thinkers ETHICAL THEORY Commonly known for his philosophical skepticism and empiricist theory of knowledge His ethical though grapples with questions about the relationship: o Between morality and reason o The role of human emotion in thought and action o The nature of moral evaluation o Human sociability o What it means to live a virtuous life His ethical theory continues to be relevant for contemporary philosophers and psychologists interested in topics such as metaethics, the role of sympathy and empathy within moral evaluation and moral psychology, as well as virtue ethics. English philosopher, scientist, and historian. Known for his 1651 book, Leviathan Considered to be one of the founders of modern political philosophy; justified wide-ranging government powers on the basis of the selfinterested consent of citizens Became a member of several networks of intellectuals in England and also became acquainted with the circle of scientists, theologians, and philosophers presided over by the theologian Marin Mersenne Hobbism became a byword for all respectable society ought to denounce ETHICAL THEORIES 1. Social Contract Theory Method of justifying political principles or arrangements by appeal to the agreement that would be made among suitably situated rational, free, and equal persons People live together in society in accordance with an agreement that establishes moral and political rules of behavior We can live morally by our own choice and not because a divine being requires it 2. Psychological Egoism The position that we always do that act that we perceive to be in our own best self-interest All behaviors are motivated by self interest where every action or behavior or decision of every person is motivated by self-interest. APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES Social contract theory says that people live together in society in accordance with an agreement that establishes moral and political rules of behavior. It sets out what the government can and cannot do. People who choose to live in certain place agree to be governed by the moral and political obligations outlined in the social contract. Social contract provides a valuable framework for harmony in society. SOREN KEIRKEEGARD Danish philosopher who imposed restrictions on his own love and emotions and declared the idea of subjectivity as truth, is now recognized as the founder of existentialism, an influential author in psychological, and an important figure in postmodernism His father, Michael Pedersen Keirkeegard, was regarded as the father of existentialism and existential psychology. German philosopher, economist, historian, and socialist revolutionary Studies law and philosophy in University of Berlin Involved in radicalism at a young age through the Young Hegelians In 1847, the newly founded Communist League in London, England, drafted Marx and Engels to write “The Communist Manifesto”, published the following year ETHICAL THEORIES ETHICAL THEORY Divine command from God and transcends ethics. o The choice is to obey God unconditionally is a true existential decision faced by every individual o Either one chooses to live in faith (the religious stage) or to live ethically (the ethical stage) o She clearly advocates for choosing the religious stage of living as the ultimate goal. Teleological suspension of the ethical o The event that a command from God take precedence over all moral and even rational obligations. o Fulfilling one’s purpose (telos) justifies actions that contradict social ethics. However, knowing when this situation may apply to one’s ethical dilemma is not always clear. o Faith allows one to believe that an unethical action will actually result in a better end. APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES Philosophical counseling and psychotherapy o Adapted and applied by mental health professionals whom he feels cannot do his job if she uses a textbook to shield herself from the personal and experiential tool of empathy. KARL MARX Marxism o The political and economic theories of Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, later developed by their followers to form the basis for the theory and practice of communism Communism advocates for a classless system in which all property and wealth are communally (rather than privately) owned A global movement, inspiring and expediting inevitable working-class revolutions throughout the capitalist world o Posits that the struggle between social classes – specifically between the bourgeoisie, or capitalists, and the proletariat, or workers o The main goal is achieving a classless society throughout the world Socialism o Not a society of regimented, automatized individuals, regardless of whether there is equality of income or not, and regardless of whether they are well fed and well clad o A political and economic system in which property and the means of production are owned in common, typically controlled by the state or government. o Based on the idea that common or public ownership of resources and means of production leads to a more equal society. o For Marx, it permits the actualization of man’s essence, by overcoming his alienation. STUART MILL The son of James Mill and Harriet Barrow Philosopher and economist; learned Green and Latin, calculus, and economics at a young age. His wife, Harriet Hardy Taylor, helped turn Mill’s attention to the progressive ideals which she was passionate about: socialism, women’s rights, individual liberty, and a “utopian” view of humanity improvability. ETHICAL THEORIES Great Happiness Principle o Determine whether an individual’s action is good or bad. Utilitarianism o A