Broaden Your Heat Exchanger Design Skills i After masteing the basics rMrtrbc hcd er.hrger (sTHEj ilr. of shell-and-tube heat exchanger design, jo .adi.r CEP ini.k .overd d'enal dsisn ot sheLL basir Here, re LdL d sonc of rhc more adv .ed 'xkc, ssucs i. er.hlngcr dcsiln \h. srde md rubcsidc utrnk. us oftrrut !id. sl'elh. ovddesig ( md louling topics cowred here: allocation of shelkide and tubeside use of f ids, muwlx shells, overdesign, and fouling. high dr liicoJiry ot lrlaler rbe ditr4nle br cr rurbulenc..'t.lre rhe 3tr1d. rhc r\eeD dr fmsf{ sl'cllside md rob.sidc hd coeflicicna A laege€d rubr lO,our pftfttr is supenor ro $ ii liie 're read! to tackle the adwnce.d vis.osi+ vnco6 Huids !r fuch ber r.r handhd oi ibe sbeLLlde Tnh is he (ru\e a..isid..ably higher hefi nsfer .oerli.e,t ch b€ obrained d rhc shell side rhxn on rh. rubeside. du ro rhe high T[i vqr sp!.iilized hcer or hed rrhxne$daign lnn ri ma where.on id&lhlc rxFnrn.c npdiddy usetul For n$y sc i.cs. rhe allm ,otr or sides n quire { iShrforumd. For eram n a ph, ror .@liiB or.odd.n:ing hrdmc& bons. .ooliiE wdu is invd$ly plk.d insnb rhe rlbci llis is becaure.oori'rg wdrr ir lolline, ind n n ernrb clsi rh. iiside ol r$es rhm the oubide Ho*evc( sl'ould thc pu.ss steam be com. sive rid Elunc l]rc use of m erFirivc dloy nccl. on. mui conside. syi.chin! rhc fluid dl@ltion. becaus ir dre com. sivc ltcam is on Ine shenside. borh rhe rubes and rte shell * l need ro bc made whsi dehi.ing &e allo.lion ol sids, rhu osineernu{ coNidei rnvr,$ry. d,.sc cotrsidcn ons ffe oftei cofiadidory. making $e sre.rioi ol sides a YLry .ompli.atd atitr pdrem, rs n Prcmo€s moErulbtrtcrce. cor.siren6s, lt rhe noie .onosiYc ntrid soi rhc tub*ide, orly lne rub.sidt lomponenls ('ubcs, chanDel and .h,iiNt lorer, lroarinB rQd coyei md rub.side rubshed rrt d&d ro be of supenor msrrrurgr How.vei f &e mor com. sire rluid G on $e shenside. dre shc|. shel cov.r, l]oanns head covdr, md sher:side frcc ot dre tubesher a eeLl as rhe rb€s mun b€ of $e superior hcld. lurgr Cbany, 6e .on ol the k(.r bod er.hrstr will b. bishe' ta$u,ling i dcnrical .oninclion pranean such r nDibf ol rubes, rubc dibd*. tube nhi.kncss. rub€ r.ng!h. and shelt di$ne, te, Thercforc, rh. dor! cotrosive fluid is p'rrsrably placed on rhe rubeside. Foultng rendenq. The not looling prefenbly rou€d &mugb Lhc rub.side. Be.lusc deE n moE dead sprces oo rhe shEllside $m on dE rubc side. rhe shcllside x moE sus€pribte ro lourrng FunhemoE. aner routitrg builds uproacenain lcrel ir bsom* n.c6sary flu n chmi.ai cldi(e 6y hldrojeni.s or rcd ding) ol lne inside of tubrs is nu.h .asie. lnrn clesi,rc rhc odside ot tubes . rssrsd , 35 de!g' lr,,( J\. . f*i,q rd n! I nft uo{ ryox€tu ! Ll !' heLk m i hP hsxLl n'r lor r LI d. priru!rLt rJt! mrh 0N bdmesr. uttt.. .t'.,'.1" -, m".."rr_., r n . / .