2013 Marketing Strategy of Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. & Its Effectiveness This report shall highlight various aspects of Pak Suzuki Motor Co. ltd.’s marketing strategy. We shall examine the Company’s position in comparison to its competitors. We shall evaluate Company’s strengths, weaknesses threats and opportunities. A realization of external factors directly influencing the Company shall be made and recommendations shall be cited for achieving Company’s objectives more effectively. NAME: SHERAZ JABBAR WORD COUNT: ACCA NUMBER: 2166355 Table of Contents 1 Topic Selection .................................................................................................................... 4 1.1 Project Highlights ............................................................................................................ 5 1.2 Research Approach and Methodology ............................................................................. 5 2 Information Gathering & Data Sources ................................................................................ 8 2.1 Sources of Data............................................................................................................... 8 2.1.1 Limitations of Data sources .......................................................................................... 9 2.2 Ethical Requirements .....................................................................................................10 2.3 Business Analysis Techniques ........................................................................................ 11 3 Company History ...............................................................................................................14 3.1 Geographical Presence ..................................................................................................14 3.2 Product Demographic .....................................................................................................14 3.3 Industry Analysis ............................................................................................................15 3.4 Operational & Financial Highlights ..................................................................................16 3.5 Competitor Analysis ........................................................................................................20 3.6 Market Segmentation .....................................................................................................21 3.7 Marketing Positioning Analysis .......................................................................................24 3.8 SWOT Analysis of Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. .................................................................25 3.9 PESTEL Analysis............................................................................................................31 4. 4.1 5. Conclusions & Recommendations .....................................................................................34 Recommendations .........................................................................................................34 References ........................................................................................................................35 Research and Analysis Report Page 1 Table of Figures Figure 1- 7 P’s of marketing...................................................................................................................... 4 Figure 2- Research Approach & Methodology....................................................................................... 5 Figure 3- Geographical Presence .......................................................................................................... 14 Figure 4- Industry Analysis ..................................................................................................................... 16 Figure 5- Operating Performance Analysis .......................................................................................... 17 Figure 6- Financial Performance Analysis ............................................................................................ 17 Figure 7- Advertising Cost to Revenue Ratio Analysis ....................................................................... 18 Figure 8- Advertising Cost to Overall Operating Cost Ratio Analysis .............................................. 19 Figure 9- Ratio Analysis .......................................................................................................................... 20 Figure 10- Competitor Operating Performance Analysis ................................................................... 21 Figure 11- Suzuki Mehran Sales statistics ........................................................................................... 22 Figure 12- Suzuki Cultus, Swift, Liana Sales Statistics ...................................................................... 23 Figure 13- Toyota Corolla Sales statistics ............................................................................................ 24 Figure 14- Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. SWOT Analysis ...................................................................... 26 Figure 15- No. of Units sold .................................................................................................................... 28 Figure 16- Annual Disposable Income Analysis .................................................................................. 29 Figure 17- PESTEL Analysis .................................................................................................................. 31 Research and Analysis Report Page 2 Introduction to the Topic and Reasons for Topic Selection 830 words approx. Research and Analysis Report Page 3 1 Topic Selection Most economists in the nineteenth century were of the view that greater success could be achieved by firms if they are able to produce more and meet the growing demand of the consumers. New and improved means of production were thus introduced to foster efficiency in mass production. The industrial revolution has thus enabled nations to produce more then they require for their domestic uses. Businesses in modern day corporate world are more anxious therefore to come up with better means of selling their products. Firms world over are spending hefty sums on advertisement. The success in oligopolistic form of competition lies entirely in effective marketing. Marketing is considered to be the back bone of any businesses operational success. This has been evident from the trends in top management of most global leader corporations in the world for instance Lenovo where the CEO’s are from a marketing background. Developing countries essentially are under enormous global pressure especially since the promulgation of the WTO. It has become essential for companies in developing countries including Pakistan to not only improve the standard of product and product quality but also explore new markets for their products and devise customized means of marketing their products in targeted segments. (Spencerstuart, 2005) The primary impetus behind the selection of topic 18 i.e. Marketing strategy and its effectiveness has been the undeniable importance of the theory and practice of the subject. I have a strong belief that by improving my skills in the subject I can make a mark as a successful manager. I wish to seek expertise in the design and development of a thorough marketing plan