An analysis of the Leadership Style of Ricardo Semler In the context of Semco Industries : Transformation of an Organization from Autocratic to Democratic structure P R E S E N T E D B Y N I L A B J A S A H A , 1 ST Y E A R MBA STUDENT OF IIEST SHIBPUR SCHOOL OF MANAGEMENT SCIENCES (2020-2022) ROLL NUMBER : 2020MSM022 PRESENTED TO : DR. SHANUJAS V. A Close Portrait of Ricardo Semler , The Brazilian Boss , Entrepreneur , One who runs his organization in self – serving mode !!! A Brief History on Ricardo’s Life and Rise Antonio Curt Semler , Ricardo Semler’s father , an Australian engineer , left Austria after his studies just before World War II to make a new life in South America. He took advantage of Brazil’s first ‘economic miracle’ in the 1950s and 60s to build his company, a major supplier of marine pumps for the shipping industry. But he wanted to do more. He wanted to build a family business, a lasting legacy. His young son Ricardo was not, however, a natural successor. Semco was founded in the 1952 by Antonio Curt Semler. A Brief History… (Continued …) Ricardo did not do well in school but he started to show some entrepreneurial flair in high school by taking the responsibility of running the school’s snack shop . After studying law in Brazil’s prestigious law school , Ricardo tried to put his feet on his father’s shoes . After the brazilian miracle in 1960-70s (Steep rise in Brazil’s economy) , which ended in late 70’s and have put a deep economical impact in Brazil’s Economy specially the shipbuilding industry , Ricardo took over Semco Industries from his father and proposed that diversification is the only solution at that time , although he had a strong dissent with his father on the future line of actions of Semco Industries . A Brief History… (Continued …) Ricardo’s father , after realizing that Ricardo and he can not co-exist in the same organization , simply handed over the entire operation to Ricardo . One Friday afternoon in 1980 , Ricardo cleaned house , fired 60% of his father’s top executives. He hired his own people and began modernizing the company, making it more efficient and productive. For example : Semco , persuaded salespeople to fill out customer-visit reports and keep statistics on orders closed versus quotes offered . Production schedules were also displayed on boards in the new planning and control department. A Brief History… (Continued …) By 1982 , Ricardo and the other new blood had turned the company around. They were manufacturing a wider range of products and secured some major contracts and new acquisitions. They had nearly doubled the workforce and tripled the number of plants, where they set about applying the new systems and financial controls . But things didn’t go as it was intended . In Ricardo’s words “Semco appeared highly organized and disciplined , but we still could not get our people to perform as well as we wanted . People were working long hours and families were complaining. Deliveries were always late .” “I knew our new tough-minded, statistical approach, along with our acquisitions and all the new employees, had created a lot of stress” , Ricardo admits . A Brief History… (Continued …) Once During a visit to a pump factory in the U.S. , Ricardo collapsed on the factory floor being sick . Also , at the annual corporate retreat , someone snuck into the conference room and drew a cartoonish Grim Reaper on one of the flip charts , holding a scythe and surrounded by bleeding stick figures . This incidents conveyed the message that Ricardo’s autocratic leadership style was wreaking havoc on him , his employees and the company , Semco . Ricardo went to some doctor(s) and the doctor(s) advised him only : everything about Ricardo’s life has to be changed . Then Ricardo went to the Botanique Hotel taking some time off from his duties from Semco , a luxury eco-resort two hours outside Sao Paulo , Brazil and Fernanda Semler , Ricardo’s wife and Ricardo’s brainchild . Ricardo took some rest and relaxation to relive and rejuvenate in the hotel Botanique . A Brief History… (Continued …) The Botanique hotel had no departments and no fixed positions . All employees were skilled waiters, many are barmen, all knew how to operate the high-end cappuccino machine, all made beds fast, some played tennis, others played the piano and many were hikers, wildlife monitors or capoeira (Brazilian martial art) masters. This permits the hotel to function at 18.5% breakeven, a level that no hotel has seen (average breakeven in hotels is 39% at Brazil) A Brief History… (Continued …) According to Fernanda , Ricardo’s Wife , the hotel provided a “post-luxury” experience that includes the best that Brazil has to offer. But Botanique was not only the most expensive hotel in Brazil, but also the first hotel based on a highly democratic philosophy where employees make all the hiring decisions themselves. For those who helped building the hotel, a position was created to match their talent as long as they were willing to be flexible as well. For example, Leandro, a capoeira teacher in his free time, helped cleaning during the construction of the hotel and now organizes capoeira classes for guests. But just like the drivers, waiters, and the hotel