Name: ___________________________________
Reviewed by: _____________________________
Peer Critique Feedback Rubric: STEM Fair Procedures
Variables: Look at
the worksheet for
the variables
Experimental Design
Order of Procedures
3
All variables are
clearly described with
all relevant details.
The independent,
dependent and
control variables
have been correctly
identified with no
errors.
Experimental design
is a well-constructed
test of the stated
hypothesis.
Procedures are listed
in clear steps. The
steps follow a logical
order.
Control Variables
There is an
explanation for how
All control variables
are addressed.
Details
Procedures outline
detailed steps for
carrying out the
investigation.
Procedures appear
to be replicable.
Steps are outlined
sequentially and are
thoroughly detailed.
Replicable
2
Most variables are
clearly described with
most relevant details.
The independent,
dependent and
control variables
have not been
correctly identified.
1
Variables are not
described OR the
majority lack
sufficient detail.
Experimental design
is relevant to the
hypothesis, but is not
a complete test.
Procedures are listed
but are not in a
logical order or are
difficult to follow. All
control variables are
not addressed.
There is an
explanation for how
most control
variables are
addressed.
Procedures outline
detailed steps for
carrying out most of
the investigation.
All steps are outlined,
but there is not
enough detail to
replicate procedures.
Experimental design
is not relevant to the
hypothesis.
Procedures do not
accurately list the
steps of the
experiment.
There is no
explanation for how
control variables are
addressed.
Procedures do not
outline detailed steps
for carrying the
investigation.
Several steps are not
outlined AND there is
not enough detail to
replicate procedures.
Peer
Feedback/Comments
(Please write 3 – 5
sentences on how
the procedures can
be improved)