which entails all aspects of the targeted market. I have chosen Pak Suzuki Motor Co. ltd owing to the fact that it is oldest automobile manufacturing company in Pakistan and I am an automobile enthusiast. I aspire to pursue a career in marketing and I am confident that the underlying report shall enhance my practical knowledge of the subject. Consider the 7P’s of marketing management in the following diagram. Figure 1- 7 P’s of marketing (Genzmarketing, 2009) Research and Analysis Report Page 4 1.1 Project Highlights This report comprises of the following core areas An understanding of the data, its types and characteristics relevance to the project underhand. An introduction to Pak Suzuki Motor Co. ltd.’s operations, its history and the range of different products being manufactured and marketed by the Company. Introduce the Company’s marketing strategy, its product range and targeted segments. Highlights of the Company’s operating and financial performance over the last three years. Comparison of Company’s performance both operational and financial with other important players of the industry. An analysis of the strengths, weaknesses, opportunities and threats facing the Company. A consideration of the political economic social technological environmental and legal factors influencing the entity. 1.2 Research Approach and Methodology The primary contributor towards the success of any project is its Plan. The extent to which minute details are considered at planning stage can have a direct implication over the efficiency and quality of output. The planning stage for this project comprised of extensive meetings with my mentor and seniors to determine the key success factors and the formation of a road map for the project. My research methodology is provided in the diagram below. Figure 2- Research Approach & Methodology Planning Research and Analysis Report Execution Compilation Review Page 5 Let us consider these stages in detail. Planning Planning comprised of determining the data requirements of the project. The identification of data sources and the collection of raw data from the selected sources. Integrity is one of the most important characteristics of any data. In order to ensure maximum reliance most data has been extracted from the Company website. As part of planning I developed the road map for the project and a raw structure upon which information was to be presented. Valuable contributions were made in this regard by my mentor and seniors. Execution The execution phase comprises of performing the analyses on the accumulated data. Various analytical tools were employed to deduce inferences relevant to the Company. Numerous meetings were conducted with the mentor as part of this process. A key skill obtained during this process was the data skimming technique. I learned to go through large quantum of data in a limited time period with maximum possible deductions. I also learned numerous tips and techniques in MS Excel and MS Word. Compilation The third phase in the process is the compilation phase. The objective behind this phase was to present the results from execution phase in the most relevant and readily understandable form while keeping intact the compliance with the University guidelines for the project. Information was adjusted in the overall structure of the report. Various tables and graphs were added along with diagrams. Review Various reviews were conducted along the different stages of the project. The final review however comprised of an in-depth assessment of all the components of the report. Certain revisions and amendments were advised by my mentor as part of the review process which was duly posted. A comparison was also conducted with successful projects of similar nature to determine any shortcomings that might still need to be rectified. Research and Analysis Report Page 6 Information Gathering & Data Sources 1540 words approx. Research and Analysis Report Page 7 2 Information Gathering & Data Sources 2.1 Sources of Data Data is the collection of raw facts and figures which are subject to various analytical tools before they convert in to meaningful information. Following are the two types of data that were obtained during the research. (Businessdictionary.com, 2013) a- Primary Data b- Secondary Data We shall now discuss these in detail. Primary Data Primary data is the collection of first hand facts and figures obtained by the reporter through his own experiences and initiatives, This form of data is usually more relevant because of its objective nature and is thus more reliable. It saves time consumed while skimming but at times has the disadvantage of being costly. (Ventureline.com, 2013) For the purpose of our report primary data comprises a structured formal interview with Mr. Mushtaq who has a thorough study of the subject and has been working in Suzuki motors for over three years. Following is the relevant extract from the interview. Elaborate the performance of auto industry in the country The auto industry in the country was established in 1953. Since then there has been steady growth in the industry. The economic condition in the country has been volatile and has an implication on the performance of the industry. The evolution and growth of the banking sector since the start of the new millennium brought overwhelming growth in this sector the industry grew from an annual production of forty thousand vehicles in the year 2000 to more than one hundred and fifty thousand in 2012. The industry owes a lot to the protectionist policies of the state which restricts foreign producers to expand sales in the country. The recent financial crisis has had a bearing on this sector too but it is again on the path to recovery. Introduce Suzuki’s marketing strategy in Pakistan Pak Suzuki Motors Co. ltd started commercial production in the year 1975. Since then the Company has expanded production horizontally. It is currently producing thirteen different models of cars, load vehicles and motorcycles. The production volume has increased almost ten times. This has been possible partly due to the product quality and reliability and partly because of its successful marketing. The company spent a hundred and thirty eight million rupees on marketing which is the highest spending per brand of any Company in the Country. With its extensive network of dealership the Company Research and Analysis Report Page 8 stretches to the far and wide of the Country. It has been due to its successful marketing strategy that the Company tops the national production of any single brand. What are the challenges faced by the Company Success comes with responsibility. The biggest challenge is to maintain the status of market leader. The competition in the industry is cut throat and the market segmentation is very complicated. Generally, the market has a strong inclination towards low cost brands which provide better quality and service. The Company thus has an uphill task of managing cost and revenues profitably. The other most challenging factor is the introduction of refurbished vehicles being imported from Japan. These provide better features and are mostly cheaper than the Company’s products. It is thus critical to market the models intelligently. Manufacture and supply of parts is another aspect the Company needs to pay heed to. The Company ranks third in terms of the most expensive parts and service after Honda and Toyota. Despite these challenges the Company still has potential and will hopefully achieve expand and