s BUSBAR SIZING CALCULATION FOR SWITCHYARD CONDUCTOR Index of Revisions 1 0 07.04.11 30.12.10 Neeraj Kumar Neeraj Kumar S.Jain S.Jain Revised as per comments First Issue Rev. Date Coord. Checker Details of Revision JINDAL INDIA THERMAL POWER LIMITED 2x600 MW/600 MW+10% THERMAL POWER PROJECT AT DERANG, ANGUL, ORISSA Date Prepared by Coord. by Checked by Department 29.12.10 29.12.10 29.12.10 Name Manish Gupta Neeraj Kumar Saurabh Jain sgd. SPEL-EN 18 Document No. Type of Document SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 Rev. No. 1 Ver. 1 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s Contents 1 Introduction 3 2 System Data 3 3 Conductor 4 4 Other Referred Inputs 4 5 Attachments 5 6 Conclusion 5 7 References 5 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa Page 2 of 5 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s 1 Introduction: The thermal calculation for conductors may be broadly divided into two categories: a. Continuous Current Carrying Capacity The current carrying capacity of a conductor is the maximum steady-state current inducing a given temperature rise in the conductor, for given ambient conditions. The continuous current carrying capacity depends on the type of conductor, its electrical resistance, the maximum allowable temperature rise and ambient conditions. The conductor ampacity is limited by the conductor’s maximum operating temperature. The temperature of a conductor depends upon the balance of heat input and output. The conductor in an outdoor switchyard gains heat mainly from solar radiation incident on it and the heat generated by Joule effect. Conductor looses heat by radiation and convection from its surface. This relationship is expressed in the Heat balance Equation which in turn gives the value of allowable magnitude of current through the conductor (for details refer detail calculation). b. Short Circuit Current Carrying Capacity A conductor’s temperature will rise rapidly under fault conditions. This is due to the inability of the conductor to dissipate the heat as rapidly as it is generated. The magnitude and duration of short circuit fault current that can be sustained by the conductor depends upon the electrical conductivity and area of cross-section of the conductor withstanding the fault current. This fault current withstanding capacity is limited to the maximum allowable temperature rise of the conductor based on its material properties beyond which the conductors become vulnerable to annealing. In the present calculation, the conductor area necessary for withstanding the fault current for the given time duration is determined 0 considering final conductor temperature limited to 200 C. 2 System Data: Switchyard 1 2 3 4 5 6 Nominal System Voltage System Frequency Short Circuit Fault Current at Bus Duration of Fault Current Design Ambient Temperature Maximum Operating Temperature 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa 400 50 50 1 50 85 kV Hz kA sec °C °C Page 3 of 5 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s 3 Other Referred Inputs: A. Calculation for Flexible Conductor 1 Solar Radiation Absorption Coefficient 2 Intensity of Solar Radiation at Site 3 Emissive Coefficient of Conductor with respect to Black Body 4 Minimum Wind Speed at Site 5 Temperature Coefficient of Electrical Resistance of Conductor 0.5 (as per Cl. No. 3.10 of IEC 1597 : 1995) 1050 W / m 2 0.5 (as per Cl. No. 3.10 of IEC 1597 : 1995) 1 m/s 0.00403 K 1 B. Calculation for Rigid Conductor 1 2 3 4 4 Solar Radiation Absorption Coefficient Maximum Operating Temperature of Conductor Emissive Coefficient of Conductor with respect to Black Body Conductivity of Al Alloy Tube 0.5 ( Table-C.5 IEEE605) 85°C 0.5 (Table-C.5 IEEE605) 55 % IACS Conductor Data: A. Flexible Conductor AAC"TARANTULA" 1 Conductor Diameter 2 Total Cross-sectional Area 3 DC Resistance at 20 °C 36.6 794.8 0.0363 mm mm 2 / km B. Rigid Conductor 4 1/2" Heavy 1 Outer Diameter 2 Wall Thickness 3 Conductivity of Al Tube 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa 120 12.00 55 mm mm % IACS Page 4 of 5 