GROUP ASSIGNMENT COVER SHEET STUDENT DETAILS Student name: To Anh Thu Student ID number: 31211025091 Student name: Nguyen Phuong Thao Student ID number: 31211023812 Student name: Nguyen Ngoc Minh Anh Student ID number: 31211022292 Student name: Nguyen Dinh Song Khang Student ID number: 31211022270 Student name: Nguyen Huynh Phuong Nhi Student ID number: 31211023792 UNIT AND TUTORIAL DETAILS Unit name: Principles of Management Tutorial/Lecture: Practical case analysis Lecturer or Tutor name: Unit number: MAN101 Class day and time: Dr.Gareth Craze - Ms. Nguyen Dang Hoai Anh ASSIGNMENT DETAILS Title: Manager Interview Report Length: 3160 Due date: December 30, 2021 Date submitted: December 29, 2021 DECLARATION I hold a copy of this assignment if the original is lost or damaged. I hereby certify that no part of this assignment or product has been copied from any other student’s work or from any other source except where due acknowledgement is made in the assignment. I hereby certify that no part of this assignment or product has been submitted by me in another (previous or current) assessment, except where appropriately referenced, and with prior permission from the Lecturer / Tutor / Unit Coordinator for this unit. No part of the assignment/product has been written/ produced for me by any other person except where collaboration has been authorised by the Lecturer / Tutor /Unit Coordinator concerned. I am aware that this work may be reproduced and submitted to plagiarism detection software programs for the purpose of detecting possible plagiarism (which may retain a copy on its database for future plagiarism checking). Student’s signature: A.Thu Student’s signature: P.Thao Student’s signature: M.Anh Student’s signature: S.Khang Student’s signature: P.Nhi Note: An examiner or lecturer / tutor has the right to not mark this assignment if the above declaration has not been signed. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 1 Manager Interview Report Thu A. To, Thao P. Nguyen, Anh N.M Nguyen Khang D. S, and Nhi H. P Nguyen Principle of Management - MAN101 December 9, 2021 Ms. Nguyen Dang Hoai Anh Dr. Gareth Craze MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 2 Introduction The purpose of this research project is to explore and obtain detailed knowledge on the topic of leadership roles, current issues, and practices of modern managerial positions. The research group carried out the Practical Case Analysis project based on the qualitative method, which included an in-depth interview, conducted on December 11th, 2021, and a single case study. The interviewee was Ms. Truc, head manager of Quynh Cake Bakery, a company operating within the food industry. The research group is composed of five members, each responsible for parts of the interviewing process, asking various questions about the manager’s background, their leadership style, the way their management practices linked with the Four Functions of Management, what problems were the company experiencing as well as the methods to resolve these issues. and their respective sections of the report. This report is divided into eight segments: The introduction, overview of the company, overview of the manager, the company’s real-life application of Four Functions of Management, problems within the company, their solutions, the research group’s solution, and the conclusion. Company’s Overview Quynh Cake is currently a famous bakery known by many young people in Quy Nhon city. Initially, Quynh Cake is a small business that offers online cake delivery, but four years ago, it opened a store so that customers can visit to buy cakes on their way home and recently opened a second branch in the city. The bakery aims to expand the scale of its brand so that it can provide cakes to the underprivileged or people who live in remote areas. Quynh Cake manages a unique workplace culture compared to other competitors in Quy Nhon city by creating a comfortable and friendly environment, in which the managers are willing to listen to employees' concerns and give support as long as they are responsible and well-mannered. Manager’s Overview Manager’s Background According to the project’s requirements, researchers have a great opportunity to have an interview with Ms. Truc - the manager of Quynh Cake with eight years of experience working in the bakery industry. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 3 After graduating from high school, she attended a baking course in Da Nang and worked in the company for about four years to save funds and gain experience before opening her own shop. Ms. Truc’s daily routine is to ensure employees work effectively at two branch stores in order to increase sales and customer satisfaction. Although Ms. Truc equips herself with adequate experience, she attempts to improve her management skills by surveying other bakeries in the city, coming up with a more effective way to communicate with subordinates. The strengths that are suitable for her current job are the ability to build trust with people in the workplace and excellent problem-solving skills, which help her handle customer complaints gracefully without causing friction between two parties. Manager’s