I
NTHEHON’
BLEHI
GHCOURTOFHOMELANDATPANDORA
APPEALFROM ORDERNO.401OF2019
MrNei
l
Jacob
(
Or
i
gi
nal
Def
endantNo.
3)
…Appel
l
ant
Ver
sus
1.
WonderHol
i
day
sPv
t
.Lt
d.
(
Or
i
gi
nal
Pl
ai
nt
i
f
f
)
2.
MrSV
(
Or
i
gi
nal
Def
endant
.No.
1)
3.
WebDesi
gnerLt
d.
(
Or
i
gi
nal
Def
endantNo.
2)
4.
Keny
aTour
sPv
t
.Lt
d.
(
Or
i
gi
nal
Def
endant
.No.
4)
…Respondent
s
(
I
nt
hi
snot
e,par
t
i
esar
er
ef
er
r
edt
oast
heyappear
edbef
or
et
het
r
i
alcour
ti
n
t
hepl
ai
nt
)
 Thepl
ai
nt
i
f
fcl
ai
mst
obeat
r
av
eloper
at
ormai
nt
ai
ni
nggl
obalr
eser
v
at
i
on
sy
st
em donet
hr
oughi
t
spr
oduct“
j
our
ney
.
com”
.Accor
di
ngt
ot
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
,
i
ti
s engaged i
nB t
o B busi
ness model
,v
i
z
.i
tdeal
s wi
t
h onl
yt
he
r
egi
st
er
edagent
sandnotgener
alpubl
i
c.Thepl
ai
nt
i
f
fcl
ai
mst
hati
thas
busi
nessi
nAsi
aPaci
f
i
cRegi
on.Accor
di
ngt
ot
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
,i
ti
si
nt
ot
he
busi
ness si
nce 1999.I
thas dev
el
oped t
wo t
r
ademar
ks – “
Wonder
Hol
i
day
sGr
oup”and“
j
our
ney
.
com”
,
andhasbeenusi
ngt
hem si
nce2007.
Accor
di
ngt
ot
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
,i
thasappl
i
edf
ort
her
egi
st
r
at
i
onoft
hesai
d
Tr
adeMar
ksundercl
ass39,
9and16i
n201516,
andnoopposi
t
i
onsar
e
r
ecei
v
edandt
het
r
ademar
ksar
er
egi
st
er
ed.Ther
ef
or
e,t
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fi
st
he
r
egi
st
er
ed pr
opr
i
et
or of t
he sai
dt
r
ademar
ks and t
her
ef
or
e,si
nce
accor
di
ngt
ot
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
,t
hedef
endant
s(
mor
epar
t
i
cul
ar
l
ydef
endant
no.
3) ar
e usi
ng t
hei
rwebsi
t
es / domai
n names i
nt
he name of
“
www.
wonder
hol
i
day
s.
com.
ca”
and
“
www.
pl
anj
our
ney
.
com”
, t
he
def
endant
sar
ei
nf
r
i
ngi
ngi
t
st
r
ademar
ks.
 I
nsof
arast
hedef
endantno.
1and2ar
econcer
ned,def
endantno.
2i
sa
companypr
ov
i
di
ngwebhost
i
ngser
v
i
ces,
sof
t
war
esol
ut
i
onsandpr
ov
i
des
l
i
cenci
ng sof
t
war
e,wher
eas def
endantno.
1i
s Managi
ng Di
r
ect
orof
def
endantno.
2.I
ti
st
hecaseofdef
endantnos.1and2t
hati
nv
i
ew of
sof
t
war
e agr
eementent
er
ed i
nt
o bet
ween def
endantno.
2 and one
WonderHol
i
day
sCanada(
si
gnedbyMrNei
lJacobasi
t
sDi
r
ect
or
)
,t
he
def
endantno.
2hascr
eat
edwebpagef
orWonderHol
i
day
sCanada.Apar
t
f
r
om t
hi
s,t
heyhav
enor
ol
et
opl
ayi
nt
heent
i
r
edi
sput
e.Ther
ef
or
e,t
hey
hav
ef
i
l
edanappl
i
cat
i
onf
ordel
et
i
onoft
hei
rnamesasdef
endant
si
nt
he
sui
t
.Theyhav
eal
sof
i
l
edr
epl
yt
ot
hei
nj
unct
i
onappl
i
cat
i
onaswel
las
wr
i
t
t
enst
at
ementt
opl
ai
nt
,
mor
eorl
essr
ai
si
ngt
hesamecont
ent
i
ons,
as
r
ai
sedi
nt
heappl
i
cat
i
onf
ordel
et
i
on.
