DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES CHAPTER-1 INTRODUCTION 1 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES INTRODUCTION Smart Village is a concept adopted by national, state and local governments of India,as an initiative focused on holistic rural development, derived from Mahat ma Gandhi's vision of Adarsh Gram (Ideal Village) and Swaraj (Self Reliance). Prime Minister Narendra Modi launched Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana(SAGY) on 2nd October 2014, Gandhi's birthday, in addition to Smart Cities and Digital India, as a development programme for India. The Parliamentarian's Model Village Sche -me main goal is for each Member of Parliament and Minister to adopt a rural village and develop it into a model by 2019 under the SAGY guidelines. The visio n of SAGY is a integrated village development plan, encompassing Personal, Human, Social, and Economic dimensions Smart Village India gets its foundation from Mahatma Gandhi's vision of Adarsh Gram (model village) and Gram Swaraj (Village self rule/independence). Gandhi in two texts, Hind Swaraj and Gram (Village) Swaraj, promotes the concept of integrated rural development to impact majority of the population, as the primary initiative after India Independence in 1947. The Eco Needs Foundation has initiated the concept of "Smart Village". Under this project the Foundation is adopting villages and putting efforts for sustainable development by providing basic amenities like sanitation, safe drinking water, internal road, tree plantation, water conservation. The Foundation is also working for inculcating moral values in the society and for improving the standard of living of the villagers. In the concept of "Smart Village" the development of the village shall be based on the five paths Retrofitting, Redevelopment, Green fields, e-Pan, Livelihood. Under the concept of Smart Village, the Foundation has adopted Village Dhanora, Teh. Bari, District Dholpur, a small and remote village of Rajasthan to develop it as India’s First Smart Village. The village is situated 30 km away from Dholpur district head quarter and 248 km from Jaipur. The population of the village is about 2,000. The village was devoid of its basic needs like sanitation, internal roads. It was also facing various other similar problems such as lack of access to potable water, non-availability of water conservation system, encroachment on the roads, power fluctuation, non-availability of employmentoriented education, unemployment and poverty, so on and so forth. Prof. Priyan and 2 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Agale Founder of Eco Needs Foundation and Dr. Satyapal Sing Meena (IRS) Joint commissioner of Income Tax has converted this idea into reality and now Dhanora has become role model of Rural Development. Dhanora village was also given an award by Prime minister of India Mr. Narendra Modi in the year 2018. Many argue that the developing world is exposed to the impact of climate change in two ways. Geography, exacerbated by economic weakness, has left many countries vulnerable to climate extremes and natural disasters. Additionally, much of the developing world faces an opportunity cost for climate resilient low carbon growth and socio-economic development in comparison to established economies, which were able to utilize fossil fuels freely to support their development. Nearly 1.3 billion people across the globe remain without access to electricity today and will find it challenging to achieve parity of development should they follow conventional models of development. Many such communities are often situated in remote areas, far away from urban centres and beyond the reach of national grid extensions. However, an exciting tranche of recent innovations in finance, renewable energy, Information and Communication Technology (ICT), mobile healthcare and biotech offer a unique opportunity for those 1.3 billion individuals to bypass the highly centralized and gas-guzzling model used by the established economies. In short, sustainable rural development can offer considerable advantages over historical approaches, reaping benefits for a demographic comprising 70 per cent of the world’s poor. The ‘smart village’ is a model in which, energy access acts as a catalyst for a range of development outcomes. If managed correctly, technology ‘leapfrogging’ could lead to rapid improvements in healthcare, nutrition, education, and economic security. Villagers could thus have the opportunity to capture many of the benefits of urban life while retaining valued aspects of rural life, and ensuring balanced development at a national level. Villagers can be empowered to realize their unique ambitions by picking and choosing the aspects of modernity they wish to incorporate into their communities. In doing so, they can take control over their own future, giving them a real choice between life in a city or a smart village. Residents would consequently be able to lead healthy and fulfilling lives, achieve their development potential, earn a viable living, and stay connected to the wider world. This model must consider not just the potential outcomes, but practical ways of 3 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES sourcing, financing, and sustaining the requisite energy generation. Fortunately, in many off-grid locations, renewable energy is increasingly seen as the most practical and economic option. For example, the increasing cost-effectiveness of photovoltaic-based technology applications and further scope of small hydroelectric resources offer development models involving new forms of energy generation. Sustainable energy access can enable the provision of good education and healthcare, access to clean water, sanitation and nutrition, the growth of productive enterprises to boost incomes, and enhanced security, gender equality, and democratic engagement. This vision is not without pitfalls. History is littered with expensive and ultimately flawed attempts by governments and development agencies to parachute infrastructure or technology into underdeveloped rural communities. Many of these actors have yet to realize the potential of energy access to transform lives and fail to take simple measures to promote progress. The Smart Villages Initiative aims to mitigate these difficulties. Our three-year ‘smart villages’ project will collect, analyse, and apply good practices and expertise from around the world on how sustainable energy can catalyse development. This collected knowledge will be presented directly to policy-makers and funders, enabling them to support and promote sound interventions. One early finding of our investigations is the importance of supporting local enterprise. Entrepreneurial ambition is both a driver and an outcome for the development of functioning smart villages. Small businesses generate not only wealth and employment but also demand for energy. Local entrepreneurs are also the best people to take ownership over power generation schemes and ensure that they are supported and maintained. The ingenuity of the Maasai in Terrat in northern Tanzania is a notable success story. The village has built a 300 KW dieselgenerating plant, fuelled by biofuel produced from locally grown Jatropha. The generator supports a mini-grid, which supplies electricity over 100 households, a radio station, a dairy, a village training and social centre, and several small shops and workshops. The social impact of the scheme has included improved health and new opportunities for income generation, giving to villagers reasons to stay within the community Introducing regulatory frameworks and financial instruments that support innovation and enterprise will be instrumental in promoting similar examples of sustainable rural development. The smart village model offers a 4 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES unifying framework that is also flexible enough to allow for different development pathways for a multitude of diverse rural communities. In turn, the smart village vision is potentially the key to achieving the post-2015 development agenda and the UN target of sustainable energy for all by 2030. By maintaining an inclusive network of stakeholders, ranging from governments, international development agencies, local NGOs, and the villagers themselves, the Smart Villages Initiative can facilitate vertical information exchange. The benefits of integrating knowledge across this spectrum are potentially significant, merging practical insight with strategic vision, all the while keeping our feet on the ground. By working closely with networks of science academies in each region, we also ensure our briefs are held to academic standards of rigour and are influential at a high level. The global scope of our engagement also provides a rare opportunity for information exchange between disparate regions. To date, Smart Villages has held workshops in East Africa and Southeast Asia. More workshops and other engagement activities are planned in South America, Central America, South Asia and West Africa. Whilst our vision may be ambitious, we believe that with broad engagement, and support from key institutions, governments, and media outlets it is eminently achievable. Most importantly, this model of sustainable development has the potential to significantly improve the lives of village communities worldwide and help ensure a sustainable future for everyone. SMART VILLAGES The idea behind smart villages revolves around shifting the paradigm, so that instead of considering small rural populations as recipients of government aid, they are equipped with the necessary means to become engines of change and productive centres. The determining factor in achieving this is the digitalisation of the villages. By using the internet and associated technologies, potential customers can be attracted from anywhere, improving efficiency, and therefore increasing produc -tivity, offering better customer service and creating job opportunities both locally and in other areas. The main obstacle is the digital divide, the difficulty in accessing 5 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES the internet outside large cities, and the lack of digital literacy, the lack of training to equip the population with the necessary skills. Implementation by states The following states and territories participate in the programme Andaman and Nicobar Islands Nagaland Odisha Puducherry Punjab Rajasthan Sikkim Tamil Nadu Telangana Tripura Uttar Pradesh Uttarakhand West Bengal Andhra Pradesh Arunachal Pradesh Assam Bihar Chhattisgarh Daman and Diu Gujarat Haryana Himachal Pradesh Jammu and Kashmir Jharkhand Karnataka Kerala Lakshadweep Madhya Pradesh Maharashtra Manipur Meghalaya Chandigarh Delhi Smart City-based development has become a trend of city development around the world. The development of Smart City is not just to improve the efficiency of the bureaucracy by utilizing information and communication technology (ICT), but also how to develop the community by making ICT infrastructure and facility as supporting factors or enablers. Smart city is defined as an innovative city on the use of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) and other means to improve its quality of life, efficiency of urban services, and 6 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES competitiveness, as well as sustainability. As a form of government support on Smart City development in Indonesia, Ministry of Communications and Informatics of Republic of Indonesia in collaboration with Ministry of Home Affairs, Ministry of Administrative and Bureaucratic Reform, Indonesia Ministry of National Development Planning/BAPENNAS, Ministry of Public Works and Human Settlement, Presidential Staff Office initiated the idea of 100 Smart City Movement of “Gerakan menuju 100 smart city”. In 2017, 25 cities/regencies were chosen to be accompanied and mentored by the experts in implementing Smart City concept. In 2019, this program targets as many as 100 cities/regencies in Indonesia that have implemented Smart City development and become models for other regions in Indonesia. The need for smart city in urban and rural areas was different, but there were some standards that must be met. The development of the village area was realized through smart village concept. Smart city and smart village are two different cases where the level of the broad are different regional size and problems, so that not all elements in Smart City were able to be applied to all regions