-i tu '.., r,,4: h9r .r \ firr_. Lhc '": h' i. , 'k. s"rn.,". ,, ii !i ior rkdm r,|dr4ds e r!ir. p^'.Id,{\ btr .i ., ,1. Lhe h. '. ; "..,,''1.,.'"""1,. .nG! lbt,r$ hJ.euL*,r -" , r,.,i, lL!.] l !Uerrd!!., ] o(m! r]]r']ro], lr l 'T3hh 'n,"' ou't,'"g,,"'..o|,.u..i 'tr!'r]l.r!f,fl!.,i0.bJh !tur n !,.. r! tl]r hr ,! \! 'rr. u ,:rf ,"r "4 u,. * s" k",r +.a ,u. p " ,_t_ -" <, ,i! ao "r_FD rlf,rr ,ilirre. n! , hhe , b. .r \herr rih ur lli a r(r\{ ,f,,.,J{er ,; Crrcr tr.oridered rhe nrloln r rtr. r hr .\+ J€ t!,1 rr, rturre , ' 36. ArcHrs - . \\,rrHVcOlstunn.,. tutr I i(r,!tu, rlLl \heltLl n]N.u,!nr ':'o, u,$rr p. r.., p rcL L'ri ,he f\ tr n9 in h: rou h! tr tuN{i !i i " '', r,. ,1". l , t..''.' i- nryes|*'IF.trpt]lfL]rnfn .!EM cal rNcrN€rBrNG moctrs . ] rr!i. n N, rNLi rotr xid. .rnrqu. ry lcr) lltrgr E' U]fiJi] ]lltr\ l].1i']1) un'o(] crtr rr: trr.qinnLheLL in i :ingL. r,rLl T[ or ]- inrdims b.tu ttr. tLhi.dilir ririhirriei rrll]nnlr!.1 hunrL., Lrurdr! lor rh. drile.eDr remnos celfi.enl " o{. {,.e rhe Jl(q$]. Liai uidi rlo tr,. fr*s iu rtrb. pAsL:.ann bc JdoPrd hr lhe rll.s$le lr nr F ctrLj i\ $d rl'. or.rill r,d trNre' .Fll, .$r i\ .fly :5s killr,nl c Ntun * rk&lor rrt ,lrnetr trri rD:'C nr d,i 'ulEnde .nid! n 106 rlr a,ells n b. Lred,n:.i\. ii Ftr.J pfu$Ul d'op mLld er.lcd rh. rhe .otr Ir \ rur fni thr (nn0L bl hridhd lloqrr.r ft\j rrl lturfldr !. n,rLh .d-L!nrilr br i$i r\p.Dsn. rub*h.dc be he.ruse tr\ hrd mrdt or {J ns nerl crcs. die.oi oI'r,c c d. on shd siJ. d.nsn Ls lrrr rl'. sheLl\Lde lrs rhc liiSh{ d*istr Iie*u.e Hor.ri. rb. clt ds ol th! (i.s.r rub-) rDil rlic !rre,itrh ol coninLlh.d re mnr liSDihmr rhrn rhi.IIcd.fd*rn prc$m. Multiplo 5hells in p3r.ll.l qh0 rl!. .cqltrd hed min{ Thn tr oDrr rppri.rblc rh.lr h r rrsed Llu'ii'f l.]v \.1..$ otc l.i Mullipls sholls in sori.s flodmg Enro\irrle tub. bnidl.s drir l,rtrdling.rF[Li.!. lu[e bDdh Lo rr.tr Ln lrrye $flshtrkn!! 150 500 mr ]r- r qtr rc ..nn.i for hrl re.orery trtl hnir ol hrdr rtf( mr. Sn!. hrd rub*h.d hed e\ drigr! do mr hrre knorible rube reiD.,ture .ro( t.ds trr h. .r .oripl6h!d. null,plc sltl\ in $ns 3 iir.hiLls ii eiier 'si!L d'!n!i€, ni . : j rdd,drd ;dhe!F sr .tnl or,!.d ri!i{ r-i.h;.; .i.i' ..g',rt"*,e*"4*ry3r!ttri'|l;r!rd,mi "r"rtar,i.:'. ,. - illladipn*m drc! t!,^d , tdds;ii!d 16 i?ri ff.ieit ir M0 9-t u *l sl 1, -, rurts Th. high rhe cmpenrm rElrr.dll 2e eliifutrlt.qrlilii k!