For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. Global Real Estate Market Outlook Q1 2021 02 Global Real Estate Market Outlook For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. “As a result of increased lockdowns, ASIRI has lowered its forecasts for 2021. The US is the exemption. Unified democratic control of the US presidency and congress, and the expectation of increased stimulus spending, should boost growth.” Executive summary • Despite several highly contagious new variants of coronavirus and increased lockdown restrictions in many major economies, unified democratic control of the US presidency and congress implies further large-scale stimulus, which will boost growth. Taking account of both developments, the Aberdeen Standard Investments Research Institute (ASIRI) has reduced its 2021 economic growth forecasts down almost everywhere. In the US, the forecasts for 2021 have been revised up as have the global forecasts for 2022. • The vaccine rollout is now underway. However, the early pace of rollout has fallen short of government promises in most economies. Take-up willingness is worryingly low in much of continental Europe; while emerging markets other than China, Russia and India are yet to secure meaningful quantities of vaccine. The US, UK and Israel are exceptions, where the initial rollout has been rapid, although still plagued by hurdles. We still expect vaccines to allow a meaningful easing in restrictions. • Although energy base effects will push inflation higher in the short-term, these will be short-lived. The global economy has enormous spare capacity, which will take time to erode. Inflation expectations are low and anchored and central banks have plenty of room to contain inflation if needed. The upshot is that both the short- and long-term implications of this crisis are likely to be net disinflationary. • Prices have started to correct on a global basis, particularly in the parts of the market that have been most affected by the impact of Covid-19. Our forecasts anticipate the decline in values playing out further over the next six months. We expect prices to recover thereafter as the occupier and investment markets revive, and as lockdown measures are eased in line with more of the population being vaccinated. • Going into this crisis, the fundamentals supporting real estate were relatively sound. Generally, there was an absence of oversupply and vacancy rates were at modest levels in most markets. Currently, there is also a large amount of uninvested capital waiting to be deployed into the asset class because of the attractive yield margin. All of these factors should help accelerate the anticipated market recovery further into 2021, assuming the Covid-19 crisis stabilises. There are likely to be opportunities for well-capitalised investors to pick up attractively priced assets further on into the correction. • We continue to prefer sectors of the market that are benefiting from long-term structural trends: ageing demographics, changes in technology, a focus on sustainability and changes in the way we are shopping and living. Sectors that continue to benefit from these trends include industrials, residential, and selective assets that are categorised as alternatives. These sectors remain more resilient than the parts of the market that are vulnerable to the secular changes. In our view, retail remains particularly exposed to the changes, with the current crisis accentuating structural transformation in the sector. We remain risk averse and continue to pursue ‘sustainable’ income in our target markets. Furthermore, we continue to maintain a forensic approach to seeking value in our favoured markets. Global economic overview • The emergence of several highly contagious variants of coronavirus has meant increased lockdown restrictions in many major economies. This will send some into double-dip recessions. But unified Democratic control of the US presidency and congress implies further large-scale fiscal stimulus, which will boost growth. Taking account of both developments, ASIRI has revised its 2021 gross domestic product (GDP) forecasts for almost everywhere outside the US down, but their US forecasts for 2021 and global forecasts for 2022 have been revised up. • There have been several important developments lately. First, data at the end of last year showed remarkable resilience in the manufacturing sector, which is less affected by renewed lockdowns relative to the spring. Admittedly, lengthening supplier delivery times show up as a positive in purchasing managers’ index (PMI) calculations, which gives a false impression of strength, while retail sales and mobility measures were weakening in the final months of 2020. But it means ASIRI has revised up its 2020 GDP forecasts (pending fourth-quarter data), particularly for the UK, Eurozone and Brazil. • Second, more infectious strains of coronavirus have been identified in the UK, South Africa and Brazil. Alongside household mixing over the holidays, this is driving sharp increases in Covid-19 cases and deaths in several economies – and has necessitated tighter lockdowns in many more. In Europe, school and hospitality closures are economically damaging, and ASIRI now forecasts that the UK and most Eurozone economies will contract in both the fourth quarter of 2020 and the first quarter of 2021. In Japan, the state of emergency has spread beyond Tokyo to more prefectures. All this could make Japanese GDP growth negative in the first quarter. • Third, the vaccine rollout has begun. The early pace of rollout has fallen short of government promises in most economies. Take-up willingness is worryingly low in much of continental Europe; while emerging markets other than China, Russia and India are yet to secure meaningful quantities of vaccine. The US, UK and Israel are exceptions, where the initial rollout has been rapid, although still plagued by hurdles. We still expect vaccines to allow a meaningful easing in restrictions and a sharp economic rebound from the second quarter of 2021 onwards. But easing may have to be more cautious with more contagious variants of coronavirus in circulation. • Fourth, Democrat victories in the two Georgia run-off elections for the senate mean unified control of the US presidency and congress. While the razor-thin majority in the senate will constrain some of President Biden’s legislative agenda, the ASIRI US fiscal policy expectations have nonetheless shifted from a sharp contraction to additional stimulus. ASIRI is factoring in at least an extra $1 trillion Covid-19 relief package in the short term Global Real Estate Market Outlook For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. 