Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 MENDEL UNIVERSITY Business Economic Faculty 1 BACHELOR THESIS RED BULL STRATEGIC MARKET MANAGEMENT Written by Margaux Baïs Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 TABLE OF CONTENTS: 1. INTRODUCTION 2 2. OBJECTIVE AND METHODOLOGY 3. RESULTS a. MARKET ANALYSIS b. INTERNAL ANALYSIS c. EXTERNAL ANALYSIS d. COMPETITORS ANALYSIS e. ANALYSIS OF CURRENT BRAND POSITIONING AND SEGMENTATION STRATEGIES f. A REVIEW OF BRAND AND COMMUNICATION STRATEGIES g. DISTRIBUTION STRATEGY 4. MIX MARKETING 5. DISCUSSION a. THINKING ABOUT STRATEGY b. THINKING ABOUT THE FUTURE STRATEGY 6. CONCLUSION 7. REFERENCES Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 1. INTRODUCTION Red Bull GmbH, Salzburg produces the world‟s leading energy drink. Red Bull is exclusively produced in Austria and exported globally to more than 160 countries. With 4 billion cans sold in 2009, it is the most consumed energy drink in the world. Red Bull has a market ranging from 70 to 90 percent across one hundred nations and has been copied by almost 100 competitors, among them Coca-Cola. No one has ever succeeded in taking its market share away or have even come close to reach the targets met by Red Bull. It‟s an empire of 2 billion Euros, which is based on a strategy of buzz - marketing to attract consumers in exclusive events and supporting many famous athletes worldwide. Red Bull GmbH was founded in 1984 by Dietrich Mateschitz. Mateschitz was a frequent visitor to Asia and was intrigued by the Thai „tonic drink‟ Krating Daeng; popular among cab drivers and other blue collar workers. The formula for the beverage was not protected by any patent, so Mateschitz began to open his own business which aimed to raise awareness and introduce the energy drinks globally. He fine-tuned the product for a western palate, developed a unique marketing concept and started selling Red Bull Energy Drink on the Austrian market in 1987. Red Bull got off the ground in no time flat, giving people wings right from the start. In 1992, Red Bull touched down in its first foreign market, Hungary. Today, Red Bull is energizing 160 countries around the globe. Red Bull continued its global expansion into Germany in 1992, the UK in 1994 and the all important United States market in 1997. It was marketed to Americans as a noncorporate alternative to Coke and Pepsi, and both packaging and pricing helped set it apart. Red Bull is much more than a soft drink – it is an energy drink. In short it vitalizes body and mind. The systematic marketing campaign practiced since the beginning has been vital and indispensible in its long term success. The Red Bull brand image is characterized by individuality, innovation, competence and non-conformism. These brand values are all reflected in the brand communication, characterized by self-confidence, a fresh and witty approach and unique identity, as well as self-irony. The Red Bull theme: “Energy” versus it‟s positioning: “Vitalizes Body and Mind”. 3 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Number of Cans Sold (Bn) 4,5 4 3,5 3 2,5 2 1,5 1 0,5 0 number of cans sold 1997 1998 2006 2007 2008 2009 The mutation of sales from 1997 to 1998 stems from Red Bulls introduction to the U.S. market. 2007 sales were up 17% to 3bn euro due to an accelerated performance of the product in Africa/ South America and Asia. Red Bull‟s popularity soared again in 2008 following sponsorship of extreme sports teams. 2008 sales rose with the introduction of Red Bull cola to the U.S. and European markets. Sales have increased from 2009 to now as a result of introduction of Red Bull shots to the functional drinks market. 4 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 2. OBJECTIVES AND METHODOLOGY Red Bulls adopts a diversification strategy and its competitive advantage lies in the Red Bull experience it offers. I chose Red Bull because it is a company facing a marketing challenge; not a sales challenge. I decided to base my focus on how does a premium good can help to stay leadership in really competed market. In order to enhance this relation, I mostly analyzed the Red Bull strategy. Red Bulls number one brand attribute is innovation and its challenge is to maintain that innovation. Where copycat brands have pushed beyond copying the product and are now copying marketing strategies, Red Bull needs to continue to differentiate itself through innovation and by maintaining its brand attributes: creative/ self-confident/ non-conformist/ self-ironic/ and unpredictable. Red Bull's current goal is to expand its presence further in the energy drinks market by capturing market share from the mature soft drinks market which was first introduced by industry giants like Coca Cola and PepsiCo. In this thesis most of the datas are from the year‟s 2009, actually it is quiet impossible to find the recent Red Bull‟s datas because multinational companies avoid to show up their numbers if they are not listed on the stock market. In fact if the results are public, competitors can have an idea of the firm‟s economic situation and thus big companies release the least amount as possible. So competitors can not have any idea of the firm health. After having introduced the Red Bull Company, I am going to consider the energy drink market. While remaining on the Red Bull example, I will proceed to an internal, external and a competitor analyze. Then I am going to study the current brand positioning and segmentation, to continue with a marketing mix study. After a review of brand communication and distributions strategies, I could finally expose a discussion about current and future strategies. 5 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 3. RESULTS MARKET ANALYSIS The energy-drink sector is relatively new and it was Red Bull who became the first mover and managed to define this market. Red Bull merits itself on creating a new market, different from the traditional soft drinks market that was pioneered by global giants Coca-cola and PepsiCo. What contributed to its unprecedented success was the launch of a new product through non-conventional practices. Red Bull‟s ideas were not focused on "classical marketing", but more on intuition, which enabled Red Bull to develop a marketing plan that was both complex and innovative. Starting from the analysis of the external environment, Red Bull managed to exploit a sub-sector of the carbonated soft drinks market. A gap existed in this soft drinks market for an energy drink that would have the same energizing properties as Krating Daeng; the Thai energy drink on which Red Bull modeled it‟s formula. Red Bull has not presented a product