Facilitator: Eric Lim Wee Hiok PARTICIPANT’S NAME: _______________________ 1 WHAT IS TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS? Training needs analysis (TNA) is concerned with addressing skills gaps at the organisational level, the group level and the individual level, and falls under the remit of learning and development. Training Needs Analysis (TNA) is an assessment of the gap between the knowledge, skills and attitudes that the people in the organization currently possess and the knowledge, skills and attitudes that they require to meet the organization's objectives. WHAT IS THE PURPOSE OF A TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS? The purpose of a training needs analysis is to close the gap between the actual and desired situations by determining discrepancies in outcomes, placing them in order of priority and selecting the most important for closure or reduction (Rothwell and Kazanas 1998). TNA therefore consists in collecting, analysing and comparing concrete (measurable) data representing, on the one hand the actual 'performance' of a system (objectives, outputs or variables in terms of actions) and, on the other hand, its desirable 'performance', whether wanted internally or externally, with the overall goal of identifying as accurately as possible the specific needs of the clienteles affected by the activities of an educational or training system” (Lapointe 1992). The training needs analysis must be carried out before training activities are organized, since it guarantees the success of those activities. It ensures synergy among individual learning needs and the quest for effectiveness, job performance, and strategic organizational development (Potter et al. 2003). To do so, the data analysis process must allow collection of the largest possible volume of information concerning the type of optimum skills required to perform a task, the actual level of skills among the population(s) under review, their opinion concerning their own performance, potential causes of the gap between the actual and desired situations, and various possible solutions, from a number of perspectives (Rossett 1987). In fact, the training needs analysis outcome is expressed not in the form of a training policy or program, but a database defining the measured training 2 needs of the population(s) under review. This database will provide the foundation for development of the training specification. WHEN IS IT NECESSARY TO PERFORM A TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS? The training needs analysis is a vital phase in planning training that will successfully close the gap between the actual and desired situations. It ensures that the right remedy is applied to the right problem. Since limited budgets are available for training, the preferred areas of training must be those ensuring that the anticipated outcome will be achieved, as well as maximum gains for the professionals and their organization (Sims 1990). In some contexts, as described below, needs analysis is crucial (McConnell 2003). Changes in the system or in work: When a work description is changed or operating methods are reviewed, or simply in the case of new expectations, training is often required. At that time, a training needs analysis allows identification of staff training needs, to enable them to adapt appropriately to the changes introduced. Example: The director of nursing and the physician responsible for the emergency department have adopted a new work allocation protocol for each staff member involved in cardiac arrest cases in the emergency department. They want to inform the various staff members in question. Introduction of new technology: Where a work environment adopts a specific new technology, this normally goes hand in hand with a method of use that must be the subject of training. In addition, this training must anticipate how use of this new technology will be adapted to the specific organizational context to which it is introduced. Accordingly, learning to operate a specific new technology requires acquisition of additional skills or knowledge, which may vary in the various staff groups likely to make differing use of the technology in question. It is therefore appropriate to perform a training needs analysis to specify the training needs of each of these groups as regards use of the new technology. Example: With the establishment of a public health information centre including, among other things, environmental data concerning air and potable water quality, a training needs analysis was ordered for regional environmental health staff. The purpose of this analysis was to determine the additional knowledge this population needed to correctly interpret and apply the environmental data provided by the Department of Sustainable Development, Environment and Parks. 