03 “Better value is beginning to emerge in some sectors as prices correct, given the coronavirus-induced impact on rents and yields.” (on top of the $900 billion bill passed last year), and a $500 billion-1 trillion broader fiscal package over subsequent years. The effect of all this is to raise the level of US GDP by the end of 2022, some 3% relative to the ASIRI November forecasts. • Bringing all this together, the ASIRI 2021 global growth forecast of 5.1% is above-trend but below-consensus. The ASIRI forecasts reflect a larger near-term hit from renewed lockdowns, which the consensus is yet to properly incorporate. By contrast, the ASIRI 2022 global growth forecast of 4.8% is both above-trend and above-consensus, as re-opening continues to drive strong global economic activity. ASIRI continues to think that the Covid-19 crisis will inflict lasting damage to the level of global GDP relative to the pre-crisis trend path. That damage will be largest in Europe where the economy is heading into a double-dip recession, and smallest in China where the recovery has been rapid although it is now moderating. • Turning to inflation, both the short- and long-term implications of this crisis are likely to be net disinflationary. Admittedly, over the next few months, energy base effects – as well as idiosyncratic drivers, such as an expiring VAT cut in Germany and the suspension of travel subsidies in Japan – are going to push headline inflation much higher. But this will be temporary and short-lived. The global economy has enormous spare capacity that will take time to erode, inflation expectations are low and anchored, and central banks have plenty of room to contain inflation if needed. And while there has been much speculation about ‘policy regime change’ driving inflation higher, the timidity of central bank framework reviews and the reactivity of fiscal policy are not pointing in that direction. • Finally, there are very wide confidence intervals around the ASIRI central forecasts. Indeed, in this interim forecast round, ASIRI has lowered the probability weighting of its central case, and increased the chance of alternative scenarios, while keeping a small positive skew to the outlook. On the upside, there are scenarios in which vaccine rollout boosts activity by more than ASIRI anticipates and limits long-term economic scarring – especially if governments decide to re-open economies as soon as the most vulnerable share of the population has received inoculations. But on the downside, if the faster-spreading variants of the virus become embedded in the likes of the US, Brazil or India, double-dip recessions will not be confined to Europe. And in extremis, virus mutations could render the current crop of vaccines dramatically less effective, meaning endemic virus spread and rolling lockdowns until such time as new vaccines can be developed. Market prices versus long-term worth • Pricing remains in a state of flux and limited transactional evidence continues to hinder price discovery. Our subdued expectations for rental growth continue because of the severe impact of the drop-off in economic activity, particularly in consumer-facing sectors and the acceleration of detrimental structural factors in some sectors. Given the ongoing limited transactional evidence, estimating yields is currently problematic. However, the ability to assess the true level of yields continues to improve as deal activity picks up globally. We expect pricing to improve as the asset class corrects and the current high levels of pricing moderate. This has already started to happen in the Eurozone and Nordic regions where overpricing is reducing. • The sector pricing trends that have been in place for some time continue. As with last quarter, our pricing indicators suggest that global residential and industrial markets offer the greatest potential for better risk-adjusted returns at this point in the cycle. By contrast, some parts of the retail and office sectors look to be the most overpriced, particularly Hong Kong offices. • Long-term worth should improve further as prices continue to correct. Post-correction, it should be less challenging to find good-quality attractively priced assets in our favoured sectors. We maintain our overweight position in the North American real estate market. We also favour certain sectors and segments in the continental European markets from a global allocation perspective. Chart 1: Aberdeen Standard Investments’ global pricing indicator (Market price as a percentage of long-term worth) 60 50 40 30 20 10 0 -10 -20 Q4 10 Q4 11 Q4 12 Q4 13 Q4 14 Q4 15 Q4 16 Q4 17 Q4 18 Q4 19 Q4 20 Eurozone Japan UK USA Nordics Canada Global Source: Aberdeen Standard Investments, January 2021 Note: Market pricing is scaled against the long-term worth for each market at the same date. Long-term worth is a proprietary estimate for Aberdeen Standard Investments. It is defined as the discounted cash flows provided by that market and is based on long-term capital market assumptions, independent of currency or stock selection effects. Market behaviour explained by short-term indicators • Given behavioural factors, market prices can, and often do, deviate from fundamental value for indefinite periods. We aim to monitor market behaviour via our global performance indicators. These help us understand the drivers of prevailing market prices (see Table 1). 04 Global Real Estate Market Outlook For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. “Again this quarter, our proprietary performance signals have improved modestly. Although the recent re-imposition of lockdowns in some areas may temper the improvements, the signals are pointing to stronger returns ahead.” • Although global investment activity has picked up from low levels, the re-imposition of restrictions and travel bans will continue to hamper activity. Given the limited occupier activity as a result of travel restrictions, sentiment is most negative towards the hotel and lodging sector. Activity has also declined significantly in the retail and office sectors. Investment activity has been most resilient in the residential and industrial sectors. • Global listed real estate remains a good barometer for what may materialise in the direct markets. Encouragingly, the listed sector is in positive territory year to date and also over the past month. Some of the sectors that underperformed significantly last year have rebounded modestly including US retail and hotels. This isn’t the case for two of last year’s underperformers – European retail and London developers – which continue to underperform this year. From a global perspective, the listed real estate markets were most resilient in the Netherlands, Norway and France over the last quarter. The weakest markets were Belgium, Finland and Sweden. • The lending market remains constrained, with lenders retrenching and continuing to adopt a risk-averse approach to transactions. There is still lending available for the most resilient assets that have secure income streams. Lenders continue to seek a lower level of loan-to-value and higher margins for lending. The volume of loans also remains low, in line with lenders’ increased caution. Lending to the retail sector is very constrained. Defaults continue to remain at a low level to date. The non-bank lenders are likely to pick up further market share this year as they are more willing to lend than the banks at present. Real estate Macro Table 1: Aberdeen Standard Investments’ Global Performance Signals Performance signals UK Europe North America APAC Global Economic fundamentals Margin over bonds Monetary Policy Supply Flows of capital Lending Fund flows 360º view Sources: MSCI, PMA, RCA, CBRE, Refinitiv, Aberdeen Standard Investments, January 2021. Key Performance Signal: Supportive Neutral Unsupportive Trend: Upward trend Stable Downward trend Global overview • As economies have started to revive, so too have the real estate occupier and investment markets. But activity in both of these areas of the market remains subdued and the current increase in infections/restrictions has affected market activity once again. With relatively subdued activity, price discovery is taking some time. We continue to expect prices to fall further in the first half of 2021, which reflects the challenging occupier markets. The market continues to be polarised between sectors that were already benefiting from long-term structural drivers (industrials and residential) and those that were struggling because of structural headwinds (retail and offices). • Given the ongoing price dislocation, there may be opportunities for investors with