 Thedef
endantNo.
3i
st
heDi
r
ect
orofoneWonderHol
i
day
sCanada
(
Canadi
anent
i
t
y
)
.Thedef
endantno.3i
sappar
ent
l
yj
oi
nedasadef
endant
on t
he basi
s t
hat t
he appl
i
cat
i
on f
or websi
t
e r
egi
st
r
at
i
on f
or
“
wonder
hol
i
day
s.
com.
ca”and“
pl
anj
our
ney
.
com”wasmadebyhi
m.The
def
endantno.4hasbeenj
oi
nedasdef
endantonl
yont
hebasi
st
hatwhi
l
e
appl
y
i
ngf
orwebsi
t
er
egi
st
r
at
i
on,t
hedef
endantno.3–MrNei
lJacob–
hadgi
v
enhi
semai
li
d(
nj
@keny
at
our
s.
com)ast
he“
Regi
st
r
antemai
li
d”
,
si
ncebef
or
ej
oi
ni
ngt
heCanadi
anent
i
t
y
,hewaswor
ki
ngwi
t
hKeny
a
Tour
s,andbymi
st
akehement
i
onedhi
sol
demai
li
dwi
t
h“
Keny
at
our
s”
suf
f
i
xwhi
l
eappl
y
i
ngf
orwebsi
t
er
egi
st
r
at
i
onf
ort
heCanadi
anent
i
t
y
.
 I
nt
hepl
ai
ntaswel
lasi
nj
unct
i
onappl
i
cat
i
on,pl
ai
nt
i
f
fhasasser
t
edt
hat
t
he domai
n name “
pl
anj
our
ney
.
com”has been r
egi
st
er
ed byWonder
Hol
i
day
sCanada.Si
mi
l
ar
l
ydomai
nname“
www.
wonder
hol
i
day
s.
com.
ca”
i
sal
sor
egi
st
er
edbyt
heCanadi
anent
i
t
y
.I
nt
hepl
ai
nt
,t
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fv
er
y
v
aguel
yr
ef
er
st
osomeor
alagr
eementbet
weenpl
ai
nt
i
f
fanddef
endant
no.
3,al
l
egedl
yexecut
edi
n2012,f
orr
unni
nganent
i
t
ycal
l
ed“
Wonder
Hol
i
day
sCA”i
nCanada.
 I
nsof
arasdocument
spr
oducedbyt
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fal
ongwi
t
ht
hepl
ai
ntar
e
concer
ned,pl
ai
nt
i
f
fhaspr
oduced TM1 For
m f
ort
r
ademar
k“
Wonder
Hol
i
day
sGr
oup”
,whi
chi
smer
el
yanappl
i
cat
i
onf
orr
egi
st
r
at
i
on.Thesai
d
t
r
ade mar
k has noty
etbeen r
egi
st
er
ed.The second Tr
ade Mar
k
“
j
our
ney
.
com”i
sadmi
t
t
edl
yr
egi
st
er
ed.
 Wi
t
ht
he sai
d back gr
ound,t
he pl
ai
nt
i
f
fhas pr
ay
ed f
orper
manent
i
nj
unct
i
on agai
nstdef
endant
sf
r
om i
nf
r
i
ngi
ng t
he t
r
ademar
ks oft
he
pl
ai
nt
i
f
fbei
ng“
WonderHol
i
day
sGr
oup”and“
j
our
ney
.
com”byusi
ngt
he
sai
dt
r
ademar
kofot
herdecept
i
v
el
ysi
mi
l
armar
kandi
ncl
udi
ngbutnot
l
i
mi
t
edt
o“
wonder
hol
i
day
s.
com.
ca”and“
pl
anj
our
ney
.
com”
.I
thasal
so
soughtper
manenti
nj
unct
i
on agai
nstdef
endant
sf
r
om i
nf
r
i
ngi
ng t
he
t
r
ademar
ksoft
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fandf
r
om passi
ngof
ft
hei
rser
v
i
cesast
hoseof
t
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
’
s.Pr
ay
erseeki
ngaccount
sanddamagest
ot
het
uneofRs.50
cr
or
esar
eal
sosought
.