in Indonesia. Based on law number 6 of 2014 about the village, the total of the villages is around 73.000 villages in regencies and around 8.000 villages in cities. Villagers were empowered to realize their unique ambitions by picking and choosing the aspects of modernity they wished to incorporate to their communities. Villages were more than cities, so they must take smart way for the improvement and development of the country as a whole. Smart Village was a new concept developed by the researchers from India, N. Viswanadham, and Sowmya Vedula. This concept was developed in 2010, by describing the ecosystem for a village and mapping the procedures of integrated design to build a smart village. The concept of smart village became an alternative for the development of rural areas in the current global era. "Smart village" was a solution to improve people’s quality of life in rural areas. In developing a smart village, the village government must set a goal, what must be developed first and what will become the supporter. The motivation behind "smart village" was technology must act as the development, bring through the education, local business opportunities, improve health and welfarea, increase democratic involvement, and improve the villager’s quality of life. This concept can be used as a basis for rural development in Indonesia. The regency in Indonesia that has begun to innovate in 7 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES the development of rural area is Banyuwangi Regency. In 2016, the District Government of Banyuwangi launched "Smart Kampung" program which was established through Regent Regulation Number 18 of 2016 concerning the Integration of Village/Urban-Based Work Programs Through Smart Kampung of Banyuwangi. This program designed a village to have an integrated program framework combining the use of optical fiber-based ICT, productive economic activities, creative economic activities, health-education improvement, and poverty alleviation efforts. The governance scope of "smart kampung" program was the implementation of public services for the community. In 2017, the enactment of Regent Regulation Number 60 of 2017 concerning the Implementati-on of Smart City Master Plan through Banyuwangi Smart Kampung was done. This regulation was attached to Banyuwangi Smart City Master Plan discussing the reference to short-term, medium-term and longterm development programs. This Master Plan adopted the smart city model developed by Ministry of Communications and Informatics covering 6 dimensions. However, Master Plan had not provided detailed explanation related to the application of "smart kampung" in each village in Banyuwangi Regency. Some legal products related to the development of "smart kampung" on http://jdih.banyuwangikab.go.id/ have not shown any models related to how "smart kampung" concept can be implemented. One legal product found was only Public Service Standard (SPM) from several villages, precisely there were 7 out of 189 villages whose SPM were on the page, including Ketapang, Cluring, Wringinrejo, Sumbersari, Plampangrejo, and Sempu Villages. Ketapang Village was the fastest growing village compared to other villages, with 35 services in 5 minutes as average standard of service. There were some differences in the number of services provided by each village, and the speed of service also varied. It showed that there were no standards used by all villages in the provision of services. In 2018, "smart kampung" program brought Banyuwangi Regency to the third place among 25 cities/regencies in the evaluation of phase 1 on "Gerakan menuju 100 smart city". It became the reason behind the selection of Banyuwangi Regency as the object of research. The concept of "smart kampung" have same subject with smart village concept. It has an innovation focusing on rural areas. This research was intended to propose the model of smart village for villages in Banyuwangi Regency. The arrangement of this model was adjusted with the 8 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES problems and characteristics of the research object, Banyuwangi Regency. The model developed was certainly supported by policies and regulations existed in order to be implemented optimally and brought positive impacts for the development of villages in Banyuwangi Regency. Fig.1.1 In India there are 6,00,000 villages out of them 1,25,000 villages are backward so there is a need for designing and building the village as a smart village. With modernization and urbanization people migrate from one place to another place for different facilities such as education, employment and affinity of people towards the locality or city. Village is main criteria for development of nation. So, develop the village in such a way that which is self dependant in providing the services, employment and well connected to the rest of the world i.e. smart village. The smart village corrects the social oversight by providing accommodations for sustainable family relationships without disturbing the lifestyle of different generations. The vision of smart village is that modern energy access can act as catalyst for development in education , health , productive enterprise , clean water , sanitation , environmental sustainability and participatory democracy which helps to support further improvement in access to energy . Initially the concept of development of village is of Mahatma Gandhi i.e. swaraj and suraj village . But, now days it is newly termed as smart village. We know that, India is a developing nation, with the help of smart village we can make India as a SS nation. Now days, our government also gives strong focus on smart village. Government implements so many schemes on smart village. 9 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES The phenomenal allocation of Budget 2018 for Agriculture and Rural Development sectors has attracted attention of media, policy makers, academicians and common people alike. This has come after 70 years of independence when the nation is still reeling under rural distress and agrarian crisis. According to Census 2011 data, 69% of India’s population, or around 833 million people of India, lives in rural areas, against 31%, or 377.1 million people, in urban areas. The World urbanization trends 2014 report from United Nations projected that the latter figure will jump to 50% by 2050.In this context, Ministry after a lot of brainstorming under the leadership of Honourable Prime Minister came up with a program named as Shyama Prasad Mukherji Rurban Mission (SPMRM). The main objective of the program was to make the villages smart and as growth centres of the nation. Through this program, government intended to breathe life into the statement “The soul of India lives in its villages” given by father of the Nation. The program was an ambitious attempt to transform rural areas into “Economically, Socially and Physically Sustainable spaces”, or smart villages “which would trigger overall development in the region”. The Prime Minister during the launch of the SPMRM program said that “It is true that people are moving from our villages with great speed. They want a certain quality of life good education, healthcare, electricity, Internet and entertainment options. The governments of the time didn’t think about how these people will settle in the city and how basic necessities will be provided. With this mission, this government has thought of a way to tackle that”. Till December 2017, 266 village clusters were adopted under SPMRM program against the target of 300 village clusters till 2019. Even though the term Smart Village has appeared in the program document of SPMRM but as it appears, the idea of developing smart villages has not come to the center stage in development discourses. Nevertheless, the concept has already gained currency in many development organizations both National and International across developed and developing nations. Perhaps time has now come to make fresh interventions with new momentum to gear up Building Of Smart Villages In India. Mahatma Gandhi envisioned the concept of an ideal village - a complete republic and independent of its neighbours for its vital daily needs. This is to ensure that every village grows enough food, milk and vegetables for villagers. It also has 10 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES a school and nobody is refrained of basic education. Primary education is mandatory and schools have playground, proper sanitation and drinking water. Village has to maintain its own water resources ensuring clean water to all. As far as possible every activity in the village is conducted in cooperation basis without any discrimination. Smart village also refers to a bundle of services delivered to its residents through community participatory approach in an effective and efficient manner (Figure 1). The services include affordable clean water, basic education, shelter and food, communication and transportation, job for the youths, farms and grazing fields for cattle and a proper market for agriculture produce. The concept implies the participation of local people in improving their economic, social or environmental conditions, cooperation with other communities, social innovation and the development of smart village strategies. Digital technologies can be applied to many aspects of living and working in rural areas. The smart village concept also suggests the adoption of smart solutions in both the public and private sectors over a wide range of policy fields such as improving access to services, developing short food supply chains and developing renewable energy sources. The smart village concept is gaining traction on the rural development agenda, coinciding with the ongoing reform of the common agricultural policy (CAP). A key element of this reform will be a new delivery model based on each Member State developing a CAP strategic plan. In December 2020, the Commission published its recommendations for each Member State on the direction their plans need to take to achieve the CAP objectives and the European Green Deal targets. The Commission’s analysis highlight the gaps Member States must address if the Green Deal target of 100 % access to fast broadband internet in rural areas by 2025 is to be met. Much will depend on how Member States respond to these recommendations in drawing up their CAP strategic plans. The European Parliament has made a significant contribution to the smart village concept, taking part in a pilot project on smart eco-villages and supporting the European Commission’s 2017 action plan for smarter villages. The European Committee of the Regions and the European Economic and Social Committee have meanwhile 11 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES both indicated their support for the concept through events, opinions and communications. In India, as per National Sample Survey (NSS) classification around 125,000 villages are truly backward out of 600,000 villages. In 2004, World Bank recognizes very poor human development in 18 regions out of 78 regions in the country. About 70 per cent of the Indian population lives in rural areas. These rural populations are vulnerable to poverty, illiteracy, poor health and unemployment. In order to handle these specific problems, government of India has brought a number of rural development programmes which are being implemented to create opportunities for improvement of the quality of life of these rural people. Out of such programmes Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana(SAGY) is a rural development programme mainly focusing on the development of villages Under SAGY, our Prime Minister Narendra Modi desires to develop around 2500 smart villages by 2019. As per this scheme, all the members of parliament of all the political parties should take the responsibility of developing physical and institutional infrastructure in villages and turn them into smart villages. The Socio economic development in Indian economy can be tackled by the Government by taking responsibility for uplifting the rural and the economically poorer sections. Initially in India, the National Informatics Centre (NIC) introduced the concept of smart village in several years back, but not streamlined. Recently, the concept of smart village in Indian context was explored and is mainly emphasizes the adoption of smart technologies at the village level to address the key sectors of water, power, housing, education, training, employment. All states, districts and local level