innovation within the soft drinks market, but has fulfilled a function different from the usual use of carbonated beverages. One can therefore say that Mateschitz has succeeded in creating a new business. Through technology and innovation he managed to meet a different function and create a segmented group of customers with a particular lifestyle. Having identified the market and thus the business, it was necessary to fully exploit the natural talent of Mateschitz to market, publicize and sell the new product. The challenge was to create a new focus for Red Bull that differed from solely relying on taste alone; an attribute which was constantly highlighted to promote the soft drinks market. In the beginning difficulties were plentiful, but they were soon overrun by the rapid growth in sales. In fact, the market did not feel the need for an energy drink; Red Bull had the ability to give birth to the need in potential customers. Red Bull has therefore implemented a strategy of focusing on one niche market and differentiating its offering from that of its competitors in the wider soft drinks market. This has allowed Red Bull to acquire a tremendous competitive strength in spite of reduced resources. Red Bull has managed over the years through unique branding innovation to make 6 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 the term energy drink synonymous with Red Bull. Even today the situation has not changed and competitors, despite massive investment and marketing research, cannot scratch the position of advantage gained over the years by Red Bull. In recent years all segments of the soft-drink industry recorded a contraction in sales and this has led the giants to invade the niche segment of energy drinks. The worldwide consumption of energy drinks increased in 2008 by 2% to 3.9 billion litres. In 2003 consumption amounted to 2 billion liters, almost doubling in five years. The average growth over the last five years was 14% per year. The slower growth in 2008 was a result of negative consumption in Asia, due to the economic crisis. North America is the leading region with 37% of global volume in 2008, followed by Asia-Pacific with 30% and Western Europe with 15%. Eastern Europe has realized the most significant gains in volume significantly over the past years and today this area represents a market share of over 6%. Asia Pacific was the only region to record a decline in 2008, with the decline in consumption by 18%. Sales decreased by as much as 41% in Thailand, mainly because of the economic crisis. The country's truck drivers, who are among the heaviest users of energy drinks, suffered many layoffs. 7 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 8 Turning to an analysis of the consumption of energy drinks at a European level, the above pie chart shows that countries who consume the most energy drinks are: the United Kingdom with 26.7%, Germany with 16.7% and Spain with 13%, these three countries alone make up 56% of the European market. The biggest growth market was France; this is ironic given the French governments ban on Red Bull until it was lifted in April 2008. Ireland holds the record with regard to per capita consumption (7.7 gallons of Red Bull per person each year). The average growth rate of consumption of energy drinks is estimated to be 8% for the next 5 years; consumption in 2012 is estimated to reach 700 million gallons in the European market alone. Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 INTERNAL ANALYSIS Marketing Analysis: The main product of Red Bull GmbH is Red Bull Energy Drink, a particular beverage that is an innovative mix of different and strong ingredients including caffeine, taurine, glucose, sucrose, B-group vitamin and glucronolactone. Red Bull is a product full of benefits; indeed it increases physical and mental performance, stimulates metabolism and improves concentration, reaction speed, vigilance and emotional status. These benefits are possible because Red Bull restores taurina, a necessary amino acid that is usually eliminated by the body in moments of heightened stress. Caffeine permits to better concentration and reaction speed. Metabolism is stimulated by Bgroup vitamin. Red Bull‟s main consumers are busy professional, athletes, drivers, stressed managers, students and “party enthusiasts” (Red Bull mixed with vodka, in fact, is one of the most popular drinks on the global club scene). In 2003, by changing only two ingredients, Red Bull created its second product: Red Bull Sugarfree, an energy drink that contains acesulfame K and aspartame, instead of glucose and sucrose. Red Bull Sugarfree allowed the company to reach a new consumer base: women and those health conscience customers who are concerned about their sugar intake. Recognizing that some consumers do not enjoy the taste of Red Bull but nonetheless consume it for its performance benefits, the Company focused the same amount of ingredients into a smaller quantity of beverage. Changing only the packaging, the concentrated, non-carbonated Red Bull Energy Shot was introduced to the global market in 2009 in both normal and sugar free versions. These shots are innovative in design and are handy for those who are on the go and require a quick boost of energy in a format that can conveniently fit in your bag, the same benefits with no hassle. Red Bull Cola, instead, was a totally innovative product. When Red Bull was asked “why this product?” the company answered “why not?” Indeed with this product the company was able to enter into a very competitive market in the wider soft drinks market, against the global leader Coca-Cola. Red Bull Cola differentiates itself from Coca-Cola by listing all the ingredients on the label and their competitive advantage is that all their ingredients are 100% natural. 