Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. J3. GAS ABSORPTION J3.1. INTRODUCTION Gas absorption involves the removal of a soluble component from an inert gas by contacting the mixture with an appropriate solvent. The solvent must be chosen such that it has a very high affinity to dissolve the solute with the inert gas practically insoluble in it. The solvent must have reasonably high boiling point to remain in the liquid state at the specified operating temperature during the absorption process. The separation process is highly influenced by the solubility of the solute in the solvent and is very much dependent on the equilibrium concentration at a given pressure and temperature. The rate by which absorption proceeds depends on the contacting area, the resistance to mass transfer and the driving force which is the difference between the concentration of the solute in the gas phase and the equilibrium concentration existing at the liquid interface as described by the two-film theory of mass transfer. The concentration at the interface depends on the solubility of the solute in the liquid phase that describes the equilibrium concentration. J3.2. PHASE EQULIBRIA IN GAS ABSORPTION The system involves three components, the solute (A), the solvent (B) and the inert gas (I). If we apply the Gibb’s Phase Rule, CP2 (J3 - 1) with as the number of degrees of freedom, C the number of components and P the number of phases, the degrees of freedom obtained is three. Usually, in the operation of a gas absorber, the pressure is fixed. This gives two more conditions to be specified. Thus, to simplify the analysis, the temperature is also fixed at a constant value. In this case, since the concentration of the liquid is fixed, there will only be one possible concentration that can be obtained in the gas phase at equilibrium. This variation in the equilibrium concentration is provided by the solubility data, which is the basis of determining equilibrium concentration. J3.2.1. SOURCES OF EQUILIBRIUM CONCENTRATION 1. Solubility Data or Solubility Curves. These information can be obtained from various references especially Perry’s Handbook. A specified total pressure and temperature, the usual data given involve values of the partial pressure of the solute in the gas phase, p A in mm Hg corresponding to the solubility in the liquid phase represented by cA’ in mass of A per 100 mass units of the solvent B. To express these concentrations in terms of the mole fraction, the following relationships can be applied, J3 - 1 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. p yA A PT cA' / M A and xA ' cA / M A 100 / M B (J3 – 2) 2. Henry’s Constants. If the mixture is somewhat dilute such that Henry’s Law can be applied, the equilibrium concentrations can be related in terms of the Henry’s constant, HA. yA HA xA mxA PT (J3 – 3) 3. Vapor Pressure. If the solution can be considered and ideal solution, Raoult’s Law can be applied in determining the partial pressure of A from the vapor pressure pAo, thus p A p Ao yA xA PT PT (J3 – 4) The vapor pressure-temperature data can easily be obtained from references or the Antoine Equation may be used to estimate this value. 4. Distribution Coefficients. If the other sources mentioned are not available for the system under consideration and the distribution coefficient, KA is known, the equilibrium relationship can also be obtained using the equation y A K A xA (J3 – 5) J3.3. EQUIPMENT FOR GAS ABSORPTION In the operation of the gas absorber the rate of mass transfer must be maintained high, in order to reduce the size of the equipment, at the same time reduce energy requirements by maintaining low-pressure drop and efficient contact of liquid and gas within the column. To increase the rate of mass transfer, a high concentration gradient, high mass transfer area and low resistance to mass transfer must be maintained. A counter-current flow can maintain high concentration gradients compared to cocurrent flow besides using the natural flow of the phases. Low resistance to mass transfer can be induced by increasing eddy diffusion or turbulence in the flow system. One important consideration is the mass transfer area which is very much dependent on the hydrodynamics and method of J3 - 2 Lean Gas V', V2 Y2, y2 Solvent L', L2 V' ZT Gas V', V1 Y1, y1 L' dZ Solution L', L1 X1, x1 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. contact between the two phases. Two types will be considered here. A packed column, composed of random or structured packings, and a plate column such as sieve trays or bubble caps. For packed column, the design problem involves the determination of the volume or height of the packed column while for plate columns, the problem is to determine the number of theoretical stages needed for the separation. In both cases, ideal conditions are assumed. The actual design values can be obtained by considering the efficiency of the column. J3.4. PACKED COLUMNS Let us consider the packed column shown in Fig. 1 with the flow rates and concentration of the streams indicated. Two types of flow and concentrations are used, based on the total and based on the solute-free component, as