Uploaded by Srijita Acharjee

bwordsworth-by-vs-naipaul-litbug compress

advertisement
V
1
B . W 0 RD SWOR. H;
V.S
Naipaul
B. Wordsworth :: The story
story
B Wordsworth
Wordsworth is taken from Naipaul’s collection of short stories
titled
titled Miguel Street. This story
narrated in first person
through aa
story is narrated
person through
boy-child’s
boy—child’s perspective.
‘poet’
perspective. The story
highlights the plight of aa ‘poet’
story highlights
whom the child encounters. The two
very easy-going
two share a
easy—going
a very
relationship
understand and
instinctively understand
seems to instinctively
relationship and the child seems
empathize
‘poet’. Narrated in a
empathize with the ‘poet’.
a humorous and fun manner,
manner,
the story
solitude, alienation,
story revolves around the themes of solitude,
admiration, love for nature
nature and the role of the artist in the society.
This story
language, the rich
brought to life through
through the colloquial language,
story is brought
Caribbean setting
of the complex intricacies of
exploration of
setting and its exploration
human relationship
expression.
relationship and artistic expression.
0
No Time? Check out this Quick
Got No
Revision by Litbug
.
'[camoRDSWORTHK.
Characters
-
B.Wordsworth
The child-narrator
His mother
Setting
.
Miguel Street
/
‘Theme
.
The role of the artist in society
Alienation
Friendship
Key
Points
Wordsworth shows up at the narrator's
house. lle's smartly dressed, speaks good English and
says he wants to watch the bees. He claims to be the
greatest poet in the world, that B. stands for black and
that William Wordsworth was his brother.
He then tries to sell a poem and finally gets chased
away by the narrator's mother.
A week later, the kid meets him in Miguel Street They
go to B's house in Alberto Street and feast on mangoes.
The kid stains his shirt, gets thrashed by the mother and
goes to 8'5 house.
B. Wordsworth tries to comfort him by showing him the
wonders of nature and the beauty of the night sky. They
go to St Clair Avenue, the Savannah and walk to the
race course. ‘On being asked why he kept his gardens
untended, B tells the kid a story about how a girl and a
boy poet fell in love, got married. how they hoped for a
child and how the girl died with the unborn kid She
had loved the garden and the husband left it as it was.
One day, Mr B. tells him that he's writing the greatest
poem in the world and that the line of the month is "The
past is deep."
They meet often and go to the Botanical Gardens, The
Rock Garden and the Chancellor Hill. Mr B. earns his
living by singing calypsoes as nobody buys his poems.
One day the boy visits him to find him in a sick state.
Wordsworth then tells him a "funny story“. instructing
One day.
B.
.
.
him to never come back again he tells the boy that
everything about him, his poetry and the poet-lovers
was a lie. The boy goes home crying.
The boy walks past Alberto Street after a year
B.Wordsworth's house and the mango trees are
replaced by concert buildings. It's as if he never t
:
o
:
www
l
.
i
tbu
‘
o
bug
B. Wordsworth :: Summary
B.
Summary
lives in Miguel
The story
an unnamed child narrator who lives
story is told by an
Street. His house is daily frequented
dhoti—clad
beggars : aa dhoti-clad
frequented by three beggars
:
Indian at ten,
woman smoking pipe at twelve and a
blind man
a blind
man led
ten, aa woman
by a
two. The strangest
a boy at two.
smartly dressed person
strangest caller is a smartly
person
who comes at about four o’clock one afternoon
wishing to watch
afternoon wishing
watch the
narrator’s bees. Thus we are
of the story:
are introduced to the man
man of
story: B
Wordsworth.
The narrator’s mother is quite
gives him
quite suspicious
suspicious of the man
man and gives
the cold shoulder. She instructs
instructs the narrator
narrator to watch the man
man while
he watches the bees
bees and the two end up
bees together,
together,
watching the bees
up watching
squatting
hour. The little boy is
palm tree for about an
an hour.
squatting under aa palm
intrigued
intrigued by the man’s appearance
appearance and seeks to know him better.
The man’s introduction about himself
himself verses
hyperbole:
verses on hyperbole:

I said what does you do, mister?
He got up and said, ‘I am a poet.’
I said, ‘A good poet?’
He said, ‘The greatest in the world.’
‘What’s your name, mister?’
‘B. Wordsworth.’
He tells the boy that the ‘B‘ in his name
stands for Black and that
name stands
White Wordsworth was his brother. This reference
reference to the British
Romantic
William Wordsworth is significant
Romantic poet
significant and shall be taken
poet William
later in the course
analysis.
course of analysis.
Wordsworth
Wordsworth then tries to sell a poem
cents, only
poem to the kid for four cents,
to end up
up getting
mother. He calmly accepts
getting chased by his mother.
accepts the
unappreciative
unappreciative response
as “the poet’s tragedy” and doesn’t seem to
response as
all. Perhaps he has been through
mind
mind it at all.
earlier.
rejections earlier.
through such rejections
B. Wordsworth
A week later, the narrator
Wordsworth at the corner
meets B.
narrator meets
corner of
Miguel
yet but invites
Street. He hasn’t sold any
invites the narrator
narrator
Miguel Street.
poems yet
any poems
to his home in Alberto Street to feast on mangoes
mangoes which have
become red, ripe and juicy.
juicy. The two
one—
two head for B Wordsworth’s oneroomed hut which looks rather wild,
wild, surrounded by a
a mango,
mango, aa
coconut and a plum tree. The narrator hogs down six mangoes
mangoes
and ends up
juice. He gets
staining his shirt with the mango
mango juice.
up staining
B.
thrashed by
by his mother on reaching
reaching home and runs
runs away
away to B.
B. comforts him and takes him for a
Wordsworth’s house. Mr B.
a walk
down Saint Clair Avenue, to the Savannah and then to the Race
Course.
Wordsworth then suggests
Course. B Wordsworth
gazing
suggests lying on the grass
grass and gazing
at
stars are
at the night
sky. He asks the kid to think how far the stars
are
night sky.
from them and the impact
young mind
mind is aa powerful
impact this has on the young
one :
I

I did as he told me, and I saw what he
meant. I felt like nothing, and at the same
time I had never felt so big and great in all
my life. I forgot all my anger and all my
tears and all my blows.
Wordsworth then teaches him the names
Wordsworth
of the constellations
constellations of
names of
which he seems
remember the Orion. Shortly,
Shortly, they
seems to particularly
particularly remember
they
are
becomes aa
policeman and the interrogation
interrupted by aa policeman
are interrupted
interrogation becomes
comic exchange:
exchange:
The
The policeman said, ‘What
‘What are
here?’
are you
you doing here?’
Wordsworth
Wordsworth said, ‘I‘I have
have been
been asking
the same
asking myself
myselfthe
same
question for forty years.’
years.’
The two become fast friends.
friends. The narrator
narrator starts visiting
Wordsworth’s home very
very often and one day, asks him why is it that
he lets
lets the bushes
bushes abound in his house. The poet then tells him aa
little story
kid:
story which completely overwhelms the kid:

He said ‘Listen, I will tell you a story . Once
upon a time a boy and a girl met each other
and they fell in love. They loved each other
so much they got married. They were both
poets. He loved words. She loved grass and
flowers and trees. They lived happily in a
single room, and then one day the girl poet
said to the boy poet, ‘We are going to have
another poet in the family.’ But this poet
was never born, because the girl died, and
the young poet died with her, inside her.
And the girl’s husband was very sad, and
he said he would never touch a thing in
the girl’s garden. And so the garden
remained, and grew high and wild.’
II looked
looked at B. Wordsworth,
he told me
he
Wordsworth, and as
lovely story,
me this lovely
story, he
as he
seemed
older. II understood
to grow
his story.”
seemed to
understood his
grow older.
The two have a
visit the Rock Garden,
Garden, the
together. They Visit
a great
great time together.
Botanical
Botanical Gardens, climb the Chancellor’s Hill late in the afternoon
afternoon
and watch the darkness fall on the Port of Spain.
Wordsworth
Spain. Wordsworth
fills the boy with
seems
seems to have aa positive attitude towards life and fills
wonder
wonder and awe.
narrator has to say
awe. This is what the narrator
say about
life:
Wordsworth’s outlook towards
towards life:

He did everything as though he were doing
it for the first time in his life… The world
became a most exciting place
Wordsworth
Wordsworth then tells the boy an
secret: that he is writing
an important
important secret:
the greatest
that
greatest poem
poem in the world by writing one line aa month, and that
B. tells the boy that
the line of the month is:
past is
is: “The past
is Deep.” Mr B.
he hopes
of aa whole month into aa single line
hopes to distil the experiences
experiences of
of poetry
years he’ll have written a
twenty—two years
a poem
poetry and that in twenty-two
poem that
will “sing to all humanity”.
humanity”.
One day while walking along the dockside,
dockside, the boys asks the poet
whether the pin he has will sink or
float in water: He asks the
or float
B.
boy to give it a
that B.
a try. The pin
pin sinks. We later come to know that
Wordsworth
he’s a
Wordsworth supports
singing calypsos
calypsos and that he’s
a
supports his living by singing
part-poet,
part—performer.
part—poet, part-performer.
When the narrator
finds B
narrator visits his house the next time, he finds
Wordsworth
Wordsworth lying on his
his bed and he says
poem isn’t going
says that the poem
well.
well. He is in a
terrible state. The boy is overwhelmed with sadness
a terrible
when he understands
understands B Wordsworth
Wordsworth is going to die soon. He tells the
kid that he will narrate
narrate him aa ‘funny’ story
promise
story and makes him promise
to never come back after he’s heard the story.
story. The boy agrees:
agrees:

He said , ‘ Good. Well, listen. That story that
I told you about the boy poet and the girl
poet do you remember that that wasn’t true
it was something I just made up. All this talk
about poetry and the greatest poem in the
world that wasn’t true either. Isn’t that the
funniest thing you have heard?
However,
However, his voice breaks and the narrator
narrator runs
runs home crying
After about a
year, the boy walks
walks down Alberto Street but
a year,
Wordsworth’s house is nowhere
nowhere to be seen.
replaced by huge
huge
seen. It is replaced
concrete
concrete buildings.
coconut and the plum
buildings. The mango
tree, the coconut
plum tree
mango tree,
have all been cut down and it seems
B.Wordsworth had never
seems as
as if B.Wordsworth
existed.
existed.
B. Wordsworth :: Analysis
Analysis
Taken
Taken from aa collection of
of short stories titled
titled Miguel Street,
Street, V.S
Naipaul’s B. Wordsworth
us a
Wordsworth presents
a complex relationship
relationship
presents before us
between
young boy and a
between aa young
a rather remarkable man
man which is forged
with great
ease and simplicity.
great ease
Revolving
Revolving around the themes of identity,
friendship,
alienation, friendship,
identity, alienation,
admiration and the role of the artist,
Wordsworth is narrated in
artist, B Wordsworth
the first person
by a
a little boy
boy who comes in contact with aa man
man of
person by
the same
name. One day, the man
man appears
same name.
appears in the narrator’s house
to ‘watch the bee’s’. He’s smartly
beggars
smartly dressed, clearly unlike the beggars
who come to his house everyday. The narrator
narrator is quick
quick to detect
the coldness
coldness with which his mother accosts the man. In contrast
to her,
judge the man and talks to him in a
doesn’t judge
narrator doesn’t
her, the narrator
a
friendly manner.
Perhaps this ease
reaching out and
manner. Perhaps
ease of reaching
communicating
narrator—kid to know and
communicating with the other enables the narrator-kid
understand
understand the life of an
an interesting,
man and perhaps
interesting, lonely man
become the only one to do so.
so.
Wordsworth
narrator—kid grow
Wordsworth helps
helps the narrator-kid
important
grow and teaches him important
lessons about life and leisure.
leisure. The narrator’s strict mother serves
serves
B. Wordsworth’s accommodating
as
lets the boy
nature. He lets
accommodating nature.
as aa foil to B.
discover things
of placing the
himself and even entertains his idea of
things by himself
pin
next. He teaches the kid to
pin on water to see what happens next.
delight
experiences we take for granted
everyday experiences
granted and presents
delight in everyday
presents
him a
a fresh pair
pair of eyes
eyes with which to observe and soak in the
wonders
wonders of the natural world.
world.
Miguel
Miguel Street,
Street, the collection from which the story
story is taken features
B. Wordsworth’s is certainly
many
certainly
interestingly odd characters and B.
many interestingly
one of them.
them. The characters in the book often struggle
their
struggle with their
identities and,
and, owing
owing to the colonial past
region, find
past of the region,
B. Wordsworth’s
themselves
themselves shaped by the colonial experience.
experience. B.
story
lives
of the artist from the society he lives
highlights the alienation of
story highlights
in and tries to come to terms with role s/he
it.
s / he might play in it.
One of the first things
his
notices about the man
things the narrator notices
man is his
English
Trinidadian folks. Though
English which quite
quite unlike that of his Trinidadian
Though he
speaks
good English,
English, there is aa hint of artificiality
speaks good
artificiality about it :
:

His English was so good, it didn’t sound
natural, and I could see my mother was
worried.
Black Wordsworth
Wordsworth calls himself
himself the ‘greatest poet in the world ‘‘ and
claims
Wordsworth was his brother. Like his Romantic
William Wordsworth
claims that William
Romantic
B. Wordsworth
counterpart
acclaimed ‘Nature Poet“,
Wordsworth
Poet“, B.
an acclaimed
counterpart who was an
loves to spend time with nature
known by anybody
nature But he isn’t known
anybody as
as aa
poet.
Though his marginalized
status may
marginalized status
poet. Though
may be attributed to his
color, it is difficult to state whether he actually
all.
writes poems
actually writes
poems at all.
One cannot help but feel that he’s
he’s quite
his identity.
identity. Parts
quite lost about his
of his identity
claims to be the
seem to contradict others. He claims
identity seem
greatest
poet in the world .. Yet we don’t see his poetry.
poetry. His poem
greatest poet
poem
remains unfinished
unfinished and he seems
artistic
seems to have fallen in an
an artistic
paralysis
past is deep. He dismisses the
the past
paralysis after writing the line the
story
narrated it with much passion.
passion. He
story he tells the kid after having narrated
is poet who earns
living by singing Calypso songs.
earns his living
songs. A lot in him
seems
imitation and he seems
identity.
seems to be imitation
seems have aa divided identity.
The setting
very
gives it a
a very
setting and the local colour of the story
story gives
distinctive
distinctive appeal.
appeal. The Caribbean setting
palm and mango
setting with its palm
mango
trees,
Chancellor Hill, the Race Course
of Spain,
Course and the Port of
Spain,
trees, the Chancellor
combined
combined with the sights
distinctive visual
Miguel Street provide aa distinctive
sights of Miguel
appeal
reader. On the other hand, the colloquial
appeal to the reader.
colloquial diction
helps
of the people inhabiting
helps us
language of
inhabiting the story.
story.
us ‘hear’ the language
B.
Notice
Notice this brief exchange
between the narrator’s mother and B.
exchange between
effect it produces:
Wordsworth
Wordsworth and the effect

I ran up the steps and shouted, ‘Ma, it
have a man outside here. He say he want to
watch the bees. My mother came out, looked
at the man and asked him in an unfriendly
way, ‘What do you want?’
The man said, ‘I want to watch your bees.
Wordsworth’s story
of the artist
artist from the
highlights the alienation of
story highlights
society
lives in and tries to come to terms with role s/he
s / he might
society he lives
play in it.
lives in the margins.
it. B.Wordsworth
B.Wordsworth lives
Nobody buys
margins. Nobody
buys his
poems
public life
poems and he doesn’t seem to have any
agency in the public
any agency
whatsoever.
whatsoever. But he does have aa great
influence on the personal
personal life
great influence
of the boy which results
results in artistic
artistic expression
expression in the form of the
B. Wordsworth’s is a poetry
boy’s
that is lived, not
boy’s narration. B.
poetry that
written. He lives
lives his life like aa poem.
poem.
The theme of the relationship
wealth is
between art
art and material wealth
relationship between
B. Wordsworth
found
utterances of B.
Wordsworth and the hardships
found in the utterances
hardships he has
to face to eke out a
a living by selling his poems
twenty cents and
poems for twenty
signing Calypso songs.
buy
songs. When the narrator’s mother refuses to buy
his poem,
truth in it :
though aa funny
funny one,
one, has some truth
poem, his response,
response, though
:

My mother say she ain’t have four cents.’
Wordsworth said, ‘It is the poet’s tragedy.’
Again,
Again, later in the story,
story, we find him unable to be able to believe
that material well—being
well-being would be his share even if
if he wrote the
greatest
greatest poem
poem in the world :
:

But you will be the richest man in the world
when you write the greatest poem ?’
He didn’t reply.
This silence
volumes about the chasm that exists
silence on his part
exists
speaks volumes
part speaks
between
between poetry
prosperity.
poetry and material prosperity.
B. Wordsworth
Whether
writes good
Wordsworth actually
Whether B.
good poems
actually writes
poems or whether he is
a
delusional person
himself aa poet
an unimportant
unimportant
poet is an
a delusional
person fancying himself
question.
assessment makes the very
question. Such assessment
very mistake which the
B. Wordsworth’s
narrator
narrator avoids –— of placing
placing aa value judgment on B.
worth.
worth. What is more important
important is his personal life, the past
past he’s
been through
boy. When
relationship he develops with the boy.
through and the relationship
his story
account, the line
story about the girl and the child is taken into account,
“The past
past is deep” which he takes aa full month to write bears aa
completely different meaning
when viewed as
meaning rather than when
as aa
disjointed
utterance of a
disjointed utterance
a madman.
It is true that
that B.Wordsworth comes across
across as
as aa strange
strange person
person but it
is this very
.He cares
‘strangeness’ which endears him .He
cares about the
very ‘strangeness’
‘lesser things’ in life and can
himself as
can see himself
as aa part
part of the universe.
His lazy loiterings
all, it is an
loiterings may
escapism but ifif at all,
an
as escapism
may appear
appear as
escape
narrator feels when
discovery. This is perhaps what the narrator
escape to discovery.
he lies on the grass
B.Wordsworth after getting thrashed
thrashed by his
grass with B.Wordsworth
mom,
watching the night
night sky :
mom, watching
:

I felt like nothing, and at the same time I
had never felt so big and great in all my life.
I forgot all my anger and all my tears and
all my blows.
Furthermore, he also comes across
across as
as aa kind person
great
person with aa great
degree
emotional intelligence.
degree of emotional
intelligence. Before his death, he makes the
narrator
he’s told him aa funny
of
narrator promise
return after he’s
promise to never return
funny story:
story: of
how all he’d said about the poet’s wife was a
voice breaks in
a lie. His voice
the process.
not. What seems
seems to be the
process. It might be aa lie, it might not.
case
he’s lying now.
now. If so,
though is that it was aa true story
case though
so,
story and that he’s
B. Wordsworth
it is actually
here. B.
Wordsworth
profound gesture
actually aa profound
making here.
gesture he’s making
is undoubtedly
undoubtedly a
young narrator
finds aa friend in the young
narrator
a lonely man.
man. He finds
with whom he can
loneliness and transforms the boy’s
can share his loneliness
outlook towards
towards life. However,
knows his end is near,
However, when he knows
near, he
attempts
young boy
boy
erase his existence from the mind of the young
attempts to erase
by saying that
that everything
everything he’s ever said is aa lie. After having
expressed
expressed his credo to perhaps
perhaps the only person
through his story,
story, he
person through
tries to erase
mind so as
person’s mind
erase his memory
as to
very person’s
memory from the very
relieve him from the burden of
of missing
missing someone
someone and allow him to
explore life in his own terms. In short, he tries to negate
himself
negate himself
for the sake of the other which is perhaps
most profound
perhaps the most
profound gesture
gesture
a
make. This noble gesture
self-effacement
a human being can
can make.
gesture of self-effacement
carries a note of sacrifice
it.
sacrifice with it.
B. Wordsworth’s
The final
final paragraphs
of B.
paragraphs portray
picture of
poignant picture
portray aa poignant
fate. A year
year after his last visit the narrator
walks along Alberto Street
narrator walks
B. Wordsworth’s hut
two—storied building.
only to find
find B.
hut replaced
replaced by aa two-storied
building.
The mango,
been cut down.
plum and the coconut trees have all been
mango, the plum
The hard, man-made
man—made material replaces
nature and
signs of nature
replaces the living signs
the last line is an
of B
an awfully sad one which sums
sums up
up the life of
Wordsworth:
Wordsworth:
B. Wordsworth
ezdsted.
Wordsworth had
It
had never
though B.
It was
was just as
as though
never existed.
This strange
‘strange’ person
story about aa ‘strange’
strange story
may appear
person may
appear humorous at
first
first sight
magnitude:
sight but at its core lies aa tragedy
tragedy of tremendous magnitude:
one with a
one’s outlook
radically change
profound lesson that can
a profound
change one’s
can radically
towards
very nature
towards people, places
existence.
nature of human existence.
places and the very
B. Wordsworth
B.
Wordsworth :: About the author
Sir Vidiadhar
writer of Indian
Vidiadhar Surajprasad
Naipaul, aa Trinidadian writer
Surajprasad Naipaul,
descent was born on 17th
Trinidad. His
His great17th August,
1932 in Trinidad.
great—
August, 1932
grandfather
Trinidad
grandfather was an
an indentured laborer who had come to Trinidad
during
very bright
student and
Raj. Naipaul was a
during the British Raj.
a very
bright student
attended the University of
of Oxford in 1950
1950 on aa scholarship. He
worked for the BBC for sometime
his career
sometime before he began
began his
career in
writing.
V.S Naipaul is a
of
prolific writer who has had an
a prolific
an enormous
enormous output
output of
literature to his credit.
credit. He has written everything
everything from the comic to
the tragic
politics, religion
overlapping themes of politics,
tragic and around overlapping
identity,
first three
colonialism, oppression
identity, colonialism,
individuality. His first
oppression and individuality.
novels of
of great
Masseur,
Mystic Masseur,
importance important
important novels include Mystic
great importance
The
The Suffrage
Street. However, it was his fourth
Sufirage of
of Elvira and Miguel Street.
novel, A House for
for Mr Biswas which propelled
propelled him to the league
league of
in the River,
the greats.
River,
greats. Some of his other works include A Bend in
Mimic
Mimic Men and The
The Enigma of
Arrival. Naipaul
Naipaul has written aa couple
of Arrival.
of nonfiction
nonfiction works centered around India which include An Area of
of
Darkness, India: A wounded
civilization and India: A Million Mutinies
wounded civilization
Now. He was also an
traveler whose travels across
an avid traveler
across the globe
precipitated
Among the
the Believers: an
precipitated in works like Among
Journey,
an Islamic Journey,
Beyond Belief,
Africa.
The Masque of
Belief, Half
Half aa Life and The
of Africa.
He received the Nobel Prize
Prize for literature in 2001.
2001.
B. Wordsworth
Miguel Street,
which B.
Wordsworth is taken
Street, the collection from which
bagged the Somerset
1961 and Somerset
Somerset
Somerset Maugham
Maugham Award in 1961
Maugham
selected it as
himself selected
thus making
Naipaul the
Maugham himself
an entry,
making Naipaul
as an
entry, thus
first non-European
writer to win the prize.
non—European writer
Naipaul
17th August
2018 and according
Greig,
Naipaul died on 17th
according to Geordie Greig,
August 2018
Naipaul’s friend and the editor of The Mail on Sunday,
Sunday, the writer
drifted towards his final
final rest after being read Crossing
Crossing the Bar, aa
poem
Tennyson.
poem by Tennyson.
Download