FL Civil Procedure Cheat Sheet A. Court Jurisdiction 1. Personal JX: Courts Jurisdiction over parties to a lawsuit i. PJ: D domicile in FL, D present in FL when served with process, D “at home” in FL ii. PJ on a non-resident must satisfy: FL Long-arm statute & Con. Due Process Clause a. FL Long-arm Statute: i. G. PJ = if a defendant engages in “substantial and not isolated” activities within Florida ii. S. PJ = always where a claim arises from D (B/L/T/C/MV) in FL: b. Constitutional minimum contacts requirement: i. Systematic and continuous activity within the forum jurisdiction ii. A cause of action arising from that activity 2. Subject Matter JX: authority of a court to hear cases relating to a specific SM i. 20 Circuit Ct.= no aggregation of claims to meet 30k threshold unless same T/O - If improper: Ct. transfers it, P pays clerk within 30 days/ if not dismiss w/o prejudice - Compulsory counter claim in Circuit court that is less than 30k is OK - Circuit exclusive JX over: a. Probate and estate matters, guardianship, incompetence b. Cases involving Juveniles (except traffic offenses); c. Cases involving title or boundaries to realty; d. Ejectment cases; tenant evicting landlord e. Actions at law exceeding $30,000 f. Equity suits exceeding $30,000 - Non-exclusive: a. Landlord evicting tenant over $30k (if under 30k MUST go to County) ii. 67 County Ct. = one for each county - If P brings claim in County and D’s counterclaim is JX of Circuit Ct. The entire case is transferred to Circuit but only if D pays transfer costs and if he doesn’t pay for transfer then Counterclaim is cut to $30k. – if not possibly waived - County exclusive JX over: a. Actions at law not exceeding $30,000 b. Landlord evicting tenants not exceeding $30,000 (more than $30,000 then can go to County or Circuit) c. Disputes in homeowners’ associations - Non-exclusive: a. Equity cases not exceeding $30,000: cases can also go to Circuit 3. Venue: What county do we sue in? Geographical location of Ct. that may hear a case i. Local Actions: venue is the county where the land lies ii. Transitory Actions: - If D resides in FL, venue is okay a. where defendant resides when complaint filed b. where cause of action accrued i. Tort: where action occurred 1 iii. iv. v. - vi. - ii. Contracts: where performance was due iii. County where property is c. County where property in litigation is located – ownership of chattel If there are two D in FL living in two different counties, either county is proper venue If D does not reside in FL, venue is OK in any county If there are two D, one a FL resident and one a non-resident, venue must be proper for FL resident Retail installment contract’s proper venue only where a. contract was signed b. buyer resided either at purchase or when suit filed or c. product attached to land (no agreeing to different venue by parties) Contract provision requiring FL con/subcontractor to be sued out of state = void Transfer of venue: If improper/proper, P/Party pays clerk within 30 days If proper only allowed for 2 reasons: 1. A party will not receive a fair trial where originally filed- factors: opponent undue influence (petition/affidavit), detestable moving party (petition/affidavit), impracticable to get a qualified jury- transfer to any county 2. Convenience of parties/ witnesses, and “interest of justice” show that another ct. is the center of gravity – court must transfer where venue is proper. Forum of Non Conveniens: A ct. might dismiss or stay b/c another ct. is center of gravity and transfer is not possible b/c ct. is in another state/country The other ct. must be adequate, and court looks at public/private factors Motion must be made within 60 days after service of process B. Information About The Case 1. Service of Process: (summons + copy of complaint) served to D - Begins by issuance of summons by clerk of court. Clerk routinely issues summons at the time the complaint is filed. Clerk need not wait to file the motion - Multiple defendants: each get a summons and copy of complaint - Suing a state: serve process on state or state attorney - Suing local gov: mayor etc. is fine - Suing non-resident: can be served by someone with legal authority so like a NY resident can be sued by NY sheriff in that state i. Process may be served by sheriff/appointee or Elisor (ct. appointed) who files proof of service – failure to file doesn’t affect validity of service ii. Service on adults: Personally served or substituted service - Substituted service of process delivered to: a. D’s abode, left with 15+ year old/lives there, server tells contents of doc. b. D’s spouse anywhere in county, spouses live together, can’t be for an adversial proceeding b/w spouses c. D’s agent for service of process d. Individual in charge of private mailbox/office only if the