{brnf"r i: il,0jr tunlLhr.irrj*r..q !{ .$tt. r"c !6 ed..l..{ :.ltr!!or. Th. number ol shell\ in rrie\ on {hc eftor olrhe rm p{durt fos rhr( n. rhe difitr $irld!p.nd .13, !:::i.: (60'r). rrc sh.lLs a.e rdeqfa€ Hor$ei in Figur l4 trhicb hA . rll0'C). lnur :hells . ft req,ned ARsrs . 37 Not,1,,r !.Lil :tr., orr fltiinl. ,h.,,,,,,",i..,.,,!,,,,,,..",.,1,., rnr{r r:!n h.d, StrL I tdrri0n .r pr$utu iNirr l:i rot .t rrd !. ir 11. I trr b.rr nr! d.or. rD - rE " rh. hntinr,;,.$ ln ! \ii$ r drii ..qt 4d nrr n,tr I I I rrr.rr t uttu t r 6 ,,-,.. M(hipls rhott. jn .€ri.. ^(!.rr]rl].].i+lt|!j.(] S,nGrr H!aio]r,L,r rr hdr r,r:h u\ rf \l.ilicLt, lib. ] :1. ll.ll , lh!rmd!!id(dllyhltd'tdL/hnI' fu b\ ]s: n..$ ;JtN rrll\idr jirror nrr.. TtLr r\. il rn n ri|. rFqn! (:: rlrr, lLrlx \h:LLdirmr., .fd 0fr4 ddr rrlLn c.M lM+.L\d.\el0ntr: ]Ll trj lL \ re$ r.i. t d0s b I \u_a lrryrherr h.r r d!r, fJ r,, fLnhlr rh m d1n ro i.nrf rh! HVai:) Lh.thr ir rrlj 13 ta 1.r{rr r rrNlLlemtr mtrruyenjL jr rh. shdkLd. Ff.rirr... lnJ dr. rortrl hex!.r ti, rl rr nrL[r r! re* rrLr mr 0rrr trdr; hr hrr nrLrr,r. l.!t,i!).liu rdr ir5 mn,it ..r \.uld b. L.n lti: ort 38. rtir AFctsr$ - cBrMc{lNcrfts(G*6Rss si4g:!l::!, &dF;i!h *.rb h ""i- s L\itr vn.ostrl lhtr\. $o \he1ls \er rN,trdridu.ll) on I prDp.d-r onputr p'osfum t.r{rl riik\ $rl, Ll,ffrre a vrio m k,.dr'etnp{ r$ (lEnveen rhi Lo\.r rhe 'h: b( oiid. nrlnue 1DLi,b{ Drrub* hft l gd,. rnd shell lD ) Tl't 'n l!5'C rid.ore.podd to 7l',i h.d dd) ir rhr h.ter sh.ll trl 264i tr] htd 0 hc $ Nul,dF *r dr No drlLs Horc!!( ir L.rin Frft rhe rorllcooL'tr! \vre' flolv rrr r.'e lht rnd Lf! llli-Lde rcded in $k\ N0Ll.Lgn\]'ecom|fi.dLnl]lblli in r€rie3/Darall€l combin,tion S ur,on\ \oDielnr$ rN Yrer L'a$r r *.i$ rfr r larLlelrrrng. irin!anem be.on'.\ trrronhbt fti:\ iLunmd b\ rrr io ovi's nl lla. rlinq rpplnr,or ts!$use rhis lrs r lontvl,d ut\urL :i(n(Lon rb! ..u!d Dor '!e hrilll(l l,j r \ingle nLD otr u,r..rmmid r,tr $rl,rigirr,.' rldejg. \ontrft. rldbb3 r1!r7.d.r1trLLy s re i, r!. {s shell: orrh: qr lhd $! r!d{ Ex.mpl6 3: MohiPl€ 3h6ll. r Lr,r tr d*trrblc tu hNt di. $mt:tr. n *s h.re' shdl |uLLd d. 5h.ll l,y !rLr h.d trsisJei rLnr 0I rh( I'Lsh .0eifi!iu (J!r ii L!b.tll! rl .qMlLy bdre$ thc r{o l.mpemtrt ol tu.0ol s shdls. ! cr 'h crtig rhe ho er rhdl {ou!d be mNb highft rlfl r5-C lriihrhr lerrD-! rhc ..lder shell quuld li. .ombinrd .dle' be.