Target Situation Analysis on Developing Writing Skills for Non-Teaching Personnel in Private Schools Biographical information: Gender Age First Language background: Tagalog/Filipino Reasons for learning the language: To develop writing skills that will improve their competency in their workplace Other languages spoken: English Time available for learning: June-July 2021 1. Why is the language needed? Language is an important communication tool used to transmit information between two or more people in carrying out their daily activities. By using language, we could understand each other. In learning language, four skills should be mastered, they were: speaking, listening, reading, and writing. Writing as one of the skills to communicate is not an ability we acquire naturally; even in our first language, it must be taught. However, writing is not interesting for most EFL (English as a Foreign Language) students. Writing is considered the most difficult and complicated language skill to be learned compared to other language skills – listening, speaking, and reading. It requires more effort to produce meaning through writing than to recognize meaning through listening and reading (Dixon & Nessel, 1983). In fact, Nunan (1999), considers it as an enormous challenge to produce “a coherent, fluent, extended piece of writing” in one’s second language. This is magnified by the fact that the rhetorical conventions of English texts – the structure, style, and organization – often differ from the convention in other languages. It requires effort to recognize and manage the differences (Leki, 1991). According to Zemach and Rumisek (2005), the teaching of writing is important due to the following reasons: (1) writing reinforces the grammatical structure, idiom, and vocabulary that the teacher has been working within the class; (2) when the student writes, Page | 1 she or he has a chance to be adventurous with the language; (3) the student becomes involved with the language, with himself or herself, and with his or her readers. For non-teaching personnel who write different letters in making reports, it is a requirement that they must create a logical and error-free letter in their field of work. 2. How will the language be used? Due to the great number of individuals who are creating letters in English in their field of work, particularly the non-teaching personnel, this ESP course targets the nonteaching personnel in private schools and aims to develop writing skills in using the English language in communication. 3. What will the content areas be? The course is designed for non-teaching personnel in private schools to improve their writing skills. This course will focus on how to help the non-teaching staff do their letters, requests, and forms, and the likes to be accurate and properly addressed before turning it in. ESP is a movement that entails to a different field that will use the English as their language, to its specific learning and how to use it towards the different group of learners, that’s the reason why this course was made to teach English to a specific group of learners, which were the non-teaching staffs of private schools. Writing is one of the macro skills that an individual should master, inside a school, we are aware of the teacher’s mastery of making it, they have a lot of things to do, and they are not available at all times if the non-teaching staff will ask them to do the writing for them. Non-teaching personnel's task is to make a letter, request, forms, etc. for the school’s compilation of information and they should undergo a convention for them to improve their writing skills, it incorporates vocabulary, letter formatting, editing, outlining, and knowing the basic principles of writing. Planned Learning Activities: A. OUTLINE Remember that Outlines are your friend – The non-teaching personnel is making forms and requests, they should start on which they are familiar with, doing a grocery or sometimes being in a restaurant, they will do an outlining activity for them to be more at ease in doing it. They will be given a format and they will fill it in based on the kinds of restaurants or grocery stores that they have traveled or visited. An outline is not needed to be a complex process. A simple framework should be followed that has a particular order with supporting detail about each section, will be enough. Page | 2 B. FORMAT A Letter for you – Non-teaching personnel are consistently making a letter and this activity will help them recognize the different structures of diverse styles in making a business letter. The clients will make a business letter that has a return address, where to put inside the letter, the inside address, a salutation, paragraphs, and closing should be intact. The learners will first identify the correct parts and how to start the letter correctly. C. EDITING Correct Me if I’m Wrong – The clients of this convention will practice their editing skills and they will amend the worksheets that will be given to them which have a lot of errors that need to be fixed. It will help the clients be more aware of their forms, requests, or letters after finishing the convention. D. BASIC PRINCIPLES The Basics – The clients will be asked to write their schema about the basic principles of writing, after soliciting their answers they will learn the suitable principles for them not to be lost while doing their job. Then, the clients will be asked to memorize the basic principles in writing. It will help them to do their paperwork faster than before. The clients should know the standards in writing to hone their skills. E. VOCABULARY In teaching ESP, vocabulary should not be neglected, especially in a communication process, because the clients will be honing their writing skills, vocabulary is needed. It will help them to become an advanced writer, it will also elevate their pride whenever they send their letter, forms, and requests to a superior or other authority. 