PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila THE STEERING WHEEL AND CLUTCH OF BPO EMPLOYEES: FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN RELATION TO A HEALTHY WORKING ENVIRONMENT In partial fulfillment of the Academic requirements for the ACCOUNTANCY, BUSINESS, and MANAGEMENT A Research Project Presented by: Donato, Francis Angelo S. Natividad, Kered Zilyo C. Ventura, Justine Dave E. Ambrona, Nicole Marie M. Desengaño, Maxine Aimelleen S.M. Reyes, Samantha Nicole M. Tagalag, Yshi M. GRADE 12 - ST. JOHN BAPTISTE DE LA SALLE 2019-2020 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management APPROVAL SHEET This research entitled, THE STEERING WHEEL AND CLUTCH OF BPO EMPLOYEES: FACTORS CONTRIBUTING TO EMPLOYEE RETENTION IN RELATION TO A HEALTHY WORKING ENVIRONMENT prepared, submitted, and discussed by: DONATO, Francis Angelo S. NATIVIDAD, Kered Zilyo C. VENTURA, Justine Dave E. AMBRONA, Nicole Marie M. DESENGAÑO, Maxine Aimelleen S.M. REYES, Samantha Nicole M. TAGALAG, Yshi M. of Grade 12 - ST. JOHN BAPTISTE DE LA SALLE (ABM-B), in fulfillment of the requirements for the RESEARCH PROJECT subject, has been examined and hereby recommended for approval and acceptance. Mark Joseph Zapanta Research Adviser PANEL OF EXAMINERS Approved by the committee on ORAL EXAMINATION on ___May 15,2020_____ Mark Joseph Zapanta Chairman Maynard Jasper Dolot Member _ Roselie Yago__ Member Accepted in completion of the RESEARCH PROJECT subject and for the partial fulfillment of the academic requirements for the Accountancy, Business, and Management Track. Mr. Alvin A. Altarejos Senior High School Principal PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ACKNOWLEDGMENT There are many people to whom the researchers are grateful for, with their help and support. With deepest gratitude and sincere appreciation, the researchers want to thank the following: To our Almighty God for the gift of knowledge, perseverance, and integrity to finish this task. He has made this substantial project possible. Mr. Alvin A. Altarejos, Pateros Catholic School Senior High School principal, for signing the approval sheet for our data gathering among the BPO companies in BGC and Mckinley Hill. Mr. Mark Joseph Zapanta, Research Project teacher, for his effort in imparting us his knowledge about research and his tireless amendment to our frequent consultations. Mr. Mark Jasper Dolot and Ms. Roselie Yago, the panelists in our final defense, for criticizing our research paper in a constructive way and in giving feedback and advice on revising our project. The researchers recognize the coordinating body of Pasig City Library for allowing the researchers to use the different books as a reference to this research’s Review of Related Literature. We give our warmest appreciation to Sutherland Global Services (BGC, Taguig) especially to their human resource officers: Ms. Nick Allen Fernandez and Mr. Martin Gurrero and to team leaders of Ingram Micro Philippines (Mckinley Hill, Taguig City), namely: Ms. Nurailam Capioso and Mr. Fernando Turingan for their participation in our data gathering despite their hectic schedule. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al i PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management DEDICATION This research project is mainly dedicated to their family of the researchers who continually guide and support them throughout their journey in senior high school. Also, for their friends who always support and push them most especially amid hardships. Most especially the research project was also dedicated to our God the Father who made everything possible and who help them through the whole process of their project. Lastly, this research is dedicated to the researchers themselves. It was not easy to accomplish this task without their hard work and perseverance. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al ii PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ABSTRACT The objective of this study is to determine the role of a healthy working environment in employee retention by knowing the factors that greatly affect the employee retention of companies. This study uses a descriptive type of design and purposive sampling technique in which respondents are chosen particularly those who have experienced in a corporate setting. The respondents of this study are 90 BPO employees and 3 people with the position of team leader, supervisor, and human resource officers. The researchers discover the different factors that contribute to employee retention concerning a healthy work environment. According to the employees, the most common factor that affects employee retention is reward and benefits which has a total of 26%. On the other hand, according to employers, the most common factor that affects their employee retention is organizational culture. The researchers conclude that behind many factors affecting the healthy working environment, personal and confidential reasons is also a factor an employee decides to leave the company that cannot be controlled by the management. Lack of benefits offered and the right compensation contributes to the desire and personal reasons of the employees to leave and choose to be on a different company and career path. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al iii PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management TABLE OF CONTENTS Acknowledgement- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - i Dedication- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - ii Abstract- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - iii Table of Contents- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- iv List of Figures - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - v CHAPTER 1: The Problem and its Background o Background of the Study - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 2 o Research Problems and Questions - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 3 o Conceptual Framework - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 4 o Assumptio - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 5 o Scope and Limitations - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 5 o Significance of the Study- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 7 o Definition of Terms - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 8 o Ethical Concerns/Issues - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 9 CHAPTER 2: Review of Related Literature o Nature of a Healthy Working Environment - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- 11 o Theories on Employee Retention - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 13 o Strategies of Staff Management - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- -- 18 o Factors Affecting Employee Retention- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 20 o Effects of Healthy Working Environment- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 27 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al iv PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHAPTER 3: Methodology o Research Design- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 30 o Sampling and Participants- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 31 o Research Instrument- - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 32 o Data Gathering Procedure - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 33 o Data Analysis- - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 34 CHAPTER 4: Presentation, Analysis, and Interpretation of Data o Demographics- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 36 o Presentation/ Discussion - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 41 o Interpretation of Interview of BPO employees and Human Resources, Team Leader, and Supervisor -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 55 CHAPTER 3:Summary, Conclusions, and Recommendations o Summary of Findings- - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 61 o Conclusions- - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - 63 o Recommendations- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 65 References - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - vi Appendices- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - vii o Appendix A - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - vii.1 o Appendix B -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - - - - - - - - - vii.2 o Appendix C- -- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - vii.3 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1.1 Conceptual Framework - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Figure 4.1 Age- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 36 Figure 4.2 Gender- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 36 Figure 4.3 Monthly Salary Range- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Figure 4.4 Nationality- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 38 Figure 4.5 City Address- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 39 Figure 4.6 Department- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 40 Figure 4.7 Years in Service- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- - - 41 Figure 4.8 Is this your first time working in a BPO company?- - - - - - - - 42 Figure 4.9 Number of Companies Worked for- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 43 Figure 4.10 Factors in Healthy Working Environment?- - - - - - - - - - - - - 44 Figure 4.11 Reasons for Choosing Facility- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 45 Figure 4.12 Reasons for Choosing Employers- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 46 Figure 4.13 Reasons for Choosing Co-workers- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 47 Figure 4.14 Reasons for Choosing Rewards and Benefits- - - - - - - - - - - - 48 Figure 4.15 Reasons for Choosing Company Culture- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 50 Figure 4.16 Do you see yourself staying longer in the company you’re 4 37 working for?- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -- 51 Figure 4.17.1 Yes, I see myself staying longer for...- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 52 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al v PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.17.2 Yes, I see myself staying longer because...- - - - - -- - - - - - - 53 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHAPTER 1 – THE PROBLEM AND ITS BACKGROUND Background of the Study The working environment plays an important role in the performance and productivity of employees. The productivity and performance of the employees may be affected due to a poor work environment as this affects their well-being and may result in low satisfaction in their job. As such, this would mean that factors of an employee’s working environment should be taken into consideration for it can affect the work of employees in both positive and negative ways. The World Health Organization (WHO) has constructed these factors in its definition of a healthy working environment. Based on the experts' review, WHO proposes the following definitions: A healthy workplace is one in which workers and managers collaborate to use a continual improvement process to protect and promote the health, safety, and well-being of all workers and the sustainability of the workplace by considering the following, based on identified needs: Health and safety concerns in the physical work environment; Health, safety and well-being concerns in the psychosocial work environment, including organization of work and workplace culture; Personal health resources in the workplace; and Ways of participating in the community to improve the health of workers, their families, and other members of the community. Since an average person spends time at least 40 hours working in a week, it is only essential that organizations look for the wellness of their employees which promotes physical, mental and social well-being, thus, it becomes a challenge for the management The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 2 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management to provide a safe workplace for their employees for the reason that this can become a factor why employees want to quit their jobs since they do not have satisfaction in working. As students in the field of management, it is only imperative to study a healthy working environment as such, the researchers, chose this topic for the reason that a healthy working environment is a foundation for employees’ retention in a company. The researchers chose this topic since having a healthy environment workplace is very relevant to all employees of a certain business which can lead the researchers to know the factors that greatly affect the employee retention of companies. Research Problem and Questions The objective of this research is to determine the role of a healthy working environment in employee retention. As stated in the work of Shakeel, N. (2015) employee retention involves making an action plan that convinces workers to stay in the company for the maximum period. Considering that money is not the only factor that keeps an employee motivated, catering to the diverse needs of employees takes part in discovering economic dimensions that must be applied to the company’s human resource strategy. In developing a system of strategy for employees, requisite compensation is necessary but insufficient as a motivation for employee’s overall performance in the workplace. This proves that other factors are contributing to the behavior of employees as they work in their fields. Knowing these factors would help a lot for companies to keep in touch with employees as a response to employee retention. This study aims to find out the factors that greatly affect the company’s employee retention. Specifically, the researchers aim to answer the following questions: The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 3 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 1. How do Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) employees define a healthy working environment? 2. What factors do BPO employees deem relevant to a healthy working environment? 3. What is the primary reason for an employee to stay for the company? 4. What are the other factors that contribute to employee retention? 5. What is the most common factor that might cause an employee’s attrition? 6. How do employers promote and create a healthy working environment in their workplace? Conceptual Framework Employees & employers Healthy Working Environment Employee Retention Programs Years in Service Cooperatives Benefits Figure 1.1 Conceptual Framework The employees and employers are the variables the researchers will use to provide an answer to the problem of the factors that greatly affect the company’s employee retention. Programs play an important role in the company’s healthy working The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 4 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management environment as it provides harmonious relationships among the workers and owners of the company. This may include programs and practices that promote fairness and justice at work. Employee retention may be effective when the employers can retain their employees by providing cooperatives and benefits that can be beneficial for the employees. An employee’s years in service may also contribute to its retention. Assumption A healthy environment has a big role in every company’s employee retention. It is one of the common factors why employees are staying at their company. Toxicity of the workplace could be a factor why most of them are deciding not to stay in their company. To testify the overall impact of the workplace environment on employee retention, the following assumptions have been made. A healthy environment is ideal when it comes to maintaining a positive outcome in a stressful atmosphere. The most important element that influences employee motivation and happiness, and how productive and efficient they can be, all goes down to their working environment. A healthy workplace environment is a huge factor and has a positive impact on employee retention. Scope and Limitations This project’s main purpose is to determine factors contributing to employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment as part of the Human Resource Officer’s staff management. Human resource has a vital role in this study. Specifically, the focus of the study is employees and employers in the Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) industry. According to Outsource Accelerator (2019), BPO companies contribute The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 5 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 11% to the GDP of the Philippines. With 1.2 million people involved in 700 outsourcing companies, this makes BPO a reliable population. These companies have a formal and standard system of operations and organizational structure compared to small scale businesses and other business entities. Respondents of this study are employees with at least 4.6 years of service since it is the average length of time in a job for wage and salary workers according to Doyle, A. (2019). For employers, knowing that they have great experience in their field, at least 2 years of service in their current position is a qualification needed by the researchers. Certainly, strategies are employed by employers or top managers since they carry out the command of the board of directors and implement it to their subordinates. Employees then appreciate what employers implement and assess their adequacy. The involvement of these two human resources helps determine the effectiveness of the human resource strategy and factors that fulfill employee retention. In the data collection, the employees’ comments and viewpoints are the primary concerns of the researchers. Knowing that compensation is a motivational factor for employees in a firm, an individual’s financial information is a private matter that is why numerical analysis and computations of their salary would not be disclosed in this exploration. More so, in the course of the study, familiarizing factors contributing to employee retention leads to the involvement of laws and policies in a certain business entity. The research takes place at Bonifacio Global City wherein some BPO establishments are situated. Personal interaction with an employee or employer of BPO companies related to or familiar to the researchers can also be done in their houses. The entire research project is conducted during the second semester of the academic year 2019 – 2020. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 6 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Significance of the Study 1. Employers and Institutions Employers would gain insights on what are the possible factors that may affect the will and decision of an employee to stay in a company. It gives them the idea that they may be a factor that contributes to that. Also, this can help them find ways on how to improve the system that they implement in the company which would lead to employee satisfaction thus increasing productivity in the workplace and finally leading to success. 2. Community and Economy The community would benefit in a way that if companies have good productivity, the output of those companies would increase and the community would produce more gross domestic product (GDP) that helps with the economy of the Philippines. Also, fewer people would need jobs if they are properly treated and satisfied with their jobs because institutions are taking care of their employees. 3. DOLE The Department of Labor and Employment would also gain insights for the development of their labor and employment codes that may contribute to a company’s employee retention. This government agency could produce more comprehensive laws and policies that lean more toward employees which would be for the protection of employees and to emphasize their dignity and value as hardworking laborers of a company. 4. Future Researchers This study would provide a glimpse and help student researchers and other future researchers to be aware of what are some factors that contribute to a company’s employee The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 7 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management retention. It would help them become good managers and this would be of help as a future reference for more studies in the future. Definition of Terms Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) – is a method of subcontracting various businessrelated operations to third-party vendors. BPO hoppers – these are agents that hop from one BPO company to another. Every jump leads to the hope that the next company is where they will settle down. Gross Domestic Product (GDP) – is the total monetary or market value of all the finished goods and services produced within a country’s borders in a specific time. Hygiene - to describe factors that cause dissatisfaction in the workplace, are extrinsic, and are linked to things such as compensation, job security, organizational politics, working conditions, quality of leadership, and relationships between supervisors, subordinates, and peers. Hedonic – of, relating to or characterized by pleasure. Proximity – refers to how near something is to another thing, especially in distance or time. Toxicity - defined as any job where the work, the atmosphere, the people, or any combination of those things cause serious disruptions for the rest of your life. World Health Organization (WHO) – is an agency of the United Nations (UN). It mainly deals with public health matters of people all around the world and acts as a coordinating authority on international public health The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 8 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Ethical Issues/Considerations Informed Consent Informed consent means that each of the participants involved in the study is fully aware of the evaluations conducted. This allows the participants to be informed about the purpose of why the study is being conducted, what are the potential impacts of their participation, how the findings can be used, and who has access to the findings. The main purpose of informed consent is to let the participants decide as to whether they would participate or not. This gives the target participants an overview of what can be their participation in the study. Voluntary Participation Participants involved in the study are free to withdraw their participation at any time without negatively impacting the study being conducted. This can help the researchers to gain more trust from the participants who voluntarily participate in the study. Voluntary participation also means great aid to researchers. To access this, the researchers allow the participants to withdraw or remain as a participant in the study. Recognizing Participant’s Welfare Harm can be both physical and/or psychological and therefore can be in the form of stress, pain, anxiety, diminishing self-esteem, or an invasion of privacy. It is very important not to harm any of the participants. Causing harm to the participants might lead to not finishing the research and can greatly affect the reputation of the researchers. Confidentiality All the different data gathered in the research are entitled to confidentiality, whether it is made to the public by the researchers. To provide a proper way of giving respect to the people involved or the data gathered itself. The researchers decided to show The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 9 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management the preliminary results to the participants and invite them to comment. It is very important to consider how reports are worded to ensure that there is no opportunity for people to be identified even though names are not used. It is very important to give respect to the participants, whether chosen or volunteer, to acknowledge their requests to hide their identity. This is very important and helpful in studies which involve very personal contact or with participants who have shared very personal information about themselves. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 10 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHAPTER 2 - REVIEW OF RELATED LITERATURE According to the World Health Organization (2010), a healthy working environment is one in which there is not only an absence of harmful conditions that can cause injury and illness but an abundance of health-promoting ones. The working environment is significant to employee performance and productivity knowing that the organization can provide good terms and conditions when it comes to employee workplace, employees are able to stay for the long term in the organization because employees have fewer complaints and are satisfied with the working environment. With that, the researchers have considered the following themes to be taken into consideration in conducting this research: the nature of a healthy working environment, theories for employee retention, factors, strategies, and effects. Nature of a Healthy Working Environment Ensuring that companies have sufficient and comfortable accommodations to their staff, they must have a healthy working environment. In a site called sahealth.sa.gov.au, entitled “What is a healthy workplace”, World Health Organization (2009), states that a healthy workplace is where the management and employees co-act to continually improve health, safety, and welfare of all the workers in sustaining the productivity of the company. Having a healthy working environment helps its employees to be more comfortable and productive in doing their works. In addition, WHO (2010), also states that people tend to spend one-third of their lives at work, thus, a working environment can have a significant impact on employee’s health and well-being. This makes a healthy working environment play a vital role in employee’s work for them to be more efficient in their tasks. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 11 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Also, according to the site: sahealth.sa.gov.au, entitled, “What is a healthy workplace” (2009), there are three factors in having an effective healthy working environment, namely: Healthy People, Healthy Places and Healthy vision. Healthy people (individual factors), focuses more on the individual’s needs such as developing and improving their health insurance, as well as helping them build knowledge and skills of the employees. A healthy place (environmental factors), talks about the general environment where the company offers to its employees. It provides a physical work environment and gives relevant resources to actively enhance their healthy behavior. The last factor is healthy vision (organizational factors), which refers to the management’s different business practices and policies that support and encourage healthy behavior of its employees. An effective healthy working environment can have a significant impact on employees’ productivity and performance, thus, making them stay more to their respective companies. To further elaborate, according to Heryati (2019), there are four aspects to look into in creating a healthy working environment: workplace culture, the physical environment, and occupational health and safety, health, and lifestyle practice, and supportive workplace environment. In the first aspect, workplace culture, a company having a positive workplace culture that is being practiced by the employees as well as the superiors, tends to have better productivity and to be healthier as everyone is happy and contented. Great workplace culture can help in keeping the employees be productive and help the company to retain its best employees. Upon building a healthy working environment, it also involves the physical environment of the company such as an office or workshop and the occupational health and safety of their employees. Recognizing the employee’s welfare can also help to keep them happy and comfortable working in the company. Simple things such as maintaining the office to its good condition and keeping it clean can make the employees not worried about staying in the workplace. Allowing the employees to be safe in their working environment can help The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 12 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management the company maintain its employees. The third aspect is health and lifestyle practice. The company should be looking after their employees to keep them stay and ensuring that they are being cared for. Employees are one of the assets in an organization, having the company’s utmost support to their wellness can help employees increase productivity and performance, better teamwork, and reduce workplace accidents. Encouraging employees to join daily morning runs of the company helps them to have a better healthy lifestyle. Theories on Employee Retention A common concern across all industries is employee retention. Though various factors may contribute to turnover among personnel, recent research may shed new light on practical means of improving retention and reducing the costs associated with excessive employee turnover. Human resources professionals can gain a wealth of insight into best retention practices by learning about job embeddedness and its implications. According to Ehrler, M. (2018). “Job embeddedness represents a broad set of influences on an employee’s decision to stay on the job. These influences include on the job factors, such as bonds with co-workers, the fit between one’s skills and the demands of the job, and organization-sponsored community service activities (e.g., the plant sponsors quarterly neighborhood clean-up days). It also includes off-the-job factors, such as personal, family, and community commitments. Ehrler also proposed that Job embeddedness theory identifies three critical elements that indicate the level of connection that individuals may develop within their organization. These can be broadly defined as: Fit — How an individual’s work relates to their values and goals Links — How an individual is connected to other people and activities The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 13 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Sacrifice — The level of disruption an individual would experience if they were to quit their job. By understanding these key factors, the researchers can assess up to what extent the employees are at risk of leaving an organization and how best to promote retention. Job embeddedness explains the factors that influence an employee's decision to stay in a particular job. Some of the factors may be the work environment, co-workers, and the job itself. Ehler proposed that job embeddedness theory has three vital elements that display the connection of the individuals in their organization namely; fit, links, and sacrifice. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs also connects to how an employer addresses the needs that will vary at each level and contribute to the satisfaction of employees. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs is a charted set of human requirements that are important for an individual to achieve complete development and self-actualization. Based on the statement of Rouse, M. (2018) “The hierarchy is diagramed as a pyramid starting at the bottom with basic needs that must be satisfied for an individual to be able to progress to addressing more secondary needs. It is understood that a person who has to struggle to survive does not think as much about or attain self-actualization as a person whose survival is relatively assured. The hierarchy of needs shows the general progression of pursuits for people once survival and comfort are assured into the spiritual, the creative, and or intellectual. The levels of the hierarchy, starting from the base of the pyramid are: 1. Physiological needs - These are biological requirements for human survival. Examples include air, food, water, shelter, clothing, warmth, sex, and sleep. 2. Safety needs – Examples include protection from elements, security, order, law, and stability. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 14 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 3. Love and belongingness needs – These are the first of social needs, involving the desire for interpersonal relationships and being part of a group. Examples of these needs include friendship, intimacy, trust, acceptance, receiving, and giving affection and love. 4. Esteem needs - Classified into two categories: 4.1 Self-esteem, stemming from dignity, achievement, mastery, and independence. 4.2. The desire for reputation or respect from others, including status and prestige. 5. Self-actualization needs – Examples include realizing personal potential, selffulfillment, and seeking personal growth and peak experiences.” This theory emphasizes the need of companies to consider the basic requirements of their employees including health, job security, and payment. They can then advance to the position of the employee in the organization. When employees know that employers care about their health and that their job is guaranteed, they will be committed to the company. Juneja, P. (2018) states that “Motivation plays an important role in employee satisfaction and eventually employee retention.” This explains that employee retention has a direct relationship with the motivation of employees which is why the Frederick Herzberg Theory is also known as Motivation-Hygiene Theory is applicable to be used by the organization to make the employee stay for the long term. Also According to Kujik, A. (2018) the people’s job satisfaction depends on two kinds of factors; The job satisfaction influenced by motivation factors such as achievement, recognition, responsibility, work itself, advancement, and personal growth while the other one is job dissatisfaction influenced by hygiene factors such as working conditions, co-worker relations, policies and rules, supervisor quality, and base wage or salary. Herzberg claims that these factors function together and if the employers take away the dissatisfaction factors it doesn’t mean employees will be satisfied rather the employees are just no The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 15 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management longer dissatisfied. Herzberg also proposed that the two factors can have four combinations. 4 different combinations exist at work: 1. High hygiene and high motivation This is the ideal situation. Employees are very motivated and barely have any complaints 2. High hygiene and low motivation Employees have few complaints, but they are not motivated, they see their work simply as a paycheck. 3. Low hygiene and high motivation Employees are motivated, their job is challenging, but they have complaints about salary or work conditions. 4. Low hygiene and low motivation This is the worst possible situation. Employees are not motivated and have a lot of complaints. Based on the four combinations made by Herzberg's theory, if employees have low hygiene and low motivation, employees tend to complain a lot since the employers are not able to provide benefits and needs of the employees. While, if employees have low hygiene and high motivation, employees are just motivated at work but still have complaints in working conditions and salary. And if employees have high hygiene and low motivation, employees just have few complaints in their working conditions but are not motivated at work. Lastly, if employees have high hygiene and high motivation, employees have barely any complaints in the job and are motivated at work. Thus, employees need to have high hygiene and high motivation to be able to work for the long term in a company. Another theory that contributes to the ideas on how employees view their job that affects employee retention is made by John Stacey Adams known as the Equity Theory. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 16 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management According to Mulder, P. (2018) “Adams is convinced that employees lose motivation when they think or feel that their input is greater than the output.” The input-referred in Adams Equity Theory includes the quantity and quality the employees make in carrying out their work. This involves the following: Effort – This is how much work employees put to fulfill their jobs and duties. It is the basic level input that employees do. Skills – The ability of employees to execute their work which employees gained through training and experience. Knowledge – This is an input where employees accumulate through education and training, interest in their field, and development. Experience – What employees have that helps the employees gain lesson and knowledge which can be used in their work. Social Skills – This is what employees used when interacting and communicating with their co-workers and employers to exchange information and knowledge. Loyalty – The value that employees give to the organization by supporting the goal of the organization. These then refer to the time employees’ engagement in working to the company. While the output refers to the Equity theory is divided into two; 1. Financial rewards which include salary, bonus, and profit-sharing. These are basically about the monetary benefits that an employee receives when the work is done and keeps the employee do the assigned work as employees receive rewards in return. 2. Immaterial rewards which include recognition, challenge, and responsibility. This type of reward helps the employees feel motivated because this is how the organization recognizes the employees’ work thus, engaging in the company because employees enjoy working. Adams Equity Theory proposes that there is a need of balancing the knowledge and skills an employee puts into their work and the result employees get in return. This is to The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 17 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ensure that employees can carry out their work well with having a healthy working environment. The Equity Theory also suggests that to have a balance between the input and output of the employees, the organization should practice fair treatment to all employees. Furthermore, using Adams’ Equity and Herzberg’s theory allows employers to be able to determine employee retention rates and be able to know the factors needed to focus on so that employers may avoid the employees from leaving the company. The organization should motivate the employees to work and know the factors that affect the employees in their work to make the employee stay from the company. Strategies of Staff Management Retention of productive employees is a major concern of Human Resources professionals that is why staff management must be effective. In a site called humanity.com, in an article entitled “Effective Staff Management is the Backbone of Your Business” retrieved on 2010 it is stated that staff management is important because this is the backbone of any business and poor industrial relations can mean that productivity will be low and staff turnover will be high. This signifies that staff management plays an important role in employee retention. Employee turnover can be lessened and avoided on the condition that a company does well in managing their employees. Also, it states that good communication serves as an important factor when it comes to successful staff management. Criticisms can be valid and taking them seriously can help improve the company. An employer must allow the employees to contribute ideas making them feel valued while benefiting from their useful ideas. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 18 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management The high turnover rate is one of the biggest problems BPO industries are facing that is why to achieve effective retention, BPO’s apply strategies and use different tools strategically. Employee turnover is so expensive because organizations pay direct exit costs when an employee leaves and incur additional costs to recruit and train new hires which is why an article entitled “BPO Employee Retention”, states that employers must “Hire the right people. Retention starts with recruitment itself.” That is why the employer must identify the requirement they need including the characteristics of the people they want to hire. It is important to hire people who are productive and are likely to stay for a longer time. Furthermore, it also states that the employer must “Find the reason why employees are leaving.” and this can be achieved by conducting exit interviews with the employees after 3-4 months of leaving the job because of most employees do not want to disclose the true reason why they leave the job so long as they are in the organization. A site called currandaly.com, in an article entitled “Employee Retention Strategies in the BPO Industry” states that the environment plays an important factor in increasing employee retention in BPO that is why an employer must “create a flexible working environment”. Having a flexible and convenient working environment helps in keeping the employees engaged, efficient, and productive in their job. By giving such extended maternal leaves for mothers, flexible hours for employees and even making those in need to work from home can help build a sense of trust, loyalty, and motivation from employees to work harder for the company. Moreover, employees are most likely to stay if they see that there’s an opportunity for them to grow that’s why employers must “provide opportunities for career growth” for their personnel. Conducting seminars and training helps in encouraging career growth and professional skills development among employees. Training is a bridge that can lead to employee satisfaction and a higher retention rate for one’s company. Keeping the The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 19 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management employees learning and the development moving by initiating mentorship and higher education programs can serve as one of the strategies in increasing employee retention that is why developing career plans for employees is vital. Besides, it is also stated in the article that “Competitive salary and address concerns of health, security, transportation, and food” count as one of the strategies for effective employee retention. Thus, according to the article, from a survey, healthcare benefits were listed among the most important reasons to stay. Employees value their health, vision, and dental insurance above all other benefits, and 10% higher base pay is linked to a 1.5 percentage point increase in the chances of an employee staying in their current company. Companies may provide employee benefits such as health insurance, security insurance, transportation allowance, and free food to gain positive results and an increase in productivity, ethics, and better engagement. Employees also demand a raise in compensation as they rise in ranks and by doing so helps in keeping top employees to stay. Contests and awards for performance also reward high achievers while increasing morale and enthusiasm. Factors Affecting Employee Retention Fitz-enz (1990) stated in the work of Rono, E., and Kiptum, G. (2017) that employee retention as a part of human resource strategies is driven by several factors that should be considered by the management as far as organizational culture and career development systems are focused on. Day (2000) pointed out in the work of Rono, E. and Kiptum, G. (2017) that once these factors are mismanaged and disregarded, devastating economic results could happen. Fitz-enz (1997) further explained in the work of Rono, E. and Kiptum, G. (2017) that effective management and utilization of human resources has a great contribution to the organization’s long-term success. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 20 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Compensation and Benefits Compensation as described by Reville, Boden & Biddle (2003), is awarded to an employee as recompense for loss, the harm suffered, or efforts made, typically in the monetary form given by the employer as a salary or wage. However, compensation is not only awarded in the form of money. Non-cash benefits can also be considered as one of its forms. Some of these non-cash benefits are pension, life and health insurance, retirement plans, and allowances which may include company cars or subsidized transportation. This factor is the fundamental and most anticipated part of the occupational welfare for an employee that is mandated by the organization. Hauser & Baggett (2002) emphasized that being one of the most common factors, it plays an important role in attracting and retaining employees. Creating and maintaining compensation policies as well as laying it down from the top-level management down to the low-level management satisfy employees which helps them to remain committed to the organization. Rewards and Recognitions Rewards as defined by Rono, E., and Kiptum, G. (2017) “are any objects stimuli or events that increase the probability and intensity of behavioral actions leading to a such objects (learning, also called positive reinforcement),generate approach and consummatory behavior and constitute outcomes of economic decision-making, and induce subjective feelings of pleasure and hedonic.” Rewards and recognitions are also one of the factors attributed to compensation. One of the management’s jobs is to let employees know that they are valued and this can be fulfilled if they are well-awarded. One of the most efficient rewards is praise and recognition which can boost the overall performance of an employee (De Ocampo, R. & Aguiling, H.; 2018). Rewards are classified into two categories; tangible and intangible rewards. Tangible rewards are considered as fixed pay. These are things that are given by the management in return for services or jobs performed by an employee. Some of these tangible rewards are pensions, The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 21 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management sick pay, insurance, meals, live-in accommodation, parking facilities, private health insurance, mobile phones, Christmas parties, staff discounts, relocation expenses, etc. On the other hand, Intangible rewards are those that cannot be measured through quantity since it does not affect financial acquisition directly. Examples of these are recognition, job autonomy, skill development, and training opportunities, career development etc. (Torrington, D.; Hall, L.; & Taylor, S.; 2013) Employee Empowerment According to Hummayoun & Muhammad (2010) in the work of Nyanjom, C. (2013) employee empowerment creates a sense of belongingness towards the organization. The management should focus on human resource policies, especially on self-governance in order to reduce the turnover rate. Hummayoun and Muhammad (2010) and Choong, Wong, and Lau (2011) set the priorities in empowering employees as stated in the work of Nyanjom, C. (2013). First, the goals of the organization must be established for them to have a guideline in doing their job. Second, the authority would make them feel confident, particularly, the decision-making process. Obligatory tasks that sometimes lead to facing pressure tend to make them persistent until such time that these tasks are finished and solved. In a corporate setting, retaining a competent and capable workforce with higher job satisfaction ensures the commitment of employees in an organization. Employee Training As perceived by Latham (1988) in the study of Nyanjom, C. (2013) the systematic acquisition, development, and improvement of knowledge, skills, and ethical standards for efficient performance of employees are purposes of employee training. Developing their skills would allow more productivity and capability on the specific job they are delegated to. Moreover, Landsman (2004) restated in the work of Nyanjom, C. (2013) explained that training clarifies the role of an employee through proper The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 22 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management supervision of the employer which can lessen the stress in the workplace. Once the desired needs of employees are attained in the training process, expected positive outcomes of the organization such as employee retention, would be reached. An employee’s self-training initiative cannot handle the factors contributing to staff retention. Training can play a primary role in human resource management but it may not be sufficient if other factors will not be focused on. Performance Appraisal Another factor to be addressed is performance appraisal defined by Gruman & Saks (2011) restated in the work of Nyanjom, C. (2013) as “a process of inspecting and evaluating an individual’s performance in his or her duty to facilitate the decision of career development of the individual.” This process serves as an assessment of an employee’s overall contribution to the organization that focuses on ethical values, the work performance itself, and the capability to handle a much higher position in the organization. To prevent the downfall of the organization in times of turbulent situations, nurturing the structure of performance measurement for employees is one of the actions of the organization. In the company’s success, top talents’ contributions are seemingly valuable but other human resources should also be taken care of as a fundamental step on the overall competitiveness and maximum effectivity of the organization. “Performance appraisal plays the role as a medium of communication between management and employee.” However, Beehr and Love (2011) in the work of Nyanjom, C. (2013) explained that if appraisal becomes disoriented even if it is applied, a stressful and confusing result to both the evaluator and respondent is produced from the appraisal. A disoriented appraisal can lead to loss of focus and stressful work conditions which can eventually lead to employee turnover or much worse, employee attrition. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 23 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Working Environment and Organizational Culture As stated by Sylesh, S. & Viswambharan, A.; (2018) “employee’s performance depends on supportive work environment provided by the organization.” The entire working environment serves as a factor to boost the interest levels of an employee encouraging them to have consistent productivity and organizational commitment. Irshad (2009) induced that the work environment connects with organizational culture. An organization must follow a fairness formula so that every decision would not be biased and will be favorable for the employees. Virtues and beliefs perceived by the organization should be governed by employers for clarity of goals and objectives of the business. This conveys that the behavior of an employee should always be aligned to the ethical standards; thus having a great contribution to the entire community. Once they can fully understand the main objective, the desire to leave the organization would be unimaginable. Engle, S. (2017), states in Post, J.’s article entitled “Does Your Company Culture Promote Employee Mental Health?” that "The culture of an organization is a reflection on the mental state of its employees.” which would mean that what the company does is based on the current state of the employees’ mental health implying that the company should also focus their attention to the mental well-being of their employees because it impacts their actions done within the company and those actions are what dictates the culture that the company lives on. At the same time, the company culture will have an impact on the well-being of the employees because the company culture is something that an employee has to deal with in his/her daily life as he/she works in the company, making it a factor for employee retention. Management and Leadership Support Supervisors play a vital role in a working environment. For Heery and Noon (2001) as a supervisor, one must attain responsible supervision as a priority that The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 24 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management corresponds to the job description. The enhancement of human resource management cannot be imagined without a support system. “Any effective program must have strong support from people in senior management positions, and these people must also serve as positive role models to subordinates” (Zenger, J.; Ulrich, D. & Smallwood, N. (2000). The employers should have a program that will give an incentive to a well-performing employee so that it can boost the employee to work harder for them to show dedication to their work. Employers should keep in touch with their personal lives not only with their work performance so that a strong connection can be linked between the two entities. “Managers and supervisors take on a new role when an organization gets into the business of employee development.” Mentoring employees can encourage them to pursue their career and appreciate development efforts. The role of managers is important but more than that, empathy toward their subordinates completes the whole support system (Moses, B. 2000). When an employee feels that he/she is valued and respected it becomes an encouragement for them to do their best and also makes them satisfied with the company they are working for. This may not be a tangible incentive but it can boost the self-esteem of an employee and make him/her feel that he /she is part of the organization’s progress. Co-workers Teamwork is a co-operative process in which people produces great outcome and even extraordinary results (Scarnati, 2001). When employees connect with their colleagues, they are likely to work well. Making use of a team approach can help in the workplace especially when it comes to enriching knowledge and skills from each party and knowing the strength an individual possesses. It may take time for employees to know each other and be interactive but it is a good foundation of a collaborative team and dedication to the company. According to McFarlin, K. (2019) throughout working in the company, good relationships do not only promote positivity in the workplace but it also The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 25 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management increases employee morale. The established relationship becomes a substantial thing that will make it impossible for them to leave the company (Chew, 2004). Facilities The facility is one of the physical and visual factors to be considered in a work setting. As expounded by Bushiri, C. (2014) physical work environment can also be known as an ergonomic workplace. Furthermore, Clean India Journal (2012) states that facilities are the basis of first impressions once an employee enters the workplace. The arrangement, workspace, quality of equipment, and even the aesthetic designs in an occupational setting determines the mood of an employee and their whole performance. For instance, it may cause an employee to be out of focus and have a loss of interest in their work if they are dissatisfied with the facility and services that a company provides. The organization should also make an evaluation tool for further improvement of the facilities that would motivate current employees and attract upcoming applicants. Flexibility of Work Arrangement The flexibility of work arrangement is another factor to consider internally. Kinnunen and Mauno (1998) pointed out in the work of Shakeel, N. and Butt, S. (2015) that employees are instantly dissatisfied once they experience work overload. Employees must not be pressured all the time. Increased working hours have been a problem since it minimizes the productivity span of an employee which results in the decline of work or employee turnover. Freedom in the workplace is still moral with the inclination of realizing limitations and the legal basis. This reveals that every decision of employees for reasonable purposes is still correct without violating the rules and regulations of the organization. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 26 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Work-Life Balance According to Mccormic (2017) in the work of De Ocampo, R. & Aguiling, H. (2018) “the work-life balance is mainly considered to manage and stabilize the personal necessities such as family, hobbies, community work and other activities”. It suggests that an employee’s life must be balanced. Work is the priority of adults but time must also be spent with friends, family, and most especially for personal interests. Darcy & McCarthy (2014) further explained that; work enables some personnel to balance time, emotion, and work pressure intertwined with personal and workplace responsibilities concurrently. Emotions or performance stress should not affect an employee’s work to perform well. Certain aspects of a job can affect the mood and emotions of an employee and therefore impact their performance; that is why joyful employees are more likely to be motivated and to interact more positively with their co-workers. Certainly, an individual evaluates the company if they offer a job where they can still balance life and work (Philips & Edwards, 2013). Finally, maladjusted time management has a great impact on an employee’s decision to stay in the organization (Mccormick, 2017). Effects of Healthy Working Environment A workplace environment can affect an employee’s morale in both positive and negative ways. Heryati (2019) states: “A healthy workplace environment is ideal when it comes to maintaining a positive outcome in a stressful atmosphere.” that is why it is a vital element that the management must maintain for them to keep the company productive, efficient, and for it to function properly, also because of the various effects that it poses among employees and the company. If a working environment is deemed healthy, employees are happier and it shows in their work. Power (2016) states in his article entitled, “10 Reasons Why it is Important to Create a Happy Workplace”, “employee happiness has a multiplying effect” in which The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 27 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management when employees are encouraged and motivated with their work, it is contagious and it spreads throughout the company. It is also said that employees that take joy in their work make excellent models and produce quality work for their company. Furthermore, he also says that a happy environment eliminates stress among employees because he believes that stressed-out employees are distracted employees and it bears a huge impact on productivity that is why he emphasizes the value of a healthy workplace environment. Also, Dr. Thieroff states that when a workplace is healthy, employees are also healthy. It has effects such as “Reduced healthcare costs” and “Low rates of Absenteeism”. Healthy employees tend to go to the doctor less often than sick employees because of stress and other factors affecting them. Companies spend less money for these employees on healthcare and insurance fees. Moreover, employees who call out sick and are always absent cost the company a lot because it reduces their productivity and overall output for the day which is why Dr. Theiroff reiterates the value of a healthy working environment and its effects on the health of employees. Additionally, Dr. Theiroff also stated that a healthy working environment “attract better quality employees”. When companies thrive and maintain a healthy working environment and make the work experience better for employees, it increases the competition among applicants thus making it easier to find employees that are more qualified and competent for the job. There are a lot of benefits that a healthy workplace environment brings in a company. The idea is that once employee satisfaction is met, a healthy and productive company is achieved. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 28 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management The managers play a substantial role in the accomplishment of it. As stated by Kohll (2017), “Management support is crucial to the success of any workplace wellness program.” This implies that as managers and leaders, they have the opportunity to build and promote each employee’s health and well-being. They have the power to implement such rules and policies that may affect the employees and the workplace itself, that is why the managers need to act accordingly for the welfare of the employees and the company. In doing such, it would be a smart investment for the company for them to manufacture efficient and dynamic workers that produce outstanding work for the company’s growth and success. Overall, the nature of a healthy working environment enables the management to have reliable background information and tends to remind employers on how a healthy workplace affects the holistic well-being of an employee as well as an introduction to factors affecting the healthy working environment. Knowing the theories in employee retention helps the management to familiarize different technical terms and psychological explanations of employees’ behavior and why do they stay for a long time in a company; which is why the management should take into consideration the factors that influence the employees in the company. These factors would then be helpful to know the effective strategies for staff management and the effects of having a healthy working environment to the productivity of employees. All of these would help in the formulation of the research instrument such as survey and interview. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 29 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHAPTER 3 - METHODOLOGY Research Design This study uses a descriptive type of design which involves observing and describing the behavior of a subject. The study also focuses on describing the population which answers the questions of what, where, when and how of the subject rather than why. A mixed approach: qualitative and quantitative, is used for the study. Quantitative method is used in the study to emphasize objective measurements and numerical or statistical analysis of data collected through surveys and questionnaires. It also focuses on gathering numerical data and to explain a particular phenomenon. Also the study is using survey questionnaires to gather data that involves descriptive statistical analysis to further analyze the data. The study also used a qualitative method which focuses on data interpretation and generalization which involves descriptive content analysis. This method helps the researchers have a deep understanding of the individual case, whether personal biography, an organization or social setting. A one-on-one interview is used and presented to have a more precise and accurate answers from the respondent perspective, it also helps the researchers to gather more specific answers for the study to gain more knowledge about the study. With the use of the different tools and data collected by the researchers, it can greatly help the study achieve its goal which is to find the factors contributing to employees’ retention in relation to a healthy working environment. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 30 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Sampling and Participants As the research focuses on the factors that contribute to employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment, the researchers used purposive sampling technique in choosing the respondents. Purposive sampling technique requires a particular characteristic of the respondents who know the study. In this research, it is used because the study requires people who have experienced in a corporate setting. Thus, with this technique the researchers can obtain data that is needed in the study. Since the study is about employee retention, the researchers choose the employees and employers in the Business Process Outsourcing (BPO) industry as the respondents for data gathering purposes. As previously stated, the BPO industry as a contributor of 11% GDP in the Philippines with 1.2 million people involved in 700 outsourcing companies, is an industry to rely on, in terms of staff management specifically, employee retention. According to Asia Premier One Source (2019) and Hired Philippines (2020), a BPO company is a service provider that serves as an extension of a client’s company. One of its functions is contracting the entire business industry such as customer experience, IT and Programming, Accounting and Finance, Human Resources, Engineering, etc. This only means that creating and adopting different strategies in staff management from broad fields of expertise is one of the concerns of this industry. Also, according to Daly, A. (2016), high levels of responsibility are given to young adults in the BPO industry that makes them engaged in leadership and most especially, workforce management. Moreover, KPSG OFFICIAL (2019) states that temporary occupation in the industry is abundant and some companies do not intend to hire professional applicants. Time limitation as a problem can also result in rushing in to find a person suitable for the vacant position. With this kind of situation, continuous attrition and turnover of employees is a major problem of a BPO company. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 31 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management The respondents of the survey questionnaires are employees that are currently working in a BPO company around Bonifacio Global City and Mckinley Hill namely: Ingram Micro Philippines, and Sutherland Global Services Philippines Inc. These employees should have at least 4.6 years of service in a particular company since it is the average length of time in a job for wage and salary workers according to Doyle, A. (2019). Also while on the process of conducting the survey, the researcher randomly picks 6 employees which will take part on the interview. For the interview, 3 people with the position of team leader, supervisor, and human resource officers with at least 2 years of service from the two companies listed above since it is the average typical tenure for a team leader in a BPO company according to Indeed (2020). Research Instrument The research instrument that is used in the data gathering process is a survey questionnaire and a guide questionnaire for interviewers containing questions regarding the opinions of employees and superiors on employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment. The instrument can help to determine the different factors that contribute to employee retention. The survey questionnaire consists of 4 questions on the first part, which has subquestions that further provide data needed by the researcher. Also, 6 questions are given for the demographics. The 10 questions are all related and relevant to the study. Data was gathered using survey questionnaires (checklist type) to evaluate the respondent’s knowledge and opinion on the topic. It was decided upon because of the following: The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 32 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management • All of the items in the questionnaires were closed-ended, which made it easier to compare the responses to each item. • There was less opportunity for bias as they were presented consistently. • They ensured a high response rate as the questionnaires were distributed to respondents to complete and were collected personally by the researcher. • They required less time and energy to administer. • They offered the possibility of anonymity because subjects’ names were not required on the completed questionnaires. A close-ended survey questionnaire was selected as the data collection instrument because it is used for a clear distinction of qualities, experiences, abilities, opinions, and knowledge of a particular individual. Close-ended questions were used because it is easier to be administered and analyzed. It is also more efficient in a way that respondents can complete close-ended questions for it is more convenient than open-ended ones. This was chosen to fulfill the objectives of the study to determine the factor that greatly contributes to employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment. The respondents were given the assurance that answers would not be linked to them when the researchers analyze the data. The questions for the interview are separated into two sets of respondents. The first set of questions for an interview is for the employees regarding the factors that contribute to their retention and it consists of 11 items. The second set of questions is for the superiors regarding their management among employees that which contributes to promoting a healthy working environment. Data Gathering Procedure The researchers utilized various materials and references for the collection of the data. Published books, web sources, and other forms of written sources were consulted The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 33 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management with the purpose of finding out points regarding BPO, healthy working environment and employee retention. The data gathering process was conducted in 2 BPO companies around Bonifacio Global City and McKinley Hill: Ingram Micro Philippines and Sutherland Global Services Philippines Inc. Contributing a total of 11% in the country’s GDP, The BPO industry is composed of 1.2 million people, 700 of which are involved with outsourcing companies, making them an appropriate variable for the study. After the consent was granted by the PCS SHS principal and by the chosen companies, the survey questionnaires were immediately distributed and the interview was conducted by the researchers when the respondents were available. The researchers used In-depth Discussion for the interview with the respondents based on the data need from the interview questionnaire where the researchers interact with the respondents on an individual level, one participant at a time to understand individual decision processes. It gives a chance to explore detailed perceptions, opinions, and beliefs. Data Analysis The researcher’s raw data undergoes statistical treatment once the questionnaires for the survey have been completely gathered. Deductive Approach will be used. After the interview, recorded voice data will be transcribed into textual data for qualitative data analysis. In interpreting the data, the researchers made a list of answers then tally it. The researchers will apply the following statistical treatment using the percentage. After the list was made, it has been converted and presented into a table with the percentage based on the total of answers on each number. Each item has a textual explanation through a The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 34 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management paragraph after the presentation of data for the researcher to fully analyze and interpret the data gathered in each question since the ranking of answers will also be considered. Descriptive statistics were used to analyze the data which was gathered from the survey questionnaires conducted by the researchers since it is not a time-consuming method. However, confidentiality and lack of truthfulness of the respondents is the main disadvantage of descriptive analysis. Still, the researchers use descriptive analysis because it fits the quantitative research that the researchers doing. In qualitative research the researchers used the interview method, after that all the data that are already transcribed into textual data will be concluded and would be presented using paragraph format. CHAPTER 4 - PRESENTATION, ANALYSIS, AND INTERPRETATION OF DATA This chapter presents the data gathered, the results of the statistical analysis done, and the interpretation of findings. These were presented in Figures following the The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 35 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management sequence of the figures of the data regarding employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment. Demographics Figure 4.1 Age Age 4,44% 3,33% 18-20 years old 7,78% 21-23 years old 12,22% 24-26 years old 22,22% 12,22% 27-29 years old 30-32 years old 33-35 years old Above 36 years old 37,78% Figure 4.1 shows the age of the research’s respondents. 24-26 years old has 37.78%, 21-23 years old has 22.22%, 27-29 years old has 12.22%, 30-32 years old has 12.22% 18-20 years old has 7.78%, 33-35 years old has 4.44% and Above 36 years old has 3.33%. Figure 4.2 Gender The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 36 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Gender Male Female 36% 64% Figure 4.2 shows the gender of the research’s respondents. Female has 64%. And Male has 36% Figure 4.3 Monthly Salary Range 1,11% 1,11% Monthly Salary Range 2,22% 0% ₱20,000-₱30,000 7,78% ₱30,001-₱40,000 ₱40,001-₱50,000 ₱50,001-₱60,000 28,89% 58,89% ₱60,001-₱70,000 ₱70,001-₱80,000 More than ₱80,000 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 37 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.3 shows the monthly salary range of the research’s repondents.20,000-30,000 pesos has 58.89%, 30,001-40,000 pesos has 28.89%, 40,001-50,000 pesos has 7.78%, more than 80,000 pesos has 2.22%, 60,001-70,000 pesos has 1.11%, 70,001-80,000 pesos has 1.11% and 50,001-60,000 pesos has 0%. Figure 4.4 Nationality Nationality Filipino 100% Figure 4.4 shows the Nationality of the research’s respondents. Filipino has 100% The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 38 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.5 City Address 1,11% 2,22% 1,11% 1,11% City Address 1,11% 2,22% 2,22% 2,22% 22,22% 7,78% 11,11% 33,33% 12,22% Makati Pasig Pateros Taguig Mandaluyong Rizal Cavite Pasay Antipolo Paranaque San Juan Quezon City Manila Figure 4.5 shows the City Address of the research’s respondents. Taguig has 33.33%, Makati 22.22%, Pateros has 12.22%, Pasig has 11.11%, Mandaluyong has 7.78%, Rizal has 2.22%, Cavite has 2.22%, Pasay has 2.22%, Paranaque has 2.22%, Antipolo has 1.11%, San Juan has 1.11%, Quezon city has 1.11% and Manila has 1.11%. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 39 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.6 Department 1,11% 6,67% Department 8,89% 5,56% 5,56% Information Technology Department Quality Assurance Department Operations Department Marketing Department 28,89% Finance Department 43,33% Customer Support Technical Support Figure 4.6 shows the department of the research’s respondents. The marketing department has 43.33%, Finance department has 28.89%, Information technology department has 8.89%, Customer support has 6.67%, Quality assurance department has 5.56%, Operation Department has 5.56% and Technical support has 1.11%. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 40 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Presentation/ Discussion Figure 4.7 Years in Service 4,44% Years in Service 7,78% 3-4 years 5-6 years 26,67% 55% 7-8 years 9-10 years Figure 4.7 shows the number of years that the employees have worked for the company they are in. 55% of the respondents are currently working in the company for three (3) to four (4) years. 26.67% are working for five (5) to six (6) years. 7.78% have been working for seven (7) to eight (8) years and 4.44% are working for nine (9) to ten (10) years in their respective company. Among the ninety (90) respondents’ answers, 55% of them are currently working for three (3) to four (4) years in their company. According to the site called currandaly.com, in an article entitled “Employee Retention Strategies in the BPO Industry”, it states that environment plays an important factor in increasing employee retention in BPO that is why an employer must “create a flexible working environment”. Being an employee with a flexible and convenient working environment helps them to be more engaged in working and to be more productive and efficient at work. These kinds of The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 41 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management benefits offered by a company give the employees to build trust, loyalty, and to stay for a long time in the company. Also, companies that provide opportunities for their employees’ career growth leads to the employees to stay. By providing training and development for the employees helps them to have a higher retention rate for the company. Figure 4.8 Is this your first time working in a BPO company? Is this your first time working in a BPO company? 32,22% Yes No 67,78% Figure 4.8 shows how many times the respondents work in a BPO company. 67.78% of respondents answer they are working for the first time in a BPO company while, 32.22% answers no. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 42 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.9 Number of Companies Worked for Number of Companies Worked for 17,24% 13,79% 1 company 2 companies 3 companies 68,97% Figure 4.9 shows the number of companies that the respondents have worked for. 68% have worked for only one (1) BPO company and 32% of them said no. For the respondents who answered no, 68% of them have worked for two (2) BPO companies followed by 17% that has been in three (3) BPO companies and 14% have been to one (1) BPO company before. Most of the respondents answered “Yes” that it is their first time working in a BPO company while others had been on other BPO companies. Having a healthy working environment, employees are happier and it reflects in their work. According to an article entitled, “10 Reasons Why it is Important to Create a Happy Workplace”, employees’ happiness has different effects in a company. When employees are encouraged and motivated in their work it affects and spreads throughout the company. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 43 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Employees that are happy in their work can produce role models for others and produce more efficient and quality work for their company. Figure 4.10 Factors in Healthy Working Environment? Factors Affecting Healthy Working Environment Rewards & Benefits 25,93% Facility 21,85% Co-workers 21,48% Employers 18,52% Organizational Culture Is not enough for me as an employee 11,85% 1,23% Figure 4.10 shows the factors that the BPO (Business Processing Outsourcing) employees consider for a healthy working environment. 25.93% say they consider rewards and benefits. 21.85% are considering the facility. 21.48% are considering coworkers. 18.51% are considering employers. 11.85% are considering organizational cultural, and less than 1% are considering the management. The factor that the BPO employees mostly consider when it comes to a healthy working environment is the rewards and benefits which have a total of 25.93%. This proves how the rewards and benefits an employee gets in a company encourage them to stay longer in their company. This conclusion is supported by Hauser & Baggett (2002) in which they emphasized that the rewards and benefits play a significant role in attracting and retaining employees. This also shows that employees working in a BPO The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 44 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management industry are motivated to work more because they know that their work is properly compensated and being valued by their employers Figure 4.11 Reasons for Choosing Facility Facility Is easily accessible for me 31,97% Makes me comfortable enough to work properly Has a beautiful working ambiance Provides the amenities that satisfies me as an employee Has places where I can have a break peacefully 22,95% 17,21% 14,75% 13,11% Figure 4.11 shows the facility category, Out of 122 respondents, 39 of them answered "It's easily accessible for me" which got the highest percentage of 31.97%. Next is "Makes me comfortable enough to work properly" which is the second with 22.95%, then 3rd with an answer of "Has a beautiful work ambiance" which has the percentage of 17.21%, next is the "Provides the amenities that satisfy me as an employee" which have the percentage of 14.75 % and the lowest in the "Have places where I can have a break peacefully" that has a percentage of 13.11%. According to Clean India Journal (2012), the arrangement, workspace, quality of equipment, and even the aesthetic designs in an occupational setting determines the mood of an employee and their whole performance. This figure proves that most of the employees stay in their work since their workplace is easily accessible and makes them The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 45 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management comfortable to work. With these, a good and comfortable ambiance of workspace is one of the factors that employees considered. Figure 4.12 Reasons for Choosing Employers Employers Values me as an employee 32,38% Is able to communicate and effectively give the task needed 20,00% Be a role model for me to follow 20,00% Motivate me to work harder for the company 19,05% Knows when and where to have fun leaves no one behind 17,14% 0,95% Based on the graph shown above, Employers who value an employee gathered the highest percentage of 29.57%, employers being a role model for them to follow and employers who communicate and effectively give a task needed both garnered 18.26% and employers who motivate an employee to work harder for a company got 17.39% lastly, for employers who know when and where to have fun got the lowest percentage which is 15.65%. On the other hand, one of the respondents answered others and stated employers who look not only for themselves but their team as well gathered 0.87%. This shows that employers who value an employee can be a huge factor that greatly contributes to a healthy working environment. As support, (Moses B. 2000) states that “Managers and supervisors take on a new role when an organization gets into the The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 46 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management business of employee development. Mentoring employees can encourage them to pursue their career and appreciate development efforts.” Thus, the role of managers is important but more than that, empathy toward their subordinates completes the whole support system. This would mean that when an employee feels that he/she is valued and respected it becomes an encouragement for them to do their best and also makes them satisfied with the company they are working for. Figure 4.13 Reasons for Choosing Co-workers Co-workers Inspire me to do my work 29,03% Values me as a co-worker 27,42% Know when and where to have fun 18,55% Are people who are competent 13,71% Should be able to relate to me 8,87% Knows how to respect co-workers 0,81% Have strong values 0,81% Open for teamwork 0,81% Figure 4.13 shows the co-workers as one of the factors considered for a healthy working environment and its reasons. 29.03% the people they work with inspire them to do their work, 27.42% values them as a co-worker, 18.55% know when and where to have fun, 13.71% are competent people, 8.87% should be able to relate to them and other reasons such as “open for teamwork”, “have strong values” and “knows how to respect co-workers” gathered the same 0.81% for each. This shows that the most reason that the BPO employees considered “co-workers” as one of the factors for a healthy working environment is that the people they work with The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 47 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management inspire them to do their work which has a total of 29.03% which supports Scarnati’s (2011) idea that employees with great relationship tend to work as a group which develops individual’s knowledge and skills for their duty while being dedicated to the task and to the organization which results in achieving extraordinary results. Thus, in research by Clark (2001) “personnel tend to remain in the organization because of the relationship established between and among members of the team” (Chew, 2004) which proves that co-workers serve as a factor for employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment because employees build relationship with each other that leads to inspiring everyone to be dedicated to their work which also results in productivity and a healthy working environment. Figure 4.14 Reasons for Choosing Rewards and Benefits Rewards and Benefits Is very beneficial for me as an employee 30,06% Provides motivation for me to work harder 25,77% Properly compensates the work that I give to the company 20,25% Shows that my work is valued by my superiors 15,34% Are enough for me as an employee Is not enough for me as an employee 7,36% 1,23% The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 48 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.14 shows specific attributes for rewards and benefits which is considered as the most pervasive factor for BPO employees. 30% of the respondents find rewards and benefits as a very beneficial part of employee retention. 26% are motivated in doing their job well because of this factor. 20% believe that they are properly compensated with the work that they give to the company. 15% agree that their work is valued by their superiors. 8% say that they are satisfied with the rewards and benefits of the company they work for. Finally, 1% is not satisfied with the rewards and benefits offered by their company. Most of the respondent favors rewards and benefits as a very beneficial factor having a total of 30%. This proves the fact that this factor helps meet an employee’s needs. It supports the argument stated in the Review of Related Literature: Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs also connects to how an employer addresses the needs that will vary at each level. This means that it encompasses the holistic growth of employees, not just the physiological needs and safety needs. As stated in the factors affecting employee retention, Intangible rewards include training opportunities and career development where employees interact with their employers that can help them attain love and belongingness, esteem needs, and self-actualization. This data also proves that management has a good policy in terms of rewards and benefits. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 49 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.15 Reasons for Choosing Company Culture Company Culture Enhances my mental well-being as a… 24,24% Improves my performance as an… 22,73% Serves as an opportunity to boost my… 18,18% Bring joy to me as an employee 18,18% Provides rest for me after the work… 12,12% Have a work-life balance 1,52% Promote positive culture 1,52% Incorporate work etiquette 1,52% This shows that the company culture for employees enhances their mental being as a person which would mean that it is essential for the overall employee well-being. Complementary to Engle’s (2017), states that “The culture of an organization is a reflection on the mental state of its employees”. The two ideas support each other in a way that the company culture is what the company does on a daily or even occasional basis which can affect an employee’s way of doing things because he/she is influenced by the environment he/she moves in, also affecting his/her mental health because of what the employee encounters in their day-to-day interaction with the company. In the same way, their mental health reflects on the company’s culture because the actions of the employees will depend on their mental health and their actions are what dictates the culture that the company will show among its employees. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 50 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.16 Do you see yourself staying longer in the company you’re working for? Do you see yourself staying longer in the company you’re working for? 17% Yes No 83% This shows whether the BPO employees see themselves staying longer in the company they are working for. Those who answered yes gathered a total of 83.33% and 16.67% answered no. This implies that the BPO Companies have a great working environment that contributes to employee retention as the results show that the employees more likely see themselves working in the company they are working for. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 51 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.17.1 Yes, I see myself staying longer for... Yes, I see myself staying longer for... 5,33% 9,33% 1 year 4 years 13,33% 36.67 % More than 5 years 18,67% 2 years Until retirement 28% 5 years 18,67% 3 years This Figure shows how long do the employees see themselves staying in the company they are working for. 5 years gathered the highest percentage which is a total of 28%, 2 years and until retirement both has a total of 18.67%, 13.33% answered more than 5 years, 9.33% answered 4 years, 6.67% answered 3 years. Lastly, 5.33% answered they see themselves staying longer for 1 year The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 52 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.17.2 Yes, I see myself staying longer because... Yes, I see myself staying longer because… Rewards and Benefits 30,67% Comfort 30,67% Personal & Career Growth 12% Compensation 10,67% Company Culture and Practices Experience Work-Life Balance 6,67% 5,33% 4% This shows the reasons for the employee staying longer in the company they are working for. 30.67% of the respondents answered comfort and rewards and benefits, personal & career growth gathered a total of 12%, followed by compensation which has a total of 10.67%, 6.67% answered company culture and practices, 5.33% answered experience. Lastly, 4% of the respondents answered a work-life balance. Based on the results, comfort and rewards and benefits are the main reason for the employees for staying longer in the company they are working for. This supports Hauser & Baggett (2002) idea that compensations and benefits plays an important role in attracting and retaining employees. Benefits and rewards such as pension, life and health insurance, retirement plans, meals, staff discounts, and allowances satisfy employees to make the employees committed to the organization. Having a comfortable working environment greatly contributes to employee retention. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 53 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Figure 4.17.3 No, I do not see myself staying longer because... No, I do not see myself staying longer because… Toxic Environment Little Opportunities 53,33% 20% Not Enough Salary 13,33% Different Career Path 13,33% This shows the reasons why they do not see themselves stay longer in the company they are working for. To have a different path gathered the highest percentage which is a total of 47% followed by 20% due to a toxic environment, 13% for a not competitive salary, and the growth in the company is slow. Lastly, 7% has another plan or work. This shows that the most common reason regarding employee attrition is the voluntary reason which is to have a different career path which has 47%. This shows that unavoidable reasons highly contribute to the employee attrition rate. The article “BPO employee retention” further explains that an organization should hire the right people from the start as one of the strategies for employee retention. This supports why the employer must identify the requirement they need including programs that enable an employee to have a new learning from other fields. This shows that unavoidable reasons highly contribute to the employee attrition rate. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 54 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interpretation of Interview of BPO employees and Human Resources, Team Leader, and Supervisor Definition of a healthy working environment Joan Apring, a senior associate in Ingram Micro defines a healthy working environment as having a good ambiance while working, provides good benefits, and give learning. As stated by Clean India Journal (2012) having a good quality facility determines the mood of an employee and their whole performance thus, it is considered as a factor in a work setting. For the benefits it also allows the employees to remain committed to the organization as they are satisfied with what they have received may it be in a non-cash benefit like life and health insurance which can also help the employees dependent. Moreover, an employee's definition of a healthy working environment plays an important role in their well-being as it gives them productivity and be able to function well. On the other hand, Mr. Martin Guerrero, a Human Resource Officer in Sutherland implies that a healthy working environment is enforced by leaders who have a positive attitude towards their employees. As Hummayon & Muhammad have stated, that empowering the employees create a sense of belongingness in which that empowerment comes from the superiors of the organization. They are the ones who have the power to enforce what kind of environment will be present in their workplace. In the case of Mr. Guerrero of Sutherland, what their executives do to provide a healthy workplace is make their employees feel welcome, especially those who are newly-hired by their method called “town-hall” – quarterly talk with their employees for them to assess their needs or their troubles with regards to their work life. With this, they are able to make their employees feel comfortable because they show their care for them by entertaining and listening to their needs. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 55 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Factors that BPO employees deem relevant to a healthy working environment Based on the interview conducted by the researchers, these are the prominent factors in having a healthy working environment: rewards and benefits, and co-workers. Nurailam Capioso, a supervisor, describes Ingram Micro, particularly its healthy working environment as her home because her co-workers appreciate her efforts and value her well-being. As supported by Mcfarlin, K. (2019) good relationship promotes positivity and employee morale. This factor helps them to develop a healthy relationship with their co-workers and will greatly help them to be more positive and motivated to work consistently in a workplace setting. Furthermore, Heryati (2019) states: “A healthy workplace environment is ideal when it comes to maintaining a positive outcome in a stressful atmosphere.” When employees are burnout because of overwork, it would help eliminate stress if an employee has a supportive team which also affects their productivity. This proves that having an interpersonal relationship with others is first in fulfilling the social needs of a person. Building friendship, trust, giving affection, and love for his co-workers and can greatly help the company’s growth for it makes the employees be more positive and efficient in doing their job because of their co-workers. Thus, co-workers also serve as a factor affecting the employee retention of a company. Elliot Castillo, a Sales representative also points out that rewards and benefits of the company are other factors that must be considered for a healthy working environment. According to Thomson (2013), a well-rewarded employee feels that he/she is being valued. The satisfaction of the employees is one of the main objectives of the company because it is one of the first presented things in a work setting. It also reflects the company’s policy-making body. To correspond to the needs of employees, creating sufficient rewards and benefits fulfill the physiological and safety needs in Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs. Therefore, rewards and benefits play a vital role in attaining employee retention and it helps the employees to gain motivation and boost work productivity. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 56 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Meanwhile, when asked about the perception of employees, particularly those who hold middle-level job positions about the factor that they think is the most important, it showed that what the employees said falls under company culture. Mr. Fernando Turingan from Ingram stated that what he does as a Team Leader is that he provides fun activities for his subordinates. Every week, he and his team have a game night held during Friday nights after a long and stressful week for them to bond, have fun together, and relax. For Ms. Nurailam Capioso, a supervisor in Ingram, what she considers for a healthy working environment is the presence of support within the organization. She believes that as long as they, as supervisors, must listen to the needs of their employees, realize the impact that they bring to the company because they are the ones who comprise most of the organization so they are important and an asset to the company and its growth. Both of the answers fall under the company’s culture. Reasons for an Employee to Stay for the Company Based on the interview with Elliot Castillo a sales representative, and has been an employee for almost 5 years in Ingram, He said that he stays in the company to gain experience, use it as a stepping stone to be in a big company and also because of the management that provides good benefits that are good for employees. This can be explained by the Maslow Hierarchy of Needs which according to Rouse, M. (2018), connects to how an employer addresses the needs that contribute to the satisfaction of employees. It also states that an employee needs to pass the different level stage of Maslow's Hierarchy of Needs to be able to reach the self-actualization that includes the personal growth of an individual seeking fulfillment in their job. As such Mr. Elliot Castillo, the reason for staying in the company is leaning towards the self-actualization stage whereas He wants to achieve full growth by staying longer in the company to develop his knowledge and skills. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 57 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management In the same way, based on the interview conducted on Sutherland, Mr. Martin Guerrero. said, “most of the employees kasi dito uh... nagre-retain uh... nag-stay sila because of the healthy culture of the company” This serves as a support for the statement of Sylesh & Viswambharan “The entire working environment serves as a factor to boost the interest levels of an employee encouraging them to have a consistent productivity and organizational commitment” implying that a workplace environment contributes to an employee’s decision to stay in a company thus affecting employee retention. Factors that Contribute to Employee Retention Based on the interview conducted with Elliot Natividad and Nurailam Capioso another factor that contributes to employee retention is the good relationship between an employee and employers they also said that having a good connection with their coworker motivate them to work well. Having communication with no barrier but with respect can lead to a healthy working environment. As stated in the work of Zenger, J.; Ulrich, D. & Smallwood, N. (2000).”Any effective program must have strong support from people in senior management positions, and these people must also serve as positive role models to subordinates” Employers should keep in touch with their personal lives not only with their work performance so that a strong connection can be linked between the two entities aside from that it might help the employees to boost their confidence to perform their best. On the other hand, consultative communication also serves as a factor that contributes to employee retention. Addressing employee’s feedbacks and concerns regarding their work greatly affect employees in a way that they will feel valued by the company they are working for when the company attends to their needs, not just by listening to it but also acting on it. According to Mr. Nurailam Capioso, a supervisor in Ingram Micro, making the employees feel that they are an important factor of the The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 58 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management company by listening to their feedbacks not just regarding with the organization but to their well-being helps in building trust, loyalty, and the overall relationship that coincides within the organization itself. Factors that Cause Employee Attrition Based on the interview conducted with Fernando Turingan he said that attrition is something that is inevitable and they can’t do about it aside from having a plan or existing system on how to cope up with that. As for Martin Guerrero, he said that “BPO hoppers” is one of the factors that cause employee attrition. BPO hoppers are the employees who tend to go to a certain BPO company and then work for 6 months and get their bonuses or benefits and then jump to another BPO company that is why the attrition rate for a BPO company is higher compared with other types of company. According to Ehrler, M. (2018). “Job embeddedness represents a broad set of influences on an employee’s decision to stay on the job. These influences include on the job factors, such as bonds with co-workers, the fit between one’s skills and the demands of the job, and organization-sponsored community service activities (e.g., the plant sponsors quarterly neighborhood clean-up days) meaning, benefits can greatly influence in terms of employee attrition that is why employee tend to transfer to a different company because they are trying to find which company offers more benefits or incentives that will probably help their financial needs. Ways to Promote and Create a Healthy Working Environment in their Workplace According to Fernando Turingan and Martin Guerrero, they focus on the employee's individual growth like the Individual Development Program (IDP) which is established for each associate's career growth and making the workplace employeeThe Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 59 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management friendly by making facilities like activity hubs for recreational activities like chess, billiards, and videoke rooms for the workers when they're not on duty and teambuilding to further strengthen the bonds of their colleagues. As stated to the work of Heryati (2019), "there are four aspects to look into in creating a healthy working environment: workplace culture, the physical environment and occupational health and safety, healthy and lifestyle practice and supportive workplace environment. In the first aspect, workplace culture, a company having a positive workplace culture that is being practiced by the employees as well as the superiors, tends to have better productivity and to be healthier as everyone is happy and contented." It means that people tend to spend one-third of their lives at work, a working environment can have a significant impact on employee’s health and well-being. Using the IDP Program and creativity hubs for recreational activities, employers tend to build a good relationship with their workmates and would lessen the misunderstandings between them. Having a good relationship with their workmates will help them to promote and create a healthy working environment. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 60 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHAPTER 5 - SUMMARY, CONCLUSIONS, AND RECOMMENDATIONS Summary of Findings This chapter presents the summary of findings, conclusions drawn from the findings, and the corresponding recommendation of the researchers. The findings of this study show are presented according to the sequence of identified problems: This shows the factors that greatly affect the company’s employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment. As stated in the work of Shakeel, N. (2015) employee retention involves making an action plan and policies that convince workers to stay in the company for the maximum period. Furthermore, in a site called sahealth.sa.gov.au, entitled “What is a healthy workplace,” World Health Organization (2009), states that a healthy workplace is where the management and employees co-act to continually improve health, safety, and welfare of all the workers in sustaining the productivity of the company. Thus, it greatly contributes to a factor in boosting employees’ interest levels that encourages them to have a consistent productivity and organizational commitment. The data gathered shows that rewards and benefits are the most prominent factors BPO employees mostly consider when it comes to a healthy working environment. This proves how rewards and benefits encourages employees to stay longer in their company which is supported by Hauser & Baggett (2002) that the rewards and benefits serves a significant role in retaining employees which also shows how properly compensating employees’ work and making them feel valued cultivates their motivation and dedication to their work and organization. It is followed by the facility as one of the prominent factors BPO employees deem relevant to a healthy working environment. The facility as one of the physical and visual factors serves as a basis of first impressions of an The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 61 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management employee to an organization (Clean India Journal, 2012). In addition, co-workers also serve as a factor affecting employee retention of a company. As supported by Mcfarlin, K. (2019) good relationship promotes positivity and employee morale which leads to a healthy working environment. Moreover, based on middle-level managers, the most important factor that they consider is company culture. According to them, fun activities for the relaxation of employees and supportive means within the organization have an impact in attaining company’s growth because employees are the most important resources that the company has. The data manifested that the primary reason for an employee to stay for the company are comfort and rewards & benefits. As stated by an article entitled “Employee Retention Strategies in the BPO Industry” benefits were listed among the most important reasons to stay. Thus, the provision of employee benefits helps the employees in increasing productivity, positive results, and better engagement resulting to employees being motivated with their work and in the long run, the of trust and loyalty to the organization. From the interview for managers, the other factors that were acquired are proximity and consultative communication. A BPO company having a large population of employees equates to diversity in the workplace leading to workers coming from multiple and different locations making it difficult for some to traverse from their homes to their workplace. For human resource officers and middle-level managers, their supportive style of addressing employee’s feedbacks and concerns regarding their work greatly affect employees in a way that they will feel valued by the company they are working for when the company attends to their needs. In terms of employee attrition, the data gathered shows that the most common reason for employees leaving the company is having different career growth which is The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 62 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management considered as an unavoidable circumstance that is sometimes caused by personal reasons. This result is supported by the Motivation-Hygiene Theory of Frederick Herzberg wherein 3 of the different combinations may exist namely: High hygiene and low motivation where employees have few complaints, but they are not much motivated, they see their work simply as a paycheck. Low hygiene and high motivation where employees are motivated, their job is challenging, but they have complaints about salary or work conditions. Lastly, low hygiene and low motivation which is the worst possible situation where employees are not motivated and have a lot of complaints. These are possible circumstances that exist in a work setting that affects the employee’s mindset and desire to leave the company. The employers and middle-level managers' way of promoting a healthy working environment is through empowering the employees create a sense of affiliation in which encouragement comes from the higher authorities of the company. Having a good relationship with their employees like making them feel welcome always and making use of town-hall which allow them to assess the employee’s needs and/or troubles with regards to their work-life makes them feel comfortable working and to stay more in the company by hearing out their concerns. Conclusion The researchers discovered the different factors that contribute to employee retention in relation to a healthy work environment. The research questions were answered through the use of surveys and interview which helped the researchers find the different reasons why the employee stays in their job. Based on the survey conducted, the most common factor that affects employee retention is Reward and Benefits which has a total of 26%. It supports the argument The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 63 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management stated in the Review Related Literature. Maslow’s Hierarchy of Needs, also connects how an employer addresses the needs that will vary each level. This means that it surrounds the holistic growth of an employee. The reward is also one of the factors why employees are staying in their job; it includes training opportunities and career development where employees interact with their employers. Based on the interview conducted with employers, the most common factor that affects their employee retention is organizational culture as a support to the statement of Sylesh & Viswambharan (2018), “the entire working environment serves as a factor to boost the interest levels of an employee encouraging them to have consistent productivity and organizational commitment” implying that a workplace environment contributes to an employee’s decision to stay in a company thus affecting employee retention. Considering the most influential and prominent factor affecting the healthy working environment of a BPO company, from different levels of the job description, the major difference is identified by the researchers: for middle-level managers, organizational culture greatly contributes in finding and creating ways of promoting a healthy working environment that supports employee morale and holistic growth of their subordinates. This implies that a team leader, as one of the middle-level managers is more concerned on the welfare of their employees because it can be inferred that they are already well-compensated and receive rewards and benefits that are useful in their everyday life because of their position inside the company. For employees, rewards and benefits are the factor one considers that is most beneficial affecting the company’s employee retention. This is an indication that rewards and benefits play a role in motivating employees to have a better and positive performance at work and their choice to stay at the company they are working for. Behind many factors affecting a healthy working environment, there will also be personal and confidential reasons as to why an employee decides to leave the company that cannot be controlled by the management. Lack of benefits offered and the right The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 64 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management compensation contributes to the desire and personal reasons of the employees to leave and choose to be on a different company and career path. Recommendations Based on the findings and conclusions presented in the study, recommendations are formed for the following: 1. Employers and Institutions The researchers recommend to the employers and institutions to have programs delegated to their employees which can give them good reasons to stay with the company. Employers and Institutions should establish a compelling rewards and benefits system that creates strong leverage among their employees such as giving incentives to employees who perform well on a particular period of time. Also, non-monetary rewards can be effective like mentoring activities that teach an employee on job-related skills and show how to enhance their interpersonal relationships. Lastly, the researchers recommend companies prioritize their own employees who have been with company for a long time, give them promotions if they are qualified for it and incentives such as retention bonuses instead of finding new employees. 2. Community and Economy For the community, the researchers recommend having patience and respect when dealing with employees of BPO companies. Lay their concerns and ask for assistance with courtesy because who they are asking to are people who require understanding and compassion as well. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 65 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 3. DOLE The researchers recommend to the Department of Labor and Employment to implement laws that would focus on the rewards and benefits received by the employees of BPO companies. Unlike the other factors, the rewards and benefits are the only areas where the department can lay their hands on, so the researchers suggest that they make more comprehensive laws about it. 4. Future Researchers For future researchers, it is recommended that they allot more time for the collection of data among BPO companies. Give an ample amount of time for the company to respond to the letter of request. Make sure to get the contact details of each company, leave the necessary contact information of the researchers to the company, and do not procrastinate. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al 66 PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management References Websites Bloomenthal, A. (2019). Business Outsourcing BPO. Retrieved from https://www.investopedia.com/terms/b/business-process-outsourcing.asp. Burton, J. (2010). WHO Healthy Workplace Framework and Model: Background and Supporting Literature and Practices. Retrieved from https://www.who.int /occupational health/healthy_workplace_framework.pdf. Call Center Survival Philippines (2011). TIPS ON – HOW NOT TO BE A CALL CENTER HOPPER. Retrieved from http://www.callcentersurvivalph.com/2011/06/tips-onhowtoavoidcallcenter.html?m=1&fbclid=IwAR0u_1ubGTnsRNg6z3quS5rt8hjgFw EX6krGx8ARTSVzO_dXw0brjIOozc Chappelow, J. (2019). Gross Domestic Product. Retrieved from https://www.investopedia. com/terms/g/gdp.asp. Clean India Journal (2012). Role of Facility Management in Employee Retention. Retrieved from https://www.cleanindiajournal.com/role_of_facility_management_in_employee_ret ention/?fbclid=IwAR1QUPSLGgnXJV9sJFepwC5YaJXHc3kcuXo2UtnJfBpkECA 6MQYgpio8rY4 Daly, C. (2019). “Employee Retention Strategies in the BPO Industry”. Retrieved fromhttps://currandaly.com/employee-retention-strategies-in-the-bpo-industry/. Day, D.V. (2000), Leadership development: A review in context, Leadership Quarterly, 581-613 De Ocampo, R. & Aguiling, H. (2018). Comparative Analysis On The Factors Affecting Employee Turnover Between Supervisors And Frontline Employees In The BPO Industry. Retrieved from http://www.ijarp.org/published-resea The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al vi PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 1 papers/july2018/Comparative-Analysis-On-The-Factors-Affecting-Employee-TurnoverBetween-Supervisors-And-Frontline-Employees-In-The-BpoIndustry.pdf?fbclid=IwAR3QJIr6vId62XlzWx-hPqaZDyMsB7HlM6QsPoayTyx1RpaIwW8kdEy2FM Doyle, A. (2019). How long Should an Employee Stay at a Job? Retrieved from https://www.thebalancecareers.com/how-long-should-an-employee-stay-at-a-job2059796. Ehrler, M. (2018, September 24). Using Job Embeddedness Theory to Improve Employee Turnover. Retrieved from https://www.tlnt.com/using-job- embeddedness-theory-to-improve-employee-turnover/ Engle, S. (2017). Does Your Company Culture Promote Employee Mental Health?. Retrieved from https://www.businessnewsdaily.com/10472-companyculture-promote-mental-health.html Halvorson, C. (2018). “7 Great Employee Retention Strategies”. Retrieved from https://wheni work. com/blog/7-great-employee-retention-strategies/ Hartzell, S. Herzberg's Two-Factor Theory: Hygiene Factors & Motivation. (n,d). Retrieved from https://study.com/academy/lesson/herzbergs-two-factor-theory- hygiene-fac tors-motivation.html. Heryati, R., (2019). Creating a Healthy Workplace Environment for Your Employees. Retrieved from https://inside.6q.io/creating-a-healthy-workplaceenvironment/. Juneja, P. (2018). Role of Motivation in Employee Retention. Retrieved from https://www.managementstudyguide.com/motivation-for-employee-retention.htm. Kuijk, A. (2018). Two Factor Theory by Frederick Herzberg. Retrieved from https://www.tools hero.com/psychology/two-factor-theory-herzberg/. Mccarthy, A. & Darcy, C. (2010). Work-Life Balance Policy and Practice: Understanding Line Manager Attitudes and Behaviors. Retrieved from The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management https://www.researchgate.net/publication/236272765_Work-Life_Balance_ Policy _and_Practice _ Understanding_Line_Manager_Attitudes_and_Behaviors. Mulder, P. (2018). Adams Equity Theory. Retrieved from https://www.toolshero.com/psychology /adams-equity-theory/. Moses, B. (2000). Give people belief in the future: In these cynical times, HR must assure employees that faith and work can coexist. Workforce, 79 (6), 134139. Nyanjom, C. R. (2013). Factors Influencing Employee Retention In The State Corporations in Kenya. Nairobi, Kenya: University of Nairobi. Power, R., (2016). 10 Reasons Why It Is Important Create a Happy Workplace. Retrieved from https://www.inc.com/rhett-power/10-reasons-why-it-is-importantcreate-a-happy-workplace.html Macmillan Dictionary (n.d.). Definitions and Synonyms. Retrieved from https://www.macmillandictionary.com/us/dictionary/american/proximity Reville, R. T., Boden, L. & Biddle, J. (2003). Comparing Compensation Adequacy: Workers' Compensation Permanent Disability Benefits in Five States. Santa Monica, Calif.: Rand. Rono, E. & Kiptum, G. (2017). Factors Affecting Employee Retention At The University Of Eldoret, Kenya. Eldoret, Kenya: Jomo Kenyatta University Of Science And Technology. Rouse, M. (2018). What is Maslow's hierarchy of needs? - Definition from WhatIs.com. Retrieved from https://whatis.techtarget.com/definition/Maslows- hierarchy-of-needs. Shakeel, N. (2015). Factors Influencing Employee Retention: An Integrated Perspective.Retrieved from https://pdfs.semanticscholar.org/834 5/26aea7538d 6a77da4bbcf9d0268870b76ba9.pdf?fbclid=IwAR0ZbXGYxYR7sDNUZbYUe kSmPnYrWdDt_rB0cp6Jws-dtUIh4zUtseW5BM The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Sylesh, S. & Viswambharan, A. (2018). The Impact of Human Resource Management Practices on Organizational Performance with Special Reference to BPO Industry in Kerala. Kerala, India: International Journal of Management Studies. Theiroff, S., (2016). Benefits of a Healthy Work Environment. Retrieved from https://www. healthyworksofpa.com/benefits-of-a-healthy-work-environment/. Torrington, D., Hall, L. and Taylor, S. (2007) Human resource management [online]. 7th ed. Harlow: Pearson Education. Available at: www.dawsonera.com [Accessed 28 September 2013]. Outsource Accelerator (2019). Top 40 BPO companies in the Philippines. Retrieved from https://www.outsourceaccelerator.com/guide/top-40-bpo-companies-in-the- philippines/. World Health Organization (WHO) Law and Legal Definition. (n,d.). Retrieved from https://definitions.uslegal.com/w/world-health-organization-who/. WHO. (2010). What is a healthy workplace? Retrieved from https://www.sahealth.sa.gov.au/ wps/wcm/connect/public+content/sa+health+internet/healthy+living/healthy+com munities/workplaces/for+business (2010). “Effective Staff Management is the Backbone of Your Business”. Retrieved from https://www.humanity.com/blog/effective-labor-management-isthe-backbone-of-your-business .html “BPO Employee Retention”. Retrieved from http://www.naukrihub.com/retention/bpo-employee-retention.html Books Hauser, A.H. & Baggett, M. S. (2002). Workers' Compensation: The Statutory Framework for Defending a Claim. Trial Advocate Quarterly 21 (fall). The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Villegas, B. and Lorenzo, P. (1982). Productivity, Path to Philippines Progress. Rizal, Philippines: SINAG-TALA PUBLISHERS, INC. Zenger, J., Ulrich, D., & Smallwood, N. (2000, March). The new leadership development: It’s about results for your company. Training & Development, 54 (3), 22-27 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management APPENDICES Appendix A LETTERS AND CORRESPONDENCE PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Appendix B INSTRUMENTS Good day, we are students from Pateros Catholic School Senior High School and we are conducting a study entitled “The Steering Wheel and Clutch of Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment”. Please do take time to answer this survey questionnaire for it will be collected as data and is going to be beneficial for our study. Instruction: Please check the box that corresponds to your answer. 1. How long have you been working for your company? Less than a year 1-2 year/s 3-4 years 5-6 years 7-8 years 9-10 years More than 10 years 2. Is this your first time working in a BPO company? Yes If not, how many BPO companies have you worked for? _______________ No 3. What are the factors that you consider for a healthy working environment? Please choose your top 3 factors. Facility Employers Co-workers Rewards & Benefits Organizational Culture Others:_____________________ Please state the reason why ______________________________________________________ ______________________________________________________ ____________ 3.1 For this item, please only answer the portion of the factor that you have checked in item no. 3 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Please tick the box of the reason of your chosen factor. You may choose more than one answer Facility – “The place that I go to for work...” Is easily accessible for me Has a beautiful working ambiance Has places where I can have a break peacefully Makes me comfortable to enough to work properly Provides the amenities that satisfies me as an employee Others:___________________________________ Employers – “The employers who handle me...” Values me as an employee Be a role model for me to follow Knows when and where to have fun Motivate me to work harder for our company Is able to communicate and effectively give the task needed Others:___________________________________ Co-workers – “The people who I work with...” Inspire me to do my work Values me as a co-worker Should be able to relate to me Are people who are competent Knows when and where to have fun Others:___________________________________ Rewards & Benefits – “The rewards and benefits that the company provides...” Are enough for me as an employee Is very beneficial for me as an employee Provides motivation for me to work harder Shows that my work is valued by my superiors Properly compensates the work that I give to the company Others:___________________________________ Company Culture – “The things that the company usually does (i.e. celebrations) ...” Bring joy to me as an employee Improves my performance as an employee Enhances my mental well-being as a person The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Serves as an opportunity to boost my morale Provides rest for me after the work that I endured Others:___________________________________ 4. Do you see yourself staying longer in the company you’re working for? Yes How long do you think would you work for the company and why? ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ ____________________________________________________________ _______________ No What are the reasons for you to not stay any longer? ___________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________ ___________________________________________________ _______________ Demographics: 1. How old are you? 18-20yrs old 21-23yrs old 24-26yrs old 27-29yrs old 30-32yrs old 33-35yrs old Above 36 years old 2. Gender: Male Female 3. Monthly Salary Range: ₱20,000-₱30,000 ₱30,001-₱40,000 ₱40,001-₱50,000 ₱50,001-₱60,000 ₱60,001-₱70,000 ₱70,001-₱80,000 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 4. 5. 6. More than ₱80,000 What is your nationality? ______________________________ What is your city address? Makati Pasig Pateros Taguig Mandaluyong Others: ______________ What is your position in your company? Team Manager Operations Manager Chat Support Quality Assurance Sales Representative Customer Sales Representative Others:_____________ The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Research Questions: Interview for Employees 1. How long have you been working in the company? 2. How many companies, particularly BPO, have you previously worked for? a. How long did you stay? b. What made you stay for that particular period of time? 3. Do you consider this workplace environment that you are currently in, a healthy one? Why or why not? 4. Facility. What company facility do you like the most? What other facility do you think could be added to further improve the company? 5. Management. How would you describe your relationship with your superiors? What can you say are his/her strengths? Weaknesses as superiors? 6. Co-workers. How would you generally describe your relationship with your co-workers? Strengths? Weaknesses? 7. Rewards & Benefits. Are these benefits sufficient? And do they somehow motivate you to work harder for the company? 8. Company Culture. Does your company have any traditions or practices that they observe during special days that you particularly like as an employee? If none, what practice, would you want to see your company celebrate? 9. *Is working in a BPO company any different compared to other types of company in terms of benefits, employers, and such? 10. *What can you say is the major difference between working with BPO companies from other companies? 11. Do you see yourself staying in this company for a long time? If so, what do you think is the reason why you consider such? The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interview for Employers: 1. What are the programs you implement for employee retention? 2. Among the implemented policies, what do you think greatly contributes to healthy working environment? 3. How do you promote positive work environment? 4. Does your organization engage in conference practices to hear the feedbacks of your employees regarding with their workplace? 5. What do you do about the feedbacks given by your employees in their workplace? 6. How do you support and motivate your employees to work? 7. How do you respond to the employees leaving the company? 8. Do you have any possible suggestions for a positive work environment? The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management TRANSCRIPT Transcript Interview for Employees Interview #1 Elliot Castillo, Sales Representative, 30 yrs. old Kered: How long have you been working in the company Elliot: I’ve.. I’ve been working in Ingram for almost 5 years Kered: How many companies, particularly BPO, have you previously worked for? Elliot: None, it’s only Ingram Kered: Do you consider this workplace environment that you are currently in, a healthy one? Elliot: Yes ofcourse, Kered: Why? Elliot: Because of the good ambiance while you are working, good working stations and um.. Magandang upuan. Kered: Facility. What company facility do you like the most? Elliot: Sleeping quarters Kered: What other facility do you think could be added to further improve the company? Elliot:Ahh yung elevator cuz ang bagal niya, minsan umaabot ng 15 mins. Kered: In terms of management. How would you describe your relationship with your superiors? Elliot: With my superior, I’m… I’m in a good working relationship with my manager but with my team leader I guess there’s more to learn from it, ahhh… he needs to improve his attitude towards his associates, soooooo, working wouldn’t be a hindrance everyday. Kered:Co-workers. How would you generally describe your relationship with your coworkers? Elliot: Uhhh.. speaking of co-workers we are only two in the team so I guess there’s no problems with my co-worker uhh.. I mean my colleague. I’m always in good terms with The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management my colleague even if when we are-were four in the team I am with good relationship with my colleagues. Kered: Huhhh…Rewards and benefits. Ar… are the benefits in the company sufficient? Elliot: Yezsz, yung hmo napapakinabangan talaga yung hmo lalo na sa mom ko Kered: And do they somehow motivate you to work harder for the company? Elliot: Oo naman syempre, kasi ang gandang benepisyo nuneh. Kered: Company culture. Does your company has any tradition or pactices that they observe during special days that you particularly like as an employee? Elliot: Madami, madaming activities sa company namen, if New Year, Chinese NewYear, pag summer may pa summer sa mga employees pwedeng isama yung family and pag… pag Christmas ayun yung pinaka main nung Christmas party, yung year-end party na tinatawag. Kered: Have you work for ano, for another company? Elliot: Hindi pa, yung Ingram pa lang Kered: Kahit ano sa gin? TANGA nagtrabaho kana, diba sa ibang company BALIW TO! Diba nagtrabaho ka sa French Bakery tatlong araw okay lang yun tatanong ko nalang uli. Kered: Is working in a BPO company any different compared to other types of company in terms of benefits, employers, and such? Like co-workers Elliot: Malaki yung pinagkaiba kasi sa BPO kahit parang yung mga manager mo parang ka-level mo lang, kasiii… meron silang open door policy, pwede mo silang lapitan kung may problem ka, tsaka maganda yung benefits sa BPO unlike… sa ibang Filipino company may mga benefits din naman nag anon pero minsan kasi toxic pag Filipino company. Kered: Ahhh.. What can you say is the major difference between working with BPO companies from other companies? If so, what is the reason? Elliot: YESSS! Ahhh kasiii may pangarap akong maging operations managers, mga 10 years pa siguro. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interview #2 Nurailam Capioso, Supervisor Kered:How many companies, particularly BPO, have you previously worked for? Nurailam: This is my first. Kered: Do you consider this workplace environment that you are currently in, a healthy one? Nurailam: Yess! Kered: Ahhhmm. In terms of facility. What company facility do you like the most? Nurailam: Ahmmm… the clinic, theeeerreee are 24hour clinic support the doctors have uhmm in house nurse as well, in house doctors they are the one that we like. That is really important when we have emergency right, right away they have a clinic in house. Kered: Ummm… What other facilities po yung mai-susuggest niyo na to further improve the company? Nurailam: Probably fitness, I think that is more in demand now right? Gym? Fitness gym? Hahahaha. Kered: In terms of management, how would you describe your relationship with your superiors po? Nurailam: Ahhh…, I think it is an open book for us and free and comfortable to approach anytime and very comfortable to open up to share feedback to tal to them, there is no barriers huahuahua. Kered: In terms of co-workers po, how would you generally describe your relationship with your co-workers? Nurailam: I think when I see them they are happy people. Just one word, happy people. Kered: Ahhhh..,, sa rewards and benefits po, are the benefits in your company sufficient? Nurailam: Are they? What was the question? Kered: Are the benefits sufficient in your company is sufficient po? Nurailam:Sufficient? I think yes, although from time to time because of the changes in management, they keep on changing but I think ummm what we have now with the hr The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management are in terms of rewards and benefits is they are trying there best and they are coming up with new ideas and I think that’s good like umm, we have umm a quarterly star awards programs um and there is a year-end star awards program as well to you know umm to reward those associates performing really well. Kered: In terms of the organizational culture, does your company have any traditions or practices that they observe during special days that you particularly like as an employee? Nurailam: Yah so companies also observing that we have programs, we have actually a floor there were in, there are programs umm catered to the employees as well. There’s a lot of programs catered by the hr and the learning and development. Kered: Ahhh…, Aside for BPO company, uhhh is working in a BPO company any different compared to other types of company, in terms of benefits or employers and such? Nurailam:Yes Kered: What can you say is… what is the difference po? Nurailam: So working in a BPO your shift is right factors ummm, when you get to work at night you have to follow the shift when you get to work in the morning because your supporting usually you’re not supporting local like your supporting umm other countries you have to follow the..their..the time there, the timezone and then and ummm, and then another benefits that you get not exactly the same as you get when you are working for the locals and comparing to my previous company because I work abroad, and compared here I think there are more benefits here than working abroad because abroad you get only your salary, you have to pay for the rest you don’t get the-but the in terms of, so base of my experience in terms of the ummm benefits for medical and all this which is really good, because you don’t have to spend anything even for medicine but here you have to spend it for medicine, and then there is easy to get sick, you just tell them uhhhhhmhahaha, I’m on sick leave and then you just need to show the certificate its easy to get, just go to the clinic and they will provide you and they value really the health of the employees and once you get the med cert. they call it, they really won’t allow to go to work, but here it’s really different the work is in demand you have to be in the office as much as possible you have to take care of yourself which is, ofcourse is um the same thing but umm, the lifestyle here also is different right? Working in a BPO to lik.. its uhh fast pacing environment and then the umm but the growth and the growth is also fast The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management right? You can as young you can be as a manager as young as possible depends how talented you huahuahua. Yah yah yah. Kered: Last question po ahh, do you see yourself being in this company for a long time, so what do you think is the reason? Nurailam: Umm, I feel home and then ummm I continue to grow and they continue to, I feel that they continue to value me , to continue to see my-my-my effort, contribution, what I can contribute to the team ummm I feel valued. That’s the key Kered: thank you very much po! Nurailam: You’re welcome! Interview #3 John Michael San Jose, Sales Representative, 27 years old, Male 1. How long have you been working in the company? - 3 years and a half 2. How many companies, particularly BPO, have you previously worked for? - only 1 A. How long did you stay? - 3 year and a halg B. What made you stay for that particular period of time? - My colleagues who were fun to be with and to work with 3. Do you consider the workplace environment that you are currently in, a healthy one? Why or Why not? -Yes because I get to work from/at home. 4. Facility. What company facility do you like the most? What other facility do you think could be added to further improve the company? -Nap room. Adding a gym would be nice 5. Management. How would you describe your relationship with your superiors? What can you say his/her strengths? Weaknesses as superiors? -Good effective leadership and good decision making skills are some of their strengths. I guess their weakness is they are too kine hearted. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 6. Co-workers. How would you generally describe your relationship with your coworkers? Strengths? Weaknesses? - Good they are good team players. However they are not that good wth de-escalations. 7. Rewards & Benefits. Are these benefits sufficient? And do they somehow motivate you to work harder for the company? -Yes and Yes 8. Company Culture. - No. I would want to see the company celebrate Christmas 9. Is working in a BPO company any different comapared to other types of company terms of benefits, employers, and such? - No 10. What can you say in the major difference between working with BPO companies from other companies? - I cant tell because I havent been to a non BPO Company. 