institutions are required to provide the governance framework and will be supported by IT-enabled service delivery mechanisms at the village level. All these efforts are in initial stages and not much improvement has been achieved in most of the villages. The “emerging concept” (European Commission, undated) of smart villages has been actively promoted by the European Commission since around 2017 to describe a developing thematic policy priority.2 The most recent proposals for the future of the CAP (European Commission 2018 para 16) promote the development of smart villages across Europe. Two rather separate discourses frame the thinking and policy development around smart villages. First, the idea of smart villages is 12 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES framed by the presence of high-speed broadband and the application of wider digital technologies to support business innovation and wider community development. The Bled Declaration (2018) strongly emphasises this digital dimension and the ENRD (2018) argues that “broadband infrastructures, the availability of digital services and digital literacy are among the potential gaps that need to be filled on the road to smart villages”. Second, smart villages are seen as communities which build on the human and social capital of their inhabitants and local assets to support their development. Although Agricultural Commissioner Hogan (2018: 2) has stated that “smart villages are about people- they are about rural communities taking the initiative to find practical solutions to challenges and make the most of new opportunities,” often smartness is couched in terms of the availability and ability to use a robust digital infrastructure, with many references to a need for high speed broadband and IT-based solutions to a range of rural problems. Elsewhere, the Commissioner has argued for an “agri-tech revolution” and the use of advanced ICT at all stages in the food chain on the farm, through to processing and retailing.” 3 This would cover not just precision farming in the arable sector but every facet of farming from livestock enterprises to viticulture. Broadband rollout to “not spots” and improvements in broadband speed are seen by others as an essential enabling infrastructure development to improve rural business connectivity and improve the quality of life (Skerratt 2010). This dualistic characterisation of smart villages comprises a chaotic conception (Sayer 1984) which is a product of neoliberal thinking about innovation and specialisation and communitarian thinking about collaborative action. Can one have a smart village with very poor broadband services? Or, is the right mix of social capital a sufficient defining characteristic? The idea of smart villages is connected to the idea of smart specialisation, which has been explored in a rural context by Naldi et al. (2015) and Teräs et al. (2015), who question whether the village is the appropriate spatial scale to create the hubs of knowledge and innovation which underpin smart growth. Smart villages are also intimately connected to the concept of social innovation (ENRD 2018b). Social innovation is regarded as central to the recovery of the European economy in the aftermath of the economic crisis (Barroso, 2009), although the term is often considered to be weakly conceptualised, despite which, and as is also the case with smart villages, it has been rapidly adopted as a component of mainstream policy 13 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES rhetoric, although it is missing from the most recent CAP proposals (European Commission 2018). A smart village could thus be thought of as one that has confronted developmental challenges successfully to increase its resilience, often using social innovation as for the basis of such practices and ventures. Smart villages are loosely used as a descriptor for communities which have both strong human and social capital and good digital connectivity and whose capacity to deliver innovative solutions is high. The implied spatial scale is normally the physical community the village and its hinterland and there are strong implications in the rhetoric surrounding smart villages that smartness is a kind of collective property associated with successful innovation. 4 This implies that there must be un-smart or less smart villages. If such communities exist, and few would disagree that there are differences in overall socioeconomic performance between communities, arguably the researcher’s task should be to identify the features that differentiate one category from the other. Smart Energy Provision of clean and sustainable, energy is central to almost all other dimensions of rural development. Energy security is the secret mantra, which enables development in agriculture, health-care, education and skilling of rural communities. With a wide variety of solar, wind, biomass and biogas technologies now available at competitive costs, we are at the cusp of witnessing energy disruption and creating an abundant energy economy. For rural energy supply and management, the element of ‘smart’ refers to creation and management of mini, micro and nano grids within the energy eco-system of a village or a group of villages. It is particularly relevant to rural areas with no or unreliable grid connectivity. These micro / nano grids bring in the element of selfreliance in energy for rural community and create a possibility of giving back the surplus to the grid. Developing a village with this approach can usher in a new developmental model. The vision for a smart village revolves around energy security. Energy is the golden thread that connects economic growth, increased social equity, and an environment that allows the planet to thrive. One such case has been shared in the below for reference. 14 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Smart Connectivity Smart connectivity has two distinct connotations for smart village concept. One is to provide reliable and highquality broadband and voice communications. And the second, probably more importantly, through a range of Information and Communication Technology (ICT) solutions, applications and services, be an integral part of smart technology solutions for all other domains like smart agriculture, smart water management, smart education, smart health-care and so on. Rural communities tend to be politically disenfranchised due to their relative remoteness. Consequently, they lack information on societal issues and have difficulty becoming actively involved in debates about how to address them. Smart villages, through ICT, can allow rural communities to become more aware of their social, economic and political rights, engage in governance processes at all levels to the collective benefit and empowerment of all. Smart Agriculture For any village, its agricultural eco-system is one of the most intrinsic identities that directly relates to its social, environmental and financial fabric. Efficiency and productivity in agriculture is directly related to the farming practices adopted by the communities. Fortunately, the intersection of technology and agriculture has opened up a lot of opportunities for the farmer, consumer and suppliers. This intersection is now called as Precision Agriculture (PA). The development of PA is driven by Internet of Things (IoT), BDAA (Big data and advanced Analytics) and the plummeting cost of sensors in the semiconductor industry. Infusion of PA techniques and practices can drive transformation at every stage in agriculture. The immediate benefits are self-sufficiency for villages, generating business and increasing financial freedom for villagers (both farmers and suppliers). Smart Education Smart villages aim to increase the time available for students to study and will address prevalent factors that negatively affect the ability of students to acquire the knowledge and skills necessary to achieve economic goals and improve labor 15 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES productivity. ICT-equipped schools can provide a good deal of handholding in accessing internet and consequently the world’s knowledge base, ending the information isolation experienced by many rural communities. New opportunities can be generated for distance and adaptive learning, reducing the need to move to towns or cities to achieve higher levels of education. In addition, ICT and internet access also have a “pull factor”, providing incentives for school attendance and for attracting and retaining good teachers, addressing issues such as school dropouts and cognitive development. Smart Health At the most basic level, households in smart villages will be able to consume potable water and a more nutritious diet due to the reduced cost of boiling water and cooking food, and enhanced agricultural productivity arising from associated development initiatives and reduced wastage. ICT-enabled m-health initiatives can enable mobile health diagnostic solutions, requiring relatively low levels of local medical skill and providing access to specialist health-care services based in urban communities where necessary. Epidemiological data can be gathered, providing the opportunity for more effective interventions and early warning capability to address health related challenges such as malnourishment, underweight child birth, anemic mother etc. 2.6 Smart Environment Smart villages can be stewards of the environment aided by technologies to monitor key environmental indicators such as forest health, water quality, soil conditions and changes to the landscape. They can also reduce pressure on deforestation using efficient cook stoves to decrease the need for traditional biomass energy sources such as charcoal and wood a key driver of unsustainable forest use. Smart villages can host community-run recycling facilities ranging from those equipped to recycle wastewater and organic waste from agro-processing, to next-generation facilities for the recycling of e-waste, including energy-storage and generation technologies such as batteries and solar panels. Depending on geographical endowments, some smart villages will be able to operate as regional ecotourism hubs, an activity that can improve the welfare and connectivity of rural and urban communities. The aforementioned Villages have all emerged as Smart Villages but only in a particular domain. It’s not holistic in nature. 16 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES However, the pressing need of hour is to have a Smart Village with all sorts of comprehensiveness in it. Smart Infrastructure In order to ease life of villagers in every possible way, a village has to be well supported with infrastructure to enhance efficiency of habitants and efficacy of inputs from the villagers. The infrastructure includes roads, institution buildings, weather station equipment, hospital equipment, telephone towers etc. Most of these infrastructures can be established with well-intended village habitants and the guiding institutions through convergence of funds, functions and functionaries. Smart element needs to be included in every stage of infrastructure development. Initiatives of government under Unnat Bharat Abhiyan1 (UBA) and Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana (SAGY) are worth mentioning here in this section, for their intentions and outcomes. Development of Smart Villages: It is clear that the situations and challenges in developing urban and rural area are different due to the constraints and opportunities. Many researchers believe that the existing technologies developed for the smart city may be useful for the smart village concept. Researchers reported that the Smart village system can be developed on the lines of smart city model. The components taken in to consideration will vary from region to region for villages, based on the available resources and opportunities. Following are some generalized guidelines for the development of Smart Villages. 1. Economic Component: This component will include local administration and economic factors. It will cover governance models, bandwidth, mobility, cloud computing, entrepreneurship etc. 2. Environmental Component: This component will address the issues related to resources and infrastructures available at local level. It may covers cleaner 17 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES technologies, public and alternative transportation, green spaces, smart growth, climate change etc. 3. Social Component: This component may address issues related to community life, participatory democracy, social innovation, proximity services etc. Technologies For A Smart Village The new technologies are coming together to help the development of rural communities: IoT: the Internet of Things is linked to the concept of smart cities, but is also applicable in rural areas. For example, using sensors that allow crops to be more competitive or applied to education and health in isolated areas. Artificial intelligence: the adoption of artificial intelligence systems is directly applicable to improving crops and environmental management, as well as in optimising health services and infrastructure use. Big Data: the huge amount of data generated today (Big Data), allows changes in climate to be analysed accurately along with water consumption, livestock movements, the growth of pastures and forests, and other essential information. Drones: the use of drones, hectares of land can be monitored automatically thereby collecting data on temperature, crop status, animal movements or controlling the spread of pests, thus improving the use of pesticides. Robots: from autonomous tractors that do not need a driver to robots capable of picking delicate fruits one by one without damaging them, the introduction of robots in rural areas is driving a revolution in efficiency and sustainability. 18 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES CHAPTER-2 REVIEW OF LITERATURE 19 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES REVIEW OF LITERATURE This literature review was taken from books, journals, previous studies related to the smart city and smart village or smart rural. 1. A A Aziiza and T D Susanto (2020): Smart Village refers to a concept developed in rural area that provides solutions to problems occurred and improves the quality of life. The main problems faced by rural areas are cover poverty, low level of education, and limited access to technology. Smart village concept emerged due to some different characteristics between rural and urban areas. Banyuwangi Regency is one of regions that created smart concept starting from rural area, called smart kampung. So far, smart kampung only focused on public services, which included only a small part of smart city concept. Hence, this research was intended to propose the model of smart village examined through initial interview in village sample of Banyuwangi, literature reviews related to smart city, smart village, and smart rural. Then, the results were confirmed and adjusted to support local regulations. This research created a smart village model that was capable to be a guide for each village to develop towards better future. The proposed smart village model was categorized into 6 dimensions including (1) Governance, (2) Technology, (3) Resources, (4) Village Service, (5) Living, and (6) Tourism. This research is expected to be applied to villages in other Regencies by adjusting the characteristics of each region. 20 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Smart City Smart city was an adaptive city, possessing high capacity to react; the key was on the adaptation and learning capacity, in which the citizens as the main roles in reacting, listening and receiving learning itself, this learning must be done within groups. Smart city concept was operated in complex urban area, combined several complex infrastructures, human behaviour, technology, social structure and politic as well as economy. Smart city was more than digital city as it was able to connect the capital city physically with its social and develop the services and infrastructures of a better city by combining IT and politic vision to clear program for the city improvement and its services. Smart city had various models developed by the researchers around the world. The models developed were diverse, adjusted to the needs in certain areas. Smart city firstly was introduced by IBM in 2009 on a journal entitled “A vision of smarter city: How city can lead the way into a prosperous and sustainable future”. Hongkong Smart City Blue Print (2017) states that there were 6 areas of smart cities covering “Smart Mobility”, “Smart Living”, “Smart Environment”, “Smart People”, “Smart Government” and “Smart Economy”. Besides, there were other models mentioned by the researcher, according to Giffinger, there were 6 characteristics of smart city covered smart people, smart environment, smart living, smart mobility, smart governance and smart economy. In addition, smart city model developed in cities of overseas, Ministry of Communications and Informatics launched a model which was contained in the book of smart city guidance. This smart city model had a slight difference from the other model which lied on smart branding dimension to make a city able to display the face of each city through the tourism they had. There were 5 dimensions including: 1) smart government 2) smart economy 3) smart environment 4) smart living and 5) smart society 21 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Smart Village Smart Village was one of concepts for the developed villages in India. This concept was developed by Viswanadham and Vedula in their book entitled “Design of Smart Village”. A smart village model followed a model from smart city as an effect of integrated technology changes to be implemented in the remote areas. The aim of smart village was to help it solve all problems through the implementation of ICT (Information and Communications Technology) and GIS (Geographic Information System). Nowadays, Indonesia has implemented the concept of “nawacita” for regional development, this program prioritized the development in rural area. Smart village concept focused on the role of technology in building governance and public services. Technology used by Muke and Nilesh in their research was able to be used by people lived in rural area in order to improve their quality of life. The use of technology utilized by villagers was able to make them become more responsive. Smart village model based on the concept of “Access to Information for Everybody” in which ICT (Information and Communications Technology) service was reached easily by villagers through IIIC program. Smart village model developed by N. Viswanadham and S. Vedula was called as smart village ecosystem covering 4 aspects; 1) Institution, 2) Resources, 3) Service Chain and 4) Service delivery technologies & mechanism. Besides, there were 7 focus areas in smart village including economy, ICT, people, governance, environment, living and energy. Smart village existed because of ICT awareness that was able to be utilized as the instrument as the efforts of local economic development. The use of technology became a main factor in creating smart village. Based on Guzal-Dec, technology in smart village had important roles such as investing in the infrastructures, business development, human resources, potential and community building. 22 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES 2. David Freshwater (2000): Sustainable development is generally discussed in terms of environmental considerations, but from a rural community perspective, sustainable development must address how the people of the community generate the income to maintain their rural lifestyle. In those instances where employments considered as part of sustainability discussions, it is too often thought of in static terms jobs that will last. But the reality of both modern rural and urban life is that economic conditions rapidly change, and so a discussion of sustainable employment has to be conducted in a dynamic context where different types of employment evolve as economic conditions change. While market signals alone can, in principle, provide the information and the conditions for this type of dynamic process, the argument of the paper is that the nature of rural areas makes it unlikely for markets alone to allow sustainable employment. 3. Zhao Zhifeng (2009): The fast urbanization has become already a main characteristic of socioeconomic transition in China. This paper points out the characteristics and the problems of villages in Beijing metropolitan region. The paper also explores the role of villages in the metropolitan region in the process of urbanization. As a representative case, the Village System Planning of Changing District in Beijing is presented in this paper. According to the research on the economic and the spatial typologies of villages in Changing District, the villages are classified to three categories in the planning. In conclusion, by the guideline of categorization, the Village System Planning intends to solve those problems of villages under the background of fast urbanization so as to realize the sustainable development of rural area. 4. Dr. Milind Kulkarni (2010): In India majority of the population still lives in villages. A lot of work needs to be done in making the villages clean. There are different aspects of clean village such as: water supply, sanitation, indoor air quality, solid waste management and renewable energy etc. All these aspects have different alternatives with the 23 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES associated merits and demerits. In some aspects such as water supply, considerable work is done whereas in some areas like sanitation lot of work is required to be done. We can learn lot of lessons based on success and failure in adopting different alternatives. Keeping in touch with technology clean village projects should integrate technology and digital design, which will make the village not only clean but also smart. The paper discusses all these aspects with reference to Maharashtra and India. This discussion plans to give important inputs and alternatives to policy makers so that they can redirect and reformulate the policy. Engineering students can design and implement projects of clean and smart village which will help in their skill development. At the end paper gives recommendations for effective making of Clean and Smart Village. 5. N. Viswanadham, SowmyaVedula (2010): we describe the ecosystem for a village and then map out an integrated design procedure for building a smart village. We define a Smart Village as a bundle of services which are delivered to its residents and businesses in an effective and efficient manner. Dozens of services including construction, farming, electricity, heath care, water, retail, manufacturing and logistics are needed in building a smart village. Computing, communication and information technologies play a major role in design, delivery and monitoring of the services. All the techniques and technologies needed to build a smart village are available now and some of them are being used in villages in India but these are disparate, fragmented and piecemeal efforts. We recognize that the need of the hour is strategy, integrated planning and above all monitoring and execution of the activities using appropriate governance models. Our integrated design is a way forward to deal with the demographic deficit and also achieve the goals of inclusive growth. It is replicable and can be used to design and build smart villages in other parts of the World. 6. Haslenda Hashim, Wai Shin Ho, Jeng Shiun Lim, Sandro Macchiato (2013): Integrated biomass solar town concept is a concept which encourages local community to utilize biomass waste comprehensively with strong ties between community and local stakeholders. This paper discusses about an Integrated 24 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Biomass Solar Town for eco village with and without load shifting (LS). On the other hand, the energy storage (ES) is also incorporated which could help cut electricity demand during peak periods and smoothing variations in power generation by variable solar power. A substantial technical and economic benefit was achieved through the implementation of integrated (LS) and ES. In this study, LS issued mainly to increase demand during periods of high supply and also shift the load to interval with low demand hence reduce the size of ES significantly. The concept is one of the great initiatives to spur economic growth and environmental protection through energy efficiency improvement and deployment of low-carbon technologies. 7. Parminder Kaur & Anshu Parashar(2021): According to the United Nations, Sustainable Development Goals are framed for improving rural health, hunger, poverty issues, environmental conditions, and illiteracy globally. With the upcoming technology, there have been many advances in the lifestyle of people all around the world. Comparatively, more emphasis has been given to the development of urban areas than rural. The sustainable development of a country depends on the growth of its rural areas. Countless technological and theoretical models, projects, and frameworks have been proposed and implemented to help overcome sundry issues and challenges faced by rural people in quotidian life. New technological methods are deemed to be the future of livability, therefore; a technologically advanced solution for sustainable rural development is called for. Blockchain Technology is the next step for innovation and development and it has far many applications in sustainable rural development that are yet to be discovered. The objective of this paper is to explicitly review research conducted in rural development to fill the undone work in the future with better research ideas, to make rural areas a livable and advanced place while also maintaining their integrity leading to sustainable development. To conduct such a review, a systematic research methodology is applied following regulations in the conduction of standardized but explorative analysis. Within the timeline of 2010–2021, 112 papers are carefully selected to perform the systematic review. This review will provide a comprehensible as well as concise research compendium for all applications proposed, implemented, and possible in the future to realize the 25 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES concept of smart villages for the development of rural areas using blockchain technology. 8. Simona Stojanova, Gianluca Lentini, Emilija Stojmenova Duh(2021): Highlighting the important role of rural development, this paper represents a review of rural policies. Data were generated, including a broad literature research and online survey on existing and future, post-2020 rural development policies. The survey was shared among project partners from six different EU Member States including eleven regions, all from the Alpine Space. The number of total policies covered in this review paper, together with policy projects, programs or actions, is 114. Based on these, key policy findings and future recommendations are provided, attributing to the future studies on this topic as well as for policymakers at the local, regional, national and EU levels. 9. Dr. Milind Kulkarni(2015): Clean and Smart Village: In India 70% population still lives in the villages. Present scenario of the government is to be work out on the Swachh Baharat Abhiyan for making village clean. There are different aspects of making clean villages such as: drainage system, solid waste management and renewable energy sources etc. 10. Pritesh Y Shukla: A smart village known for its citizens, available resources, available services and schemes. Smart village start focuses on renewable energy resources, basic amenities and liable individual and community behavior to build a vibrant and happy society. The motivation behind the concept on “Smart Village” is that the technology should acts for development, education and local business opportunities, improving health and welfare. 11. Trivedi, Kafeel Ahmad: Solid waste management in India, Solid waste management is one of the major environmental problems in Indian villages. Improper management of solid 26 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES waste causes hazards to inhabitants. Various study reveal that about 90% of solid waste is disposed of unscientifically in open dumps and landfills. Thus, creating problems to public health and the environment. In the present study, an attempt has been made to provide a comprehensive review of the characteristics, generation, collection and transportations disposed and treatment technology of solid waste practiced in India. The study pertaining to solid waste management for Indian villages has been carried out to evaluate the current status and identify the major problems. Various adopted treatment technologies for solid waste management are critically reviewed, along with their advantages and limitations. 12. Shanmuga Priyan (2019): The Future of India lies in its villages" Mahatma Gandhiji. A smart village knows about its citizen, available resources, applicable services, and schemes. It knows what it needs and when its needs. The concept of the smart village makes the villages self-sufficient in respect of their needs. It will encompass a sustainable and inclusive development of all sections of the village community so as they enjoy a high standard of living. This paper presents the development of the village as a smart village by providing the basic facilities in a hasty manner from past literature. We make smart villages by taking a smart decision using smart technologies and services. 13. Rutuja Somwanshi (2016): They study the project report deals with study and development of smart village. Smart village is one of the energy access acts as a catalyst for development in education, health, security, productive enterprise, environment that in turns support further improvement in energy access. This report focuses on improved resource use efficiency, local selfgovernance, access to assure basic amenities and responsible individual and community behavior to build happy society. Smart village by taking smart decisions using smart technologies and services. 14. Dr. C. Grace Indira and V. Anupama (2016): Explain besides smart cities, it is necessary for us to have smart village for, sustainable and inclusive future of emerging India. Smart villages are the need of 27 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES the hour as development is needed for both rural and urban areas for improved livelihood. The impulsive motive behind the concept 'smart village' is that the technology. Now it's need of the hour is integrated planning, strategy, and above all monitoring and execution of the activities using proper governance models to work property for the real future of emerging India. They focuses on the key areas as vision and need for smart villages, approaches, government programmes, technology used for smart villages, areas of interest in smart village and it outcomes expected. 15. Boda Ramesh (2016): Explains concept of smart village is the development of the village shall be based on the five path that is retrofitting, redevelopment, green fields, E-pan, livelihood, 69% of India lives in villages, if it is ignored, then it will hamper the economic growth of the country. Villages are backbone of our countries economic growth as most of the primary sector activities occur in villages. To explore new opportunities and dimensions for the rural population in other sectors will definitely boost the country growth. In that path smart village is an initiation through the concept of Rurbanization. 16. Ankit D. Gangani, Mehulkumar A. Dungrani, Kuldeepsinh Y. Jadeja (2016): They study the planning aspects for betterment of smart Indian village. Smart villages are the need of the hour as development not just for rural areas but for integrated urban growth including smart cities as well for better livelihood. Planning for betterment of smart village is needs smartness in technology, ecofriendly environment, maximizing employment potential of rural youth. Taking education, skill for vocations etc. to villages can well channelize the energies of the youth as a powerful tool for the nation. Most of the overall development of the country can be possible with the development of the villages only. 28 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES CHAPTER 3 RESEARCH METHODOLOGY 29 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES RESEARCH METHODOLOGY The methods used to arrange a model in this research were done through preliminary interview, literature review of previous studies, books and analysis of supporting regulations. Literature review was taken by selecting journals according to the definition of the model used and the examples of its applications. Then it was continued by an analysis of local regulations dealing with the research object, Banyuwangi Regency. Fig.3.1 Research Methodology This research carried out the preliminary interview to obtain information related to the general overview of smart kampung implementation in Banyuwangi Regency. The criteria of the informants were Head of Village, TI Staff or service staff and head of department or staff at related department in Banyuwangi Regency. Literature review was done afterwards to find out the definition, model and implementation of smart kampung. Literature review of this research was taken from the database of electronic journals such as Scopus, IEEE, Emerald Insight, Springer, Science Direct and Google Scholar. The keywords used to find the literature were ‘smart village’ and ‘smart rural’. The keywords used were not 30 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES specified by the year. The “smart village” keyword shows that there were 78 research documents of Science direct database, 87 research documents of IEEE, 1680 research documents of Google Scholar, 84 research documents of Springer database and 36 research documents of Emerald insight database. Another keyword, “smart rural”; showed that there were 23 research documents of Science direct database, 10 research documents of IEEE, 578 research documents of Google Scholar, 127 research documents of Springer database and 8 research documents of Emerald insight database. In a total, there were 2711 research document search on “smart village” and “smart rural” around the world. Based on these results, not every document was analyzed. The researcher verified the redundant documents and filtered based on its titles. The selection results collected 138 journal documents referring “smart village” and “smart rural”. These documents then were read and analyzed based on definition, model and examples of application. There were 25 journal documents selected in the final analysis. These documents were then analyzed by using mapping method concerning the objective, model and examples of its application. The results were confirmed by related regulations to produce smart village model of this research. Mahatma Gandhi envisioned the concept of an ideal village - a complete republic and independent of its neighbours for its vital daily needs. This is to ensure that every village grows enough food, milk and vegetables for villagers. It also has a school and nobody is refrained of basic education. Primary education is mandatory and schools have playground, proper sanitation and drinking water. Village has to maintain its own water resources ensuring clean water to all. As far as possible every activity in the village is conducted in cooperation basis without any discrimination. Smart village also refers to a bundle of services delivered to its residents through community participatory approach in an effective and efficient manner. The services include affordable clean water, basic education, shelter and food, communication and transportation, job for the youths, farms and grazing fields for cattle and a proper market for agriculture produce. 31 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.3.2 Frame Work The Smart Village Framework for a region depends on the resource availability, people’s occupation, co-operation between the villagers and social acceptance. It is indeed important to understand the dynamics of socio-economic aspects of the village with geographical features and quantifying available resources. Knowledge of current skills and practices with gaps in the agriculture, energy, water resource and livestock management will help in choosing apt technologies for sustainable development. Smart village framework essentially management approach based on the nature’s principles with sustainable technical interventions to achieve self-reliance in food, water, energy, education, job and other vital needs. The framework embraces local resources and skilled man power to ensure sustainable intervention of technology which are technically feasible, economically viable, user and environment friendly. The primary step is to quantify the available natural resources in the region which include land, water, energy and human resource. Status or the quality of the resource is also an important factor to be considered apart from quantity in order to implement technological interventions. However, educated and sensible human power is the most important resource as they constitute ultimate users and stakeholders of the all other natural wealth. 