3 Introduction of new government standards: Revised or new government standards normally require training for professionals whose practice is affected by these changes. This is the best way to ensure compliance with the new standards. At that time, the training needs analysis will allow definition of the skills that must be developed for correct implementation of these new standards. Example: The government introduces new occupational health and safety rules in clinical laboratories. Laboratory coordinators must therefore analyse training needs with respect to implementation of these rules and the skills required to implement them correctly. Following this needs analysis, they organize training activities for all medical technologists, so that they will have all the necessary tools to apply the new government rules. Decline in quality of work or performance in department or organization: Many factors contribute to a decline in quality of work or performance of a given department or area of activity. A training needs analysis among the various professional groups involved will indicate whether training is one of the ways to improve attainment of preset objectives. Example: A team of social workers is responsible for preventing sexually transmitted and blood-borne infections among injection drug users (IDUs) in a specific neighbourhood. Over time, the team notices that its activities are reaching fewer and fewer IDUs in the neighbourhood and that the incidence of sexually transmitted and blood-borne infections is rising, while the number of its social workers is also increasing. A training needs analysis will establish what these workers need to acquire or change to have a greater impact on their environment and counter this decline in performance. Departmental meetings, opinion surveys, organizational studies and separation interviews Departmental meetings, opinion surveys, organizational studies and separation interviews of employees leaving their job, although conducted for other purposes, are often opportunities for disclosure of felt or demonstrated training needs. Training needs analysis will then provide the possibility of establishing whether these needs are common to all staff. Example: At a team meeting, a professional states that she does not feel she has the necessary skill to perform a specific part of her job. After listening to this individual, other professionals also admit that they feel they have the same shortcoming regarding this part of the job. Conducting a training needs analysis is then appropriate, since it will be used to accurately identify the weaknesses in capacities making up the skills enabling them to perform the part of the job in question. 4 Lack of skills and knowledge: Setting of specific objectives by an organization does not provide information as regards staff capacity to attain them. A training needs analysis will determine whether training needs exist associated with attainment of these objectives and, if so, which ones (Rossett 1987, 43). Example: A work team promotes physical activity among the teenagers of a community. The team realizes that it is having problems communicating with its target public. Given the rapid changes in teenagers’ communications methods and lifestyles, the team leader carries out a training needs analysis to identify the knowledge and skills the professionals must improve in order to make better use of the resources available to reach their target public. Absence or lack of motivation: Absence or lack of motivation affects work performance. Two factors increase in proportion to work motivation: the value ascribed to work and the level of its performance. The greater value an individual ascribes to their work and the higher their performance, the greater will be their motivation. The inverse relationship also holds true. In such a situation, a training needs analysis can help identify the causes of lower performance or bring to light undeveloped skills. Welltargeted training, by cultivating deficient skills, could quickly raise the level of self confidence–a factor often intrinsically linked to motivation. Training can be beneficial for an individual lacking in motivation if it enables the person to achieve quick gains in their level of confidence. Example: A work team is responsible for promoting pro-health public policies. Although it performs a large volume of activities designed to raise awareness among decision-makers of the social, economic and environmental determinants of health, the group loses motivation because its work seems to have no impact on emerging public policies. A training needs analysis identifies a need for training in decision-making processes leading to establishment of public policies. Following a training activity on public policy development, the work team learns to intervene more effectively in the decision-making process. As a result, it has an impact on development of public policies and its motivation accordingly increases. Changes in Manpower or Structure: In today’s context, changes in the organisation’s manpower is becoming more common. With companies attempting to optimise their business models amidst the digital transformation era, the organisation’s structure may need to evolve faster than expected. To ensure continuity, the existing manpower within the organisation may be forced to undergo a Job-Redesign to fulfil the organisation’s strategy and requirement. 