4. Who will the learner use the language with? The people who will receive their writings. It can be a production staff whenever they have suggestions or complaints about some delivered books or a librarian from other schools if the client needs some advice about creative bookkeeping and the likes. This course aims to use the English language in communication through writing, to have strict and precise wordings, an intelligent letter, a straight point in a request or forms, a report for all the loads they need to address. It will be a great help in their work environment and to give them a positive assurance that the papers that they will send to the other establishments will be appropriate and correct. Page | 3 5. Where will the language be used? The needs analysis undertaken here was designed for developing writing skills for English Language Communication and aims to improve learners’ competency in their workplace. The target students of this course are the non-teaching personnel in private schools whose main duty is to carry out administrative tasks that include clerical work and routine documentation in the school to foster greater productivity. This course aims to enhance the writing skills needed and communicative competence of the learners by accentuating the resemblance of the tasks in their field of work in the real world. Generally, the writing skills will be used in their everyday tasks alongside teachers on the professional input and expertise. This ensures that there is an efficient infrastructure within which effective teaching and learning can occur. 6. When will the language be used? As we learn a language, there are four macro skills that we need for communication, these are listening, speaking, reading, and writing. We need to master these skills for us to communicate with other people. Humans adapt the language by listening first, then will eventually learn to speak, and then will learn how to read and write with the help of formal education. Listening, speaking, and reading skills are complex in various ways for it decodes and delivers messages verbally and by analyzing symbols conveyed by the sender. However, writing is considered to be the most complex skill in communication. For it takes time and practice to grasp the said skill. Writing is not just about practicing by knowing the strokes of each letter in the alphabet. Writing is also a process in which a person can communicate his thoughts and feelings through symbols. This can also be a means to develop and strengthen human connections and society. Writing is a multifaceted intellectual task including various component skills, some of which learners may lack completely, and some of which they may have only somewhat mastered. When people lack skills in these areas, the performance in their workplace will be greatly affected. Their outputs may be unsatisfactory in numerous ways – from poor grammar and syntax to vague organization to weak reasoning and arguments. That is why the complex nature of writing can help us to design assignments and provide support as students continue to hone their skills more effectively. However, in New Zealand, there has been very little research into determining exactly what is meant by "written communication skills". Surveys have consistently shown that employers rank oral and written communication skills as highly as or more highly than any technical or quantitative skills. (Gray et al., 2005) In connection to this, the target situation analysis is carried out based on the needs of educational units which are suitable with the students’ interests and needs, social and cultural local developments, and current and future conditions. An understanding of the Page | 4 target workplace setting will help acculturate to the English demands, which suggests pedagogies in the implementation of the English for Non-Teaching Personnel in Private Schools. Where learners of this course as non-teaching personnel will not only develop competency to do their job but also express confidence in English communication particularly in the demands of writing outputs. The implementation of this course is expected to engage non-teaching personnel to transform and support education to enable new ways to work together with the use of writing skills gained from this program in their workplace. For it makes the most of opportunities provided to change education since it also provides support for teachers too and they variously play a vital role in the educational system. Page | 5 ESP Program for Non-Teaching Personnel in Private Schools Course Title: Writing Skills Development for Non-Teaching Purposes Course Description: This ESP course is designed to improve the workplace writing competence of nonteaching personnel working in private schools. The course aims to help prepare clients for different kinds of writing they will encounter as non-teaching staff of the school they are currently employed. This 15-hour short course is conducted in a workshop format that includes short lectures and writing activities. Mode of Instruction: To avoid the risk of contracting the virus from having face-to-face