32 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Technology is basically utilisation of resources to achieve required outcome such as agriculture and agro processing, livestock and milk products, oil seed cropping and oil extraction, medicinal plants and herb production etc. On the other hand, technology can also help to improve the resource status and balance the natural system. For example, percolation ponds and check dams across the streams will increase the water percolation and recharges the ground water. Planting grass like lemon grass and trees in slopes conserves soil and water. Technological interventions should be aptly chosen for optimum utilisation of resources and the sustainable development of region. Sustainability is a qualitative as well as quantitative parameter which is tagged with every process. In a village scenario sustainability refers to the revitalising the resources with a feedback process ensuring a closed operating cycle. Ideally, any process which displaces resource to achieve an outcome, either help in generating the utilised resource or should have neutral effect of the environment. Nevertheless, most of the village processes bring resources back to the system either in a residual form with technological interventions. For illustration, soil fertility used for agriculture is recuperated from organic manure, where agriculture residue is used as livestock fodder. The feedback process has to be maintained to ensure sustenance of resources. Proposed smart village framework ensures the sustainable agriculture, livestock, horticulture, energy utilisation and water exploitation. Local institutional support plays a major role in achieving sustainable development of any region. Gram panchayat plays a key role in the implementation of developmental activities and also to get the feedback of stakeholders. It also coordinates with external institutions and with the other village committees such as Self Help Group (SHG), Village Forest Committee (VFC) etc. Intra village organisations and NGOs help in motivating the villagers and also to spread awareness about new schemes and rights. Research organisations (both government and private) can also impact the rural environment through vocational trainings, scientific technological introduction, CSR initiatives etc. 33 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana (SAGY): Sansad Adarsh Gram Yojana (SAGY) was initiated by Govt. of India with the vision to make at least one Gram Panchayat as an “Ideal Panchayat (Adarsh Gram)” from each Member of Parliament (MP) constituency every year. Guidelin es narrate possible interventions in the village and also the government departmen ts which are responsi-ble developments. A Member of the Parliament needs to adopt a Gram Panchayat from his constituency and understand the needs of people, status of resources and develop a village development plan which is executed with the help of various administrative departments. Ragihalli Gram panchayat of Bengaluru Urban district is adopted under SAGY programme by Shri Ananth Kumar, Member of Parliament, Bangalore South, Bangalore and Honourable union Minister for Chemicals and Fertilisers. The village is located about 32 km from Bengaluru city centre in Jigani Hobli, Anekal taluk of Bengaluru urban district in Karnataka. The Ragihalli panchayat shares a common boundary with Bannerghatta National park which was Ragihalli state forest before 1972. Rural Development: Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) were framed for improving rural health, hunger, poverty issues, environmental conditions, and illiteracy globally. The present situation of rural areas brings us to a list of issues (Fig. 1) that can further promote the eradication of rural areas from the global chain if not technologically. Beginning with poverty which has been an issue unresolved regardless of the various monetary schemes provided by the government drives the young generation out of the community to find jobs to sustain daily needs. Many of them fail to finish even high school, which leads to securing menial jobs in urban regions. This brings us to the second issue in the rural community, illiteracy. Education that plays a vital role in the overall development of humans, as well as the community, is often disregarded to fulfill contemporary requirements such as money. In many cases, the parents exploit their children into working on the farm or small family businesses. 34 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Concept: The basic concept of smart village is to collect community efforts and strength of people from various streams and integrate it with information technology to provide benefits to the rural community. According to Mahatma Gandhi’s philosophy and thoughts smart village project provides, “Global means to the local needs.” The concept of smart village is defined as below S - Social, skilled and simple. M - Moral, methodical and modern. A - Aware, adaptive and adjusting. R - Responsive and ready T - Techno savvy and transparent Zero Requirement Of Smart Village: 1. Smart security. 2. Efficient public transportation system. 3. Improving sanitation conditions 4. Solid and liquid waste management 5. Rain harvesting /Rain water drainage system. 6. Safe drinking water facilities. 7. Use of renewable energy. 8. Energy conservation. 9. Grievance redresser. 10. Strengthening CBOs. 35 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES 11. Functional bank account. 12. Facilities regarding to the agriculture. 13. Latest& affordable medical facilities. 14. E-governance. 15. Use of modern technologies for improvement of locality. 16. Improvement on women empowerment. 17. Educational facilities Benefits: Locally produced and locally consumed energy: In villages if the mountains, hilly area are present then use of solar energy & wind energy then energy is produce in that village itself & use for development of village. Creation of job: Generally village people migrate from village to city for purpose of job. If village becomes smart so all the job requirements are fulfills & people not migrate from one place to another. Contribution to global environment: The system can reduce reliance on fossil fuels &contribute to reduction of green house gases such as carbon dioxide .Energy consumption optimization 25-30% average energy saving. For farmer e-learning etc. facility that will be able to ask there quarries online. New technologies in education, e-learning, desktop publishing, horoscope generation of interested person of the village. Transportation of village into comfortable & safe space that enhance quality. NGO’s Role: NGOs play important role in rural development of India. NGOs acts as Planner & Implementers of Developmental Plans and perform a variety’s of services & Humanitarian. 36 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES NGOs services focus on assessing individual strength and settling personal goals& encourage overall growth and development. NGOs play role in co-ordination, collaboration and bridge he communication between the govt., private sectors. NGOs creating awareness among the public active to promote education.Ex.Education of girls .NGOs have important role in bringing about social change and development. The projects like construction of Dams, Roads, Highways’, railways& important role in religious discrimination. The role of NGOs has a very important to protection of environment through social services. NGOs are taking up this job sportingly and successfully. Peoples Role: • Inculcating hygienic behavior and practices.ART • Inculcating respect for the cultural heritage. • Volunteerism: activities for promotion of voluntarism like Bhrat Nirman. • Reducing risk behavior - alcoholism, smoking, substance abuse. • Behavioral changes.various programs implemented by grampanchayat, • Drinking water pipeline is under construction with the help of rashtriy peyjal yojna, • Mahatma Gandhi national rural employment guarantee scheme – under this jalygovt. scheme is under construction. Government Contribution: a) Reorienting education towards sustainable development: • Education is critical for promoting sustainable development and improving the capacity of the people to address the environment and development issue. 37 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES • Basic education provides underpinning for any environment and development education , the latter needs to be incorporated as essential part of learning . • It is critical for achieving ethical awareness, values and attitudes, skills and behavior consistent with sustainable development and for effective public participations in decision making. • To achieve the accessibility of environment education , linked to social education from the primary school age through adulthood to all groups of people. b) Increasing public awareness: • Public awareness should be recognized as a process by which human beings and societies can teach their fullest potential. • Small scale enterprise promotion through social media. • Education empowerment and access to information through smartphones. • By making Motivational Videos. c) Promoting training programs: • Government with the help of non-government authorities can arrange various trainings to aware the people . • Implement various schemes and projects in accordance with policies. • Training for all age group people. • With the help of social media, motivational speeches and videos we can give training to the people. Solid Waste Management: • Establish a waste collection, transport and treatment within the panchayat. • The collected waste should be segregate into biodegradable and nonbiodegradable at each house itself by making two dustbins, 38 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Green dustbin = bio degradable waste Red dustbin = non biodegradab le waste. • From bio-degradable waste we can prepare bio-compost and vermincompost and non-biodegradable is sold to recyclers or sent to the landfills. • To collect this waste, under Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme grampanchayat appoint a team of trained youth called as Friends of nature who do entire operation starting from collection to composting and land fill. The no. of friends of nature, 1 for 150 households. So, number of friends required for JAVALGAO village, No. of houses = 1095 No. of green friends required = 1095/150 = 6. • For this management, various tools and equipments are required for daily collection and treatment of waste and the land required to construct treatment plant and capital cost required to construct vermin-compost bed and shed which are obtained under Solid Waste Management Scheme Fund and Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme. • For collection of waste tricycle is required, 1 for 300 households. • Therefore for JAVALGAO, provide 3 tricycles. • The payment of Green Friends will be given for first 100 days from Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme and next 100 days from Solid Waste Management Scheme Fund. • After that village panchayat may use its own revenue generated from solid waste management activities and users fees. • The user fee is Rs-30/month for each household at doorstep with receipt. • On an average each village panchayat may require 5.5 lakh for solid waste management. 39 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES RO Plant: • Reverse osmosis (RO) is a water purification technology that uses semipermeable membrane to remove ions, molecules and larger particles from drinking water. • About 60% of diseases afflicting the rural population are waterborne. • So, instead of spending money on medical facilities use clean drinking water. Total population of the JAVALGAO village is near to 5000. o In javalgao, there are 1095 families and which carry 20 liter water daily. • Therefore provide 2 RO plant of capacity 2000 lph having cost of 10 Lakh each and which is implemented under the various scheme of Department Of Rural Development And Panchayat Raj. • With RO plant provision of WATER ATM is done to solve the problems such as delivery of water using manpower and payment related issue. • The cost of one liter of water is 50 paise. • The total cost required for Ro plant is 20 lakh and for water atm and installation cost of 10 Lakh is required. Rainwater Harvesting: Rainwater Harvesting is a technique of collection and storage of rainwater into natural reservoirs and tanks, or the infiltration of surface water into subsurface aquifers. The rainwater harvesting is of different types such as, a) Directly from roof tops and stored in tanks, b) Monsoon runoff and water in swollen streams during the monsoon and storing it in underground tanks, c) Water from flooded rivers can be stored in small ponds, d) Collection and transfer of rainwater into percolation tanks. So as to facilitate discharge into ground. e) But for village we use roof rainwater harvesting for houses. 