THE DEVELOPMENT AND IMPLEMENTATION OF CODES AND STANDARDS FOR ENGINEERING PRACTICE: THE ROLE OF STANDARDS ORGANISATION OF NIGERIA & OTHER STAKEHOLDERS By Chinyere V Egwuonwu (Mrs.) Director, Standards Development Standards Organisation of Nigeria At a One Day Virtual Seminar organised by the NSE Codes And Standards Committee on 10th July 2010 OUTLINE SEMINAR OBJECTIVES INTRODUCTION STANDARDS ORGANISATION OF NIGERIA IN BRIEF SON- AS AN ESTABLISHED NATIONAL STANDARDS BODY (NSB) THE CHARACTERISTICS OF THE STANDARDS WE DEVELOP THE NIGERIAN INDUSTRIAL STANDARDS (NIS) WHAT IS A STANDARD? BENEFITS OF STANDARDS PRINCIPLES OF GOOD STANDARDISATION PRACTICE HOW ARE STANDARDS DEVELOPED AND STRUCTURED? WHO MAKES STANDARDS? STANDARDS REVIEW WHAT IS STANDARD ADOPTION? PARTICIPATING IN THE DEVELOPMENT OF INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS ROLE OF SON IN IMPLEMENTATION OF CODES AND STANDARDS FOR ENGINEERING PRACTICE - SON CERTIFICATION SCHEMES ROLE OF STAKEHOLDERS - How to Get Involved CONCLUSION Seminar Objectives Understand the role of SON as a National standards Body with the mandate of developing National Standards The role of stakeholders in the standards development and implementation To understand what a standard is, the different types of standards and different levels of standards development Understand the Stages of developing a National (formal) standard To Acquaint participants with the Review of a standard, adoption of international or regional standards as national standards is all about and what is expected of us as standards developers in adopting international standards as national standards . INTRODUCTION • Standards affects all aspects of our every day life • Develop standards to ensure orderliness in a given context everyday life • The importance of a National Standards Body that would coordinate the development of National standards and ensure the availability of National Standards for implementation in a country can not be overemphasised • Standards in Everyday Life STANDARDS ORGANISATION OF NIGERIA IN BRIEF Standards Organisation Of Nigeria ( referred to as “SON”): Established as a National Standards Body in 1971 by an Enabling Act No 56 of 1971. With several amendments Repealed and re-enacted and currently the SON Act of 2015 Is a government Parastatal under the Federal Ministry of Industry, Trade and Investment Governed by a Governing body known as Standards Council of Nigeria(commonly referred to as “the Council”) SON IN BRIEF (contd) SON Cooperate Headquarters Abuja SON Operational Headquarters Lagos State Offices SON Has 33 state offices covering the 36 States of the Federation & FCT Coordinated by the Regional offices in the six geopolitical zones STANDARDS ORGANISATION OF NIGERIA IN BRIEF Cont’d The Responsibilities of SON amongst others are: To develop Standards relating Products, materials, measurements, Processes and Services Promotion of these standards at national, regional and international levels To ensure that locally manufactured or imported products and services comply with the requirements of the relevant Standards through Conformity Assessment activities. Establish and maintain Laboratories Establish and Maintain National Metrology Institute Maintain and circulate information relating to standards Advice government at all levels on matters relating to standardisation It is Nigeria’s Representative ,National Secretariat and member of International Standardization Bodies such as ISO, IEC, Codex Alimentarius, ARSO, AFRAC, AFSEC, AFRIMET, ECOWAS etc . SON in Brief (contd ) - Awareness And Collaboration Promotion of these standards at national, regional and international level • Membership African Organisation for Standardisation Codex Alimentarius Commission International Electrochemical Commission International Telecommunication Union International Organisation for Standardisation MoUs , MRAs with other International Standardisation organisations WTO/TBT Desk – National Enquiry on TBT • Membership /Agreements allow and permits the adoption (identical and modified) of standards that are elaborated by the above International organisations SON- As an Established National Standards Body (NSB) – The Standards Development SON is the organization most representative of standardisation in Nigeria → National standards Our standards development activities are demand-driven and are developed according to international fundamental principles of good standardisation practice articulated by the WTO, ISO IEC DIRECIVES Parts 1 and 2 Development of National Standards is Committee Driven through National Technical Committees (sub committees, working groups) SON is the secretariat of these committees – coordinates and facilitates the activities SON Oversees / coordinates other standards development organisations (SDOs) (mandated by our SON Act) Publishes & maintains National standards known as