For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online PL3103: Cognitive Psychology Categories, Knowledge, and Semantic Organisation Lecture 7 ▪ Week 8 ▪ 7 March 2022 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online How do people organise knowledge about the world around them? 2 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Today’s Agenda 1. Categories and Concepts Classical view of categories Natural categories PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 2. Categorisation Models Prototype Exemplar Goal-derived Social, other Strategies 3. Semantic Memory, Tasks, Models Semantic memory Tasks Models Video/demo: Spreading activation 4. Schema Theory and Scripts Schemas Scripts Video clip: Schemas and stereotypes 3 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories, Knowledge, and Semantic Organisation Categories and Concepts 4 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Concepts Categories: objects or events that are grouped together because of relatedness. • Enables us to interact with our environment without being overwhelmed by its complexity. Concepts: ideas that represent a class of objects, events, or their properties. • Alternatively: mental grouping that is used to remember and understand what things are, what they mean, and what categories or groups they belong to. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 5 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Concepts Knowing the category provides a lot of information. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 6 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Concepts Categories are helpful and necessary for multiple reasons (Bruner et al., 1956): 1. 2. Reduce complexity of the environment. Ability to identify objects in the world. 3. Reduces the need for constant learning. 4. Allows us to decide what constitutes an appropriate action. 5. Enables us to order related classes of objects and events. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 7 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Imagine having to interpret this scene without any knowledge of categories… 8 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Classical View of Categories Classical view of categorisation posits that all categories have defining features (i.e., attributes), and that these features are: • Singly necessary (a member of the category must have each feature) • Jointly sufficient (something with these features must be a member of the category) Logical rules and defining features used to define categories. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 9 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Category membership can be controversial… 10 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Classical View of Categories Although the classical view of categorisation captures the intuition that concepts have “essences,” it has been criticised. Disagreement over defining features. • Example: what are the features of a “game”? Some categories, particularly those found in everyday circumstances, are based on continuous dimensions rather than defining features. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 11 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Classical View of Categories The classical view of categories does not readily explain typicality effects (Rosch, 1973). • Example: some birds rated as more “birdy;” as in robin vs. penguin. • If the classical view was true, there should be no gradation of membership within the same category (since they all have the necessary features) • Typicality affects how people respond to objects; e.g., reaction times. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 12 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Natural Categories Rosch et al. (1976) Real world categories have hierarchical organisation. Some category members are more representative (typical) than others. Categories are organised into three nested levels from largest to smallest. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 13 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Natural Categories Superordinate Rosch et al. (1976) level Real Superordinate world categories level categories have are hierarchical the largest. organisation. Some Difficulty category is thatmembers membersare share more few representative attributes. (typical) than others. Examples: furniture, musical Categories are organised into three instruments, vehicles nested levels from largest to smallest. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 14 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Natural Categories Superordinate Basic levellevel Superordinate level categories Basic level categories are most are the largest. important. Difficulty that members share few First to beislearned. attributes. Most often used to name objects. Examples: furniture, musical Provides most new information instruments, vehicles compared to other levels. Basic level objects are most differentiated from one another. Examples: chair, table, lamp. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 15 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Natural Categories Subordinate Basic level level Basic Subordinate level categories level categories are most are important. most well known by experts. Experts can turn “subordinate” First to be learned. categories into basic levels, e.g., a Most often used to name objects. dog expert shown a picture may say Provides most newjust information “cocker spaniel” as quickly as compared to other levels. other people would say “dog” Basic level objects are most may Difficulty in that members differentiated from one another. share attributes with members of Examples: chair, table, lamp. other subordinate categories. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 16 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories, Knowledge, and Semantic Organisation Categorisation Models 17 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Prototype Models Posner & Keele (1968) • Categories are organised around a prototype or “best example” which is an average of the most typical features. • Members have a family resemblance. • There is no single feature in common, but several members share common features. • Similarity between a specific item and the prototype determines how likely it is a member of the category. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 18 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Prototype Models Strengths: • Typicality and unclear cases are predicted • Items with the most attributes in common with the prototype are judged to be more typical. • Fits nicely with the notion of a Basic level • Prototypes should be at the level where category members have most features in common. • A prototype of a category should be at the level where it is most distinct from the prototypes of other categories. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 19 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Prototype Models Criticisms: • Does not preserve enough information about individual members • People are sensitive to frequency, variability, correlations of features among members. • Does not explain context effects: • Example: is a harmonica a typical musical instrument around a campfire? In an orchestra? PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 20 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Exemplar Models Medin & Schaffer (1978) • Concepts are represented by the individual instances or exemplars. • While each exemplar may not be retrievable, an item is compared to most of them and overall similarity is found. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 21 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Prototype Models Strengths: • Does not lose information. • Sensitive to context. Criticisms: • Does not explain how categories are formed in the first place. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 22 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Goal-Derived Categories Both prototype and exemplar models of categorisation are similarity-based; items classified based on how much they resemble a prototype or each other. Goal derived categories exemplify ill-defined categories wherein individual items are very dissimilar, with no family resemblance, but share the same “essence” for a particular situation or goal. • Example: things to bring on a picnic. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 23 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Social and Other Categories People can be categorised into groups based on religious or social causes, among other attributes. • Clinical diagnoses. Stereotypes are a form of social categorisation in which withingroup similarity is exaggerated. • May result in misleading impressions and assumptions. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 24 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categorisation Strategies How does one identify whether a presented item is a member of a given category? • Nearest neighbor rule: select category containing an item that is most similar to the new item. • Average distance rule: compare new item with all members in a category in order to determine the average similarity between the new item and all members of the category. • Feature frequency rule: select the category with the most feature matches with the classified item. • Prototype rule: select the category with the prototype that is most similar to the new item (appears to be most popular strategy). PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 25 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories, Knowledge, and Semantic Organisation Semantic Memory and Semantic Memory Models 26 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Type of LTM involving the capacity to recall words, concepts, or numbers. • Organised knowledge of the world. • Fairly constant knowledge structure (stable). • Includes knowledge of words, and also things that cannot be readily expressed in words. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 27 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Examples: • I know that the meaning of the word “semantic” is closer to the meaning of the word “vocabulary” than it is to the word “disarmament.” • I remember that the chemical formula for water is H20. • I know that velvet is soft. • I know that a penguin is a bird, but a robin is a better example of the category “bird.” PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 28 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Tasks Hierarchical organization Information that is presented in an organised way is better remembered (e.g., Bower, 1970). Sentence verification Given a sentence, indicate whether it is true or false. Reaction time is measured. True or False: “A poodle is a dog.” PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 29 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Tasks Category size effect Sentences containing pairs drawn from smaller categories are verified faster than sentences containing pairs drawn from larger categories. Category Sentence size verification effect violated In Given some a sentence, cases, sentences indicatewith whether pairs drawn it is true from or false. larger categories are than sentences with verified Reactionfaster time is measured. pairs drawn from smaller categories. True or False: “A robin is a bird.” (faster) “An “A apepoodle is an animal.” (faster) is a dog.” vs. vs. “A robin is an animal.” (slower) “An ape is a primate.” (slower) PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 30 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Tasks Relatedness effects Sentences containing pairs that are highly unrelated (i.e., anomalous) semantically are verified faster. “A car is a bird.” (faster) vs. “A bat is a bird.” (slower) PL3103 Cognitive Psychology Typicality effects Category size effect violated Sentences referring to more typical In some cases, sentences with pairs members of larger a category are verified drawn from categories are faster than sentences referringwith to verified faster than sentences less typical of acategories. category. pairs drawnmembers from smaller “Aape robin bird.” (faster) “An is is anaanimal.” (faster) vs. “A chicken a bird.” (slower) “An ape is aisprimate.” (slower) 31 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Models Hierarchical network (Collins & Qullian, 1969) • Category information is stored directly in memory by means of associations. • Features are stored at highest level at which they are true for all concepts/instances below that level. • Verification time as a function of hierarchy of levels. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 32 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Models Feature comparison (Smith, Shoben, & Rips, 1974) • Concepts are stored as lists of features (no property inheritance). • Classifications made by: 1. Compare all features of two concepts to determine similarity 2. If needed, examine defining features to determine category membership. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 33 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Memory Models Spreading activation (Collins & Lofthus, 1975) • Concepts are interconnected in a network. • Length of links between concepts is a function of relatedness. • Activation spreads over network, but loses strength with distance. • Could explain false recognition of words in the Deese-RoedigerMcDermott (1995) paradigm. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 34 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Networks National Geographic (2014; 3:17) PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 35 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Semantic Networks The available evidence does seem to suggest that people organise knowledge around hierarchies and association networks. • Example: given “bread,” one is faster at recognising “butter” as a word than “pigeon” or some semantically unrelated word. However, the nature of such networks, and cognitive mechanisms involved, remains a matter of debate. • Yet other theories have been proposed (e.g., ACT model of Anderson, 1976). PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 36 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories, Knowledge, and Semantic Organisation Schemas and Scripts 37 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Schema and Scripts Schema: an active organisation of past experiences in which the mind abstracts a general cognitive structure to represent many particular instances of those experiences (Bartlett, 1932). • Framework for organising clusters of knowledge • Allows us to make sense of new information – match to existing schemas • Allows us to make intelligent guesses in the absence of specific information PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 38 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Schema and Scripts Scripts are schemas of routine events (Schank & Abelson, 1977) Examples: • Knowledge of important activities for a type of event. • Knowledge of sequence of activities for a type of event. Violations of schemas and scripts can trigger surprise, confusion, curiosity, and other emotional responses. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 39 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Schema and Scripts UCLA (2016; 2:31) PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 40 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Semantic Organisation Concepts and categories allow us to create equivalence classes for different objects. The classical view of categorisation is based on logical rules and defining features. The classical view ignores the characteristics of natural categories, which are based on continuous dimensions, rather than defining features. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 41 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Semantic Organisation Prototype and exemplar models are instances of similarity-based approaches to categorisation. • Prototype models focus on matching an instance with the prototype or “best example” of that category. • Exemplar models focus on matching an instance with the prototype or “best example” of that category. Other types of categorisation rely on a more functional underlying principle or goal. Different categorisation strategies have been proposed. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 42 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Semantic Organisation Semantic memory refers to memory for meanings; general knowledge. The hierarchical organisation and sentence verification techniques have been used to explore semantic memory. The available evidence does seem to suggest that people organise knowledge around hierarchies and association networks. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 43 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Semantic Organisation Models of semantic memory have been proposed based on hierarchical structure, feature lists, and spreading activation networks. Schema theory provides a framework for organising knowledge clusters at a more macro level. Scripts store knowledge about the structure of routine events. PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 44 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Categories and Semantic Organisation What do you think is a good schema to adopt when thinking about cognitive psychology? PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 45 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online PL3103 Week 8 Lecture Readings Textbook chapters 10-11 (for next week) On LumiNUS Quiz 4 (Chs 8-9) released on Friday, due Monday Tutorial Readings Squire & Knowlton, 1995 (for next week) PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 46 For Module Use Only: Do Not Share or Post Online Next Week… Special Guest Lecture Language and Text Comprehension PL3103 Cognitive Psychology 47