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s 5 Attachments: Attachment1 : Calculation of continuous current carrying capacity for flexible conductor (AAC"TARANTULA") Attachment2 : Check for circuit current withstand capicity of flexible conductor (Twin AAC"TARANTULA") Attachment3 : Calculation of continuous current carrying capacity of Tubular Conductor (4 1/2" Heavy) Attachment4 : Check for circuit current withstand capicity of Tubular Conductor (4 1/2" Heavy) 6 Conclusion: The following table summarize the result: a. Flexible Conductor Conductor Type Twin AAC"TARANTULA" Fault Current Carrying Operating Temperature Current (kA) Capacity (A) 2460 85 Duration of Fault Current (sec) 1 50 b. Rigid Conductor Conductor Type 4 1/2" Heavy 7 Current Carrying Operating Fault Capacity (A) Temperature Current (kA) 2823.70 85 Duration of Fault Current (sec) 50 1 References: 1. IEC 1597:1995: Overhead Electrical Conductors - Calculation Methods for Stranded Bare Conductors. 2. IEC 865:1993: Short-Circuit Currents - Calculation of Effects 3. IEEE Std 605: 1998 IEEE Guide for design of Substation Rigid-Bus Structures 4. Technical Specification for 400 kV Substation 5. ABB T&D Book. 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa Page 5 of 5 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s Attachment 1 Calculation of continuous current carrying capacity for flexible conductor Reference Document : IEC 1597. Designation of OHL Conductor : AAC"TARANTULA" Design Inputs : a. b. c. d. e. Overall Diameter of conductor Cross-sectional area Design Ambient Temperature Maximum Operating Temperature Temperature coefficient of resistance D A Ta Tf 1. The heat balance equation is : = = = = = 36.6 794.8 50 85 0.00403 mm mm2 0 C 0 C Pj + Psol = Prad + Pconv ……(1) where, Pj is the heat generated by Joule effect W/m Psol is the solar heat gain by the conductor surface W/m Prad is the heat loss by radiation of the conductor W/m Pconv is the convection heat loss W/m 2. The power loss, Pj, due to Joule effect is given by : Pj = RT . I 2 ……(2) where, RT is the electrical resistance of conductor at a temperature T (/m) I is the conductor current (A) The value of DC resistance for the conductor at 20°C => The value of DC resistance for the conductor at 85°C = = R20[1 + (Tf-20)] = = Now, where, 0.0363 /km 3.6300E-05 /m 4.5809E-05 /m 7.3722E-02 /mile from Electrical T & D Ref. Book - ABB X= 0 .063598 f RDC = = f = = = 1.0 (non-magnetic materials) 50 Hz = RT = 1.0382 (Table 5, Ch.3 of Ref. 5) 4.7558E-05 /m permeability frequency ='> Skin Effect ratio, K, corresponding to the value of X Therefore AC resistance at 85°C is 1.6563 (Rdc in /mile) The value of RT will be substituted in equation 2 and value of I will be found. Refer Equation 8 below. 3. The solar heat gain, Psol, is given by : Psol = . D . S i where, is the solar radiation absorption coefficient = D is the conductor diameter S i is the intensity of solar radiation = = Hence, Psol = 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa ……(3) 0.5 0.03660 m 2 1050.00 W/m 19.22 W/m Page 1 of 2 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s Prad = s . . D . K e . (T24 - T14) 4. Heat loss by radiation, Prad, is given by : where, s is the Stefan-Boltzmann constant D is the conductor diameter K e is the emissivity coefficient in respect to black body T 1 is the ambient temperature = 50°C T 2 is the final equilibrium temperature = 85°C = = = = = Prad = Hence, 5.67E-08 0.03660 0.5 323 358 ……(4) W.m-2.K-4 m K K 18.06 W/m Pconv = . Nu . (T2 - T1) . ……(5) Nu is the Nusselt number and is given by the equation : Nu = 0.65Re0.2 + 0.23Re0.61 ……(6) Re is the Reynolds number and is given by equation : Re = 1.644x109.v .D [T1+0.5(T2-T1)]-1.78 ……(7) 5. Convection heat loss is given by : where, is the thermal conductivity of the air film in contact with the conductor T 1 is the ambient temperature = = T 2 is the final equilibrium temperature v is the wind speed (minimum) D is the conductor diameter = -1 -1 0.02585 W.m .K = = = = 323 358 1.00 0.03660 => Re = 1871.606 => Nu = 25.725 50°C 85°C Hence, Pconv = K K