Marketing Communication S1 Strategic Communication & Strategic Marketing Communication 1.1 Online Session2_What is Strategic Communication Strategic communication Def.: Strategic communication = communication aligned with the company’s overall strategy, to enhance its strategic positioning. Criteria for strategic communication: Have a clear message Have a consistent message Repeat the message to achieve a positioning in the customers’ minds Use various mechanisms and the right channels to reach customers Get feedback from customers (-> adjust strategy and adjust communication) Tie communication with financial and behavioral outcomes Communicate within a given budget 1.2 Online Session3_What is Marketing Communication Marketing – Definitions: “The process by which companies create value for customers and build strong customer relationships in order to capture value from customers in return.” (Kotler & Armstrong) “The activity, set of institutions and processes for creating, communicating, delivering, and exchanging offerings that have value for customers, clients, partners, and society at large.” (American Marketing Association) Creating value is at the core of what marketing is How to create value for target customers? 1. Select customers to serve: requires (1) segmentation and (2) targeting 2. Decide on value proposition: requires (1) differentiation from competitors and (2) positioning 3. Deliver value by means of the marketing mix: product, price, place, and promotion Promotion = Marketing communication = “The collection of all elements of a firm’s marketing mix that facilitate exchange by establishing shared meaning with the firm’s customers.” How can marketing communication be strategic? Strategic Intent Strategic Execution Element of the 6M Model of Marketing Communication Mission Market Message Media For marketing communication to be strategic, it should… it should be created for a particular target market it should have a clear and consistent message; it should be coordinated within the promotional perspective of the marketing mix and with all other elements of the marketing mix (integration) It should be executed in appropriate media Strategic Impact Money It should be created to achieve a specific objective within a given budget Measurement It should have a measurable impact Role of Marketing Communication Def.: Marketing Communication = establishing shared meaning with the firm‘s customers. Role: Marketing Communication facilitates communication between brand and consumer. Marketing communication contributes to the formation of brand building blocks (such as attitudes, responses, etc.). social media -> shift from one-way communication (brand to consumer) to two-way directional communication Role of Brand Management Brand Resonance Model (Keller, 2001): considers how brand positioning affect what consumers think, feel, and do and the degree to which they resonate or connect with the brand Elements of brand positioning: - Brand identity: who are you? Brand meaning: what are you? Brand responses: what about you? what do I think or feel about you? -> brand attitudes -> cognitive, affective, and behavioral responses Brand relationships: what about you and me? Role of Marketing Communication in Brand Management helps to reach out to consumers by means of segmentation and targeting: with marketing communication campaigns, a company can develop messages that appeal to the specific needs and desires of different segments and transmit those messages via appropriate media for the specific segments-> reach customers better helps to communicate with consumers (whether they are customers or not): creates awareness, informs, can lead to attitudinal and behavioral changes in consumers) helps to differentiate offerings and to position within the market helps to achieve financial outcomes Role of Marketing Communication in customer decision making process Marketing communication plays a role in each step of the consumer decision making process. Problem Recognition: remind consumers of existing needs Information Search: educate consumers about product features and benefits Evaluation of Alternatives: assist consumers in making comparisons among options Purchase Decision: encourage and reinforce consumers to making the purchase Post-Purchase Assessment: encourage product usage and make consumers feel good about their purchase decisions S2 Strategic Intent of Marketing Communication – Mission & Market 3.1 Strategic Mission 1 Marketing communication can have different effects; the hierarchy of effects model displays six potential stages of the relationship between brand/product and consumer 1. Awareness and knowledge relate to information or ideas (Lavidge and Steiner, 1961) related to the cognitive/rational component of behavior ads provide information and facts Examples: slogans, sky writing, teaser campaigns, announcements; must not necessarily be the identification of the brand name -> image product package (Percy and Rossiter, 1992) 2. Liking and preferece have to do with favorable attitudes or feelings toward the product (Lavidge and Steiner, 1961) related to the affective component of behavior ads change attitude and feelings examples (liking): image ads, status/glamour appeals examples (preference): competitive ads, argumentative copy 3. conviction and purchase are to produce action - the acquisition of the product (Lavidge and Steiner, 1961) conative or motivational component of behavior ads stimulate or direct desires examples (conviction): testimonials examples (purchase): point of purchase deals/last chance offers, price appeals Depending on the relationship stage, a different marketing communication effect is desired: 1. Create awareness 2. Disseminate information1 3. Change attitude The information provided does not necessarily have to be related to the advertised product, it can also be an information about something else related to the brand (e.g. product ad + information that old product can be returned for a discount) 4. Change behavior The different stages of relationship can further be assigned to the three dimensions Think, Feel, Do Markers can focus on one specific mission but they usually use a mix and match of different missions by 1. determining what steps are most critical in leading to purchase in a particular setting 2. determining how many people are at the moment on which stage 3. determining which people on which steps it is most important to reach (Lavidge and Steiner, 1961) 4. -> design of a multifaceted communication with multiple effects that addresses consumers at different stages 5. Finally, consumers perceive one and the same message different which means that without attempting so, the effect of a marketing communication is naturally different in different consumers Measuring the effect of Marketing Communication: 1. communication can aim at different effects -> success of marketing communication should not be solely measured by no. of direct purchases (Lavidge and Steiner, 1961) 2. e.g. the direct impact of attitudinal change on sales can’t be qualified in the shortterm but it CAN be measured in the long-term because it will positively influence brand equity in the