location is the only public address of D and D still maintains mailbox/office at that location 2 iii. Service on minors: guardian/parent. Service on parent is fine. Minors need to be represented by guardian or similar fiduciary and suit can be under either minor or guardian’s name / iv. Service on incompetents: serve 2 copies on person w. custody/ask ct. for GAL v. Service on Corp.: Serve highest rank if not director/officer vi. Service on resident/registered agent: If there is neither, serve any employee at PPB vii. Service on non-resident w. office in FL/done business here: if no resident agent, serve FL secretary of state and have D served personally out of state by a proper officer or by registered/certified mail, return receipt requested. viii. Service Nail & Posted: Where landlord sues tenant to disposes him of premise and has failed twice (at least 6 hours apart) to make personal substituted service, then landlord may have process posted conspicuously on the premises and have the clerk mail process by first class to tenant at those premises. ix. Publication Service: Made be made as provided by statute in cases involving: i. Realty ii. Construction of a will or other written instruments iii. Dissolution of marriage iv. Adoption - P must give a sworn statement that D cannot be found in FL after diligent search and inquiry and must state whether D’s address is un/known. If known, must state address in or out of FL. Copy of published notice mailed by clerk to last known address. x. Wavier of formal service: P mails process/wavier form to D and within 20 days D can return waiver form. D has 60 days from receipt of waiver to respond to complaint - If no return of waiver, P can effectuate formal service and ct. can require D to pay costs. THIS DOES NOT WAIVE VENUE OR PJ xi. Filing of complaint stops SOL and P must serve D within 120 days of filing - Court can order a different time or can dismiss w/o prejudice unless P shows good cause for delay in serving - Cannot serve process on Sunday unless plaintiff gives an affidavit that she has reason to believe D will leave the state under “protection of Sunday” xii. Subsequent doc. (motions etc.) served via email to party’s attorney - Email is sent by the court’s e-filing portal, service is complete when the doc. is electronically filed otherwise service is complete when sent. - If attorney/pro se is excused from having an email address, docs. can be delivered, or snail mailed. The time in which to respond to any documents is increased by 5 days if service is made by snail mail. 2. Pleadings i. All pleadings must have: ct. name/case file#/Parties names/attny. name, address, #, FL bar #, email/designation of pleadings/each claim & defense/ # paragraphs - Documents that are the basis of a claim/defense must be included in pleading ii. Attorney Certificate: At lease 1 attorney must sign pleadings - Certifies attny. read document, info good support of claims/defenses/ not for delay iii. Party in case can recover attny. fee if losing party raised a claim or defense that was not supported by facts or law or good faith argument for modification of law - Payable 50/50 by losing party and attny. If lawyer acted in good faith/not liable 3 - iv. - v. - vi. vii. viii. ix. - - At any time in case, a party can move to recover damages for delay in litigation show by a preponderance of the evidence that the opposing party took an act primarily for unreasonable delay Complaint: pleading filed + civil cover sheet (or proceeding stayed) begins action a. Statement of ground for SMJ & PJ if suing non-resident b. Short and plain statement of “ultimate facts” showing entitlement to relief c. Demand for judgment. For damages: Ad damnum clause: dollar figure not req. Special matters must be pleaded with specificity: a. Circumstances establishing fraud b. Facts supporting punitive damages: stated separately from general/ P can’t org. plead punitive damages so must present evidence and then move to amend the complaint to add punitive damages c. Special damages: stated separately from general D must motion/answer within 20 days/ if motion is denied must answer within 10 Defense Motions: not pleadings but request for court order a. Issues of Form: more definite statement, to strike=(no ext.), jud. on pleadings b. Major defenses: can be raised either in answer or by motion 1. Lack of SMJ: never waived 2. Lack of PJ: waivable 3. Improper venue: waivable 4. Insufficiency of process: waivable 5. Insufficiency of service of process: waivable 6. Failure to state cause of action: raised anytime through trial. 