40 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES f) With rooftop harvesting, most any surface tiles, metal sheets, plastic but not grass or palm leaf can be used to intercepts the flow of rainwater and provide a clean water and year-round storage. Other uses include water for gardens, irrigation of annual crops pastures and trees, domestic and livestock consumption, ground water recharge. g) The rainwater harvesting is mandatory to all in village. h) The reasons for using rainwater harvesting systems answer three questions: What: rainwater harvesting will improve water supply, food production, and ultimately food security. Who: Water insecure household or individuals in rural areas ill benefit the most from rainwater harvesting system. How: Since rainwater harvesting leads to water supply which food security, this will greatly contribute to income generation. Advantages: 1. Rainwater harvesting provides a good supplement to other water sources .Thus relieving pressure on other water sources. 2. It can be as a buffer and can be used in times of emergency or breakdown of public water supply systems. 3. Helps to reduce the storm drainage load and flooding in the cities. 4. It is a flexible technology and can be built to require meets of any range .Also the construction, operation and maintenance is not very labour intensive in most systems. 5. Prevents water wastage by arresting soil erosion and mitigates flood. 6. Sustains and safeguards existing water table through recharge. 7. Arrests sea water intrusion and prevents salination of ground water. 41 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Income Source: The main business of people in javalgao village is agriculture and along with that poultry, business related with dairy products, animal conservation, nursery. Agriculture: • Agriculture has a significant role in the socioeconomic fabric of India. About 70% people in India do the agriculture. • The history of agriculture in India dates back to the RugVeda. Today India ranks second worldwide. • Now a day the major problem is of scarcity of water and it is same in our selected village. • To avoid this problem, avoid the production of crops which require more quantity of water like sugarcane, banana etc. while taking crops first check the quality of soil and according to that take crops which are suitable. • To reduce the wastage and overuse of water use latest modern techniques like drip irrigation, sprinkler irrigation and so on. • As a main business government launches so many schemes which help to reduce stress and pressure generated in farmers mind because of today’s condition. • The schemes are, 1. Soil health card scheme. 2. National agricultural development program to promote use of organic farming. 3. Fertilizer subsidy. 4. Bank loans, free electricity. 5. Gram Swaraj Abhiyan. Saksham Kisan, samriddh Bharat. 42 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES 6. Pradhan Mantri Fesal Bima Yojna (PMFBY). 7. Crop intensification such as SRI. 8. Micro-irrigation, Agro-service center. 9. Setting up seed banks In Andhra Pradesh the government has introduced the 'Seven Star Formula' for development of smart villages. The formula includes the following schemes: 1. Power supply to every household in all villages, LED bulbs everywhere. 2. Gas connection for every household 3. Drinking Water for all villages 4. Toilet for every house, setting up vermicompost units, underground drainage system 5. CC roads, school, play ground, anganwadi center and internet facility 6. Pond for village, planting for greenery. 7. At least Rs. 10,000 income for every family in the village 43 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES CHAPTER 4 DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION 44 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES DATA ANALYSIS AND INTERPRETATION Fig 4.1 Representation of No. of respondents based on which part they are from? Which part of India you are Count of Which part of from? India you are from? Percentage(%) North 3 10.3 South 26 89.7 Total 29 100 Table 4.1 Representation of No. of respondents based on which part they are from? Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 29 responses, 89.7% of people are from the southern part and remaining 10.3% of people are from the northern part of India. 45 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.4.2 Representation of No. of respondents are from which state? Which state you are from? Count of Which state you are from? Percentage(%) Andhra Pradesh 20 69 Karnataka 8 27.6 Kerala 1 4.4 Total 29 100 Table.4.2 Representation of No. of respondents are from which state? Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 29 responses, 69% of people are from Andhra Pradesh, 27.6% of people are from Karnataka and the remaining 4.4% of people are from Kerala. 46 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.4.3 Representation of No. of respondents who mare from rural areas? Are you from Rural area? Count of Are you from Rural area? Percentage(%) Maybe 2 6.83 No 19 65.5 Yes 8 27.67 Total 29 100 Table.4.3 Representation of No. of respondents who mare from rural areas? Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 29 responses, 27.67% of people are from rural area, 65.5% are not from rural area and the remaining 6.83% of people may be from rural area. 47 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.4.4 Representation of No. of respondents have idea about smart villages? Do you have any idea about smart villages? Count of Do you have any idea about smart villages? Percentage(%) No 18 62.1 Yes 11 37.9 Total 29 100 Table.4.4 Representation of No. of respondents have idea about smart villages? Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 29 responses, 37.9% of people are from rural area, 62.1% are not from rural area. 48 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.4.5 Representation of No. of respondents what they think their govbernament is well being towards there area? Do you think your present government is well being towards your areas? Count of Do you think your present government is well being towards your areas? Percentage(%) Maybe 7 24.1 No 14 48.3 Yes 8 27.6 Total 29 100 Table.4.5 Representation of No. of respondents what they think their govbernament is well being towards there area? Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 29 responses, majority of 48.3% of people think that their present government is not well being towards their areas, 27.6% of people say that their present government is well being towards their areas and the remaining 24.1% of people tell that their present government might be doing good towards their areas. 49 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.4.6 Representation of No. of respondents think there is an impact of villages in development of India? Do you think there is an impact of villages in development of India? Count of Do you think there is an impact of villages in development of India? Percentage(%) Maybe 2 6.9 No 5 17.2 Yes 22 75.9 Total 29 100 Table.4.6 Representation of No. of respondents think there is an impact of villages in development of India? Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 29 responses, 75.9% of people tell there is an impact of villages in development of India, 17.2% of people tell no, and the remaining 6.9% of people tell theirs no impact of villages in development of India. 50 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Fig.4.7 Representation of No. of respondents gave ratings for their government How much ratings you will give for your government? Count of How much ratings you will give for your government? Percentage(%) 1 5 17.2 2 7 24.1 3 9 31 4 4 13.8 5 4 13.8 Total 29 100 Table.4.7 Representation of No. of respondents gave ratings for their government Interpretation: From the above table it is inferred that out of 26 responses, majority of 31% of people have given 3 star ratings to their government, 24.1% of people have given 2 star, 17.2% of people have given 1 star that is the lowest rating, 13.8% of people have given 4 star, and remaining 13.8% of people have given 5 star rating to their government. 51 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES CHAPTER 5 BUSINESS PROPOSITION/SUSTAINABLE SOLUTION 52 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES BUSINESS PROPOSITION/ SUSTAINABLE SOLUTIONS Empowering Villages with Frugal Technologies and Open Business Models Creating a Transport Business Plan Choosing a Transport Business: Transport businesses can be broadly categorized into passenger transport and goods transport businesses. Passenger transport includes taxis and other commercial vehicles that are used to ply passengers and goods within villages, towns, and also between different cities and states. Freight or goods transport can also be within regional geographical locales or across cities and countries. Unlike passenger transport, goods or freight transport carries raw materials and ready-made goods for consumption, retail business or industries Getting to know the Business: Like any other business enterprise, one needs to conduct research to understand the feasibility and profitability of a business enterprise. Since this may vary regionally, one will need to understand the specification of the transport business market in the regions that one wants to operate in. This will include the fleet of vehicles that a business owner will have to invest in, the loan schemes available for setting 53 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES up such a business, important and popular routes, and making business connections with already successful entrepreneurs in the transport business Registering the Transport Business: To set up any kind of transport business, one will require legitimate licenses for the transport personnel and vehicles that are registered for business purposes. Legitimate licenses are mandatory for the setting up and management of a transport business Investing in Transport Vehicles: While this may seem an obvious step, this needs meticulous research if the business has to succeed. While the first criteria of choice will be based on the nature of the business i.e. whether passenger or goods transport, one will further need to choose the appropriate kind of vehicles that will be practicable for the given context Insurance and Tracking Devices for Transport Vehicles: In the case of both vehicles for personal use or for business, vehicle insurance is mandatory. Today, however, there are also various tracking devices that can in fact prevent theft or help in the retrieval of stolen vehicles. Especially in the case of goods transport vehicles, one can also avail of extra insurance for goods that are being transported Organizing the Business Team: Drivers: For passenger or freight transport businesses, the primary personnel is the drivers. All drivers need to be above 18 years with legitimate licenses and adequate driving experience supplemented by onthe-job training. In the case of freight transport, truck drivers should possess a commercial license for large vehicles Customer Care Executives and Accountants: Like any business, a professional customer care department is important for an efficient and smoothly operating transport business. The business will also need a good accounts team that can efficiently manage income and expenditure balances Advertising the Company: Over and above the necessary logistics and research in order to set up a transport business, one of the most important components of setting up a successful transport business is a strong advertising campaign to promote the business 54 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Transport Business Options In rural and urban India, there exists a complex system of public and private transport services constituted of a variety of motor vehicles such as auto-rickshaws, taxis, buses, and trucks catering to a wide demographic. These systems are distributed across a range of services such as public transport, on-demand conveyance, freight transport, and healthcare. Below are some of the transport services and transport business options that new entrepreneurs can invest in, 1. Taxi Service: Taxi service is one of the most lucrative transport business options these days. While a large portion of this market has been captured by ride-hailing and ride-sharing businesses like Ola and Uber, a large population continues to use private taxi services for intra-city, inter-city, and inter-state travel. With fast-expanding digital networks creating large data networks between entrepreneurs and consumers, a taxi business can be a highly profitable enterprise. 