5 CAN TRAINING OVERCOME PROBLEMS IN THE WORKPLACE? Despite the benefits provided by well targeted training, other factors must be taken into account to improve operations and work quality. Although a training needs analysis suggests shortcomings related to work performance or quality, training will not necessarily solve the problem. To avoid misconceived training needs, it is essential to draw a distinction between causes and symptoms. The gap between actual and desired levels of skills in a specific organization is a symptom that may have both multiple and varied causes (Sims 1990). For example, staff shortage, mismanagement, incorrect work allocation, lack of procedures, inaccurate work descriptions and unrealistic set objectives may all be causes of a gap between the actual and desired situations. Where the obstacles are organizational in nature, training may achieve little or nothing, since it will only change those subjected to the learning process. The author of The Revolution in Training, Robert F. Mager, makes the point clear in the following way: “If a man doesn’t have a skill, train. If he has the skill but doesn’t perform, manage” (Tracey 1971). Here are some examples of solutions not involving training (Wright 1999): • review and rewrite work descriptions; • increase staff or budgets; • make changes in staff; • implement methods and measures to stimulate motivation among professionals; • develop management policies and structures. In a work environment where there are no incentives, productive professionals are burdened with the heaviest workload, while less competent professionals are simply ignored. In other words, high-performance individuals are penalized. In such a situation, introduction of new policies may be beneficial: • reorganize work methods. It is said that the work environment is harmful when its organization, spatial layout and available tools are inadequate. The work quality of the organization’s staff will then decline despite their motivation and adequate skills. Development of better work methods, redesign of the work area or better matching of individuals and jobs may be beneficial in a situation where the work environment is harmful (Rossett 1987): • enhance communication systems and practices; • even…do nothing. To conclude, we will introduce here an essential element of successful training activities. If we want to see training produce the best possible results, it is necessary to create a situation allowing transfer of gains from training in the organization’s daily operations. For example, work tools must be consistent with what the professionals have learned during training. In fact, where training is part of the solution to a specific situation, it is often necessary to apply complementary organizational methods, so that the organization can truly benefit from the training (Pérusse 2001). 6 EVOLUTION OF LEARNING AND DEVELOPMENT *Put a Tick in the circle which best describes your current situation TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS CYCLE Analysis of Current Situation Consolidating and Analysing Results Conducting the TNA Identifying Desired Outcome(s) Designing TNA Methods 7 ANALYSIS OF CURRENT SITUATION In order to analyse the current situation, you will need to examine the factors involved in designing the desired outcome(s). In the boxes below, write down your company’s situation. 8 Other Factors: 9 COMPETENCY MAPPING Competency Mapping is a process of identifying key competencies for an organization and/or a job and incorporating those competencies throughout the various processes (i.e. job evaluation, training, recruitment) of the organization. HOW TO MAP COMPETENCIES 1. Skill identification from the job description. Every resource has their designated set of job description allotted. Identify the skills from the explained job description. 2. Club all the skills across organization. Repeat the above-mentioned process department wise. Talk to managers and resources. Sum up all the Job description and list down every possible skill that contribute towards an effective task performance. 3. Categorize skills. Fix the categories appropriate for your organization. This may depend on your organizational industry, product, strength and client base too. Example- Technical, Behavioural and Processes; are some of the category that are common to almost all. 4. Develop a skill dictionary. As the name suggests, it is the explained dictionary of every skill that we have mentioned above. We have to explain level wise description of every skill. You can either choose a three - level or four – level dictionary. Level 1 being lowest, Level 2 is Needs improvement, level 3 being Average and level 4 is good. If the highest level is level 5, try to mark accordingly. Other types of Mapping Behaviour Technology Event Lominger Competency List: https://academianlp.org/lominger-67-competencies https://www.inspq.qc.ca/pdf/publications/884_Cadre_reference_ang.pdf - PAGE 23 EXAMPLE OF FRAMEWORK 10 PLANNING YOUR DESIRED OUTCOME(S) To be able to identify the desired outcomes, it is therefore important to consider all the factors