7. Failure to join indispensable party: raised anytime through trial. So if D makes a motion for lack of PJ, D waives defenses 2,3,4, and 5. – must be raised first response of complaint Answer: D must answer or risk default and include in answer: i. Admit: non-denials are treated as admissions ii. Deny iii. State you are “without knowledge” iv. Affirmative defenses: SOL, assump. of risk, lack legal capacity or capacity to be sued, res judicata, or comparative negligence Reply: is a responsive pleading: To deny, P does nothing & can reply to avoid affirm. defense within 20 days P can “Reply” to affirm. defense that P wants to avoid within 20 days Counterclaim: Part of D’s answer and claim against opposing party/ P must respond Counter Claim must be served to P’s attorney unless Ct. directs O/W Compulsory CC arises from same T/O – failure to raise waives claim Compulsory CC must be asserted w. answer if not barred and if D states no answer then not barred i. If D serves answer and should of asserted compulsory CC too, the court might let him do it if he shows excusable neglect or that justice so requires ii. If A sues B and B files a Compulsory Counterclaim and A voluntarily dismisses her original claim, A’s claim is now a compulsory claim and she’s making a mistake because she will now waive her claim Permissive CC: does not arise from same T/O and isn’t waived if not filed 4 Crossclaim: claim against a co-party/must arise same T/O/ isn’t waived if not filed x. Amending: P can amend 1 before D answers/ D can amend answer 1 within 20 days - Motion to amend: if no right to amend and granted if justice so requires - Opp. P must respond w/in 10 days of amendment - Variance & SOL: same as federal 3. Discovery i. Discovery tools: No required initial disclosure but same tools as federal ct. Deposition: you can depose party(notice)/non-party (subpoena) - Party can be officer, director, or managing agent of a party – can be disposed by notice - Parties have a right to be at deposition. - Videotape depo is authorized without court order (if party but if non party you still need subpoena) but they must also be stenographically recorded unless otherwise agreed upon by parties - Nonresident nonparty: must be subpoenaed in by court where they live so if they live in NY then an NY court must subpoena & compelled to appear in the county they were served aka most likely out of state bc FL wouldn’t have JX there - Duces tecum: requires W to bring evidence with them/ documents in a hearing/depo – no inspection or copy without ct. order unless P agrees if he doesn’t agree he puts it in writing and other side needs to get ct order - Court order req.: depo before case filed or less than 30 days after serve of complaint - A person who wishes to perpetuate her own testimony but complaint has not been filed may upon verified petition obtain a Ct. order for an oral/written depo and service must be made upon all expected adverse parties and person being deposed which will be granted if court believes the testimony may prevent a failure or delay of justice - P (including corp. officers) deposed where case pending & D/nonparty county of resident/biz (could agree o/w) - Court may order depo to be taken for the convenience of the parties at any location - FL court has subpoena power in all of FL Interrogatories: answered in writing/under oath, w/i 30 days /or 45 with complaint - 30 interrogatories and answers binding signed by parties/obj. signed by attny. - No requirement to supplement answer if new info coming to light makes submitted answer wrong - Can ask court for more if party shows good cause Request to produce: receiving P must respond w/i 30 or 45 agreeing/objecting - D’s financial net worth is only discoverable for punitive damages Non-parties: must subpoena & give notice to all other parties his intent to serve subpoena at least 10/15 day before subpoena is issued. Notice isn’t given to non-P - Sub. Served by personal service/mail with written confirmation of delivery, signed by person accepting the subpoena, and filed in court - Nonparties may condition the preparation of copies of the documents on the payment in advance of the reasonable copy cost - If party objects, party seeking discovery can move for a ruling on the objection or notice the non-party depo with a subpoena duces tecum Physical/mental examination: no court order needed if physical condition of the party is in controversy - 5 ii. - iii. serves notice stating reasonable time, place, manner, and scope of examination, and person by whom exam is to be made Other party must respond in writing w/i 30/45 days either agreeing or objecting If condition in controversy is not physical, then examination is available only upon motion. Must show good cause for the examination Person examined may get report of examination, but this waives privilege on reports regarding the same condition Request for admission: request to admit the truth of any discoverable matter Respond in 30/45, failure to deny = admission, admissions not