LONG JOURNEY HOME OF BNEI MENASHE
Lost Israelite tribe ending 2700 years of exile
By: Howard Flower
The story of the Bnei Menashe begins in 732 BC, when the Empire of Assyria began to take
captive the tribe of Manasseh and other Israelite tribes and resettle them in what is today
Iraq and Iran.
The Bible tells us that they were placed “in Halah, on the Habor, the river of Gozan, and in
the cities of the Medes.” (2 Kings 17:6; 1 Chronicles 5:26)
There they remained until about the time of the conquest of Alexander the Great in 323 BC,
according to 1st Chronicles and other sources. When Alexander started to conquer Persia,
the Bnei Menashe fled to the north and then to the east to avoid being enslaved by the
Greeks.
Legend has it that they journeyed along the Silk Road and eventually ended up in China,
forming part of what came to be known as the Kaifeng Jewish community. According to the
early stone tablets of the Kaifeng Jews, there were Israelites in China during the period of
the Han Dynasty, from around 206 BCE to 220 CE. One stele erected in 1512 detailed the
earlier presence of Jews in the western part of China near the border of Uzbekistan.
This helps corroborate the unconfirmed forensic DNA tests done in India in 2004 which
showed the similarity of the female mitochondrial DNA in some of the Bnei Menashe
women to the women of Jewish communities in Central Asia.
Uzbekistan lies in Central Asia and the Silk Road runs from Kaifeng to Jerusalem right
through the heart of this region. Indeed, Jews were considered some of the most successful
traders along the Silk Road.
There is also a map on the wall of the Kaifeng
Jewish museum in China which shows the locations of the earliest Jewish communities in
China and Central Asia. This writer viewed the map and the stelae during a visit to Kaifeng in
1993 while visiting the local Jewish remnant and speaking with them about their possible
return to Israel.
According to the 1512 Kaifeng Stele, the Jewish community identified their home in western
China, a settlement at the outskirts of the Taklimakan Desert, as prophetic according the
scripture found in Psalms 104:8-10. It was here that Han General Li Guangli discovered them
during a military expedition in 108 BC.
The Han Empire began to decline in the second century AD and as the Han army began to
withdraw from the Western regions, the Jews migrated to more central regions of China,
preferring the protection of the Han rulers to the risks of living under the Tatars. So they
moved eastward to the area of what is called Gansu province today. According to Bnei
Menashe accounts, the tribe then moved to Kaifeng in the year 231AD.
The post-Han period was a time of warfare and trouble with the neighboring tribes and the
narrative of the Bnei Menashe tells us that they were exiled and that a Chinese emperor
took their holy book, namely their Torah scrolls.
After the loss of their Torah, the Bnei Menashe wandered again and not much is known
about this period, other than their lore says they lived in caves for a while before coming to
India and Burma. Thus they came to be called the “Shinlung,” referring to the valley of caves
where they once sought refuge.
Eventually settling in the Mizoram and Manipur provinces of northeast India, they were
without any holy books or written histories, but their priests continued to hand down their
traditions orally, including ritual observances of worship, until the early nineteenth century.
It was there that they were re-discovered in 1813 by British missionaries who were allowed
to enter the area. It was Baptist missionaries who first reported the discovery of possible
descendants of the Lost Tribes.
One of the legends of the Bnei Menashe tribe is that even though a Chinese Emperor had
taken their holy book, one day a white man would return it to them. That white man would
be Christian missionaries from Europe.
Later at the end of the 19th century, missionaries sent out from the great Welsh revival
arrived and many peoples in the region soon converted to Christianity, including many
among the Shinlung.
Yet, the missionaries had found a people with oral traditions straight out of the book of
Genesis, such as a great flood and a dramatic separation of languages, along with tales of
patriarchs that fit biblical figures. This was likely why they readily accepted Bibles from the
missionaries.
As the British missionaries translated the Bible into the local dialects and taught them how
to read, the Bnei Menashe discovered with great joy that their stories, legends and songs
matched the biblical accounts. In their minds, this confirmed they were descendants of the
tribe of Manasseh and certain clans decided to cling to their Israelite traditions
In the 1950s, a small group decided that they should move to Israel and tried to journey on
foot but failed in their attempt. The Bnei Menashe did manage, however, to make contact
with Jewish communities in India’s larger cities, and word of their existence eventually
piqued the interest of Israeli rabbi Eliezer Avichail, who ventured to the region in the 1980s
to explore their origins.
Avichail eventually brought along an Israeli author, Hillel Halkin, whose celebrated
work Beyond the Sabbath River recounts his own quest to discover who these people truly
were.
They found that among the Bnei Menashe customs and traditions passed down through the
generations were certain communal songs which predated their contact with the
missionaries – songs which spoke of biblical events connected to ancient Israel.
For instance, the annual festival of Sikpui, one of the most important Bnei Menashe
holidays, could not commence until the whole community had finished singing a sacred
song which has clear references to the Exodus from Egypt, the pillar of cloud and fire, and
the parting of the Red Sea.
In the documentary film This Song is Old, Halkin insists that this ancient communal song was
one of the most convincing proofs for him that the Bnei Menashe have Israelite origins.
Michael Freund of Shavei Israel later became their main advocate for rejoining the Jewish
people in the Land of Israel, and in April 2005 the Sephardi chief rabbi Shlomo Amar
accepted the Bnei Menashe's claim of Israelite origins, primarily because of their devotion
to Judaism. His decision paved the way for the Bnei Menashe to gain entry to Israel.
An initial wave of 1,750 Bnei Menashe arrived by 2007, while another 7,200 have been
waiting anxiously back in India to make the trek home. Their wait – and their long journey –
is now almost over. A second wave starting in 2012 has begun and nearly 1,500 more have
has come now. For these fortunate one their wait and their long journey home is over. But
more remain in India.
A. Howard Flower serves as director of aliyah operations for the International Christian
Embassy Jerusalem
This article was first published in the February 2013 issue of The Jerusalem Post Christian
Edition