long-term 3. Specify the amount of change Mission 1: Awareness Consumers can have different levels of brand awareness 1. Unaware of the brand 2. Brand recognition visual or verbal2 3. Brand recall 4. Top of mind awareness -> consumer easily calls brand into mind Basic awareness = level at which the consumer knows at least the brand’s existence (between (1) and (2)) A consumer can perceive an ad different depending on his/her brand awareness 1. Marketing communication can either be designed in a multifaceted way and address recipients at different awareness stages 2. Or it can be targeted at consumers in one specific brand awareness stage 2 Lavidge and Steiner, 1961): A Model for Predictive Measurements for Advertising Effectiveness -> steps, advertising must go through in the consumer: 1. unawareness Difference between brand recognition and brand recall depends on what occurs first in buyer's mind: category need (brand recall) or brand awareness (brand recognition); for the same product, the decisionmaking situation can be different for two consumers; brand recall is associated with a higher brand knowledge (e.g. consumer can remember values, multiple brand elements, product details, etc.) whereas brand recognition is associated with a lower brand knowledge level (e.g. consumer can only establish a link between a cue and a brand but lacks detailed information) 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. merely aware of existence know what product has to offer favorable attitudes towards offer conviction actual purchase The greater the commitment/involvement involved in the purchase (psychological or economic), the longer it will take to bring consumers up these steps Mission 2: Disseminate Information Convey a single message Mission 3: Change attitudes Mission 4: Change behavior Percy and Rossiter Framework Rossiter and Percy model (1987) = 2x4 communication model; underlying rational is that brand awareness and brand attitude + the interaction between both form the basis of consumer behavior and result in eight possible communication strategies Brand awareness: depending on brand awareness, communication can have two different brand awareness objectives Brand attitude: brand attitude has a cognitive and an affective component and can be classified along two dimensions (involvement and motivation) 1. Cognitive components arise from beliefs about the brand’s benefits, affective components “energize behavior” 2. Brand attitude and involvement dimension: relates to the cognitive aspects of a brand attitude critical points for low involvement strategies: Extreme claims which don’t necessarily have to be believed but remembered Critical points for high involvement strategies: Claim must be believed and accepted 3. Brand attitude and motivation dimension: according to the Rossiter and Percy model (1987) brand attitude originates from the consumer’s underlying motivation negative behavioral motivation is present in consumers with an information need / closely linked to cognitive components -> informational strategy is appropriate “one utilizes an informational strategy only when the advertised brand is linked to one of the five negatively originated motivations: problem removal (pain relievers) problem avoidance (detergent products) incomplete satisfaction (new and improved products) mixed approach avoidance (low-tar tobacco products) normal completion (any loyal brand that one runs out of)” positive behavioral motivation is closely linked to affective components -> transformational strategy is appropriate “transformational strategies are used only when the advertised brand is linked to one of the positively originated motivations: sensory gratification (dessert products) intellectual stimulation (personal computers) social approval (cosmetic or status goods)” critical points for transformational strategies: emotional authenticity of the communication appeal of the communication / consumer should like the ad irrespective of his liking of the brand Means that one buyer’s brand attitude is situational rather than stable And means that different consumers can have a different underlying motivation regarding the same product: → marketers can use the underlying motivation as a segmentation variable and chose their communication strategy so that it matches the motivation (informational vs. transformational strategy) → If marketers have previously targeted segments with an negatively originated motivation by means of an informational strategy, they can target new segments by changing to a transformational strategy and target those segments which have a positively originated motivation 3.2 Strategic Market – to whom is the communication addressed? 3.2.1 Select Customers to serve Segmentation: Divide the total market into smaller segments Segmentation is relevant for 1. Dividing the total market in smaller segments which can be targeted specifically 2. Becoming aware of target customers’ specific needs and preferences because marketing communication must be designed to specifically address them Segmentation approaches 1. Geographic 2. Demographic: age, gender, income, etc. 3. Psychographic: psychographic segmentation variables refer to consumers’ activities, interests, and opinions (AIOs) 4. Behavioral: behavioral segmentation variables describe how people behave with respect to a particular product category / class of related products; usage rate, loyalty status, benefits sought Targeting: Select the segment(s) to enter Targeting approaches 1. Undifferentiated marketing: one big market and one product mix (e.g. Coca Cola) -> mass marketing, generic communication strategy 2. Differentiated marketing: multiple markets and separate marketing mix for each market (e.g. umbrella brands such as P&G with several smaller sub-brands or mother brand such as Coca Cola with different tastes for different targeted segments) 3. Concentrated (niche) marketing: target a large share of one or a few smaller segments or niches3 4. Micromarketing: personalized marketing to suit the tastes of specific individuals (e.g. based on their location); complex communication strategy 3.2.2 Decide on Value Proposition Differentiation: Differentiate the market offering to create value4 Positioning: Position the offering in the minds of customers Critical points: 1. Deliver on promise 2. Consistency 3. Simplicity and distinctiveness 3.2.3 Macro Market Perspective The macro market perspective views a brand in a market environment with diverse external influences and conditions. It’s essential for brand managers to adapt this perspective when deciding on the customers to serve (Market) but it’s also relevant for brand management in general. Cultural influences: can be specific values, role models, habits, lifestyle characteristics, etc. to be considered Regulatory influences: minimum age, ingredients, declarations, etc. Technological influences: mobile usage, media preferences, etc. Economic influences: relevant economic conditions in the target market, e.g. financial resources of target segment Natural influences: specific natural conditions to be considered S4 Strategic Execution of Marketing Communication 4.1 Message 3 Messages are relevant to communicate the brand’s value to the target customers Consumers have a limited capacity to receipt stimuli and to process information from their environment -> message must be designed to enhance consumer motivation to focus his capacity on the information presented by the communication -> executional strategies and elaboration likelihood model of persuasion Niche marketing can be a source of growth as many brands focusing on sustainable consumption have proved: 10 years ago, the target audience were niches but the segment grew drastically and sales exploded 4 E.g. IKEA differentiates from other furniture stores trough its value proposition to be “The Life Improvement Store” (more than just furniture, customer experience,…) Link between Marketing Communication and Brand management: “Develop a message that is different and unmistakably linked to a company’s brand.” 