binding in other lit. 30 max request of admissions that may be served on a party unless the parties agree to more or the court orders more for good cause Scope of Discovery: anything relevant to SM of the case Privilege not discoverable Must assert privilege expressly in privilege log Accidental disclosure of privilege material does not waive privilege if the party serves a written notice w/i 10 days of discovering disclosure. The other party must return or destroy material but can challenge the assertion of privilege Must request discovery of facts known and opinions of experts retained for trial If the expert is expected to testify, send interrogatories to the other party, seeking expert name, substance of facts + opinion, grounds for opinions/ Relationship between party and expert, / pay expert’s fee. No need ct. order to depose expert – so can depose without leave of ct. If expert is not expected to testify, then discovery absent exceptional need Enforcement of Discovery Rules Discovery disputes: party seeks protective orders or partial/total failures To get any sanction, moving party first try to confer with other party Partial Failure: i. Seek an order compelling answers to unanswered questions and costs including attorney’s fees incurred to bring motion ii. If party violates the order compelling, merits sanctions plus attorney’s fees incurred Total Failure: Merit sanctions plus cost/attny. fees incurred bringing motion In a false denial of request to admit= you can recover costs of having to prove the issue including attorney’s fees Different Merit Sanctions: establishment order, strike pleadings, stay proceedings until discovery is given, disallow evidence, contempt, (dismiss case or enter default = only if willful or deliberate refusal to obey discovery order) C. Multiparty Litigation i. Proper Parties Permissive joinder: these parties may be joined since claims arise from same T/O - If Ps have independent COA against same D: cannot join even if same T/O unless spouses/parents and or their children may join together Necessary & indispensable parties should be joined b/c relationship with the action 1. If A is necessary and should be joined by the court: i. Without absentees, court may not be able to accord complete relief or 6 - - ii. Absentee’ interest may be harmed in a practical way if she isn’t joined 2. If there is PJ over A 3. If the absentee cannot be joined, then court must decide either to proceed without A or dismiss the whole case. A is indispensable if court decides to dismiss rather than proceed Intervention: absentee can join with in discretion of ct. but not req. to intervene Impleader: D adds a new party who is 3rd party D and is/ may be liable for all or part of the underlying claim, so D seeks indemnity or contribution from 3rd party. 3RD party must have PJ Right to implead w/i 20 days of serving answer. After = you need court permission 3rd party can raise defenses that defendant could raise against the Plaintiff 3rd party can assert a claim against P and vice versa as long as the claim arises from the same T/O as underlying case. Interpleader: One holding money/property can force all claimants into a 1 lawsuit Stakeholder deposits the property in court and recovers his costs and attorney’s fees (if innocent party) and disappears/ Claimants litigate, and court decides who gets the property If stakeholder is interested (it believes it has right to $), then it would deposit property and not disappear but participate in litigation. Class Actions: fit case within 1 of the 3 types of classes & ct. must certify class act. Initial req.: same as fed. i. Numerosity ii. Commonality iii. Typicality iv. Adequate representation Notice (paid by rep) required to ALL types of class and must inform that they can opt out, bound by jud if they don’t, and enter separate appearance in case through counsel Parties may only settle/voluntarily dismiss with court approval: court gives notice to all members and considers feedback in deciding voluntary dismissal/ settlement D. Adjudication i. Termination of Case without Trial Voluntary dismissal: File notice of dismissal but not allowed if case has been submitted to jury/motion of SJ is pending/property in ct. custody/ indepen. CC - Even if parties agree on dismissal not allowed if property in ct. custody - First v. dismissal is w/o prejudice and second is dismissed w. prejudice - Lis pendens is automatically canceled when dismissal filed. A lis pendens is a written notice that a lawsuit has been filed concerning real estate, involving either the title to the property or a claimed ownership interest in it. – automatic if dismissal is recorded - Default/Default by Judgment: If D fails to plead within 20 days of service Entry of default: filed by clerk if D didn’t file anything/by judge