SEI Lesson Tool Name: _______Kelly Nash______________________ Date: _________10/20/15_______________ Grade Level___2_____ Teaching Context: 2nd grade- regular education Curriculum or Content Area: 2nd grade- general education ___17____ students in my class, of which ____2___ are ELLs My ELLs’ linguistic and cultural background(s): A.A. mostly speaks Russian at home with her family. When talking with her brother she usually speaks English. Did not attend any pre-school. She speaks and understands Russian and is taking classes to learn to read and write as well. Her parents are well educated and also speak good English. H. C. is new to our school this year, coming from Quincy. He attended a language based pre-school in Quincy in addition to K-1. His family is from China and speaks mostly Mandarin at home. His grandmother speaks a different dialect from China. The parents speak Mandarin almost exclusively but H.C. does speak English with his siblings at home. H does not read or write Mandarin but speaks and understands well. My ELLs’ level(s) of English Proficiency: WIDA ACCESS <Semester/Year> 5.0 4.0 3.2 5.0 4.3 3.8 5.0 4.1 H. C. 2.0 2.0 2.0 4.0 2.2 2.0 3.0 2.3 1 http://www.wida.us/standards/CAN_DOs/ Listening 15%, Speaking 15%, Reading 35%, Writing 35%] A. A. Overall Literacy [Listening30%, Reading 70%] Listening Comprehension Speaking [Listening 50%, Speaking 50%] Writing Oral Language Reading Student(s): [Reading 50%, Writing 50%] See WIDA “Can Do” descriptors1 to help explain proficiency level based on ACCESS scores SEI Lesson Tool Other support services that my ELLs receive: H.C. recently qualified for speech services but has not started receiving them yet. Lesson Standards and Objectives Content State Standards (discipline, standard number, and description): Content Objective(s): Students will be able to participate in a Partner Reading activity during guided reading with an article, The Difference Between Maps and Globes.” Language Objective(s): Language Objectives should be directly linked to the language skills students will need to be successful in achieving the content objective. Language Objectives Differentiation for Proficiency Levels: Mentor Text or Source: From ReadWorks.org- The Difference Between Maps and Globes SEI Lesson Tool Targeted Tiered Vocabulary2 from Mentor Text or Source Tier 2 & Tier 3 words should be integrated into student product/assessment. Ship, people, men, women, children, place, months, dark, wet, houses, built, food, eat, sick, windows, ceiling, ocean Year, ship, ocean, place, home, weather, bad, winds, strong Dog, family, kids, house, grandma, movie, theater, roller coaster, police, hero, home, “give away”, sad, good Letter, writer, question, author, story, date Happy, sad, surprised, tired, bored Round, flat, map, different, same, pocket, planet, place, spin, picture Trip, sailed, worship, land, crops Land, years ago, nearly, land, sail, across, north, plan, end up, Breath/breathe Breathless, breathtaking “lose your breath”, visit, horrible, reward, burglar, view, “wanted”, miracle, “on the horizon”, save/saved, faint, Comparison, transform, amazed, description, craft, body, greeting, closing, signature Glad, ecstatic, excited, satisfied, delighted, joyful, thrilled, blue, depressed, down, gloomy, melancholy, glum, upset, nervous, alarmed, amazed, shocked, stunned, startled, astonished, dazed, lazy, sleepy sluggish, exhausted, flabbergasted Pilgrims, the Mayflower, Atlantic England Pilgrims, Atlantic Ocean, Virginia, Mayflower, Plymouth, Halitosis vs. Hally Tosis (dog’s name) metaphor, simile, sensory images North America, atlas Globe, similar, space, passage Student Prerequisite Skills or Background Knowledge: What content or language knowledge or skills do my ELLs need to successfully complete the content and language objectives? What background knowledge or skills might my ELLs already have in their 2 For more information on Tiered vocabulary, see Beck & McKeon (1985), Calderón (2007). SEI Lesson Tool primary language but may need help in transferring to English? The content, language knowledge and skills that my ELLs need to have to successfully complete the objectives are: -Previous experience with the 7 Steps, Partner Reading, Think Aloud strategies -Previous experience with multiple choice questions and open-ended questions -Knowledge of tiered vocabulary words -Decoding and comprehension strategies to read at a GRL G or above -Previous experience with retelling/summarizing Assessment of content learning and language development: Have I included Tier 2 & Tier 3 words in my assessment of my student’s discourse: written or oral? I will assess my ELLs content learning and language development through: - informal assessments such as observing the students at work - listening in on students during Turn and Talk discussions during the 7 Steps - analyzing the completed multiple choice and open-ended questions - conversing with students as they complete their Partner Reading SEI Lesson Tool Content and Concept Language Integration How have I integrated all possible domains into my teaching and learning strategies and activities? Discourse Integration: Sheltered Instruction Strategies Which domain(s) does my strategy/activity target? How does this strategy connect my content and language objectives? Reading Listening Writing Lesson Sequence: Speaking How does this strategy facilitate my students’ ability to access the content? How does this strategy facilitate my students’ ability to comprehend the mentor text, build essential knowledge, or produce oral or written discourse connected to the content objective? How does this strategy provide comprehensible input for my students? 