4.1.1 Message Strategies Message Strategy Messages Description and examples Underlying mission5 Generic Messages Cognitive Message Strategies = presenting pieces of information to target customers Preemptive Messages Unique selling proposition Messages Hyperbole Messages Comparative Messages Affective Message Strategies = designed to invoke feelings/emotions Conative Message Strategies = designed for more direct consumer response Focusing on selling the category, not the brand E.g. dentist advertises teeth whitening rather than his personal office Brand chooses to be the first to make a claim about a product/service claim may also be true for competitors, but you’re the first to tell the target audience about it highlight what is unique about the brand (compared to other brands); differentiation focus is on own uniqueness, not on competitors (see comparative messages) Wild exaggerations which don’t necessarily reflect the truth Create awareness and disseminate information Comparisons with competitors Resonance Messages Strong and deep tone with long lasting effect (e.g. Dove) Emotional Messages Using feelings to connect with audience Change attitude Action Inducing Promotion Supporting Change behavior Means-End chains models Means-end chain models generally assume that consumers use products/services (means) to achieve desired end states/values (ends). Different variants of means-end chain models exist (e.g. by Gutman, 1982, or MECCAS). In addition, different conceptualizations on values exist (e.g. Schwartz’ Personal Vlaues model, 1994). Implications for marketing messages are that besides product attributes, functional benefits and psycho-social benefits, messages must also include consumers’ personal values. 5 Does not mean that affective message strategies cannot be used to create awareness, but it’s the mission which matches best with the respective message strategy Example 1: Means-End Conceptualization of Components for Advertising Strategy (MECCAS) Consumers have abstract (and individual) ideals (= personal values) that guide their decisions Message must – according to MECCAS model - convey o Product attributes = tangible product features o Functional benefits = tangible benefits achieved from using the product/service o Psycho-social benefits = emotional benefit achieved from using the product/service o Personal value of using the brand = the desired end-state the consumer wants to achieve by using the product/service -> Marketers must identify the most important values of their customers (Schwartz framework) and design the message so that it adds to the customers’ values and help them achieve their goal Example 2: Means-End Chain Model by Gutman, 1982 Assumptions Consumers have desired end states that guide their decisions “people cope with the tremendous diversity of products that are potential satisfiers of their values by grouping them into sets or classes so as to reduce the complexity of choice” (Gutman, 1982); those classes are defined by the value they provide and not necessarily by the product class6 “all consumer actions have consequences (..), and that consumers learn to associate particular consequences with particular actions” (Gutman, 1982); consequences can be: o Physiological (e.g. satisfying hunger) o Psychological (e.g. self-esteem) o Sociological (e.g. group membership) Rationale “Consumers choose actions that produce desired consequences and minimize undesired consequences” (Gutman, 1982) In other words, consumers use products/services (means) to achieve desired end states/values (ends) -> means-end chain models This means, the model links 1 Values to consequences -> allows to evaluate consequences 2 Product attributes to consequences: “consumers create arrays of products that will be instrumental in helping them achieve their desired consequences” (Gutman, 1982); see assumption 2: these arrays aren’t necessarily product classrelated but rather add to the same value for the customer 3 Thus on a higher level perceived product attributes and values 4 And finally values to behavior Marketers can use this model to intentionally establish means (through advertising) which help consumers to achieve their desired end states “Consequences leading to important values should be more important to a person than those leading to less important values” (Gutman, 1982) Model appropriateness 6 This grouping (also referred to as distinction by Gutman) can be used as a starting point to adapt a new marketing approach: by understanding how consumers group products of different classes together in one category based on the value provided, they reveal insights about the most important values provided by those products (e.g. if consumers group lemons together with washing liquid because of its function to clean, marketers can use this insight for a completely new way to advertise lemons) Model “permits (…) to focus on the basic aims consumers have in life while not losing sight of how these aims influence choices in specific situations.” (Gutman, 1982) It is thus appropriate to analyze (frequent) consumption choices in the long-term / consumption habits and less appropriate for one-time-consumption-behaviors One-time-consumption-behaviors often go along with low-involvement purchase situations meaning that the model also does not fit these situations Framework: Schwartz’s Personal Values (1994) Model classifies consumers values into 10 different categories Category Self-Direction Defining goal independent thought and action-choosing, creating, exploring Stimulation excitement, novelty, and challenge in life Hedonism pleasure or sensuous gratification for oneself Achievement personal success through demonstrating competence according to social standards Power social status and prestige, control or dominance over people and resources Security safety, harmony, and stability of society, of relationships, and of self Conformity Conformity values derive from individuals’ desire to avoid actions that could upset or harm others and violate social expectations or norms respect, commitment, and acceptance of the ideas that one's culture or religion provides; subordinating the self to socially imposed expectations preserving and enhancing the welfare of those with whom one is in frequent personal contact Tradition Benevolence