m/s m 73.12 W/m I = [(Prad + Pconv - Psol)/RT]1/2 6. The steady-state current carrying capacity is : ……(8) Where, Hence, a Single conductor can carry a continuous current Prad Pconv Psol RT = = = = I 18.06 73.12 19.22 4.7558E-05 W/m W/m W/m /m 1230 A Therefore, TWIN AAC"TARANTULA" conductor is capable of carrying a continuous current = 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa 2460 A Page 2 of 2 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s Attachment - 2 Check for circuit current withstand capicity of flexible conductor Reference Document : IEC 865 Designation of OHL Conductor : Twin AAC"TARANTULA" I th I k'' m n Thermal equivalent short-time current is given by: I k'' I k with (IEC865-1, equation-63) See Section 4.6.3, IEC 60909-0 where: I th is thermal equivalent short-time current (r.m.s, in A) I k'' is initial symmetrical short-circuit current (r.m.s, in A) I k is steady state short-circuit current (r.m.s, in A) m is factor for the heat effect of the d.c. component n is factor for the heat effect of the a.c. component Factor m is given by: m (IEC865-1,A.8) 1 e 4 fTk ln( 1) 1 2 fk ln( 1) where: is factor for calculating peak short-circuit current f is frequency in Hz Tk is duration of short-circuit current (sec) Factor n is given by: 2 2 '' ' ' I ' I T' I' T' 1 d 1 e 20 Tk / Td k k d 1 e 2Tk / Td k 1 2Tk 20Tk Ik Ik Ik ' '' ' ' ' ' ' Td 1 e 10 Tk / Td I k I k 2Td 1 e Tk / Td I k 1 I I 5Tk k k I k Tk ' '' ' ' Td ' I I I 1 e 10.1Tk / Td k k k 1 I k I k I k 5.051Tk n I 1 '' k / Ik 2 with I k' I k'' / I k Ik 0 . 88 0 .17 I k'' / I k T d' 3 .1 I / Ik ' k Thermal equivalent short-circuit current density is given by: S th I th Ac ………………(6) where Ac is the cross-sectional area of aluminum conductor Bare Conductor have sufficient thermal short-circuit strength as long as the following relation holds: S th S thr T kr Tk 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa (IEC865-1, equation-67) Page 1 of 2 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s with S thr K where K (IEC865-1, equation-69) T kr 20 c 1 20 e 20 C ln 20 1 20 b 20 C (IEC865-1, A.9) S thr is the rated short-time withstand current density (r.m.s) for T kr sec. Tkr is rated short-time e is conductor temperature at the end of a short circuit b is conductor temperature at the beginning of a short circuit For aluminum alloy and ACSR conductor with base temperature of 20 °C 20 c 20 = 34800000 = 910 = 2700 = 0.00403 Now for the given system: Conductor No. of subconductors f e b Tkr Tk Ik I k per sub- conductor I k'' per subconductor = = Twin AAC"TARANTULA" 2 = 50 Hz = 200 °C = 85 °C = = 1 sec 1 sec = 1.8 = 50 kA = 25 kA = 25 kA m = I k' / I k Td' n = I th Ac = 25.554038 kA = = 794.8 mm 2 0.0007948 m 2 S th = 32151.533 kA / m 2 K = 81465472 S thr = 81465472 A / m = 81465.472 kA / m 2 = = 0.045 1 3.1 sec 1 (IEC865-1,1993, Figure 12b) 2 Since S th < S thr , Twin AAC"TARANTULA"Twin conductor can safely withstand fault current of 50kA for 1 sec with final conductor temperature of 200 °C. 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa Page 2 of 2 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s Attachment - 3 Calculation of continuous current carrying capacity of Tubular Conductor Reference Document : IEEE 605-1998 Designation of tube : 4 1/2" Heavy Design Inputs : a. b. c. d. e. g. Outer Diameter of tube Wall Thickness Cross-sectional area Design Ambient Temperature Maximum Operating Temperature Conductivity of Al Tube = = = = = = Ta Tf C' 120 12 4071.50 50 85 55 mm mm mm2 °C °C % IACS I2RF+qs=qc+qr+qcond 1. The heat balance equation is : ……(1) where, I is the current for allowable temperature rise (A) R is direct current resistance at the operating temperature (/ft) F is the skin effect coefficient qs is the solar heat gain (W/ft) qc is the convective heat loss (W/ft) qr is the radiation heat loss (W/ft) qcond is the conductive heat loss (W/ft) 2. The DC resistance and skin effect coefficient at operating tempreature is calculated as : Outer Diameter of tube Thickness of Tube d = t = 4.728 inch 0.47 inch Now, as per C.3.2.9 IEEE 605, the