9 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Value Chain Using Porters value chain, we can analyze the activities and relationships that give Red Bull its competitive advantage. Porter's value chain is composed of two types of activities: primary, which include inbound logistics and outbound logistics, operation, marketing and sales and services and secondary activities which include human resources management, firm infrastructure, procurement and technological development. The inbound logistics is not a source of competitive advantage for the Red Bull. The logistics industry output distributes products to present at national subsidiaries involved in the distribution to individual states. Operations are carried out in establishments which are all located in Austria. The first activity that is a source of competitive advantage for Red Bull is Sales and Marketing (“marketing operation”, which is responsible for managing the marketing-mix price, promotion, distribution and product-) EXTERNAL ANALYSIS Macro Environment Political and Legal Aspects Red Bull was marketed as a new product and through innovation succeeded in creating a new market; the functional energy drinks market. Initially healthcare organizations labeled Red Bull as a new drug because it contained controversial ingredients like taurine. To disprove these allegations, the ISME, in 1998 proved that Red Bull does not create any kind of addiction. Despite this, the energy drink needs to be approved by each country before entering its market and this approval process is often long and expensive. Only in 2008 was the ban on Red Bull lifted in the key European markets of France and Denmark. Red Bull‟s high levels of caffeine and taurine content violated food health and safety legislation there. Economical Aspect Red Bull is not very exposed to economic cycles as it is a special drink that targets a niche market. Included in this niche market are sports professionals, those who lead busy and 10 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 active lifestyles; essentially all those who require an energy boost. There are very few direct substitutes within the functional drinks market, and thanks to intensive advertising, Red Bull have positioned themselves as the world leader. Socio-Cultural Aspect 11 When Red Bull was first introduced to the market in 1987, society was reluctant to try new things. Nowadays however, thanks to a shift in the societal mindset, lifestyles have changed, and people are much more open to experimenting new and intriguing products on the market; particularly where they are marketed as fashionable and an essential in any Gen Y‟s hand. Research conducted by the ISME confidently proves this point. The resulting image for Red Bull is very fashionable and their market share has extended not only to bars but also nightclubs, where it has become a very popular vodka mixer. Technological Aspect Red Bull is produced entirely in Austria and from there is exported to all markets. There are two fundamental reasons for this: to ensure integrity of the brand and its flavor and to ensure global continuity is maintained. Environment The can is made of recycled aluminum and is therefore environmentally friendly. Since ethics and interest in environmental issues are increasingly important topics (and the European standards in this are always higher) this gives the company an additional competitive advantage over its competitors. Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 COMPETITOR ANALYSIS The market demand is being driven by the growing consumer awareness of the need for more active and healthier lifestyles. Red Bull holds a 70% share of the world market for energy drinks, or functional beverages. A category it was largely responsible for building. However to compare its performance against competitors we must analyse the markets on a local level. Direct Competitors: North America is the leading region within the energy drinks market with a 37% share of global volume. The energy drinks market in the US alone became a $5.4 billion dollar market in 2007, and Goldman Sachs predict that this will exceed $9 billion by 2011. The market share in the US is as follows: The U.S.A. 1,4 1,5 0,7 0,5 0,5 1 % Dollar Sales 0,44 0,4 0,4 2 Red Bull Monster 4 Rockstar 8 40 AMP Full Throttle 12,3 Doubleshot NOS 23 No Fear Private Label Red Bulls principle competitor in the United States market and indeed globally is Monster energy. Monster is distributed in the United States by the Coca-Cola company and maintained a 23% share in 2008, this was down from 27.3 % in 2007. Monster lost some of its share to Red Bull when it introduced Red Bull Cola to the market in mid 2008. Monster is however, the number one selling energy drink by volume in the United States, Red Bull maintains the number one selling brand by units. This is a direct result of Monsters larger can; retailing at 500ml versus Red Bulls famous 250ml can. Monster adopts a more low cost strategy and value proposition, advertising their product as “twice the size of Red Bull for the 12 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 same price”. Monster carries a three product folio; original, lo-carb and ripper. Monster has acted as a trend responder and attempted to follow the marketing innovation set by Red Bull by sponsoring the tech 3 Yamaha team for the 2009/2010 season. It has also expanded into the UK/Ireland/Spain and Australia. Rockstar is an energy drink created in 2001 and maintained 12,3% of the US market in 2008. It differentiates itself from the market leader Red Bull by offering twelve different flavours in over 20 countries. Like Monster, Rockstar uses a 16oz against Red Bulls 8oz and it markets itself as being better value. Rockstar switched distributors from Coca Cola to PepsiCo in Spring 2009 and benefits from the established distribution channel and shelf space that Pepsi offers. Like Monster, Rockstar also sponsors a range of events including the Mayhem festival; a U.S. touring metal and rock festival. Australia Asia Pacific follows North America as the 2nd leading region with a 30% share of the global market. Red Bulls main competitor in the critical Australian and New Zealand market is energy drink V, manufactured by Frucor. Together V and Red Bull account for 94% of sales. V is the market leader with 53% market share in Australia ahead of Red Bulls 41%. However, Neilson who compile these results do not capture on-premise sales in this category. Red Bull sell huge volumes on-premise and overall sell more cans in Australia . V is available in 5 varieties and has recently released 500 ml cans called “ V double hit”. Mother is an energy drink marketed to Australians and New Zealanders and is a new entrant to the Australasian market since 2008 by Coca-Cola. Coca-Cola undertook extensive market research to rejuvenate the competition dominated by Red Bull and V. Coca-Cola altered the formula of its original attempt and doubled its can size to 500ml, without affecting the cost. In 2009, Red Bull in order to compete with the new emerging trend of big boxes, published XXL Red Bull, a 473ml can. 13 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Europe The UK and Germany currently hold the largest markets for energy drinks in Europe, with combined sales in 2009 of $4.6 billion. Red Bull is the undisputed market leader in the UK with a market share of 60%, other players include Coca-Cola‟s Burn which was a new entrant in 2008, it has however made little or no impact on Red Bull‟s market