Academic writing Myths & Facts MYTHS FACTS Writing well is a talent you either have or do not have. Writing well is something that you need to learn and practice. There is one standard way of writing at university You need to find out all you can on the topic and put it all in your assignment. Writing critically is when you say what is negative or incorrect about something. Many aspects of writing are common across subjects and assignment types, but you need to develop awareness of specialized characteristics of you subject, task type and tutor's approach. You should demonstrate that you can discriminate between relevant and non-relevant sources. Being critical means using the questioning process to comment on or evaluate something. Your evaluation can be positive, negative or both. Myths & Facts MYTHS FACTS You should use lots of quotations. It is recommended that you re-express and integrate the information using your own words and phrases. Being original means coming up with a totally new idea or making a new discovery. You are expected to develop your own understanding of an issue. This unique understanding arises as you choose your resources, how you evaluate them and the conclusions you come to. You should not say what you think or use 'I' in the assignments. You can express your views through analysis and evaluation of evidence and viewpoints from other sources. You do not need to explain things in your writing that your tutor already knows. Your assignments usually need to explain background information and terms in a way that an educated and intelligent non-expert reader would be able to understand. Myths & Facts MYTHS FACTS Successful writing at university means writing in long sentences and using lots of long words. Successful writing is precise, clear and to the point. You need to use formal vocabulary items. Successful writers think, then write, check and hand in. Successful writers make lots of mistakes and rewrite and correct their work many times before arriving at the final revision. Features of academic writing Academic writing in English is linear, which means it has one central point or theme with every part contributing to the main line of argument, without repetitions. Its objective is to inform rather than entertain. There are ten main features of academic writing that are often discussed. Academic writing is to some extent: complex, formal, objective, explicit, hedged, and responsible. It uses language precisely and accurately. It is also well organised and planned. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Complexity Written language is relatively more complex than spoken language (Biber, 1988; Biber, Johansson, Leech, Conrad & Finegan, 1999; Chafe, 1982; Cook, 1997; Halliday,1989). Written language is grammatically more complex than spoken language. It has more subordinate clauses, more "that/to" complement clauses more long sequences of prepositional phrases more adjectives more passives than spoken language. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Formality In general this means in an essay that you should avoid: colloquial words and expressions; ""stuff", "a lot of", "thing", "sort of", “like” abbreviated forms: "can't", "doesn't", "shouldn’t” two word verbs: "put off", "bring up" sub-headings, numbering and bullet-points in formal essays - but use them in research paper. asking questions. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Precision (content) In academic writing you need to be precise when you use information, dates or figures. Do not use "a lot of people" when you can say "50 million people". Examples: Example 1 Chinese are Buddhist. They go to the temple five times a year, live simple lives, and give money to charity. Example 2 Many Chinese are Buddhists. Practising Buddhists go to the temple about five times a year, generally try to live simple lives, and give money to charity when they can. HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITING-ASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/CLEARCOMMUNICATION/WRITING-CLEARLY-CONCISELY-AND-PRECISELY Precision HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITINGASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/CLEAR-COMMUNICATION/WRITING-CLEARLYCONCISELY-AND-PRECISELY Objectivity This means that the main emphasis should be on the information that you want to give and the arguments you want to make, rather than you. Nobody really wants to know what you "think" or "believe". They want to know what you have studied and learned and how this has led you to your various conclusions. In general, avoid words like "I", "me", "myself". Don't write:" In my opinion, this a very interesting study." Write: "This is a very interesting study." Avoid "you" to refer to the reader or people in general. Don't write: "You can easily forget how different life was 50 years ago." Write: "It is easy to forget how difficult life was 50 years ago." HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Explicitness Academic writing is explicit in several ways. It is explicit in its signposting of the organisation of the ideas in the text (Biber, Johansson, Leech, Conrad & Finegan, 1999, pp. 880-882). For example, if you want to tell your reader that your line of argument is going to change, make it clear. The Bristol 167 was to be the largest aircraft ever built in Britain. However, even by the end of the war, the design had run into serious difficulties. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Accuracy (Vocabulary & Grammar) In academic writing you need to be accurate in your use of vocabulary. Choose the correct word, for example, "meeting", "assembly" , "gathering" or "conference". Or from: "money", "cash", "currency", "capital" or "funds". You also need to be accurate in your use of grammar. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Rules of academic writing An academic text not a narrative-it is an argument. Formal, logical, cautious & unemotional language. No slang, jargon, personal anecdotes, colloquisms, exclamation marks & contractions (‘e.g. can’t’). Clear, succinct writing. A % of the overall mark will be awarded for clear, accurate writing & referencing & the converse also true. FJ SEPT. 2008 Rules of academic writing Not 1st person (I and my). 