Action Research Insert Intro ( ℅ ma’am Annie) Context and Rationale The context and rationale is a two to a three-page key part of an action research process because it describes the underlying basis for the study. This section provides an overview of the existing and prevailing problem situation or current challenge, issue, or difficulty encountered in the classroom, school, or district that needs to be addressed. (Cristobal & Dela Cruz-Cristobal, 2017) What is the problem? An action research problem is a statement about an area of concern, a condition to be improved, a difficulty to be eliminated, or a troubling question that exists in classrooms, schools, and educational organizations that points to the need for meaningful understanding and deliberate investigation. To establish the research problem in the context and rationale, the following should be taken into consideration: 1. Brief overview of the problem situation that the study aims to address. 2. Local Context. It comprehensively explains the local problem that needs an apt solution. It should be provided with relevant data, authentic local or school/ district specific statistics, narratives, and observations driven from documents such as learners’ pertinent records, results of the assessment, anecdotal records, individual monitoring forms, School Improvement Plan (SIP), Annual Implementation Plan (AIP), and Basic Education Learning Continuity Plan (BELCP+). 3. Nature of the problem. It briefly discusses the characteristics of the problem. It identifies whether the problem is emerging, new, old but persisting, long ignored, or disturbing and requires urgent action. 4. Extent of the problem. It provides the concentration or locus of the problem. It specifies the scope of the problem: classroom, grade level, subject area, school, or district. Why is there a problem? A problem occurs as a result of discrepancy or a gap between the desired condition in performance indicators such learning competencies, literacy performance, and academic school/ district/ division targets. What is known about the problem? A sufficient background in determining the boundaries of the study is needed which includes: 1. Salience of the Problem. It gives emphasis on the evident indications and effects of the problem on teaching and learning, child protection, governance, human resource development, and cross-cutting themes such as disaster risk reduction and management, gender and development, and inclusive education. 2. Literature and related studies. It includes relevant literature and similar studies about the topic being presented. In choosing literature and related studies, note that it should adhere to five-year recency except for conceptual research literature. Conceptual literature should be written in present tense while the research literature in past tense. This is written in a brief and concise manner. What is the need to be addressed? 1. It provides a brief description of the proposed intervention to address the problem. The description should not be repeated in the Proposed Intervention, Innovation, and Strategy. What is the timeliness and relevance of the study? 1. Relevance of the Topic. It basically takes into account the reason of pursuing the study. It highlights the importance and benefits on the conduct of the research endeavor. It prompts to the attainment of the DepEd’s vision, mission, and intermediate outcomes and the realization of the school’s Priority Improvement Areas through the utilization of an intervention to address a pressing issue. 2. Timeliness of the Topic. It remarkably takes into consideration the timeliness and urgency of immediate solution of the problem to the distinct characteristics and features of the current generation being the participants and/or respondents of the study. It should include topics that are well-timed and are related to existing and updated educational research trends and program implementation of current DepEd thrusts. Note: 1. In writing the context and rationale, all essential components (what is the problem, why is there a problem, what is known about the problem, what is needed to answer the problem, and what is the timeliness and relevance of the problem) should be included. However, the proponent can exercise creativity in organizing and presenting the contents. Action Research Questions All action research starts with action research questions which guide the process through the design and conduct of data collection, the analysis and validation of data, and the writing of the results. Research questions are specific questions that you want answered during the duration of the conduct of research. According to Fraenkel and Wallen (2012), a research problem is initially posed as a question, which serves as the focus of the researcher’s investigation. Research Questions identify the problem/s which will be addressed by the research in terms of investigating or testing an idea; trying out solutions to a problem; creating a new procedure or system; explaining a phenomenon; or a combination of any of these (D.O. 43 s. 2015). There are 4 elements in writing Action Research Questions which should be written logically. The elements should state the performance/behavior before, after, difference or relationship, if any then the action plan question. 1. General Research Objective The general objective relates directly to the research problem and states clearly what the researcher will do and expects to find out. It is preferably stated in behavioral terms in terms of who or what will be studied, who will do it, when it will be done (optional), or where it will be done. This is the introductory statement of aim/purpose of conducting a study which usually begins with, “This action research ● intends to find out …, ● seeks to determine the …, ● aims to ascertain the effectiveness …, ● delves into finding out… ● focuses on determining/ finding out ….” ● tiyakin at suriin ang…, After the purpose is decided, the more specific and extremely important research questions are derived from and closely linked to the purpose. It is viewed as sub-objectives or small particles of the general objective which are expressed in measurable terms and suggest the type of analysis to be done. 2. Descriptive Research Question/s (Required) Descriptive Research Questions aim to provide a description of the variable under consideration. It is used to quantify action research variables before and after the conduct of the intervention/innovation. 3. Inferential Research Question/s (Optional) Inferential research questions relate variables or compare groups in terms of variables so that inferences can be drawn from the sample to a population. 4. Action-Related Question (Required) This research question is the post study plan after determining the result of the conducted Action Research. Single Group Enhanced Jibo-Pouch and Parental Involvement at Homes on the Numeracy Skills of Learners Mark John A. Belleza, BERF 2020 Jibolo Elementary School This study aims to determine the effectiveness of enhanced Jibo-Pouch and Parental Involvement at homes on the General Objective Descriptive Inferential Action Related Two- Group Crossword Puzzle: Pagpapalawak ng Bokabularyo ng mga Mag-aaral sa Baiting 7 Shannon Khey A. Amoyan, BERF 2017 Alimodian National High School Layunin ng pag-aaral na ito na tiyakin at suriin ang General Objective Descriptive Inferential Action Related Two- Group Effectiveness of Individualized and Collaborative Activity in Teaching Biology to Special Science Class 10 students Nemia L. Alerta, BERF 2017 Janiuay National Comprehensive High School General Objective Descriptive Inferential Action Related Two- Group Contextualized Learners’ Materials on Misconceptions in Biodiversity Among Academically Challenged Learners Ariette A. De Asis & Heide S. Alturino, BERF 2017 General Objective Descriptive Inferential Action Related Two- Group The Effect of Video-Based Story Telling on the Reading Assessment of Grade 5 Learners Brayn B. Canete, BERF 2017 Mostro Elementary School General Objective This study aims to determine the effect of