share. Many UK super markets have launched their own brands of energy drinks at lower prices. These are mostly manufactured by US beverage maker Cott. Tesco sell KX (formerly known as kick), is sold in 250ml cans and 1L bottles, Sainsburys sell blue bolt, Asda sell Blue Charge. In Ireland the line is still blurred between functional energy drinks and sports nutrition drinks. For this reason, Lucozade remains the number one energy brand in the Irish market. C&C Ireland introduced Club Energise in 2005 and BPB was launched by Coca-Cola in 2003. In 2006 Club energise had 18.6% of the market, taking 14% from Lucozade. Powerade took 16.6% in the same year. As of June 2009 there were 250 energy shot brands in the USA with 5 Hour power owning 78% of the market share, its nearest rival is 6 hour power, manufactured by NVE Pharmaceuticals with 7%. These are Red Bulls main competitors in its new energy shots market. Indirect Competitors: In 2007 energy drink powders and effervescent tablets were introduced, in the form of a tablet. These can offer a more portable option to cans and shots. Red Bull‟s main competitor here is Berocca. Below, Red Bull‟s main global competitors can be categorised into three main global competitors: Coca-Cola Company, PepsiCo and Independent manufacturers. 14 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 ANALYSIS OF CURRENT BRAND POSITIONING AND SEGMENTATION STRATEGIES Red Bull positions itself as the innovator. Creating this perception amongst customers is easiest shown when it is based on product innovation. Perceived innovation can also be driven by indicators of leadership and energy. Strategic Position of Red Bull: Product Category: Red bull created a functional energy drink – to vitalise the mind. It targeted an edgier, more non-conformist type of person. Maintaining Relevance: Red Bull maintains relevance by continuing to be a trend driver and at times responder. Red Bull propelled the trends which defined the functional drinks category. It also recognised the energy shots trend and sustained success in this dynamic market. Functional benefits: Red Bull is unique in the soft drinks industry as a result of the attributes of its product, the presence of Taurine vitilises the body and mind. Organisational Intangibles: Red bull loves to make product claims, its core slogans include: “Gives you wiings” and “vitilizes body and mind.” Red Bulls segmentation focuses on its brand loyalty. Red Bull rewards its loyal customer by living up to expectations consistently, providing an ongoing relationship and offering extras that surprise and delight. 15 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 4. MARKETING MIX Product : Red Bull is a unique product. It is not a soft drink, it is an energy drink. Drinking Red Bull, the consumer can improve his/her performance, vigilance, and emotional status. The company invests some 30% of its year on year revenue to establish this strong concept about the product. The packaging is an essential aspect. It was a difficult and well-thought choice. The can is very different: it is higher and smaller (250ml) than its competitors. Red Bull pioneered the design which has become known as the sleek can. Marc Gobè, (president and CEO of the Desgrippes Gobé Group) calls it slim, sexy and powerful and he says that its “diminutive size only bolsters Red Bull's reputation as a concentrated experience.” Another important attraction of this packaging is that Red Bull looks like a product from a global economy. It doesn't look like a traditional American soft drink; it's not in a 12-ounce can, it's not sold in a bottle, and it doesn't have script lettering like Pepsi or Coke. It looks European. It was the first can with this form. It is easy to identify the product thanks to its innovative packaging. The most remarkable thing about Red Bull's can is that it is the company's only offering. Until 2003, Red Bull was one size, one color, one sticky, sweet taste (Mateschitz added carbon dioxide to give it the western taste). In addition the company chose the logo accurately. Indeed, Dietrich Mateschitz, the mind behind Red Bull, refused 50 projects before choosing the right one. The logo; two thicknecked crimson bulls in opposing charge against a yellow sun, was the symbol of kinetic virility and pugnacity. The leit motiv “Red Bull gives you wiings” is really strong. There are now different versions of the product: original, shots and light. The company reached a new target as a result of this diversification of its product. Indeed, with the light product, for example, the company conquers the consumer base that cares for their figure. Red Bull Cola is an important new entry. This new and innovative product cleverly contrasts the colossal Cola Coca. Red Bull Cola is manufactured with all natural ingredients. 16 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Price : The price is the only element of the marketing mix that gives profit. Red Bull uses the high price to differentiate the product from others direct and indirect competitors. Indeed, the price of a can of Red Bull is higher. The high price stresses the strategic position and differentiation in the market and the target of the product. In addition, the high price underlines the concept of the product: Red Bull is not a simple soft drink, it‟s an energy drink, a life-style, it improves your performance thanks to its unique ingredients (taurine) and quite simply “it gives you wiings!” Costumers buy Red Bull because they recognize the quality of it and the properties of Red Bull. As a consequence, the demand is not elastic to the price. Promotion: Red Bull has used three different systems of promotion: The first has been used since the beginning. The company utilized non-conventional marketing. It used unusual information channels, such as promoting extreme sports events. The firm couldn‟t support costs to have personalized stadiums so it sponsored the athletes of extreme and adventure-related sports, such as motor sports, mountain biking, snowboarding and dance music. With this system, the company promoted the brand directly to Generation Y, the socalled “millennials”: people born after 1981 who were believed to be cynical of usual marketing strategies. The company conquered these consumers also recruiting 'student brand managers' who would be hired to promote Red Bull on university campuses and educate this core market on the benefits of the product. Red Bull encouraged throwing parties at which Red Bull would be distributed. For Red Bull's target audience being authentic means being a little irreverent, a bit antiestablishment, and every bit different from your