indicated by a prime for flow rates and capital letters for concentration. The convert from one type to the other, the following equations can be applied V ' V (1 y) L' L(1 x) (J3 – 6) x 1 x (J3 – 7) X 1 X (J3 – 8) Y y 1 y X y Y 1 Y x J3.4.1. Mass Transfer Equations. Referring to Fig. 2, which represents the two-film theory of mass transfer, it is possible to generate two mass transfer equations, one for the gas phase and the other for the liquid phase. Gas Phase PA A. Gas Phase dNTA G kG p A p Ai (dNA)G dA (J3 – 9) since the interfacial area dA is usually very inconvenient to measure, it can be expressed in terms of the element of volume of the packed section dA aSdZ (J3 – 10) J3 - 3 interface Liquid Phase PAi (dNA)L CAi CA Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. where a is the interfacial area provided by the packing per unit volume. This property can be determined depending on the type of packing used. Also, the partial pressure in Eq. (J3 - 9) can be expressed in terms y, the mole fraction of A. Thus, Eq. (J3 - 9) can be written in the form dNTA G kG aPT y yi SdZ (J3 – 11) or, if we let kya = kGaPT, the equation becomes, dNTA G k y a y yi SdZ (J3 – 12) B. Liquid Phase For the liquid phase, similar equations can be derived, dNTA L k L cAi cA dA dNTA L kL a m xi x SdZ k x a xi x SdZ (J3 – 13) J3.4.2. Determination of Height of Packed Column The volume or height of the packed column can be evaluated from these mass transfer equations. For brevity, only the derivation based on the gas-phase mass transfer equation will be shown and a similar equation for the liquid phase can be generated. Solving for Z from Eq. (J3 – 13), we get Z y2 y1 ( dNTA )G k y aS ( y yi ) (J3 – 14) A material balance around the element of volume SdZ gives, dNTA G V 'dY (J3 – 15) expressing in terms of mole fraction, Eq. (J3 – 15) becomes, y dy dNTA V 1 y d V 1 y 1 y (J3 – 16) substituting this in Eq. (J3 – 14) and simplifying by just getting the arithmetic mean of the gas flowrate and the mass transfer coefficient, we get J3 - 4 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. V / S y2 dy Z k a y1 (1 y )( y y ) i y ave (J3 – 17) Equation (J3 – 17) may be split in terms of height of a transfer unit, HTU or HG, and the number of transfer units NTU or NG given by Z H G x NG (J3 – 18) Similarly, if the same mathematical operation is done on the liquid-phase mass transfer equation, the following equations will be obtained x2 L/S dx Z H Lx NL x1 (1 x)( xi x) k x a ave (J3 – 19) in both cases, the number of transfer unit NG and NL are evaluated by numerical or graphical integration. The values of the bulk concentrations and the corresponding interfacial concentrations are obtained from a plot of the operating line using a material balance around the column, the equilibrium curve obtained from the solubility data and slope of the tie-line obtained from the mass transfer equations. J3.4.3. Procedure in the Evaluation of N G or N L (1) Using the coordinates in terms of mole fraction of the solute in the liquid, x and the mole fraction of the solute in the gas phase, y, first plot the equilibrium curve by converting the solubility data to these units. These equilibrium values are referred to as y* versus x. Here the asterisk indicate equilibrium concentration. (2) Plot the operating line from the solute balance around the element of volume and integrating this from the inlet conditions to any point in the column. dN A V ' dY L' dX integrating N A V ' Y1 Y L' X1 X (J3 – 20) (J3 – 21) expressing Eq ( ) in terms of the mole fraction y1 x1 y x ' V ' L 1 y1 1 y 1 x1 1 x J3 - 5 (J3 – 22) Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. It is seen that the operating line if plotted using a coordinate system in terms of mole fraction will not necessarily generate a straight line unless the gas and liquid phase solutions are very dilute. However, if the coordinates used are in terms of mole ratios, that is, X and Y, the operating line obtained is a straight line with a slope of L’/V’ which represents the liquid to gas ratio on solute-free basis. (3) The equation of the tie line is obtained by equating the mass transfer rates in both phases since there is no accumulation of solute at the interface. dN A G dN A L (J3 – 23) EC slope= -kya/kxa TL substituting Eqs. ( J3 -12 ) and ( J3 -13 ), we get y k y a y yi SdZ kx a( xi x)SdZ (J3 – 24) OL y yi y* re-arranging this equation, we obtain y yi k a x x xi k ya (J3 – 25) x xi x* x and the slope of the tie line is given by Slope kxa kya (J3 – 26) If a tie line is drawn from any point along the operating line at x and y, this line which is slanting to the left, since the slope is negative, will intersect the equilibrium curve at xi and yi as shown in Fig. J3 - 2. Since several parallel tie lines can be drawn, then various values of y vs yi or x versus xi can be obtained to evaluate the values of NG or NL numerically or graphically. It is important to note that the driving force in the gas phase is represented by the vertical distance from y to yi while the distance from yi to y* may be considered to represent the driving force in the liquid phase in terms of concentrations based on the