&r rl tlr rl,N tr 'eDip{rh'R) l,L-!hll uncquxl lrer \hrll\. Smr.o.lLns rdcr {di'rg s {n rn'eud.ed r hL-!h{ brll tcni perduA. ,|tr\ \v.uld l.td b herrloL ni! n rr l,or.r rhe11 T0 trroid rhi\ ptubLcD. rlt .oolLns \rx'd flo{ d*i,!red lor rh. nurY lPeriliqL sinlc the vco han h b€ .oo ril eftid orftc ndlsidc l&k,!e nEms csE.rllr rh. sh.!lro b.fl]e lerker p'"trt -a ,t. ".e,m* "; $ercbj rhe mrtrtr tmPlmure difi{ 1"J"., * -" .r,ar.la. p.*-. *"r "-ta uined sirhin ft ruowabl.listr \irh r{o Jrlk in 5!,ns rhr rub.nde Pb ,,s ",\;s iwhnh tr rhemiii'num lor a splir nn,e Nilrrtroush 8odn,! hean .oNhdnr,) Funl,.!r,oF, rho cml d;ed. ft ns o d l.'nF.irurc {ofrd rheD exred 4i'c. trlirhlouLd n sxcesne Luln! (s.3liig) Thei.Jor.. 'l,e oDlY fesible iesuLr soltr ' dd$ 39 dL!er. iP|r rrrnlrdr j:]. jl rrd itr oL rd rsrr.rm im b.,f ll]! 5ht]l\ |DulL] t]j.c rr:r rhir. \thr tkrrler rhri 11!r lrr 4rr!b!.F'i€,r m0D.,n;dd^66 ii. . n lk oLda me .sl. ,; . Rnii! \!!c ir.nLr nror i,r bdh 1r! rr.,r te\iq, b !n;'!,r r Ov6rd€rign on surrace A\ Lhi Lnf i,4le. or. .\i:D tr,,r \!r nltrli, n0 ! ed,il rd lLraif, I r,r Ttu Lr ! hur q I , I,rr tre\.rLL; c ri,dr Jrnr. I r|.: ., s;r :^-r0'r xLhr orrtd{i!tr 'Ugil]nrhIj,.mly[.molc prud.d rh. Li{hn rhe r.qffv i. ,h: rioas dr; d ,h. r, ghr;dj" mdh.d isolirro. Lhe ro\o rri! mr-eif oi o\r.denen rh n.eds ro cll{r\ ..!hi.r:|) htrr i.,.^ Lr beol n ! d,m, h" er',llnlll.!,.,'D. . h"r . I i F,;i.Lr L,l;,, !r. hur irrh nLlt:?o tr llrr rr fu{ !/. It in i,L rh t !rrr rl'flnllLlD.L]eln{Jlo}nLA -lt'rnser l ilrn Drr c.trDeltd r..ftrirN nN \irh iah. r,i!h.\*l!\ qi i on sbn daiLludioi ol her.r.lraia de5isn lol r|. rfl c[lrJjE: D l dhl;. rtu \ n.r i..e ,rble,1hr d.!Os ontt'Led r, r,!qr rfr rij!.,i-& r.qur(d aM sreftdes Pn: a.: nl{i !er. IsiDPr! s e bmdi! {i[b.d eLruF rir nt ,h- nd ltl 0ie .3n b"."med r ir,, :rh pdrmr.r .r shell 3id rtr! bear e\ .hrtrpf\. lodrd zd'of .t d.aa n I tu$ei dJn.uk rask. ird rhe d. 40. narcHrs, i h.J hNrr'. ,rrJ nor rhc mr rol,LnErtr uLI ri dr hd \ r.$,;,| r.,L 0d,rAi{i oi idonr;,( " lK r r n^rn rL\ h i,! ,did r i| ( bu rdrr ! gd! (r!d tr\ j:a L h i r0jr r{lnnnrr.. or{d-i!tr ()r.dNlr !r P{r.r Dri.. a trr'.h lr\ dtu,r d*, lj { it .bf L .\.ILf D :n 'lllll.lr.Je! )r,,!h {prd ui Lr,.nr unLt nb.r.rtrbr\be .;m0,Fl dLllmffl,$t|L.MTD{Ll]tl! d{ i| rf! hrg{ nrdL n, d. orrRillgf {ould ior bc u r!r(!rn ly r,i!h Tfn l,r!i. f.cnai,rtr nhi \ ir,b* irr rour tuI uj r; rolf a he ncthla\ on H \crr (.nrider dine^ rild ex.hin, !i ri lLl iEr r. €, rerFrc. { sri.dhal lhr D Trbe 3 A dsi$ rr\ $n J!.nr hrD; I !r^ riEps(d gle d,cll 'o, .f ltL n: h Ltr ;r !n :!d'is {rips hou ld lrdiDLor.rj al l.ce. lTu ob*. :5 nn OD : l5 hmdi\ct! tr en.qhar ;;, i,r. lhrr ! 