 I
nt
he appl
i
cat
i
on ori
nt
er
i
m i
nj
unct
i
on,t
he pl
ai
nt
i
f
fhas pr
ay
ed f
or
t
empor
ar
yi
nj
unct
i
onagai
nstdef
endant
sf
r
om i
nf
r
i
ngi
ngt
het
r
ademar
ks
oft
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fbei
ng“
WonderHol
i
day
sGr
oup”and“
j
our
ney
.
com”byusi
ng
t
hesai
dt
r
ademar
kofot
herdecept
i
v
el
ysi
mi
l
armar
kandi
ncl
udi
ngbutnot
l
i
mi
t
edt
o“
wonder
hol
i
day
s.
com.
ca”and“
pl
anj
our
ney
.
com”
.I
thasal
so
soughtt
empor
ar
yi
nj
unct
i
on agai
nstdef
endant
sf
r
om i
nf
r
i
ngi
ng t
he
t
r
ademar
ksoft
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fandf
r
om passi
ngof
ft
hei
rser
v
i
cesast
hoseof
t
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
’
s.Pr
ay
erf
ordest
r
uct
i
onofal
lmar
ket
i
ngmat
er
i
al
,st
amps,
st
at
i
oner
y
,
i
nv
oi
ces,
et
c.bear
i
ngt
het
r
ademar
ks“
wonder
hol
i
day
s.
com.
ca”
and“
pl
anj
our
ney
.
com”i
sal
sosought
.
 Thepl
ai
nt
i
f
fhascont
endedt
hatsi
ncebot
ht
hewebsi
t
esi
ndi
sput
ear
e
accessi
bl
ef
r
om Pandor
aandt
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
fcompanybei
ngr
egi
st
er
edi
n
Pandor
a,t
he l
ocalci
v
i
lcour
toft
he ci
t
yhas j
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
on t
ot
r
yand
ent
er
t
ai
nt
hesui
t
.
 Uponbei
ngser
v
edwi
t
ht
hesummonsoft
heCour
t
,asi
ndi
cat
edabov
e,
t
hedef
endantnos.1–2hav
ef
i
l
edt
hei
rr
epl
yandwr
i
t
t
enst
at
ementt
o
t
hei
nj
unct
i
onappl
i
cat
i
onandt
hepl
ai
ntr
espect
i
v
el
y
.Theyhav
eal
sof
i
l
ed
anappl
i
cat
i
onf
ordel
et
i
onoft
hem asdef
endant
sf
r
om t
hesui
tont
he
gr
oundt
hatt
heyhav
enot
hi
ngt
odowi
t
ht
hedi
sput
ebet
weent
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
andt
her
estoft
hedef
endant
sort
heCanadi
anent
i
t
yandt
her
ei
sno
causeofact
i
onagai
nstt
hem ast
heyar
enotusi
ngt
hedi
sput
edwebsi
t
es
/domai
nnames.Thi
sappl
i
cat
i
oni
spendi
ng.
 Thedef
endantno.4hasbeenser
v
edandi
thasal
sof
i
l
edanappl
i
cat
i
on
f
ordel
et
i
onofi
t
snameasdef
endantont
hegr
oundt
hatdef
endantno.
4
hasnot
hi
ngt
odowi
t
ht
hedi
sput
eand/
ort
het
r
ademar
ksi
nquest
i
on.I
t
hasbeenj
oi
nedonl
yont
hebasi
sofmi
st
akeofdef
endantno.
3whi
l
e
appl
y
i
ngf
orwebsi
t
e/domai
nnamer
egi
st
r
at
i
on,
wher
ei
nhehasgi
v
enhi
s
ol
demai
li
dcont
ai
ni
ngnameofdef
endantno.
4,si
ncebef
or
ej
oi
ni
ngt
he
Canadi
anent
i
t
y
,
def
endantno.
3waswor
ki
ngwi
t
hdef
endantno.
4andhad
anemai
li
dwi
t
ht
henameofdef
endantno.
4i
ni
t
.Thi
sappl
i
cat
i
oni
s
pendi
ng.
 Thedef
endantno.