affecting this. The overall organisation strategy tends to be the over-arching factor above all the other factors. In order to identify this, you will need to engage the key stakeholder, usually the HR Lead or the CEO/COO. Example: A new CEO wanted to implement 5 training days for each employees across the entire organisation. He is willing to fund the training fees involved. However, there are many barriers involved. As the organisation is an engineering firm, one of the biggest challenges is for operations to miss out 5 days of productions per operator. The operators will in turn has to clock more hours in Overtime which is a result of this policy. Productions might also be affected. PRINCIPAL CONSIDERATIONS Organisation Goals: This is probably the first and top priority which you need to address. If the organisation is beginning her sales in a new product, training resources have to be dedicated to any activity related to the product. Examples: Product Knowledge, Procurement procedures, Finance processing, Sales Training, templates and checklists etc. Budget Available: The budget available in your disposal will determine how extensive your TNA should go. If you have very modest budget, there is no point in conducting TNA which will go into areas which your budget cannot support. 11 Training Hours vs Operations: One of the main challenges of running training in an organisation is the time taken out of the employee’s time to attend the program. If the training is not related to the employee’s work, but due to company policy, the employee has to attend the training, the employee is less motivated to learn, or even attend. In cases where the employee is contributing to production or operation figures, training presents a challenge to their supervisors and in productions lagging behind deadline. In such instances, overtime will need to be clocked which might reduce the company’s profit margin. Equality across departments: One of the considerations you have to pay attention to is the amount of training which each department is receiving. It is difficult to strive for full equality. Thus, whatever plans you made, make sure you have valid reasons for the plans. Why is it important to think about the desired outcome(s) beforehand conducting the TNA? ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________________________ Mantra: Leave no stone unturned 12 YOUR APPROACH TO THE TNA IN YOUR ORGANISATION Imagine you have been appointed as the in-charge to conduct a TNA in your company. Using the knowledge you have acquired, make a plan on how you would approach the project. 13 DESIGNING YOUR TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS After analysing your current situation, you should have a much better idea on what type of training the organisation needs. The competency categories also allows you to simplify any of the methods you choose for the participants or employees. Your next step is to design the methods of collecting the data. Below are some factors to consider before you design your TNA: Organisation Structure: This is perhaps the most important consideration. You need to think about how the data collection is to be done and how in-depth. Do you go all the way down to the last employee, or should you stop at supervisory levels? Do you have assistance within your team to collect the data and arrange the schedules? Depth of TNA: The depth of the TNA is important, as it will affect participant’s perception. If you go too in-depth during data collection, you might create a false impression that the training will be made available. Thus, it is vital that the depth you are going to collect the data is close to how much your budget can manage. You can also consider to put a disclaimer at the beginning of all the data collection methods. Timeline: Ideally, you should complete your TNA and plans before the beginning of the financial year for your organisation. The best time to begin all the plans is in the last quarter of the financial year. That would allow you to go through the entire process, and made the necessary communications. Focus Area(s): In some instances, there are some areas which your management are more interested than others. When that is the case, you have to ensure that your TNA is highly focused on those areas. For example, if the CEO is wanting to push new products for next year, then the training budget should be spent on that first, before the other competencies are to be considered. In another example, the management team might implement a new training policy to ensure all employees clock at least 5 days of training. In this example, you can consider more comprehensive TNA methods to ensure you have sufficient choices for the employees to choose from. There are many methods of conducting the TNA. The data collection process is essential to prepare yourself to present the overall training schedule to the management team. Data provides support to your plans, with references to the budget, type of training selected, target participants and objectives. The data allows you to present a more compelling case. Mantra: Under-promise, Over-deliver 