6 nL tons ot €ftnn n.. prrrf dh.,L!.d hrrlbr ; ri!!D Dn lrd our on a 32 nn Fbrit ! 1r oip.'t'ni'l'{o^,'n { Ll ,he Ov.rd6sign on p.rf ohsnc€ crliL! r, or.jd-prnl Lrj c! .ri.msr, \rrLdrrre n0; rfm rheLrs cuMbllNGrN@Nc moc#$ ! pi'.h rhse trde so iube pr$ejlmd sir-{lltgmedrL 6.tles sBr cm rloteLl x sFdins ol lm h dd rris r ol l:i or dic dimer. the NIID etr\ 33 2'c and tu Fftsuc doF {cre 0 .15 kg/.nf rnr lhl Dedi ,i fdrii fl r\IP,\r nr.m r 0 6i rg.n hr llic mrdc rne oEdc I srlr !x\ 215c, lh n, rhe rQr mnsld a€tr |'.vi,l!d (l]l n,rr ]a :l 5+ rrY. th{n !hd \as €quncrL Th. .|!rii,r ol rhF erchhlcr $r!sinn,l rJroe uare r.r$crrd .jlinrlns p{Iomance. trid rbe lol .\ n! ! fomd MPA od d km F'iMe = i90.9'c. ude odhr rm \r\1rcir/h. md \rTD = 3,150c rhu\ rhc er.hrnger y.ukl dud rr d.rns x ber duty rl4lt MM :ra \lM krilnr ThcEbF. ft3 Ii: lr.at dnr' xnlt rhe MTD J::rtrtd \o'i.rcr\.d rh rh. lrn hnster -.i r.lurtd \a! eqlar 10 thd pm \ J:,r 'i!:nr ,:! th. or r[ h.d rrn\1ir.oer Ema,ned ldutrll! rhr :rme P.in.iprllr ulr.r drr chrDse ir and rb eby rh! phFi.xl '.ipenhr. In LbL.N rbe o' d4rgi oi $r n-.!rll.i[r lne.vdlsignoi 3..rrnm ce {as 69. this n h. .ri* rle hor !ftri md the cold nil'e'e.r. md rheE ks considenbh !_op. tor no.e heati"S (ol rhe .old !@in) d .ml'rc (or rDre b.rree. die lhe hor ourlcr hor and.old shm re'np rtuas n lo{ei so 1}4 a ,ncrcase n he duly is a.coDpx. nid b) firr ir rhe MTD cod. k'tue ry rhe ove.dAj!tr on perfor mrn.e tr mtr.h ro*errh,n rhe ovdde. a sharp lgn on suifr. Typicd\ a t0+ o\eRr{ier oi surlkc rdd 4 ro r l orrd{isn on pe.fonan.c Orcrdesisn on pedannxnle {9r. dedl! morc i\ \igniicanr dn.,ni.s rul rhxn orerdsign on su,rr.. mr lr cblnsu mr be .{|cd&l ro Frlonn H.{ erchaieer s i.e\ aE osuslh d(dr\ ir rlr rotrlrL .o riLlon. HNey!( {lre j I hexr r\ .hrirlr r cltir iniLrllr- 0r rhq ai3r"7cd and die .lcNrin!, trr ore ll hexr !.nsaei nJ dli.e is triL.h hrgtr. rlirn du ii thr n\L ed r.ndirii i nr r!'r I r hilh r oyturnred c.meqne lr. ( \inL nrLudel rmirl r,L,ikrgr ot soy flr tfd 'lhr rdrri erf(s or f,Nrtr! . iiitrfd .rpirJt r\r du. (i rrr: tdLr.d .Ysr| trd trfl. { . oul !i{sr- quEme . d.inl.Mrle co* lnr tr \:i lourd. $.mirxr r!h.i. rnd don LL(nLrr lr nriy hr f.r.d rrcn du il rtje .urrd the tu lluid! 'lnP.rdri.\.f li(rhitnr orrtr! inft.v if Lh. h.r Llul}.nomtrtltr\hllhll'corfud. \ !n or \untc I0 itrh I crse. rri! .v{dtrign of t,.r[n n.e rnit P F!!r Foulingr ir3 con.equsnco. on dne$ror .r flulrDp I 'l.hikd un br f.uid hcd e{.hrigq5 ttl llou{rd: sin.e nr n! [li\s x 1ri\ ;]jroid rlc jn lhL des:q' ol h.; lrrh$strs tr hri. K.otr r ii pit nrr- li! drlmed r rhe dr ji\irion or tr lsiftble Dix(( or ! Fouling hr(txnsf iunir( li r D or hcd rmsJt, hdtr..n r*. nRims rid . 