Universalism understanding, appreciation, tolerance, and protection for the welfare of (1) all people/society and (2) for nature Values creativity, freedom, choosing own goals, curious, independent, self-respect, intelligent, privacy a varied life, an exciting life, daring pleasure, enjoying life, selfindulgent ambitious, successful, capable, influential, intelligent, selfrespect, social recognition authority, wealth, social power, preserving my public image, social recognition social order, family security, national security, clean, reciprocation of favors, healthy, moderate, sense of belonging obedient, self-discipline, politeness, honoring parents and elders, loyal, responsible respect for tradition, humble, devout, accepting my portion in life, moderate, spiritual life helpful, honest, forgiving, responsible, loyal, true friendship, mature love, sense of belonging, meaning in life broadminded, social justice, equality, world at peace, world of beauty, unity with nature, wisdom, protecting the environment, inner harmony, a spiritual life Tripartite model of attitude (tricomponent model) Message influences attitude which – according to the tricomponent model – is connected to the behavior “correlations among these three components were moderate, suggesting the practical importance of discriminating among them” Breckler, S. J. (1984) -> when measuring attitude change caused by a marketing message, marketers should focus on the effect of the message of one specific attitude component rather than on attitude in general “not all attitude components are built up through cognitive processes” Breckler, S. J. (1984); an affective attitude component may arise from a solely emotional stimulus -> brand attitude does not only result from cognitive stimuli but also from nonverbal or noncognitive ones 4.1.2 Message strategies to enhance motivation Two main objectives of the marketing communication message can be distinguished: For both objectives, several executional strategies are possible: Use messages that appeal to hedonic needs of target audience 1st objective: enhance consumer motivation to attend to the message provided to them Use messages that use novel stimuli Use messages that use intense or prominent cues Use motion 2nd objective: enhance consumer motivation to process the brand information Use messages that increase the relevance of the brand to the self; aim is that consumer can relate to a situation/issue/emotion presented Increasing curiosity about the brand Use sex appeals, appetite appeals Innovative (mostly visual) presentations Use big billboards, colorful and vivid images, celebrities Presentations which include motion The product to be advertised is often absent in the ad or becomes visible later; use fear appeals the consumer can relate to; use rhetorical questions Use humor, teasers 4.1.3 Message Executional Strategies Message executional strategies Animation Slice of life Informative Demonstration Testimonial Authoritative Fantasy Description Use of an animation character Use everyday people in everyday situations Provide information Demonstrate the performance and effectiveness of the product (e.g. by demonstrating product in use or showing before/after comparisons) Testimonial can but must not necessarily be a celebrity, can also be a “man on the street” who illustrates the effectiveness of the product Use an expert praising the product Illustrate a fantasy situation in which the consumer has used the product Elaboration Likelihood Model (Petty & Cacioppo, 1986) The elaboration likelihood model helps to grasp how consumer may react to communication messages intended to change their attitudes or behavior Rationale The kind of sensory data which is appropriate for a given purchase situation depends on the nature of the situation (e.g. the product) and the consumer’s involvement (Elaboration Likelihood Model) and the consumer’s general need for cognition Assumption “consumer attitudes are changed by two distinctly different routes to persuasion” (Schiffman et al., 2008) which are illustrated by an elaboration continuum central route: is the appropriate strategy for attitude change in high involvement situations in which consumers are willing/motivated to invest high cognitive effort for information processing -> provide educational information peripheral route: is appropriate in low involvement situations in which consumer rely on surface characteristics, emotional cues and shortcuts, have limited assessment skills, and are not motivated to invest high cognitive effort -> provide secondary inducements (e.g. price promotions, free samples, an appealing purchase environment, great packaging, etc.) -> 4.1.2 Message strategies to enhance motivation In the short term, both routes may be effective and lead to the desired attitude change (Schiffman et al., 2008). In the long-term “attitude changes via the central route appear to be more persistent, resistant, and predictive of behavior than changes induced via the peripheral route.” (Pretty & Cacioppo, 198) This is mostly because object-relevant information is better accessible if attitude is based on the central route which gives the attitude a more substantial basis. 4.2 Media where, when, and how will the message be communicated main goal: motivate consumer to process the provided information strategically select the media to use within the marketing communication plan o what’s the strategic mission o what does the market look like o at which stage of the decision making process is the target group by selecting a certain kind of media, which route does the company select to go? (peripheral vs. central route) 4.2.1 Types of Media Mass Media vs. Addressable Media (decision was relevant earlier) Mass Media viewed by mass audience no customization possible e.g. TV advertising Addressable Media customized / addresses the needs of a specific consumer e.g. personal selling Synchronous Communication vs. Asynchronous Communication Synchronous Communication both, firm and consumer participate at the same time e.g. TV advertising Asynchronous Communication firm and consumer participate at different times consumer decides when he/she pays attention and attends to the message e.g. direct mail Owned Media, Paid Media, Earned Media (this decision is more relevant nowadays) Owned Media includes all media which are owned by the company e.g. company’s website, SoMe channels, owned retail stores, catalogues Paid Media company earns the control but pays for using the media e.g. TV, print, outdoor media, radio, online advertising 4.2.2 Marketing Communication Media Advertising Social Media Direct Marketing PR Event Marketing and Sponsorships Sales Promotion Earned Media channels the company has earned through PR activities, SoMe outreach, viral campaigns, event marketing, etc. e.g. consumer blogs, rating sites, customers’ SoMe feeds, online communities A. Advertising = “paid7 placement of a non-personalized message by an identified sponsor intended to inform and persuade people about a product or service” Advertising types type 1: product advertising = is related to communication relating to a company’s product type 2: corporate advertising o = aims to establish