3rd person only– ‘this writer’ believes that’… ‘this student’s experience has been’… It is believed… Many researchers have noted… Some writers have stated.. The research suggests… The evidence indicates... It will be argued that … This essay will critically examine the process leading to…. FJ SEPT. 2008 Formatting Assignments HEADER: First name and last name, Unit Code, Assessment # FOOTER: Page number MARGINS: Top & Bottom 3.0cm and Left & Right 2.5cm PAGE SIZE: A4 BODY TEXT: Font: Arial Size: 12pt Alignment: Justified (both sides); but not for references in a list or bibliography Line Spacing: 1.5 Paragraph Spacing: 0pt ‘before’ and 12pt ‘after’ FILE NAME: Last name_First name_Student #_Unit Code_Assessment # Assignments should be submitted to Learnline in Microsoft Word file type. Word count Word Count: all words from beginning of introduction to end of conclusion. References List not included in word count. Research topics The following topics can be explored relevant to your chosen academic discipline: business writing crisis management conflict management social media Types of research primary research: is information gathered through self-conducted research methods secondary research (Literature review research): is information gathered from previously conducted studies. HTTPS://WWW.GEOPOLL.COM/BLOG/PRIMARY-VS-SECONDARYRESEARCH/#:~:TEXT=PRIMARY%20RESEARCH%20IS%20INFORMATION%20GATHERED,USUALLY%20 WHERE%20MOST%20RESEARCH%20BEGINS. Major parts of a research paper The major parts of a research paper are abstract, introduction, review of literature, research methods, (primary: questionnaires, surveys, interviews, etc.; secondary: review of literature) findings and analysis, discussion, limitations, future scope and References to the studies included in the literature review section How to write a research question? The process of developing your research question follows several steps: Choose a broad topic Do some preliminary reading to find out about topical debates and issues Narrow down a specific niche that you want to focus on HTTPS://WWW.SCRIBBR.COM/RESEARCH-PROCESS/RESEARCH-QUESTIONS/ What makes a strong research question? Focused and researchable Feasible and specific HTTPS://WWW.SCRIBBR.COM/RESEARCH-PROCESS/RESEARCH-QUESTIONS/ Complex and arguable Sample research questions Which of the following is a clear research question? How should social networking sites address the harm they cause? What action should social networking sites like MySpace and Facebook take to protect users’ personal information and privacy? Which of the following is a focused research question? What is the effect of global warming on the environment? What is the most significant effect of glacial melting on the lives of penguins in Antarctica? HTTPS://WRITINGCENTER.GMU.EDU/GUIDES/HOW-TO-WRITE-A-RESEARCH-QUESTION Sample research questions Which of the following research question has an appropriate level of complexity? How are doctors addressing diabetes in the U.S.? What main environmental, behavioral, and genetic factors predict whether Americans will develop diabetes, and how can these commonalities be used to aid the medical community in prevention of the disease? HTTPS://WRITINGCENTER.GMU.EDU/GUIDES/HOW-TO-WRITE-A-RESEARCH-QUESTION Research paper scaffold http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/lesson_images/lesson1155/scaffold.pdf Example research paper scaffold http://www.readwritethink.org/files/resources/lesson_images/lesson1155/example_scaffold.pdf Reading: Finding suitable resources Types of texts in academic papers: textbooks, Websites, Journal articles, official reports, newspapers, magazine articles, E-books, edited books, etc.) How these can be find? Using reading list Using library websites to search electronic resources Evaluating sources CRAAP Test is a widely-used method to evaluate a resource against a checklist of criteria. Currency: When was the information published or posted? Relevance: The importance of the information for your needs. Authority: The source of the information. Accuracy: The reliability, truthfulness and correctness of the content. Purpose: The reason the information exists. SOURCE: HTTPS://LIBRARY.CSUCHICO.EDU/HELP/SOURCE-OR-INFORMATION-GOOD Wikipedia: Wikipedia pages can be edited by anyone, which means that sometimes the information stated is not reliable. Online News Articles: When examining online news articles, find out what you can about the organization behind the articles. Evaluating digital sources Online Databases: the most reliable information you will find on the internet will come from online databases HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/CONDUCTING_RESEARCH/EVALUATING_SO URCES_OF_INFORMATION/EVALUATING_DIGITAL_SOURCES.HTML Using the CDU library When using the CDU library database: list out some possible keywords - a significant word or phrase - that would express your research question create a list of all possible synonyms for these key words Make use of Boolean operators (AND, OR , NOT) AND is used to combine two or more concepts OR is used to combine synonyms or words that are acceptable substitutes for each other; it helps expand your search and you will get more resources NOT is generally used to exclude those "false hits" Reading sources: developing a critical approach 1. Titles and subtitles 2. Text features a. Author b. Publication date and edition c. Abstract d. Contents e. Introduction: the reason for writing, the organization principle f. References Structure of abstracts 1. Background position 2. Aim and thesis of the paper 3. Method of research 4. Results of research Research Plan Working Title (1 Noun Phrase) ◦ Give a title to your research essay. Research Question (1 or two sentences) Motivation for This Research. ◦ 1 paragraph about why this topic is interesting to you and relevant to the world. Place of this research in current scholarship ◦ one or two sentences linking this topic to a chapter in a textbook or recent journal article. Research Plan Scope and Limitations of the Research ◦ Two or three sentences explaining what part of the topic you will study (i.e. what years, what countries, what industry…) Method(s) and Methodology ◦ What method(s) and methodology do you plan to use for your study? ◦ This study will be from a literature review of… Proposed Timetable ◦ What are the key deadlines you will need to meet in order to submit your research on time? How will you be allocating your time over the course of the semester? Research Plan Working Outline ◦ This should be a draft Table of Contents, including section headings and a sentence detailing what will be included in each section.) Introduction Subtopic 1 Subtopic 2 Subtopic 3 Summary and Conclusion Bibliography. Research Plan Starting Bibliography ◦ The three most important books or articles Self Care Strategy ◦ How will you care for your mental, physical, social and spiritual health as you do your studies? (1 paragraph) Harvard Referencing When using Harvard referencing, there are two stages for acknowledging an author: In-text citation is what you do in the text of your essay where you highlight the information and ideas incorporated for someone else's work Referencing is where you put all the information of the sources you used in a separate section References are written on a separate page headed by the title References, centred and bold References should be in alphabetical order by first named author, or title if there is no author Harvard Referencing Each of your references should be on a new line with double line spacing between each reference entry References should be left aligned All your references should have a matching in-text citation and vice versa Using