11. Do you see yourself staying in this company for a long time? If so, what do you think is the reason why you consider such? - Yes, because of the fact that I get to earn money while being at home. Interview #4 Yroll Mariano 1. How long have you been working in the company? - more tha 4 years 2. How many companies, particularly BPO, have you previously worked for? - only 1 Do you consider the workplace environment that you are currently in, a healthy one? Why or Why not? -Yes because the client we are working for provides good benefits. 3. Facility. What company facility do you like the most? What other facility do you think could be added to further improve the company? -Pantry The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management 4. Management. How would you describe your relationship with your superiors? What can you say his/her strengths? Weaknesses as superiors? -Its just a normal team member and team leader relationship. I don’t know their strengths weakness. 5. Co-workers. How would you generally describe your relationship with your coworkers? Strengths? Weaknesses? - Fun to be with. Competitive 6. Rewards & Benefits. Are these benefits sufficient? And do they somehow motivate you to work harder for the company? -Not very sufficient. It somewhat motivate me to work harder. 7. Company Culture. - Yes, typical Philippine traditions. 8. Is working in a BPO company any different compared to other types of company terms of benefits, employers, and such? - Yes. 9. What can you say in the major difference between working with BPO companies from other companies? - Salary and work schedule 10. Do you see yourself staying in this company for a long time? If so, what do you think is the reason why you consider such? - Yes, benefits. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interview #5 Fernando Turingan Interviewer: Question po ahhh, how many companies particularly BPO have you worked for po? TL: For the BPO type actually, this is my first Ingram ahhh micros company ahhh before joining Ingram Micro actually, I’ve been with at least 4 companies but these are normal or daily jobs Interviewer: Ahhhh, is working in a BPO company any different compared to other types of company? TL: Yah, definitely fo BPO, for a BPO setup, actually it’s more stressful in a sense that you are always given deadlines on, or quotas ahhhh we you you have you are actually given weekly SLA’s, monthly SLA’s or service level agreements and we are measured through scort cards on a monthly basis. Interviewer: Ahhh, in terms of benefits po, yung pagkakaiba po? Tsaka employers po? TL: AHhh, in terms of benefits ahhh, in terms of benefits, I would say based on my experience, the B BPO companies, give higher salaries compared to the normal daily ahhh, daily job, ahhhh day job rather. Interviewer: ahhhh, Do you consider this workplace environment that you are currently in, a healthy one? TL: Ahhhh, I would say so, ahhhhmm like I’ve said, ahmmm Ingram Micro, Ingram Micro is actually established a good system that is beneficial to the associates, they ahhh actually advocate of work and life balance and that’s what I like most working here at Ingram Micro. Interviewer: Ahhh, in terms of facility po, what facility do you like the most po? And What other facility do you think could be added po? TL: For now, what we enjoy with Ingram Micro is we, we do have pantries, and we do have sleeping quarters where we can take a nap whenever we feel dizzy or somehow, we need to energize and I think, also we have ahhhhmmm, hospital partner; my health where we could easily go to whenever we are feeling something over were sick. I think, ahmmmm I could not, I think waaaa one probably I could suggest is Ingram Micro for now, doesn’t have a sort of a gym The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management where where associates could relax by exercising ahhhh that’s ahhhh I’ve heard from other BPO companies that they do have this so called ahhh, ahhh little gym within the company that ahmmmm associated could exercise whenever they have freetime it’s ahh, it’s some this is one thing that we don’t have here at Ingram Micro. Interviewer: So in terms of management po, how would you describe your relationship with your superiors po? TL: Yahh, we we, ahhh we have a good ahhhh working relationship with our superiros and, and like what I’ve said a while ago, our management is an advocate of work and life balance and that that’s one thing that me personally like with Ingram Micro. Interviewer: Sa co-workers naman po, How would you generally describe your relationship with your co-workers po? TL: Well ahhhh, aside from Joan Apring probably, no, I’m just kidding ahmm yah ahmmm I would say, we have a very healthy and friendly work environment. Ahhh, not only with my ahhh with associates under me but I could see with other teams, it’s the same way, the the atmosphere here at Ingram Micro the working environment is very friendly Interviewer: Ahhh, in terms of rewards and benefits, are these benefits sufficient po? And do they somehow motivate you to work harder ? TL: Ahmmm, for me now we have for for for the finance group or… where we belong, we don’t have much bonuses or special perks but uhmmm, these year there’s actually a plan of for management to provide bonuses to associates it’s something that we are looking forward Interviewer: Ahhhh, in terms of company culture po, does you company have any traditions or practices that they observe during special days that you particularly like as an employee? TL: For for Ingram Micro, we follow certain culture but, to the extent of celebrating it we don’t have the the such uhmmm the the since Ingram Micro is glo is a global ahhh business, global organization, the culture is is set for not only for Filipinos but all associates worldwide. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interviewer: ok na po. TL: Yun lang? Interviewer: Thank you very much po! Interview #6 Joan Apring, Female Kered: So good evening po we’re here to interview po for our research project we would like you to now that we are recording this interview Kered: your name po? Joan: Hi I am Joan Apring Kered: How long have you been working in the company? Joan: I’ve been with ingram for 4 years…already Kered: How many companies, particularly BPO, have you previously worked for? Joan: Well this is my 2nd job and pangalawang BPO na rin Kered: uhh in the previously BPO you work for how long did you stay? Joan: For my last job I work for 2 years. Kered: What made you stay for that particular period of time? Joan: I’m sorry?? Kered: Uhmm..What made you stay for that particular period of time? Joan: Since first job ko yon nagge-gain pa ako ng experience and it was my stepping stone para mas makapasok sa mas malaking company and yon benefit din maganda for employees The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Kered: Do you consider the workplace environment that you are currently working in, dun sa ngayon pinagtratrabahuhan mo ngayon a healthy one? Healthy working environment ba yung pinagtatrabahuhan mo? Joan: Yes healthy siya in a sense na maganda yung nabibigay na knowledge, learning sa akin and aside from that yung mga workmates ko is masaya rin silang mga kasama Kered: In terms of facility. What company facility do you like the most? What other facility do you think could be added to further improve the company? Joan: For the facilities that I like in Ingram yung sleeping quarters nila maganda tapos yung building maganda rin the pantry yung mga ginagamit namin for… like yung PC naming magaganda rin siya. Tapos dun naman sa mga kailangan pang improvement uhmmm yung cleanliness ng company. Kung sa building is yung elevator nila which is parating nasisira. Ayun lang kasi for almost 3 years na nag stay ako sa Ingram nakikita ko naman yung improvement nila Kered: In terms of management. How would you describe your relationship with your superiors? Sa mga team leader and supervisor. Joan: Okay yung treatment ng team lead and associate sa company kasi parang mag kaibigan lang pero theres a limt din in terms of sa process which is mararamdaman mo yung superiority ng team lead. Kered: Pwede niyo po bang i-assess yung strengths and weakness nung superior niyo? Joan: Yung direct report ko? Kered: yes po Joan: Yung strength niya is sa pag hahandle ng tao magaling siya kumausapa ng tao kung paano mapapasunod yung associates niya tapos yung weakness naman is I think since bago pa lang siya sa team is hindi niya pa masyadong alam yung buong process na ginagawa namin inaaral niya din ayun pero in time makukuha niya rin kasi magaling din yung tl na na-assign sa amin. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Kered: Sa co-workers. How would you generally describe your relationship with your co-workers? Description lang po Joan: Okay para sa akin yung number 1 na reason kaya ako nag stay sa company is yung my co-workers kasi we treat each other as family na rin hindi lang magkakatrabaho hindi yung parang may kompetensya.. Healthy competition siya unlike.. Kered: walang ilangan kumbaga? Joan: True Kered: Rewards&Benefits. Are these benefits sufficient? Yung mga benefits niyo po sa company sufficient ba? Joan: yes, yes, I can say yes kasi pagdating sa hmo which is nagagamit ng eployees and ng dependent siguro kung meron lang kailangan i- improve is yung additional I think para sa HMO dependent kasi alam ko sa ibang company mas marami yung free nila. Kered: Ano po yung HMO? Joan: yung health card yon, yung health insurance ng employee. Kered: Nakakamotivate po ba yung mga benefits ng company para gawin yung best niyo or work harder para sa company? Joan: For me yes, ayun nga kasi nagagamit siya ng magulang ko and in terms sa salary okay din ang Ingram magpasahod Kered: Sa company culture. Does your company have any tradition or pactices that they observe during special days that you particularly like as an employee? Kung baga may mga norms po bang na sinusunod yung mga employess kunwari po pag kapag sa special day or occasion kahit yung mga simple lang po? Joan: oo palaging may ganyan yung company naming like for example kapag Christmas may pa event sila may year end party sa Halloween party may mga ganyan trick or treat tapos kapag family day may mga ganyang event din si Ingram madami siyang events actually. Kered: Do you see yourself staying in this company for a long time? The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Joan: Yes mga 5 years pa Kered: If so, what do you think is the reason why you consider such? Joan: Ah… Kasi kailangan ko pang mag grow professionally meron akong gusto pang ma achieve sa company which I think kailangan ko pa ng mga more or less 5 years na mag stay para ma achieve ko yon. Kered: Okay po. Thank you Transcript Interview for the Human Resources, Team Leader, and Supervisor Interview #1 Fernando Turingan – Team Leader in Ingram Micro Interviewer: uhhhhh, we are going to record the interview and uhhhhhh. So these are the questions for team leaders or the employers. The first question uhhhh… Ano po yung name niyo po? TL: uhhhh my name is Fernan, Fernando Turingan and I’ve been a team lead for Ingram Micro- Accounts Payable Department for 10 years. Interviewer: *turns to the next page Uhhhh… for demographics po. How old how old are you po? TL: uhhhh… I’m 45 years old. Interviewer: Uhhhhh… yung city address po? TL: Pasig City Interviewer: your position po? Ayy wait lang TL: uhhhh… team lead, team lead for accounts payable Interviewer: *turns to the next page. Uhhmmmm.. the first question: what are the programs you implement for employee retention po? The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management TL: One of the programs we are implementing currently is the IDP or Individual Development Program wherein we do provide certain trainings for our associates especially the new hired for their career growth here at Ingram Micro Interviewer: Uhhhhh… among the implemented policies, what do you think greatly contributes to healthy working environment? Uhhhh… yung nakakapagcontribute po ng malaki sa healthy working environment. TL: ah okkkk. Uhhh… I think uhhh… the one I mentioned earlier; the IDP program uhmmm because this is actually a plan for career growth of these individual of the organization like for example for new hires. The entry level is in voice posting and as… as… as… they as… they stay in Ingram Micro we do train them to become vendor reconcilers or uhmmm… vendor payment planners. In such a way after they got promoted and hopefully stays with Ingram. Interviewer: Uhhhh… yung about po sa IDP what can you tell about that sir? TL: It’s actually a step by step procedure uhmmm… plan uhmmm… program for each individual or each associate in the organization for their career growth like… we provide certain trainings it’s either it’s art sponsored or uhmmm… team lead sponsored training that helps them know more of the processes involved in accounts payable. Interviewer: yung yung mga training po it certainly happens sa mga low level hanggang sa… sa ano po middle level naaa. TL: uhhhh… senior level senior level uhh yes actually uhhh… each job level uhmmm… meron siyang uhhh… kanya kanyang program uhhh each job level is on uhmmm… development program uhmm… that we follow like annn uhmmm… it is not only limited to new hires but actually all associates in Ingram Micro whether tenured or new hires. Interviewer: uhhh… *turns to the next page. Uhh does your organization have annual The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interviewer: uhhh… *turns to the next page. Uhh does your organization have annual objectives for the wellness of your employees? TL: Yah yahhh actually we do haveeee uhmmm… yearly uhhh speech uhhh… yearly we do have the annual physical exam uhhh this is actually given to each associate . uhmmm .. February and march wherein we are requested by the company to go to our ne to our nearest uhmmmmmm… uhhh… what do you call this uhmm… aaaahhh hospital partner where we could test our, both our physical and mental uhmmm… uhmm… aptitude Interviewer: uhhhh… Does your organization engage in conference practices to hear the feedbacks of your employees regarding with their workplace po? TL: yah we do uhhh… quarterly ahh actually uhmm… on my level-team lead for accounts payable uhhh I do conduct a monthly ahhh one on one with my associates and aside from that uhh the company actually have a quarterly survey where associates could voice out their sentiments or anything they have in mind as reagards to their work status and work environment with Ingram Micro. Interviewer: uhhh… usually po dun sa mga sa mga naaaa… naririnig niyo pong feedback ano po yung ginagawa niyong ano TL: ahhhh okay Interviewer: intervention po? TL: Yahh ahhh feedbacks yang mga feedbacks nay an ahh ano actually ano namin yan ginagather naming and then weeeeee make sure them in a way thattttt ahhh we gather all uhmm… results not only from one asso… associate within but also associates from other team and based on the results we provide action plans on how uhh… to cope up with them on how to improve on especially on those uhmmm… results that somehow negative as to the working environment within Ingram Micro. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interviewer: *turns to the next page. Sa… in terms of ano po sa employee attrition po ahhh ano po yung masasabi niyo ahh ano sir ahhh how do you respond to the employees leaving the company? TL: Uhmmm attrition is is something kase naaaa hindi maiiwasan ng company it’s already uhmmm a a given challenge for not only with I think with Ingram Micro but the associates in ge in general. For attrition we do have plan or existing system on how to cope up with that like for example. Its processes on my team or within accounts payable team we have desta procedures installed or saved that if anyone goes a new hired could step step up and could uhmmm do the work by simply referring to the standard procedure that is saved in our system. Interviewer: uhhh… do you have any possible suggestions for healthy working environment? Possible suggestions. TL: uhmmmm… for me, the best uhmmm the best way to promote a healthy working environment is getting associates involved not only involve the sense of uhhhh… doing their daily task but somehow you should find way to have some fun like doing team buildings preferably monthly but if not we can do that at a whiles every two months or quarterly instead and in my case I do have a weekly… weekly game a fun game. We do that every Friday just to relax after stressful work during the week. Interviewer: Thank you very much po. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interview #2 Nurailam Capioso – Supervisor in Ingram Micro Interviewer: First of all, we are letting you to letting you know that this interview is recorded po. Uhhhh… what… your name po? Supervisor: My name is Nurailam Capioso Interviewer: Uhhh… for demographics purposes po. How old are you po? Supervisor: I’m 35 Interviewer: uhhh… your city address po Supervisor: Cavite city Interviewer: Your position in the company po? Supervisor: Supervisor Interviewer: *turns to the next page. Starting off sa interview po uhhh. What are the programs you implement for employee retention po? Supervisor: So uhhmm… in the company, because I work for Ingram Micro rights uhmmm… there is a career growth development for each employees right? There is an opportunity provided not just limited to one department but also to other team that one associate can cross can uhmmm you know can grow not just within the department but also is able to grow and cross to another department, right? And then, there are teams and tower engagement provided for the for the associates, for the employees of Ingram Micro and a as well as hr events. Interviewer: Among the implemented policies, what do you think greatly contributes to healthy working environment? The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Supervisor: I think when you have uhmm… a fun a great culture that is you get to have a motivated people working for the company uhmmm continue supporting for the growth of the company. We have that uhmm that no matter how stressful the company, the work is, it’s always like that right? Whenever you go to company uhmm not just Ingram Micro but when you have this uhmm… you come to work, you feel home because normally when you go to work it’s the second home. So Ingram Micro that’s how I feel, it’s my second home. The culture, the I mean the people that we work around uhmmm is is unexplainable. It’s just uhhh that’s why it got me 10 years to work in for the company right? I just feel comfortable being here. Interviewer: So uhhh… in your company do you have any annual objectives for wellness of your employees? Supervisor: Yes, we value the of each associate right? So uhmmm during town hall events which is done not just once it’s uhmm quarterly events, town hall done for all the associates. By the way just to let you know, we have almost 3,000 associates in the company and yearly the uhmmm the directors, right? From from other country comes here for the town hall event wherein we gather all the associates. Especially the the all the tenured ones and all the ha the one with the high performance. We bring them in… together and then we uhhh… we listen to their feedback and from that feedback right? Uhmm there is an analyzation done by the company and there is also a survey conducted. We have a third party that is doing that for the company and in order to, you know process, in order to obtain the right, most accurate feedback and then we act from that. We also have programs, we have actually a floor there wherein there are programs that is catered to the employees as well. Interviewer: Uhhh… from that feedback po, ano po yung mga intervention na ginagawa niyo po para po maresolve yung problems po? The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Supervisor: So in order to address right, we show like a dashboard, a presentation and we benchmark different companies as well, right? We compare our performance versus our companies and we compare our performance versus other teams or other tower or other managers and we address what’s the common uhmmm feedback uhmm whether good or the lowest, the least, right? Or the best and then from there, we we take action plans and it goes down, it goes down to different teams, different towers and different supervisors and we provide… how we contribute is we come up with action items. Okay? Interviewer: Uhhh… In terms po sa paghandle ng mga employees, how do you support and motivate your employees to work po? Supervisor: So uhmmm… I continuously conduct a one on one or coaching, uhmm it’s it’s really good to have that at least once a month right? That way, you are able to build trust, you are able to build, to build network, you get to know each other, you get to know the life of your employee. Uhmm… not just professionally but you know slowly personally as well, you get to know what they are doing outside the company and by that you are building network, connection with your team and then, they get comfortable working with you and you instill not a stressful but a fun environ working environment. Interviewer: *turns to the next page. So in terms of employee attrition po sa company, how do you respond to the employees leaving the company po? Supervisor: Uhmm, well I feel sad, everyone feels sad when everytime you you get this uhmm you get into this situation wherein one of the employees will be leaving the company. Uhmmm, but there are also a lot of feedback and I’ve encountered a lot of associate leaving the company but wanting to comeback which is positive and I know for a fact that one of the reasons why they are leaving is because uhmmm… you know being having… being employed in this industry, the competitors is very high. From time to time, uhhh, there are new company popping up uhh up right here uhmmm within the industry we have here uhhh it’s growing here aaaa… I’m not sure if you realize. It’s The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management growing here in Taguig there you see Mckinley West and there are a lot of young that are being hired because they are young and still want to explore but uhmm… later on they will realize that the culture really in Ingram Micro is really different from from the rest. I think it’s still the best for me. This is my second company and haven’t left. Interviewer: Uhhhh… aside po dun sa mga competitors as a factor uhhhh what are the other factors po na uhhhh… Supervisor: Well, uhmmm so sometimes, it’s not sometimes, it starts with the team, right? With the supervisor. That’s why it’s important that you uhmmm you listen to their challenges, to their feedback that’s why I conduct one on one regularly and if not, you won’t be able to understand their needs, right? Their challenges uhmmm sometimes uhmmm it could be uhmm they’re stressed, they’re overloaded. It could be the, the culture built right? Uhhh but uhmm in general, I think the last team that I handled, It took us three years before I finally got an attrition. So