video-based storytelling on the level of reading comprehension of Grade five learners. Specifically, it seeks answers on the following questions: What is the level of reading comprehension of Grade five learners in terms of: entire group, control group, and experimental group before the intervention? What is the level of reading comprehension of Grade five learners in terms of: entire group, control group, and experimental group after the intervention? Descriptive Inferential Action Related https://us.sagepub.com/sites/default/files/upmassets/87236_book_item_87236.pdf Formulating the Proposed Innovation, Intervention, and Strategy Sample SEQ Figure \* ARABIC 1 Description and/or Definition of the Intervention/Innovation/ Strategy Kindred Spirits Connection is a social support group and Christian spiritual mentorship to be established through mentoring sessions and online group chat which aims to nurture a Christ-centered life towards the development of the ability to fulfill life’s purpose, ability to accept self, and capacity to feel right with others and be a helping hand to everyone towards positive mental health utilizing regenerative prayer counseling strategy utilizing theological-spirituotherapy. An original idea of solving the classroom challenges is a great contribution to the field of knowledge and in the improvement of educational practices. A contribution formulated out of a series of discoveries that solved one’s problem that might be Taken from the study Kindred Spirits Connection Towards Learners’ a solution to system-wide and long-endured Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) challenges. It might be an innovation, intervention, or BERF Completed Research. strategy. In this section, the researcher will discuss the solution in a form of innovation, intervention, and/or strategy as an original idea of solving the problem at hand. This part presents the defining characteristics and/or features of the proposed intervention/innovation/strategy. What are the Required Features in Formulating this Section? This section shall be discussed comprehensively in the research proposal. The discussion shall include the following features: 1) Description/Overview; 2) Persons/Parties Involved; 3) Activities/Phases/Components (A/P/C); 4) Extent/Limitations/Duration; 5) Bases for the Intervention; and 6) Plausibility of the Intervention. Examples of the Required Features of the Proposed Innovation, Intervention, and Strategy 1) Description/Overview. Generally, this sub-section discusses the definition of the innovation/intervention/strategy. Terminologies, concepts, and theories deliberately considered in constructing the unique and original name of the innovation/intervention/strategy shall be defined with in-text citations. An example of this feature can be seen in Sample 1. It answers the question “what is your intervention?” Sample 3 Discussion of the Phases of Conducting the Intervention 2) Persons/Parties Involved. People who played significant contribution/s in the implementation of the innovation/intervention/strategy shall be listed in this section. Their roles and responsibilities in the Generally, this investigation will be implemented Sample 2 in three (3) phases. Phase 1 will be the administration of the pretest. The in the Study Discussion on the Persons/Parties Involved respondents will be gathered at a scheduled in Connection the classroom The Kindredtime Spirits will beafter conducted for the benefit of the learners with signs of securing consent and permission from unhealthy mental health conditions withthe the help of the following persons: parents and school head The who proposed the Kindred Spirits Connection Teacher-researcher. Therespectively. teacher-researcher will be the overall implementation of the intervention. This included the test willresponsible be given in for printed form. In Phase preparation of thewill venue, supplies, schedules, and other needs of the persons involved in the 2, the intervention be implemented (see conduct thephase study;includes 12 sessions. Figure 1).ofThis Learner-counselees. learners, participants of the study, are the very important persons The twelve sessions The will be conducted in in the implementation ofThe the last intervention. five whole-day activities. phase willThe participants will be the learners with signs of unhealthy mental health conditions; be the conduct of the posttest, and data Research Assistants and Peer-counselors. These people will assist the researcher in the analysis, and the preparation of the purchase of supplies, food, and other needed materials for the implementation of the study. research report. They were trained to assist in the prayer counseling sessions. Likewise, this group of people will assist researcher the Connection data gathering process. Taken fromthe the study Kindred in Spirits Towards Learners’ Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) Taken from the study Kindred Research. Spirits Connection Towards Learners’ Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) - BERF – BERF Completed Completed Research process shall be discussed objectively. Interventionist (teacher-researcher), recipient (participants/respondents), and support parties (research assistants, sponsors, donors, and the like). This feature is very important for the persons involved in the study to function effectively and efficiently (see Sample 2). 3) Activities/Phases/Components (A/P/C). A detailed discussion of the series activities in the implementation of the intervention/innovation/strategy shall be discussed in this part. It is suggested that the activities shall be discussed chronologically and comprehensively from the start until the end of the implementation. This researcher might organize the activities by phase with specific components. The general phases of the activities such as pre-implementation, implementation/intervention, and post-implementation (see Sample 3) shall be discussed in the paper. However, in this section, it is suggested that the researcher/author shall organize the activities in phases/stages to explain comprehensively the components of the unique and original intervention/innovation/strategy (see Figure 1). Figure 1: Stages of Activities in the Implementation of the Intervention Taken from the study Kindred Spirits Connection Towards Learners’ Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) – BERF Completed Research. 4) Extent/Limitation/Duration. In this sub-section, the researcher shall provide a specific time frame for the conduct of the intervention. It should be discussed with a specific date and duration (see Sample 4). For instance, the timeline shall be for one onequarter, once a week. It shall be stated with a particular date such as January to April 2022. When the intervention is organized by phases, there should be a specific date for the conduct of all the phases. In addition, the extent and limitation of the study shall be discussed by specifying the characteristics of the participants, the context of the study, and other considerations in conducting the study. It shall also discuss the competency or variable where the intervention will be applied in a certain context. Sample 4 Discussion of the Extent/Limitation/Duration of the Intervention This study will mainly focus on the mental health of the participants. The participants will be the drafting learners of Santa Barbara National Comprehensive High School with signs of unhealthy mental health conditions. This will serve as their social support group and an avenue for spiritual development. As part of this group, Kindred Spirits Connection, they will establish their relationship and support system both physical and virtual. Physically, they will have time to be together and support one another. The learners will have a Group Chat on Messenger where they can communicate with one another and extend help to their kindred spirits in a virtual way. Generally, this involves the establishment of Kindred Spirits Connection – social support groups and Christian spiritual comradeships. Based on the features of the Kindred Spirits Connection (See Appendix F), the allotted time for the intervention will be 12 sessions. This will be from November – January 2020. The schedule will be flexible which will be relative to the availability of the participants and the researcher. Taken from the study Kindred Spirits Connection Towards Learners’ Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) – BERF Completed Research. 