grow in coming years. Secondary Data Secondary data is also known as desk research. It is the collection of facts and figures which the reporter did not experience himself but rather accumulated from various sources. Secondary data has a huge advantage of being low cost and easy availability. It does however require more dexterous analysis and skimming. Reliability is another issue faced with secondary data. Secondary data needs to be referenced in order to compliment the source and avoid issues of copyright infringement. (Nordquist, 2013) 2.1.1 Limitations of Data sources Data forms the bricks to the information structure and needs to be based upon accurate and updated facts. Ensuring data legitimacy is an exhaustive exercise. I obtained valuable insight from my seniors in this regard which enabled effective resolution of the following experiences during data collection. (Zeepedia.com, 2013) Data Efflux Data efflux is beneficial depending on the nature of the project. It does however have the disadvantage of being time consuming considering the effort that needs to be put to generate relevant information. I resolved the problem by adopting brisk reading and making use of Microsoft office tools to search relevant aspects of the report. Data Accuracy and Updating Accurate and updated information plays a primary role in successful and objective decision making. Ensuring accuracy can prove time consuming especially with large Research and Analysis Report Page 9 volumes of data. Updated data is also an integral aspect of objective reporting. I ensured accuracy by choosing reliable and prestigious data sources. Majority of the data relevant to the Company has been obtained to the official website of Pak Suzuki Motors Co. ltd. Other information has been reconciled to obtain the most accurate and widely accepted facts and figures. Data Source Conflicts It is a common experience that information available on various sources of the web conflicts with each other. It is very important to base ones judgment on the most common and accepted information. Access to Data The access to physical information and people is usually restricted due to confidentiality or official decorum. Moreover companies do not make intimate information public because the managers consider it to be helpful for the competitor organizations. Access to such information is thus very difficult. Identification and approach to the relevant personnel might also prove to be a hard nut to crack. I was however lucky to have known Mr. Mushtaq through a family contact and thus did not feel any problem while contacting and convening a discussion session with him. Completeness Completeness is another primary aspect of data which needs to be considered for any report. Completeness cannot be ensured without extensive knowledge of the subject. Thus thorough reading is required to identify what elements of data need to be included and which segments to be spared. I discussed this issue in detail with my mentor and he elaborated various key concepts of the subject together with the data needs to objectively address them. Conciseness is another element of effective communication and should be taken care of to avoid loss of credibility and interest. 2.2 Ethical Requirements As described earlier data obtained from secondary sources is the proprietary information of the original reporter. It is thus imperative to relate the information to its true owner. This not only enhances the trust of the reader but also saves the reporter from facing any trouble for copyrights violation. I have made sure that all information that is obtained from any secondary source be appropriately referenced using Harvard referencing technique. The conclusions and recommendations are based on my own judgments and analysis together with a logical evaluation of cited factors. Research and Analysis Report Page 10 2.3 Business Analysis Techniques Numerous techniques have been made use of for the purposes of this report. Following is an introduction of these techniques and methodologies. a- Competitor Analysis A competitor analysis is a tool that evaluates Company’s operating and financial performance amongst its key competitors. It is a vital technique that enables market researchers to position the Company in the particular market segments.(Riley, 2012) Limitations of Competitor Analysis A Competitor analysis despite being a commonly used technique has certain limitations, some of which are cited below; Obtaining confidential competitor information is difficult and costly. Competitor analysis makes a company responsive to competitor actions and thus makes it a follower. It has limited usability in terms of decision making and can prove to be demoralizing for a Company going through slump. (Referenceforbusiness.com, 2013) b- SWOT Analysis The strengths, weaknesses, threats and opportunities analysis is another very commonly used analysis technique. It is based on the underlying assumption that any information about a Company can be one of the above characteristics. The strengths and weaknesses relate to internal aspects of the Company. While the opportunities and threats are posed by outside factors. (Renaul, 2013) Limitations of SWOT Analysis Following are the limitations of SWOT analysis. It is a very subjective technique and has limited practical importance for strategic decision making. It is greatly influenced by the entity’s perception of itself and thus might prove to be remote from realism. SWOT Analysis costs in terms of time and loss of opportunity to perform routine functions if it is conducted by indigenous staff of the Company, it can prove to be costly if the Company hires consultants for the task. (Business.qld.gov.au, 2013) Research and Analysis Report Page 11 c- PESTEL Analysis The political, economic, social, technical, environmental and legal factors that influence the entity are analyzed in the PESTEL analysis is a commonly used appraisal technique and is essentially performed before formulating a Company’s marketing strategy. (Strategicmanagementinsight, 2013) Limitations of the Analysis Following are the limitations of the PESTEL analysis. It is very subjective in nature. The environmental factors are continuously evolving and are dynamic in nature, a PESTEL analysis thus needs to be conducted at regular intervals. Most of the factors highlighted by the analysis are beyond the Company’s control and jurisdiction and thus this analysis has a limited usability. Research and Analysis Report Page 12 Analysis 3900 words Approx. Research and Analysis Report Page 13 3 Company History Pak Suzuki Motor Co. ltd was founded in 1975 when the first 4×4 vehicle name “Nay Dour” was introduced. The company became a public listed company in the year 1983. Mr. Osamu Suzuki, chairman of Suzuki motors Japan was awarded Sitar e Pakistan, the highest civil award in the year 1985 for his cooperation and commitment towards establishment of automobile sector in Pakistan. The Company started manufacturing 800 cc and 1000 cc cars in 1988 while the first 1300 cc car was manufactured in 1992. By 2005 the production capacity of the Company had expanded to 80,000 units annually which rose to 150,000 units in 2007. In the year 2009 the Company produced its one millionth vehicles (Company milestones, 2013) 3.1 Geographical Presence Following image provides the vide dispersion of the company’s dealership network across the far and wide of the Country. Figure 3- Geographical Presence (PakSuzuki, Dealer Network, 2013) With over thirty authorized dealership Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. has by far the most comprehensive network of sales and services in Pakistan. 