parents. In addition, cans of Red Bull were given out free to people on the street who had been identified as being in need of energy. The energy drink was given to club DJs and empty cans would be left on tables in strategic spots like trendy bars, clubs and pubs. The brand managers would report back to Red Bull, giving the company a low cost form of market research data. Red Bull has created a successful brand built by word of mouth; person-to-person marketing. In Europe, for example, collegiate buzz junkies have been successfully addicting friends and classmates for years thanks to a foolproof branding plan: Red Bull provides 17 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 student reps with free cases of its drink and then encourages the students to throw a party. Red Bull's target consumers began to adopt nicknames for the product such as 'liquid cocaine' or 'speed in a can'. The use of this kind of marketing strategy is also called 'viral' marketing. Red Bull does not use the traditional informative or persuasive communications; instead it uses the youth 'underground' to spread the popularity of the drink. As Gobé, author of “Emotional Branding: The New Paradigm for Connecting Brands to People” (Allworth Press, 2001) said: “The beauty of Red Bull is that it's the antibrand, Red Bull doesn't have any of the commercial trappings of a traditional, off-the-shelf product. It's underground, even when it's above ground, and this appeals to the young people who drink it." Secondly, Red Bull had cash and possibilities to create personal stands and “Red Bull events” such as motorcycle races, surf competitions and snowboard challenges. In addition, Red Bull used pick-up trucks as mobile displays, painted blue and silver with a giant can of the drink mounted on top of the vehicle. Recently, Red Bull has organized events for “normal” people, including “Red Bull Flugtag” and “Red Bull DJ contest”. Red Bull hired équipes to drive vehicles that were painted blue and silver with logos on the side and a big Red Bull can mounted on the back. The cars contained fridges stocked with cans of Red Bull, which the teams handed out for free to “those in need of energy,” at truck stops, construction sites, office buildings and gyms. The third step is the use of common advertising channels like television and radio. Red Bull still maintains its innovative and anti-conformist image however. Indeed, its spots are original and more amazing than educative. Red Bull never uses tools such as: banner ads, billboards, taxicab holograms, blimps, Super Bowl spots. Paper advertisements, for example, don‟t reflect the brand image. They are seen as too one-dimensional to capture the true essence of the Red Bull brand. Red Bull used mass-media only to bolster its image. The main strategy was its “buzz” marketing. Red Bull is an example of a strong marketing promotion strategy. Buzz marketing has a lot of advantages. The main advantage is that the company can find new functions for 18 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 product use. The company started to promote extreme sports, but it also obtained further success because Red Bull is a perfect alcohol mixer. Red Bull acquired two Formula 1 teams. This proved to be highly effective in improving the image of the brand and it increased its target segment involving adult people who like extreme sports. It‟s an important step as Red Bull manages these teams. The company promotes and sponsors new pilots. Red Bull promotes and is active within this extreme sector. Placement: Red Bull used sales reps to promote and sell its product. They were responsible for their units and had to answer for their achievements within the company. Red Bull chose a selective strategy. The product was sold only in selected bars and trendy nightclubs, it was not distributed everywhere. They used DJs and popular figureheads to promote the brand. In addition, they put empty cans in popular places. Red Bull then started to sell the product using retailers, again using a selective strategy. It maintained its exclusivity through its high price. Position: The emblematic phrase used to understand the concept of Red Bull is: “the Porsche of soft drinks”. The company insisted on spreading this unique concept of its product. Red Bull is not simply a soft drink; it‟s a powerful tool and a lifestyle choice which is absolutely unique. The company used all elements of the marketing mix to achieve its objective: - Price: Red Bull is more expensive than its competitors. The consumer pays more for quality and performance; - Promotion: uses non-conventional marketing, called viral marketing or “buzz” marketing; - Product: the packaging is innovative and easily identifiable over its competitors. The logo stresses the power and the properties of the product; - Place: only sold in selective places. 19 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 INNOVATION Position Red Bull 20 FUNCTION TASTE Position Coca-Cola TRADITION This map shows the concept of Red Bull in contrast with the leading soft drink brand Coca-Cola. Red Bull is perceived as an innovative brand and as a beverage useful to improve performance and increase emotional status. With promotion, the firm doesn‟t use traditional advertising but it relies on a strategy of word-of-mouth or “buzz” marketing. Red Bull concentrated on getting its word out through different stealth marketing techniques, playing on associations with energy, danger and youth culture, cultivating its mystique. The rumour that taurine is made from bull's testicles, for example, added to its notoriety. Generation Y (Aged from 18 to 29 years old) became the main target segment for the company. These consumers perceived it as an anti-brand. While it was making its mark as an energy drink, it was largely sold in clubs and bars as an alcohol mixer. As the leader of the company (Mateschitz) said: “We don’t bring the product to the people; we bring people to the product. We make it available and those who love our style come to us. Red Bull isn’t a drink; it’s a way of life.” The company invested a lot in sponsoring events and organizing events including: BMX biking, kite-boarding, snowboarding, free skiing, paragliding and skydiving and also Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 youth culture events like DJ competitions. More recently Red Bull invested in F1 and motorcycle racing to broaden its reach. As a consequence, the drink became associated with dangerous, adrenaline-fuelled activities, such as the Red Bull King of the Air. 21 For example, Red Bull organized events including: - Kite boarding event in Maui; - Big Wave Africa Surf Competition