'edu. m.r or rh. ph$sx. trhich rsulrs irr incnsed prcs4 rio. in rhe ilo\r The d+r.r ol }ntrtrn! vrncs mrledry wirh rh. narur ol De Rtrtds be'rs hrrdlld. conse+.n r. ri .hdgen haidLins deatr iluidr riDin Ire. of huling lhefas .rchrtrecr handrinc diiy iErir rf conna(iLj, rr tr ccMrllr, trol (ros.ned $xr missc in presuf dnip n I fd more sn ou! consquenr . r {ouli.! rh.n LD crcN in thelmrqisunce rd deF by rdudion in di.nil pelfom.nft \vh.i a bed excharce is lirai our ot *.i.e to.dr ig iLniDr:nrhLrb€ .aL se ot rhe rdu.eJ rhrDqhp( due rn iuror lnt h! L ( st ar nE) m r\: tu her . trrJtt surr:r. PirJ.kl!.llrrJt rl]r r.u, lr r(olp [rs:usi]cnrld I I0rtd o h! her k{isr surn.e cn,r.Jtrr /;rrr! rrt dep.siriL)n .ht\dt alti.nINtr"t tht ft\ n ton ot detr\irs b! rr,cmr.rt re.c ror io.s 1L! diflek lonnnudrJ irl Tlr ieposns .i borh llic inlde r^d th. orridc orlhc tub i\trh Ltrr rtdrcdon D rrtr or xn h. ransrr lodii.LeDrdtr. ro rhe e\.3 r$xh.c ro her hNftr !h.h fNnb j't r l.r!{ he rastu fttr, Carqories ot ronlins. Thrrc /n.tr'ltr! rhr dhdrr.nl 0rhLo orgrinN h rhr r,!d urrftr rosi!.rt .r//,?rrt ,rr,h lrrrr! rt,c sojjdrri cati.i ot r Dm! tiqlrd or Pannutrr coi\trrLent.rr liqud roludon otr x suh\oo In Led h r d l(nnei tudice pdntrirhe dlhmger: d. pendin! upof rhe !tu ion oie or motu ol rh. 3bor. mods or fo iri may tE erFi L.n(ed fadon rr'r. arrcl touljng. Thc pnnlipr trimden rhd rfie.r foul t rk x^ft rl ttt ioti( t"id *ruh{ rh. 00id f drxi or rrr,d is. :.i^ ,.to.irr HiPh denr ninirit.5 I rlps olloulire Llrr,?r4 The rnFnture 01 lluirL-roullr lnEda.e n(nlry ir lluer* th. desto! olrriotrs mod* of tourlig nre nr.s ol ch. ! re rd'otr mc x srorg ft'.clor of rm pemrur rtrrere sottrbititr, lrlrs Gds *hok solub try dcferfs ui.h iD ftrrtrg rmFnue) core od ot so rhe rulion aM depo{on rhe hed hi!tu surfi.e shcD .he iihratue teno ruie n saEr {hm $ttrh i r; r aiofotrlin! n a hidjon ot .dt !rc*thftre. *hich i'rrears nnor I n.kri.t o[ onnhdu) i!r/i.? 16, ont rh rc!-qhne. !! blline iuclea or. rdiDenrarior. ;nd .he *irkjn! Eddency of deDosn! rhus. oush $.rms ;dd ro r;ur h, mo'? ruaJity than p.lishcd sDfa.er {her (here ft vmoB mode\ ot Iout_ i'u 6 \rll as rvenl tdom rl( ddnif. de desEe or dr vriour nodA ot fo iDs, |rcddi.3 rhe e{3nr or Jbtrlii! n exremelr diftculr CoiR_ r qlairrule ippmLh rd Lttu" o p4t erF.icnrt ror $e sctc.