5) Bases for the Intervention. Ideally, an intervention/innovation/strategy conceptualized for implementation will be based on theories and concepts (see Sample 5). For instance, constructivism, theory of motivation, zone of proximal development, etc. Theoretical and conceptual literature cited shall be discussed with in-text citations. The discussion should include the application of the theories and concepts in the study. These shall serve as the conceptual or theoretical framework in the formulation of the innovation/intervention/strategy. Several theories/concepts can be integrated for this purpose. Sample 5 Discussion of the Conceptual or Theoretical Support of the Intervention Kindred Spirits Connection was formulated based on the idea of Lynch (2014) which states that kindred spirits are more than just close friends with whom we have exchanged soul lessons and connected at different levels of consciousness across many lives. These are the people who assist us achieve our goals by providing us with energy, light, unconditional love, and compassion. It will utilize theological-spirituotherapy. Social support and spirituality are the key components. The providing of assistance or comfort to others, usually to help them cope with biological, psychological, or social stressors, is referred to as social support. Any interpersonal contact in an individual's social network, such as family members, friends, neighbors, religious institutions, coworkers, caregivers, or support groups, can assist (American Psychological Association, 2019). Spirituality is another 6) Plausibility theintervention. Intervention. The possibility thatas thea intervention be effective important aspect ofofthe Spirituality is defined concern for might or sensitivity to based on the results study/ies utilizing similar intervention (see concerns, Sample 6).asFor example, things of the spiritoforthe soul, especially as opposed to materialistic well as a the findings experimental studies with the same/similar intervention conducted by other concern of foractual God and a sensitivity to religious experience, which may include the practice of researchers. In some cases, the basis of the plausibility of the intervention/innovation/strategy a particular religion but may also exist without such practice (American Psychological is the findings of scholars Association, 2019). employing similar concepts applied in the formulation of the intervention. Concepts applied in the study on the same variable/s such learning motivation, mental health, The integration of the psychological, social, andas spiritual aspects of understanding academic performance. The findings of understanding the study withmental similar health, concepts to that of thespiritual, proposed is anchored to Dasgupta’s Model of which includes: study shallcharacter, be cited with in-textdisease/biological/medical, citation/s to support the plausibility of thesocial, proposed intervention moral statistical, psychological, psychosocial, and/or assumed effect(Dasgupta, of the intervention. andthe biopsychosocial 2013). In this study, the interventionist considered the psychological, social, and spiritual models of understanding mental health. In the spiritual approach, Sample 6 the counselor explains who we are in the world and how we are to act. It also tells us wePlausibility can expect afterIntervention death based on our actions. The spiritual perspective Discussionwhat of the of the discusses good and evil as they relate to suffering (Dasgupta, 2013). The psychological modelDespite states the thatuncertainties, mental healththe develops alongassurance an expected path. People try to adjust to researcher’s of achieving the favorable results their environment to survive within it. Problems arise when a person learns maladaptive of the study is strengthened by the existing literature on the effect of spirituality and social strategies as a response to new situations (Dasgupta, 2013). According to Dasgupta support on mental health. Mental health is associated with perceived social support (Chui & (2013), the social model stresses that biology, psychology, and society all affect a person’s Chan, 2017). Social support is a significant predictor of mental health outcome -life satisfaction mental &health. influence of societal normssocial is important the adaptive or maladaptiveof (Stewart Suldo,The 2011). Moreover, extending supporttoreduced the manifestations behavior of the individual. In the implementation of Kindred Spirits Connection, depression (Lincoln et al., 2005). In spiritual development, many scholars proved the the researcher will be thebetween interventionist. The interventionist applied his psychosociospiritual remarkable connection spirituality and mental health. Spirituality has a positive effect social,distress and spiritual) capability in The establishing thisbeing socialconnected support group andis on(psychological, people with mental or mental illness. feeling of to God Christian mentorship. Psychosociospiritual capabilities knowledge skills to associated with your mental resilience and helps people involve make sense of lifeand experiences Additional Features: apply Biblical principles to the mental health of learners, prayer counseling skills, and the (Mental HealthanFoundation, RankinProposed (2015), found out that spirituality is ● Provide Annotated 2019). SampleInofaddition, the complete Innovation, Intervention, and ability to work by the power of the Holy Spirit in dealing with the psychosociospiritual linkedStrategy to positive mental health. Spiritual counseling, reflective listening, and faith-filledneeds prayer of the participants. help remind an individual that Holy Spirit is always with us. He is our constant resource and Regenerative prayerLife counseling is the main component of spirituality development. is guide (Unity Spiritual Center, 2016). Furthermore, spirituality is associated with aItsense to Dasgupta therapeutic intervention might be of individual well-beingcounseling. relevant toAccording people's mental health(2013), conditions. Spirituality served as inspiration three different ways namely individual group counseling, and forexperienced excellence, in provided life purpose, provided an abilitycounseling, to overcome barriers, and reduced ACTION RESEARCH METHODS family therapy. In this study, the researcher considers individual counseling for its relational distractions, especially those not aligned with a Christian worldview (Wood & Hilton, 2012). relevance to its context. Individual counseling is a one-one session with a trained The Action Research Methods section begins with an introductory paragraph where the counselor. on are: the type of therapy used, these sessions can continue for research designDepending and method months or years (Dasgupta, 2013). counseling is the individual counseling ● explicitly stated;Prayer Taken from the study Kindred Spirits Connection Towards Learners’ Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) – BERF employed in this study. This prayer counseling will be conducted based on the principles ● defined with proper in-text citation; and Completed Research. of theological-spirituotherapy. According to Raphah Ministries Malaysia (2016), ● given a brief justification as to why they are the most appropriate theological-spirituotherapy is adesign wholistic consistent within research andcounseling method tomodel be used, and howand it iscompatible to be applied the Bible. It is implemented with the principle ‘Being in order to be’ the full revelation of the which means broken study. persons need to be restored and healed for the person to live in victory and freedom in Christ; do and obey the commands of the Bible (p.4). Taken