in-text citation depends on whether you are quoting or paraphrasing information from a source. Direct quotation: you need to put quotation marks around the words. You have to indicate the source of information at the end. This includes the author(s)'s last name followed by a data and a page number. Paraphrased: you should include the author's surname and the year the source was published. Reporting verbs Presenting a case (believe, consider, say, suggest, think, argue, assert, claim, conclude, confirm, contend, insist, maintain, state, warn) Showing (demonstrate, explain, indicate, note, prove, reveal, show) Commenting on previously stated opinions (accept, agree, deny, doubt, admit) Negative or critical position (blame, condemn, criticize) Describing (characterize, classify, define, evaluate, identify, portray, present) Using in-text citation Paraphrasing & summarising sources Theory and research on impression management suggest that people may monitor the image that they provide of themselves to the audiences they address (Baumeister 1982; Leary & Kowalski 1990; Schlenker 1980) Citing a direct quote There seems to be a ‘consensus among researchers and policy makers that experiments constitute a gold standard in policy evaluation, although they are not a complete recipe for policy evaluation’ (Danielson 2007, pp. 381–382). HTTPS://LIBGUIDES.SCU.EDU.AU/HARVARD/CITING-IN-TEXT Using in-text citation Citing sources with no date If the publication date of a reference is unknown or unsure, cite it using n.d. (no date), e.g. XXXXXXXXXXXX (Smith n.d.) Smith (n.d.) maintains that…….. Citing a source if page numbers are not available (direct quotations) For example: As Myers (2000, para. 5) aptly phrased it… …………………………….(Beutler 2000, Conclusion, para. 1) [Tip: if your resource is a journal article in html format (and therefore with no page numbers), check to see if the article is available elsewhere as a pdf. Usually, pdf documents include page numbers.] HTTPS://LIBGUIDES.SCU.EDU.AU/HARVARD/CITING-IN-TEXT Using in-text citation Cite a source discussed in another source (secondary source) For example, if Lister cited Miller’s work in his/her research and you did not read Miller’s work, you should refer to Miller in text in the following way: David Miller’s simple definition of social justice (1999, cited in Lister 2007, p. 113) sums up … In the reference list, provide the details of the article you actually used (Lister): Lister, R 2007, 'Social justice: meanings and politics', Benefits, vol. 15, no. 2, pp. 113-25. HTTPS://LIBGUIDES.SCU.EDU.AU/HARVARD/CITING-IN-TEXT Activity: in-text citation Create an in-text citation for the following reference entry. Samuelson, W & Marks, SG 2015, Managerial economics, 9th edn., John Wiley & Sons, Inc. …… (Samuelson & Marks 2015) Samuelson and Marks (2015) maintain that ……… Create an in-text citation for the following reference entry. Patterson, J. 2005. Maximum ride. New York: Little, Brown …………..(Patterson 2005) Patterson (2005) claims that ……. Books & Ebooks Author, AA & Author, BB Year of publication, Title of book, Edition, Publisher. Single author Reference Deegan, C 2013, Financial accounting theory, McGraw-Hill Australia. In-text citation …………… (Deegan 2013) Deegan (2013) believes that ………….. 2 authors Reference Fletcher, R & Crawford, H 2016, International marketing: An Asia-Pacific perspective, 7th edn., Pearson Australia. In-text citation Fletcher and Crawford (2016) maintain that …… ‘...facilitator and inhibitor of international business’ (Fletcher & Crawford 2016, p. 60) Books & Ebooks No author Reference Employment the professional way: A guide to understanding the Australian job search process for professionally qualified migrants 2000, Australian Multicultural Foundation. In-text citation (Employment the professional way 2000) OR the book Employment the professional way (2000) includes arguments about…. Shorten title and put in italics For more information, refer to the CDU Harvard style guide. Journal Articles Author, AA & Author, BB Year of publication, 'Article title', Journal Title, vol., no./iss., p/pp. Single author Reference Mirvis, P 2012, 'Employee engagement and CSR: Transactional, relational and developmental approaches', California Management Review, vol. 54, no. 4, pp. 93-117. In-text citation ‘30 percent were dissatisfied, and 8 percent were outright disengaged’ (Mirvis 2012, p. 95). Mirvis (2012) points out that ……. Journal articles Multiple authors Reference Banke, R, Byzalov, D & Plehn-Dujowich, J 2014, 'Demand uncertainty and cost behaviour', Accounting Review, vol. 89, no. 3, pp. 839-855. In-text citation ... advantages such as fixed and higher variable costs (Banke et al. 2014) Banke et al. (2014) mention that …… Activity: finding a mistake Chuah, S, Hoffmann, R & Larner, J 2014, 'Chinese values and negotiation behaviour: A bargaining experiment', International Business Review, vol. 23, no. 6, pp. 1203-1211. What is the mistake in this reference entry? Samuelson, W & Marks, SG (2015), Managerial economics, 9th edn., John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Find two mistakes in the above reference entry. Using referencing to emphasize different aspects of academic sources Emphasizing the information in your sources rather than the author Although the law overlaps with ethics, it usually only regulates the lowest level of acceptable behavior (Crane and Mattern 2007). Emphasizing both the information and the author Research has indicated that job satisfaction is linked to regulating emotion (Cote & Mogan 2002; Barrik 2002). Emphasizing the author Wolf (2008) shares his view and Prindl and Prodham (1994) also suggest that … What went wrong? According to (Reynolds 2000) there is no strong evidence of long-term damage to health. According to Padash 2000 there is no strong evidence of long-term damage to health. George Marchais (1984) discusses three main factors. Smoking and related illnesses cause over 500,000 deaths annually in the UK. Plagiarism How to avoid accidental plagiarism No reference = all you It’s all or nothing when paraphrasing Change almost everything except key terms or change nothing and use it as a quotation Putting a source into your own words is good but not giving it a reference is bad One reference is often not enough Example: Dickinson (2009) argues that the language translation industry, for example translation brochures and websites, is a key to helping Britain recover from recession. He also stresses the importance of hiring professional translators. How to avoid accidental plagiarism An assignment that has too much quotation Don’t give the impression that you have read something when you haven’t Opponents of the concept of ethics in business include those who claim that making a profit is the only responsibility a business has to society (Friedman 1970, cited in Fisher and Lovell 2003) Writing a definition Simple definitions Word Category Application An agenda is a set of issues to be discussed in a meeting. A