Nigerian Industrial Standards (NIS) (Maintain and circulate information relating to standards Represents country in regional / international standardization organizations Independence Operates without undue political influence Departments and services in SON • • • • • • • • • • • • Standards Development Product Certification Management System Certification Laboratory Services Operations Inspectorate & Compliance Monitoring Metrology and Instrumentation Planning, Research and Statistics Finance & Accounts Human Resources Management Legal Services Corporate Affairs &SON Consult SON CERTIFICATION SCHEMES Standards Development Preparation of Standards Relating To Products, Process, Materials, Measurement Among Others SON develops National standards through the Standards Development Directorate Standards Development Directorate: Functions in specialised Groups viz Chemical Technology Civil/Building Engineering Electrical/Electronics Food Technology/Agriculture Liquefied Petroleum Gas Mechanical Engineering Textile and Leather Service Standards The Characteristics of the Standards we develop Voluntary in participation and market driven – every interested party can participate in the making of a standard and provide comments when a standard is submitted to public consultation. The decision to develop new standards is driven by market needs/requests. Develop according to international fundamental principles of good standardisation practice articulated by the WTO. Strict Adherence to the internationally acceptable principles of standard elaboration Consensus based – all standards are subject to dialogue in order to establish general agreement and consesnus of opinion based on scientific and technical data. Strong stakeholders’ engagement. Approved by a recognized body – the Standards Council of Nigeria Nigerian Industrial Standards (NIS) As an NSB, Formal recognition to produce formal Standards We develop Formal standards (De jure (according to law) – National Standards known as Nigerian Industrial Standards (NIS) National, not SON, Standards (Nigerian Industrial Standard (NIS)) Industrial standards other than those established under section 23 of this Act, shall not be called·Nigerian Industrial Standards. (section 24,subsection 2 SON ACT 2015) Precise, authoritative, concise, consensus and formal document approved by the SON Council Basic support for industrialization, trade, economic growth and market development; Recognised means for assuring quality, safety, interoperability and reliability of products, processes and services; Technical basis for procurement(government); Technical support for appropriate regulation; What is a Standard? Learning Objectives • To understand what a standard is. • To get knowledge of the difference between national, regional and international standards • To be able to differentiate between different types of standards including de jure and de facto standards. Definition of a Standard There are many definitions of a standard. The one used in the formal standardisation system is: • A document, established by consensus and approved by a recognized body, that provides, for common and repeated use, rules, guidelines or characteristics for activities or their results, aimed at the achievement of the optimum degree of order in a given context. [ISO/IEC Guide 2:2004, definition 3.2] • Standards should be based on the consolidated results of science, technology and experience, and aimed at the promotion of optimum community benefits What is a standard? : It is a document : established by all interested parties reflects consensus approved by a recognised body meant for common and repeated use Developed at various levels : – -International Standards, -Regional Standards -National Standards Standards at these three levels are developed by recognized official standardisation organisations. De jure and de facto standards • De jure (according to law) standards • Formal standards – standards developed by official standardization organizations. These organizations can be international (like ISO, and IEC), regional (like the European ARSO,CEN, CENELEC, ETSI) or national (like SON, BSI, GSA,AFNOR, DIN, etc.) and have been given formal recognition to produce formal standards. • De facto standards • The remaining group of standards, i.e. standards that are not developed by one of the above-mentioned recognized bodies. These are standards that have gained currency over time e.g. music notes. Other de facto standards could be a result of one or more companies products where the products become the ‘standard’ on the market. Types of standards Different types of standards fulfill different needs • Basic standard: covers wide range aspects or a general provision of a particular fields - e.g. SI units (International System for units). • Product standard: that specifies requirements to be fulfilled by a product or a group