capital to re-enter the market further on into the cycle at a more attractive price point. Our long-term worth analysis suggests that pricing remains stretched, although this is changing as prices correct and yields increase. • The significant monetary and fiscal support that has been extended to economies remains a key positive for real estate markets, ensuring we avoid a financial crisis. It also helps to keep occupiers in business and limits unemployment, which should help moderate the expected increase in vacancy rates. A proportion of the income real estate generates at present is vulnerable to insolvencies and occupier distress. For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. Global Real Estate Market Outlook “Given the heightened uncertainty at present, we continue to maintain a risk-averse approach to investing. With stronger returns expected in the second half of the year, there should be more appetite to take on modest levels of risk.” Nevertheless, we anticipate that income will remain favourable on a longer-term basis when compared with the yield from government bonds. These are likely to be close to zero or at low levels for a significant period. Presently, the margin between the asset class and the risk-free rate has moved to elevated levels. Undoubtedly, a higher risk premium is appropriate for consumer-facing sectors that were already struggling with longer-term secular trends. However, the increase in risk premium for sectors that will benefit from long-term structural drivers is likely to be relatively small. We expect the income from these sectors to compare favourably with the low yields on offer from other asset classes. • We therefore favour the industrial sector, which is benefiting from changes in technology and the way we are shopping. We also like the private rented sector because of the increased propensity to rent and the unaffordability of housing markets generally. We favour the alternatives sectors that are benefiting from population ageing, namely the senior living and healthcare sectors. We also prefer prime sustainable well-located office buildings. We continue to remain risk averse and a forensic approach to underwriting is key at present given the heightened market risk. 05 06 Global Real Estate Market Outlook For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. Regional outlooks North America • Recent democratic wins in the state of Georgia have shifted the balance of power in the senate along with the US policy and economic outlook. This increases the likelihood of additional fiscal stimulus and other government spending measures. Another relief package is expected to be passed by Congress in the immediate future. This will include state and local government funding, along with another round of stimulus checks. Aberdeen Standard Investments Research Institute (ASIRI) estimates the value of a bipartisan deal will total approximately $1 trillion. Broader proposed spending and tax measures include a green infrastructure plan, expansion of the Affordable Care Act and funding for social programs, amounting to $1 trillion. Increased fiscal policy spending would significantly boost the economic recovery and has resulted in a large upward revision to the economic growth forecast for 2021. These measures will support stronger inflation, but a return to target will most likely be a slow process with the Federal Reserve (Fed) maintaining its stance. ASIRI has factored in a gradual tapering of its asset purchases next year, with a rate hike not expected until the end of 2023. • Vacancies rose across property sectors in 2020. The sharpest rise was in offices as leasing activity has plummeted. Rental losses have been modest thus far, but they are expected to accelerate as more leases expire. Gateway markets are likely to experience the greatest near-term weakness as their rents have been more volatile during recessionary periods. The net operating income (NOI) for apartments declined significantly in 2020, driven by a deterioration in fundamentals among urban core properties. The central business district (CBD) net absorption in gateway markets turned negative for the first time in the available 20-year history from the CoStar Group. However, suburban submarket demand continued to expand, supporting effective rental growth. Malls have continued to underperform, while grocery-anchored centres remained resilient in 2020. Simon Property Group, the largest shopping mall operator in the US, reported a 24% annual decline in NOI among comparable properties in the third quarter. At the same time, vacancies for grocery-anchored centres were stable. After slowing in the second quarter of the year, leasing activity for industrials has returned to pre-pandemic levels. Leasing activity in the fourth quarter of 2020 was 10% higher than the historical average, as per CoStar data. Demand growth remained strongest for bulk industrial assets. • Transaction activity slowed significantly in 2020 but recovered from pandemic lows at the end of the year, according to Real Capital Analytics (RCA). Total sales volumes were down by 30% for the year, with the steepest declines in hotels, retail and offices. However, sales volumes rebounded to $145 billion in the final quarter, driven by gains in apartments and industrials – nearly triple the $50 billion mid-year low. Office sales volumes rose substantially from recent lows. But sales volumes remained weaker for the CBD compared with offices in the suburbs. The average suburban office cap rate compressed modestly, while it rose slightly for CBD offices. The suburban-to-CBD cap rate spread fell just below its historical average (since 2002) of 100 basis points. • The industrial sector is expected to remain a clear near-term outperformer. It is the most resilient major sector with the strongest demand for larger assets. Investors will continue to increase exposure to the segment, which will support pricing gains. Residential sectors offer a favourable return outlook, but there are major areas of weakness. Apartment fundamentals remain stable for suburban assets, but urban core property performance has deteriorated. It is likely to experience continued losses early this year. However, an improving labour market, vaccine rollout and slowing supply growth should support an urban recovery by the end of 2021. Retail performance will suffer most, with record-level store closures leading to continued NOI and value losses over the next year. Retail returns for centres focused on essential goods will lead, while malls will lag. Office sector fundamentals will continue to weaken, particularly for primary CBD assets. NOI losses and reduced investor appetite for the sector will weigh on capital values. Increased adoption of flexible work arrangements is a major long-term risk for the sector. UK • After November’s lockdown and the rapid tightening of restrictions in mid-December, we expect the UK economy to have contracted by 2-3% in the final quarter of 2020. A renewed lockdown to combat the highly transmissible new variant of Covid-19 is set to cause a further contraction in GDP in the first quarter of 2021. • Unfortunately, the rapid escalation of cases and hospitalisations since mid-December has necessitated another national lockdown akin to that of last spring, including school closures. Measures to combat the new variant – and evidence that other strains, such as that first detected in South Africa, may be even more infectious – are set to cause a further contraction in GDP in the first quarter of 2021. With vaccines now being rolled out, it is a case of ‘the darkest hour just before the dawn’ and we continue to expect a strong rebound in the second half of the year as the vaccines start to deliver herd immunity. • In mid-December, the furlough scheme was extended to the end of April, which gives greater time for business planning and decision-making around redundancies following the March budget. But it also means all the main business support measures are in place until at least the end of March, which should shield much of the economy from the effects of the renewed lockdown. • Brexit negotiations went right to the wire but a chaotic no deal was averted. As we have previously flagged, the ASIRI believes the very narrow deal agreed will be a drag on UK economic growth over the longer term. Trading for the consumer-facing retail, leisure and hospitality sectors remains challenging in the face of Covid-19 restrictions. The retail sector experienced a further blow in the final quarter of the year with both Debenhams and the Arcadia group entering into administration. More than 550 Debenhams and Arcadia fascia stores are set to close, removing the key anchor retailers from many towns. • The Covid-19 impact on UK retail has not been homogenous across retail sub-sectors as illustrated by the resilience of supermarket trading. Kantar data showed that all UK supermarket groups benefited from unprecedented Christmas demand in 2020. Take home grocery sales rose 11.4% Global Real Estate Market Outlook For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. year-on-year over the 12 weeks to 27 December, despite higher online penetration than the previous year. • With a sizeable increase in demand, 2020 broke all previous records for the UK logistics sector, with occupiers signing up to 50.1 million square feet (sq. ft.) of new space. The sector has been a key beneficiary of shuttered shops and the marked acceleration in online retailing. Although Amazon was by far the largest single occupier, accounting for a quarter of all leased space during 2020, take-up would have still broken new records even if Amazon was removed from the numbers. • Both the hierarchy and quantum of our new forecasts remain largely unchanged. We are forecasting further capital declines across discretionary retail in 2021, with greater declines in rental values. The renewed lockdown, which is likely to last for most of the first quarter, will put further pressure on retailers, leisure operators and hospitality providers. This reinforces the current problem. • Conversely, industrials are set to be the best performing sector in 2021 for a fifth successive year on the back of continued strong sentiment towards the positive structural drivers of the occupier market. In our view, those drivers are strongest for logistics units in urban areas. • In offices, the occupational fundamentals have weakened further; availability has increased, notably, without any meaningful impact on rents thus far. We do not believe that situation is sustainable and we are forecasting rental declines in central London this year, with more modest declines in the main regional markets. We expect quality buildings in strong locations to hold up better through this adjustment period. • At close to £12.8 billion, the fourth quarter of 2020 saw a noticeable pick-up in investment volumes when compared with the previous two quarters. Despite the occupational uncertainties, offices accounted for over 35% of total investment. Positive industrial sentiment resulted in the sector accounting for over 30% of total investment volumes in the final quarter of the year. • Despite a noticeable pick-up in investment volumes in the final quarter, 2020 marked the weakest year since 2012. • With a no-deal Brexit averted, a renewed sense of optimism in 2021 is likely to be tempered, at least initially, by the latest national lockdown. Investors will assess the potential damage to occupier markets. With liquidity likely to be impaired in the first quarter, 2021 looks set to be a year of two halves for the investment market. Provided vaccinations can be rolled out at sufficient scale in the first half of the year to materially suppress the virus, we expect to see a recovery in activity in the second half of 2021. • Multiple lockdowns have reinforced existing structural changes and introduced new ones. While the investment market is rightly demanding ever higher risk premia for most discretionary retail, there are parts of the market where investors appear disinclined to price in any material structural change. The greatest opportunities may be found where there is greater liquidity and structural change. Investment strategies will continue to favour sectors with more defensive characteristics. Fundamentally, we prefer investing in areas where the structural drivers of demand are positively affected by or largely insulated from the ongoing pandemic, including logistics and supermarkets. 07 Continental Europe Economic outlook • The Eurozone growth profile is now an upwardly sloping “W shape”. The initial contraction and subsequent rebound has been very sharp, but the Eurozone will have been through a renewed contraction in the fourth quarter of 2020 and into the first quarter of 2021. Moreover, lockdown stringency is unlikely to be meaningfully lifted until we approach the second quarter of 2021, which means we are forecasting no growth in the first quarter. The risk of a full-blown double-dip recession (consecutive quarterly contractions in both the fourth quarter and the first quarter) is very likely. • The eventual vaccine-driven recovery should be strong and drive a “year of two halves” in 2021. But we incorporate long-term damage to the level of GDP that will be about two years’ worth of economic growth. • This upward sloping ‘W-shaped’ profile, as well as low inflation expectations, mean that even after the current deflationary period ends in early-2021, inflation will remain well below the European Central Bank’s (ECB) target. This, in turn, means that we expect additional monetary policy stimulus, starting with the €500 billion of asset purchases and subsidised bank loans in December 2020. This probably won’t be the last easing move in this cycle, and we have pencilled in further quantitative easing in 2022. • Fiscal policy, which has been highly expansionary so far in this crisis, is now set to be a small drag. But this is on nothing like the scale of the post-financial crisis retrenchment that set the scene for the Eurozone sovereign debt crisis. In any case, the EU Recovery Fund should now replace at least some of the waning domestic fiscal stimulus. Occupier market trends • Contracted rent falling into arrears has crept up, but generally remained surprisingly low, as have overall vacancy rates. This owes much to the substantial stimulus packages put in place and the ability of companies to adapt to operate remotely or with increased online sales. In addition, landlords have extended rent holidays and have generally been supportive of tenants disrupted by the pandemic. We believe that conditions will get harder before they get better through 2021, in what will be a year of two halves. • Office markets are starting to soften after a period of surprising resilience. Vacancy rates edged up in the latter stages of 2020, a trend that reflects the reticence of companies to sign new lease agreements in preference of placing space requirements on ice. These trends in softer demand and new supply pushed the average vacancy rate up across Europe from 6.4% in the fourth quarter of 2019 to 7.1% a year later. Despite a 40% quarterly rebound in office take-up in the fourth quarter of 2020, the volume reflected a 35% annual decline and the weakest quarter since 2002. Overall, weaker