gas-phase. Similar interpretation can be done with the difference between xi and x, to represent the driving force in the liquid phase while xi – x* represents the driving force in the gas-phase based on the liquid phase concentration. The relative distance of yi to y and xi to x will depend on the slope of the tie line which can also be interpreted as the ratio of the mass transfer resistance in the gas phase to the mass transfer resistance in the liquid phase. If the resistance to mass transfer in the gas phase is controlling, the tie line tends to be vertical and yi is almost equal to y*. Similarly if the resistance in the liquid phase is controlling, the tie line tends to become horizontal, making the xi approach x*. J3 - 6 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. The above rigorous procedure may be simplified depending on the prevailing requirements of design. There are cases when approximate methods can be applied due to certain conditions such as strong or weak solubility, the solutions are dilute and the data or correlations available do not warrant very precise calculations. J3.4.4. Simplified Equations In Terms of the Over-all Driving Force. One way of simplifying the design procedure is to use the over-all driving force (y – y*) instead of the interfacial driving forces. In this case the resistance that should be considered will now be the combination of the gas and liquid phase resistances by calculating the equivalent over-all mass transfer coefficient, Kya or Kxa, this time defined by the mass transfer equations as (dN A )G K y a( y y*)SdZ (J3 – 27) (dN A ) L K x a( x * x)SdZ (J3 – 28) Eq. (J3 - 27) may be written in the equivalent form (dN A )G K y a[( y yi ) ( y * yi )]SdZ (J3 – 29) by combining this with Eq. (J3 – 27) and if we assume that (y – yi) = m (xi – x), where m is the slope of the equilibrium curve, it can easily be shown that 1 1 m K y a k y a kxa (J3 – 30) Similarly, for the liquid phase over-all resistance to mass transfer can be expressed in terms of the individual resistances by 1 1 1 K x a k x a mk y a (J3 – 31) From Eqs. (J3 – 27) and (J3 – 28), the height of the packed section can be derived as V S Z K a y ave dy 1 y y y L S dx Z K x a ave 1 x x x J3 - 7 H OG N OG H OL N OL (J3 – 32) (J3 – 33) Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. Although NOG and NOL will still require graphical or numerical integration, however, the procedure is reduced by one step since the slope of the tie-line is no longer needed. The tielines used here are either vertical, for gas phase, or horizontal for liquid phase. (a) For Very Dilute Solutions. If the solutions are very dilute such that (1 – y) = 1 or (1 – x) = 1, the above equations can be simplified further to V S Z K a y V '/ S dy y y K a y dY Y Y * (J3 – 34) For very dilute solutions, the operating line is linear, however, if the equilibrium curve is also linear, the log-mean driving force may be applied instead of integration. That the equation for NOG can be written as N OG where y y y1 y 2 y y (J3 – 35) , ln y y y y y y ln y y ln 1 2 (J3 – 36) 1 2 (b) If solution is concentrated and EC and OL are linear within limits, V S y1 y 2 1 Z K a y y y ave 1 y ave ln (J3 – 37) (c) For very soluble solutes (gas phase resistance is controlling) Slope of Tie Line k x a since k x a k y a k ya yi y ; N G N OG ; Kya Kya (J3 – 38) (d) For very slightly soluble solutes (liquid phase resistance is controlling) Slope of Tie Line 0 since k x a k y a xi x ; N L N OL ; k x a k y a J3 - 8 (J3 – 39) Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. (e) Approximate Integration of MTE The mass transfer equation in terms of partial pressure driving force may be written in the form dN A G KG a p p SdZ (J3 – 40) To approximate the design calculations, the logarithmic mean of the driving force may be applied. Thus, N A KG a p p SZ ln (J3 – 41) J3.5. PLATE COLUMNS For plate columns, contacting of gas and liquid are facilitated using bubble caps or sieve trays identical to those used in stagewise distillation columns. The design problem, therefore, involves the determination of the number of plates, which, can be based on the assumption of ideal or theoretical stages. That is, the gas and liquid leaving a particular stage is considered to be in equilibrium with each other. To determine the theoretical number of stages, the following procedure may be applied: a. plot the equilibrium curve (EC) based on the solubility data or equilibrium equation derived, b. plot the known concentrations of either gas or liquid c. plot the operating line (OL) using the material balance equation around the column or use the slope which represents the liquid to gas ratio. d. From the point x2,y2 draw a step up lines between the OL and EC until the point x1, y1 are reached. The theoretical number of stages is equivalent to the number of triangles formed. J3 - 9 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. If operating line (OL) and the equilibrium curve (EC) are linear, apply the Absorption Factor Method or the Tiller-Tour Equation, given by y1 y1* y2 y2* y y log 1* 2* y1 y2 log Ntheo x1 x1* x2 x2* x x log 1* 2* x1 x2 (J3 – 42) log Ntheo (J3 – 43) J3.6. LIMITING