Leadership Style Leadership plays a critical role as an organizational basis for formulating oversight and effectiveness, as well as fostering dedication and solving problems (Sitkin & Pablo, 2005). Understanding the crucial role of leadership, our interviewee chose the democratic style that best describes her as a manager, referring to a leader who engaged subordinates in decision-making. This is a leadership style that Ms. Truc has developed through continuous attempts to listen and understand her employees more, aiming to create a harmonious working environment and reduce employees’ pressure. All considered, the democratic style has brought her organization a lot of benefits, maximizing productivity in a more convenient way. Further in the interview, the research team also asked Ms. Truc a small case which was about the solutions she offered when dealing with unmotivated team members. The answer goes well with her style that she supports her employees as much as she can. First, she would work directly with that employee and ask about the problem she was facing. Ms. Truc is willing to provide support and assistance if the employee has any concerns and personal problems so that the employee does not neglect the work. However, if the situation repeated many times, she would fire this employee to avoid affecting other employees. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 4 Four Functions of Management After having a look at the bakery’s overview as well as the manager’s overview including the background and leadership style, the research team investigated more into the functions of management. The functions of management are divided into four basic aspects which are planning, organizing, leading, and controlling. Planning Setting objectives and choosing a course of action to achieve those objectives is planning in management. Managers must be aware of the current state of their organization's environment and foresee future situations in order to plan (UOM, 2015). Types of plan. Quynh Cake follows the Time-Frame Plans which include 3 types of plans: short, medium, and long-term plans. The long-term plan defines the development goals of the bakery, which will be followed by the company’s mission. The second type is a medium plan which lasts for 1 month and is developed on a regular basis to attain smaller, more specific goals. While designing the plan, it is important that the managers must consider the current situation and market, then set a goal to achieve for the store, not simply a fanciful goal. The last one is a short-term plan which covers the bakery’s day-to-day activities and special occasions. It is vital for a company to be able to manage short-term plans promptly and successfully which is the same as laying a foundation, which demonstrates how a company's ability to withstand the test of time (Gibson, 2004). Plans’ criteria and how to communicate plans to employees. Quynh Cake plan always follows three criteria: ensure food quality and safety; ensure revenue and number of customers; ensure service attitude as well as benefits for both customers and employees. By these criteria, the plan will have benefits like higher profitability, standing out from the competition, a protected brand reputation, and better employee morale (Hall, 2020). Ms. Truc built the bakery based on an open and friendly environment with flexible management policies to create a strong belief in the company so that employees will dedicate themselves wholeheartedly. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 5 Organizing Organizing is the division of varied responsibilities among different persons or groups with mutual coordination of their efforts and authority recognized for work to others (Terry, 1968). To be a successful manager, generating detailed and systematic operation's purposes, especially assuring what work tasks need to be completed, plays a role in creating detailed and systematic operation's purposes, resulting in the best performance. Organizational structure. Quynh Cake follows the Flatarchy Structure which flattens the structure and chain of command and allows its employees a great deal of autonomy (Robbins & Coulter, 2016). Ms. Truc directly manages 6 employees who are responsible for different positions then each department must report revenue and expenditure to management at the end of the day. According to traditional thinking, it is counterproductive if all employees report directly to the manager (Robbins & Coulter, 2016). However, research has shown that for a developing family business, it is best for the managers to have control of all employees (Harith, 2020). Work regulations and managing human resources. Ms. Truc always sets rules for her employees before they start working. Within the working process, the managers will guide the inexperienced employees gradually in their first week and make the decision whether it’s a potential employee or they need to let them try another job that suits them better. If an employee commits the same mistake more than 3 times, of course, they will be punished with penalties of varying severity depending on the severity of the damage caused to the bakery. The decisions are quick, steady and in the best interest of the bakery, however, there are a few times that it may ignore other factors such as employees’ opinions. Ms. Truc will create a concept for each cake model and the staff will follow it. She always encourages creativity and input from employees to keep up with current trends. Leading Robbins and Coulter (2016) stated that leading means motivating and doing tasks involved in dealing with people to influence them to achieve organizational goals. Therefore, this section intends to point out how Ms.Truc stimulates her employees as well as resolves conflicts among them. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 6 How to motivate employees. Initially, Ms.Truc believes that establishing a strong connection among employees could uphold their motivation. She creates such interesting traditions for the bakery as exchange gift days, annual bonding parties, baking contests etc, to help employees feel relaxed, connected to complete their work effectively. Also, Ms.Truc holds regular meetings to ask for feedback on her leadership style in parallel with giving constructive feedback on employee performance positively. Plus, she applies the 3P Compensation Model including Pay for Position, Pay for Person, and Pay for Performance which could both create internal fairness in the bakery and give workers performance-based rewards (Pawirosumarto, Sutisna & Sambas, 2020). Ms.Truc uses this method to not only set each employee’s pay rate but also motivate them through increasing their salary and adding more days off. Additionally, a free and creative way while allocating tasks to the time frame could make the team feel stimulated then have more effective working performance. (Sabir, 2017). How to resolve conflicts. Conflicts could be resolved through the functional team structure of the bakery in which the employees are divided into teams taking care of different functions (Sanyal & Hisam, 2018). Moreover, it is necessary to set general concepts for product-making and ground rules including respecting-others criteria. Furthermore, Ms.Truc mentioned her way to lessen the tension between newcomers and old-timers. She usually analyses the pros and cons of two views after taking into consideration both two perspectives. However, if one side did not cooperate, she would fire them right away. Controlling In regards to the controlling function, the interview with Ms. Truc has provided several key points. Firstly, employee performance is monitored and daily quota progress is tracked throughout the entirety of the workday, not just taken from the end-of-day summary report. Staff who diligently carried out their assigned tasks were given praises and rewards. This is in line with academic studies, which have found that by implementing a performance orientation culture and rewarding employees who have good evaluations, companies can significantly reduce turnover rate, retain staff morale and loyalty at a relatively high level while also encouraging workplace positivity (Karikari et al., 2018). MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 7 Secondly, when hiring new staff, the company's website will post job advertisements with specific requirements, so as to limit the scope to applicants with desired traits. This method will save time for managers when hiring personnel, remove unqualified candidates, and speed up the process of finding those who are suitable (Prathibha et al., 2019). Additionally, Quynh Cake does not have a strict rule on prior experience - with the exception of baking positions - and instead offers job training to newcomers. According to the academic study by Ismael et al. (2021), job training directly impacts organizational effectiveness in a positive way, improving individual skill sets and proficiency of staff and contributing towards effective teamwork and healthy organizational culture. After a trial period of one week, a detailed overview is given and subsequently used to determine whether the applicant is officially employed. Thirdly, the workload is efficiently distributed between employees based on their positions and capabilities, but they are also encouraged to support one another to complete their tasks during work hours. The supportive interaction between personnel has been found to have a positive effect on employee social satisfaction, work efficiency, motivation, and competence (Jungert et al., 2018). Company’s Problem Human daily life has been dramatically affected by the COVID-19 pandemic for the last two years and the answer to our fight with the pandemic is still vague. It is proved that COVID-19 has had a rapid impact on businesses as well as worsened and slowed down the economic status (Haleem, Javaid & Vaishya, 2020). As a result, Ms.Truc’s stores have been facing plenty of problems, especially when Ms. Truc owns a chain of stores. The most significant issue that Ms. Truc’s stores have been dealing with during the outbreak is the lack of budget, which will go along with the decrease in the monthly total revenue. During the pandemic, brands in various industries are anticipated to be in trouble as a result of the restrictions on individuals freely moving