learning, workshops shall be conducted via digital platforms while clients stay at the comfort of their homes. A combination of digital learning platforms and applications will be utilized to deliver the learning and teaching effectively. Time Allotment: This short course has a total of 5 sessions and each session will last up to 3 hours. The schedule is as follows: Session 1 Session 2 TOPIC/CONTENT What is Writing? A. Introduction B. Types C. Genres D. Writing Process What is Business Writing? A. Types COMPETENCY/IES - define what is writing - determine the different types and genres in writing - recognize the correct writing process - identify the types of business writing DURATION 3 hours METHODOLOGY - lecture - formative assessment - clients’ expectation - lecture 3 hours Page | 6 B. Principles of Good Business Writing C. Business Letter Format - grasp the principles of a good business writing - recognize the format of a business letter - The Basics (Individual activity) - A Letter for you (Group Activity) - drills Session 3-4 Session 5 Business Writing A. Writing a Request Letter B. Writing a Report C. Writing an Email D. Writing a Memo Formatting a Business Document A. Using Graphics B. Typography Grammar Review A. Verbs B. Pronouns C. Punctuation, Mechanics, and Spelling - classify the different ways in writing a specific business letter - compose a request letter, a report, an email, and a memo - recognize the use of graphics and typography - recall verbs and pronouns - analyze the different punctuation marks and their use - review spelling 6 hours 3 hours - lecture - Correct Me if I’m Wrong (paired activity) - Remember that Outlines are your friend (individual activity) - short quiz - drills - lecture - group discussion - oral activity - Practical Examination Grading System: Writing Outputs 20% Group Participation 20% Practical Examination 50% Attendance___________________________10% TOTAL 100% Page | 7 Attendance Policy: Our client attendance policy outlines the expectations about the clients' attendance to class. Being punctual when coming to class helps maintain efficiency in the learning process. Clients are encouraged to complete the entire course without absences. Being consistently tardy or absent can cause problems for the program. This behavior may bring about a “bad attendance” record and the client may need to go through make-up classes before obtaining the certificate. Post-Course: At the end of the ESP Course, participants will have to take part in the course assessment and evaluation. A digital certificate of completion will be sent to the clients by email, up to 15 days after they have completed the course. This digital certificate can be shared with their professional network and showcased for promotion purposes. Page | 8 EVALUATION Target Situation Analysis on Developing Writing Skills for Non-Teaching Personnel in Private Schools Subjective Analysis 1a. Who are your learners? Objective Analysis Audience 1b. To whom is the material intended for? The librarian, registrar, cashier, and the property custodian who deals with different letters may it be a request or a report. 2a. What are the aims of your course? It is intended for administrative staff of Charles Sturt University (CSU). Aims 2a. What are the aims of the materials? To develop the writing skills among these non-teaching staff. To develop or continue the learners’ understanding of Business Writing, Report Writing, and Business Reporting Language (BRL) at CSU. Content 3a. What kind of language description do 3b. What type(s) of linguistic description you require? is/are used in the materials? The course requires functional-notional grammar. 4a. What language points should be covered? The linguistic description that is used in the materials is from functional-notional grammar wherein the outputs of the learners are based on their intention or purpose in writing such a report, letter or forms, and the likes. 4b. What language points do the materials cover? The course will cover grammar, coherence, accuracy, effectiveness, and appropriate proofreading. Writing with the correct format of the different business letters or reports with strict structures and proper arrangement using the language. 5a. What proportion of work on each macro skill (e.g. writing) is desired? 5b. What is the proportion of work on each skill? Is there skill-integrated work? Writing accurate and appropriate business letters, reports, or forms. The material focuses on writing, that’s why it has skill-integrated work - writing, reading, and listening. Page | 9 6a. What micro-skills do you need? The micro-skills needed on this course that the clients need to be aware of is to reflect on the features, semantics, and pragmatics when writing different business letters, reports, and the likes. 7a. What text types should be included? It is a combination of factual text types that includes description, recount, or persuasive and literary text types such as narrative or personal response. 8b. What is/are the subject matter area(s), and types of topics in the materials? Subject Matter: ESP for Non-Teaching Staff The following topics are needed for this course: ● What is Writing? - Introduction - Types - Genres - Writing Process ● What is Business Writing? - Types - Principles of Good Business Writing - Business Letter Format ● Business Writing - Writing a Request Letter - Writing a Report - Writing an Email - Writing a Memo ● Formatting a Business Document - Using Graphics - Typography 6b. What micro-skills are covered in the material? These are the micro-skills that are covered in the materials used, the client should remember and classify typing, spelling, and punctuation in writing different business letters, reports, and the likes. 7b. What kinds of texts are there in the materials? Descriptive and narrative texts are mostly included in the materials used. 8b. What is/are the subject matter area(s), and types of topics in the materials? The material focuses on: - Purpose of Effective Writing - Different Styles of Correspondence and CSU Templates - Writing for a Purpose - Ensuring Professional Documents - Common Business Reporting Language - Effective Emails - Reviewing and Proofreading: CSU Styles and Standards - Report Writing: Purpose, Planning, and Structure - Representing Data Visually ● Grammar Review - Verbs - Pronouns - Punctuation, Mechanics, and Spelling Page | 10 9a. How should the content be organized in the course? 9b. How is the content sequenced throughout the book? The content should follow strict organization based on its topics and subtopics, from simple to complex process to hone the clients writing skills. 10a. How should the content be sequenced within a unit? Short lectures and handouts are given in the beginning for each part. It is followed by sets of exercises and application activities. 10b. How is the content sequenced within a unit? The content will act in accordance with comprehension to production. The sequence within the unit started on how the clients comprehend the topics presented to them until they produce their outputs. Methodology 11a. What theories of learning should the 11b. What theories of learning are the course be based on? materials based on? It is based on Constructivism theory with an affective factor. 12a. What aspects of the learners’ attitudes to/ expectations about learning English should the course take into account? The aspects of the learners’ that were taken into considerations are their learning styles, retention, transference, and their interest or motivation. 13a. What kinds of exercises/tasks are needed? The materials are based on constructivism theory, in which the learners are the ones who will create or establish their outputs and the center of the learning process. 12b. What attitudes to/expectations about learning English are the materials based on? The materials are based on clients’ motivation, learning habits, retention, and transference to improve their writing skills. 13b. What kinds of exercises/tasks are included in the materials? The exercises/tasks needed for this course are the repetition of making different business letters or reports, an individual and group activity to promote cooperation and collaboration. The exercises/tasks that are included are more on writing skills and making their own output (letter, report or forms, etc.). 14a. What teaching-learning techniques are to be used? 14b. What teaching-learning techniques can be used with the materials? These techniques were used in implementing the course, it was a The materials to be used will help the students in their writing skills because they do editing, outlining, and proofreading. Page | 11 combination of group work, pair work, and client’s presentation of their outputs. 15a. What aids are available for use? 15b. What aids do the materials require? A computer/laptop and a smartphone will be used to implement the course. The clients should accomplish the module by the end of the workshop. 16a. What guidance/support for teaching the course does the course need? 16b. What aids do the materials require? To be able to achieve a good result of this course, the following support/guidance should be present; Clients are encouraged to expand their knowledge and skills by taking up work-based or more formalized learning opportunities at the programs conclusion. a. thorough discussion and application of activities so the non-teaching personnel will become more at ease in writing a letter, report, and the likes b. clear objectives for this course and c. variety of materials that supports writing skills to improve. Decision: We will conform and modify the evaluated material. Link to the material evaluated: http://www.csu.edu.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0004/51934/Business-Report-WritingSkills.pdf Page | 12 APPENDIX A Interview Questions of English Language Needs of Non-Teaching Personnel in Private Schools PART ONE 1. Where do you work? 2. What is your job title? 3. What is your field of specialty? 4. Where did you graduate from? 5. What is your course in college? PART TWO 1. What percentage of your work is conducted in English? Librarian Registrar Accounting Staff Property Custodian Sacred Heart Academy of Sta. Maria (Bulacan), Inc. Librarian Sacred Heart Academy of Sta. Maria (Bulacan), Inc. Admission and Records Officer Keep official school records of students (hard and electronic copy). Make sure that students have complete documents with identical information. Sacred Heart Academy of Sta. Maria (Bulacan), Inc. Cashier Bulacan State University Baliuag University Bulacan State University Sacred Heart Academy of Sta. Maria (Bulacan), Inc. Property and Facilities Head Make sure that everything is working properly from the simplest thing (doorknobs) to the complex things (breakers and wirings). Ensure the safety of the equipment and facilities. Bulacan State University Bachelor of Elementary Education Bachelor of Science in Business Administration Bachelor of Science in Business Administration Bachelor of Industrial Technology 95% of my task is related to English. Everything from making a request, and finding 90% of my task is related to English. School forms and other important documents are written in the 85% of my task is in the English language, even the software and the receipts are in the English 80% of my tasks are conducted in English language. Forms, request letters, even Keep record of books (acquired and for evaluation). Assist teachers and students in finding reading materials and references. Assist parents and students in payment. Receive payments, answer queries, and audit money. Page | 13 2. Have you been engaged in writing workshops while working at school? If yes, what language was used in the workshop? 3. How important is it to have a high level of English proficiency to perform your job effectively? PART THREE 1. Rank the following English language skill in terms of importance in performing your references are all in WRITTEN English language. English language, language. The only thing that is not English (most of the time) is communicating with parents and students. No. incident reports are all written using the English language. No. No. It is necessary to have a high level of English proficiency. As a librarian, most of the books that we acquire, especially researchrelated, are printed overseas. I need to have good written communication skills to communicate with different publishers. It is needed. I can say that learning the spoken English language is needed, but the written English language is necessary. Written English is a must as we write a lot of things regarding students' accounts. We give statements of accounts and verify their payments online. We need to have knowledge of formal written English. It is not much needed, but it is still a must to learn the language. Writing reports is important, and we need to have enough knowledge on how to make a report less terrible as possible. 1 – Reading 2 – Writing 3 – Listening 4 – Speaking 1 – Writing 2 – Reading 3 – Speaking 4 – Listening 1 – Writing 2 – Reading 3 – Speaking 4 – Listening 1 – Writing 2 – Reading 3 – Speaking 4 – Listening No. Page | 14 job. Please write 1 being the most important and 4 being the least important. 2. Will you be Yes. interested to avail an ESP program in the future? Yes. Yes. Yes. Page | 15 APPENDIX B May 3, 2021 To whom it may concern, I voluntarily agree to participate in the interview of Ms. Arminda Barlam for their target situation analysis. I understand that this interview is being conducted by Ms. Barlam to develop the writing skills of the non-teaching personnel in Goldenville School of Montessori Inc. and is also a terminal requirement for her ELE 906 – English for Specific Purposes subject. I grant permission for the interview to be tape recorded and transcribed, and to be used only by Ms. Barlam and her groupmates for analysis of interview data. I grant permission for the data gathered to be published in their Target Situation Analysis Report. Sincerely, ANNA CHARICE REYES Signature over printed name Interviewee: Ms. Anna Charice Reyes Position: Cashier/Registrar PART ONE 1. Where do you work? Goldenville School of Montessori Inc. 2. What is your job title? Cashier and at the same time registrar. 3. What is your field of specialty? Biology and ICT Page | 16 4. Where did you graduate from? Bulacan Agricultural State College 5. What is your course in college? Bachelor of Secondary Education 6. When did you graduate from college? April 2005 PART TWO 1. What percentage of your work is conducted in English? 80-90% 2. Have you been engaged in writing workshops while working at school? If yes, what language was used in the workshop? Yes, I am always included in every writing workshop that were conducted in school with all our teaching personnel. The language used is always English. 3. How important is it to have a high level of English proficiency to perform your job effectively? As the registrar and cashier in an English-speaking school, it is a must for me to always speak and communicate in English with our clients. Also, with the nature of my job, communicating in English seems to be a sign of formality from letters, emails, clearances and all the transactions that I made with the people involved whether online, printed letters, or actual communication. PART THREE 1. Rank the following English language skill in terms of importance in performing your job. Please write 1 being the most important and 4 being the least important. • Writing 1 • Speaking 2 • Reading 3 • Listening 4 2. Will you be interested to avail an ESP program in the future? Yes. Page | 17 Page | 18 References Dixon, C., & Nessel, D. (1983). Language experience approach to reading. The Alemany Press. Gray, F. E., Emerson, L., & MacKay, B. (2005). Meeting the demands of the workplace: Science students and written skills. Journal of Science Education and Technology, 14(4), 425–435. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10956-005-8087-y Leki, I. (1991). The preferences of ESL students for error correction in College-Level writing classes. Foreign Language Annals, 24(3), 203–218. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1944-9720.1991.tb00464.x Nunan, D. (1999). Second language teaching & learning. Macmillan Publishers. Writing with Sharon Watson. (2016, April 6). Writing curriculum reviews for writing with sharon watson. Writing with Sharon Watson-Easy-to-Use Homeschool Writing and Literature Curriculum. https://writingwithsharonwatson.com/reviews/ Zemach, D., & Rumisek, L. E. (2005). Academic writing from paragraph to essay. Macmillan Publishers. Page | 19