from the study Kindred Spirits Connection Towards Learners’ Mental Health (Bendayon, 2019) – BERF Completed Research. To achieve this, an example with annotated parts is provided below for your reference: Action Research Methods This study will employ the pre-experimental research design, specifically, the one-group pretest-posttest design. This design includes a pretest measure followed by a treatment and a posttest for a single group (Creswell, 2014). Introductory paragraph stating and defining the research design and method with proper in-text citation. Figure 1. Pre-experimental design (one-group pretest-posttest design) used in the study. This design fits the goal of this study, for the researcher intends to determine the effects of the treatment by comparing the results of the pretest and posttest general mathematics performance and learning motivation of the learners. The design of this study is shown in Figure 1. Justification for the appropriacy and applicability of the chosen research design and method for the study. In the study, a pretest on general mathematics performance (O 1) will be administered to a single group of learners (Group A) followed by a virtualsupported modular distance learning approach (X) and then a posttest on general mathematics performance (O2) to the same group of learners. Reference: Almer D. Sibonga, Almer D.(2021). General Mathematics Learners’ Performance and Motivation in A Virtual-Supported Modular Distance Learning Approach. SUPPLEMENTARY INFORMATION ON RESEARCH DESIGNS There are three types of research designs, namely: quantitative, qualitative, and mixed-methods (Creswell, 2009). Quantitative Research. This research design is to be used when the nature of the study involves systematic investigation of observable phenomena or characteristics of the population being studied where quantitative or numerical data are gathered and analysed using statistical procedures (Barrot, 2017). Under the quantitative research design, there are various kinds of research methods that a researcher may employ depending on the purpose of the study and the extent to which the findings will be used. This includes: (1) descriptive research; (2) correlational research; (3) causal-comparative (ex post facto) research; (4) evaluation research; (5) survey research; and (6) experimental research. The most frequently used quantitative research design for action research is the experimental research which Creswell (2009) further subdivides into: (1) true experimental; (2) quasi-experimental; and preexperimental. A. True Experimental Designs include the following: Pre-Test-Post-Test Control-Group Design. A traditional, classical design whose procedure involves random assignment of participants to two groups. Both groups are administered both a pre-test and a post-test, but the treatment is provided only to experimental Group A. Group A R———O———X———O Group B R——— O———————O Post-Test-Only Control-Group Design. This design controls for any confounding effects of a pre-test and is a popular experimental design. The participants are randomly assigned to groups, a treatment is given only to the experimental group, and both groups are measured on the post-test. Group A R—————X—————O Group B R———————————O Solomon Four-Group Design. A special case of a 2 X 2 factorial design, this procedure involves the random assignment of participants to four groups. Pre-tests and treatments are varied for the four groups. All groups receive a post-test. Group A R———O———X———O Group B R———O———————O Group C R———————X———O Group D R——————————-—O B. Quasi-Experimental Designs are as follows: Nonequivalent (Pre-Test and Post-Test) Control-Group Design. In this design, a popular approach to quasi-experiments, the experimental group A and the control group B are selected without random assignment. Both groups take a pre-test and post- test. Only the experimental group receives the treatment. Group A O————X————O ____________________________ Group B O—————————O Single-Group Interrupted Time-Series Design. In this design, the researcher records measures for a single group both before and after a treatment. Group A O—O—O—O—X—O—O—O—O Control-Group Interrupted Time-Series Design. This is a modification of the Single-Group Interrupted Time-Series design in which two groups of participants, not randomly assigned, are observed over time. A treatment is administered to only one of the groups (i.e., Group A). Group A O—O—O—O—X—O—O—O—O ______________________ Group B O—O—O—O—O—O—O—O—O C. Pre-Experimental Designs consist of: One-Shot Case Study. This design involves an exposure of a group to a treatment followed by a measure. Group A X_____________________O One-Group Pre-Test-Post-Test Design. This design includes a pre-test measure followed by a treatment and a post-test for a single group. Group A 01————X————02 Static Group Comparison or Post-Test-Only With Nonequivalent Groups. Experimenters use this design after implementing a treatment. After the treatment, the researcher selects a comparison group and provides a post-test to both the experimental group(s) and the comparison group(s). Group A X_____________________O ______________________________ Group B ________________________O Alternative Treatment Post-Test-Only With Nonequivalent Groups Design. This design uses the same procedure as the Static Group Comparison, with the exception that the nonequivalent comparison group received a different treatment. Group A X1____________________O _____________________________ Group B X2 _____________________ O Qualitative Research. This type of research emphasizes verbal descriptions and explanations of human behaviour and practices in an attempt to understand how the units or members of the study population experience or explain their world (David, 2002). The process of research involves emerging questions and procedures, data typically collected in the participant’s setting, data analysis inductively building from particulars to general themes, and the researcher making interpretations of the meaning of the data. The final written report has a flexible structure (Creswell, 2009). A researcher who intends to employ the qualitative research design may consider to apply any of the following methods: Phenomenology. Phenomenological studies examine human experiences through descriptions provided by the people involved. These experiences are called “lived experiences”. The participants are asked to describe their experiences as they perceive them, and the goal of this study is to describe the meaning that experiences hold for each subject/participant. They may write their experiences, but information is generally obtained through interviews, preferably the focus group discussion (FGD) (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Ethnography. This method involves collection and analysis of data about cultural groups or minorities where the researcher immerses with the people and becomes a part of their culture. The researcher becomes involved in the everyday activities of the subjects/ key informants, and gets to empathize with the cultural group experiencing issues and problems in their everyday lives (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Case Study. This method involves in-depth examination of an individual, groups of people, or an institution over a period of time to gain insights into a little-known problem, provide background data for broader studies and explain socio-psychological and socio-cultural processes where conclusions about the impact of a significant event in a person’s life are drawn (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Grounded Theory. In this method, data are collected and analyzed and then a theory is developed that is “grounded” in the data. It is more concerned with generation rather testing of hypotheses. The theory is generated as data are gathered and involves comparing units of data against one another until categories, properties, and hypotheses that state relations between these categories and properties emerge (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Content Analysis. Qualitative