of products, to establish its fitness for purpose e.g. toys, electrical equipment, • Methods/Testing standard: concerned with tests may contain other provisions related to testing, e.g. sampling, use of statistical methods, sequence of tests • Terminology: concerned with terms accompanied by their definitions, and sometimes by explanatory notes, illustrations, examples– e.g. definitions of main terms within different fields. • Code of practice - a type of standard that document that recommends practices or procedures for the design, manufacture, installation, maintenance or utilization of equipment, structures or products. • Symbols – e.g. pictograms, symbols for machines, conveniences etc • Management systems/Service standard: • Management systems e.g. quality, risk, energy or environmental management. • Service standards may be prepared in fields such as laundering, hotelkeeping, transport, car-servicing, telecommunications, insurance, banking, trading The Benefits of Standards Illustration of the common benefits of a standard and standardization in general PRINCIPLES OF GOOD STANDARDISATION PRACTICE Learning Objectives To understand the Principles of Good Standardisation Practice To Acquaint participants with how SON is adhering to and complying with these Principles To understand the role of the stakeholders in achieving these principles. PRINCIPLES OF GOOD STANDARDISATION PRACTICE Certain fundamental principles: Are maintained during standardisation activities. Have been articulated by several organisations such as the WTO. Formal international /regional/national standards, such as those from ISO and SON are prepared following such principles. PRINCIPLES OF GOOD STANDARDISATION PRACTICE To ensure that international /regional/national standards (ISO, IEC, CODEX, NIS) have global relevance and acceptance worldwide International /regional/national standards are developed according to good standardization practice. As an ISO member, we are a part of this good practice. We follow ISO rules, involve stakeholders, and are able to implement and adopt ISO standards This means that, to develop standards, you need to have standards systems and processes in your national standards body in line with the good standardisation principles PRINCIPLES OF GOOD STANDARDISATION PRACTICE • These key principles of good standardisation practice are: Transparency; Openness; Impartiality Consensus and Stakeholders’ Engagement; Effectiveness and Relevance; Coherence; 1 Transparency: All essential information regarding: current work programmes, as well as on proposals for standards, guides and recommendations under consideration and on the final results should be made easily accessible to at least all interested parties(including all WTO Members) Regularly updated information is easily accessible in due time to allow all parties, including stakeholders, to participate in the standardization process if they want to. Access to the contributions of all other parties actively involved in the standardization work. Established a WTO/TBT DESK Upload on our website,(SOP, work plan, catalogue) Strategic business plan NNSS 2 Openness: This includes openness without discrimination with respect to the participation at every stage of standards development. Shall allow a specifies period (of at least 30 days) for the submission of comments on the draft standard by interested parties within the territory of a Member of the WTO this means giving equal opportunity and timing to all stakeholders Membership of Technical Committee should be open on a non-discriminatory basis to relevant stakeholders. Our National Technical Committees are opened to all relevant /interested stakeholders We ensure participation of stakeholders at every stage starting from the drafting of the committee draft to enquiry stage to TC and final approval by theTC Chair We allow enquiry period of 30 days 3 Impartiality The standard development process will not give privilege to, or favour the interests of, a particular group supplier/s, country (ies) or region/s. All relevant stakeholders/bodies should be provided with meaningful opportunities to contribute to the elaboration of standards. Enquiry stage , TC meetings Consensus General agreement characterized by the absence of sustained opposition to substantial issues by any important part of the concerned interests and by a process that involves seeking to take into account the views of all parties concerned and to reconcile any conflicting arguments Consensus procedures should be established that seek to take into account the view of all parties concerned and to reconcile any conflicting arguments make every effort to achieve a national consensus on standards we develop Stakeholder Engagement All parties participate in decision making. All views are sought and parties involved in coming to decisions General agreement as to the outcome