2. Bicycle Rental: While motor vehicles provide quickness, they are also environmentally unsustainable. With increasing awareness regarding ecological sustainability, many people today seek to use modes of transport that are less polluting and also offer the chance towards a healthier lifestyle. Owing to this, one can also consider bicycle rental services as a viable and profitable transport business alternative. 3. Freight and Logistics Services: Freight transport is possibly one of the oldest transport services and has changed only in form, owing to better motor vehicle technology and larger digital networks. Since it was and continues to remain absolutely necessary for a variety of business enterprises, freight transport services are one of the most profit-making transport business options. 4. Specialty Transportation: Specialty transportation can be considered as a subset of freight or goods transport where one can devise specialized transport services for specific industry needs such as the transport of huge industrial machines, large mechanical components such as airplane parts, windmills, etc. It also includes other specialized services such as modular houses, perishable frozen items, human organs, etc. 55 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES 5. Livestock Transportation: Livestock is a primary component of many manufacturing industries and forms an important part of the supply chain for these enterprises. Livestock is also more vulnerable than other kinds of goods and this demands specialized kinds of transport services that can be tapped into by new entrepreneurs in the transport business. 6. Healthcare Transportation: Healthcare transportation can include ambulance services for medical emergencies and emergency services for road accidents etc. Logistics and transport business requires a lot of investment and to carry out that investment business owners should be well aware of all the necessary information required to start a new business. Therefore, it is highly recommended to frame a detailed transport business plan to make a base for your business to further grow and flourish. How to establish an Agriculture Business? 1. The best way to start an agriculture business plan or activity is to conduct market research on the available resources and technology. 2. Farming is a technically intense process and requires the help of qualified and experienced professionals. 3. Market research shows that organic farm business plan is on a high along with partnerships with the retail chains, food delivery start-ups and large restaurants. 4. The most important thing in the business is the quality and trust of the business partners and individual customers. 5. The hybrid seeds available in the market and the knowledge of fertilizers and other inputs are essential. 6. The most important step is to decide what to grow and where to grow along with the amount of the produce. 7. The agriculture farm business plan itself has a lot of divisions and varieties. 56 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Innovations in agriculture business and start-up enterprises The medicinal plants, such as Aloe Vera and Neem are targeted by the medical and pharmaceutical industries for mass production The plants require high inputs at the initial stage but have a promising sustainable revenue generation capability and growth rate The other important requirement or decision is the place. There are many options available, such as backyard, renting an open space, large balconies or even the terraces Once the place and the varieties of produce are decided, whether it is the seasonal vegetables or the medicinal plants the next step is to take help of an expert to create a financial plan for the whole farm business plan Making business plan for your agriculture business 1. The financial plan will include all the initial and running costs along with the revenue generation calculations. 2. The correct calculation of the growth curve and breakeven point is essential for futuristic sustainable growth and positive aggressive expansion. 3. The next step is to develop a pitching and marketing strategy. 4. There are a lot of options that need to be explored, such as grocery delivery giants, large retail stores and the various restaurants around the region. 5. Nowadays, trend is also considering hiring of a self-business team and trucks for selling the produce in the urban societies in order to avail the correct value for the produce. 6. The owner of the farm business plan can create its own start-up and sell its own products in the open market to create sustainable income and reduce dependability. 57 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Market research and analysis According to the market research the government and financial institutions, such as banks have initiated and launched many schemes to promote agriculture farm business plan and start-ups The owner must take business loan that is nowadays provided with competitive interest rates and flexible repayment options along with reasonably longer tenure schemes Hiring an experienced farmer along with a qualified professional in the field of agriculture will provide the exact balance required to achieve success in the business The particular business is a labour intensive business and thus it is very much necessary to hire experienced and qualified management and marketing team to manage the operations efficiently 58 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES CHAPTER 6 CONCLUSION 59 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Findings, Suggestions, and Conclusion Findings: Among the findings, The aim of the Smart Villages Initiative has been to identify the framework conditions necessary that the government should b e more concentrate of agriculture, transportation, technologies, employment opportunities, education facilities for the provision of energy services to villages to enable the livelihood opportunities, provision of services (healthcare, education, clean water and sanitation) and empowerment embodied in the Smart Villages concept. In this concept, the provision of sustainable energy services to rural communities, in turn enabling the connectivity made possible by modern informat ion and communication technologies, can have a catalytic impact on the lives of villagers when appropriately integrated with other rural development initiatives The evidence was based on the feedback from the rural area people through a survey. 1. The survey says that 37.9% of the respondents says yes 62.1% says no for whether they have idea about smart villages. 2. The survey says that 69% of the respondents from Andhra Pradesh whereas 27.6% are from Karnataka. 3. The survey says that 27.6% of the respondents are satisfied whereas 24.1% are somewhat satisfied and 48.3% of respondents are not satisfied about their present government well-being towards their area. 4. The survey says that 75.9% of the respondents says yes whereas 6.9% says some impact and 17.2% of respondents says no for impact of villages in development of India. 60 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES SUGGETIONS: 1. Maintain its identity, culture and heritage. 2. Plans for development based on people. 3. Service centric information and tracks its progress. 4. It works towards revenue generation. 5. Has functional solid/liquid waste management system. 6. Homes with access to toilet, safe drinking water and regular power. 7. A smart village knows all information about its citizens available resources, applicable services and schemes. 8. End all preventable maternal deaths and infant deaths. 9. Providing good basic health facilities in rural areas. 61 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Conclusion Smart Villages are the need of the hour as development is needed for both rural and urban areas for better livelihood and technology will offer effective solution. The technological support already exists at the urban side and there is a tremendous pressure on urban landscapes due to Migration of rural people for livelihood Smart Villages will not only reduce this migration but also irrigate the population flow from urban to rural area as well. Taking education, skill for vocations etc to villages can well channelize the energies of the youth as a powerful tool for the nation. An educated rural youth will be an asset to the country and even if he shifts to a city he shall prove to be an asset rather than a burden as is happening now. And at most the overall development of the country can be possible with the development of the villages only. There is no denying fact that we need smart villages. This is the biggest challenge facing all developing countries today. There are technologies available and they are successful elsewhere. But the failure comes from lack of strategy, integrated planning and execution the ecosystem framework of a village and city based on its location and investment climate will guide in developing growth strategies They can be replicated to millions of villages and towns. Around the World and this is in line with the inclusive growth initiatives. 62 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Bibliography 1. Zavratnik, V., Kos, A., & Stojmenova Duh, E. (2018). Smart villages: Comprehensive review of initiatives and practices. Sustainability, 10(7), 2559. 2. Visvizi, A., Lytras, M. D., & Mudri, G. (Eds.). (2019). Smart Villages in the EU and Beyond. Bingley: Emerald Publishing Limited. 3. Komorowski, Ł ., & Stanny, M. (2020). Smart villages: Where can they happen?. Land, 9(5), 151. 4. Stojanova, S., Lentini, G., Niederer, P., Egger, T., Cvar, N., Kos, A., & Stojmenova Duh, E. (2021). Smart Villages Policies: Past, Present and Future. Sustainability, 13(4), 1663. 5. Holmes, J., Jones, B., & Heap, B. (2015). Smart villages. science, 350(6 259), 359-359. 6. Ranade, P., Londhe, S., & Mishra, A. (2015). Smart villages through information technology–need of emerging India. IPASJ International Journal of Information Technology (IIJIT), 3(7), 1-6 7. Cvar, N., Trilar, J., Kos, A., Volk, M., & Stojmenova Duh, E. (2020). The Use of IoT Technology in Smart Cities and Smart Villages: Similarities, Differences, and Future Prospects. Sensors, 20(14), 3897. 8. Visvizi, A., & Lytras, M. D. (2020). Sustainable smart cities and smart villages research: Rethinking security, safety, well being, and happiness. Sustainability, 12(1), 215. 9. Wolski, O., & Wójcik, M. (2019). Smart villages revisited: Conceptual background and new challenges at the local level. In Smart Villages in the EU and Beyond. Emerald Publishing Limited. 63 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES Questionnaire Email * _________________________________________ Name * _________________________________________ Which part of India you are from? * South North East West Which state you are from? * Andhra Pradesh Karnataka Kerala Tamil Nadu Telangana Are you from Rural area? * Yes No Maybe What kind of development you are wishing to have in Rural areas in India? * _______________________________ Do you have any idea about smart villages? * Yes No May be 64 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES If yes, mention your ideas about smart villages. * ____________________________________ Do you think your present government is well being towards your areas? * Yes No Maybe If yes, tell the changes what the government had done to that areas? * ___________________________________ If no, suggest some points what government should make the changes in that area? * ________________________________ What are your suggestions for government in developing rural areas in India? * ____________________________________ How much ratings you will give for your government? * 1 2 3 4 5 What is your contribution for development of villages near your place? * Do you think there is an impact of villages in development of India? * Yes No Maybe 65 DEVELOPMENT OF SMART VILLAGES If yes, on which aspects government should be focus more for India's development? * ____________________________________ 66