3.2 Product Demographic Following are the different brands being manufactured by the Company. Research and Analysis Report Page 14 Brand Name Suzuki Ravi Type Engine Capacity Carriage vehicle 800 cc Suzuki cargo van Suzuki Bolan Suzuki Jimny Suzuki APV Suzuki Mehran Suzuki Cultus High roof High roof 4×4 jeep High roof Passenger Car Passenger Car 1000 cc 1000 cc 2600 cc 1500 cc 800 cc 1000 cc Suzuki Liana Suzuki Swift Suzuki Raider Suzuki GS 150 Suzuki Sprinter Eco Suzuki Sprinter Passenger Car Passenger Car Motorcycle Motorcycle Motorcycle Motorcycle 1300 & 1600 cc 1000 & 1300 cc 110 cc 150 cc 110 cc 110 cc (PakSuzuki, 2012) 3.3 Industry Analysis The following table represents the cars manufactured and sold by different manufacturers during the 2012 and preceding four years. The data has been obtained from the Pakistan Automobile manufacturer Associations web portal and has been reproduced for the purposes of this report. Manufacturer Honda (Civic) Honda (City) Honda Total Toyota (Corolla) Suzuki (Liana) Suzuki (Khyber/ Cultus) Suzuki (Alto) Suzuki (Mehran) Suzuki (Bolan) Suzuki Total Hyundai (Santro Plus) 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Produced Sold Produced Sold Produced Sold Produced Sold Produced Sold 5,813 5,762 4,985 4,662 5,648 5,908 6,408 6,365 5,396 4,977 8,220 8,439 6,755 6,482 7,852 8,212 9,294 9,121 7,089 7,142 14,033 14,201 11,740 11,144 13,500 14,120 15,702 15,486 12,485 12,119 33,672 33,640 27,054 26,760 43,382 43,510 41,419 41,111 46,352 46,207 2,605 27,662 18,805 36,249 17,250 102,571 2,028 268,908 2,983 27,563 19,097 35,526 17,209 102,378 2,227 269,025 684 9,181 6,641 13,239 9,639 39,384 327 129,629 851 9,198 6,550 13,421 8,664 38,684 404 126,820 900 12,453 10,665 22,271 10,541 56,830 212 184,254 1,025 12,658 10,794 22,513 11,439 58,429 244 188,852 614 12,414 12,873 25,935 14,359 66,195 470 11,428 11,932 24,119 13,311 61,260 334 13,600 15,288 33,839 21,594 84,655 450 13,693 16,288 35,131 22,540 88,102 205,213 194,603 240,632 246,649 (Production & Sale of vehicles, 2012) Research and Analysis Report Page 15 Figure 4- Industry Analysis 120 000 100 000 Honda Total 80 000 Toyota (Corolla) 60 000 Suzuki Total 40 000 Hyundai (Santro Plus) 20 000 0 2008 3.4 2009 2010 2011 2012 Operational & Financial Highlights As evident from the analysis above the Company currently holds the first place amongst domestic automobile manufacturers. It is also the largest automobile manufacturer of the country in terms of revenues earned. Let us not consider the operational performance of the Company over the span of last three years Description Sales Revenues Other operating income Cost of Sales Financial Year ended March (Rs. in millions) 2012 2011 58,531 52,718 494 620 (56,185) (50,849) 2010 42,642 575 (41,638) Distribution and marketing costs Administrative expenses (357) (263) (197) (861) (735) (636) Other operating expenses Net Profit before tax (111) 1,500 (107) 1,365 (56) 211 (PakSuzuki, Annual Report, 2012) Research and Analysis Report Page 16 Operating Performance 60 000 50 000 40 000 30 000 20 000 10 000 - Figure 5- Operating Performance Analysis Consider the following table for the financial performance of the Company. FY’ 2012 Description FY’ 2011 FY’ 2010 Rs. In Millions Noncurrent Assets Current assets Current Liabilities 4,282 4,716 4,937 17,060 18,585 14,313 5,548 8,008 4,752 Figure 6- Financial Performance Analysis Financial Performance Analysis 20 000 15 000 10 000 5 000 0 Noncurrent Assets Research and Analysis Report Current assets Current Liabilities Page 17 Evidently from the above diagrams the Company has grown in terms of sales revenues. This has been real growth since the numbers of units sold have grown by 44%. The cost of sales has not grown with the same ratio which typically means that the Company has been extremely successful in putting a tight leash over the costs associated with production. All operating costs have also grown at a lower rate than revenues except for the administrative costs. The improvement in the revenues in comparison to costs is also evident from the net profits which have been kept at a steady growth rate. This particularly is commendable considering slowdown in the overall market and allowance of refurbished vehicles to be imported and sold in the Country. Domestic competition is also stiff. However, the Company has successfully enhanced the sales and made its mark. A testament to this fact is that the market share of the Company grew from 58% to 62% during 2011-12. Let us consider and interesting analysis. (Khan, 2012) Description 2012 2011 Rs. in Thousands 2010 217,727 160,894 111,481 Advertising cost to Revenue ratio 0.37 0.31 0.26 Advertising cot to operating cost ratio 16.38 14.56 12.53 Advertising expenses Figure 7- Advertising Cost to Revenue Ratio Analysis Advertising cost to Revenue ratio 0,4 0,3 0,2 0,1 0 2012 Research and Analysis Report 2011 2010 Page 18 Figure 8- Advertising Cost to Overall Operating Cost Ratio Analysis Advertising cot to operating cost ratio 18 16 14 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 2012 2011 2010 A steady growth is evident from the above diagrams. The Company is investing in to promotional activities for its products and its marketing strategy has been successful in reaching out to the people and addressing their needs effectively. A dominating factor has been the market segmentation based on which the Company designs its marketing plan. The Company manufactures products which address the needs of the economy class of the Country which dominates the overall consumer percentage. This has led to the popularity of the Company’s products in the Country. Let’s consider some other significant ratios. Description 2012 2011 2010 Gross Profit ratio 4.01 3.55 2.35 Net profit ratio 2.56 2.59 0.49 Current ratio 3.07 2.32 3.01 The blue bars represent GP ratio, the orange bars show NP ratio and Grey bars show current ratio. Research and Analysis Report Page 19 Figure 9- Ratio Analysis 4,50 4,00 3,50 3,00 2,50 2,00 1,50 1,00 0,50 2012 3.5 2011 2010 Competitor Analysis We shall make an effort consider the Company’s position amidst stiff market competition. We shall analyze the company’s operating and financial performance amongst key competitors. We have selected Indus motors Ltd. and Atlas Honda Ltd. for the purpose of our analysis. Let’s consider the operating performances of these companies for the years 2012. Description Pak Suzuki Sales Revenues Other operating income Cost of Sales Distribution and marketing costs Administrative expenses Other operating expenses Net Profit before tax Indus Motors Rs. in million Atlas Honda 58,531 494 76,963 1,774 16,600 204 (56,185) (357) 70,401 820 (16,643) (130) (861) 628 (159) (111) 516 (218) 1,500 6,312 (346) (PakSuzuki, 2012) (Indus, 2012) (Honda, 2012) Research and Analysis Report Page 20 Figure 10- Competitor Operating Performance Analysis Competitor Operating Performance Analysis 80 000 70 000 60 000 50 000 40 000 30 000 20 000 10 000 0 -10 000 Evidently from the above analysis Indus motors which are the assemblers of Toyota Corolla in Pakistan lead the competition in terms of revenue. This is primarily because of the huge uplift in the sales of Corolla owing to its excellent after sales services and healthy resale value. Also per unit price of Toyota Corolla is almost 100% higher than average price of a Suzuki