which results in better acceptance of the result (TC, TC CHAIR APPROVAL, APPEAL) STANDARDS DIRECTORATE SECRETARIAT 5 Effectiveness and relevance: In order to facilitate both local and international trade and preventing unnecessary trade barriers, standards need to be relevant and to effectively respond to regulatory , market/industry needs, as well as scientific and technological developments The relevance of standards is ensured by an efficient standardization work, i.e.: when the expected deliverables are produced within the set deadlines/Timelines and are costs effective Demand driven, Review for adequacy we have set Timelines for each stage of the standards development stage and abide by the ISO directives part 1) Strategic business plan NNSS 6 Coherence: In order to avoid the development of conflicting international /national standards, it is important that international or national standardizing bodies avoid duplication of, or overlap with, the work of other international standardizing bodies. In this respect, cooperation and coordination with other relevant standards development organisation/bodies is essential. collaborating with sectorial associations, professional bodies in the development of standards eg NSEs In line with SON Act 2015 (section 5 subsection 2) “For the purposes of uniformity of standards in Nigeria, all regulatory Agencies or Organisations dealing with matters pertaining to or related to standards shall do so in collaboration with SON” HOW ARE STANDARDS DEVELOPED AND STRUCTURED? Who Makes Standards? Standardisation is open to anyone. Standards are developed by groups of experts called Technical Committees - stakeholder committees representing the interests of all those who will be (or are likely to be..) affected by the standards. Technical Committees(sub committees, working groups) - group of relevant experts and other stakeholders in the public and private sector charged with the responsibility of formulating our National Standards) - consumers, manufacturers Govt Agencies, the Academia , research institutes, NGO, The easiest way to find out and to get involved in standardisation is to contact your National Standardisation Organization - SON Technical committee TC members: interested stakeholders nominated by their organisations, companies, groups to represent them at the TC. TC Chair: The chair of a Technical committee is elected by the members of the TC and is responsible for the overall management of the technical committee, including any subcommittees and working groups The secretariat of a Technical Committee: provides technical and administrative services to allocated technical committee or subcommittee How are Standards Made? Standards elaboration involves a lot of activities starting from the identification of the need for a standard (initiation) to the drafting, to the phase of a Public Enquiry, Technical Committee, approval by the Standards Council of Nigeria, publishing and finally, the implementation of a standard. SON standards development processes are guided by the WTO/TBT agreement and ISO/IEC Directives Parts1(Procedures for the technical work ) ad 2(Rules for the structure and drafting of International Standards). Revising a standard is also part of the lifecycle of a standard. The Technical Committee makes sure that a standard is up-to-date Stages in developing a Nigerian Industrial Standards (NIS) Stage 1 Stage 2 Stage 3 Stage 4 Proposal stage - Initiation of the need for a standard (Needs may be identified by any of the stakeholders (from government, individual or public , private organisation sectorial groups. Approval of new work Preparatory stage - The preparatory stage covers he preparation of a working draft (WD) by the Technical Secretary Committee draft stage – development of the committee draft (CD) by working group (comprising of some relevant experts/stakeholders and SON). Enquiry - circulation of the enquiry draft (DNIS) to all stakeholders for 30 days using Comment Template. Wide circulation as much as possible (not only to TC members) Collation of comments from stakeholders Stage 5 Technical Committee meeting (– Round table meeting for consensus on the draft standard. Approval by the TC Chairman) Stage 6 Editing by the Editorial Committee Stage 7 Approval stage - Approval by Standards Council of Nigeria Stage 9 Publishing How Standards are Structured? • One important feature of de jure standards is that they are all structured in the same way. This makes it much easier to get an overview of, and to find specific information in a standard. Standards Review Is the activity of checking a standard to determine whether it is to be reaffirmed, changed or withdrawn Standards are reviewed after 5 years inline with ISO and SON Act Why are standards reviewed? Standards are reviewed: To ensure that the standard is still adequate Due to change in Government policy When