FLOWRATES In the operation of the absorption columns, certain limiting flow conditions should be determined so that these flow rates can be avoided to insure that the conditions specified in the performance of the equipment is achieved. These limiting flow rates are based on flooding conditions and the solubility of the solute in the liquid phase. J3.6.1. Based on Flooding Conditions: When a gas flows counter current with a liquid in a packed column, pressure drop J3 - 10 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. along the column is induced. This pressure drop is very much dependent on the liquid to gas ratio, the physical properties of the streams, the characteristics of the packing and the crosssectional area of the column. If the pressure drop is plotted with gas flow rate in a log-log graph, a straight line is generated with a slope of approximately two as shown in Fig. 1. When the gas flow rate is further increased, at a given liquid flow rate, the slope changes and tends to approach a very high value. This is the point where phase inversion starts to occur and further increase in the gas rate, the liquid flow is arrested due to high pressure generated by the gas. At this condition, flooding occurs and the efficiency of the column is drastically reduced. To determine the flooding velocity of the gas, the Generalized Pressure Drop Correlation (GPDC) chart may be used as shown in Fig. 4. Flooding may be assumed to occur at a pressure drop of 1.5 in. H2O. A chart that can be used to determine the flooding condition indirectly is found in Foust, et al (19__). When the flooding velocity is determined, the actual velocity can be evaluated as a fraction of this maximum value. Design heuristics suggest that 50 per cent of flooding may be a good estimate. From the actual velocity of the gas and the fixed volumetric flow rate of the inlet gas, the cross-sectional area may be calculated which will then determine the diameter of the column. J3.6.2. Based on Equilibrium Conditions The flow rate of either gas or liquid may be limited based on the extent by which the solute can dissolved in the liquid phase defined by the solubility or equilibrium conditions. Consider the graph shown in Fig. J3-5. The operating line can be adjusted in such a way that it can intersect the equilibrium curve to generate a minimum slope. At this condition, the driving force at the top of the column is zero. This will then require an infinitely tall tower or infinite number of stages. Thus the limiting slope is a minimum given by L' Y1 Y2 ' V X min 1 X2 (J3 – 44) If the gas flow rate is fixed, the liquid flow rate becomes minimum and therefore, in order not to operate an infinitely tall tower, the specified liquid flow rate must be greater that the minimum. Heuristics suggest between 1.5 to 2.0 times the minimum. Of course, this will have to be checked for consistency with the flooding conditions. On the other hand, if the conditions at the bottom of the tower are fixed, an operating line with a maximum slope becomes the limiting condition. From this slope, it is now possible to determine which becomes the limiting flow rate. J3 - 11 Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. NOMENCLATURE A a C c’A HG HA K KA kGa kxa kya L L’ M m N NTA P pA PT S V V’ X x Y y Z number of degrees of freedom mass transfer area interfacial area per unit volume of packing number of components concentration of A in the solution height of a transfer unit Henry’s constant over-all mass transfer coefficient distribution coefficient of A individual gas phase mass transfer coefficient individual liquid phase mass transfer coefficient individual gas phase mass transfer coefficient flow rate of solution flow rate of solvent, molecular weight slope of a linear equilibrium curve number of transfer units total moles of A transferring number of phases partial pressure of A total pressure cross-sectional area of the column total gas flow rate, inert gas flow rate, mole solute/mole solvent mole fraction of solute in solution mole solute/mole inert gas mole fraction of solute in gas height of the packing in the column J3 - 12 [-] [ft2] or [m2] [-] gm A/100 gm of B [m] [-] [lb mole/hr] [lb mole/hr] gm/gm-mole [-] lb mol/hr [-] mm Hg or atm mm Hg or atm [ft2] or [m2] [lb mole/hr] [lb mole/hr] [-] [-] [-] [-] [ft] or [m] Philippine Handbook in Chemical Engineering Gas Absorption by Servillano Olaño, Jr. Gas Absorption, J3 – 1 absorption factor method, J3 - 10 distribution coefficients, J3 - 2 equilibrium concentration, sources of, J3 - 1 NG or NL evaluation, J3 - 5 gas absorption, J3 - 1 gas absorption, equipment for, J3 - 2 gas absorption, phase equilibria in, J3 - 1 Gibb’s Phase rule, J3 - 1 height of a transfer unit, HTU, J3 - 5 Henry’s constants, J3 - 2 limiting flowrates, J3 - 10 limiting flowrates, based on equilibrium conditions, J3 - 11 limiting flowrates, based on flooding conditions, J3 - 10 mass tranfer equations, J3 - 3 number of transfer units, NTU, J3 - 5 packed column, determination of height of, J3 - 4 packed columns, J3 - 3 plate columns, J3 - 9 solubility curves, J3 - 1 Tiller-Tour equation, J3 - 10 vapor pressure, J3 - 2 J3 - 13