office occupancy trends are forcing landlords into reducing asking rents from peak levels, and the market is slowly edging more in the tenants’ favour on negotiations. • Retailers have largely struggled under current conditions and many have needed rent deferrals to avoid cash shortages. Retail failures have increased, with the latest data to the second quarter of 2020 showing 21 retailers in Europe with net revenues over €50 million entered insolvency proceedings. We believe that most in-store retail formats, aside from supermarkets, will struggle over the short, medium and long term. 08 Global Real Estate Market Outlook • Of the commercial sectors, the logistics market is a clear outlier. Shocks like the current pandemic have challenged and put pressure on all layers of supply chains. However, the strong demand drivers established prior to the pandemic have been accelerated through enforced changes to the way people source goods. Ecommerce has grown sharply, with estimates putting 2020 retail sales via online platforms at 15-25% of total retail sales, depending on the country in Europe. According to the latest data available to the third quarter of 2020, total European logistics take-up reached 21.8 million square metres in the first three quarters of the year, representing a 10% uplift on the same period of 2019. Investment market trends • The vast majority of material valuation uncertainty clauses (MVUCs) have been removed in Europe. With the exception of discretionary spending retail assets, hotels and leisure properties, values have largely rebounded from their second-quarter of 2020 dip, following their knee-jerk downward adjustment at the onset of the pandemic. Valuation methodology has reverted to normal, even despite the second round of lockdowns. • European transaction volumes experienced an acceleration in the fourth quarter of 2020, rising 35% quarter on quarter (q-q) to reach €63.3 billion. However, volumes in the fourth quarter were just half the level of the fourth quarter of 2019, and the annual total slid to 3% below the previous year. However, in light of the strict lockdowns and the barriers to movement, it is remarkable that liquidity held up so well. • In particular, we have seen an increasing share of capital flow into residential and logistics assets. Residential and senior living accounted for 25% of total investment at €66 billion in 2020, an increase from 21% of the share in 2019. Logistics accounted for 14% of the total volume, a share that would have been higher had there been more stock on the market. This volume matched retail investment, also at 14%. In the context of the negative sentiment towards offices, as a result of the largely successful enforced remote working, it is surprising that investment in offices held up well. Offices still accounted for the largest share of investment by sector, representing 37% of the total, down from 42% in 2019. Within the office sector, investors have adopted an increasingly lower-risk approach – focusing mainly on large, efficient and well-located buildings in the major cities with close proximity to public transportation. • Geographically, the lockdowns have had a specific impact on the ability of some markets to close deals at the same rate as before the pandemic. However, it has been particularly evident that institutional investors have targeted core European markets like Germany and France – with the idea that liquidity is stronger and that the economic recovery is more sustainable. • These investment market pressures have influenced pricing trends. According to data from CBRE, Eurozone residential and industrial real estate yields compressed over the fourth quarter of 2020 to reach new lows. The inward yield shift in the logistics market was most noticeable with a sharp step down of roughly 15 basis points (bp), driven by the weight of capital in the market. For retail assets, we have seen a (continued) repricing of assets across Europe where yields have moved out further during lockdowns. They rose by five bp in the fourth quarter of 2020 for all retail and by 17 bp in secondary shopping centres. • Overall, capital values have recovered sharply in the best assets and sectors. It’s particularly evident where tenant revenues are more resilient or where the demand drivers are structurally higher. Assets and sectors are more at risk where bank finance conditions For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. are tightening sharply. This implies more pain for hotels, retail and leisure. Overall, we are less negative on capital values over the next 12 months than in the previous quarter, as the fundamentals have remained more resilient than expected. • Bank lending remains selective and polarised between good and bad assets and sectors. Good-quality assets are less affected, but lenders have started to price risk assets more cautiously. However, with swap rates remaining negative, the all-in cost of debt has not risen dramatically at this point. Furthermore, listed property companies that are focused on retail have issued substantial bonds at coupons below 1%. Loan-to-value (LTV) ratios are stable overall, although investors are generally looking to trim loan portfolios and reduce risk. Performance outlook and risk tolerance • It should be noted that any forecast assumptions in the current environment remain uncertain. Our current base case suggests All Property returns of 3.7% per annum (pa) over the first three years and 4.7% pa over five years. Our view is that falling capital values are front-loaded through 2021, before recovering from year three onwards and contributing positively to total returns. • Sector spreads between forecast returns remain large. The biggest decline in values next year (fourth quarter of 2020 to the fourth quarter of 2021) is expected for hotels followed closely by the retail sector. Residential and logistics assets are expected to demonstrate far stronger fundamentals under the current base case with values continuing to rise unabated. Offices have so far shown resilience. But there is an increasing disparity between the strength of high-quality and sustainable buildings (with solid tenants on long contracts and in strong locations) clearly offering better prospects than secondary offices. • In the short-to-medium term, we are more concerned about markets that experienced more pain in the global financial crisis and Eurozone crisis as a result of stress in the debt markets and sharp falls in liquidity. This would include Spain, Italy, Portugal and Ireland, while Central and Eastern European markets also look more vulnerable in a risk-off market environment. • We continue to suggest a risk-averse approach in most aspects of our investments, while market uncertainty is high. This means reducing financial leverage, development exposure and focusing on longer and more robust cash flows. However, the polarisation of the real estate market does mean that there are pockets where we have conviction that value-add strategies will pay off, mainly in logistics and residential assets. Asia-Pacific (APAC) • The global economic outlook is dominated by two conflicting forces: an intense second wave of Covid-19 in Europe and North America that is already weighing on recoveries; and recent news that highly effective vaccines are on the way, which raise the likelihood of an eventual return to ‘normal’ life. The outlook has become much more mixed, though. While new Covid-19 cases have been contained at low levels in China and East Asia, and are moving lower in other emerging markets, the US and Europe are in renewed outbreaks that appear to be as large as the first wave. We also