normative ethical theory that defines good in terms of overall happiness. Actions that increase pleasure and decrease suffering are good. Actions that decrease pleasure and increase sufferings are bad. o He defines “utilitarianism” as the creed that considers a particular “theory of life” as the foundation of morals. APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES 1. Utilitarianism is one of the most popular normative theories in modern philosophy. a. Effective in the field of animal ethics i. Many ethicists argue that eating and using animal products causes more suffering to animals than pleasure to human; therefore, it is morally wrong. b. Utilitarian reasoning can be used for many different purposes i. It can be used both for moral reasoning ii. Rational decision-making iii. Applying in different contexts, it can also be used for deliberations about the interests of different persons and groups iv. Vaccinations v. Charity work rather than staying and chilling at home FRIEDRICH NIETZCHE German philosopher and cultural critic Used his psychological analyses to support original theories about the nature of the self and provocative proposals Also objects to the content of our contemporary moral commitments The birth of tragedy our of the spirit of music (1872) Famous for compromising criticisms of traditional European morality and religion, as well as of conventional philosophical ideas and social and political pieties associated with modernity. ETHICAL THEORIES Morality – Master-Slave Morality; for him, the world was divided into two realms: o Masters The minority groups Wealthy, powerful, nobles Follows the master morality o Slaves Majority of people No power/wealth/strength Follows the slave morality APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES 1. Origin of master-slave morality From the Judeo-Christian History The enslavement of the Jews in Egypt developed and internalized a moral code suitable for surviving slavery 2. Slave morality Believes that slave morality is everywhere Anytime people ground their morality to some master rather themselves Christians to Christianity, Nazis to the National Socialist German Party, soldiers to their commanders 3. Master morality Believes that the only time master morality is being practiced is when a person thinks for himself/herself and lives by his/her own rules. They only think that things are good is because they believe and desire it to be good JOHN RAWLS American political and ethical philosopher Best known for his defense of egalitarian liberalism in his major work “A Theory of Justice” (1971) Widely considered the most important political philosopher of the 20th century Enlisted in the army and served with the infantry in the South Pacific until his discharge in 1945 Strongly influenced by traditional social contract theories expounded by Locke and Rousseau Justice as fairness is sort of social glue that binds society together Social and economic inequalities are to satisfy two conditions: 1. They are to be attached to offices and positions open to all under conditions of fair equality of opportunity 2. They are to be the greatest benefit of the leastadvantaged members of society APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORIES ETHICAL THEORY 1. Utilitarian principle – greatest happiness of the greatest number 2. Intuitionist principle – those considered appropriate or acceptable by the citizens 3. Egoistic principle – society is ordered, if at all, for the sole benefit of the individual Rawls proposes his own principles by which a just society could be guided: 1. There must be basic freedoms (freedom of speech, association, religion) 2. The inequalities which inevitably result from freedom are so arranged to bring most benefit to the worst-off, including full equality of opportunity The veil of ignorance as a path to justice – eliminates prejudices because each person is blind to their station in life Justice as fairness – the heir to the social contract theory but distinct from utilitarian forms of justice o Social justice involves the appropriate distribution of the benefits and burdens of social cooperation Two Principles of Social Justice Concerns Political Institutions 1. First principle Each person has the same and indefeasible (permanent) claim to a fully adequate scheme of equal basic liberties, which scheme is compatible with the same scheme of liberties for all 2. Second principle Theory of justice o Resolve the problem of distributive justice in society o Create a conception of justice as fairness that can apply in a constitutional democracy o Disadvantages are neutralized and everyone receives the same benefits of justice o Fairness as a corporate doctrine can be applied to all stakeholders and define a culture of trust and openness, with all the corresponding benefits, in marketing, advertising, board development, client relations, and so on ALBERT CAMUS 1. 2. 