vehicle. (Pama.org.pk, 2012) 3.6 Market Segmentation Market segmentation describes the way in which a Company divides its customer base in to separately identifiable groups for the purpose of devising a customized marketing plan for each segment. (Managementstudyguide.com, 2013) The automobile market is segmented based on the following categories. Category Segment A Segment B Segment C Segment D Characteristics mini cars Small cars Family cars for value for money seeking buyers Large family/ compact executive cars Segment E Segment F Segment M Segment J Executive cars Luxury vehicles Multi utility vehicles Sports utility vehicles (Jayati, 2010) Research and Analysis Report Page 21 Pak Suzuki Motor Co. ltd has been targeting the economy class consumers with basic functionality. It targets the following segments; Segment B This segment is categorized by the cost effectiveness and fuel efficiency. Another key characteristic of this segment is the low cost of repair and replacement of parts. Suzuki Mehran is a popular model from this class. Consider the sales statistics of the car over the 5 years. (pama.org.pk, 2012) Year No. of units sold 2007 36,988 2008 36,249 2009 13,239 2010 22,271 2011 25,935 2012 33,839 Figure 11- Suzuki Mehran Sales statistics Suzuki Mehran Sales Statistics 40 000 35 000 30 000 25 000 20 000 15 000 10 000 5 000 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 No. of units sold 2009 was a particularly hard year for automobile manufacturers. The power crises were at its peak and Companies were finding it hard to fulfill their orders. As seen in the industry analysis in the above sections the production was at its lowest in the five years considered. (AFP, 2013). The country was struck by worst floods in history in 2010 thus the recovery was slow. (BBC, 2010) Segment C Research and Analysis Report Page 22 This category is characterized by value for money cars for the comfort seeking customers. The Company manufactures three models in this category. i.e. the Suzuki Cultus, Suzuki Swift, Suzuki Liana. Following are the sales statistics of these in the last five years. Model Suzuki Cultus 2012 2011 2010 2009 2008 13,600 12,414 12,453 9,181 27,662 Suzuki Swift Suzuki Liana 7,128 334 4,376 614 2,578 900 684 2,605 (pama.org.pk, 2012) Figure 12- Suzuki Cultus, Swift, Liana Sales Statistics Suzuki Cultus, Swift, Liana Sales Statistics 30 000 25 000 20 000 15 000 10 000 5 000 0 Suzuki Cultus Suzuki Swift 2012 2011 Suzuki Liana 2010 2009 2008 Consistent decline in Sales is observed mainly Toyota Corolla was taking up most of the market share during the same period. Consider Toyota’s sales figures for the same period. (Pama.org.pk, 2012) Year No. of units sold 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 35,036 33,672 27,054 43,382 41,419 46,352 Research and Analysis Report Page 23 A key reason for this is the cost consumers were paying for Suzuki’s products and its comparison with the quality of the product. All the three brands are marketed as Suzuki’s premium models in Pakistan. However, the comfort and reliability in relatively lower cost provided by Toyota is an attraction for the buyers. Figure 13- Toyota Corolla Sales statistics Toyota Corolla Sales Statistics 50 000 40 000 30 000 20 000 10 000 0 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 No. of units sold 3.7 Marketing Positioning Analysis Market positioning analysis enables entrepreneurs to establish how their targeted market perceives their brand or product. (Kokemuller, 2013) We have conducted this analysis based on two positioning variables a- Price b- Quality Positioning based on Price Consider the following table for the price of the top quality brands marketed by the three competitors. Model Suzuki liana Toyota Corolla Altis Honda Prosmatic Price in PKR 1,511,000 1,994,000 2,319,000 Civic (wheels, 2013) (wheels, Toyota Corolla Altis 1.6 Cruisetronic Overview & Price, 2013) Research and Analysis Report Page 24 Clearly Suzuki is positioned as a budget brand. Consumers categorize it as a low price brand with average quality and customer services. Positioning based on Quality Perceived quality is very important especially because in automobile industry the word of mouth plays a very important role in improving sales. Suzuki is perceived as an average quality product in the domestic industry because of the compromised quality of materials used in its cars and frequent problems faced by consumers. Following graph can be plotted based on the above analysis. High Price Low Quality High Quality Suzuki Low Price 3.8 SWOT Analysis of Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. SWOT analysis (alternately SWOT Matrix) is a structured planning method used to evaluate the Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, and Threats involved in a project or in a business venture. A SWOT analysis can be carried out for a product, place or person. It involves specifying the objective of the business venture or project and identifying the internal and external factors that are favorable and unfavorable to achieve that objective. The technique is credited to Albert Humphrey, who led a convention at the Stanford Research Institute (now SRI International) in the 1960s and 1970s using data from Fortune 500 companies.(Business balls, 2013) Research and Analysis Report Page 25 Following is the SWOT matrix of Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. Figure 14- Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. SWOT Analysis •Growing personal income •Low cost leadership •Environmental friendly vehicles •Market Share •Financial Resources •Human Resource •Geographical Presence •Economies of Scale Opportunities Strengths Threats Weaknesses •Improving competition •Low Current Ratio •Improving global health and safety standards •No premium models •Research & Development •Product life cycle We shall now discuss these in detail. Strengths We have identified the following areas where the Company possesses a strategic advantage. Market Share Pak Suzuki is the second largest automobile manufacturer in terms of revenue received. It is the largest car manufacturer in terms of no. of units produced (largest also in 2010 and 2009). This huge market share is an immensely advantageous factor which the Company can make use of in terms of long term policy making. Market share in Research and Analysis Report Page 26 automobiles in turn implies large number of parts produced and sold. The marketing policy of the Company should target the existing consumers more enthusiastically. One of the greatest reasons for the Company to have captured such high percentage is the global economic meltdown which started in the start of this millennium. The financial crisis led consumers to switch from luxury cars to low cost sedans. Suzuki’s success has mainly been due to the effective marketing of its low cost models such as Suzuki Mehran and Suzuki Cultus. Towards the end of this decade Mehran consistently held the title for being the most popular consumer car in Pakistan. (Brecorder, 2012) Financial Resources As cited before, the Company has immensely improved revenues over the last decade and is currently amongst the most affluent companies of the Country in terms of revenues. (Zaheer, 2013) This huge financial fortune is a huge advantage owing to the fact that Company can undertake research and development programs and can foster growth not only through improving the production and supply chain mechanism but also excelling in the manufacture of low