a favorable attitude toward a company as a whole and to build the image of the firm o communicates an organization’s views o sometimes positions the firm’s products against competition o plays an important role in integrated brand promotion o no direct link to a product Advertising objectives depend on underlying communication mission Mission Advertising objective Brand awareness: recognition Objective is that consumer recognizes the ad/product/brand when shown the ad (brand awareness) Brand awareness: recall Objective is that brand is in the long-term memory or evoked set of the consumer (not identical but closely linked to brand preference8) Brand image Resulting advertising focus Reach Frequency Theories on achieving advertising objectives theory 1 about achieving advertising objectives: Three-Exposure Hypothesis according to the theory, advertisements must be exposed at least three times to the target customers assumption: consumers have an intrusion value, meaning that – even if they don’t want to attend to an ad - they will pay attention to it if it is exposed at least three times to them theory 2 about achieving advertising objectives: Recency Theory according to the theory, three exposures are not enough assumption: consumers have a selective attention, meaning that they decide to which messages they pay attention and they do not have an intrusion value result: need for continuous advertising; exposure can be increased by adding reach Variables concerning advertising objectives9 variable 1: effective reach = % of audience that must be exposed to an advertisement to achieve a specific objective -> refers to the whom of media variable 2: effective frequency = no. of times an audience must be exposed to an ad to achieve a specific objective -> refers to the how of media 7 Advertising is hence part of the paid media (vs. owned media vs. earned media) Brand recall is primarily about being able to link brand elements to the brand which does not include an evaluation per definition but often, recall goes along with preference 9 Variables the company must decide on in developing the marketing communication 8 Advertising media channels10: TV Radio Magazines Newspaper Alternative media: e.g. placing brand/product in a movie/TV show or in outdoor/public places (e.g. on trucks, restroom spaces, etc.); referred to as brand placement) Digital media: refers to digital advertising = advertising which uses the Internet to deliver promotional messages to consumers; in contrast to traditional media, digital media helps to enhance the brand relationships, to create bonds between consumers and brands and to create brand communities; they are mainly used in the post-purchase phase (brand advocates) but can also help during the evaluation process and be meaningful in influencing; examples: Digital media examples company websites Description (Internet) banner ads Pop-ups Online video ads Videogame advertising Mobile advertising and apps Search ads used for advertisements for the company in general, not for individual brands represents a venue to generate and transact exchanges between organizations and their customers provide the possibility to link to other marketing communication activities and hence provide a way for integrated marketing communication have been the first digital advertising media but still accounts for 20% of digital advertising has evolved over time and meanwhile allows to embed videos banner ads can be positioned on specific websites which means they allow for targeting only those consumers who view a specific website -> high match with audience = ads that appear in a separate window as a pop-up = audio-video ads which are similar to TV commercials = positioning of the brand/product in a videogame Refers to ads in apps, pop-ups during online searches For this reason, they provide the same options for targeting Option for personalization (consumers provide personal data which can be used for personalized recommendations) Customers have to download app (show initiative) -> app is appropriate to influence later stages of decision making process = ads that appear on search results pages Options for targeting Targeting can be based on locations (e.g. restaurant appears if consumer makes a search related to the location) or on keywords (referred to as branded keywords) Social Media Three views on exposure frequency (Krugman, 1972) View 1: “the ad must be learned in the same way that habits are learned – by practice” (Krugman, 1972) -> continuous exposure to ad is crucial 10 Communication mission must also be reflected in selection of media channels View 2: “at the right moment (when one is “in the market”) it just takes minimal exposure to achieve appropriate effects” (Krugman, 1972) -> openness of the customer towards the ad is crucial (and hence the right moment) View 3 (middle road): o Research suggests that the optimal number of exposures is not endless but rather a few (two to four for TV commercials) o First exposure is characterized by stimuli’s novelty -> focus on object’s nature -> cognate response -> the consumer MUST elicit some response, “if only for the mental classification required to discard the object as of no further interest” (Krugman, 1972) o Second exposure evokes more evaluative and personal responses as cognate responses from first exposure are usually still available (object recognition, memory) -> reevaluation of object’s relevance with focus on personal relevance o Third exposure is “the beginning of disengagement, of withdrawal of attention from a completed task” (Krugman, 1972) Consumers’ moment-to-moment emotional responses to advertisements Research about hedonic experiences provides the following insights: 11 “Frederickson and Kahneman (1993) suggest that the representation of emotional episodes in memory can be likened more to a collection of snapshots than to a continuous film. They argue that people do not simply add up the hedonic values associated with the separate moments to arrive at the measure of overall utility of the series. Rather, they seem to rely on a weighted average model wherein certain key moments are weighted more heavily than others and in fact could serve as proxies for the sequence as a whole.” (Baumgartner et al., 1997); “the peak or most extreme experience and the final moments of the episode have the greatest impact on retrospective evaluations” (Baumgartner et al., 1997) (referred to as peak-end rule11) Preference for improvement: consumers prefer an “improving series of outcomes to a declining one” (Baumgartner et al., 1997) -> preference for “a high peak and a strong positive end note” (Baumgartner et al., 1997)12 Preference for a fast improvement: consumers “are also more satisfied when the improvement occurs at a fast pace” compared to gradual improvement (Baumgartner et al., 1997) (referred to as “velocity of the change”) “people might ignore other factors in evaluating extended experiences” (Baumgartner et al., 1997) such as total or cumulative gain or loss, experience duration (referred to as “duration neglect”13) o Experience duration does not play a direct role on evaluation but is functional in building to a high peak which