grant is a sum of money given for a specific purpose. A seminar is an academic class meeting with a tutor for study. BAILEY, S. 2018, ACADEMIC WRITING: A HANDBOOK FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS (5TH ED.). NEW YORK: ROUTLEDGE. Writing a definition Complex definitions Quote from another writer Example: Bowlby (1982) suggested that attachment is an organized system whose goal is to make individuals feel safe and secure. A variety of relevant situations Example: The definition of a failed project ranges from abandoned projects to projects that do not meet their full potential or simply have schedule overrun problems. Process explanation Example: Development is a socio-economic-technological process having the main objective of raising the standards of living of the people. BAILEY, S. 2018, ACADEMIC WRITING: A HANDBOOK FOR INTERNATIONAL STUDENTS (5TH ED.). NEW YORK: ROUTLEDGE. Paraphrasing Paraphrasing is one way to use a text in your own writing without directly quoting source material Your own version of essential information and ideas expressed by someone else, presented in a new form A more detailed restatement than a summary, which focuses concisely on a single main idea Paraphrasing is a valuable skill because... ◦ It is better than quoting information HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/USING_RESEARCH/QUOTING_PARAP HRASING_AND_SUMMARIZING/PARAPHRASING.HTML Techniques for paraphrasing Changing vocabulary by using synonyms Example: argues > claims; prize > awards; anarchy > chaos Changing word forms Example: Explanation > explain; analyse > analysis; extend > extensive Changes in structure Example: medical services are coming under pressure as a result of people living longer. > People are living so much longer that medical services are coming under pressure. PATERSON, K. 2013, OXFORD GRAMMAR FOR EAP, OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, OXFORD. Steps for effective paraphrasing Reread the original passage until you understand its full meaning. Set the original aside, and write your paraphrase on a piece of paper/Word document. Check your version with the original to make sure that your version accurately expresses all the essential information in a new form. Use quotation marks to identify any unique term you have borrowed exactly from the source. Record the source (including the page) on your note card so that you can credit it easily if you decide to incorporate the material into your paper. HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/USING_RESEARCH/QUOTING_PARAP HRASING_AND_SUMMARIZING/PARAPHRASING.HTML Example Original text Students frequently overuse direct quotation in taking notes, and as a result they overuse quotations in the final [research] paper. Probably only about 10% of your final manuscript should appear as directly quoted matter. Therefore, you should strive to limit the amount of exact transcribing of source materials while taking notes. Lester, J 1976, Writing Research Papers. 2nd ed., pp. 46-47. Paraphrase In research papers, students often quote excessively, failing to keep quoted material down to a desirable level. Since the problem usually originates during note taking, it is essential to minimize the material recorded verbatim (Lester 1976). HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/USING_RESEARCH/QUOTING_PARAP HRASING_AND_SUMMARIZING/PARAPHRASING.HTML Original text Because of the complexity of homelessness from a social policy and service delivery perspective, there are a wide range of views on what constitutes homelessness. Definitions of homelessness are culturally and historically contingent. They range from limited objective measures which conflate homelessness with rooflessness to more subjective definitions founded on culturally and historically determined ideas of ‘home’. Paraphrasing A Homelessness is complicated from both policy-making and service delivery points of view. For this reason, there are many different opinions on what homelessness means. Characterisations of homelessness are linked to culture and history. They encompass both narrow objective views which define being homeless as being roofless, and more personal definitions based on cultural and historical understandings of 'home' (ABS 2012). Paraphrasing B A multi-faceted concept, homelessness can be defined in a variety of ways, most simply as the basic lack of shelter. However, our understanding of what constitutes a ‘home’ is also informed by our culture and history. This complexity impacts the development of effective policy and services to address homelessness (ABS 2012). HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITING-ASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/PARAPHRASING-SUMMARISING-AND-QUOTING Summarising Summarising means briefly outlining the main points of a reading in your own words without adding your own ideas or changing the author’s meaning. Here is how to summarise: ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ Similar to paraphrasing, the first step is to read the original text and get a full grasp of it. When reading, ask yourself: What is the overall message? What are the key points? Concentrate on the essentials and leave out details and examples. Put the source aside and state its key points in your own words. Finally, proofread, revise and edit your summary as necessary. HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITING-ASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/PARAPHRASINGSUMMARISING-AND-QUOTING What to include in a summary? Your summary should include the following: 1. a topic sentence; including the author's last name and date of publication and the main point of the article. 2. 5-7 supporting sentences that prove the main point. 3. a concluding sentence that reinforce the main point of the article. Original text With respect to daily intakes of specific micronutrients, 40% of adolescent girls and 8% of adolescent boys were at risk for inadequate intakes of iron. While protein intakes were adequate in these subpopulations, the top two sources of iron were from plant-based, iron fortified sources (breakfast cereals and breads and bread rolls). With regard to higher iron bioavailability and density, animal-based protein sources may be another strategy to address iron intake, particularly among females, as it has been previously shown to be a less popular food choice among Australian children and adolescents and avoided by young female adults (Fayet-Moore et al., 2017). Summary Fayet-Moore et al. (2017) found that 40% of adolescent girls, compared to 8% of boys, are likely to have an inadequate amount of iron in their diets, in spite of a sufficient protein intake. They attribute this to a tendency to avoid foods derived from animals. HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITING-ASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/PARAPHRASINGSUMMARISING-AND-QUOTING Quoting Quoting means repeating the author’s exact words. Some