I think I was able to build a good you know, team. And uhmm although it’s unavailable especially when uhmm working in a sales department and right, people come and go but for finance, uhmm it’s not really high in terms of attrition. Okay, do you have further question? Interviewer: Do you have any possible suggestions for positive work environment po? Supervisor: Any possible suggestions for a positive work environment? And when people are not uhhh suggestions okay. When you continue to support their needs right? When uhmmm as as a supervisor or team manager when we continue to listen to the needs of the employees, when we, not just listening and acting on it, right? And giving importance of providing them feedback continuously honest feedback uhmmm timely feedback to them, uhmm it’s like making them feel they they are part of the company make uhhh letting them know, realize their impact uhmm, in a big picture. That’s when you know you get uhmmm you know that you’re important. You’re an important factor of the company, right? Of the growth. The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interview #3 Martin Guerrero and Nic Allen Fernandez, Human Resources in Sutherland Martin: so i am the first blind employee of uhh sutherland, di po ko nakakita parehong eyes umm i was hired, kelan ba ko nahired? Nic: Hindi he was ano kasi agent bago sya… Martin: I was part of paypal kasi before so i applied as a call center agent here and then i was transitioned to recruitment in hr 1, na dissolve ung account namen so umm, yon! Sam: Ilang years na po kayong nagtatrabaho dito? Martin: Dito? 3 ba, oo mga 3 ganon, 3 years Donato: Eto po for demograph purposes lang po namen, san po ung city address niyo Martin: aahh nakatira talaga ko sa cavite, however nagrerent ako dito sa western, ang layo kasi Kered: Now these are the ahh ano po interview questions po. 1st question po, what are the programs you implement for employee retention? Martin: uhh usually kasi dito kay sutherland, umm, once na ah si employee ay wants to resign, the first thing that the managers do is to talk to them, kung ano ang ah naging problema umm sometimes kasi ang karaniwang reasons is proximity so ah other people in the call center industry kasi ahh medyo mahirap sa kanilang mag biyahe ng malayo, like you can imagine naman ung stress na umm hinahandle nila sa production, and um magbabiyahe ka ng 2 hours 3 hours thatsss ahh hindi namakatangap tangap so ah usually proximity umm others umm nagcocomplain sila regarding salary now um pag salary umm sometime the company provides retention bonus as they call it so uum ung retention bonus naman naten im not that familiar pero umm i think they are agreeing to some amount kunyare kelangan ni employee ng higher salary, and then kelangan i mean gusto The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ni company na maretain sya they can do that or umm sometimes they do promotions umms sometime if meron kasi tayong employee na sagad na talaga ung salary nila for their position so the only thing that salary can increase is um promotion so yon un ung usual na ginagawa namen when it comes to um retention Kered: in terms po dun sa salary increase na nabanggit niyo po dun sa upon the request ng employee sino po ung nagaapprove non and kelan po Martin: umm usually pagka may mga ganong ahh cases, it will be pass on to the account na , hindi na kasi controled ni sutherland yon kasi si account ang magbabayad so usually umm finoforward nila yon sa directors nila for approval umm and then i dont know kung ah may hr interventions ba ung part na un eh hindi ako masyadong sure don Donato: ok po, ang research po kasi namen is about employee retention in relation to a healthy working environment, sa tingin niyo po, ung sa mga implemented na policies niyo po, ano po ung greaty na nakakacontribute po dun sa healthy working environment po ng mga employees niyo Martin: umm most of employees kasi dito ahh nag rerete=ain ah nag nag ahh stay sila becasue of the healthy culture of the company so umm other accounts have their teambuilding sometimes adn then we have facilities then for employees, we have a game room, we have aa music room dun sila nag vivideoke and then we also have umm recreational are we have billiards and chess i think tapos umm balak pa nilang mag dagdag this year im not sure kung ano ung dadagdag nilaahh we have meetings pa kasi regarding that so umm nagsusurvey din kami kay employee kung ano ung kelangan nila what they want and umm ano ung gusto nilang makita, yun nga lang dahil as you can see nagrerent lang kasi si sutherland dito sa bulding soo umm whatever we got um kung anong makita namen sa survey nila umm depende padin yon kasi may mga umm other request na di natin kaya i accomodate kasi maliit ung place naten or we dont have enough space for that The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Donato: umm ano naman pong um nagkakar sa um ano po sa feedback po regard sa mga employee, nagkakaroon po ba kayo ng conference po regarding that po pag may inqueries sila tungkol sa workplace mga ganon Martin: umm regarding that ang mga higher positions ang gumagawa non so they ah collaborate with the survey team and then um ang alam ko kinocconsoledate nila yon and then they will have a meeting with the ah the side heads ung talagang medyo executive positons namen and they will see what they can do with ahh our admin with our um facility control and then tsaka nila paguuspaan kung possible ba na magawa ung gusto ung gusto nilang gawin Donato: ah okay kered: for next question po, how do you support and motivate your employees to work Martin: hmm pano ba nick, kasi ano eh ano ba minomotivate, kasi ung work na yan gawain talaga ng vhr namen so usually umm usually um nagkakaroon ganto umm ang first umm encounter kasi ni employee kay hr is their initial their hew hire orientation so that way umm si hr pumupunta sila hay employee and then they talk regarding the policies of the company the um tawag dito teh compensation and then ah they also discuss incentives so ah like for example on one of our accounts ahh ahh tawag dito ahh one of the accounts namen is the team mobile they have a lot of incentives they have dollar incentives so dito kasi ah bpo umm mostly um ang needed ng employees naten money thats why they are here, so before we have another account and binibigay naman nila is appliances mga cameras um tawag dito mga gadgets mga ganon so dun nila napupush ung employees na mag gain ng scores Kered: sa employee attrition po, how do you respond to employees leaving the company Blind employee: umm sa attrition kasi naten, umm usually kasi kaag naioffer nanamen ung sinabe ko sa inyo kanina na we talk to employees we offer higher salay or promotion The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management kapag ganun wala na kami magagawa kapag gusto na nila umalis kasi usually sa bpo kasi um andami nateng ka kompetisya may tinatawag nga tayong bpo hoppers dba they go from um certain bpo for 6 months get their bonuses and then jump to another bpo, so usually sa attrition rate ahh ill be honest with you medyo mataas kami dito sa bpo industry Nic: we have given ah, pag asa training na nila ganon meron tayong attrition recruitment sila yon kasi madalas tayo eh may mga employees tayo na papasok g work, incomplete naman ang mga requirements dba pag magwowork ka syempre dapat ready na lahat, s aknila kasi un nga bpo, kilala na madaming tao, different personality and attitude ung mga yan kaya ganun sa training naman may mga attrition tayo mga attendance ang ssue si sutherland mahigpit pag dating sa ano aten Martin: so ung sinasabe ni nick ahh we have ah two kinds of attrition voluntary and involuntary soung ah voluntary attrition tahts where the company ah i mean that’s where the employee wants to resign na talaga or abadon or everything kung may nang yare man and the involuntary attrition is kapag kunyare kasi ah one of our accounts, they need 15 days or they have ony 1 days to complete their requirement ah they have basic requirements kasi so ah if those requirements are not submitted within that 15 days, they will be automatically removed from that account, so sometimes naman ah kapag nasa training attriiton naman nah ah usually kunyare nagtraining na si employee syempre si sutherland nagivest na sa kanya then we see nmn na meron syang potential however that account bumagsak sya so um we transfer them to another account ah na medyo makikita ah our trainer equipped naman sa knowledge kung saan dapat ahh, sometimes kasi um we do assessments however um dun sa next thing period nung account bumabagsak parin sila Nic: kapag nagpupullout sila tinatry natin silang hanapan ng other accounts once na mapullout yung ano nila The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Martin: ayon so once na um kunyare bumagsak sila um we give chances naman ah we also allow them to take assessmens from other accounts ah not only on this ah we also forward them to other sites we have 10 sites na sa Philippines na kasi so ah we have um Cubao, Shaw, BGC we have here um Carmona we have in Clark, ah Tarlac and then Davao in Bicol we have legaspi so there Donato: um eto last question na po marami po kaming tanong and nasagot niyo na din nmn po ung iba so ah iaano nalang po namen, may possibles suggestion po ba kayo um personal opinion po for positive working environment po? Martin: um kasi ah sa bpo industry um medyo ung positive environment medyo mahirap syang makuha kasi we have alot of people na ibaba ung ugali, fortunately here in Sutherland we have positive environment because our leaders ar eimplementing umm those kinds of attitude so um here we do a town hall, town hall means meron kaming quarterly talk with our employees and kinakausap sila mismo ng executives so the executives uum will handle a progam they wil speak to the employees then um our regualr employees like the level one im talking to the level one employees they an really ask questions to themso then we also do our global town hall which is um we have our um higher ups na talagang executives naten from other country which also employees can ask questions so in that way they feel na um they are being heard by the ano executives kahit na kasi other companies kapag executives they dont talk to um employees below the level dba so here we ah our executives accept suggestions they ah um tehy will read all emails from employees then they will see what they can do kung possible sya then they will give it if not yon they will offer other one, ganon Nic: kasi di kami nakapag ano sa vhrs naten yon nga inexplain ko naman sa inyo na sobrang hirap kasi talaga mag set ng ano sa kanila kapag pupunta kayo ng bpo company madami talagang nagaawall( d ko magets around 13:00) kaya marami tayong admin hearing yah ung admin hearing papasok sya dun sa ano naten am The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Martin: makikita niyo ung vhr naten meron silang paper na ganyan kataas pipirmahan nila yon para sa employee female: sa number 9 questions niyo dun sya papasok umm pag may nagaawol tayo di nmn agad tinatanggal yon uhh nag gigive kami ng chance sa kanila Martin: pinaprocess kasi female: yah ung papers Martin: kasi pag na tanggal din naman kami agad DOLE naman yon si hindi sya pwedeng basta bastang gagwen female: sobrang dami so kaya ung kanina the last time inexplain ko 2316 ang hawak namen and hanggang ngaun 2316 paden hawak namen kasi sobrang laki ilang libo't ilang libo tayo dito so we have to consolidate and rename all the files imagine all the 2316 of our employees i mean all of them, ganon kaya hindi kami um nakapagset agad ng meeting kaya nag ano kami pinilit din namen na ngaun, kami nalang makikipagmeet sa inyo, pati ung sa mga papers di naten nacomplete kasi wala don halos lahat naman kasi na napupunta sameng mga employees nagmamadali mga pa-out na mga nagrereach out samen pag active syempre di naman tayo pwede magpasurvey ng inactive employee kasi di nmn maganda ung iallagay nila jan (tumawa lahat) ma aano tayo Nic: yon Donato: ok na po umm Nic: picture ba tao Donato: for documentation lang po ok lang The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management DOCUMENTATION Interview with Mr. Fernando Turingan, a Team Leader in Ingram Micro Interview with Mr. Martin Guerrero and Ms. Nick Allen Fernandez, Human Resource Officers of Sutherland The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Interview with Mrs. Nurailam Capioso, a supervisor in Ingram The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Appendix C RESUME ___________________________________________ NAME: Francis Angelo S. Donato Home Address: #44 Macopa St., Comembo, Makati City Mobile: 09185406480 Home Number: None E-mail Address: francisdonato@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 18 years old Gender: Male Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: May 26, 2001 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Senior High School Strand / Track: Accountancy, Business, and Management Inclusive Dates: June 2018 – April 2020 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Junior High School: School: Inclusive Dates: Pateros Catholic School Grade School: School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: June 2007 – March 2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES CONFLICT RESOLUTION TIME MANAGEMENT DECISION MAKING LEADERSHIP ADAPTABILITY TEAMWORK COMMUNICATION CRITICAL THINKING ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: PCS Courier Position: Copy Editor Inclusive Date: June 2017 – April 2020 Name of Organization: Supreme Student Council Position: Accountancy, Business, and Management Representative Inclusive Date: June 2018 – March 2019 Name of Organization: Supreme Student Council Position: Auditor Inclusive Date: June 2019 – October 2019 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHARACTER REFERENCES Reynette Getizo Grade 10 Level Coordinator – Pateros Catholic School 09155890279 Roselie Yago Supreme Student Council Adviser – Pateros Catholic School 09300354220 I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Francis Angelo S. Donato The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management _______________________________________ NAME: Kered Zilyo C. Natividad Home Address: 505- A. Yakal St., Comembo, Makati City Mobile: 0966-448-1052 Home Number: 881-1156 E-mail Address: keredzilnat@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 18 years old Gender: Male Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: December, 3, 2001 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Strand / Track: Academic Track – Accountancy, Business and Management Strand Inclusive Dates: 2018-2020 Junior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: 2014-2018 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Grade School: School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: 2008-2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES Teamwork Leadership Adaptability Time Management Writing proficiency Communication proficiency ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: Ministry of Altar Servers Position: Treasurer Inclusive Date: 2018-Present Name of Organization: Legion of Mary Position: Member Inclusive Date: 2014-Present Name of Organization: Lakbay Basa Position: Volunteer Inclusive Date: 2018-Present The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHARACTER REFERENCES Mr. Marlon John C. Vidallon Grade 12 Adviser Pateros Catholic School Mr. Leo Cerbolles Humanities and Religious Education Department Head Pateros Catholic School I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Kered Zilyo C. Natividad The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ________________________________________ NAME: Samantha Nicole M. Reyes Home Address: 26 S. Alquillera St., Pateros, Metro Manila Mobile: 09393083385 Home Number: None E-mail Address: reyessamantha927@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 18 years old Gender: Female Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: December 28,2001 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Senior High School Strand / Track: Accountancy, Business, and Management Inclusive Dates: June 2018 – April 2020 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Junior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: June 2014 – April 2018 Grade School: School: Pateros Elementary School Inclusive Dates: June 2007 – March 2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES Active Listening Adaptability Communication Decision Making Time Management Problem-solving Teamwork Initiative Organization Attention to Detail ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: Math Club Position: Member Inclusive Date: June 2014 – April 2018 Name of Organization: Journalism Club Position: Member The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Inclusive Date: June 2018 – April 2019 Name of Organization: Eco-warriors Club Position: Member Inclusive Date: June 2019 – April 2020 CHARACTER REFERENCES Mr. Marlon V. Vidallon Grade 12 Adviser Pateros Catholic School Ms. Ana Adriatico Grade 11 Adviser Pateros Catholic School I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Samantha Nicole M. Reyes The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management _________________________________ NAME: Yshi M. Tagalag Home Address: #7 Alley7 P.Rosales St. Sta Ana Kanan Pateros, Metro Manila Mobile: 0999705082 Home Number: None E-mail Address: yshimtagalag54@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 17 years old Gender: Female Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: May 4, 2002 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Senior High School Strand / Track: Accountancy, Business, and Management Inclusive Dates: June 2018 – April 2020 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Junior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: June 2014 – April 2018 Grade School: School: Pateros Elementary School Inclusive Dates: June 2007 – March 2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES Multitasking Organized Communication Flexible Time Management Problem-solving Teamwork ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: Volley Ball Club Position: Member Inclusive Date: June 2014 – April 2020 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHARACTER REFERENCES Mr. Marlon V. Vidallon Grade 12 Adviser Pateros Catholic School Ms. Ana Adriatico Grade 11 Adviser Pateros Catholic School I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Yshi M. Tagalag The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management _______________________________________ NAME: Justine Dave E. Ventura Home Address: Block 39 Lot 13 Phase 2 Brgy. Pinagsama, Taguig City Mobile: 09053518809 Home Number: -------E-mail Address: justineventura2@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 18 Gender: Male Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: February 18, 2002 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Strand / Track: Academic track- Accountancy, Business and Management Inclusive Dates: June 2018- April 2020 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Junior High School: School: Benigno Ninoy S. Aquino High School Inclusive Dates: June 2014 - March 2018 Grade School: School: East Rembo Elementary School Inclusive Dates: 2007-2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES Math literate Computer Literate Trustworthy Fluent in speaking Filipino and English ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: Foreign Language Club Position: Member Inclusive Date: June 2019- April 2020 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHARACTER REFERENCES Mr. Marlon Vidallon Grade 12 Adviser Pateros Catholic School Mr. Mark Anthony Orpiano Grade 11 Adviser Pateros Catholic School I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Justine Dave E. Ventura The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ____________________________________________ NAME: Maxine Aimellen S.M Desengano Home Address: # 321 Duhat St. Comembo Makati City Mobile: 09260448774 Home Number: None E-mail Address: Maxinesmd@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 18 Gender: Female Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: December 30, 2001 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School Strand / Track: Accountancy and Business Management Inclusive Dates: 2018-2020 Junior High School: The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: 2014-2018 Grade School: School: Pateros Catholic School Inclusive Dates: 2009-2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES -Multi-Tasker -Good in Time Management -Motivation Skills -Optimistic -God Fearing -Talented -Funny -Sense of Humor ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: Volleyball club Position: Member Inclusive Date: 2018-2020 Name of Organization: Pcs Jaggers The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Position: Member Inclusive Date: 2014-2018 Name of Organization: Acoustic Club Position: Member Inclusive Date: 2009-2014 CHARACTER REFERENCES Mr. Mark Orpiano Grade 11 Adviser Pateros Catholic School Mr. Marlon Vidallon Grade 12 Adviser Pateros Catholic School I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Maxine Aimelleen S.M. Desengano The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management ____________________________________________ NAME: Nicole Marie M. Ambrona Home Address: 9 ruhale st. Brgy.Calzada, Taguig City Mobile: 09669980458 Home Number: 403-1518 E-mail Address: Nicoleambrona@gmail.com PERSONAL DATA Age: 17 Gender: Female Civil Status: Single Citizenship: Filipino Birth Date: September 8, 2002 EDUCATION Senior High School: School: Pateros Catholic School-senior high Strand / Track: Accountancy and Business Management Inclusive Dates: 2018-2020 Junior High School: School: La Immaculada Concepcion School The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management Inclusive Dates: 2014-2018 Grade School: School: Little Friends of st. Mary Learning Center Inclusive Dates: 2009-2014 SKILLS AND PROFICIENCIES - Can work under pressure - Proficient in English -Good in Time Management -Motivation Skills -Optimistic -Talented - Artistic ORGANIZATIONAL AFFILIATION Name of Organization: Volleyball club Position: Member Inclusive Date: 2019-2020 Name of Organization: Arts and Design Club Position: Member Inclusive Date: 2018-2019 The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al PATEROS CATHOLIC SCHOOL Senior High School Department Pateros, Metro Manila Accountancy, Business, and Management CHARACTER REFERENCES Ms. Anna Adriatico Grade 11 Adviser Pateros Catholic School Mr. Marlon Vidallon Grade 12 Adviser Pateros Catholic School I hereby certify that all information presented above are true. Nicole Marie M. Ambrona The Steering Wheel and Clutch of BPO Employees: Factors Contributing to Employee Retention in Relation to a Healthy Working Environment Reyes, S.N. et.al