14 Below are the types of Data Collection Method: Quantitative: - Online Surveys - Manual Questionnaires - Delphi Technique - Aptitude Test - Part of Performance Appraisal - Part of Employee Engagement Survey Qualitative: - Interviews - Focus Group Discussions - Observations - Part of Team Building or Strategic Retreat https://www.inspq.qc.ca/pdf/publications/884_Cadre_reference_ang.pdf - PAGE 54 EXAMPLE OF TRAINING NEEDS ANALYSIS PLANS The key components of a detailed TNA are shown above. It is important to know your resources. You can also choose to add more components such as business objectives or challenges that the data is trying to resolve, or the new product which the organisation is rolling out. Once you have your plan, you can develop a Gantt Chart to follow through the entire process. 15 CONSOLIDATION OF RESULTS AND PRESENTATION Your next step is to consolidate the results and prepare a presentation to your HR Lead and/or the management team. By now, you will have loads of data and information to present. Presenting them all will be a disaster as it is information overload. Not preparing sufficient information will give management the impression that you are not well prepared. Mantra: Always go through your presentation with your HR Lead first There are some key components in presenting your TNA and training plans which you should take note of. Presentation of Results: You would have quantitative and qualitative data to crunch. Your role is to highlight the findings which enable you to derive your training plans. This linkage is essential to the success of your role. For quantitative data, you can opt to use charts and tables to present. Support the data using the qualitative data you find to summarize based on departments, categories or competencies. Always summarize your data with some key findings. Business strategies / Challenges: It is also important to understand that while your data says one thing, the management team might be saying another. Thus, it is vital that you take into account the business strategies and challenges, and your plans can also facilitate or assist in strategies or addressing certain gaps. Training Plans: As much as possible, your derived training plans should take both the data, and the business strategies and challenges into account. Arrange your plans into various categories, e.g. technical training, soft skills training, team learning, computer skills. You should also take note of the timeline in terms of frequency needed to fulfil the participant’s requirement and possible blackout periods. If you can, build in a buffer where participants turnout might not be good. Budget required: For this portion, it will be very different depending on whether your training budget is centralised or de-centralised. It is important to ensure that the costing per pax is as low as possible. If you find difficulty in doing that, you can also split up the number in accordance 16 to the seniority of the participants. In theory, the more senior the staff, the more expensive is the cost of each day of training. If the budget is decentralised, then the cost should be presented on a functional/ departmental level. Timeline: The timeline should include the frequency of each training, and any black-out or peak period which you have avoided to ensure that operations are not affected. In this portion, you should demonstrate your ability to practice your due diligence before presenting the plans with timeline. Next Steps: This step may or may not be necessary depending on your plan. If your plan includes programs which straddles across departments, e.g. Microsoft Excel training, then you can include steps necessary for the departments to fill up the various training classes which are scheduled. This is likely to be done by the supervisors working under the Functional or Department Leads, 17 CASE STUDY 1 You are now a HR Generalist working in an engineering company which produces metal parts for large machineries. You just have a change of CEO from the founder, to the founder’s eldest son. He has approached your HR Lead, and expressed his interest in implementing training programs internally within the organisation. Your HR Lead has in turn approached you to lead the project in finding out more on the training needs of the organisation and make a proposal to her. Historically, the company has never had any training programs implemented. The company is largely divided into several departments: (1) Corporate Office (Inclusive of HR, Finance and Admin), (2) Marketing and Sales, (3) Productions and (4) Delivery. There is about 150 staff across the company, divided into 4 levels, (1) C-suite, (2) Department Heads, (3) Supervisors and (4) Operators. Within your group, discuss how you would approach the project. CASE STUDY 2 You are now a Generalist in a logistics firm with a call centre of about 50 operators. The team lead of the call centre has approached your HR Lead to ask for assistance in conducting training to improve the level of call handling in the call centre to better facilitate client’s queries and to promote the business in a positive way. The