7 steps X x 1. Developing an understanding of some of the trickier words and concepts before reading the text allowed the students to focus on the overall meaning of the text. They were able to discuss the meaning of the text with a partner and answer follow-up questions that addressed surface level understanding, SEI Lesson Tool more thoughtful inferencing, as well as author’s craft. This strategy helped my ELLs to produce academic discourse by helping them to feel confident about words that they would be using frequently to explain the basis of the text and motive of the Pilgrims to leave England. We had a group discussion about why people would want to leave a place where they weren’t allowed to go the church they wanted, or eat foods that they liked. The discussions caused the students to feel indignant about England’s rules. When I briefly referred to learning that would be coming up about some children not being allowed to go to school because they had to help their parents work, all students had something to add to the discussion. 2. This strategy provides my students with the important vocabulary words they will need to know, understand and use to be able to understand, access, and respond to the content material within the text. The 7-steps is crucial to developing the vocabulary of my ELL students so that they not only learn to use these words within the context of this lesson, but understand and apply them in other related curriculum and beyond. When students turn and talk and try to use the word as many times as they can, the ELL student is hearing a variety of contexts for these new words. If as a class, we display the word and make efforts to use the word throughout the days, weeks, SEI Lesson Tool months, these once “new” words will become a natural part of their vocabulary allowing them access to the content. 3. Without comprehension of these key words, the larger meaning of the story would be missed or misunderstood making demonstrating understanding of the mentor text nearly impossible. With access to key vocabulary words, ELL students establish a foundation to build upon as the concept develops. The 7-steps strategy gives students a practice period in a low-pressure situation, just one peer partner, to try out the word in sentences as well as hearing the word used in a variety of contexts. Oral practice makes using the word in writing significantly easier and much less of a risk when the time comes. 4. This strategy provides comprehensible input by developing understanding of the key words of a content area, unit, or text at an appropriate level for ELL students. The seven-step strategy develops the context for each word in a variety of ways. Students hear the word in the context of a text, a dictionary, and an age/level appropriate definition. Because the strategy provides a predictable structure, a variety of definitions and contexts, and an opportunity to try using the word orally, ELL students are able to develop their understanding of the word. Given this basis for important vocabulary words, students will be SEI Lesson Tool able to use the connections they have made to the presented vocabulary to understand other parts of the text as well. Partner Reading X X X 1. Variation #3 proved effective for ELLs because it provided students the opportunity to discuss the pretaught vocabulary in a low-pressure partner situation. It was helpful for the ELL students to hear the vocabulary being used by native English speakers. The native English speakers in some cases helped their ELL partners with comprehension of the text. The ELL students were able to model their speaking parts after the example of the stronger speaking English students and hear someone else’s opinion and interpretation of the text. Some students were more open and honest than others about their understanding of the text and it was helpful for all students to hear that there were parts that each partner could help with. Both groups of students responded that reading with a partner helped them to keep their focus so that they remembered more details. They also helped them to remember the meanings of the pre-taught vocabulary words. 2. This strategy facilitates my students’ ability to access the content by providing an opportunity to listen to their peers comment about the reading as well as SEI Lesson Tool orally express their own thoughts and opinions. Students also take turns reading enabling ELL students to listen to their peers reading from the same context. This can help ELL students with pronunciation and decoding issues. This support will be useful when they need to access and apply the contextual information at a later date. Hopefully, the chances of the ELL student being understood increase as well. These low-pressure opportunities also allow students to revise and adjust their thinking appropriately in cases of misunderstanding. 