on the Cape peninsula; - The infamous Red Bull Flugtag (where amateur pilots build their own flying machines and leap off a parapet into water); - Red Bull Music Academy (RMBA) (where aspiring musicians and DJs attend a two week workshop and studio sessions, and listen to guest lecturers). With regard to secondary activities, and in particular procurement, we see how this is not a competitive advantage for Red Bull as it operates in the food and beverage industry; a sector characterized by repetition of operation. The development activities are technological development and Red Bull Austria is responsible for researching and developing the production process. Regarding the human resources management, the company gives the opportunity for anyone interested in working with the company to send their CV through the website www.redbulljobs.com. BCG Matrix Initially Red Bull was placed in the "question mark" category. In this place the Strategic Business Unit presents new growth markets and requires substantial investments that absorb cash flow. Now Red Bull is placed in the "star" category thanks to its development policies implemented over the years, it has managed to capture a large market share in a segment which presents exponential growth rates. Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Marketing Strategy: Red Bull has succeeded within a few years to reach very high market shares in the functional energy drinks market (47% of U.S. market and 80% in other markets) due to its innovative product and a very aggressive marketing policy. The significant market position gained by Red Bull in the energy drinks market has allowed it to achieve high profitability and high capacity to generate substantial cash flows. When Red Bull entered the market, its product was a novelty in the beverage industry. This enabled it, to expand rapidly and reach high levels of sales, with an effective marketing strategy. Now that the energy drinks market is a mature one and affected by the presence of strong competitors such as Coca Cola, who have a greater capacity to product innovation and greater ability to lower costs of production and distribution, Red Bull must look to changing its marketing strategy. In a mature market it is necessary to do more to diversify supply. Red Bull needs to change from a growing strategy to product development. Currently its business strategy has the typical characteristics of a penetration strategy, based upon the initial novelty of the product and a high price niche. Red Bull has until recently focused solely on the characteristics of the product and its ability to increase physical performance of its consumers. It tried to retain customers rather than vary the supply by diversifying the taste or the image of the product. Red Bull has not substantially diversified its product line and has never expanded its current product line. In a mature market it is necessary to offer consumers more products in the same industry that can meet the different needs of customers. Recognizing this need, Red Bull has begun to diversify its product line with the expansion of its current product to include Red Bull Sugarfree and Red Bull Shots and in 2008 it created a new innovative unique product in Red Bull Cola. 22 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 SWOT Analysis 23 Strengths -Effective communication -Loyal customers -Market share leadership -Strong brand equity -Reputation management Weaknesses -Higher price than its competitors -Red Bull is only manufactured in Austria Opportunities -Emerging markets and expansion abroad -New products e.g. Red Bull vodka and Red Bull Iced Tea Threats -Economic slowdown -European Laws against -Lower cost competitors imports Negative brand aspect & health concerns (when combined with alcohol) Health Concerns In May 2009, Germany banned Red Bull‟s new entrant to the market; Red Bull Cola. It had found traces of naturally occurring cocaine in the drink. After conducting a series of tests 4mg of cocaine were found to be naturally occurring in Red Bull Cola. This amount is too little to have dangerous consequences on the health of consumers, but is enough for Germany to place a ban on the product. Red Bull has responded to these accusations, saying that it was not pure cocaine that was found in the drink, but the coca leaf extract, which is used as a natural flavor, contains alcoide which was removed chemically. Despite this, Germany still classifies Red Bull Cola as a narcotic drink product. Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 A REVIEW OF BRAND AND COMMUNICATION STRATEGIES Red Bull‟s branding is revolutionary. It has at times been referred to as an „anti-brand‟ strategy. In the beginning the company faced problems in the UK in particular where Lucozade which was consumed by many young Britons, to recover from colds or flu, Red Bull had to promote its brand differently. The firm avoided usual methods of marketing relying on „buzz marketing‟ or word of mouth. A brand image was created and cultivated which associated the drink with youth culture and extreme and adventure-related sports, such as motor sports, mountain biking, snowboarding and dance music. This viral marketing approach has been discussed above. Red Bull‟s image gave the firm an edgier, even dangerous look, which appealed to its gen y target. Younger consumers are drawn towards products that offer legal highs. Red Bull‟s marketing focused heavily on getting product samples into the right hands. Slogans including “Red Bull gives you wiings” and animated tv ads aimed at mature markets were developed. What counts is what the consumer envisions about Red Bull when he holds a can in his hand. Red Bull is not just an energy drink, it is a lifestyle. It is for this reason that the company spends an astonishing 30% of its annual year on year revenue on its marketing. This is in stark contrast to the 9% spent by global soft drinks giants Coca Cola. Mateschitz had an uncanny instinct for successful product innovations, this marketing strategy meant that this innovation was often copied but never equalled. Red Bulls marketing strategy has been described as the three pillars: sampling, advertising and sponsoring. The brand awareness source for Red Bull brand equity notes that the key elements of brand awareness: recognition and recall. If buy decisions are made at the point of purchase, then brand name, logo, packaging etc are important factors. If the buy decision is made before arriving at the point of purchase then brand recall is important. Red bull felt it productive to spend time getting the logo, name and packaging perfect. Central to Red bulls marketing is its Wiings team, as experienced during our presentation. The team are professionally trained to educate consumers on the unique proven benefits of Red Bull, this strategy highlights a core differentiation policy and high a value proposition. 