and showing up outside their homes (Tucker, 2020). Consequently, there are fewer and fewer customers coming to visit and purchase the products, which causes the lack of expenditure that prevents Ms. Truc from paying for raw materials and ingredients needed as well as staff salaries. Hence, it is inevitable that there will be a decline in human resources when the working staff leaves as employers offer less salary MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 8 due to decreased profits. As a result, this will cause the stores to be unable to operate normally and effectively. Furthermore, because of the COVID-19 outbreak, Ms.Truc’s stores have to enter into fierce competition with those online shops increasingly emerging in the market. Recent research shows that during the epidemic, most consumers’ purchase attitudes have formidably shifted to online shopping (Naseri, 2021). Now, the consumers’ preference has changed as they believe that virtual shopping will be safer and less time-consuming. This will only add to the difficulties that offline stores such as Ms. Truc’s have to deal with, and it might get worse if the pandemic is not going to be controlled in the future. Company’s Solutions As researchers mentioned earlier, the outbreak of COVID-19 is a challenge that not only the service industry but also other sectors in the economy have to face, and Quynh Cake is not an exception. When the budget is tight and the bakery is unable to meet a sales target, Ms. Truc lowers the price of cakes, but the quality of them is still ensured. Therefore, customers worry less about money and feel valued due to less financial burden status. In terms of human resources of the bakery, despite facing budget difficulties, Ms. Truc provides support to employees by paying for their meals, which can reduce employees’ mental breakdowns and stabilize their productivity. When the COVID-19 situation is more serious and the Vietnamese government establishes policies on suspending business activities to prevent transmission to the community, Ms. Truc chose to temporarily close the second branch as well as lay off employees, promising to bring them back to work if the situation was better. At the same time, the shop accepts cake orders in small quantities, and employees in the first brand are in charge of delivery. Moreover, the emerging trend of online stores during the pandemic is also a challenge for Ms. Truc's shop, especially when it comes to cake prices. Ms. Truc has come up with solutions to solve this problem, such as offering delivery within a certain area or extra desserts. These types of promotions appear to be effective in making customers reconsider their choice because of the quality of the cakes and give them MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 9 value for their money. Ms. Truc believes that competition in the business world is common and she focuses on quality over quantity. If the bakery gains respect from its customers, building brand trust is not a difficult task. Research Group’s Solutions During the COVID-19 pandemic, Quynh Cake has encountered many problems, therefore, the research group carry out an in-depth analysis of the issues and suggest the following solutions to help the businesses cope with them. Firstly, the research team realized the need for a signature type of cake, convenient combos, and social networking. Quynh Cake should differentiate its cake menu from others by offering a signature cake. Customers could be willing to pay for a cake that they cannot find at other places. Additionally, small combos with nice decorations consisting of matching drinks and cakes may catch customers’ attention as it is more convenient and time-saving for them to choose what to buy. Also, at present Quynh Cake does not have an official Instagram platform which has gained popularity lately among youngsters (Ngoc, 2021) then the researchers propose creating an Instagram account along with paying for ads just focusing on such features as signature cake, combo or best seller product to promote the page. Secondly, it is necessary to do frequent market research. An empirical study revealed that consumers' perception has a significant impact on product purchases, specifically in the food industry (Chandrasekhar et al., 2019). Within the study, it is documented that customers were drawn to unique prices, quality, delivery, and reliability, which is helpful data when companies need to consider their production quantity, pricing, and branding. This is especially true with the current shift to online shopping, where personalized advertisement is dominant (Aryani et al., 2021). By grasping current trends and preferences, managers are able to make effective decisions in order to increase sales and allocate appropriate resources. Thirdly, building and strengthening the brand by creating a fund from revenue to do charity is considered as another effective strategy. The COVID-19 outbreak has caused human life to suffer from a significant loss, whereby the rapid unemployment rate has left people with their families with hunger and MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 10 poverty (Chriscaden, 2020). Therefore, setting