Uploaded by raymondmoono

esther m

advertisement
Introduction
The importance and value of the organization are perceived in how its stakeholders or parties come
together and harmonize their interests to achieve common goals and objectives of the organization
while achieving their personal goals and objectives as well. Harmonizing the interest of employees
with the interest of employers is one important step to the organization’s success and or failure.
Therefore, there should be strategies that seek to understand the interest in common and those in
the conflict between employers and their employees. Hence, putting in a sense the differences in
many factors of interest by organizational players or stakeholders, industrial relations which are
also called employee relations comes into play. Conlon, Paul M. (2012) The Industrial Relations
section depicts the interaction between management and workers in the industry, as well as the
role of a regulatory body in resolving industrial disputes, as a result of their combined attitudes
and approaches to managing the affairs of the business, for the benefit of not just the management
and the workers, but also of the industry and the economy as a whole. A diverse group of
behavioral practitioners and theorists perceives industrial relations differently. Some thought
industrial relations were tied to class conflict, while others thought it was related to cooperation,
and yet others thought it was related to competing interests of distinct groups. There are four major
approaches to Industrial Relations based on these perceptions. These are; the unitary approach,
Marxist approach, human relations approach, and pluralist approach. However, this writing seeks
to disagree with one of the approaches, the unitary approach in particular as it is not based on
reality but the perception of the theorist.
Unitarianism
The unitary method is founded on the idea that all members of the organization, such as managers,
workers, and other staff, have a common set of objectives, purposes, and interests and, as a result,
work together to achieve shared goals. In this case, the disagreement is viewed as a transient
difference caused by inadequate management or employees' failure to grasp and integrate with the
organizational culture.
The unitary method is founded on the concept that if everyone in the organization has a common
interest/purpose and works unanimously towards its accomplishment, the overall profitability of
the firm can be raised, hence promoting harmonious relations. The unitary frame of reference is
given to Alan Fox (1966). The organization, according to the unitary viewpoint, points to a single
or unified authority and loyalty system. The unitary approach prioritizes shared values, interests,
and goals and it avoids the difference in interest. Those who embrace this perspective see all
organizational participants as a team or family, emphasizing shared values, goals, and a common
destiny. Unitarianism, in essence, means the absence of factionalism inside the organization
(Fajana, 2000). Conflict is viewed as ridiculous, and firing strikers is prioritized over dialogue or
negotiation. Conflict is regarded as unhealthy, unpleasant, or negative. Trade unionism is outlawed
and suppressed because it is viewed as an illegitimate intrusion or trespass on management's
authority to control. According to Armstrong, M. (2009), under the unitary model, trade unions
are considered an outside intrusion into the corporation, competing for employee allegiance with
management. The authoritarian and paternalistic nature of the unitary theory is evident. It is promanagement in nature, emphasizing consensus and industrial peace. The basic assumption of this
worldview is that the organization runs in perfect harmony and that all conflict is unnecessary.
Discussion
Shorts site of Unitarianism
The following understanding of the unrealistic and false character of the unitary approach can be
offered based on the assumption of the unitary method:
Conflicting interests of employees and employers
Although employees have a vested interest in the success of the firm and typically act responsibly,
they also have other interests, such as maximizing their compensation, developing and improving
their careers, taking time off work, devoting time and energy to their families, and so on. Employee
interests vary greatly, but they typically relate to fair treatment by employers, career objectives,
and managing work-related obligations in proportion to demands from outside the work
environment.
Employees have interests outside of work: they want to be able to take vacation time even when
there is a lot of work to be done; they want to be able to care for their children when they are
unwell, and they want to spend time on non-work pastimes that they like. Employees have interests
that may conflict with those of the organization, even within the office: they want the boss to spend
money on training for them; they want a promotion; they want to work on things that interest them
rather than tiresome chores that must be accomplished. The employers’ interests, on the other hand,
are opposed to those of the workforce. The employer wishes to maximize profits to pay out
significant dividends to its stockholders; widen the market segment; maximize output, stay in
business, and so on, which this unitary strategy does not account for.
Management as the only Authority
The unitary approach highlighted that authority should only originate from management. This is
most likely to cause conflict in the organization because employees' interests may not be
considered very much as unitary advocates of authoritarian leadership in the organization, this
would mean that employees' interests are most likely not to be considered much in decision making
because managers who spend much of their time in the office are the ones to decide on issues faced
by employees who spend time on solid work and experience whatever challenges first hand. The
benefits of employees engaging in decision-making and power were overlooked by the unitary
model. Employees develop a professional and personal stake in the organization and its overall
success when they participate in decision-making. Employees are more productive when they are
actively involved in numerous elements of the organization and want to see their efforts succeed
overall because they have a sense of authority.
Dividends vs salaries and wages
The other interest difference can be observed in the compensation or end gains of employees and
employers after production sells. The company's profits are not distributed equitably, indicating
how big of a disparity exists between the interests of employees and employers. Employers share
dividends which are the profits from the overall activities of the organization. While employees
get salaries and wages which can be the end profits from hours worked or units produced. In
other words, the employer gets the better side of the deal. So, the unitary approach was not very
logical and objective on the part of interest.
Trade unions
Trade unions play a vital role in facilitating efficient communication between employees and
management. They offer advice and help to ensure that disagreements do not escalate into
serious disputes. A trade union's primary function is to represent employees at work. However,
they also play a larger role in defending their interests. They also have a vital educational
function, organizing courses on a variety of topics for its members. Seeking a healthy and safe
working environment is another important aspect of union activities. Decisions made through
collective bargaining and talks between employers and unions have more clout. Trade unions
play an important role in fostering discussion between employees and employers, and they strive
to align the interests of all parties. Workers' behavioral manifestations are primarily governed by
the labor unions to which they belong. As a result, workers' views and attitudes toward
management are influenced by trade union perceptions and attitudes toward management,
forming a mindset that regulates/promotes contact with management.
Conclusion
The unitary method is nothing more than a theory based on genuine evidence. The method took
little account of the employees' interests, instead of assuming equal interest with no meaningful
analysis or objectivity.
Reference
1. Conlon, Paul M. (2012) "Conflict of Employee–Employer Interest: Introducing an
Optimal Work Happiness Framework." Rice University: https://hdl.handle.net/1911/77668.
2. Armstrong, M. (2009) Armstrong’s Handbook of Human Resource Management Practice
London: Kogan Page
3. Fajana, S.A. (2000) Industrial Relations in Nigeria: Theories and Features Lagos: Labofin
and Co
4. Fox, A. (1966) Industrial Sociology and Industrial Relations, HMSO, London. Fox, A.
(1974)
Download