24 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Red Bull takes advantage of the sources of brand equity: Brand awareness: Through its wiings team and global sponsorship deals Perceived quality: Scientifically proven benefits of its product, yet to be equalled Brand associations: “Red Bull gives you wings”, “vitalizes body and mind Brand Loyalty: A major source of its success has been through word of mouth. DISTRIBUTION STRATEGY Red Bull’s Sales & Distribution Tactics: Red Bull chose its distribution strategy carefully. The company has created a high position and a perception of exclusivity of its product. The main idea was that Red Bull is different to regular soft drinks. As a result, Red Bull has a decentralized sales department that is responsible for marketing, sales and distribution in their own zone. At the beginning people were reluctant to sell Red Bull; a drink that tastes like a medicine! However, after three years, the product started to gain success. Sales reps for the company contacted small distributors to distribute the product by a dedicated sales force. They set up their own warehouse, bought vans, painted them with the company logo, and hired their own deliverymen to pass out the product. The firm had a selective sales strategy. They chose five key strategic accounts in their area like cool clubs and bars. Then, they established an individual approach with DJs, bar tenders and trend people. They gave them Red Bull to promote the brand and to improve the brand visibility. Operating with these individual accounts, Red Bull obtained the advantage of being fast. Other strategic places they chose were shops near universities and gyms. The sales reps refused to sell the product everywhere and refused offers from other distributors. An innovative figure was used by the company: the student brand managers. They had to promote the product into universities and refer information about the trends to the company. With this system the firm could make market research, while boosting the products notoriety. 25 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 The company decided to also use large distribution measures and as a result Red Bull was sold by more retailers than at the beginning. Red Bull however maintains its exclusivity through its premium price and product placement. Red Bull entered in the foreign markets using the local distributors to corner the market, and then taking back the control. In USA, for example, Red Bull has established eight own sales units. In each division, managers are responsible for how much they sell. They have to find the strategic and trend places to sell the product and they have to obtain a minimum target and specific objectives. In addition, like Gatorade in 80‟s and 90‟s: it started to sell chilled Red Bull in places where there was a lot of people that needed caffeine (e.g. athletes). As a result, Red Bull distributed its own fridges to retailers to promote its prestige and visibility. Indeed, a research from AC Nielsen stressed that 75% of Red Bull consumers tend to drink the product immediately after they buy it. Red Bull has used a short channel and so, it controls the distribution strategy and it can use this strategy to branding its product. 75% IMMEDIATE USE 25% POSTPONED USE 45% RETAIL RED BULL 55% Prompt use In 2003, 64% of volume was created by consumption in bars, clubs and petrol stationsaccounting for 79% of the value due to the price premium-while retail outlets made up the rest 36% of volume. Red Bull was facing considerable competition in the retail space, both from beverage heavyweights like Coca-Cola and Pepsi, and from private labels. For example, in the UK, Asda (part of Wal-Mart) launched its own energy drink branded Blue Charge. The alliance with Cadbury Schweppes in Australia in 2003 is an example of the company experimenting with the distribution mix. This kind of distribution contributed to a 26 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 40% increase in sales between the summer of 2003 and 2004 across its existing core channels of grocery, licensed premises and convenience stores. The managing director of Red Bull Australia's, Stuart MacLean, said the mission of the partnership was to “allow more customers to have access to Red Bull." In 2009 Red Bull Australia severed ties with Schweppes leaving Red Bull with the difficult task of organising distribution, a challenge which will require significant investment. Schweppes, meanwhile, will lose one of their best selling products and it leaves them without an energy drink product to market in Australia. It was suggested that as Red Bull seeks to bring its Cola product to the Australian market, it was the right time to depart from Schweppes, as they distribute Pepsi in Australia. In addition, Red Bull considered using vending machines both to improve sales and to reinforce its brands. Indeed, Coca-Cola and Pepsi and others soft drink manufacturers had expanded sales and enhanced brand awareness using vending machines. 27 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 5. DISCUSSION Thinking about strategy Red Bull is a company for profit and its main objective is to continually win new market share. The energy drinks market has stabilized since 2006, but Red Bull continues to state the importance of the brand among millions of consumers. This is thanks to its expenditure of $600 million (approximately 30% of revenue) to ensure that the brand is imposed on the market. Red Bull is automatically considered as the founder of the energy drinks market and as a result of its first mover advantage can sell 700 million cans in 2006 in the United States alone. In terms of a growth strategy since the stabilization of the energy drinks market in 2006, Red Bull chose the Market Penetration option. This gave it the chance to double its market share without having to invest heavily in product innovation. Nancy F Koehn, an associate professor of business studies at the Harvard School of Business stated that: "As a private company with a hands-off founder, Red Bull does not feel financial pressure from investors and board members, the company can take its time with the brand, and it should." Red Bull is establishing itself as a very powerful mover in a relatively new and evolving category. To do this, they are trying to, according to Koehn “get their knitting exactly right before they start weaving." Red Bull‟s strategic competitive advantage lies in the fact that it was the founder of the energy drinks market and has a young target audience that can count not only on the huge expenditure for mass marketing, but also on a widespread buzz that will enable revenue and market share to grow even higher. While being aware that it can penetrate certain markets, Red Bull has to take into consideration certain adverse political and socio-cultural barriers. France had a ban on Red Bull in place until April 2008, as the caffeine levels contravened state legislation, to keep its consumer base within this market Red Bull needed to focus on resilient guerrilla marketing and promotion. 