3. This strategy is a tremendous aid in facilitating understanding of the mentor text. Hearing the thoughts and opinions of their partner and being held accountable for responding to the text orally keeps the students actively involved with the text. The production of oral discourse is a necessity in the Partner Reading strategy. The fact that the discourse is within a low-pressure situation helps ELL students to take the risk of trying out new language. The first attempt is the most difficult. Used successfully will increase confidence and assist ELL students in using the language in other contexts, including writing. 4. Partner reading provides comprehensible input by allowing the student who is not decoding to focus all of their attention on the meaning of the text. When the SEI Lesson Tool roles switch, the input from a peer regarding the content of the reading is shared, helping the reader to gain a deeper or possible a different interpretation of the text. In both situations, the ELL student only needs to focus on one aspect of reading at a time, making successful comprehension more likely. Partner reading also provides comprehensible input by having a peer relay their thoughts and opinions in a child-friendly way. In most cases, the peer will be using language that is easier for the ELL student to access than if an adult were to share their thinking. Think Aloud X X X 1. This strategy helped my ELL students to achieve the content and language objectives through the use of a model for speaking. A visual track of our thinking as to the parts of a story was on chart paper near me and where my Ell students were sitting. This strategy helped students to produce academic language because they heard the language orally many times before trying it themselves. All of the key words students needed to use was also written on a chart displayed so that every child had access to it. Also, by sharing some of my own thoughts, opinions and experience, they were able to recall some of their own experiences to share with a classmate. 2. Think alouds facilitate my ELL students’ ability to access the content through oral clarification and an SEI Lesson Tool audible thought process by the teacher. Having an adult break down difficult language within the context of the material to be learned helps ELL students to be able to focus on the content instead of the unfamiliar words. Therefore, students can create their own meaning for the content instead of being burdened by a multitude of new language. 3. This strategy is crucial to the comprehension of a mentor text and one I use frequently in all whole class lessons. All students benefit from hearing a teacher’s interpretation, word clarification and connections to a story. Even when students have a decent understanding of the text, hearing the thinking of a teacher helps to deepen their understanding, which facilitates expressing their grasp of the information to others. If students gain confidence through a commonality between their own understanding and their teachers, it increases the likeliness they will share their thinking with the class. Peer sharing in turn increases confidence for others to take a risk and share. 4. Think alouds provide comprehensible input by taking difficult material and bringing it down to the students’ level. In this situation, the teacher has the ability to take a difficult text and make it applicable and comprehensible to students. Activating background knowledge, explaining difficult SEI Lesson Tool vocabulary words and sharing thinking throughout the text makes the content more accessible for ELLs and other students as well. The teacher can also check understanding during the think aloud and provide additional clarification if necessary. RAFT X X X X 1. This strategy helped my ELL students to see an example of what the final product could look like. We brainstormed many possibilities that students could use and this exposed ELL students to a wide variety of possibilities for their own writing. This way, they did not have to come up with everything on their own/with their partner. They were able to piggyback and expand upon ideas they agreed with most. The ELL students in my classroom were able to produce academic language after hearing it modeled thoroughly by myself and their peers. They were able to pull from past charts we produced as a class that broke down craft moves of Jane Yolen’s that we could use in our own writing. 2. This strategy was helpful in providing the access to the content through extensive modeling and partner work. Modeling the process, and deciding on the focus of our letter promoted interest across the classroom. Because the students were invested in the activity, they put more effort into understanding the content so they could relay the connected SEI Lesson Tool information. In order for the student to complete the assignment, they needed to be familiar with the content and able to use the related terms in the correct context. 