think investors should temper some of the recent vaccine optimism. Realistically, the manufacturing and distribution timelines are not going to contain the current wave of infection. The mass vaccination of the entire global population will be a multi-year and sustained effort. • We continue to think that both the short- and long-term global implications of this crisis are likely to be net disinflationary. For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. The scale of this disinflation is likely being exaggerated by the inability of price indices to keep up with changes in the composition of spending at the moment. That being said, the global economy has enormous spare capacity, which will take a long time to erode and thus put sustained downward pressure on wage growth and firms’ pricing power. • The average decline in net effective rents (NER) has accelerated across the major office markets in APAC as vacancy continues to climb. NER fell by an average 8.8% year-on-year (y-y) in the third quarter of 2020 (from -6.9% y-y in the second quarter) while the average vacancy rose to 11.2% (from 10.1%) during the same period, according to Jones Lang LaSalle’s (JLL) estimates. Hong Kong remains the worst performing office market in APAC, with the average NER now 21.7% off its second quarter of 2019 peak and average vacancy is now at its highest since the fourth quarter of 2004. There has also been a marked deterioration in the Australian prime office market – average NER fell by 7.7% y-y in the third quarter of 2020 (from +0.5% y-y in the second quarter). Within the APAC context, we believe Australian central business district (CBD) offices could be more vulnerable to suburbanisation and remote working trends. On the other hand, the prime office market in Seoul has outperformed year to date (YTD), with the average gain in NER accelerating to 4.5%y-y in the third quarter of 2020 (from +3.8% y-y in the second quarter). This is in spite of an increase in vacancy to 14.3% (from 9.1%) during the quarter, on account of the completion of Parc1 in Yeouido. Technology companies appear to be one of the few remaining bright spots in terms of office leasing demand. In Singapore’s CBD, Amazon has taken up more than 90,000 square feet (sq ft) at Asia Square Tower 1 and ByteDance has signed a lease for 60,000 sq ft at One Raffles Quay. We forecast office rents in APAC to fall by an average 0.6% per annum (pa) over the next three years. We think the bulk of the potential near-term downside in rents may already have been front-loaded given the faster-than-expected decline year to date and that the worst of the economic fallout is likely behind us. • Similar to the office market in APAC, the average decline in prime retail rents accelerated to -12.9% y-y in the third quarter of 2020 (from -8.9% y-y in the second quarter), while vacancy rose to 5.7% (from 5.5%) during the quarter. Hong Kong prime retail remains the worst performing occupier market (-32.9% y-y in the third quarter of 2020, from -25.8% y-y the previous quarter). Regional centres in Perth fared relatively better during the last quarter (-1.6% y-y, from -2.2% y-y), with the pandemic largely under control in Western Australia. The pandemic has weighed heavily on retailers and the concern is that the number of retailers entering administration could increase once government support ceases. Also, the crisis has accelerated the adoption of online shopping. A case in point being Australia where online retail penetration is estimated to have risen to 13.3% (from around 11% in 2019) – a number originally not expected to be reached until 2024. Notwithstanding the positive developments on the vaccine front and the potential for retail spend to recover further as economies reopen, we maintain our bearish stance on prime retail real estate. This is because of structural challenges, such as the loss of market share to online shopping, thinning retailers’ margins and already high occupancy costs. Indeed, we forecast prime retail rents in APAC to fall by 3.2% pa over the next three years. • The pandemic has accelerated the adoption of ecommerce. Potential changes to supply chain management (including the maintenance of higher levels of inventory) are also expected to increase the demand for logistics space over the longer term. But the pandemic has had a negative impact on rents, even Global Real Estate Market Outlook 09 though the sector still outperforms. The average rent for logistics space in APAC fell by 0.6% y-y in the third quarter of 2020 (from -0.2% y-y in the second quarter), even as vacancy tightened to an average 2.7% (from 2.9%) during the quarter. Logistics properties in China’s tier one cities remain the best performers in APAC, registering a gain of 3.8% y-y in rents during the third quarter of 2020 (from +5.8% y-y in the second quarter). The economic recovery in China has been stronger than expected and this has released pent-up leasing demand from express delivery firms and ecommerce platforms, as well as traditional retailers and wholesalers. In Australia, the average rental growth in logistics space slowed to 1.2% y-y in the third quarter of 2020 (from 1.7% y-y), principally on account of the lockdown in Victoria. But land-constrained urban locations continue to outperform. We reiterate our bullish view on the sector and forecast an average rental growth of 0.7% pa over the next three years. • The latest data from Real Capital Analytics (RCA) suggests the total transaction value of investment properties in APAC (excluding development sites) fell by 29.2% y-y to USD92.2 billion during the first nine months of this year. South Korea was the best performing investment market in APAC year to date, with a total transaction value of USD15.9 billion in the first nine months of 2020 (+1.9% y-y). Notwithstanding the pandemic, 2020 is shaping up to be a record-breaking year for the Seoul office market in terms of price per pyeong (3.3 square metres (sqm)) achieved, as domestic capital turned its focus back to its home market during the year. On the other hand, transaction values amounted to just USD2.7 billion (-72.5% y-y) in Singapore during the first nine months of 2020, making it the worst-performing investment market in APAC (though the high watermark achieved in 2019 was an important factor). By sectors, investment activity for industrials jumped to 21.4% during the first nine months of 2020 (versus the average 11.1% over the previous 10 years), while investment activity for apartments increased to 8% during the same period (from an average 6% over the previous 10 years). Unsurprisingly, activity in the retail sector shrunk to 15.4% in the first nine months of 2020 (from 24.3%, on average, during the previous 10 years). • The rebound in stock performance of APAC’s listed real estate investment trusts (REITs) from its trough in late-March continues. REITs are trading at an average 22% premium to book value as at end-December (from 15% three months before). Unsurprisingly, managers of listed REITs have capitalised on the buoyant demand for listed real estate equity to raise new funds from investors. As of end-December, the total amount of new equity raised by REITs listed in Japan, Australia and Singapore during the fourth quarter of 2020 was USD5.04 billion. This is 5.7% more than the equity raised a year ago in the fourth quarter of 2019, which in turn was twice the USD2.4 billion raised in the fourth quarter of 2018. The most active market in the fourth quarter of 2020 was Japan where J-REITs raised a total of USD2.4 billion in new equity (versus 1.3 billion a year ago). This includes the JPY127 billion (USD1.2 billion) raised by Nippon Building Fund in October to partially fund the purchase of two office properties in Tokyo’s CBD from its sponsor Mitsui Fudosan. This represents the largest equity raise by a J-REIT to date. The deal values the Shinjuku Mitsui Building at JPY170 billion (USD1.6 billion; implied net operating income (NOI) yield 4.2%) and the five floors at Gran Tokyo South Tower in Marunouchi at JPY47 billion (USD445 million; implied NOI yield 3%). The vendor had bought the space at Gran Tokyo South Tower for JPY35 billion (NOI yield 3.4%) in the first quarter of 2013, which implies an appreciation of 34% in capital value over the past seven years. 10 Global Real Estate Market Outlook • The Asian Association for Investors in Non-Listed Real Estate Vehicles (ANREV) published its quarterly index on 18 December and the all-funds index returned +1.7% in the third quarter of 2020. This represents a reversal from the 2.3% loss registered in the previous quarter and the first positive return since the fourth quarter of 2019. Positive total returns from both core strategies (+1%, from -3.1%) and value-added strategies (+5.6%, from -0.3%) helped to lift the overall APAC performance during the quarter. Value-added strategies, in particular, appear to have been helped by robust performance reported by Chinese funds in the third quarter of 2020 (+5.7%, from +1%). Core strategies benefited from the first positive capital growth in three quarters (+0.3%, from -3.7%) as well as an improved income return in the third quarter of 2020 (+0.8%, from +0.6%). • We expect total returns for non-listed real estate in APAC to remain under pressure in the near term. We forecast an average total return of 1.8% pa for the region over the next three years and we expect greater divergence in performance among the sectors. We continue to expect outperformance in industrial properties (6.5% pa) and rental apartments in Tokyo (6.8% pa) to be offset by underperformance in the prime retail (-1.8% pa) and office (2.2% pa) markets. On a risk-adjusted basis, we believe the real estate markets of South Korea and Japan remain relatively attractive within the APAC context (total returns over the next three years of 6.4% pa and 4.5% pa, respectively, on our estimates). Specifically in the Seoul office market – notwithstanding its outperformance in 2020 and near-term vacancy risk – we expect investment demand to remain robust especially in the CBD and Gangnam. The above-average yield gap relative to rental outlook should remain attractive to investors within the APAC context, in our view. • In the near term, the balance of risks is skewed to the downside in our view, as second waves of the pandemic threaten to overwhelm healthcare systems and shut down economies. Fiscal policy mistakes are also looming. However, from around mid-2021 onwards, we think the risk is actually of more positive outcomes than we are forecasting, particularly because global vaccine coverage and its effects on activity could be greater than we have factored in. This would mean a faster 2021-onwards recovery and less long-term damage to the level of global GDP, relative to the pre-pandemic path. In fact, we attach only a slightly lower probability to this upside scenario than we do to our baseline scenario. • Since bond yields are likely to remain lower for longer, the macroeconomic risk is skewed to the upside from mid-2021. Given the weight of capital that is still chasing yields, we think investors who are still holding out for materially higher yields in the short term may be disappointed. This is particularly the case for core assets and in sectors that are deemed to have benefited from the pandemic, such as industrial properties and data centres. Unless investors are willing to settle for a lower target return (even though the proposition might be the same or even better if we adjust for risk and opportunity cost), it appears investors have little choice but to move up the risk curve to generate the required returns. • For investors looking for higher returns in sectors that are deemed to have benefited from the crisis – such as industrial and logistics properties – a higher risk strategy, such as converting the use or a build-to-suit (BTS) development might make sense. Industrial properties close to population centres currently owned and occupied by small manufacturers could be converted into last-mile delivery facilities. This is particularly the case if the rollback of government support were to prompt the smaller enterprises to raise cash via the real estate market. For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. Also, BTS development projects further from urban locations could leverage on cheaper land costs and demand from companies that are planning to hold more inventory in the longer term. • For investors looking to capitalise on potential bargains in sectors that are deemed to be challenged by the crisis, such as prime retail and hotels, converting the use would also make sense. This is assuming the entry price has adequately discounted the potential costs and risks involved. That is far from certain, though, especially if the pace at which economies reopen were to surprise on the upside from mid-2021. A case in point is the sale of the Sheraton Palace Gangnam Hotel in Seoul during the fourth quarter of 2020. A developer has bought the site for KRW350 billion and the plan is reportedly to redevelop it into either a new commercial building or a residential project on account of the prime location. Compared with the expected sale price of around KRW400 billion when the hotel was first put up for sale in the third quarter of 2020, the transaction price represents a discount of just 12.5%. This is hardly ‘distressed’, in our view. Summary Renewed lockdowns and the more virulent strains of the coronavirus have led to reduced activity once again in the commercial real estate sectors that rely on consumer facing interaction – hotels, retail and leisure. Despite this, our view is that the year ahead will be made up of two halves with improvement materialising in the second half of the year as mass vaccinations ensue and restrictions are lifted and the occupier and investment markets start to get back to their normal functioning. Although we have not seen much in the way of distressed selling this could pick-up as the year progresses and banks start to work through non-performing assets. We continue to expect the capital value declines that are already in train to continue as the year progresses. As these declines fall-out of our three year projections for total returns, stronger returns are anticipated as we move into the second half of the year. As a result of Covid-19, we continue to expect an acceleration of the longer-term structural trends that were already underway in certain sectors. For example, more on-line activity is benefiting the industrial sector to the detriment of the retail sector. In the office sector, we are very selective in terms of asset attributes. The increase in home working will lead to less demand in the sector and more occupier desire for value-add attributes, such as flexible workspace solutions. Asset-specific qualities, such as good connectivity, a core location and positive ESG (environmental, social and governance) factors are also important. Already we are seeing the office fundamentals deteriorate globally and investors are increasingly more selective when it comes to the attributes associated with offices. They favour large, efficient and well-located buildings, with close proximity to public transport nodes. We remain very cautious towards poorly located older assets that are most vulnerable to the changing dynamics in the sector. We expect there to be more opportunities to source attractively priced assets that can be repositioned or repurposed later on in 2021. Given the expected further price declines, we continue to adopt a conservative approach to risk in positioning and continue to focus on resilient income in our favoured sectors. Simon Kinnie Head of Real Estate Forecasting The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up and your investor may get back less than the amount invested. Real estate is a relatively illiquid asset class, the valuation of which is a matter of opinion. There is no recognised market for real estate and there can be delays in realising the value of real estate assets. Important information For professional investors only, in Switzerland for qualified investors only – not for use by retail investors or advisers. Contact Us To find out more, please speak to your usual contact or visit our website aberdeenstandard.com. Other important information This document is strictly for information purposes and should not be considered as an offer, investment recommendation or solicitation to deal in any of the investments mentioned herein. This document does not constitute investment research. The issuing entities listed below (together ‘Aberdeen Standard Investments’) do not warrant the accuracy, adequacy or completeness of the information and materials contained in this document and expressly disclaims liability for errors or omissions in such information and materials. Any research or analysis used in the preparation of this document has been procured by Aberdeen Standard Investments for its own use and may have been acted on for its own purpose The results thus obtained are made available only coincidentally and the information is not guaranteed as to its accuracy. Some of the information in this document may contain projections or other forward looking statements regarding future events or future financial performance of countries, markets or companies. These statements are only predictions and actual events or results may differ materially. Readers must make their own assessment of the relevance, accuracy and adequacy of the information contained in this document and such independent investigations as they consider necessary or appropriate for the purpose of such assessment. Any opinion or estimate contained in this document is made on a general basis and is not to be relied on by the reader as advice. Neither Aberdeen Standard Investments nor any of its employees, associated group companies or agents have given any consideration to, or made any investigation of, the investment objectives, financial situation or particular need of the reader, any specific person or group of persons. Accordingly, no warranty is given and no liability is accepted for any loss arising, whether directly or indirectly, as a result of the reader or any person or group of persons acting on any information, opinion or estimate contained in this document. Aberdeen Standard Investments reserves the right to make changes and corrections to any information in this document at any time, without notice. Tax treatment depends on the individual circumstances of each investor and may be subject to change in the future. Professional advice should be obtained before making any investment decision. This content is available in the following countries/regions and issued by the respective entities detailed below: (entities as at 25 May 2020) Europe, Middle East and Africa United Kingdom (UK): Aberdeen Asset Managers Limited, registered in Scotland (SC108419) at 10 Queen’s Terrace, Aberdeen, AB10 1XL. Standard Life Investments Limited registered in Scotland (SC123321) at 1 George Street, Edinburgh EH2 2LL. Both companies are authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority. Austria, Belgium, Cyprus, Denmark, Finland, France, Germany, Gibraltar, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Italy, Luxembourg, Netherlands, Norway, Portugal and Sweden: Aberdeen Asset Managers Limited, registered in Scotland (SC108419) at 10 Queen’s Terrace, Aberdeen, AB10 1XL. Standard Life Investments Limited registered in Scotland (SC123321) at 1 George Street, Edinburgh EH2 2LL. Both companies are authorised and regulated in the UK by the Financial Conduct Authority. Switzerland: Aberdeen Standard Investments (Switzerland) AG. Registered in Switzerland (CHE-114.943.983) at Schweizergasse 14, 8001 Zürich. Abu Dhabi Global Market (“ADGM”): Aberdeen Asset Middle East Limited, 6th floor, Al Khatem Tower, Abu Dhabi Global Market Square, Al Maryah Island, P.O. Box 764605, Abu Dhabi, United Arab Emirates. Regulated by the ADGM Financial Services Regulatory Authority. For Professional Clients and Market Counterparties only. South Africa: Aberdeen Asset Managers Limited (“AAML”). Registered in Scotland (SC108419) at 10 Queen’s Terrace, Aberdeen, AB10 1XL. AAML holds a Category I financial services provider (FSP) licence in terms of the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act, 2002, (FAIS) under licence 43675. Asia-Pacific Australia and New Zealand: Aberdeen Standard Investments Australia Limited ABN 59 002 123 364, AFSL No. 240263. In New Zealand to wholesale investors only as defined in the Financial Markets Conduct Act 2013 (New Zealand). Hong Kong: Aberdeen Standard Investments (Hong Kong) Limited. This document has not been reviewed by the Securities and Futures Commission. Indonesia: PT Aberdeen Standard Investments Indonesia, an investment manager license holder registered and supervised by the Indonesia Financial Services Authority (OJK). Japan: Aberdeen Standard Investments (Japan) Limited. Malaysia: Aberdeen Standard Investments (Malaysia) Sdn Bhd, Company Number: 200501013266 (690313-D). This document has not been reviewed by the Securities Commission of Malaysia. The People’s Republic of China (“PRC”): Aberdeen Standard Asset Management (Shanghai) Co., Ltd in the PRC only. Taiwan: Aberdeen Standard Investments Taiwan Limited, which is operated independently, 8F, No.101, Songren Rd., Taipei City, Taiwan Tel: +886 2 87224500. Thailand: Aberdeen Standard Asset Management (Thailand) Limited. Singapore: Aberdeen Standard Investments (Asia) Limited, Registration Number 199105448E. Americas Brazil: Aberdeen Standard Investments is the marketing name in Brazil for Aberdeen do Brasil Gestão de Recursos Ltda. Aberdeen do Brasil Gestão de Recursos Ltda. is an entity duly registered with the Comissão de Valores Mobiliários (CVM) as an investment manager. Canada: Aberdeen Standard Investments (“ASI”) is the marketing name in Canada for Aberdeen Standard Investments (Canada) Limited, Aberdeen Standard Investments Luxembourg S.A., Standard Life Investments Private Capital Ltd, SL Capital Partners LLP, Standard Life Investments Limited, Standard Life Investments (Corporate Funds) Limited, and Aberdeen Capital Management LLC. Aberdeen Standard Investments (Canada) Limited, is registered as a Portfolio Manager and Exempt Market Dealer in all provinces and territories of Canada as well as an Investment Fund Manager in the provinces of Ontario, Quebec, and Newfoundland and Labrador. United States: Aberdeen Standard Investments is the marketing name for the following affiliated, registered investment advisers: Aberdeen Standard Investments Inc., Aberdeen Asset Managers Ltd., Aberdeen Standard Investments Australia Ltd., Aberdeen Standard Investments (Asia) Ltd., Aberdeen Capital Management LLC, Aberdeen Standard Investments ETFs Advisors LLC and Standard Life Investments (Corporate Funds) Ltd. Visit us online aberdeenstandard.com 121044136 02/21 | DH: GB-040221-141928-9