resistance of aluminium conductor at a temperature is expressed as : -4 RT2 = (8.145*10 /C'A2)*[1+0.00403*C'(T2-20)/61] where C' A2 = = Conductivity of Al conductor in % IACS Cross-sectional area of conductor in in2 2 6.31 in 85 °C = T2 = Hence for 85°C temperature, the value of RT2 is calculated as : RT2 Skin effect ratio = 2.85E-06 /ft F 1 3 .409 10 13 2.078 3.92 3 .32 10 21 4.55 ……(2) valid for 0.05 t / d 0.4 with t/d , f / R where, f is system frequency = 50 X Y Z = = = 0.1 2313.568 6.499406 and hence skin effect ratio T2 and 6 .50 1 .27 3.33 2000 f / R 3000 T2 Hz (RT2 in /m) F = 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa 1.4323 Page 1 of 2 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s qs = 0.00695*6*Qs*A9*K*sin() 3. The solar heat gain, qs, is given by : where, 6 is the solar radiation absorption coefficient = effective angle of incidenceof Sun = cos-1*[cosHc*cos(Zc-Z1)] considering Hc = 0.5 = 90 deg = 88 deg Zc = 180 deg Z1 = 90 deg 2 97.55 W/ft 2 56.70 in /ft Q s is the intensity of solar radiation A' is projected area of conductor,Square inches per foot = = = 12*sin* conductor size K = Heat multiplying factors for high altitudes = Hence, qr = 36.9*10-12**A (Tc4 - Ta4) where, A is the conductor surface area is the emissivity coefficient in respect to black body T a is the temperature of 50 °C surrounding bodies in kelvin T c is the maximum operating 85 °C temperature of conductor Hence, ……(4) = = = 2 178.24 in /ft 0.5 323 K = 358 K qr = 18.22 W/ft qc = d-0.4*A*T 5. Forced convection heat loss is given by : ……(5) heat transfer is considered at wind speed 2fps and 1 atm pressure where, T difference in temperature in deg C = between conductor surface and ambient qc = Hence, 35.0 °C 33.51 W/ft I = [(qr + qc - qs)/RF]1/2 6. The steady-state current carrying capacity is : qcond is neglected for practical purposes Where, qr qc qs R85F Hence, a Tubular Bus Conductor can carry a continuous current withstanding a 35 °C temperature rise above ambient I = = = = 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa (As per TableC.1, Pg-57 : IEEE 605 1998) 1.00 (Table-C.1, Pg-58 IEEE 605-1998) 19.22 W/ft qs = 4. Heat loss by radiation, qr, is given by : ……(3) 18.22 33.51 19.22 4.08E-06 ……(6) W/ft W/ft W/ft /ft 2824 A Page 2 of 2 SIEM-JITPL.5404A-EL-3-2026 s Attachment - 4 Check for circuit current withstand capicity of Tubular Conductor Reference Document : IEE 605-1998 Designation of tube : 4 1/2" Heavy Maximum Fault Current that can be allowed to flow through the tubular conductor with it's final temperature within the limits determined by it's mechanical properties is given by :I where, C x 106 A [1/t log10{Tf - 20 + (15150/G) / Ti - 20 + (15150/G)}]1/2 A ………………(1) I = Maximum allowable root mean square value of fault current (A) C = 0.144 A = Conductor cross-sectional area (in2) G = Conductor conductivity (% International Annealed Copper Standard, IACS) t = Duration of fault (s) Tf = Allowable final conductor temperature (°C) = Ti = Conductor temperature at fault initation (°C) Therefore, for a system with given fault level, the cross-sectional area of the conductor suited to withstand the fault current for the defined duration and within the allowable final temperature is determined from the equatioin above a From eqn ..(1), the expression for area of conductor is A = (1/C ) x 10-6 I [t / log10{Tf - 20 + (15150/G) / Ti - 20 + (15150/G)}]1/2 in2 Now, for the given system the values are :I = G = C' = t = Tf = => 50 55.00 1 200 kA % IACS sec °C Ti = 50 °C A = 0.83 in2 Therefore, required Cross-sectional Area of the conductor suited to withstand the fault current for the defined duration and within the allowable final temperature of the conductor A = 537.81 mm2 4071.50 mm2 Now, Cross-sectional Area of selected Al Tube At = At > A Hence, actual cross-sectional area of the tube, At (4071.5 mm2) is more than the required cross-sectional area A ( 537.81 mm2) Thus selected Al. Tube is capable of withstanding the Short Circuit Fault Current safely. 2x600 MW Thermal Power Plant Project at Derang, Angul, Orissa Page 1 of 1