3. French philosopher, author, dramatist, and journalist Received the 1957 Nobel Prize in Literature at the age of 44 for his important literary production, which with clear-sighted earnestness illuminates the problems of the human conscience in our times The three novels published during his lifetime: The stranger The plague The fall His two major philosophical essays 1. The myth of Sisyphus 2. The rebel His belief was that the absurd – life being void of meaning, or man’s inability to know that meaning if it were to exist – was something that man should embrace He defined the absurd as the futility of a search for meaning in an incomprehensible universe, devoid of God, or meanings ETHICAL THEORY Absurdism o Human beings exist in a purposeless, chaotic universe o One way to deal with absurdity of life is acceptance o Two life lessons from Camus which can help us appreciate the absurdity of life: 1. Create your own meaning of life 2. Don’t make happiness a distant goal APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORY The Myth of Sisyphus o He uses the Greek legend of Sisyphus o Condemned by the Gods for eternity to repeatedly roll a boulder up a hill only to have it roll down again once he got it to the top, as a metaphor for the “individual’s persistent struggle against the essential absurdity of life.” o A man overcomes struggles by accepting life is absurd and (efforts are pointless) while also grasping that he alone gets to decide how to live and feel within. o “The realization that life is absurd cannot be an end, but a beginning.” o By realizing it all absurd, a man could have the opportunity to rebel against the meaninglessness. o One of the only coherent philosophical positions is REVOLT, and revolt is a constant confrontation between man and his own obscurity. CAROL GILIGAN Received an A.B. with highest honors in English literature from Swarthmore College, a master’s degree in clinical psychology from Radcliffe College, and a Ph.D. in social psychology from Harvard University Developed psychologist best known for her research into the moral development of girls and women. Worked alongside leading psychologists Erik Erikson and Lawrence Kohlberg who influenced her In 1982, Giligan published “In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development” ETHICAL THEORIES Giligan’s work on moral development outlines how a woman’s morality is influenced by relationships and how women form their moral and ethical foundation based on how their decisions will affect others. Level of Moral Development 1. Preconventional morality – there is a strong focus on survival and self-interest 2. Conventional – women prioritize selflessness and caring about others 3. Postconventional – women emphasize taking responsibility for the consequences of their choices and gaining control of their own lives Levels of Thinking 1. Care-based morality – kind of thinking found in women (mother); more emphasize is given to inter-connected and universality 2. Justice-based morality – kind of thinking found in men (father); view the world as being composed of autonomous individuals who interact with one another APPLICATION OF ETHICAL THEORY Ethics of Care o Living in relationship with one another Moral orientations o Care-based morality – based on real relationship o Justice-based morality – based on abstract principle Three stages of moral development o Pre-conventional Stage: I love me (selfinterest) Caring for one’s self Individual survival o Conventional Stage: I love you more than me (selflessness) Caring for others Self-sacrifice Selfishness to responsibility towards others o Post-conventional Stage: I love me and you (balanced) Caring for self and others Non-violence Transition to balance and interdependency HUMAN ACT VS. ACT OF MAN 1. Human Act Knowledge Freedom Voluntariness 2. Act of Man Sleepwalking Consequence Responsibility UTILITARIANISM An ethical theory known as utilitarianism establishes right from wrong by emphasizing results. It embodies consequentialism in some way. According to utilitarianism, the decision that will result in the greatest good for the largest number of people is the most morally right one. DEONTOLOGY An ethical theory that distinguishes between right and wrong using rules. Immanuel Kant, a philosopher, is frequently linked to deontology. Kant held that moral behavior must abide by general moral principles, such as “don’t lie, don’t steal, don’t cheat.” In other words, an ethical theory that asserts that behaviors are good/evil in accordance with a certain set of guidelines. Deon, which means duty in Greek, is where it gets its name. These guidelines define what constitutes ethical behavior, and what does not. ETHICS OF CARE Feminist ethics is approached through the lens of ethics of care. It criticizes conventional moral theories as flawed and male-centric to the extent that they were remove/minimize traits and qualities typically associated with women or with the rules that are frequently portrayed as “feminine”. VIRTUE OF ETHICS Arguably the oldest ethical theory in the world, with origins in Ancient Greece. Defines good actions as ones that display embody virtuous character traits, like courage, loyalty, or wisdom HEDONISM The word “hedonism” is derived from the Greek word for pleasure. According to psychological or motivational hedonism, we are exclusively motivated by pleasure or suffering. In addition, according to ethical or evaluative hedonism, only happiness has value and only suffering has disvalue, which is the polar opposite of worth. EUDAIMONIA The highest and ultimate aim of both moral and thought and behavior (Plato). A broad concept to describe the highest good humans could strive toward – or a life “well lived” (Aristotle). MORAL EVALUATION Moral Agent o A person who has the ability to discern right from wrong and to be held accountable for his or her own actions. o Have a moral responsibility not to cause unjustified harm. o By expecting people to act as moral agents, we hold people accountable for the harm they cause others. Moral Act o An act is morally good when we make choices coherent to our true good and brings us closer to God. o The goodness of a moral act is assessed based on three conditions: 1. Object (and its goodness) 2. Intention (or end as expressed by St. Thomas Aquinas) 3. Circumstances ELEMENTS FOR ACTS TO BE CONSIDERED JUSTIFIABLE