pianist , he also needs to clean the rooms. Botanique sought to maximize the flexibility and freedom of its employees, giving them a level of control that encourages them to take initiative and craft their jobs in a way that best leverages their own individual abilities and interests. Decisionmaking at Botanique was fully democratic and requires the input of all staff members who, in turn, need to be fully informed about occupancy rates, expenses and ongoing activities at all times. For example, everyone was involved in interviewing potential colleagues and bosses and new people cannot join without the input of all staff members first. Ricardo and Fernanda said that it is precisely because of these policies that Botanique has been a success story so far, having won numerous industry awards in its short time in operation. A Brief History… (Continued …) However, Ricardo didn’t have the luxury of starting from scratch when he wanted to transform the culture and management practices at Semco. But he knew things had to change. His employees were stressed and unhappy, and his own health problems were a testament to the deleterious effects of such management practices on both followers and leaders. Then , Ricardo put the principles and working style that was prevalent at the Botanique hotel into his organization , Semco , in various phases . He turned Semco from an autocratic organization to a democratic one where employees are free to take key decisions like hiring decisions , and it is the company that runs itself . Semco’s Radical Make Over : 1984 Ricardo started leaving the office at 19:00 and stopped working weekends . He stopped wearing a watch and started spending time outside work . To help him manage the changes he wanted at Semco, Ricardo teamed up with a new human resources director, Clovis Bojikian, a former school teacher . Semco’s Radical Make Over … (Continued …) Dress code was abolished . Surveillance was also made not very tight . Things like expense reports were then eliminated – employees would monitor their own spending when away from the office. And a nonterritorial, open office plan was created with plants and flowers separating communal desk spaces that were used on a first-come-firstserved basis. Semco’s Radical Make Over … (Continued …) Flexible working hours were introduced on the manufacturing shop floor so that employees could work the hours that were most convenient for them. In the mid-1980s, Semco manager João Vendramin convinced Semler to create a lattice organization. Under this program, self-managed groups of six to ten manufacturing employees were placed in charge of all aspects of production. To promote a sense of true ownership of the process, the groups were charged with setting their own budgets and production goals. Tying salaries to monthly budget and production performance aligned employee and organizational goals. With the implementation of the lattice, unit production costs fell dramatically while employee productivity soared. Semco’s Radical Make Over … (Continued …) Ricardo moved on from dress codes and expense accounts to bigger matters. When a new factory was needed, a search committee of workers was created to research and make the decisions themselves. Workers were subsequently given control over how the plant itself was set up and run. Perhaps most interesting was the employee-suggested system of “manufacturing cells”: small clusters of workers, each responsible for creating batches of the entire product. Although each team would be entirely responsible for product quality, they would also have the satisfaction of learning how to operate all the machines involved and of completing a task from start to finish. As the accountability of the teams increased, so the need for quality control decreased – and whole departments were abolished. The size of Human Resources department was reduced from 90 people to two. In its place, a new worker-led hiring system sprang up. Workers started to recruit new members for their own teams – and fire those who did not measure up. And a new job rotation plan meant that employees were encouraged and even expected to change departments regularly. Semco’s Radical Make Over … (Continued …) Semco then implemented a system whereby subordinates played a key role in directly evaluating their bosses. Every employee completed the form twice a year with anonymity guaranteed. However, the manager’s overall score (average 80-85; 70 minimum to remain in good standing) was posted for the entire company to see, putting those with low scores (less than 70) “under intense pressure to change”, as Ricardo wanted . The system not only helped mangers improve their skill and increased communication; it helped insure bad managers could not hide for long. Employees were asked to consider their length of service, level of decision making, and time spent with customers as they decided on a figure to request for their remuneration . By 1989, Semco had one of the highest growth rates in the country. It won a national award for labor relations. Sales had risen from around $4 million, when Ricardo took over, to $35 million. Where once it was a company with only one factory and 100 employees, it now had six factories and 830 