situations which might justify direct quoting could be: ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ the author has devised and named a new theory, model, concept, technique or scale the author has provided a definition of a concept the author’s words have unusual impact and would be difficult to express in any other way the author is a notable authority on the subject and their words will lend weight to your argument Keep the quote as brief as possible and integrate it into the development of your argument or discussion. All quotes require page numbers in the citation. HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITING-ASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/PARAPHRASINGSUMMARISING-AND-QUOTING Synthesizing resources Synthesis is putting together your sources that agree or disagree and try to draw broader conclusions. Note that synthesizing is not the same as summarizing. ◦ A summary restates the information in one or more sources without providing new insight or reaching new conclusions. ◦ A synthesis draws on multiple sources to reach a broader conclusion. In order to successfully synthesize your sources, you might begin by grouping your sources by topic and looking for connections. Construct your body paragraphs in a way that acknowledges different sources and highlights where you can draw new conclusions. HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/CONDUCTING_RESEARCH/RESEARCH_OVERVIEW/SYNTHESIZING_SOURCES.HTML Example Parents are always trying to find ways to encourage healthy eating in their children. Ben-Joseph, a doctor and writer for KidsHealth, encourages parents to be role models for their children by not dieting or vocalizing concerns about their body image. The first popular diet began in 1863. Banting named it the “Banting” diet after himself, and it consisted of eating fruits, vegetables, meat, and dry wine. Despite the fact that dieting has been around for over a hundred and fifty years, parents should not diet because it hinders children’s understanding of healthy eating. HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/CONDUCTING_RESEARCH/RESEARCH_OVERVIEW/SYNTHESIZING_SOURCES.HTML Example Parents are always trying to find ways to encourage healthy eating in their children. Different scientists and educators have different strategies for promoting a well-rounded diet while still encouraging body positivity in children. Just and Price (2009) suggest in their article “Using Incentives to Encourage Healthy Eating in Children” that children are more likely to eat fruits and vegetables if they are given a reward. Similarly, BenJoseph, a doctor and writer for Kids Health, encourages parents to be role models for their children. She states that “parents who are always dieting or complaining about their bodies may foster these same negative feelings in their kids. Try to keep a positive approach about food” (Ben-Joseph 2000 p.90). Nepper and Chai (2012) support Ben-Joseph’s suggestions in their article “Parents’ Barriers and Strategies to Promote Healthy Eating among School-age Children.” Nepper and Chai note, parents felt that patience, consistency, educating themselves on proper nutrition, and having more healthy foods available in the home were important strategies when developing healthy eating habits for their children. By following some of these ideas, parents can help their children develop healthy eating habits while still maintaining body positivity. HTTPS://OWL.PURDUE.EDU/OWL/RESEARCH_AND_CITATION/CONDUCTING_RESEARCH/RESEARCH_OVERVIEW/SYNTHESIZING_SOURCES.HTML Types of Synthesis The explanatory synthesis: Wilson (2009) and Smith (2011) state that by providing continual exposure to appropriate listening material can improve acquisition. The effectiveness of these cognitive, metacognitive and socicognitive strategies are wellstudied (O’Malley & Chamot 1990; Goh 2002; Lynch & Mendelsohn 2002; Miller 2005) The argument synthesis: …they need what is called ‘comprehensible input’ (Krashen 1982). However, the opposing argument here, is highlighted by Blake (2008, p. 19), who questions what constitutes to ‘comprehensible input’. HTTPS://WWW.ACADEMIC-ENGLISHUK.COM/SYNTHESIS Example Using assignment essays for assessment supports learning better than the traditional examination system. It is considered that course-work assignment essays can lessen the extreme stress experienced by some students over ‘sudden death’ end of semester examinations and reduce the failure rate (Langdon 2016; Jones 2018). Study skills research by Jones et al. (2014), UCL (2016) and Peters (2018) support assessment by assignment because research assignments can be used to assess student learning mid-course and so provide them with helpful feedback. They also consider that assignment work lends itself to more critical approaches which help the students to learn the discourse of their subjects. In contrast, Abbot (2008) and Cane (2018) both argue that assignments are inefficient, costly to manage and are the cause of plagiarism problems in universities. A key argument is that “assessment by examination is a clean-cut approach as you obtain students’ knowledge under supervised circumstances” (Bable 2008, p.20). The weight of evidence, however, would suggest that it is a fairer and more balanced approach to have some assessment by assignment rather than completely by examinations. HTTPS://WWW.ACADEMIC-ENGLISHUK.COM/SYNTHESIS Synthesis Explained Synthesis questions (Reading tutorials) 1. How many sources are mentioned in the X section? 2. Which writer examines the X argument? 3. What was the main argument of X’s study? 4. Which writer looked at X? 5. Why do you think page numbers are given for X author? 6. Summaries the different points made by each of the X sources cited. Structure & sequence Sections Ideas & Arguments Words Introduction State the main issues you will deal with in the paper 10%-15% Main body Readings, lecture 70%-80% Conclusion This is not a summary of all the points made in paper but it should state what you believe to be reasonable conclusions based on the arguments made. It is important to relate the conclusions to the question 10%-15% (Adapted from Nottingham Trent University, Academic Writing Information Sheet) Paragraph structure Most paragraphs in an essay have a three-part structure—introduction, body, and conclusion Introduction: the first section of a paragraph should include the topic sentence and any other sentences at the beginning of the paragraph that give background information. Body: follows the introduction discusses the controlling idea, using facts, arguments, analysis, examples, and other information. Conclusion: the final section summarizes the connections between the information discussed in the body of the paragraph and the paragraph’s controlling idea. HTTPS://WTS.INDIANA.EDU/WRITING-GUIDES/PARAGRAPHS-AND-TOPIC-SENTENCES.HTML Topic sentences Every paragraph in your paper needs a topic sentence. The topic sentence expresses what the paragraph is about. It should include two key things: The topic of the paragraph The central point of the paragraph. Example: Research has consistently shown that the effective conflict management has a significant workplace relationship impact. HTTPS://WTS.INDIANA.EDU/WRITING-GUIDES/PARAGRAPHS-AND-TOPIC-SENTENCES.HTML Ways to support an argument Statistics Examples Expert opinions Reporting on experiments and case studies SOURCE: HTTPS://WWW.UMT.EDU/WRITINGCENTER/DOCS/RESOURCESFORWRITERS/WAYSTOSUPPORTANARGUMENT.PDF Counterarguments What is included in a counterargument paragraph? 