up a fund to provide support to people in need can both solve the problem of attracting customers, increasing the revenue of the business, and establish a reliable base for customers to assist people in difficulties. Research shows that businesses that contributed to charity create a closer connection with their customers and society (Barnes, 2003). As consumers have a positive vibe when they purchase products associated with the community, this will be one of the helpful strategies for Ms.Truc’s bakery. Conclusion In summary, the research group has gained a deeper insight into the management issues through this interview. Ms.Truc applied the democratic style to her management process, prioritizing teamwork. In terms of the four functions of management: For planning, the interviewed manager has presented the bakery's multi-stage plans and criteria when formulating which is suitable for the size and staffing of the bakery. The organization of this company follows the Flatarchy structure, having a few key staff who report directly to the manager, implementing clear rules and policies. In leading, 3P Compensation Model and interesting traditions are used to motivate the employees together with resolving conflicts through the functional team structure. The store applies the controlling function by establishing a performance-oriented culture, supportive environment, and training programs, ensuring efficiency and morale. Regarding company problems, the recent pandemic has impacted the overall sales, reducing customer visits and competing with online shops. The company’s solutions were to lower prices, provide financial support for employees, lay off some staff members, and shift focus to online platforms. Solutions from the research team are: broadening business platforms, doing frequent market research, and combining business with charity. Ms. Truc’s advice to become a good manager is: be soft, flexible, decisive, keep an open mind for feedback, be professionally friendly, do not let personal feelings interfere with work and give constructive criticism. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 11 References Aryani, D. N., Nair, R. K., Hoo, D. X. Y., Hung, D. K. M., Lim, D. H. R., Chew, W. P., & Desai, A. (2021). A study on consumer behaviour: Transition from traditional shopping to online shopping during the COVID-19 pandemic. International Journal of Applied Business and International Management (IJABIM), 6(2), 81-95. Barnes, J. G. (2003). Establishing meaningful customer relationships: why some companies and brands mean more to their customers. Managing Service Quality: An International Journal. Burhan Ismael, N., Jabbar Othman, B., Gardi, B., Abdalla Hamza, P., Sorguli, S., Mahmood Aziz, H., ... & Anwar, G. (2021). The Role of Training and Development on Organizational effectiveness. Chandrasekhar, N., Gupta, S., & Nanda, N. (2019). Food delivery services and customer preference: a comparative analysis. Journal of Foodservice Business Research, 22(4), 375-386. Chriscaden, K. Impact of COVID-19 on people's livelihoods, their health and our food systems. World Health Organization. Cone Communications. (2010). 2010 Cone Cause Evolution Study. Retrieved from http://www.conecomm.com/2010-cone-cause-evolution-study Gibson, B. (2004, June). The Importance of Short Term Financing Sources in Small Firms. In Proceedings of the 49th International Conference of the International Council for Small Business (ICSB) (pp. 1-14). Haleem, A., Javaid, M., & Vaishya, R. (2020). Effects of COVID-19 pandemic in daily life. Current medicine research and practice, 10(2), 78. Hall, J. (2020). Quality not quantity: The importance of quality management in the food industry. Retrieved from: https://www.columbusglobal.com/en-gb/blog/quality-not-quantity-the-importance-of-quality-manage ment-in-the-food-industry Harith, S., & Samujh, R. H. (2020). Small Family Businesses: Innovation, Risk and Value. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 13(10), 240. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 12 Ismael, NB, Othman, BJ, Gardi, B., Hamza, PA, Sorguli, S., Aziz, HM, Ahmed, SA, Sabir, BY, Ali, BJ, Anwar, G. (2021). The Role of Training and Development on Organizational effectiveness. International Journal of Engineering, Business and Management, 5(3), 15-24. Jungert, T., Van den Broeck, A., Schreurs, B., & Osterman, U. (2018). How colleagues can support each other's needs and motivation: An intervention on employee work motivation. Applied Psychology, 67(1), 3-29. Karikari, A. F., Opoku Boadi, P., & Sai, A. A. (2018). Rewarding employees for corporate performance improvements. Human Systems Management, 37(3), 311-317. Naseri, R. N. N. (2021). Issues And Challenges Of Online Shopping Activities On The Impact Of Corona Pandemic: A Study OnMalaysia Retail Industry. Turkish Journal of Computer and Mathematics Education (TURCOMAT), 12(10), 7682-7686. Ngoc H. (2021). How Gen Z in Vietnam is using social media. VOV WORLD. Retrieved from: https://m.vovworld.vn/en-US/digital-life/how-gen-z-in-vietnam-is-using-social-media-994111.vov Pawirosumarto, S., Sutisna, D., & Sambas, I. G. (2020). The 3p Concept to Employee Job Satisfaction