standard is noted to be defective Due to change in technology/process. The review may lead to the revision of the standard or its withdrawal What is Standard Adoption? Standards adoption What is Standards adoption ? This is the process of acquiring an existing national , regional, or international standard as Nigerian Industrial standard with or without amendment to the original standard. This is normally done when the requirement of the standard suits our local environment The adoption of an International Standard is defined as: “The publication of a regional or national normative document based on a relevant International Standard, or endorsement of the International Standard as having the same status as a national normative document, with any deviations from the International Standard identified” (ISO/IEC Guide 21-1 (Adapted from ISO/IEC Guide 2:2004, 10.1.) Why adopt international standards? • Improves quality of local products/produce and services • Enhances market competiveness of the products both locally and internationally. • Constitutes important basis for the removal of technical barriers to trade. Therefore, Promotes export of products • Protects the country against the practice of dumping of sub standard products. • Reliable basis for technological transfer and industrial development What to consider before adopting a standard International standards to be adopted for national use shall comply with the following: Not dependent on indigenous technology Not dependent on climatic conditions Not dependent on trade practices Not in conflict with statutory regulatory requirements Types of Adoption (Identifying the degree of correspondence) ISO/IEC Guide 21 defines three degrees of correspondence between an International Standard and adopting regional or national standard Identical adoption Identical in technical content, structure and wording (or is an identical translation ) Can contain certain defined minimal editorial changes (eg substitution of a decimal comma by a decimal point; correction such as spelling errors or pagination changes ) Modified adoption Can contain technical deviations (changes introduced in the adopting regional or national standard), which are clearly identified and explained Changes to the structure of the standard must be limited so that an easy comparison is possible between the adopting regional or national standard and the International Standard Not equivalent Not equivalent in content and structure, technical deviations identified are not clearly Degrees of correspondence Identical Adoption Modified Adoption Not equivalent No adoption A regional or national standard, which has a degree of correspondence to the International Standard identified as “not equivalent” IS NOT an adoption THEREFORE: An International Standard is considered to have been adopted when the regional or national standard is identical or modified in relation to the International Standard. Methods of indicating technical deviations and editorial changes The regional or national standards should include an explanation using a regional or national introduction or preface or foreword Note that where technical deviations (and reasons for them) or editorial changes are few, they may be placed in the regional or national introduction or preface or foreword, But where the text is large they can be placed as an annex which will be refrenced in the foreword We use NATIONAL FOREWORD Content of a National Foreword A national foreword may contain information or instructions pertinent to the national adoption of the standard. Such information would normally include the following: The status of adoption (whether identical or modified) The original parent publication title and reference number of the international standard(with the year of publication), e.g. ISO 9001:2015, Quality management systems — Requirements The name of the National Technical Committee responsible for the adoption of the standard. Where it applies, details of editorial changes; Where it applies, the technical deviations and changes in structure, together with the explanations of why they have been made (reasons for them), and how they are identified in the text. ( or reference to the annex giving this information). Participating in the development of international Standards International Standardisation Activities • Involved in International Standards Development at ISO, IEC, CODEX. • Use Natiomal Experts • National Mirror/Technical Committees • The National Mirror Committee are expected to articulate the views of the industries and regulators from Nigeria and canvas it through its national delegates to the technical committee, subcommittee or workgroups meetings • Articulate and ensure inputs in developing international standards • Adopt International Standards (identical or modified) Harmonisation of standards • Harmonized standards - equivalent standards