carbon emitting vehicles. Human Resources The company has an overall work force of over eleven hundred skilled and semi-skilled individuals. It has production facilities in two locations in the country. The huge work force can be a huge marketing advantage. Its extensive geographical presence means that the Company can communicate more closely with its buyers. It can obtain a thorough understanding of various economic and geographic factors of the population and can come up with brighter and more relevant ideas for growth. (Paksuzuki, 2013) Geographical Presence Geographical presence is one of the dominating considerations while deciding the Company’s marketing strategy. While on one hand it has a huge bearing on the revenues earned by the Company on the other it influences cost of production too with lower cost of transportation and labor. Geographically dispersed Companies attain many economies of scale such as the ones mentioned earlier. However, expanding across geographical boundaries has certain diseconomies of scale too in the form of loosened control and communication. Problems of language and cultural adaptation arise when Company’s expand operations. (PakSuzuki, Dealer Network, 2013) Economies of Scale Suzuki enjoys enormous economies of scale in the form of low cost labor, availability of raw materials and skilled workforce, trust and confidence of financial institutions all over the Country and low cost of transportation. The Company can make use of these economies to reduce cost of production and increase its Gross Profit ratio making its operations even more profitable. Research and Analysis Report Page 27 Weaknesses Despite being a market leader the Company still has to focus and improve certain areas. Some of which are highlighted below. Lack of Premium models The Company has positioned itself as a low cost leader and has specialized in the production of family vehicles. It does lack however in the production of premium models. Suzuki manufactures Suzuki Liana which is its top notch brand. Following is the comparison of sales in 2012 of Pak Suzuki’s countrywide sales and another premium model the Toyota Corolla sales in Pakistan only. Year Suzuki Liana Toyota Corolla No. of units sold 2012 450 46,207 (Pama.org.pk, 2012) Figure 15- No. of Units sold 50000 45000 40000 35000 30000 25000 20000 15000 10000 5000 0 SUZUKI LIANA TOYOTA COROLLA This huge difference is primarily because Suzuki considers its success in marketing low cost models such as Mehran and Cultus. Despite the fact that Suzuki Liana possesses some ground breaking features such as Antilock braking system which are not present in its immediate rivals, it has not been marketed in the Local market with great zeal. Research & Development Suzuki Motors Japan is spending hefty sums in to product and market research. However the same is not being conducted in Pakistan, Suzuki Mehran whose production began in 1989 is being marketed with almost the same shape and feature as the earliest version. Pak Suzuki still needs to go a long way in upgrading its low cost models. Rival companies are continuously moving towards driver comfort and the rigidity of drive in few models of the Company might lose customer confidence in the Company’s products. (Khan B. , 2010) Research and Analysis Report Page 28 Product Life Cycle Pak Suzuki is at the peak of its product life cycle for most products. The Company needs to make a clear assessment of where it needs to be in terms of domestic and global sales and growth in the coming years. The economic condition of most countries who suffered in the economic crisis is improving. This calls for an enthusiastic marketing oriented approach. By utilizing its strengths the Company can prolong its current status as the market leader. Indus Motors crossed Pak Suzuki’s flagship model the Suzuki Mehran in terms of units of goods sold in 2012 by 11,076 units Country wide. This loss of market share might convert in to a threat if the downward trend continues. (Pama.org.pk, 2012) Opportunities Let us now take a look at the opportunities which the Company can make use of to encourage growth. Growing Personal disposable Income The disposable personal income of individuals in most countries is improving especially in East Asian and South East Asian country that manifested a steady growth rate of 6 percent and above. The improving national economy has an effect on the personal disposable income of individuals. In India for instance had the following trend in disposable income over the last few years Annual Disposable Income 2008 2009 1,073,243.4 1,095,398.6 2010 USD in Millions 1,356,096.4 2011 2012 1,511,001.3 1,578,903.4 (Euro monitor, 2012) Figure 16- Annual Disposable Income Analysis Annual Disposable Income 2 000 000,00 1 000 000,00 Annual Disposable Income 0,00 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 Research and Analysis Report Page 29 This growth in disposable income brings a hoist of opportunities for growth for the Company. Low Cost Leadership Many low cost manufacturers have entered the market especially in China which is dominating the world output of automobiles by producing 14,485,326 units in 2011. These cost models compromise quality but owing to the poor financial performance of most economies consumers were ready to accept the tradeoff between cost and performance. The Company needs to market itself as a cost effective and performance oriented manufacturer. Features like low carbon emission and fuel efficiency can strengthen its cause. (Worldometers, 2013) Environmental Friendly Vehicle Suzuki has huge potential in hybrid vehicles. It started producing hybrid cars internationally in 2003 and since has grown tremendously in terms of technology and expertise in marketing these vehicles. The recent milestone is the plug in hybrid technology that has taken fuel efficiency to a new level. Pak Suzuki needs to capitalize this potential. (Jerry, G. 2007) Threats The Company has to keep a close eye on the following important threats from the environment. Competition American car makers have learned a lot from their Japanese rivals. They gained extreme success in the early sixties and seventies. When Henry Ford was one heard saying “People will buy the Ford T in every color as long as it is black.” The eighties and nineties saw panoramic shifts in the consumer preferences and people started buying low cost, fuel efficient Japanese brands. The US producers such as General Motors were forced to shift resources towards producing fuel efficient cars. The US technology can surely prove to be a potential threat for Suzuki as seen in 2011 when GM ranked number one in the world in terms of units sold. (Ford, 2013) Cost Control The Company needs to consider its cost control policies. The gap between revenues from sales and cost of sales is narrowing down as cited previously. This not only has the effect of deteriorating investor confidence but also hampers growth due to dwindling support from internal financial resources. Environmental Laws and Safety Awareness The governments across all developed countries and some developing countries including Pakistan have promulgated statutory amendments making safety of the Research and Analysis Report Page 30 consumer and environmental protection mandatory for all manufacturers. This increase cost of production due to additional components being incorporated to the design of the vehicle but also creates problems for the Companies to pass the Local standards. 