3. This strategy helped to produce oral and written discourse. Because I gave the second graders a partner to complete this assignment, students needed to agree on what they were going to write before putting it down on paper. In this way, they were able to orally rehearse and bounce their ideas off their partner before recording it. Partners helped each other to include academic language in their writing. For ELL students, working with a partner proved especially important because they had multiple opportunities to hear, speak and write the information related to the content. 4. RAFT provided comprehensible input through the multiple opportunities to see and hear the language necessary to completing the assignment. First, they heard the language during a teacher think aloud and then had time to discuss the material in their own words with a native English-speaking peer. Ratiocination X X X 1. This strategy helped my ELL students by providing them with a word bank to make their writing more interesting and to expand their vocabularies. All students were able to make poignant changes with SEI Lesson Tool the support of a partner, our class charts and teacher support when necessary. Having charts of categorized feelings words helped my ELL students to engage with their partner when they tried to get across why or why not they thought a particular word would or wouldn’t work. They had to say a little more about their feelings and the basis for their feelings, which some students were also able to incorporate into their writing. Choosing from the chart took the anxiety away because they already had a group of possible choices but just needed to choose the right one. 2. This strategy facilitated my students’ ability to address the content by giving them a very specific focus to improve upon. ELL students have to think about so many things as they write, taking away from the quality of their writing at times. Given a specific focus, a word bank and practice with the tiered words, they could concentrate on just improving the feelings words in their pieces. Using interesting words raises a students’ score when writing is assessed formally. This focused practice ensures ELL students’ scores will rise along with the class. SEI Lesson Tool 3. Ratiocination facilitated my students’ ability to produce written discourse by compelling them to improve upon something that is typically difficult. Choosing the best and most precise word is no easy talk for native English speakers in second grade. ELL students have the added challenge of less exposure to the multitude of words we use in the English language. This strategy also allowed my ELL students to converse with a partner to decide on the best vocabulary word to fit their piece. Through oral discourse and hearing another child’s rationale, they gained more exposure and experience with feelings words. 4. Ratiocination helped my ELL students to receive comprehensible input by honing in on a difficult aspect of English learning with a partner. By incorporating the 7-steps to introduce and give practice with new vocabulary, students were better able to use new and interesting vocabulary words in their pieces. SEI Lesson Tool Further Practice: Homework or extension activities: How do these activities reinforce the comprehension and discourse as well as content or language objectives I have set for my ELLs? - The content material covered will be built upon during Social Studies geography lessons. The skill of summarizing will be practiced throughout the year during guided reading, reading conferences, think alouds, “buzzing” about our books and reader responses. Asking questions to clarify will be built upon during reading lessons. Lesson Integration Checklist: □ My Content and Language Objectives support each other. □ I differentiated my language objectives to accommodate my students’ proficiency levels. □ I used my students’ proficiency levels when choosing my instructional strategies to support their content and language learning. □ I chose activities that integrate speaking, writing, reading, and listening to the extent possible. □ I differentiated my assessment to accommodate my students’ proficiency levels. □ My assessment reflects the targeted language from my lesson’s mentor text or source. SEI Lesson Tool Steps in Building an SEI Lesson After selecting the appropriate academic content and WIDA ELD standards: Develop content and language objectives Choose a mentor text that appropriately aligns to the standards and objectives Analyze/Parse text Choose & Tier vocabulary Identify main concepts & connect with previous lessons Select strategy to pre-teach vocabulary Design activity to draw on background knowledge Select reading comprehension strategy Develop an activity that allows students to engage in the content, consolidating knowledge & skills Select/develop assessments (formative/summative)