if D files something P must make an application for entry of default & D only gets notice if he filed something. Once default is entered, D cannot answer or file a motion Entry of judgment: only entered by judge & D gets notice of hearing on damages 7 - - P can only recover what’s stated in complaint nothing more Relief from Judgment: Before judgment, D can make motion to set aside default but must show either good cause (excusable neglect) or due diligence after learning D can also make motion to set aside judgment after entry of judgment -same req. Involuntary Dismissal: There is no action for 10 months because P failed to prosecute then After 10 months, notice can be given and 60 days after notice is given then motion to involuntary dismiss can be made by Ct., D, or any party in action for failure to prosecute: Ct. will dismiss unless P can show good cause 5 days before hearing In a nonjury trial after P completes presentation, D can move for involuntary dismissal on grounds that P hasn’t proven case and no right to relief Ct. could move for inv. Dismissal for failure of adverse party to comply with ct. order Any inv. dismissal is presumed w/prejudice unless the court said otherwise or unless it was based upon JX, venue, failure to prosecute, or indispensable parties So it’s possible for a Ct. to order an involuntary dismissal w/o prejudice Rule Nisi: court order asking party to show cause so judge does not enter order Scire Facias: Order requiring one to show cause why some matter of the record like a judgment should not be revived and enforced. Summary Judgment: must show there is no genuine dispute on a material fact and is entitled to judgment as a matter of law - Party must serve notice of hearing date with reasonable timing - D may move any time and P must wait 20 days after filing complaint - Party opposing the motion may serve its evidence by snail mail at least 5 days before the hearing or by delivering, electronically filing it, or emailing it to movant’s lawyer no later than 5pm two days before hearing - Ct. can review affidavits, pleading, deps, interrogatories, admissions, but not oral testimony ii. Pretrial Judicial Management Case Management Conference: Judge has discretion in deciding whether to hold CMC Court may convene this with reasonable notice – blueprint for overall case scheduling, discovery, setting trial date etc.- Ct. responsibility and must specify matters to be considered at conference Pretrial Conference: Ct. gives 20-day notice and considers issues to simplify trialjudge is required to schedule pre-trial upon timely motion of party Failure to attend: Ct. takes action to award merits: severe if willful iii. Trial Magistrates: With parties’ permission a circuit court can refer matters to a magistrate and have 10 days to object decision- ultimate decision is for judge ADR: Judge can order to use mediation/arbitration and either’s conference must take place w/I 60 days of court orders. P can move to dispense ADR for good cause - Mediation: Must complete within 45 days of first mediation conference- unless ct. extends. Mediator reports to ct. if case cannot be settled. If settled, terms are put in writing and filed and case jointly dismissed 8 - Arbitration: Must complete within 30 days of first arbitration hearing Nonbinding: very informal, evidence summarized by counsel, arbitrators send written decision to parties and court that sets forth conclusions and findings, decision becomes final unless a party request trial de novo within 20 days Binding: two or more adverse parties must agree and enter written agreement setting out hearing procedures or court will set procedures. Decision is sent to parties and court which can be appealed to circuit court in 30 days if not it becomes final – grounds for appeal are narrow - Voluntary Trial Resolution: case heard by attorney w. decision enforceable in circuit – similar to binding arbitration Offer of Judgment/Proposal for Settlement Expedited Trial: if parties agree, discovery completed in 60 days and trial in 1 Jury Trial: must demand in writing within 10 days after service of last pleading - Withdrawal of demand only allowed if other party agrees - 6 jurors or 12 in eminent domain cases - Unlimited striking jurors for cause - 3 preemptory challenges for each side: 2 P and 3 D= P get 9 and D get 9 - Jury can submit written, unsigned questions directed to witnesses or court. - Jurors must each get copy of jury instruction during its deliberations - To preserve the issue of appeal, a party must object to a jury instruction or to the court’s failure to give a particular instruction before the jury is charged - If counsel failed to object judge instructions at court conference preceding final argument: waiver of objection and counsel cant object iv. Judgment Direct Verdict: Effect of this order is to take the case away from the jury - Defendant can move after Plaintiff is heard. Plaintiff goes once all evidence is heard. Verdict: must be unanimous/approved by judge/read by clerk - the jury must itemize damages to be awards in three categories. : must specify the basis for each form of damages i. Economic Loss: past/future loss = compensatory damages ii. Non-economic Loss: past/future loss = compensatory damage iii. Punitive damages: for intentional misconduct or gross negligence: must be shown by clear and convincing evidence compensatory damages: Cap is that it can’t exceed the greater of 3X compensatory awarded to each claimaint or 500k. No limit if D had specific intent to harm P or under the influence of alq. or drugs. Entry of Judgment: official decision by ct. - A party seeking judgment taxing costs or attorney’s fees or both must serve motion within 30 days of filing judgment - Prevailing party must file with the clerk a final disposition form at the time the court filed the judgment disposing of the case Belated Directed Verdict: To file, party must have moved for directed verdict at a proper time at trial/ must be in writing and filed within 15 days after verdict - If granted, the court is saying that the jury reached a conclusion that reasonable people couldn’t have reached- takes victory away and gives it to other side v. Post-trial Motions 9 - - - Motion for new trial: Verdict returned or judgment entered, but errors at trial require a new trial/ must be in writing, filed, and served within 15 days after return of verdict by jury or judgment( nonjury) - Grounds: a. Prejudicial error at trial makes judgment unjust b. New evidence that could not have been discovered w. due diligence c. Prejudicial misconduct of party or juror d. Judgment is against weight of evidence The party should object to any event serving a basis for a new trial at the time of the event. A Parties failure to object to evidence/testimony will preclude them from raising issue A party could seek a new trial based upon improper closing argument if he failed to object at the time of the argument if the argument was so harmful, incurable, and unfair that public interest demands new trial vi. Inherent Authority: Trial courts have inherent authority to award attorney’s fees against a party for bad faith conduct. Also can be imposed against attorney for bad faith The bad faith conduct must be in the litigation Th amount of the award must be directly related to the attorney’s fees and costs incurred by the other side as a result of the bad faith conduct / court should rely on statute if there is one vs inherent authority vii. Relief from judgment: motion to set aside a judgment Grounds: 1. Clerical errors: anytime 2. Mistake, excusable neglect, surprise: reasonable time not exceeding 1 year 3. Fraud by opposing party: reasonable time not exceeding 1 year 4. Newly discovered evidence not previously available despite due diligence: reasonable time not exceeding 1 year 5. Judgment void: reasonable time/ no max viii. Execution of Judgment: After Judgment entered, clerk may issue document to sheriff that he is to levy on the defendant’s property to satisfy the judgment. Execution is stayed for 15 days after entry of judgment Stay pending disposition of such motions is automatic Stay pending appeal is not automatic: must file supersedeas bond in amount of judgment plus 15 percent E. Appellate Review i. Courts: file notice of appeal in trial court within 30 days after judgment - Raise issues on which made timely objection in trial ct. ii. Final Judgment Rule: can only appeal a final judgment iii. Interlocutory Review: Appealable even though not final judgments - Orders granting a new trial - Orders re injunctions - Orders determining PJ or venue - Orders re right to immediate possession of property - Orders on a distinct and separable claim 10 Supreme ct. can’t review a decision by district court of appeals that expressly construes a state statute: expressly interprets it Court reporters are optional for trial and must be compensated by parties Pending discovery motion does not preclude setting of trial date. When all pleadings have been served in the case and there is no motion directed to those pleadings pending, a party or court itself may take action to set a trial date It’s up to the Ct. discretion to let the jury see accident scene or any other thing or matter in controversy if necessary, to a just decision Affidavit may only be signed by person with personal knowledge of what’s written Generally, communications b/w lawyer and public entity are available for inspection. However, a public record prepared by agency attorney reflecting mental impression, legal theory etc. is exempt from disclosure until conclusion of litigation 11