3.9 PESTEL Analysis PESTEL Analysis is one of the most commonly employed appraisal techniques used by Companies to evaluate the effectiveness of their marketing strategies. It analyses the political, economic, social, technical, Environmental and legal factors concerning the entity. Following diagram provides Pak Suzuki’s PESTEL factors. (Strategicmanagementinsight, 2013) Figure 17- PESTEL Analysis Import Quotas Economic Crisis Embargos Rising Cost of Production and Capital International Relations Consumer Prferences Hybrid Technology Cost effective production techniques Awareness about environmental effects of Carbon emmission Stutory Involvement Currently, Pak Suzuki faces a need for accelerated investment, in order to deploy the new technologies, for pressing geo-political, economic, environmental and societal reasons. Political Observers will see a continuing progression in the ruinous steps which have forced the industry into a socio-politico-economic corner. Whether this is related to flat demand or to the company’s creation of an ever-wider range of vehicles that many buyers seem to care little about, there is a problem. The company is likewise linked closely to the policies of governments, the earnings of banks. Little wonder then that so many emerging countries are keen to develop an auto sector or that there is such a political pressure to protect it in the developed countries. Pak Suzuki Motor Company Ltd. is currently dominated by little more than a handful of firms, each wielding colossal Research and Analysis Report Page 31 financial, emotional and political power. The company’s approach to dealing with political institutions has not always been brilliant. It tends to be good on technical issues, although it has not always fully presented the longer-term options, in order to make the choices and their implications clear. Economic For much of the developed world, and increasingly for the developing world, Suzuki is a pillar company in auto mobile business, a flag of economic progress. Without Pak Suzuki in automotive industry, it is impossible to develop an efficient steel business, a plastic industry or a glass sector – other central foundations of economic progress. The Company has been a core company, a unique economic phenomenon, which has dominated the contribution to the national exchequer for over a decade now. However, the automobile industry including the Pak Suzuki Company now suffers from a series of structural schisms and has become riddled with contradictions and economic discontinuities. For the capital markets and the finance sector, it has lost a lot of its significance, as a result of falling sales of flagship models. The proliferation of products means that it has become hopelessly wasteful of economic resources. While all these and more sound like a very gloomy assessment of such a vast economic phenomenon, the industry is not in the end despondent. A different future is possible for the industry, a highly desirable one. Social As part of the development in automotive industry, the Pak Suzuki Motor Co. Ltd. actually affects the society as a whole. It employs over eleven hundred people directly, Labor is also involved indirectly. Its products have transformed society, bringing undreamed-of levels of mobility, changing the ways people live and work. The social value of the additional mobility that this industry brings involves the value of the people being able to commute over longer distances easily, among many others. For most of its existence the Company has been a model of social discipline and control and it is not just that the auto sector offers a ‘pillar’ of national growth. There are, on the other hand, particular social issues to address in many developing countries, often those that are the result of an undertone of religious faith. The Company has the role to play in helping develop the mobility of the Country and it can be achieved at an acceptable social cost of the country is prepared to learn the necessary lessons from those who have traveled this route before it, and to make the necessary investments. Technological The Pak Suzuki Motor Company works on a scale so awe-inspiring and has an influence so vast that it is often difficult to see. The level and diversity of technologies that it must deploy are increasing, which imposes both new investment burdens and new uncertainties and risks. Roughly a million new cars and trucks are built around the world each week – they are easily the most complex products of their kind to be massResearch and Analysis Report Page 32 produced in such volumes. The industry uses manufacturing technology that is the cutting edge of science. But still, the potential for developing coordination skills, intellectual capabilities and emotional sensitivities through electronic technologies remain far from fully exploited. There are numerous additional near-term technological opportunities to adapt the company to changing energy availability. The possibilities suggest that automotive technology is unexpectedly robust and provides a powerful defense against energy starvation even if the real price of oil climbs steadily during the next couple of decades. Legal Pak Suzuki Motor Company is subject to numerous technical directives and regulations, as well as legislation of a more legal nature. The legislation covers areas such as competition law, intellectual property law, consumer protection and taxation, and emissions (air quality and fuels). When the auto parts industry reached full development, accelerated technological efforts were made to create a web of local suppliers that would make it possible to meet the growing legal requirements for the national integration of production. Environmental Other than the vehicles themselves, and the roads and fuel needed to run them; the business is intricately tied to the manufacture of a wide range of components and the extraction of precious raw materials. Indirectly, it brings people road congestion, too many fatalities and a wave of other environmental troubles. The effect to the Pak Suzuki Motor Company is that they needed to establish R&D centers to take advantage of research infrastructure and human capital, so that they can develop vehicle products locally to satisfy the requirements of the environmental and safety regulations more effectively. Research and Analysis Report Page 33 4. Conclusions & Recommendations 4.1 Recommendations In the light of the above analysis it is clear the Company is stably positions as a market leader and low cost high quality manufacturer of automobiles. The growth of the Company over the past deserves applaud. It has survived through all the global financial crisis of the last century and has emerged as an exemplary organization. A lot of credit goes to the industrious engineers who have developed the automobiles keeping in view the requirements of the masses. The marketing of Pak Suzuki deserves equal praise for its astounding success. Amidst immense pressure and competition they have managed to foster growth and prosperity. We would like to bring to light the following important factors which the Company needs to consider in order for strengthening its position as a global leader of automobile manufacturing firms. Proactive Marketing Strategy As cited in the previous analysis the Company needs to reconsider its marketing plan which has exceedingly become responsive to competitor actions. It needs to come up Research and Analysis Report Page 34 with an aggressive and proactive marketing strategy. Its status