content analysis is a research method for the subjective interpretation of the content of text data through the systematic classification process of coding and identifying themes or patterns (Hsieh & Shannon, 2005). Content analysis is a qualitative research tool or technique that is used widely to analyse the content and its features. It is an approach used to quantify qualitative information by sorting data and comparing different pieces of information to summarize it into usefu e population being studied where quantitative or numerical data are gathered and analysed using statistical 2017). Under the quantitative research design, there are various kinds of research methods that a researcher may employ depending on the purpose of the study and the extent to which the findirPART III. ACTION RESEARCH METHODS a. Design of the Study ⮚General Approach (Definition & Characteristics) ⮚e.g. Descriptive I. Participants & Other Sources of Data a. Encompassing Label ⮚ “Grade 0 Learners/Teachers in XYZ National High School” ⮚ More Specific Identifier (If Applicable, e.g. Frustrated Readers) b. Number & Breakdown ⮚ Total & Aggregated Number (Sex/Section/Department) c. Other Characteristics ⮚ Other Relevant Details ⮚ e.g. Age Range, Socioeconomic Status, Religion d. Sampling Method ⮚ Selection/Sampling Method & Assignment Method (If Experimental) e. Justification for Sampling ⮚ Supporting Literature/Logical Support f. Types/Classification of Data ⮚ Identification of Data to be Collected ⮚ e.g. Behavior Sample, Exam Performance, Audio Data, Textual Data II. Data Gathering Method ⮚ Technique ⮚ e.g. Interview, FGD, Pretest-Posttest Method a. Justification for Type of Method ⮚Supporting Literature / Logical Support b. Instruments ⮚Description of Data Collection Tools to be Employed c. Steps/Phases ⮚ Schedule of Data Recording/Acquisition III. Data Analysis Plan a. Steps ⮚Schedule/Flow of Data Analysis b. Tests/Technique/Approaches ⮚Statistical Tests (Quantitative) & Modes of Analysis (Qualitative) c. Justification for T/T/A ⮚Supporting Literature d. Software/Tool ⮚Computer Programs (e.g. MS Excel, SPSS, NVivo) Participants and/or Other Sources of Data and Information The participants of the study serve as the primary source of data in the research process. Participants are typically a sample of the population you want to study. Necessary information and characteristics of the participants should be included. In identifying and characterizing the participants of the study, consider the following components: 1. Proper label/identification. Be specific as possible. Labels should be defined by the most specific relevant characteristics and depends upon the scope and purpose of the research project. It is further important to note that labels are adjectives describing a group of individuals giving respect to the individuality of the participants. Example: Grade level and School of the participant, Subject area focus, More Specific Identifier (learners with disability, frustrated readers, academicallychallenged learners, and the like) 2. Discuss the number, breakdown, and specific characteristics of participants involve in the study. Example: Total & Aggregated Number (Sex -Male/Female; Section; Department), Age Range (12-15 years old), Socioeconomic Status, Religion, Cultural background) ……participants of this action research will be Grade 8 academically-challenged learners of Alimodian National Comprehensive High School for school year 2017-2018. Grade 8 section X consists of 35 learners while Grade 8 section Y has 35 learners. The researchers will utilize these groups of learners because section assignments after enrollment for each school year were based on the learners’ general average in their Grade 7, thus academically-challenged learners are evident in these sections (De Asis, et.al., 2017 BERF). 3. Sampling Technique. State what sampling technique/method is used in selecting the participants. Sampling is the process of choosing a representative portion of a population or some elements in a population that will represent the entire population (Fraenkel and Wallen, 1996). There are two basic types of sampling: probability sampling and non-probability sampling (David, 2002). a. Probability Sampling Technique. This involves random selection, a method wherein every unit of the population is given an equal chance of being chosen for the sample. Simple Random Sampling. A method of choosing samples in which all the members of the population are given an equal chance to be selected as respondents/ participants. It is an unbiased way of selection as samples are drawn by chance through roulette wheel, fishbowl technique, or use of the table of random numbers (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Stratified Random Sampling. In this sampling technique, the population is first divided into strata or subgroups, and then samples are selected from these strata or subgroups – not from the population as a whole (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Cluster Sampling. Involves the grouping of the population into subgroups or clusters. However, these clusters are not created based on specific characteristics or traits; thus, they are heterogeneous (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). This is used in largescale studies in which the population is geographically spread out. Systematic Sampling. It is a method of selecting every nth element of the population (e.g., every 5th, 8th, 11th element). After the size of the sample has been determined, the selection of the sample follows (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Multistage Sampling. This often considered an extended version of cluster sampling. In this sampling technique, you divide the population into clusters and select some clusters at the first stage. At each subsequent stage, you further divide up those selected clusters into smaller clusters, and repeat the process until you get to the last step. At the last step, you only select some members of each cluster for your sample (Bhandari, 2021). b. Non-Probability Sampling Technique. It is a process of selecting respondents in which the members of the entire population do not have an equal chance of being selected as samples. There are cases in which a sample is given priority instead of other members. Also known as “non-scientific sampling. Convenience Sampling. This is also called ‘accidental” or “incidental sampling” and involves subjects that can be easily reached with selection on the convenience of the researcher. Quota Sampling. It is somewhat similar to stratified sampling in which the population is divided into homogenous strata and then sample elements are selected from each stratum (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). For example, the researcher desires to have 50 male students. The first 50 male students, who are approached by the researcher as respondents will be asked to participate in the survey in this case. Purposive Sampling (Quantitative Research) and Purposeful Sampling (Qualitative Research). This involves the handpicking of subjects. Also known “judgmental sampling” for the selection of samples rely upon the researcher’s judgment in selecting the subjects/participants (Cristobal & Cristobal, 2017). Snowball Sampling. This is where research participants recruit other participants for a test or study. It is used where potential participants are hard to find. Example 1: Furthermore, diagnostic test results revealed that these two groups of academicallychallenged learners are comparable in terms of their academic performance in the topic biodiversity. Randomization using cluster sampling will be also used in assigning the two sections into control and experimental group (De Asis, et.al., 2017 BERF). Example 2: Thus, the participants of this study will be 40 purposively chosen grade 7 learners with 23 males and 17 females, ages 12 to 14;15 learners from the star section and 25 learners from the second section. .Rationale for inclusion. Justify your choice of participants Example 1: The Grade 10 learners of Lanag Norte National High