1. Identify the opposing argument. 2. Respond to it by discussing the reasons the argument is incomplete, weak, unsound, or illogical. 3. Provide examples or evidence to show why the opposing argument is unsound, or provide explanations of how the opposing argument is incomplete or illogical. 4. Close by stating your own argument and why your argument is stronger than the identified counterargument. Sample: https://writingcenter.ashford.edu/sites/default/files/inlinefiles/Sample%20Counterargument%20Paragraph.pdf HTTPS://WRITINGCENTER.ASHFORD.EDU/COUNTERARGUMENT Coherence Each sentence relates clearly to the topic sentence Each sentence flows smoothly into the next without obvious shifts or jumps. Techniques to establish a coherent paragraph 1. Repeat key words or phrases 2. Create parallel structures 3. Use transition words or phrases between sentences and between paragraphs SOURCE: HTTPS://WTS.INDIANA.EDU/WRITING-GUIDES/PARAGRAPHS-AND-TOPICSENTENCES.HTML Example Credit cards are convenient, but dangerous. People often get them in order to make large purchases easily without saving up lots of money in advance. This is especially helpful for purchases like cars, kitchen appliances, etc., that you may need to get without delay. However, this convenience comes at a high price: interest rates. The more money you put on your credit card, the more the bank or credit union will charge you for that convenience. If you're not careful, credit card debt can quickly break the bank and leave you in very dire economic circumstances! SOURCE: HTTPS://LITERARYTERMS.NET/COHERENCE/ Writing the introduction The introduction should include four elements: General sentence which introduces the general topic, background information, reasons for controversy. Specific sentence what is the main topic, definition (if applicable) Thesis statement (the main argument that the essay/research paper will be based on) Outline (the subsections of the paper, which aspects of the topic will be the focus of the research paper) General sentence Specific sentence Thesis statement Outline HTTPS://WWW.ACADEMIC-ENGLISHUK.COM/THESIS-STATEMENTS Thesis statement How to tell a strong thesis from a weak one? A strong thesis statement takes some sort of stand (viewpoint) There are some negative and positive aspects to the Banana Herb Tea Supplement. Because Banana Herb Tea Supplement promotes rapid weight loss that results in the loss of muscle and lean body mass, it poses a potential danger to customers. A strong thesis statement justifies discussion My family is an extended family. While most American families would view blood-related marriage as a threat to the nuclear family structure, many Iranian families, like my own, believe that these marriages help reinforce kinship ties in an extended family. PRODUCED BY WRITING TUTORIAL SERVICES, INDIANA UNIVERSITY, BLOOMINGTON, IN SOURCE: HTTP:WWW.INDIANA.EDU/~WTS/PAMPHLETS/THESIS_STATEMENT.SHTML Thesis statement A strong thesis statement expresses one main idea Companies need to exploit the marketing potential of the Internet, and Web pages can provide both advertising and customer support Because the Internet is filled with tremendous marketing potential, companies should exploit this potential by using Web pages that offer both advertising and customer support. A strong thesis statement is specific World hunger has many causes and effects. Hunger persists in Glandelinia because jobs are scarce and farming in the infertile soil is rarely profitable. PRODUCED BY WRITING TUTORIAL SERVICES, INDIANA UNIVERSITY, BLOOMINGTON, IN SOURCE: HTTP:WWW.INDIANA.EDU/~WTS/PAMPHLETS/THESIS_STATEMENT.SHTML Sequencing language Verbs, such as start, begin, move on to, follow, finish, conclude Words and phrases such as firstly, first of all, in the second part, next, then, finally, lastly, in conclusion Example: First of all, this essay will define the strategies for expansion beyond the country of origin, globalisation, internationalisation, and 'worldification'. Then, it will identify examples of each of these in the strategies of well-known companies. Next, it will move on to an evaluation of the value added by each model. Lastly, the essay will conclude with ..... PATERSON, K. 2013, OXFORD GRAMMAR FOR EAP, OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, OXFORD. 5 Easy steps to write a thesis statement Make a Thesis Question Example: Divorce. Thesis Question: How does divorce affect children? Brainstorm Answers Example: Divorce causes children to feel insecure about the future, not do as well in school, feel insecure in relationships, worry about their parents, become bullies or be bullied, have to get along with a new family of siblings, have a lower standard of living, wonder if they caused the divorce. Pick a Thesis Answer Example: How does divorce affect children? Divorce causes children to feel insecure. SOURCE: HTTPS://OWLCATION.COM/HUMANITIES/EASY-WAYS-TO-WRITE-A-THESIS-STATEMENT-FOR-AN-ESSAY 5 Easy steps to write a thesis statement Make a Thesis Road Map Example: How does divorce affect children? Divorce causes children to feel insecure because they often have a lower standard of living after the divorce, they feel less secure in relationships, and they worry about the future. Add Emphasis Example: How does divorce affect children? Although some people argue that children quickly get over a parent's split, in reality, divorce causes children to feel insecure for a long time afterwards because they often have a lower standard of living after the divorce, they feel less secure in relationships, and they worry about the future. SOURCE: HTTPS://OWLCATION.COM/HUMANITIES/EASY-WAYS-TO-WRITE-A-THESIS-STATEMENT-FOR-AN-ESSAY Conclusion The conclusion normally starts with ‘In conclusion’ or ‘To sum up’ and should include the following: Restatement of your thesis statement Summary of the major points Research Outlines Outlining using a topic sentence for each paragraph Introduction i. begins with discussion of your specific topic (not a broad background overview) ii. provides just enough context (definitions of key terms, for example) to prepare your readers for your thesis or purpose statement. Thesis statement i. comes at the end of your introduction and state clearly and concisely what the purpose or central argument of your paper is. The introduction prepares your reader for this statement, and the rest of the paper follows in support of