then again has an indirect positive effect on the evaluation o “Therefore, for commercials that generate pleasant feelings, consumers are likely to prefer advertisements that delay the peak emotional moment as much as possible with the best possible outcome being a high end note” (Baumgartner et al., 1997) Remembering self vs. experiencing self Assuming two ads have a similar, positive end and an identical integral of positive moments, consumers will prefer an ad with an extreme, positive peak to an ad with a consistent sequence of less extreme, positive moments 13 The reason for duration neglect lies in the fact that several key moments rather than the sequence of experiences as a whole are used for evaluation; 12 o “Time after peak is likely to be “dead” time with little beneficial effect on overall evaluations” (Baumgartner et al., 1997) and “actually reduces global evaluation by depressing the final moment of the series” (Baumgartner et al., 1997) Effects of Banner Advertisements Approximately 47%of online advertising spending is allocated to banner advertising In general, responsiveness to different media types varies across different consumer segments; “Hoban and Bucklin (2015) reveal that a consumer’s online responsiveness to banner ads varies over time as the consumer progresses to different stages of the purchase funnel. Likewise, Ackerberg (2001) finds support for differential effects of advertising for experienced versus inexperienced consumers.”; Based on their research, Lobschat et. Al (2017) draw the following conclusions o Banner ads: Consumers in earlier stages of the purchase funnel “seem to become activated by the firm’s banner advertising (…) and are likely to visit the firm’s website to search for more information. Thus, these consumers should be targeted with banner ads that provide concrete information about the firm’s current product offering” o TV ads: “Given that TV advertising serves the same role of motivating these consumers to visit the firm’s website, TV ads aired at time slots when mostly nonrecent consumers are watching should explicitly mention the website and highlight the information that can be obtained there.” o “banner ads are effective for both types of consumers, albeit through different routes” Banner ads contribute (1) directly to the objects advertised, and (2) to the brand building in general “For nonrecent online consumers, the success of a banner ad campaign can be gauged by the number of website visits generated by banner ads, as they are strongly linked to offline sales.”; “a lack of online response should not be interpreted as an indication of low banner ad effectiveness because these consumers do show a positive offline sales response” B. Social Media = “utilization of social media or social networks to market a product, company, or brand” Social Media Marketing Strategies Social Media Marketing Strategy Real-time Marketing Creation and execution of an instantaneous marketing message via SoMe in response to or during a live event Video Marketing Using videos on SoMe to promote and market products/services Influencer Marketing Using an individual to market a brand Alignment between brand and individual is crucial Interactive Marketing Usage of two-way communication channels to allow interaction / to allow consumers to connect with the company directly Consumer-Generated Usage of customer-generated material and feedback (e.g. consumer Content Marketing reviews) What drives consumer sharing of Social Media brand messages (Ordenes et al., 2018) "Consumers are more willing to share brand messages with informational or emotional content, rather than demands or commands” o Emotional: e.g. “Fridays are fun!” o Informational: e.g. “We have a new product launch this Friday” o Demands/commands: e.g. “Come to our event Friday!” On Facebook, rhetorical styles are likely to be shared “On Twitter, explicit advertising cues (e.g., directive messages, including repetition and alliteration) will turn consumers’ attention elsewhere “action images in combination with assertive or expressive messages will result in greater engagement than action images with directive messages” WOM “Word-of-mouth communication strategies are appealing because they combine the prospect of overcoming consumer resistance with significantly lower costs and fast delivery” “We find that WOM referrals have a strong impact on new customer acquisition.”; “The elasticity for WOM is approximately 20 times higher than that for marketing events and 30 times that of media appearances.” “The electronic tracking of WOM, along with new member sign-ups, enables us to provide a concrete and measurable link between observed WOM activity and customer acquisition” C. Direct Marketing Direct Marketing Types Database Driven Marketing Direct Response Marketing Personal Selling Usage of databases to derive appropriate communication strategies usage of ID codes and cookie data to customize content on websites usage of personalized communications (e.g. birthday mails) usage of available data to personalize content (e.g. based on previous purchases) aims to evoke a direct response/action by customer -> strong focus on activating (e.g. by using coupons) includes direct mail, catalogues, and mass media appropriateness depends a lot on product D. Public Relations = “Public relations is a strategic communication process that builds mutually beneficial relationships between organizations and their publics” objectives: generating publicity, enhancing the general reputation of the company, informing the public about activities at the corporate level rather than product/brand level PR strategies: proactive vs. reactive (defensive) E. Event Marketing and Sponsorships Sponsorship Objectives Event Marketing Objectives Enhance company image Aim to support certain lifestyles At the corporate level Brand-name recognition Increase company visibility Mostly at the corporate level Differentiate company/brand from competitors In both marketing activities, match between company mission (+ underlying values) and the sponsored athlete, celebrity, etc. or event is crucial F. Sales Promotion Sales Promotions Discounts & Allowances Promotional pricing Segmented pricing Reduced prices to reward customer responses such as making volume purchases, paying early, or promoting the product Discounts: Early-bird discounts, quantity discounts, functional discounts (=discounts for referrals to friends) Allowances: “Turn in the old item when buying a new one” Temporal price reductions Different prices for different segments S6 Strategic Impact of Marketing Communication – Money & Measurement 6.1 Money How much will be spent to communicate? 6.1.1 Types of Budgets Percentage of Sales o Allocations are derived from either Sales from previous year Or anticipated sales for the next year Meet the Competition o Seeks to prevent loss of market share o Depends on how much your competitor spends on communication What Can we Afford o Sets marketing communication budget after all the company’s other budget have been established Objective and Task o Identify the marketing objective (not marketing communication objective!) to pursue and then calculate the cost of accomplishing each objective o Communications budget is the cumulative cost of accomplishing each objective Payout Planning o Management establishes a ratio of communications to sales or market share o Allocate greater amounts in early years to get payouts later Which budget type is appropriate in which situation? 