3hasbeenser
v
edwi
t
ht
hesummonsoft
heCour
t
t
hr
oughemai
landbyPostatCanada.Hehasf
i
l
edhi
swr
i
t
t
enst
at
ement
t
ot
hePl
ai
ntaswel
lasr
epl
yt
oi
nj
unct
i
onappl
i
cat
i
on.Hehasal
sof
i
l
edan
appl
i
cat
i
onunderOr
derVI
IRul
e11oft
heCodeofCi
v
i
lPr
ocedur
e,1908
(
CPC)f
orr
ej
ect
i
onoft
hepl
ai
ntonv
ar
i
ousl
egalgr
ounds,aswi
l
lbe
i
ndi
ct
edher
ei
naf
t
er
.Hehasmai
nl
ycont
endedt
hatt
hepl
ai
nti
sdev
oi
dof
mer
i
t
sandsuf
f
er
sf
r
om gr
osssuppr
essi
on.Thepl
ai
nt
i
f
fhassuppr
essed
t
hatoneofi
t
sownDi
r
ect
or
sMrJPi
soneoft
hePar
t
ner
/
Di
r
ect
oroft
he
Canadi
anent
i
t
y
.I
nf
actt
heCanadi
anent
i
t
ywasi
ncor
por
at
edwi
t
hhi
s
v
i
si
onofexpandi
ngt
hebusi
nessofWonderHol
i
day
si
nCanada.MrJP
cont
i
nuest
obe25% st
akehol
deri
nCanadi
anent
i
t
y
.I
ti
st
hecaseof
def
endantno.
3t
hatt
het
wowebsi
t
es/domai
nnamesoft
heCanadi
an
ent
i
t
ywer
eappl
i
edwi
t
ht
heexpr
essconsentandknowl
edgeofMrJP.I
t
i
sonl
ybecauseofsomei
nt
er
nalf
i
nancer
el
at
eddi
sput
et
hatt
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
f
t
hr
oughot
herDi
r
ect
orhasf
i
l
edt
hesui
t
.
 I
ti
st
hecaseofdef
endantno.
3t
hatt
hel
ogo,
st
at
i
oner
y
,
et
c.
,
ofCanadi
an
ent
i
t
ywer
eal
ldesi
gnedbyt
het
eam ofMrJP.Fur
t
her
,t
heCanadi
an
ent
i
t
y
’
sst
at
i
oner
yandwebsi
t
econt
ai
nst
henameandwebsi
t
eofWonder
Hol
i
day
s and si
mi
l
ar
l
y
,t
he websi
t
e and st
at
i
oner
y
,et
c.ofWonder
Hol
i
day
scont
ai
nt
henameofCanadi
anent
i
t
yasi
t
sgr
oupCompany
.
 I
ti
sal
socont
endedt
hatoneoft
het
wot
r
ademar
ksi
sunr
egi
st
er
edmar
k,
and hence,t
he pr
ay
er
s pr
i
mar
i
l
y soughtf
ori
nf
r
i
ngementar
e not
mai
nt
ai
nabl
e.I
ti
sf
ur
t
hercont
endedt
hatt
heent
i
t
y
,whi
chi
sadmi
t
t
edl
y
usi
ngt
hewebsi
t
es/domai
nnames,
andwhoi
st
he“
Owner
”oft
hesame,
i
snotj
oi
nedasadef
endanti
nt
hesui
t
.Hence,t
hesui
ti
sal
sobadi
nl
aw
i
nv
i
ew ofnonj
oi
nderaswel
lasmi
sj
oi
nderofnecessar
yandpr
oper
par
t
y
.Pr
i
mecont
ent
i
onofl
ackofj
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
onoft
hel
ocal
t
r
i
al
cour
ti
sal
so
r
ai
sed.I
ti
s cont
ended t
hatf
ort
he r
egi
st
er
ed t
r
ademar
k,assumi
ng
wi
t
houtadmi
t
t
i
ng,t
hei
nf
r
i
ngementi
scommi
t
t
edbyaCanadi
anent
i
t
y
,
whi
ch i
s notj
oi
ned i
nt
he sui
tand t
he l
ocalcour
twoul
d nothav
e
j
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
on ov
ert
he sai
d ent
i
t
y
.I
nsof
arast
he unr
egi
st
er
ed mar
ki
s
concer
ned,t
hecauseofact
i
onhasnotar
i
senwi
t
hi
nt
hel
ocall
i
mi
toft
he
t
r
i
alcour
t
,
andt
her
ef
or
eal
so,
t
hesui
ti
snotmai
nt
ai
nabl
e.I
ti
scont
ended
t
hatmer
ei
nt
er
act
i
v
i
t
yofanywebsi
t
ewoul
dnotconf
erj
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
ont
oa
par
t
i
cul
arcour
t
,unl
essi
ti
sshownt
hatany“
commer
ci
alt
r
ansact
i
on”
f
r
om suchwebsi
t
ehasact
ual
l
yt
akenpl
acewi
t
hi
nt
hej
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
onoft
hat
par
t
i
cul
arcour
t
.