and The Impact on Organizational Performance. International Journal of Psychological Rehabilitation. Prathibha, G., & Sandhya, K. (2019). SCREENING AND SELECTION PROCESS IN RECRUITMENT. Robbins, S., & Coulter, M. (2016). Management (13th ed.). Pearson. Sabir, A. (2017). Motivation: Outstanding way to promote productivity in employees. American Journal of Management Science and Engineering, 2(3), 35-40. Sanyal, S., & Hisam, M. W. (2018). The impact of teamwork on work performance of employees: A study of faculty members in Dhofar University. IOSR Journal of Business and Management, 20(3), 15-22. Sitkin, S. B., & Pablo, A. L. (2005). The neglected importance of leadership. Mergers and acquisitions: Managing culture and human resources, 208-223. Terry, G., R. (1968). Principles of management. Richard 0. Irwin, Inc., Homewood, Illinois. Tucker, H. (2020). Coronavirus bankruptcy tracker (Doctoral dissertation, these major companies are failing amid the shutdown). Forbes. MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 13 University of Minnesota. (2015). 1.5 Planning, Organizing, Leading, and Controlling. Retrieved from: https://open.lib.umn.edu/principlesmanagement/chapter/1-5-planning-organizing-leading-and-controlli ng-2/ MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT Appendix A: Communication with the Manager Invitation email Confirmation email Thank you email 14 MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 15 Appendix B: Question Protocol No. Questions Introduction Heading Company’s Heading Overview In-charged by Song Khang 1. What is the vision and mission of the Anh Thu bakery/ 2. What is the organizational culture of the bakery? Manager’s Heading Phuong Nhi Overview Manager’s Level one background heading 3. Name, Job title, Experience ? 4. How did you get this manager position? 5. What is the overall purpose of the position? Anh Thu MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 16 6. Are there any skills you need to learn when you become a manager? 7. What strengths make you think you are suitable for your current job? Leadership style Heading 8. Which style of management best describes you? A) Democratic (communicate, team work) B) Autocratic (powerful, dictative) C) Laissez-faire (not much action, freedom) 8a. Is this your original management style or did you change it during work? If you changed it, do you find it suitable for your work? 8b. Minicase: *) Autocratic: If the most agreed opinion is against your decision, what will you do? *) Democratic: When there is an unmotivated / passive person in your group, what is your solution? Phuong Thao MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT Four functions Heading of A short paragraph summarises the main key 17 Phuong Nhi points management Planning Level one heading 9. What is your target priority for the firm when you work as a manager? 10. How do you deal with inexperienced employees? 11. What are your weaknesses in this position? And how do you plan to improve them? 12. Will you apply the same planning process for all projects (events, sale off,...)? Why or why not? Minh Anh MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT Organizing Level one heading 13. How do you resolve problems that cause difficulties multiple times? 13a. What do you think about the solutions you make (good or bad in which aspect) ? 13b. Do you want to change the solutions that you made before? Why and why not? 14. From the first year of managing to now, are there any specific differences in the way you work? 15. When planning a monthly expense, how do you allocate your resources? Are there any KPIs in your bakery? 16. How can you estimate the amount of ingredients needed for a day and order it enough for a day ? 17. When do you order ingredients and how long can they last in your storage? 18. Are you responsible for daily accounts or your employees will do it? 18 Minh Anh MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT Leading 19. What strategies do you use to motivate a 19 Phuong Nhi team? 20. How do you connect members with different personalities in your company? 21. How do you deal with the differences in perspectives while working (eg. ideas for making cake, etc,.) between you and your subordinates? 22. What policies/methods do you impose to mitigate internal tensions in general, especially between long-time employees and newcomers? Controlling Level one heading 23. How do you evaluate the performance of Song Khang your subordinates? 24. What are some of your criterias when accepting inexperienced newcomers? 25. How are the tasks distributed among the employees? (ex: based on skills, forte, preferences,...) Organization’s Problems Heading 26. What is the biggest issue that you/ your company encountered? Phuong Thao MANAGER INTERVIEW REPORT 20 27. What are pandemic impacts on the bakery? (e.g. budget shortage, lack of labor,etc,.) Problems’ solutions from the organization Heading 28. How did you solve those issues? Anh Thu Group solutions Heading All Conclusion Heading Song Khang 29. Could you evaluate your decision? Good or bad? If you could change your decision, would you change? Why or why not? Appendix C: Group photo with the manager