28 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 Thinking about the future strategy Red Bull has a lot of challenges for the future. It has for example to maintain its market share, it has big competitors, and it has legal challenges and more. As regard the marketing mix elements there will be big changes and big opportunities but also many obstacles. In June 2009, Red Bull was working on the launch strategy for its Energy Shot brand in the UK following its successful US debut the month before. After the launch of the Red Bull Cola, last year, this new product is the latest in a series of brand extensions by the company. This item could herald a new era of innovation in the sector of soft-drinks. This year the company plans to spend more than £2m on marketing the new Red Bull shot in the UK. It has already rolled out a TV campaign and sampling program. The target comprises consumers from 18 to 35 years old. Red Bull will have to move quickly if it is to prevent Quick Energy's lead becoming unassailable. This is a competitive challenge because there are big and aggressive competitors. Indeed, a spokeswoman for the British Soft Drinks Association said: “The UK food and drink market is active and fluid so there is always room for new products if they can appeal to consumers, but only the most successful products will survive.” The advantage of the 'shots' category is that these products are seen as a newsworthy alternative to larger-format energy drinks because they provide energy loads in small doses. Shots are also considered healthier inasmuch they can avoid the use of sugar, although Red Bull's Energy Shot in the US contains sucrose, glucose and sugar substitutes. Another competitor is Pepsi who have a citrus-flavoured energy shot brand in the US called Amp. However, there are no immediate plans for Pepsi to launch the product in the UK. Coca-Cola, instead, launched its Relentless energy drink in 2006 in the UK. It posted sales of £40m in the 52 weeks to 17 January 2009. The choice of Red Bull to bring its Shots to the UK is an evident indication of the potential growth within a nascent area of soft-drink innovation. The market of sports and energy drinks in UK grew 15% in 2008. The forecasts suggest that strong growth is likely to continue. 29 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 The soft-drinks market is a highly competitive market. Indeed, by 2004, the worldwide energy drinks market was worth an estimated £1.6 billion. Red Bull had reached a market leading position, with a market share of 70%. The company is perceived as a non-conventional firm and so it‟s important for it to spread its concept through the use of traditional channels. It has to be careful when using a traditional channel to continue to maintain its innovative image. As discussed, Red Bull promotes a lot of events and for the future it will continue to sponsor a lot of challenges and races. Red Bull has a lot of challenges for the future. The drink was banned in France and Denmark, is considered a medicine in Norway and it‟s sold only in Chemists in Japan. With regards its on-premise sales, Red Bull has to tackle the ever increasing problem of passing off. The company will maintain the high concept of the product and will not change the target. It will continue to conquer new markets and always present a high quality product…“the Porsche of soft drinks”! 30 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 6. CONCLUSION Through this thesis, we tried to understand how does a premium good can help to stay leadership in really competed market. To make it, we analyzed strategically Red Bull‟s position as leader in the niche market it created, it is clear that the company faces many challenges from a marketing perspective. As the functional energy drinks market becomes saturated, Red Bull will need to do more to further differentiate itself from its competitors who are fast gaining market share, particularly in the Australian and U.S. markets. Red Bull needs to build on the brand it has already created; which in itself acts as its competitive advantage and focus its resources on maintaining brand loyalty, through the various measures as mentioned above. Product diversification has been successful for Red Bull thus far and in order to remain competitive in the now saturated energy drinks market, Red Bull needs to look further into diversifying its product range. A more aggressive expansion into the once leading Asian market will allow Red Bull assume a larger share of the global market through a local distributor may be another success story on Red Bull‟s already flawless resume. So Red choose the diversification to maintain his leadership in the energy market, but Now that the energy drinks market is a mature one and affected by the presence of strong competitors such as Coca Cola, who have a greater capacity to product innovation and greater ability to lower costs of production and distribution, Red Bull must look to changing its marketing strategy to maintain and win some market share. 31 Bachelor Thesis – Red Bull 2011 7. REFERENCES http://outside.away.com/outside/news/200204/200204red_bull_1.adp http://www.earthtimes.org/articles/show/254168,red-bulls-growth-rate-halved-in-2008.html 32 http://www.marketingmagazine.co.uk/news/916633/Red-Bull-X-Fighters-partner-TV-channel-Dave/ http://www.marketingmagazine.co.uk/News/918277/ http://www.redbull.com/cs/Satellite/en_INT/Red-Bull.com/001242745950125 http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0BDW/is_22_42/ai_75286777/ http://experiencethemessage.typepad.com/blog/files/Speed_In_a_Can.pdf http://www.beverfood.com/v2/news+article.storyid+1976.htm http://www.beveragedaily.com/Markets/Energy-drinks-market-will-grow-says-report http://tg24.sky.it/tg24/cronaca/2009/08/13/cnr_riischio_energy_drink.html http://www.zeusnews.com/index.php3?ar=stampa&cod=10424 http://www.redbull.com/ www.australianfoodnews.com www.glaxosmithkline.com www.energyfiend.com www.bized.co.uk