on the same subject approved by different National standardizing bodies. • Harmonisation of standards within ECOWAS • Harmonisation of standards within Africa • In both where there are international standards of interest we adopt such • Adopt the harmonised standards and withdraw conflicting National standards. • Participated actively in formulating the ECOWAS quality policy • AfCFTA – working hard to ensure standards of interest to our stakeholders are presented for harmonisation – Nigerian National Standardisation Strategy Role of SON in implementation of Codes and Standards for Engineering practice - SON CERTIFICATION SCHEMES Ensure locally manufactured or imported products and services comply with the requirements of the relevant Standards through Conformity Assessment activities.(SON ACT OF 2015) PRODUCT CERTIFICATION SCHEMES Product certification Directorate - Is in the process of achieving accreditation to ISO/IEC 7065 The main product certification schemes operated by SON: Mandatory conformity Assessment Programme (MANCAP) SON Conformity Assessment Programme (SONCAP) Product type Certification for Exports Voluntary Product Certification Scheme (NIS Mark of Quality). Nigerian Quality Award Scheme (NQA) Various Agricultural produce/products, farming tools/machineries, engineering products have been certified –PMS, Lubricants, LPG, AGO, paints, Welding electronic, cables, electrodes, welding equipment, safety equipment, petrol, LPG, AGO, Lubricating oil, bolts and nuts, screw, pressure vessel, pipelines, Fuel tanker etc. Role of SON in implementation of Codes and Standards for Engineering practice - SON CERTIFICATION SCHEMES Management system Certification Directorate Accredited to to ISO/IEC 17021 Offers third party certification services to organisations on applicable management systems standards (Quality, Environment, Food safety, Occupational Health and safety and integrated Management System). Use highly competent Auditors Have certified several organisations (including many engineering firms ) spread across the country Role of SON in implementation of Codes and Standards for Engineering practice - SON CERTIFICATION SCHEMES Establish and maintain Laboratories Laboratory Services Directorate The Laboratory Services Directorate offers testing services using high tech testing facilities to enable effective performance of quality assurance activities during the implementation of standards. The laboratories are: Food Technology Laboratories , Lekki, Lagos Chemical Technology Laboratory Electrical/Electronic Laboratory Engineering Laboratory Textile and Leather Laboratory The physico – Chemical Testing and Microbiology laboratories have been accredited The Micro nutrient Laboratory is also in the process of getting accredited The Electrical laboratory is also in the process of getting accredited. Role of stakeholders - How to Get Involved There are different ways to get involved and different levels of involvement in the standards development process: Become a member of a National Mirror/ Technical committee, working group Ensure Effective Participation in TC/NMC Meetings Have demonstrated competence in the field in which the committee is writing standards Attend meetings and actively participate in the development of a standards project Submitting comments at the public consultation stage. Work with SON to ensure the availability of national standards, Share information obtained through research, experience Have the ability to represent the NMC consensus viewpoints in a clear, concise and persuasive manner Implement the published standards (testing and certification) CONCLUSION Standards are key drivers of business across all sectors of the economy Promotes consumer confidence SON certification schemes promotes global competiveness of Nigerian products /services: among domestic manufactures and organisations through compliance with the requirements of the relevant NIS or equivalent International standards Processes are streamlined and made easy for stakeholders The world can not do without standards CONCLUSION Standards rule the world. We are in a very complex world, where countries are striving to improve their systems and processes in order to gain market share of the Global market. It is only the Technical specifications contained in the standards that determine what is acceptable to the market. The SON is alive to its responsibilities to contribute to national wealth, improving quality of life, increasing employment, improving health and safety of Nigerians through standards. Conclusion The NSE is encouraged to continue to: Work together with SON to ensure availability of standards Collaboration with the Standards Organisation of Nigeria as it deals and handles its regulatory duties and matters pertaining to or related to standards as specified by the SON Act of 2015 57 Thank you For Your Attention • QUESTIONS