HR Lead has assigned you with the project. The company has recently gone through a cost saving exercise which resulted in the headcount cut in the team through a redundancy exercise. These are done through a skills assessment process and a voluntary exercise. The remaining staff were unmotivated and the level and quality of the call centre had dropped significantly. There were also rumours of a further round of job cuts planned by the management. Within your group, discuss how you would approach the project. CASE STUDY 3 You are now working in a medium sized hotel with 156 rooms. The hotel is local in city fringe and is near a train station. The building is now under construction and will be completed in three months’ time and the hotel will begin operations one month after completion, and the official launch is three months after completion. You have just be hired as the L&D Lead for the hotel. Your role is to design a training plan in conjunction with the recruitment of the staff. The hotel headcount is targeted at 300-350 staff, divided into the following departments (1) Corporate Office (Inclusive of HR, Finance, Admin and Security), (2) 18 Marketing and Sales, (3) Housekeeping and laundry, F&B and (4) Front Office, and (5) Cleanliness and maintenance. The staff will be divided into 4 levels, (1) C-suite, (2) Department Heads, (3) Supervisors and (4) Operators. Within your group, discuss how you would approach the project. CASE STUDY 4 You are now working in a medium sized hotel with 156 rooms. The hotel is local in city fringe and is near a train station. The hotel has been in operations for one and a half years. The HR Lead of the hotel felt that the hotel is in a steady state. The training within the hotel are mostly conducted within the various departments with the senior doubling up as trainers to new hires and juniors. Staff turnover in the hospitality industry is high at close to 20%. The hotel’s staff turnover is about 15% for the time in operations. He wants you to ENHANCE the training within the hotel staff to improve productivity and service standards, to assist in the staff turnover rate and improve the hotel’s reputation as a service oriented hotel. The hotel headcount is targeted at 300-350 staff, divided into the following departments (1) Corporate Office (Inclusive of HR, Finance, Admin and Security), (2) Marketing and Sales, (3) Housekeeping and laundry, F&B and (4) Front Office, and (5) Cleanliness and maintenance. The staff will be divided into 4 levels, (1) C-suite, (2) Department Heads, (3) Supervisors and (4) Operators. Within your group, discuss how you would approach the project. 19 References and Recommendations 1. Training and Development: Enhancing Communication and Leadership Skills, by Steven A. Beebe, Timothy P. Mottet and K. David Roach Training and Development presents a step-by-step approach to developing training programs organized around the Needs-Centered model of training. This book suggests that every aspect of developing a training program should be based upon trainee needs. It includes application and discussion questions at the end of each chapter, offering readers the opportunity to put principles and skills to the test. It also provides readers with examples of needs assessment questionnaires, task analysis, training plans, and other tools that can be used as models when planning their own training programs. 2. Employee Development on a Shoestring, by Halelly Azulay It has been estimated that 70 percent of employee development takes place through informal learning, rather than through formal learning events. Employee Development on a Shoestring offers insights and lessons for leveraging non-training activities for on-the-job employee development. It therefore offers specific implementation techniques for developing motivated, engaged employees in today’s “do more with less” business environment and acts as a tool kit for any employee developer including: Step-by-step guidance for initial goal-setting, templates, worksheets, checklists, ways to capitalize on development ideas that are easy to implement immediately and cheaply, and the hidden value of job rotation, stretch assignments, and special teams. 3. Telling Ain’t Training- 2nd Edition, by Harold D. Stolovitch and Erica J. Keeps First published in 2002, this book is full of training myth-busting research and ready-to-use tools, delivered in a lighthearted and entertaining style. This new edition has been updated, expanded and enhanced to reflect almost a decade of progress. This is a book that faithfully practices what it preaches, engaging the reader from page one and immediately involving them in the first of many tryit-yourself exercises in learning. 4. Design For How People Learn (Voices That Matter), by Julie Dirksen Products, technologies, and workplaces change so quickly today that everyone is continually learning. Many of us are also teaching, even when it’s not in our job descriptions. Whether it’s giving a presentation, writing documentation, or creating a website or blog, we need and want to share our knowledge with other people. But if you’ve ever fallen asleep over a boring textbook, or fastforwarded through a tedious e-learning exercise, you know that creating a great learning experience is harder than it seems. In this book the authors describe how we can all use the key principles behind learning, memory, and attention to create materials that enable an audience to both gain and retain the knowledge and skills being shared. 