it. HTTPS://ACADEMICGUIDES.WALDENU.EDU/WRITINGCENTER/WRITINGPROCESS/OUTLINING Research outlines Review of literature should be divided into sections and subsections that answer your research question(s) Conclusion i. restates your paper's major claim and ties that claim into a larger discussion. ii. Rather than simply reiterating each major and minor point, quickly revisit your thesis statement and focus on ending the paper by tying your thesis into current research in your field, next steps for other researchers, your broader studies, or other future implications. HTTPS://ACADEMICGUIDES.WALDENU.EDU/WRITINGCENTER/WRITINGPROCESS/OUTLINING Structure of a report 1. Title page 2. Table of contents 3. Introduction 4. Body, use headings, subheadings and numbering 5. Conclusion Voice in Writing 1. Make your unattributed (not referenced) assertion at the start of paragraphs followed by evidence, findings, arguments from your sources. Example: "To date there is no well-established tool to measure divided attention in children. Current methods used to assess divided attention usually involve a variation of the CPT with an additional task included e.g. counting or listening to auditory stimuli (Salthouse, 2003)." 2. Explicitly tell your reader what the connections are between sources. Example: "Smith (2009), however, takes a different approach..." SOURCE: HTTPS://LIBRARY.LEEDS.AC.UK/INFO/14011/WRITING/106/ACADEMIC_WRITING/8 Voice in writing 3. Use language to show your strong agreement/disagreement/cautious agreement with sources. Example: "Smith's (2009) findings show a clear...A serious weakness with this argument is...The research suggests..." 4. Include "so what" summary sentences (evaluative sentences) at the end of paragraphs. Example: "This shows that it is detrimental to strictly categorise chronological periods with artistic genres, as many art historians suggest different movements were taking place in separate geographical locations at the same time." SOURCE: HTTPS://LIBRARY.LEEDS.AC.UK/INFO/14011/WRITING/106/ACADEMIC_WRITING/8 Advanced ways to show your attitude Agreeing with an author: acknowledges affirms analyses applauds argues contends explains identifies observes persuades proves supports HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF Advanced ways to show your attitude Disagreeing with an author: accuses alleges apologises speculates Asserts comments doubts guesses hopes questions HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF Advanced ways to show your attitude Perhaps you don’t feel positive or negative about the source you are citing. In this situation, you should use a neutral reporting verb. accepts acknowledges adds agrees assures claims concludes confirms describes expresses maintains recognizes reports says thinks HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF The grammar of reporting verbs Pattern 1: Verb + Noun (noun phrase) The authors show the devastating results of this policy (Smith & Jones 2008, p. 12). Gillard (2012) indicated her negative opinion of Abbott’s proposal. Pinker (2002) frequently approves of Chomsky’s theories. Pattern 2: Verb + That + clause (i.e. sentence) The authors show that this policy had devastating results (Smith & Jones 2008, p. 12). Gillard (2012) indicated that Abbott’s proposal was indefensible in her opinion. HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF Tense Reporting verbs are normally present simple – especially for recent articles and books: Turner (2010) states that the modern state wields more power in new ways. However, use the past tense if presenting the results of past research – even in recent literature: The groups observed during the research showed a range of leadership styles (Kang 2006). HTTPS://WWW.UTS.EDU.AU/SITES/DEFAULT/FILES/REPORTING%20VERBS%20REFERENCE%20SHEE T.PDF Common errors in critical writing Conclusion given before the evidence or argument Ethical behavior is not compatible with successful business practice. This essay will look at the reasons why… Opinion that is then presented as fact Animal testing is thought by some to be necessary. This essay will argue that even though such testing is currently needed, we should put more effort into finding alternative methods for testing new drugs. Empty, circular argument The government should instigate an “opt out” system of organ donation. This will ensure that a person’s organs are automatically available for donation unless they have specified otherwise. Therefore, this legislation should be introduced as soon as possible. Common errors in critical writing Assumption of a causal connection Children who play violent computer games commit more violent acts; therefore, the violence portrayed in computer games causes violent behavior in children. Steps in reasoning that do not follow logically Identity theft is increasing, therefore the government should introduce identity cards. Statements that do not analyse in enough detail The growth in international trade requires improved legislation to control worldwide monopolies. Overgeneralisation or vague statements Men are stronger than women Portable technology is used by everyone nowadays. Using first person pronouns in academic writing Use the first person pronoun to … Example …to organize the text and guide the reader through your argument In this paper, I will argue that… First, I outline the development of… We conclude that… … to report methods, procedures, and steps We analyzed… undertaken. I interviewed… … to signal your position in a debate or contrast your claims with another source. Contrary to this theory, our findings suggest that… However, I contend that… How to avoid first-person pronouns First-person sentence Revision Revised sentence I interviewed 20 students. Use 3rd person The researcher interviewed 20 students. We argue that the teaching method should be refined further. Use a different subject This paper argues that the teaching method should be refined further. I checked the dataset for missing data. Use passive voice The dataset was checked for missing data. Expressing levels of certainty and caution Verb phrases Certainty The data show The findings indicate/ suggest/tend to show The data seem/ appear to There appears/ seems to be This might/may/could indicate This would seem to/appear to Caution Expressing levels of certainty and caution Adverb/verb phrases Certainty This strongly/certainly/definitely suggests This almost certainly/definitely suggests/ shows This essay would strongly suggest This perhaps suggests Caution Expressing levels of certainty and caution Adjectives/Noun phrases Certainty This proves with absolute certainty It is almost certainly/it is highly probable There is a good/strong/definite possibility It is probably/likely There is a tendency for It is possible There is a slight/small possibility Caution MQO004 Features of academic writing Academic writing in English is linear, which means it has one central point or theme with every part contributing to the main line of argument, without repetitions. Its objective is to inform rather than entertain. There are ten main features of academic writing that are often discussed. Academic writing is to some extent: complex, formal, objective, explicit, hedged, and responsible. It uses language precisely and accurately. It is also well organised and planned. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Complexity Written language is relatively more complex than spoken language (Biber, 1988; Biber, Johansson, Leech, Conrad & Finegan, 1999; Chafe, 1982; Cook, 1997; Halliday,1989). Written language is grammatically more complex than spoken language. It has more subordinate clauses, more "that/to" complement clauses more long sequences of prepositional phrases more adjectives more passives than spoken language. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Formality In general this means in an essay that you should avoid: colloquial words and expressions; ""stuff", "a lot of", "thing", "sort of", “like” abbreviated forms: "can't", "doesn't", "shouldn’t” two word verbs: "put off", "bring up" sub-headings, numbering and bullet-points in formal essays - but use them in research paper. asking questions. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Precision (content) In academic writing you need to be precise when you use information, dates or figures. Do not use "a lot of people" when you can say "50 million people". Examples: Example 1 Chinese are Buddhist. They go to the temple five times a year, live simple lives, and give money to charity. Example 2 Many Chinese are Buddhists. Practising Buddhists go to the temple about five times a year, generally try to live simple lives, and give money to charity when they can. HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITING-ASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/CLEARCOMMUNICATION/WRITING-CLEARLY-CONCISELY-AND-PRECISELY Precision HTTPS://WWW.MONASH.EDU/RLO/RESEARCH-WRITINGASSIGNMENTS/WRITING/CLEAR-COMMUNICATION/WRITING-CLEARLYCONCISELY-AND-PRECISELY Objectivity This means that the main emphasis should be on the information that you want to give and the arguments you want to make, rather than you. Nobody really wants to know what you "think" or "believe". They want to know what you have studied and learned and how this has led you to your various conclusions. In general, avoid words like "I", "me", "myself". Don't write:" In my opinion, this a very interesting study." Write: "This is a very interesting study." Avoid "you" to refer to the reader or people in general. Don't write: "You can easily forget how different life was 50 years ago." Write: "It is easy to forget how difficult life was 50 years ago." HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Objectivity 1. Compare these two paragraphs: The question of what constitutes "language proficiency" and the nature of its cross-lingual dimensions is also at the core of many hotly debated issues in the areas of bilingual education and second language pedagogy and testing. Researchers have suggested ways of making second language teaching and testing more "communicative" (e.g., Canale and Swain, 1980; Oller, 1979b) on the grounds that a communicative approach better reflects the nature of language proficiency than one which emphasizes the acquisition of discrete language skills. We don't really know what language proficiency is but many people have talked about it for a long time. Some researchers have tried to find ways for us to make teaching and testing more communicative because that is how language works. I think that language is something we use for communicating, not an object for us to study and we remember that when we teach and test it. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Explicitness Academic writing is explicit in several ways. It is explicit in its signposting of the organisation of the ideas in the text (Biber, Johansson, Leech, Conrad & Finegan, 1999, pp. 880-882). For example, if you want to tell your reader that your line of argument is going to change, make it clear. The Bristol 167 was to be the largest aircraft ever built in Britain. However, even by the end of the war, the design had run into serious difficulties. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Accuracy (Vocabulary & Grammar) In academic writing you need to be accurate in your use of vocabulary. Choose the correct word, for example, "meeting", "assembly" , "gathering" or "conference". Or from: "money", "cash", "currency", "capital" or "funds". You also need to be accurate in your use of grammar. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Hedging HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Hedging HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Hedging-Examples Compare the following: It may be said that the commitment to some of the social and economic concepts was less strong than it is now. The commitment to some of the social and economic concepts was less strong than it is now. There are certainly cases where this would seem to have been the only possible method of transmission. There are cases where this would have been the only possible method of transmission. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Responsibility In academic writing you are responsible for demonstrating an understanding of the source text. You must also be responsible for, and must be able to provide evidence and justification for, any claims you make. This is done by paraphrasing and summarising what you read and acknowledging the source of this information or ideas by a system of citation. HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Organisation Academic writing is well organised. It flows easily from one section to the next in a logical fashion. A good place to start is the genre of your text. Once you have decided on the genre, the structure is easily determined. Looking at typical structures can help you with your organisation HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Planning Academic writing is well planned. It usually takes place after research and evaluation, according to a specific purpose and plan. The following procedure is typical when writing an extended essay or assignment: Read the question or brief and understand what you are required to do Think about what you know and write it down in some way Go to the library or a database and find relevant books, articles or websites Find the books on your reading list - if you have one - and study them Make notes on these books and articles Organise your piece of work HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM Planning-continued Type or write your first draft Discuss your first draft informally with friends, other members of your class and your lecturer if possible Revise your first draft, bearing in mind any comments that were made in your discussions and produce your second draft Proofread your draft Produce a final typed version HTTP://WWW.UEFAP.COM/WRITING/FEATURE/FEATFRAM.HTM