School for school year 2020-2021 with final rating of 75% to 79% (developing level) in Mathematics 9 were the participants of the study. Out of 132 officially enrolled Grade 10 learners, 36 learners of whom 6 are girls and 30 boys belong to developing level in their Mathematics performance, hence the participants of the study. The researcher purposively chooses Grade 10 learners as participants of this study, for they are certain that the problem exists in this group of learners; thus, it is apt to address or test the solution to the same group of learners (Braza, 2020 BERF). Example 2: The researcher chose this group of learners for he believes that virtual-supported modular distance learning approach may work for them. Moreover, the learners will be taking the General Mathematics subject in the first semester of the SY 2020-2021 and the researcher will be handling their class in which virtual-supported modular distance learning approach will be used (Sibonga, 2020 BERF). References: An introduction to multistage sampling Published on August 16, 2021 by Pritha Bhandari. https://www.scribbr.com/methodology/multistage-sampling/ Ethical Issues The Ethical Issues section deals with the identification of ethical concerns that could possibly emanate from the conduct of the research, and an elaborate discussion on how to prevent these from taking place (DO 43, s2015). In drafting an action research proposal, the researcher should be careful and be aware of the ethical issues that need to be considered. In this section, the researcher should discuss the following: A. Permission How will you seek permission to conduct the study? Before conducting the study, make sure to ask permission from persons in authority, (e.g. school principal, head of the department, etc). Also, secure letters of consent (for participants below 18 years old) and letter of assent (for participants 18 years old and above). Example: B. Orientation How will you conduct the orientation to your participants and other persons involved? Conduct an orientation/ debriefing as well to all the participants and other persons involved prior to implementing the study. Example: C. Personal Safety and Confidentiality Could the study be harmful to one’s race, ethnicity, gender, age, or sexuality? Discuss the kind of harm or risk, if any, that the participants are likely to be exposed to when conducting the study. Provide measures then to be undertaken to avoid them. Discuss here on how to maintain confidentiality. Example: D. Health and Safety Protocols for Infectious Disease How will you observe proper protocols set by the National or Local authorities? Provide measures on how to obey rules and protocols during the conduct of the study set by the Inter-Agency Task Force on Covid-19 and the Department of Health in this new normal situation. E. Intellectual Property Rights State the upholding of intellectual property rights through proper referencing and citation in the study in order to avoid plagiarism issues. F. Data Privacy Act/RA 10173, s2012 It is the policy of the State to protect the fundamental human right of privacy, of communication while ensuring free flow of information to promote innovation and growth. The State recognizes the vital role of information and communications technology in nation-building and its inherent obligation to ensure that personal information in information and communications systems in the government and in the private sector are secured and protected. The proponent shall see to it that data privacy is being upheld. Utilizing “Information Use Form” through online and offline surveys shall also adhere to this policy. G. Incentives If applicable, provide incentives for the participants of the study. References: DO 43, s2015 Cañete, B. (2017) De Asis, A. (2017) Sabido, D. (2017) Data Privacy Act of 2012, https://www.privacy.gov.ph/data-privacy-act/#16 Retrieved from Data Analysis Plan This section contains the steps or flow of data analysis, statistical test or appropriate mode of data analysis, justification for the appropriateness of the statistical tools or mode of analysis, and software or tool to be used. Quantitative data analysis involves the use of descriptive and inferential statistics. Descriptive statistics tells about the position of one data in relation to other data and the extent of the distribution of these data. It is concerned with describing important features of the data without attempting to infer. It includes the computation of Mean, Median, Mode, Frequency, Rank, and Standard Deviation. Descripti ve Statistic al Tools Mean Description Average of all data or items included. Median Score in the middle of the set of items arranged from lowest to highest or from highest to lowest. It divides the set into two groups. Mode Score or item that has the most repeated appearance in the set. Frequen cy Number of responses given repeatedly for each question or item. Rank Position or placement of one item in relation to another item. The data are arranged from highest to lowest or from lowest to highest. Standar d Deviatio n Extent of the difference of the data from the mean. Inferential statistics does not focus only on the category of the given set of data. It also focuses on the characteristics of the sample that are also true to the population from where the sample were drawn. It includes the choice between parametric and non-parametric tests. Parametric tests are used when the data are normally distributed and are of interval or ratio type, there is homogeneity of variances, and when the samples are independent. On the other hand, non-parametric tests are often suitable for smaller samples or when data collected are measured at nominal or ordinal level. Tests Parametric Tests Non-Parametric Tests Same group at two points t-test for paired samples Wilcoxon Signed Rank Test Two independe nt Groups t-test for Independe nt Samples Mann-Whitney U Test Qualitative data can be analyzed in various ways. The most common method is thematic analysis. It involves conceptualization, coding, categorizing, examining relationships, and displaying data. Powell and Renner (2003) suggested the steps in analyzing qualitative data. The steps include: (1) getting to know the data; (2) focusing the analysis by organizing the data by question and by case; (3) categorizing information by themes or ideas; (4) identifying patterns and connections within and between categories; and interpreting the data. Direct quotes of the respondents should be included in the analysis to give color and life to the data. The alternative approaches in qualitative data analysis include ethnography, case study, narrative analysis, phenomenology, historical, grounded theory, and participatory action research. The research method employed in the study shapes the selection of an analytic approach. Furthermore, mixed methodology researches should be analyzed based on the methodology being combined. Sample Data Analysis Plan (Quantitative Research) Excerpts from the manuscript of Clark B. Banabatac, Estela Marie F. Escorpiso, and Monique Joy R. Balayo entitled “Instructional Module Patterned from Learners’ Non-School Activities: Its Effect on Their Mathematics Performance” (BERF 2017) . Several statistical tools will be utilized for the analyses of the data. The researcher will use the SPSS version 21. Means and standard deviations will be utilized to describe the level of the mathematics performance of the learners before and after the intervention. In the inferential part, t- test for paired samples will be used to determine if there is a significant difference in the mathematics performance of the learners before and after the intervention. On the other hand, t- test for independent samples will be used to ascertain if there is a significant difference in the mathematics performance of the learners before their exposure to the instructional module patterned from non-school activities and to the existing module. t-test for independent samples will also be used to determine if there is a significant difference in the mathematics performance of the learners after their exposure to two different modules. The two statistical inferences will be tested at 5% level of significance. Sample Data Analysis Plan (Qualitative Research) Excerpts from the manuscript of Mary Odessa C. Santillana entitled “Exploring Difficulties in the Mother Tongue Subject: The Learner, Parent, and Teacher Perspectives (BERF 2017). According to Parahoo (2006, p. 375), data analysis is an integral part of research design,” and it is a means of making sense of data before presenting them in understandable manner. The qualitative questions will be answered using thematic data analysis. On this process, answer to these questions will be read several times. Themes will be identified and coded. Then after more readings, these codes will be reclassified into fewer categories. Raw data will be analyzed through data reduction. Data reduction is the abstraction of data from transcriptions, deleting data which are not important and transforming it into a comprehensive material easily understood by many (Suter, 2012). . Action Research Work Plan and Timeline Contains the research timelines-- when will the study begins and how long will it take for it to be completed. It also includes time estimates for each step in the research process. There is an introductory paragraph followed by the table (in APA format) of schedule of research activities. Clustering of Activities such as Planning, Implementation, Submission of Liquidation Reports & Deliverables, and Dissemination are given. List of Activities is stated in the 1st column of the table, Timeline in the 2nd column, and Duration in the 3rd column. Span is set at the last line in the table containing the total number of days of the activities and written in bold letters. Components of Tables Number (Ex. Table 1) appears above the table title and body in bold form. Number tables in order in which they are mentioned in the study. All tables include column headings, including stub heading (heading for the leftmost, or stub, column). The heading “variable” is often used for the stub column if no other heading is suitable. Center column headings and capitalize them in sentence case. Table body formatting using APA format: a. Table body may be single-spaced, one-and-a-half spaced, or double spaced. b. Left align the information in the leftmost column or stub of the table body (but center the heading). c. In general, center the information in all other cells of the table. However, leftalign the information if doing so would improve readability, particularly when cells contain lots of texts. Table 2 Schedule of Research Activities Activity Timeline Duration August 9-20, 2021 10 Days A. Planning 1. Preparation of Action Research Activities Proposal Proposal 2. Preparation of Data Gathering Instrument 3. August 23-30, 2021 4. tottto220212019 7 Days 5. Instrument . Instrument 3. Submission of Research Proposal 1 Day September 11, 2021 B. Implementation 1. Identify the participants to be used in the study study through Pretest 2. Meeting the parents and conduct orientation on the mechanics of the intervention 3. Strategy Implementation 4. Encoding, Analyzing and Interpreting the November 2-4, 2021 4 days November 8-12, 2021 5 days November 15 – December 17, 2021 January 3-14, 2022 25 days 10 days Data using the Appropriate Statistical Tool 5. Formulating conclusions, January 10-12, 2022 summary and recommendations recommendations from the interpreted data C. Submission of Liquidation Reports and 30 days upon the Deliverables release of fund 3 days 1 day D. Dissemination 1. Preparation of the final action research paper 2. Checking, proofreading, and editing of final action research paper 3. Liquidation of expenses/cost estimates 4. Submission of the final action research paper June 6–10, 2022 5 days June 13–17, 2022 5 days June 20–21, 2022 2 days June 22–24, 2022 3 days August 23, 2021 – 81 days June 24, 2022 ________________________________________________________________________ Span COST ESTIMATES Include the detailed research cost, broken down per research task, activity and/or deliverable. The detailed research cost of the itemization and pricing are also given. Number (Ex. Table 2) appears above the table title and body in bold form. Number tables in order in which they are mentioned in the study. There is an introductory paragraph followed by the table (APA format) of Materials and Costs. Items are given on the 1st column of the table, Unit Cost on the 2nd column, and Total Cost on the 3rd column. Total is given on the last line. The research fund according to DO 43 s. 2015 shall be utilized for the implementation of the approved research proposals and results dissemination and shall be guided by the existing auditing and accounting rules and regulations and shall not be used for the following expenses: - Equipment - Software - Salary, overtime fee, honorarium for research persons, statisticians, and other providers of services - Utilities - Office rental - All overseas travel and all items not included in the approved research proposal The following are allowed to be included in Cost Estimates: Notarial Fee, Supplies and Materials, Transportation/ Travelling Expenses, Communication and Internet Expenses, and Snacks for the Participants. Table 2 Materials and Costs 1. 0. 0. 0. 1. 6. 7. 8. Item Ink Letter sized bond paper Folder Flash Drive (8 GB) Internet Load Food for the Participants Transportation and Travel Expenses (for seeking Technical Assistance), Submission of Pertinent Documents,Results Dissemination and Canvassing of Materials Notarial Fee Grand Total Unit 4 Bottles 4 Reams 20 Pieces 1 Piece 2 Cards 30 Meal Sets Estancia Iloilo City Round Unit Cost Total Cost 300.00 1,200.00 220.00 880.00 8.00 160.00 700.00 700.00 500.00 1,000.00 80.00 2,400.00 400.00 3,200.00 200.00 200.00 9,740.00 Plan for Dissemination and Advocacy This section deals with the plan of the researcher on how to disseminate and utilize the research findings. A. Types of Dissemination & Utilization (Brief description) ⮚ Classification of Delivery/Usage e.g. Scholarly Presentations, School Announcements, Publications, Actual Application, Policy Basis B. Venues/Platforms (Brief description) ⮚ Tangible & Specific Activities & Places e.g. Specific Departments/Units, Conferences, LAC, INSET, Meetings, Research Journals, Web Journals, Pamphlets, ESIP, SRC C. Target Audience/Recipient (Brief description) ⮚ Identified People/Groups e.g. Learners, Parents, Co-Teachers, DepEd Teachers, DepEd Officials References In writing the reference section, the researcher/s should consider the following: 1. List of all references (in alphabetical order) cited in the body of research. 2. Follow the American Psychological Association (APA) 7th Edition format in citing the reference. Notable Points in Writing References 1. What are References? · References provide the information necessary for readers to identify and retrieve each work cited in the text. · In your manuscript, check each reference carefully against the original publication to ensure that the information is accurate and complete. · Consistency in reference formatting allows readers to focus on the content of your reference list, discerning both the types of work you consulted and the important reference elements (who, when, what, and where) with ease. 2. What are the Elements of a Reference? · A reference generally has four elements: author, date, title, and source. Each element answers a question: ü Author: Who is responsible for this work? ü Date: When was this work published? ü Title: What is this work called? ü Source: Where can I retrieve this work? • Considering these four elements and answering these four questions will help you create a reference for any type of work, even if you do not see a specific example that matches it. 3. Reference examples · Reference entry • Author/s last name, Initial(s). (Year of publication). Title of book. Publisher • Smith, T. (2020). The citation manual for students: A quick guide. Wiley. • In-text citation • Parenthetical: (Author’s last name, Year of Publication); (Smith, 2020) • Narrative: Author’s last name (Year of publication); Smith (2020) … 4. How to create a reference when information is missing? • Author o Provide the title, date, and source. o Title. (Date). Source. • Date · · · · o Provide the author, write “n.d.” for “no date,” and then provide the title and source o Author. (n.d.). Title. Source Title o Provide the author and date, describe the work in square brackets, and then provide the source. o Author. (Date). [Description of work]. Source. Author and date o Provide the title, write “n.d.” for “no date” and then provide the source o Title. (n.d.). Source Author and title o Describe the work in square brackets, and then provide the date and source. o [Description of work]. (Date). Source Date and title · · o Provide the author, write “n.d.” for “no date,” describe the work in square brackets, and then provide the source. o Author. (n.d.). [Description of work]. Source. Author, date, and title o Describe the work in square brackets, write “n.d.” for “no date,” and then provide the source. o [Description of work]. (n.d.). Source. Source o Cite as personal communication or find another work to cite. o No reference list entry | (C. C. Communicator, personal communication, month day, year) 5. Formatting the reference page · Apply these formatting guidelines to the APA reference page: · Organize references by the author’s last name in alphabetical order (A-Z) · Double spacing (within and between references) · Hanging indent of ½ inch · Legible font (e. g. Times New Roman 12 or Arial 11) · Page number (in the top right header) 6. Which sources to include in the reference page? · Include sources that you have cited in the text (with an intext citation). · Do not include references to personal communications that your reader can’t access (e. g. emails, phone conversations, or private material). 7. Few reminders in the APA 7th edition reference list entries · Up to 20 authors should now be included in a reference list entry. Use ampersand (&) before the final author’s name · For sources with more than 20 authors (21 and more), after the 19th listed author, any additional authors’ names are replaced with ellipsis (…) followed by the final listed author’s name. Do not place an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. · The publisher location is no longer included in the reference. · Digital object identifiers (DOIs) and URLs are now both presented as hyperlinks for electronic sources. · The label “DOI:” is no longer used for entries that include a DOI. · The words “Retrieved from” (preceding the URLS or DOI) are now only used when a retrieval date is also provided in the citation. · The website name is included (unless it’s the same as the author), and web page titles are italicized. 8. Basic format in writing the reference · Use an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. · Separate the elements in your reference using a period (.). · Sources of works in your reference are italicized. · Do not add a period at the end of an available URL or DOI in your reference. Basic Format Book 1. Author(s). Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A., Author, B. B. & Author, C. C. Use an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. 2. (Year). 3. Title of the book. Note. For works that stand alone (e. g. books, reports), italicize the title. Only capitalize the first word of the title and subtitle and any proper nouns. 4. (Edition). Note: if there is an edition or volume, include it in parentheses and use abbreviations of ed. or vol. 5. Publisher. Note You do not include the publisher location or databases where you retrieved it. Book Chapter with Editor/s 1. Author(s). Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A., Author, B. B. & Author, C. C. Use an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. 2. (Year). 3. Title of the chapter. Note. For works that are part of a greater whole (e. g. articles, chapter), use sentence case. Only the first word of the title and subtitle and proper nouns are capitalized. 4. In Editor(s). Note: List each editor’s last name and initials as A. A. Editor, B. B. Editor, & C. C. Editors, include (Ed.) or (Eds.) in parentheses, and end with a comma. 5. Title of the book. Note: For works that stand alone (e. g. books, reports), italicize the title. Only capitalize the first word of the title and subtitle and any proper nouns. 6. (pp.xx-xx) 7. Publisher. Note: You do not need to include the publisher location or databases where you retrieved it. Journal Article 1. Author(s). Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A., Author, B. B. & Author, C. C. Use an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. Read more from APA Style website if there are 21 more authors. 2. (Year). 3. Title of the article. Note. For works that are part of a greater whole (e. g. articles, chapter), use sentence case. Only the first word of the title and subtitle and proper nouns are capitalized. 4. Title of the journal, Note: Italicize and capitalize each word in the journal. 5. Volume. Note: Italicize the journal volume. If there is no issue, include a comma before the page range. 6. (Issue), Note: If there is an issue number in addition to a volume number, include it in parentheses. 7. Page range. 8. DOI (Digital Object Identifier). Read about DOIs from the APA style website. News/Magazine Article 1. Author(s). Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A., Author, B. B. & Author, C. C. Use an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. Read more from APA Style website if there are 21 more authors. 2. (Year, Month Date). Note: You do not need to abbreviate the month 3. Title of the article. Note. For works that are part of a greater whole (e. g. articles, chapter), use sentence case. Only the first word of the title and subtitle and proper nouns are capitalized. 4. Title of the Newspaper of Publication. Note: Italicize and capitalize each word in the publication. 5. URL Web page 1. Author(s). Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A., Author, B. B. & Author, C. C. Use an ampersand (&) before the final author’s name. Read more from APA Style website if there are 21 more authors. 2. (Year, Month Date). Note: You do not need to abbreviate the month 3. Title of the article. Note. For works that are part of a greater whole (e. g. articles, chapter), use sentence case. Only the first word of the title and subtitle and proper nouns are capitalized. 4. Source. Note: Usually the official name of the website. If the source would be the same as the author, you can omit the source to avoid repetition. 5. URL Dissertation or Thesis 1. Author. Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A. There is usually only one author for a thesis or dissertation, you don’t need to include any faculty advisers. 2. (Year, Month Date). Note Provide as specific a date as is available. 3. Title of the dissertation or thesis. [Doctoral dissertation or Master’s thesis, Name of University].Note. For works that stand alone (e. g. books, dissertations, theses), italicize the title. Only capitalize the first word of the title and subtitle and any proper nouns. The title page will indicate whether it’s Doctoral Dissertation or Master’s thesis and list the names of the university granting the degree. 4. Source. Note: Include the name of the database or institutional repository where you can access the work (e. g. ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global, PQDT Open, CSU ScholarWorks) here. 5. URL Note: If available it’s available. Online Report 1. Author(s). Note: List each author’s last name and initials as Author, A. A., Author, B. B., & Author, C. C. If there is no author, spell out the name of the organization that published the report. 2. (Year, Month Date). Note Provide as specific a date as is available. 3. Title of the report or document. Note: For works that stand alone (e. g. books, reports), italicize the title. Only capitalize the first word of the title and subtitle and any proper nouns. 4. Source. Note: Include the names of the parent agencies or other organizations not listed in the group author name here. 5. URL