as market leader is a huge support in terms of risk associated with change. It needs to consider redesigning its marketing plan keeping in view the requirements of the European consumers who are fond of luxury and convenience. Focus on Product Market Mix The Company should consider focusing its marketing resources on promoting its premium models such as the Suzuki Liana and Suzuki Swift which despite having huge potential have been unable to make their mark especially in the affluent domestic consumers. Expansion in African States The Company needs to expand more significantly in African markets like most international players are currently doing. There can be many ways to substantiate this expansion. One of them could be collaboration with local partners through licensing agreements. This is one of the most economical means of expansion in that the financial stake is minimized. The African market currently depends on used Japanese cars for satisfying the demand. By introducing locally produced low cost models the Company can make use of the enormous potential of this important segment. Diversification Pak Suzuki needs to explore other fronts for growth. Unlike Toyota and Honda who have a history of manufacturing four wheelers and aeronautical equipment, till present Suzuki has focused completely on producing automobiles which has ripped great fruit for the Company. However, at the current position of the product life cycles most products have matured and the market completely saturated. This calls for diversification and moving to other product lines. 5. References AFP. (2013). Pakistan power crisis looms large over general elections. Retrieved April 25, 2013, from http://dawn.com/: http://dawn.com/2013/04/28/pakistan-powercrisis-looms-large-over-election/ Association, P. A. (2012). Production & Sale of vehicles. Retrieved from pama.org.pk: http://www.pama.org.pk/statistical-information/historical-information/annual-salesproduction BBC. (2010). Monsoon floods in Pakistan. Retrieved April 25, 2013, from http://www.bbc.co.uk/: http://www.bbc.co.uk/learningzone/clips/monsoon-floods-inpakistan-causes/10769.html brecorder. (2012). Pak Suzuki Motor Company. Retrieved May 2 2013, from http://www.brecorder.com/: http://www.brecorder.com/company-news/235/1234114/ Research and Analysis Report Page 35 business.qld.gov.au. (2013). Benefits and limitations of SWOT analysis. Retrieved April 26, 2013, from http://www.business.qld.gov.au/: http://www.business.qld.gov.au/business/starting/market-customer-research/swotanalysis/benefits-limitations-swot-analysis businessballs. (2013). swot analysis. Retrieved April 30, 2013, from http://www.businessballs.com/: http://www.businessballs.com/swotanalysisfreetemplate.htm businessdictionary.com. (2013). data. Retrieved April 16, 2013, from http://www.businessdictionary.com/: http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/data.html Ford, H. (2013). Henry Ford. Retrieved May 10, 2013, from http://en.wikiquote.org/: http://en.wikiquote.org/wiki/Henry_Ford Genzmarketing. (2009). 7 P's of marketing. Retrieved from genzmarketing.blogspot.com: http://genzmarketing.blogspot.com/ Honda, A. (2012). Annual Reports. Retrieved from hondaatlas.com.pk: hondaatlas.com.pk/investor relations/Annual reports.aspx Indus, M. (2012). Annual Reports. Retrieved from indusmotors.com.pk: www.indusmotors.com.pk/investorrelations/Annual reports.aspx Jayati, N. A. (2010). Marketing Strategy of Toyota. Retrieved from scribd.com: http://www.scribd.com/doc/35954117/Marketing-Strategy-of-Toyota-for-different-carsegments Jerry, G. (2007). Small Things in Good Packages. Retrieved from nytimes.com: http://www.nytimes.com/2007/11/25/automobiles/25MICRO.html?ref=automobiles&_r =0 Khan, A. S. (2012). Pak-Suzuki stops booking orders. Retrieved April 30, 2013, from http://dawn.com/: http://dawn.com/2012/02/14/pak-suzuki-stops-booking-orders/ Khan, B. (2010). The legacy of Suzuki Mehran. Retrieved May 6, 2013, from tribune.com.pk: http://blogs.tribune.com.pk/story/1691/the-legacy-of-suzuki-mehran/ Kokemuller, N. (2013). Positioning Analysis in Identifying Target Market Opportunities. Retrieved April 30, 2013, from http://smallbusiness.chron.com/: http://smallbusiness.chron.com/positioning-analysis-identifying-target-marketopportunities-15551.html Ltd., P. S. (2013). Company milestones. Retrieved from paksuzuki.com.pk: http://www.paksuzuki.com.pk/Automobile/Pages/Milestone.aspx managementstudyguide.com. (2013). Market Segmentation - Meaning, Basis and Types of Segmentation. Retrieved April 15, 2013, from http://www.managementstudyguide.com/: http://www.managementstudyguide.com/market-segmentation.htm Research and Analysis Report Page 36 minutebyminute. (2013). Top Budget Brand Tablets. Retrieved April 28, 2013, from minutebyminute.co.uk: http://www.minutebyminute.co.uk/top-budget-brand-tablets/ Nordquist, R. (2013). secondary source. Retrieved April 18, 2013, from http://grammar.about.com/: http://grammar.about.com/od/rs/g/secsourceterm.htm PakSuzuki. (2012). Annual Report. Retrieved from paksuzuki.com.pk: http://www.paksuzuki.com.pk/Investor relations/Annual Reports.aspx paksuzuki. (2013). COMPANY MILESTONES. Retrieved May 5, 2013, from http://www.paksuzuki.com.pk/: http://www.paksuzuki.com.pk/Automobile/Pages/Milestone.aspx PakSuzuki. (2013). Dealer Network. Retrieved April 27, 2013, from http://www.paksuzuki.com.pk/: http://www.paksuzuki.com.pk/Automobile/Pages/DealersNew.aspx pama.org.pk. (2012). Production (P) & Sale (S) of Vehicles. Retrieved April 23, 2013, from http://www.pama.org.pk/: http://www.pama.org.pk/images/stories/pdf/historicaldata.pdf referenceforbusiness.com. (2013). COMPETITIVE ANALYSIS. Retrieved April 25, 2013, from http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/: http://www.referenceforbusiness.com/small/Bo-Co/Competitive-Analysis.html#b Renaul, V. (2013). SWOT analysis. Retrieved April 25, 2013, from http://ctb.ku.edu/: ctb.ku.edu/en/tablecontents/sub_section_main_1049.aspx Riley, J. (2012). Competitor Analysis. Retrieved April 22, 2013, from tutor2u.net: http://www.tutor2u.net/business/strategy/competitor_analysis.htm Spencerstuart. (2005). 2004 CEO Study: A Statistical Snapshot of Leading CEOs. Retrieved April 15, 2013, from http://bus.wisc.edu/: http://bus.wisc.edu/~/media/bus/mba/why%20wisconsin/statistical_snapshot_of_lead ing_ceos_relb3.ashx ventureline.com. (2013). PRIMARY DATA DEFINITION. Retrieved April 17, 2013, from http://www.ventureline.com/: http://www.ventureline.com/accountingglossary/P/primary-data-definition/ wheels, P. (2013). Honda Civic 2013. Retrieved from http://www.pakwheels.com/: http://www.pakwheels.com/new-cars/honda/civic/ wheels, P. (2013). Toyota Corolla Altis 1.6 Cruisetronic Overview & Price. Retrieved from http://www.pakwheels.com/: http://www.pakwheels.com/newcars/toyota/corolla/1-6-cruisetronic/ worldometers. (2013). Cars produced in the world - sources and methods. Retrieved May 6, 2013, from http://www.worldometers.info/: http://www.worldometers.info/cars/ Research and Analysis Report Page 37 Zaheer, F. (2013). Pak Suzuki reports 23% higher profits for 2012. Retrieved May 5, 2013, from http://tribune.com.pk/: http://tribune.com.pk/story/524480/pak-suzukireports-23-higher-profits-for-2012/ zeepedia.com. (2013). USE OF SECONDARY DATA. Retrieved April 20, 2013, from http://www.zeepedia.com/: http://www.zeepedia.com/read.php?use_of_secondary_data_advantages_disadvant ages_secondary_survey_data_research_methods&b=71&c=37 Research and Analysis Report Page 38