6.1.2 Allocating Money for Marketing Communications Largely depends on the decisions regarding the execution of the marketing communication Types of schedules o Pulsating schedule = continuous communications during the year with bursts of higher intensity at specific times Makes sense for products that are (1) used continuously/products of daily life (e.g. deodorants) and that are (2) used more at specific times of the year (e.g. summer months) o Fighting schedule o = communications are presented at only peak times and not at al during other times Makes sense for products that are solely used during specific times of the year (e.g. winter coats) Continuous campaign schedule = spending in level amounts to keep the brand in front of the consumers repetitively Makes sense for products that are used continuously over the year without peaks (e.g. detergents) 6.2 Measurement How will the impact of the marketing communication be assessed? Marketing research objective: identify and define marketing opportunities and problems generate, refine and evaluate marketing actions to make them more effective assess the impact of the marketing communication Marketing research process: 1 Problem definition 2 Research design development 3 Data collection: manage and implement the data collection process 4 Data analysis: analyze the results 5 Communicating findings: communicate the findings and its implications 2 Research design development: Exploratory vs. Conclusive Research design the method/plan for collecting information Research Design Process: o Define the information needed to answer the problem defined earlier o Decide on the design -> Exploratory vs. Conclusive Research o Decide on the techniques of understanding and/or measurement o Construct form for data collection -> See classification of marketing research data o Sampling method/size o Develop data analysis Research Design Classification depends on the kind of information needed for the specific marketing communication campaign Exploratory vs. conclusive design o o Exploratory research uses: obtain background information to define problem areas and formulate hypotheses to reduce no. of different ideas in new marketing communication campaign to identify relevant behavior patterns to explore sensitive issues (e.g. explore emotions associated with a brand in the target segment) Conclusive research: Uses: To describe characteristics of relevant groups To make specific predictions To compare findings over time To determine the degree to which marketing variables are associated E.g. measure the impact of a marketing communication on sales Conclusive design can either be descriptive research: o a prior formulation of specific research questions and hypotheses exists o information needed is clearly defined o Examples: market size, consumer buying power, sales by geographic region, consumer perceptions of the company, consumption patterns, consumer responses to price changes, media consumption habits, traffic-flow of channels or casual research o objective is to obtain an evidence of cause-and-effect relationships o Examples: whether the intro of the new brand will increase market share of the brand; whether the campaign will increase sales 3 Data collection: Classification of Marketing Research Data Primary data: collection of new data Qualitative data/research: Objective is to gain a qualitative understanding of the underlying reasons and motivations (e.g. how did the affective campaign influence consumer emotions) sample: small sample of nonrepresentative cases Collection: unstructured Data analysis: nonstatistical intended to provide an initial insight and understanding Direct (try to get deep down to motivations) Focus In-Depth groups Interviews Indirect (try get the top of the mind associations) Projective techniques: Association techniques Completion techniques Construction techniques Expressive techniques Secondary data: already available data Quantitative data/research: Objective: seeks to quantify data and generalize the results from the sample to the population of interest sample: large number of representative cases Collection: structured Data analysis: related to measurement and statistical analysis Recommends a final course of action Descriptive Survey Data Causal Obser- Experimental vational & other data 3 Data collection: Focus groups = discussions conducted by a trained moderator in a non-structured and natural manner with a small group of participants 6-10 people who discuss with each other -> members “feed off” each other Objective is similar to in-depth interviews; aim is to uncover deep lying associations and feelings Drawback: members may feel intimidated, shy and not reveal anything significant -> try to compose a homogeneous group which allows a relaxed, informal and comfortable setting Use of storyboards, mood boards, products, advertisements, films, music, websites to stimulate discussion Use of audiocassettes, videotapes and notes to record the discussions 1,5 – 6 hours 3 Data collection: In-depth Interviews Unstructured, direct, personal interview in which a single participant is questioned by an interviewer Objective: uncover underlying motivations, beliefs, attitudes and feelings on a topic (the marketing communication plan); affective associations which lie deep within consumers’ minds and are difficult to be assessed from the outside Techniques: o Laddering technique: interviewer develops a mental map of consumer’s view toward a particular product this is done for several homogeneous consumers results in a laddered map which represents the link between products and consumer’s perceptions enables to understand how consumers translate attributes through their personal meanings focus on motives behind the consumption focus on cognitive structure (means-end chain: attributes .