 TheHon.Tr
i
alCour
thasgr
ant
edanexpar
t
est
ayagai
nstdef
endant
s
r
est
r
ai
ni
ngt
hem f
r
om usi
ngt
hewebsi
t
es/domai
nnamesi
nquest
i
on.
Hence,
t
heDef
endantNo.
3haspr
ef
er
r
edAppealagai
nstOr
derbef
or
et
he
Hi
ghCour
t
,
whi
chi
spendi
ng.
Poi
nt
st
obeconsi
der
ed:
1.
Cant
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
ff
i
l
eacomposi
t
esui
tf
or(
i
)i
nf
r
i
ngementofi
t
s
r
egi
st
er
edt
r
ademar
kand(
i
i
)passi
ngof
fofanunr
egi
st
er
edmar
k?Can
t
hi
sbesai
dt
obe“
bar
r
edbyl
aw”
?
2.
Cant
heCour
ti
nPandor
ahav
ej
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
ont
ot
r
yandent
er
t
ai
nasui
tf
or
passi
ngof
fofanunr
egi
st
er
edmar
k,
whi
chi
sappar
ent
l
ydonebyan
ent
i
t
yi
nCanada?
3.
Cant
hepl
ai
nt
i
f
ff
i
l
easui
tagai
nstanent
i
t
y(
orj
oi
ni
ti
npendi
ngsui
t
)
r
egi
st
er
edundert
hel
awsofCanadaal
l
egi
ngi
nf
r
i
ngement
?
4.
Cant
hePl
ai
nt
i
f
ff
i
l
easui
ti
nPandor
aonl
ysi
ncei
ti
sr
esi
di
ng/car
r
y
i
ng
outi
t
sbusi
nessi
nAhmedabadt
houghnocauseofact
i
onhasaccr
ued
i
nt
her
e?CanSec.
134Tr
adeMar
kAct
,
1999bei
nv
okedwi
t
houtany
causeofact
i
on?
5.
Cant
heCour
ti
nPandor
ahav
ej
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
ont
ot
r
yandent
er
t
ai
nasui
tf
or
i
nf
r
i
ngementoft
r
ademar
kwher
ei
nf
r
i
ngementi
sal
l
egedonl
yont
he
basi
sofanonl
i
newebsi
t
e(
i
nt
er
act
i
v
i
t
ynotal
l
eged)wi
t
houtt
her
ebei
ng
anyi
nst
anceofcommer
ci
al
t
r
ansact
i
on?(
r
ef
erBany
anTr
eej
udgment
)
6.
Cant
hedef
endantt
akedef
enceof“
deemedl
i
cense”i
nt
hegi
v
enf
act
s
ofcasewher
epl
ai
nt
i
f
fandCanadi
anent
i
t
yhasbeenwor
ki
ngi
npastas
gr
oupcompani
es?(
CommonDi
r
ect
orandnamesonst
at
i
oner
y
)
7.
Cant
heCour
ti
nPandor
ahasi
t
sj
ur
i
sdi
ct
i
onov
erCanadi
anent
i
t
yi
n
casei
ti
sf
oundt
hati
ti
sv
i
ol
at
i
ngt
heor
derpassedbyt
heCour
t
?
8.
I
st
hesui
tmai
nt
ai
nabl
ewhent
heent
i
t
yal
l
egedl
yi
nf
r
i
ngi
ngt
r
ademar
k
(
orpassi
ngof
f
)i
snotj
oi
nedasadef
endant
?
NOTE:
LawsofSt
at
eofHomel
andi
sPar
i
Mat
er
i
at
oLawsofI
ndi
a.
Knowl
edgePar
t
ner
: