Uploaded by Ronaldo Melgar

RM Policy Project Q2

advertisement
Ronaldo Melgar
Period 1
Throughout various articles and comprehensive news reports on the U.S foreign policy
towards China, it has been established that the U.S has changed their stance from one of passive
diplomacy and risk mitigation to one of more bold confrontation and a more aggressive,
antagonistic approach in technology, economics, and ideology. This has led to a sharp
deterioration in relations between the U.S and China in 2020 after three years of steadily
declining under the Donald J. Trump administration (Economy, Huang, Cohen, Segal, and Julian
2020). The Trump administration has mainly focused on a strategy of using their presidential
powers and ordering executive orders to implement policy instead of the traditional legislative
route in Congress. One notable article by Politico talks about the executive order the Trump
administration has passed in barring U.S. investments in Chinese military-linked firms. This
executive order was passed on November 12, 2020 and has taken effect as of January 11, 2020
and moved to the policy implementation step. The people who gain from this order are the
politicians and leaders in the Trump administration who have lobbied to take a harder stance on
China and believe that separating the U.S economy from China would be benefit us. The people
who lose from this are the Chinese companies who want to do business in the U.S financial
institutions but will be banned from doing so. Others who are affected are the U.S investors who
want to invest in these Chinese companies but now can’t due to this order. This order will also
only add to the already contentious relationship between the U.S and China and is in line with
the strategy the Trump administration has used throughout his presidency on trade and social
issues. Another article that supports this reasoning is by Reuters on U.S. blacklists dozens of
Chinese firms including SMIC, DJI. This policy implementation was made by the Department of
Commerce and is viewed as the continuation of the Trump’s administration strategy of being
tough on China regarding trade and economic issues. This too favors Hawks who want a tough
Ronaldo Melgar
Period 1
stance of China and domestic companies. It puts Chinese companies that want to do business in
China at a disadvantage and affect companies and investors who seek to invest in these major
Chinese corporations. The Trump’s zero tolerance against China is what most likely influenced
this escalation and have made Beijing speak out against this oppression and are considering
taking necessary measures to protect their rights. This raises the tension again as the two
countries have already been locked in a trade war since 2018. The key linkage institution that has
overseen carrying out the U.S foreign policy has been the executive branch i.e. the Trump
Administration and President Trump have been the main driving force for the direction that
foreign policy and policy making towards China has taken. The Department of Defense is
another important government department that has implemented the Trump Administration’s
foreign policy and have worked to make the blacklist of Chinese firms that have ties to the
Chinese military. The Department of State is the main government agency responsible for
America’s foreign policy with China and is led by Mike Pompeo who has followed Trump’s lead
and has taken a hard stance against China as well and has been an outspoken critic of the Chinese
Communist Party. The Treasury department and the Commerce department are another pair of
important agencies that help implement Trump’s policies on the financial front. What led to this
very aggressive and belligerent strategy for U.S foreign policy stemmed from many different
factors. Trump’s administration built their policy around the idea that as China grew
economically, they would gain influence on the world stage and spread their autocratic ideology
to other nations jeopardizing U.S interests and the freedoms of American workers and citizens
(Hass 2020, 6). This has been the main policy making strategy for Trump and his supporters in
Congress. As of now due to changing administrations between the Trump and Biden
administrations other articles researched have reflected the agenda setting and policy formulation
Ronaldo Melgar
Period 1
steps. Articles like the one written by the Harvard Business Review have reviewed the actions of
the Trump’s last actions on China in office and have speculated on What Will the U.S.-China
Relationship Look Like in the Biden Era (Reynolds and Pohlman 2021). That is where I believe
the U.S policy on China will head to next. As the Biden administration is sworn in they will have
to focus on a strategy with China that will ease tensions and open more diplomatic initiatives on
common interests but will also put pressure on Beijing on the ideological front such as Hong
Kong and the treatment of Uighurs in Xinjiang. They will also have to continue the Trump
administration’s strategy of competition with China in new technologies if the U.S want to be the
leading figure in scientific advances and a model for the rest of the world.
Ronaldo Melgar
Period 1
Bibliography
Alper, Alexandra, David Shepardson, and Humeyra Pamuk. “U.S. Blacklists Dozens of Chinese
Firms Including SMIC, DJI.” Reuters. Thomson Reuters, December 18, 2020.
https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-china-sanctions/u-s-blacklists-dozens-of-chinesefirms-including-smic-dji-idUSKBN28S0HL.
Bade, Gavin. “Trump Bars U.S. Investments in Chinese Military-Linked Firms.” POLITICO.
POLITICO, November 12, 2020. https://www.politico.com/news/2020/11/12/trump-chinainvestment-ban-436333.
Economy, Elizabeth C., Yanzhong Huang, Jerome A. Cohen, Adam Segal, and Julian Gerwitz.
“How 2020 Shaped U.S.-China Relations.” Council on Foreign Relations. Council on
Foreign Relations, December 15, 2020. https://www.cfr.org/article/how-2020-shaped-uschina-relations.
Hass, Ryan. “Lessons from the Trump Administration’s Policy Experiment on China.”
Brookings.edu, September 16, 2020. https://www.brookings.edu/wpcontent/uploads/2020/09/Ryan-Hass_Lessons-from-the-Trump-Administrations-PolicyExperiment-on-China_Final.pdf.
Reynolds, Oliver, and Arne Pohlman. “What Will the U.S.-China Relationship Look Like in the
Biden Era?” Harvard Business Review, January 7, 2021. https://hbr.org/2021/01/what-willthe-u-s-china-relationship-look-like-in-the-biden-era.
Download