-> consequences > values) appropriate for HF case as it refers back to the means-end-chain concept with the segment’s desired values and the product attributes measure if consumers establish the cues in the same way as we did in designing the marketing plan did the product attributes help to realize the desired values/does the consumer believe they do so o Zaltman metaphor elicitation technique: Interviewer creates a mental map of consumer’s views towards a communication Interviewer asks interviewees to bring in pictures that reflect their thoughts about a communication (method uses images and metaphors to reveal how consumers think and feel) Less appropriate for HF case because the segment’s desired values are not obviously linked to metaphors or images -> technique is not better than laddering 3 Data collection: Projective Techniques Unstructured, indirect form of questioning that encourages respondents to project their underlying motivations, beliefs, attitudes, or feelings regarding the issues of concern Recipients are not really aware of the fact that they are part of a research -> facilitates to uncover the processes that go on within their subconscious mind Types: word associations, sentence completion, cartoon constructions, role playing Is more appropriate to uncover attitudes which are on top of the mind of consumers’ minds (spontaneous cues) and less appropriate to uncover associations which are located deeply in consumer minds 3 Data collection: Survey Data Structured questionnaires Sample of a target population Most questions are fixed-response alternative questions -> participants are asked to select from a predetermined set of response 3 Data collection: Observation Method Recording the behavioral patterns of people in a systematic manner Can be o Personal: researcher observes actual behavior as it occurs (e.g. no of people entering store) o o Electronic (eye-tracking, neuromarketing, psycho-galvanometer, voice-pitch analysis, response latency) Or in form of a trace analysis e.g. through web cookies (traces, evidences, past behavior) 3 Data collection: Experimental Research Used to test a causal relationship between variables Procedure: o Determine test units o Determine independent variables to be manipulated o Determine dependent variables to be measured o Determine how to control for extraneous variables 4 Data analysis: Message evaluation techniques Advertising Tracking Research Is what? Conducted by famous MR companies such as Nielsen IAG or Millward Brown in the form of continuous report cards Used when? After campaign launch Procedure respondents are shown a brief portion of the ad with the brand name removed What is to be measured brand and ad recognition, unaided brand awareness, memorability, likability, unaided and aided message 14 Copytesting Neuromarketing Online Evaluation Metrics At the final stages of campaign development; One form: Emotional Reaction Tests such as Warmth Meter (used specifically for affective advertisements14) Evaluation of main message and format: brand message and image, memorability of ad and brand, enjoyability of ad, Ad design Warmth Meter provides insights on which ad sections elicit positive and which ad sections elicit negative emotions -> reveals how the audience shows emotional reactions (can also be used to investigate differences in emotional responses between target audience and total audience) recall, unaided and aided campaign recall Insights provided what the ad communicates, how well the ad communicates the intended message, potential response, persuasive power of ad, engagement of the viewer with ad and brand insights about campaign performance in comparison to previous campaigns and to competitors insights about the point at which consumers stop giving attention to campaign Evaluation Brainwave activity Associated with high costs but very valuable and thus recommended in order to test the campaign before the launch Does not rely on self-reporting and is hence a great indicator of respondent’s true reaction Online/Digital Advertising Evaluation Metrics: Click through rate (CTR) Length of engagement Dwell time Dwell rate Bounce rate Time on page Impressions Hits No of visitors New vs. repeat visitors 15 No of clicks on ad / total impressions of ad Refers to SEO: Length of time a person spends looking at a webpage after they’ve clicked a link on a SERP page, but before clicking back to the SERP results15 measures the proportion of users who physically touch the ad percentage of visitors who visit one page and then click to any other page on or off the company’s website; For a weather forecast site, a high bounce rate is a good thing as it indicates that consumers quickly found what they were looking for time a user spends anywhere on your page before leaving No of times your content is displayed Number of visits Is relevant in SEO strategy: If you operate a weather site, it may take less than five mins for people to get what they want from a link so that dwell time would naturally be low Page views Page views per visit Entry and exit pages Cost per click (CPC) Conversion ratio (CR) AOV Revenue per visit (RPV) Sales Funnel Efficiency Social Media Volume Metrics Social Media Engagement Metrics Social Media Conversion Metrics Price you pay for each click Percentage of customers who take your desired action Average dollar amount spent each time a customer places an order Amount of money generated each time a customer visits your page Measure the level of traffic to SoMe sites and no of visitors to SoMe sites: views, likes, new and lost subscribers/followers, location, time/day of visit Show the level of engagement with SoMe sites and level of involvement: mentions, shares/reposts/retweets, likes, comments, time on page, visits per day or month, bounce rate CTR, CR, AOV, RPV Retro 07-Oct 2020 Theoretical framework for marketing communication plan is the 6M model. Background information o Tie background information with why the brand needs a new marketing communication plan o strategic intent: why do you have to come up with a new marketing communication plan (think of the plan’s impact on the brand) o Strategic positioning of the brand o Overall strategy -> setting the stage for mission which component of the attitude do you intend to change? Cognitive component (mission component 1 disseminate information) and as a result affective responses to the brand (PCB hierarchy of effects: cognitions – affect – behavior order) market: focus on result of the segmentation (the target market) rather than the segmentation process o does market make sense with regard to the strategic positioning of the brand execution – message: o visualize (print ad in appendix) or storytell (what will the consumer see, how will his experience look like: busy work woman scrolls through her SoMe feed in the evening and sees a post of so of her social network with whom she can identify…) o elaboration likelihood model o why enhancing motivation to attend message and process information o Coca cola: message = taste the feeling -> they communicate different stories which convey the message o In our exam: outline one potential story / one form of execution Execution – media: o Which media channels are most important (focus on these) and which can be used as an addition o HF is known as a digital brand -> communicate via digital media o Stay with the specific story to present the media which will be used to communicate this specific story impact – money: o which associated costs are to be expected considering the selected media (budget/costs must reflect the individual components of the media mix) o how long will you engage in the marketing plan (1/2 years?) o e.g. how often will TV ads be changed impact – measurement: o must be consistent with mission (and relate to all components of the mission) o research problem: what is/how are we going to measure the impact of our marketing communications plan (in our case: on the attitude) o everyone will use conclusive research design (<-> exploratory) @Gülen: doesn’t exploratory research makes sense in order to explore the feelings within the target segment? o Indicate the research process but no need to precisely explain how, for instance, the survey will be designed etc.