20 5. The Adult Learner, Seventh Edition, by Malcolm S. Knowles Ph.D., Richard A. Swanson Ph.D. and Elwood F. Holton III Ed.D, The late Malcolm S. Knowles, Ph.D., was one of the leading authorities on adult education in the second half of the twentieth century. He wrote the first major accounts of informal adult education and the history of adult education in the United States, authoring more than 200 articles and 18 books. He is famous for his adaptation of the theory of Andragogy as a conceptual basis for adult education and learning, and was a significant force in reorienting adult educators from ‘educating people’ to ‘helping them learn’. This update of a pioneering classic contains all Knowles’ original chapters alongside a newer second part by Elwood “Ed” Holton and Richard A Swanson charting the advancements on these core principles. A third section includes selected readings from previous editions to illustrate the theory’s evolution, as well as important articles from other key experts around the world for a comprehensive view. 6. The Learning and Development Book, by Tricia Emerson and Mary Stewart This book was written for the experienced, L&D professionals looking for ways to be more effective. The insights in this book are meant to help when you feel stalled. This book gives you simple ideas and concepts to illustrate these needs and illuminate learning and development efforts for you, your clients, your teams and your company leadership. L&D is simple. Chapters are written to be short and easy to digest. Each contains just one “nugget of wisdom” from years of learning and development consulting experience. Each chapter is self-contained, so read one or read them all, in any order you like. 7. Essentials of Online Course Design: A Standards-Based Guide, by Marjorie Vai and Kristen Sosulski, In spite of the proliferation of online learning in higher education, creating online courses can still evoke a good deal of frustration, negativity, and wariness in those who need to create them. Essentials of Online Course Design takes a fresh, thoughtfully designed, step-by-step approach to online course development. At its core is a set of standards that are based on best practices in the field of online learning and teaching. Pedagogical, organizational and visual design principles are presented and modeled throughout the book and users will quickly learn from the guide’s hands-on approach. The course design process begins with the elements of a classroom syllabus which, after a series of guided steps, easily evolve into an online course outline. 8. The Gamification of Learning and Instruction: Game-based Methods and Strategies for Training and Education, by Karl M. Kapp Learning professionals are finding success applying game-based sensibilities to the development of instruction. This book shows how to design online instruction that leverages the best elements of online games to increase learning, retention, and application. It explains how to match different game strategies to types of learning content for the right learning outcome and discusses how gamification techniques can be used in a variety of settings to improve learning, retention and application of knowledge. Supported by peer-reviewed studies and examples from corporations who have adopted game-based learning successfully, the book illustrates how combining instructional design thinking with game concepts can create engaged and interactive learning experiences across a variety of media, from online to face-to-face. 21 9. Training on Trial: How Workplace Learning Must Reinvent Itself to Remain Relevant, by James and Wendy Kirkpatrick While upbeat lingo abounds about ‘complementing strategic objectives’ and ‘driving productivity’, the fact is that most training does not make a significant enough impact on business results, and when it does, training professionals fail to make a convincing case about the value added to the bottom line. The vaunted ‘business partnership model’ has yet to be realized – and in tough economic times, when the training budget is often the first to be cut, training is on trial for its very existence. Using a courtroom trial as a metaphor, “Training on Trial” seeks to get to the truth about why training fails and puts the business partnership model to work for real. Readers on both sides of the ‘courtroom’ will learn how to stop viewing training as a cost center, and bridge the gulf between what learning functions deliver and what business units need to execute their strategies. “Training on Trial” provides a new application of the Kirkpatrick Four – ‘Level Evaluation Model and many tips and techniques that allow lessons learned to be put into action now. 10. The Six Disciplines of Breakthrough Learning: How to Turn Training and Development into Business Results, by Calhoun W. Wick, Roy V. H. Pollock and Andy Jefferson Whether you’re an HR or OD professional or work in a training department, learn to apply the principles of follow-through management within your organization in the new edition of this bestselling resource. Incorporating new research on learning and learning transfer, along with new case studies, interviews, and tools, this edition shares guidelines, proven in practice by many Fortune 500 companies, on how to design comprehensive learning experiences in leadership and management, sales, quality, performance improvement, and professional certification. You’ll discover the theories and principles underlying the approach, as well as the practical methods, tools, and roadmaps for bridging the “knowing-doing” gap. BABBIE, Earl, The Practice of Social Research, Belmont, Wadsworth, 1995. BERNARD, Laurence and Céline FARLEY, Analyse des résultats de l’enquête sur les besoins de formation concernant l’investigation des éclosions, Institut national de santé publique du Québec, 2006. FERNANDEZ, Julio, Réussir une activité de formation, Montréal, Les Éditions coopératives Albert Saint-Martin, 1988. GENT, Michael J. and Gregory G. DELL’OMO, “The Needs Assessment Solution: Analyzing your environment to find out how much, if any, new training is needed”, Personnel Administrator, July 1989, pp. 82-84. GRANT, Janet, “Learning needs assessment: assessing the need”, British Medical Journal, No. 324, 2002, pp. 156-159. HUBERMAN, Michael and Matthew B. MILES, Analyse des données qualitatives : Recueil de nouvelles méthodes, Brussels, De Boeck Université, 1991. JACKSON, Winston, Research methods: rules for survey design and analysis, Scarborough, PrenticeHall Canada, 1988. JEAN, Pierre, “Pour une planification méthodique des activités de formation”, Pédagogie médicale, No. 2, 2001, pp. 101-107. JENICEK, Milos, Introduction à l’épidémiologie, Saint-Hyacinte, Edisem inc., 1977. KING, Gary, Robert LAPOINTE, Jacques-Jean, La conduite d’une étude de besoins en éducation et en formation, Sillery, Presses de l’Université du Québec, 1992. LASNIER, François, Réussir la formation par compétences, Montréal, Guérin, 2000. LAWTON, Linda, “Approaches to Needs Assessment” in Elizabeth R. PERKINS, Ina SIMNETT and Linda WRIGHT, eds., Evidence-based Health Promotion, Chichester, John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 1999, pp. 325-332. 22 MANHEIM, Jarol B. and Richard C. RICH, Empirical Political Analysis: Research Methods in Political Science, White Plains, Longman, 1995. McCONNELL, John H., How to Identify Your Organization’s Training Needs: A Practical Guide to Needs Analysis, New York, AMACOM, 2003. MILLER, Janice A. and Diana M. OSINSKI, “Training Needs Assessment”, July 2002, http://www.ispi.org/pdf/suggestedReading/Miller_Osinski.pdf NEWSTROM, J. and J. LILYQUIST, “Selecting Needs Analysis Methods”, Training and Development Journal, Vol. 33, No. 10, 1979, pp. 52-56. PÉRUSSE, Michel, “L’identification des besoins de formation: une étape trop souvent negligée”, Travail et santé, vol.17, No. 4, December 2001, pp. 30-35. PETERSON, Robyn, Training Needs Analysis in the Workplace, London, Kogan Page, 1992. PICARD, Florent, “Semaine 12 : Analyse et interprétation des résultats”, Collège Montmorency, 2005 [Consulted November 16, 2007], http://cmontmorency.qc.ca/~fpicard/410335MO/Recherche/chapitre09.htm PINEAULT, Raynald and Carole DAVELUY, La Planification de la santé : concepts, méthodes, stratégies, Montréal, Agences d’ARC inc. (les éditions), 1986. Politique 2500-002, Université de Sherbrooke, [Consulted November 23, 2007], http://www.usherbrooke.ca/accueil/documents/politiques/2500-002.pdf POTTER, Margaret A., Gerald BARRON and Joan P. CIOFFI, “A Model for Public Health Workforce Development Using the National Public Health Performance Standards Program”, Journal of Public Management Practice, Vol. 9, No. 3, 2003, pp. 199-207. POTTER, Margaret A., Christine PISTELLA, Carl I. FERTMAN and Virginia M. DATO, “Needs Assessment and a Model Agenda for Training the Public Health Workforce”, American Journal of Public Health, Vol. 90, No. 8, August 2000, pp. 1294-1296. ROSSETT, Allison, Training Needs Assessment, Englewood Cliffs, Educational Technology, Inc., 1987. ROTHWELL, William J. and H. C. KAZANAS, Mastering the Instructional Design Process: A Systematic Approach, 2nd ed., San Francisco, John Wiley & Sons, Inc., 1998. TRACEY, William R., Designing Training and Development Systems, New York, American Management Association, Inc., 1971. Training Needs Analysis Guidelines and Assessment Procedure, Carrickfergus Borough Council, October 2004, [Consulted June 16, 2007], http://www.carrickfergus.org/UPLOADS/DOCS/Training%20Needs%20Analysis%20Procedur e%202004.pdf WILSON, Jeremy, Analyzing Politics: An Introduction to Empirical Methods, Scarborough, PrenticeHall Canada, 1988. WRIGHT, Linda, “Training Needs Analysis (TNA)” in Elizabeth R. PERKINS, Ina SIMNETT and Linda WRIGHT eds., Evidence-based Health Promotion, Chichester, John Wiley & Sons Ltd., 1999 pp. 91-98. 23