Article Evaluation - Rubric
Clarity
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Accuracy
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Precision
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
matches
standard)
7.5points
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Relevance
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Depth
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Breadth
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
not match
standard)
0points
matches
standard)
5points
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Logic
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Fairness
Does not provide
examples of
where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
Provides only one
example of where
the standard is or
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
Provides one
example each of
where standard is
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points
Significanc Does not provide Provides only one Provides one
Provides one
e
examples of
example of where example each of
example each of
where standard is the standard is or where standard is where standard is
and is not met
AND/OR uses
inappropriate
example (does
not match
standard)
0points
is not met AND
uses the standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
5points
and is not met
(with
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard)
7.5points
and is not met
(non-obvious, with
detailed and
thoughtful
explanations)
AND uses
standard
appropriately
(example
matches
standard).
10points