[oi of foulitrs ft siJxnas tor ydiotrr rG.i..s Ire Tuh!lr Er.h.nger L ki r'd rJn*s for \Mou_ jem\ o!m€€l in deltkmtr: pM , d$hs /, rnN \!r4 baed r/iUn i\qrb4r' v hsevcr r rruJ _hould h! up€€Ln! J,Ldht( O..ign to mlnimir. tou ng Aldrotrgh n n diitictrh ro dermtne foulins Bisrmces accmrty, rhdr rc slad s When STtlE. nusr b6 otod Ar dfcused e,tic, tor eaier truinr.aice, rhc di&& srcmr shoutd be tuded rhmugh $e tubes 6e.s4c ir tr ssier ni ck', lne insidc rnh $e ouride.t rube\ 1ii\ rcdues tuoo d ns .o! riov$ei if the diit; nr.m n vx.ou\ s weD n trnrally rhe .ase), phcti! ^ehki n insd. inc.Ns lne 6red con l.hus .D r('i Lt.o,lttr ' $h rlc "R, rm-! m$ v de!dc or roddb?rdiDd Ld r.'tls mt d $hi, i;.\,.,.._" bc rdipkd r imrm,E bdn, h. bdh (r tr^ drrr flud m ,r: Llt! rubes rd drnr. iluid our dc dr tub.s use siyfli ahavJ more nm noumdd i. derd spa.;s. rn \hdt;d. rube hcar exchm!4. rheE aF dead str. Dn €rh bJftir 'Itr \hdt\id€ dJra!enl r! "nd dr* spjle_ rr ,n. Hovevei rhm ,ru odrer rvE. or b*r erchajlf\ s.h d olr,r ;;n A dmnle^ .dd s0i!t h i d.hoser\ ,n shnh $tre ee no deiLl \Dd.A ind $h!h rhtr for knd tu hli rd ls unrniutuEtl ptr e e\. ',I, preBth.j lhr3!A hdt Lle,en !r rnd tenp*dure linirarions. Euidted bcd heat Achrt{s rlso miniDiz. foutinS lfg€r di'hder lubls, hear erchango se^,ice. I Jmrn:id rhe(rore : che:D. noue\er. rb: r; sdes olrery smau dia,nere,.ubs art elrcmely diiit.trh b cle,j. coNe quunrt,:h.in (?0 nnn) and I rn l]5 om) rub€s &c comnonly urd sddh'dimerer rub$ t', i.. ert j, h ) nay be u\dd torcle rni.cs. Mainlrin high retdty. A hirh lcrcry sutprses a1l gDes ot fout. ns Fof.@Lns qarr ad hvJrocr boi q! d\ J fui mh \.1; \ .f l0 nts h s.nedlr rccoomenled. al.housh I 5 nts is p'rfembte whon d,c nunbf of rubr pase\ mNt Llgh Ioa.hiereihn, ll be mc*$ry a be hiahr Dresurc tu trTe haE a povhion ror $e irmm. foutirshy $i.knd* U* nib€ iNft. wt€ 6i 'ire-ffn t- s hc -chrs.r a;.oud top }ca od cons.lue.dy i.cE* djc pcstrrc drcp. ri n quic shishlfoF srd ro 6slar $e rouliq Esn@.. a fouliis taycr thjckras bv oi 'mo snb.'u m xppmpride $crnd c;du. lviry ot de dcp6ir. ftis lill usudty hc i. rhe @se or 0.r nD ro 1.0 nmi Mossoph(ric ed rhemal d*i$ soft For a smal tu qas drcmd rsn. en,y u rrk d,r rou n! re!;.. iibJli!li!j-'n''hs\'A"lou iis deD.\it buitds ur n *jI Edre th! n ' rjrir $icknr< ;r qirhe o\ei Lh! a r"u[ng pioy 3 routjn! rotrli',g in rms of This \rrell d n u* r oM quilnatrve {eli rive mla of rhumb rh4 shou bc rol^ loyed ro mini' k rhe e\ienr orrdlin!. Fotrtins AUow\umcitnr hNrFn aor Dn\ sun dmp. whenh-\) roltrn!; r, t.,prEd, it voold b€ risc 6 hi!. strfficLe marsjn {ray t0-]0E, be. .rcfl' rhe ruow$k ard crtcurared vllue! oI p.esoft dmp The idea i: rl trmr €(h g('o of(r.ir n d! J:n bruuthpu drn \rh lne m M ur3du. n \.o.i!,nrTFvqr\nd e,Fri i, n 6.n insid. rube! by rhe \c.du i.riotr of sn2ll tuugh pdict.s otr lne tube Na11 .rdon ola lube ins( b itr.Far side ruba (t-lsurc 3) hd i. rft d-ttord dNrer ceffciei;n hmina flon Ai i(tdrd beieir n $ar tuse inens rduce tort i!rqelt ni Kof, \ hh uFrrlLl ..trdetrg rhn dr! pnr.r.d ruun4 epmdo. sd ;rcmde odiar ;;N rron die tub. {,:ll ro Inc ccnrei The m,ud,m@$ € :hrnmc icd rd+{ dmc'en hj rn!tu\ld oN€don bd rlsoniri'ni7d\ rho de posi.ion .l loulsb due r. ti. dh turbrlcnce wift-fin i.rtu bave bee0 dcmonsftten b Fduce tubeside roul n.qdfrnJu!:Jfoln!n}drJ!r les inR6n..A Addr oi, ihdi \ l\. on-linP d.ann'q Pr.\.aL{ | h.trrlidrn $ I \orld li.l:ra d i jr. arr,\.j, , ,lirh\ | Ll,. L\. 1r 0ilLF dfLliN li rlLidr bn\i\,{ Ir$d bfl!\ trt r!n]r:d d[r!h rlr r.Lli\ pen0d(dlr lli \udn! r troi fre\r \ rir irlLlur o1 Iorln! i6r oi ln drrngr lrftuLrLr t! tm. rr* nlrn n.irr.iJ. Nr. 'n ri L0 r! Li br iu .5 Lh. (ol,ig L\€ a spr( tDbt bu le or$nrt h.rl iL i\r,ult1l0 r{ling 'u,r!dtrLrk \r\e i l1]iF []hr rrLi'1. f.r d trrNlr rL!rr iml xoLdlr n! rsr. r\(banscr F knLr \nrde n.I n i\ r$Jllt bdr. b enpLJl lF.|jiL tr\ o.. ftn \ ]rL]l j\ fl} \ n 1r \hdlrrli l,.n rrn{!'riLi i!lf. i r,'u m- Lrrrr rhnti$5 'luLLLI b. rnuo).d l.tr rlr nr jJc rldr. rh. iuhi. is t|ilr inrison!. I rh. rrpl,(r,.,.1 . ir n! rc r0r 116r tr r..r!3rLr roLLl[! @ rrl rll:ri$ r$rhi n r mrh hish{.1 LlrdFr in rl* iik rtrxh orlhr ribf r. M!*h{j{. R,, L* hrlical bdnr (\(hrng€6. a. rnr! l lllllra (b. h r rl rr,rtrg ! hlr r,Lrt brllr |.4rn IlLbm$ !n,,: r.Fri,ij (n.f,( r0i i; \ s i!: rltr srLrL,l: ll.! i r!.rr brdles rrrr br.: li Trrlu ni !,\ frr L.r( xrd 1li ts.lbr.r md.lr\ 'r! R., cq4wr qs' Mujq r.cougb,MJ''{dJ'nR4.5,.tq cnl4.1Gn 0er) rtr B4r!t .rd,. ar ,44!r a eddr d,q b!.I li.r rs LD The oprnitrn 6n'i .r rbe sh(il b lr id Li l5t. {s.r rlr. ll suF " p'5! rll cdlgdn! ol nlrli"s For Nrlnnrin hish rdrirl lub$iLlr. r h'gli 'elo(i!: li.,\ tro{rrf 5mrLhn u} litr. en!(l'dr: hrfi. sr.rdrt rid Pr\ntr! ssi,, Bfr6r kd"ni t4'!t{ rLc"d ron llljnisizt dod rpacs l]] u'rr ! qdLpr)tonionrl brJIlr \Fr! rg r. hrlf! rur. d. rrt! rtLr lqr t. $rh bJno re mi, nTed ,\s i h bdrern l:'i Td Et r.n$ rblr tkt 3 llorrine hud or rj tubt dcsign. nr\ i5 r Bmrrd rrqtrtrr nuid tr F,tr4lGrr D$13, d krt-L i{b4r3 * F3a69|1 o,]sr) Funher Readinq r;diihldrdslhd e!i66;Md*! s.i , ir, E d *i,T$, tn NB&dn .uda;i,is ?d h dh]'sqN$trEeiIlliucF" erc. l Yd." cr?; r4 &4;r! eii, ff l2?,iryrern). .: fuI'idqEV.,d,d'€d|1 &i!t!E!iF ldbL PvbriE& 6{ , kldtrshf NeYi* orsr)