employees. Lewin's 3-Stage Model of Change in Transforming Semco : Some Words The Final Transformation of Semco : The 1990s In 1990, Brazil’s economy crashed. Industrial output fell by 9% and GDP was back to what it had been in the 1970s. By 1992 there were nearly 1.5 million unemployed in São Paulo alone. Between 1989 and 1991, Semco’s sales fell by 40%. Layoffs seemed as inevitable but some other option instead of layoff has been tried . The workers, took a 30% pay cut and gave up most of their benefits. The managers, for their part, agreed to an even greater pay cut. By the end of third month, salaries had been restored to their old levels. Profit sharing also compensated for the reduced salaries . In an economic crisis that saw an average of 800 Brazilian companies going broke every month, Semco survived and managed to break even in the very worst years – but it was almost unrecognizable as the company founded by Antonio Semler. Productivity had soared to six and a half times the level of 1980 by 1994 and was four times the national average. Sales had recovered to around $20 million. Analysis on the Style of Ricardo Semler’s Leadership Style Ricardo Semler is a successful transformational leader, he transformed Semco company into a modernize organization. Semler was in an autocratic leadership style in the early stage of 1982, which possessed power of authority and high management control over his employees. They needed to work long hour, dress formally and constantly monitor under surveillance in order to keep up with the production schedule. However, Semler adopted to democratic leadership style as he has health problem from the stress originated from long hours of activity in office and found out his employees were equally unhappy with the organizational culture in later year of 1984. Semler has demonstrated the characteristics as below : Charismatic vision Empathy communication Confident and trust Innovation and creativity Kaizen Individual output increase The Results of Transformational Leadership Style of Ricardo’s Leadership from McGregor’s Theory : Theory X and Theory Y Explanation of Ricardo’s Leadership Style using Blake and Mouton’s Managerial Grid : Some Words Conclusion In Semco , Anyone, including lower level workers, is welcome to attend almost any meeting, read any reports and memos. Everyone is allowed to attend the budget meetings where targets and quotas are decided. Two spots are reserved for anyone to sign up and attend board meetings but nobody is obligated to attend meetings either, and people come and go as they like . That proves how much Semco promotes individual freedom at work . Ricardo also tried to use the “Semco Philosophy” in other sections of human development in the society . With some help from the Gates Foundation and the Harvard Graduate School of Education, he set up three schools in Brazil, the Lumiar schools, where the underlying pedagogical philosophy was to make students rather than teachers the center of the learning experience. In Ricardo’s explanation - Children choose their own subjects so that they are more motivated to acquire relevant language, math, and social skills. But the focus on the individual also takes place in the context of joint development. They vote collectively on their group activities and the majority decides. In this system, the teacher is replaced by a “Tutor” and multiple “Masters.” The Tutor is responsible for mapping out the future of each child’s learning, with episodic consultation of parents. The Master is someone who must possess two qualities: expertise in some subject and passion. The expertise of these Masters can be math, even though the Master is trained as a violinist, for example. The subjects are grouped under current interests of the students. A famous quote from Ricardo Semler’s Mind !! Key Facts and Figures of Semco’s Success As of 2003, Semco had annual revenue of $212 million, up from $4 million in 1982 and $35 million in 1994, with an annual growth rate of up to 40 percent a year. It employed 3,000 workers in 2003, as opposed to 90 in 1982. The company's units include: The industrial machinery unit, which now manufactures mixing equipment as opposed to pumps Sembobac, a partnership with Baltimore Air Cooler making cooling towers Cushman and Wakefield Semco, a partnership with Rockefeller property company Cushman and Wakefield managing properties in Brazil and Latin America Semco Johnson Controls, a partnership with Johnson Controls, managing large scale facilities such as airports and hospitals ERM, a partnership with Environmental Resources Management, one of the world's leading environmental consultants Semco Ventures, offering high technology and Internet services SemcoHR, a human resources management firm Semco-RGIS, an inventory control firm Sources : 1) Ricardo Semler: A Revolutionary Model of Leadership : INSEAD Case Study (Primary Source) 2) How to run a company with (almost) no rules : https://www.ted.com/talks/ricardo_semler_how _to_run_a_company_with_almost_no_rules 3) Ricardo Semler and Semco SA : A Case Study – The American Graduate School of International Business Feedback Please feel free to share your feedback on this presentation . Thank you all and The End !!